On My Block · Chicago Politics

No police superintendent pick yet. Johnson's 30-day clock runs to about Dec. 12, around the Council's last meeting of the year

Ald. Nicholas Sposato calls First Deputy Antoinette Ursitti the frontrunner. In 2023 the Council confirmed Larry Snelling three weeks after his nomination was introduced; this time the calendar is tighter.

Six days after the civilian police commission sent him three finalists, Mayor Brandon Johnson had not named a police superintendent as of Wednesday afternoon, by our check of local reporting. Under the City ordinance he has 30 days from the commission's Nov. 12 vote to nominate one or reject all three in writing, which by our count runs to about Dec. 12.

Why it matters: that window brackets the Council's only scheduled meeting before the holidays, Dec. 8 and 9, and the Feb. 23 election, when Johnson faces voters. A nominee needs a hearing in the Committee on Police and Fire and a vote of the full Council. This follows our story on the finalists.

The finalists

  • Antoinette Ursitti, first deputy superintendent and former chief of detectives, 26 years in the department. She would be the first woman to lead it.
  • Angel Novalez, chief of community policing, 26 years, who previously ran the office handling the federal consent decree; a finalist in 2023 too.
  • Christopher Papaioannou, chief of counterterrorism since the spring, 27 years.

The Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability chose them from 46 applicants after paying a search firm $200,000, the Chicago Sun-Times reported. One commissioner, Angelique Guzman, voted against Papaioannou. Fred Waller has been interim superintendent since Larry Snelling retired in July.

What members have said

From the Sun-Times:

  • Nicholas Sposato (38th), who sits on Police and Fire, said Ursitti "has to be considered the frontrunner. ... I'd be very pleased if she's the choice."
  • Matt O'Shea (19th) said, "I am a big fan of Antoinette Ursitti." He and a few colleagues had tried to delay the search until after the election; he said her presence among the finalists suggests "maybe I was wrong."
  • John Catanzara, president of the Fraternal Order of Police, said he has "very little doubt that there will be a new mayor and a new superintendent come spring."

Ald. Brian Hopkins (2nd) told ABC7 last week the City isn't "hiring a placeholder."

What our records add

The last time. In 2023, the commission sent its finalists in mid-July and Johnson chose Snelling about a month later. The Council's record shows his appointment introduced Sept. 8, 2023, recommended by Police and Fire on Sept. 22 and confirmed Sept. 27, 48 to 0 (A2023-0003864). That path took about three weeks from introduction to confirmation.

How each ward voted

46 yea, 2 absent · Sep 27, 2023 · Approved

Ward 1: Daniel La Spata: YeaWard 2: Brian Hopkins: YeaWard 3: Pat Dowell: YeaWard 4: Lamont J. Robinson: YeaWard 5: Desmon C. Yancy: YeaWard 6: William E. Hall: YeaWard 7: Gregory I. Mitchell: YeaWard 8: Michelle A. Harris: YeaWard 9: Anthony Beale: YeaWard 10: Peter Chico: YeaWard 11: Nicole T. Lee: YeaWard 12: Julia M. Ramirez: YeaWard 13: Marty Quinn: YeaWard 14: Jeylú B. Gutiérrez: YeaWard 15: Raymond A. Lopez: YeaWard 16: Stephanie D. Coleman: YeaWard 17: David H. Moore: YeaWard 18: Derrick G. Curtis: AbsentWard 19: Matthew J. O'Shea: YeaWard 20: Jeanette B. Taylor: YeaWard 21: Ronnie L. Mosley: YeaWard 22: Michael D. Rodriguez: YeaWard 23: Silvana Tabares: YeaWard 24: Monique L. Scott: YeaWard 25: Byron Sigcho-López: YeaWard 26: Jessica L. Fuentes: YeaWard 27: Walter R. Burnett: Not in officeWard 28: Jason C. Ervin: YeaWard 29: Chris Taliaferro: YeaWard 30: Ruth Cruz: YeaWard 31: Felix Cardona Jr.: YeaWard 32: Scott Waguespack: YeaWard 33: Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: YeaWard 34: William Conway: YeaWard 35: Anthony J. Quezada: Not in officeWard 36: Gilbert Villegas: AbsentWard 37: Emma Mitts: YeaWard 38: Nicholas Sposato: YeaWard 39: Samantha Nugent: YeaWard 40: Andre Vasquez Jr.: YeaWard 41: Anthony V. Napolitano: YeaWard 42: Brendan Reilly: YeaWard 43: Timothy R. Knudsen: YeaWard 44: Bennett R. Lawson: YeaWard 45: James M. Gardiner: YeaWard 46: Angela Clay: YeaWard 47: Matthew J. Martin: YeaWard 48: Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: YeaWard 49: Maria E. Hadden: YeaWard 50: Debra L. Silverstein: Yea
Yea Nay Absent

The calendar this time. A nomination introduced Dec. 8 or 9 would go to Police and Fire, chaired by Chris Taliaferro (29th). The Clerk's calendar shows no Council meeting after Dec. 9; a confirmation vote in December would need a special meeting, and otherwise would likely wait for January. Any delay pushes a vote closer to Feb. 23.

The committee. Police and Fire's members include Taliaferro, Vice Chair Lamont Robinson (4th), William Hall (6th), Gregory Mitchell (7th), Nicole Lee (11th), Derrick Curtis (18th), Jeanette Taylor (20th), Ronnie Mosley (21st), Silvana Tabares (23rd), Jason Ervin (28th), Felix Cardona Jr. (31st), Sposato, Samantha Nugent (39th), Anthony Napolitano (41st) and Timothy Knudsen (43rd), among others (committee page).

Before the Council. Papaioannou defended the department's handling of Karina's Law gun-seizure warrants at this month's police budget hearing (our story).

What's next

We'll report the pick, or a rejection, when the Mayor's office announces it.

Sources: ABC7 Chicago; Block Club Chicago, Nov. 13, 2026.

Support Chicago Politics

Keep Chicago Politics free for everyone

Chicago Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime