On My Block · Chicago Politics

Chicago police served 3 of 91 court-ordered warrants to take guns from accused abusers, the Sun-Times found. The Council's hearing didn't raise it

Karina's Law lets judges order police to seize an abuser's guns. Police say safety concerns lead them to seek voluntary surrender instead. A superintendent finalist defended the approach at the budget hearing.

Since Karina's Law took effect in May 2025, Cook County judges have issued 91 warrants directing Chicago police to seize firearms from people accused of domestic abuse, and police have carried out three, a Chicago Sun-Times investigation found. Each of the three searches recovered guns, including 26 firearms from one Bridgeport home.

Why it matters: the City Council held a three-hour domestic violence hearing on Thursday, Nov. 12, the day before the story ran, and the Police Department's victim services office testified (our story). A search of our transcript of the hearing finds no mention of Karina's Law, gun warrants or firearm seizures (video and transcript).

What the law does

The law is named for Karina Gonzalez, a Little Village resident who was shot to death in July 2023 along with her 15-year-old daughter. She had an order of protection that barred her husband from having a gun, but his weapon was never taken away, the Sun-Times reported. The law lets a judge granting an order of protection also issue a warrant to seize the respondent's firearms. Where the survivor recently made a police report, officers have 96 hours to execute it; otherwise they have 48 hours to investigate and raise any concerns with the judge, the Sun-Times reported.

What the Sun-Times found

  • In most cases, officers returned to court and asked a judge to quash the warrant, sometimes arguing the information was old or uncertain, according to Legal Aid Chicago, which has taken every Karina's Law case at the domestic violence courthouse since May.
  • Warrants the group's clients obtained against people in suburbs were all served, with guns recovered each time, managing attorney Benna Crawford said. None of more than 30 directed to Chicago police were executed, she said.
  • Nonfatal domestic shootings in Chicago are up 25% this year, to 69 people wounded, while domestic homicides have fallen.

What the department says

A spokesperson told the Sun-Times the department "does not refuse to serve search warrants," that it focuses on recovering weapons "in the safest manner possible," and that some guns are taken during arrests or surrendered after a warrant issues.

At a Cook County Board hearing in March, Mike Milstein of the department's Office of Victim Services said police had carried out two of the 60 warrants issued to that point, the Sun-Times reported. Milstein was also the department's witness at the Council hearing Nov. 12.

At this month's police budget hearing, Counterterrorism Chief Christopher Papaioannou said the "expedited" timeline makes it "very difficult for officers to … corroborate all the information" and assess risk, and that most guns "are being recovered through voluntary compliance," the Sun-Times reported. On Thursday he was named one of three finalists for superintendent (our story).

What others said

  • State Sen. Celina Villanueva, a chief sponsor of the law, called it "a problem" and said lawmakers may need to "go to the drawing board."
  • Maralea Negron of The Network: Advocating Against Domestic Violence said the findings "completely undermine" the law's intent.

What our records add

The Nov. 12 hearing was held on Ald. Nicole Lee's (11th) resolution calling for a look at investing in the Office of Victim Services (R2026-0026326). No vote was taken. Ald. Chris Taliaferro (29th), the committee chair, closed it by asking advocates to send their funding letter to all 50 alderpersons (watch). Survivors' advocates told the committee a legal aid group turns away 60% of the people who ask for help (our story).

The law is a state law; changing the warrant timelines would take a bill in Springfield, where the veto session opens Tuesday.

Sources: WBEZ: Karina's Law warrants (republished), Nov. 15, 2026.

Support Chicago Politics

Keep Chicago Politics free for everyone

Chicago Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime