Three Police Department veterans are finalists for superintendent. Johnson has 30 days to pick one, then the Council votes
The civilian commission picked First Deputy Antoinette Ursitti, community policing chief Angel Novalez and counterterrorism chief Chris Papaioannou from 46 applicants. One commissioner voted against Papaioannou.
The Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability voted Thursday night to send Mayor Brandon Johnson three finalists for police superintendent, all from inside the department, Block Club Chicago and FOX 32 reported. The job has been filled on an interim basis by Fred Waller since Larry Snelling retired in July.
Why it matters: the Mayor's pick needs a City Council vote, and Johnson faces voters Feb. 23. Whoever is confirmed would serve under the winner of that race.
The finalists
- Antoinette Ursitti, first deputy superintendent, the department's second-ranking job, since June; a 26-year veteran who spent three years as chief of detectives. She would be the first woman to lead the department, Block Club reported.
- Angel Novalez, chief of community policing, which handles consent decree requirements; 26 years in the department. He was also a finalist in 2023.
- Christopher Papaioannou, chief of the Bureau of Counterterrorism since April; 27 years in the department and a deputy incident commander at the 2024 Democratic National Convention. Block Club, citing the Chicago Tribune, reported he was suspended for seven days in 2021 after the Civilian Office of Police Accountability found he failed to report a use of force during the 2020 unrest.
The commission chose them from 46 applicants, down from 53 in 2023, after eight public forums and listening sessions. All seven commissioners voted for Ursitti and Novalez. Commissioner Angelique Guzman voted against Papaioannou, telling reporters he was not the right choice "given the current times," Block Club reported.
"We wanted to know how these candidates would address violent crime, support and lead officers under their command, and make progress on the consent decree," commission president Remel Terry said, FOX 32 reported.
Advertisement
What happens next
Under the City ordinance, Johnson has 30 days to nominate one finalist or reject all three in writing and ask the commission to search again (FOX 32, Block Club). A nominee goes to the Committee on Police and Fire, chaired by Chris Taliaferro (29th), and then the full Council.
What our records add
The last confirmation. The commission's first search, in 2023, ended with Snelling. Johnson's appointment was introduced Sept. 8, 2023, recommended by Police and Fire Sept. 22 and approved by the Council Sept. 27, 48 to 0 (A2023-0003864). The Council has a regular meeting Dec. 8 and 9; nothing is scheduled after that yet.
Papaioannou at the Council. He defended the department's handling of Karina's Law gun-seizure warrants at this month's police budget hearing, the Sun-Times reported (our story on the warrants).
What alderpersons are asking for. Ald. Brian Hopkins (2nd) told ABC7 he wants more technology, including drones, and a superintendent who acts "like you're going to be there for the long haul." "What we're not doing here is hiring a placeholder," he said (ABC7). At the budget hearing, Waller fielded questions on a frozen 368 officer vacancies and a gunshot detection pilot that officials couldn't explain (our story).
Sources: WBBM: Police superintendent finalists all CPD veterans, Nov. 13, 2026.