On My Block · Chicago Politics

S&P puts Chicago on CreditWatch, citing the CFO's resignation and the budget fight: a downgrade is possible within 90 days

The agency kept the City's general obligation rating at BBB but put it on watch with negative implications. The 2027 budget the Council passes, or doesn't, is what S&P says it will judge.

S&P Global Ratings on Wednesday reaffirmed Chicago's general obligation rating at BBB and placed it on CreditWatch with negative implications, which the Chicago Sun-Times reported means at least a one-in-two chance of a downgrade in the next 90 days. The paper noted BBB is two notches above junk.

Why it matters: a downgrade would raise the City's borrowing costs, CBS Chicago reported, and taxpayers would pay more in interest. It would also land as the Council writes a 2027 budget that, as proposed, borrows to pay police misconduct settlements (our story). The action came the same day the Council voted 45 to 5 for an outside review of City finances (our story).

What S&P said

As reported by the Sun-Times and CBS Chicago:

  • It cited the Nov. 13 resignation of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch as part of "a pattern of management instability."
  • It said "most of the measures" proposed to close the $882 million corporate fund gap are non-structural or contested by a Council majority, and that spending cuts in the plan are "significantly limited."
  • Political infighting on a condensed timeline "makes an on-time budget with substantial structural enhancement difficult to achieve."
  • A downgrade is likely if the final budget "relies too heavily on unsustainable solutions."

What officials said

  • Mayor Brandon Johnson called the warning a "sobering reminder of our collective obligation to the residents of this city" and said it "specifically cautions about the risks of an artificial gridlock," the Sun-Times reported.
  • Acting CFO Michael Belsky: "The city can avoid a downgrade by promptly passing a balanced budget built upon structural revenue solutions."
  • Joe Ferguson, president of the Civic Federation, told CBS Chicago that in the worst case a downgrade could "constrict the city's access to its lines of credit."

The dispute S&P is pointing to

Gabrysch told alderpersons that 56% of the Mayor's gap-closing measures were structural, not the 76% the administration had cited, because borrowing for settlements is a one-time fix, CBS reported (our story). Johnson has called it "a different interpretation of a very technical aspect of this budget."

The 28 members who signed the Nov. 10 letter rejecting the Mayor's plan turned down more than $400 million in revenue, the Sun-Times reported, including the $75 million up-front parking meter payment, more than $100 million from the corporate head tax and $234 million from raising the lease tax from 15% to 20% (our story). Block Club Chicago reported the Mayor's office is "developing new models" for the lease tax and a reimbursement program tied to the head tax, with no details released.

What our records add

This is the second warning in a year. S&P moved Chicago's outlook to negative and affirmed BBB in November 2025, WTTW reported at the time.

How last year ended. On Dec. 19, 2025, the Council passed its own 2026 revenue plan without the Mayor's head tax, 29 to 19 (SO2025-0021719). Twenty-seven of this year's 28 letter signers voted yes then (our story).

How each ward voted

29 yea, 19 nay, 2 not voting · Dec 19, 2025 · Passed

Ward 1: Daniel La Spata: NayWard 2: Brian Hopkins: YeaWard 3: Pat Dowell: YeaWard 4: Lamont J. Robinson: NayWard 5: Desmon C. Yancy: YeaWard 6: William E. Hall: NayWard 7: Gregory I. Mitchell: YeaWard 8: Michelle A. Harris: YeaWard 9: Anthony Beale: YeaWard 10: Peter Chico: YeaWard 11: Nicole T. Lee: YeaWard 12: Julia M. Ramirez: NayWard 13: Marty Quinn: YeaWard 14: Jeylú B. Gutiérrez: NayWard 15: Raymond A. Lopez: YeaWard 16: Stephanie D. Coleman: Not votingWard 17: David H. Moore: NayWard 18: Derrick G. Curtis: YeaWard 19: Matthew J. O'Shea: YeaWard 20: Jeanette B. Taylor: NayWard 21: Ronnie L. Mosley: YeaWard 22: Michael D. Rodriguez: NayWard 23: Silvana Tabares: YeaWard 24: Monique L. Scott: YeaWard 25: Byron Sigcho-López: NayWard 26: Jessica L. Fuentes: NayWard 27: Walter R. Burnett: NayWard 28: Jason C. Ervin: NayWard 29: Chris Taliaferro: NayWard 30: Ruth Cruz: YeaWard 31: Felix Cardona Jr.: YeaWard 32: Scott Waguespack: YeaWard 33: Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: NayWard 34: William Conway: YeaWard 35: Anthony J. Quezada: NayWard 36: Gilbert Villegas: YeaWard 37: Emma Mitts: YeaWard 38: Nicholas Sposato: YeaWard 39: Samantha Nugent: YeaWard 40: Andre Vasquez Jr.: Not votingWard 41: Anthony V. Napolitano: YeaWard 42: Brendan Reilly: YeaWard 43: Timothy R. Knudsen: YeaWard 44: Bennett R. Lawson: YeaWard 45: James M. Gardiner: YeaWard 46: Angela Clay: NayWard 47: Matthew J. Martin: NayWard 48: Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: NayWard 49: Maria E. Hadden: NayWard 50: Debra L. Silverstein: Yea
Yea Nay Not voting

The debt. Chicago owes about $55 billion to bondholders and its pension funds, WTTW and ProPublica reported this month, and debt took $3.6 billion of this year's budget (our story).

The pension payment. Gabrysch made the $75 million parking meter payment to the pension funds after the Council voted 44 to 6 for it on Nov. 2 (O2026-0029681); the administration has said she lacked "proper legal authority," which she disputes, Block Club reported.

What's next

  • Within 90 days: S&P's decision, which it tied to how the 2027 budget passes.
  • Dec. 8 and 9: the Council's next regular meetings (meetings).
  • Dec. 31: the budget deadline.

Support Chicago Politics

Keep Chicago Politics free for everyone

Chicago Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime