On My Block · Chicago Politics

Johnson says his ex-CFO 'wasn't a good fit.' She says 'twenty-plus people knew' about the $75 million pension payment

The acting CFO called the dispute 'much ado about nothing.' The Council had passed the payment 44 to 6, and on Wednesday it voted 45 to 5 for an outside review of what City Hall has told investors.

Mayor Brandon Johnson said Tuesday that his former chief financial officer, Ashlee Gabrysch, "wasn't a good fit," and again accused her of sending a $75 million parking meter payment to the City's pension funds "without proper legal authority or following the required processes," the Chicago Sun-Times reported. Gabrysch called the attacks a "pathetic attempt" to smear her and said, "It's a conversation I'm having with my attorneys."

Why it matters: the CFO vouches for the numbers behind the City's budget and its bond sales, and the Council has until Dec. 31 to pass a 2027 budget. Gabrysch, who resigned Nov. 13 after about three months, is the third CFO to leave in a year. On Wednesday the Council voted 45 to 5 for an outside review of the City's financial statements (our story).

What each side said Tuesday

  • Johnson called the split over how much of his budget is structural, his 76% against her 56%, a "technical" dispute, resolved by "providing both scenarios" in the "spirit of full transparency," the Sun-Times reported. He said he can't "predict the outcome" of the inspector general's review he asked for. "If the City Council wants more savings, they're gonna have to lay people off," he said. "I'm not gonna do that."
  • Gabrysch told the Sun-Times the $75 million went out only after a veto-proof Council majority authorized it, the Mayor signed the ordinance, and top aides were told, and that internal correspondence would show "twenty-plus people knew this was happening." She said the $480 million borrowing for police misconduct settlements shouldn't count as a structural fix.
  • Michael Belsky, the comptroller and acting CFO, called the dispute "much ado about nothing" and said the budget "can be interpreted" two ways, the Sun-Times reported. Of the City's audited annual reports, he said, "I sign this. The mayor signs this," CBS Chicago reported. Crain's Chicago Business reported he said an outside review "won't be productive in terms of the budget" (via Capitol Fax).

The emails. Crain's also reported on emails showing Gabrysch believed the Mayor's framing of the budget, without changes she requested, could mislead investors and the public, and that she raised possible issues under Securities and Exchange Commission rules, according to Capitol Fax's summary. Johnson said his office then prepared a second "narrative" explaining both percentages, posted to the City's website the day she testified. We have not seen the emails.

What our records add

The ordinance behind the $75 million. The Council passed O2026-0029681, sponsored by Finance Chair Pat Dowell (3rd), 44 to 6 at a special meeting Nov. 2, the day it was introduced (our story). It directs the payment to the four pension funds by Dec. 31. The Clerk's record lists it as signed by the Mayor; that entry carries the meeting date, Nov. 2, and doesn't say when he signed. The Mayor's office has said the money went out before the ordinance took effect (our story).

How each ward voted

44 yea, 6 nay · Nov 2, 2026 · Passed

Ward 1: Daniel La Spata: YeaWard 2: Brian Hopkins: YeaWard 3: Pat Dowell: YeaWard 4: Lamont J. Robinson: YeaWard 5: Desmon C. Yancy: YeaWard 6: William E. Hall: NayWard 7: Gregory I. Mitchell: YeaWard 8: Michelle A. Harris: YeaWard 9: Anthony Beale: YeaWard 10: Peter Chico: YeaWard 11: Nicole T. Lee: YeaWard 12: Julia M. Ramirez: YeaWard 13: Marty Quinn: YeaWard 14: Jeylú B. Gutiérrez: YeaWard 15: Raymond A. Lopez: YeaWard 16: Stephanie D. Coleman: YeaWard 17: David H. Moore: NayWard 18: Derrick G. Curtis: YeaWard 19: Matthew J. O'Shea: YeaWard 20: Jeanette B. Taylor: YeaWard 21: Ronnie L. Mosley: YeaWard 22: Michael D. Rodriguez: YeaWard 23: Silvana Tabares: YeaWard 24: Monique L. Scott: YeaWard 25: Byron Sigcho-López: NayWard 26: Jessica L. Fuentes: YeaWard 27: Walter R. Burnett: YeaWard 28: Jason C. Ervin: NayWard 29: Chris Taliaferro: YeaWard 30: Ruth Cruz: YeaWard 31: Felix Cardona Jr.: YeaWard 32: Scott Waguespack: YeaWard 33: Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: NayWard 34: William Conway: YeaWard 35: Anthony J. Quezada: YeaWard 36: Gilbert Villegas: YeaWard 37: Emma Mitts: YeaWard 38: Nicholas Sposato: YeaWard 39: Samantha Nugent: YeaWard 40: Andre Vasquez Jr.: YeaWard 41: Anthony V. Napolitano: YeaWard 42: Brendan Reilly: YeaWard 43: Timothy R. Knudsen: YeaWard 44: Bennett R. Lawson: YeaWard 45: James M. Gardiner: YeaWard 46: Angela Clay: YeaWard 47: Matthew J. Martin: YeaWard 48: Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: NayWard 49: Maria E. Hadden: YeaWard 50: Debra L. Silverstein: Yea
Yea Nay

The money was already in hand. A finance department notice filed Oct. 21 told the Council the City had received the $75 million from the meter company's sale (F2026-0029658, our story).

The review's backers grew. The outside review ordinance had 12 sponsors on Monday. By Tuesday night the Clerk's record listed 21, and 22 by the vote, adding Maria Hadden (49th), Derrick Curtis (18th), Bennett Lawson (44th), Julia Ramirez (12th), Matt Martin (47th), James Gardiner (45th), Daniel La Spata (1st), Debra Silverstein (50th) and Ruth Cruz (30th) (O2026-0030190). Five of the nine, Hadden, Ramirez, Martin, La Spata and Cruz, did not sign the 28-member budget letter.

What's next

The inspector general's office has not said whether it opened an investigation; such reviews are confidential until a report is released. The Council's regular meeting is Dec. 8 and 9.

Sources: Crain's Chicago Business: emails; Crain's Chicago Business: acting CFO.

Support Chicago Politics

Keep Chicago Politics free for everyone

Chicago Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime