Johnson petition review: both sides now cite numbers, 25,214 lines are challenged, and hearings start Monday
The challenge's tally has about 73% of ruled lines going against the Mayor; his campaign says 32% held up on day one and he'll clear 12,500. The Board hasn't published a count. What the arithmetic shows, and what it can't.
The Chicago Board of Election Commissioners holds a fourth day of its line-by-line review of Mayor Brandon Johnson's nominating petitions this morning, and hearings on both challenges to his papers are set for Monday before Hearing Officer Linda R. Crane, Chicago City Wire reported. For the first time, both sides have put numbers in public.
Why it matters: a candidate for mayor needs 12,500 valid signatures to make the Feb. 23 ballot. The Board has not published a tally, so every figure below comes from one side or the other and none is a finding. This follows our Nov. 19 story.
What each side says
- How many lines are in dispute. Johnson filed 31,936 signatures and 25,214 of those lines were challenged, according to political consultant Frank Calabrese, who has been posting running totals for the challenge, City Wire reported. Johnson's campaign told ABC7 Chicago that 6,718 signatures were not challenged, which matches the difference. CBS Chicago put the filing at about 33,000.
- The challenge's tally. About 4,038 lines had been ruled on, roughly 16% of those challenged, with 2,964 objections sustained and 1,074 overruled, a 73.4% sustain rate, by Calabrese's count as City Wire reported it.
- The campaign's tally. Campaign sources told ABC7 that 32% of the signatures examined on the first day were found valid, and that at that rate Johnson would finish with 14,788 valid signatures.
- The people involved. Former state Sen. Rickey Hendon, who represents Willie Wilson's campaign in the challenge, told ABC7 the Mayor "is not having a good time." Johnson told the station, "Yeah, feeling just fine, I'm going to be on the ballot."
What the arithmetic shows, and what it can't
If all 6,718 unchallenged lines stand, Johnson needs 5,782 of the 25,214 challenged lines, about 23%, to reach 12,500. That's our arithmetic from the figures above. The challenge's running count leaves about 27% of ruled lines standing; the campaign's day-one figure is 32%. Both are above 23%, the first by a few points.
That is not a projection, and we don't make one. The first 16% of lines may not look like the rest. Hendon told NBC Chicago on Nov. 18 that the challenge hadn't yet reached its claims about photocopied sheets and duplicate signatures. And the records exam is one step: disputed calls go to the hearing officer, who recommends a result to the Board, and either side can take the Board's decision to Cook County Circuit Court, CBS reported.
Advertisement
Our count. We counted 31,904 filled lines on the 3,301 sheets of Johnson's petition copy (our mayor page). That is a count of lines, not of valid signatures; it can't tell whether a signer is registered, signed twice or signed for another mayoral candidate, which is what the exam checks.
The two cases
- 27-EB-MUN-013, brought by three objectors including Hendon: hearing at 9:30 a.m. Monday, City Wire reported.
- 27-EB-MUN-006: hearing at 10 a.m. Monday.
Neither case is on the Electoral Board's Nov. 24 agenda, City Wire reported. We don't name objectors who are private residents.
CBS reported that 11 other mayoral candidates face challenges over signatures, residency or eligibility, and City Wire reported no rulings yet in any mayoral case. A separate objection argues Alexi Giannoulias, Mike Quigley and Maria Pappas can't run while holding their current offices (our story).
What's next
- Sat., Nov. 21, 9 a.m.: fourth records exam day, with three teams, City Wire reported.
- Mon., Nov. 23: hearings in both Johnson cases.
- Dec. 17: last day to withdraw; the Board certifies the ballot.
- Feb. 23: Election Day; a runoff April 6 if no one tops 50%.
Rulings will appear on our objections page when the Board posts them.