Joint Committee: Finance; Housing and Real Estate meeting, April 9, 2025
- When: Wed, Apr 9, 2025, 12:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Recessed
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1073984149
- Transcript: full text (36,407 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 19:25 Public comment period
- 55:32 Substitute ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 2-44 by adding section 2-44-160 establishing a…
- 56:00 Motion to accept the substitute ordinance establishing the Residential Investment Corporation
- 1:45:01 William Conway: Asked why the green social housing model would obtain lower-cost senior debt than private…
- 1:48:15 William Conway: Asked whether the city-controlled entity, as majority owner, would be willing to evict…
- 1:50:01 William Conway: Asked how the fund could be recycled within five years given expected rental returns.
- 1:57:45 Pat Dowell: Said she had twice asked the Commissioner for a list of projects with pent-up demand and had not…
- 1:59:00 Michelle A. Harris: Asked whether senior housing is included in the 70/30 mixed-income model.
- 2:00:06 Brendan Reilly: Called the revolving loan fund approach innovative but raised concerns about governance of a…
- 2:03:28 Brendan Reilly: Asked whether a future mayor could remove the board, and noted the board would write its own…
- 2:09:43 Brendan Reilly: Asked who would enforce ethics and conflict of interest rules and said FOIA and Open…
- 2:26:12 Pat Dowell: Asked that the ordinance specify the Commissioner of Housing for the ex officio board seat, then…
- 2:27:46 David H. Moore: Said he wants to get to a yes but supported holding the item until requested information is…
- 2:28:23 David H. Moore: Asked for clarification that only the $135 million revolving fund, not the whole bond, would…
- 2:34:06 David H. Moore: Asked that 'consent' of the City Council be changed to 'approval' throughout the ordinance.
- 2:37:26 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked how the program differs from current practice and what protections ensure promised…
- 2:39:15 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked whether the city would still put up most of the money on a reimbursement basis.
- 2:40:32 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked how projects qualify and whether the program affects other funds available to…
- 2:42:39 Pat Dowell: Asked what percentage of the $135 million would be earmarked for acquisition and rehab.
- 2:44:01 Daniel La Spata: Said developers identify access to capital as the main obstacle to development and that the…
- 2:44:59 Daniel La Spata: Noted that other city-created nonprofits are subject to FOIA and the Open Meetings Act and…
- 2:46:45 Daniel La Spata: Asked how the resident advisory committee would work and how representation is divided.
- 2:51:02 Gilbert Villegas: Asked whether the sustainable development policy was expanded by ordinance or by…
- 2:53:59 Nicole T. Lee: Asked why a nonprofit was chosen instead of managing the fund within the Department of Housing.
- 3:00:38 Nicole T. Lee: Said she likes the concept but agreed more time is needed, and asked for a worked example of…
- 3:03:43 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how maintenance would be funded and whether the corporation would set minimum standards…
- 3:14:13 Anthony Beale: Asked how the program would help the 9th Ward.
- 3:15:26 Anthony Beale: Asked why the city could not hire department staff instead of creating a new nonprofit.
- 3:18:00 Anthony Beale: Asked whether consultants who helped design the program would bid to run it.
- 3:24:45 Scott Waguespack: Said the ordinance lacks explicit OIG, ethics, FOIA and Open Meetings Act oversight and…
- 3:26:42 Scott Waguespack: Read proposed staff salaries and said such costs should be shared with all members.
- 3:27:50 Scott Waguespack: Said five-year board terms are longer than other city entities and should be two to three…
- 3:35:45 Maria E. Hadden: Asked what other models cities use to address the affordable housing gap.
- 3:36:50 Maria E. Hadden: Asked about the Chicago Housing Authority's role in meeting housing needs.
- 3:40:34 Maria E. Hadden: Asked whether the entity could be dissolved if it failed.
- 3:45:28 Gilbert Villegas: Asked the department to model per-unit costs for acquisition and rehab, which he said…
- 3:52:04 Gilbert Villegas: Asked whether and how the corporation could be dissolved.
- 3:59:47 Felix Cardona Jr.: Asked how the affordable housing special assessment property tax program would apply and…
- 4:03:09 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said pausing for a recess after hearing questions would lead to a better document and…
- 4:03:48 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether the tool could incentivize building where market rate is already affordable.
- 4:05:25 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked what accountability exists if a property is poorly maintained and whether the…
- 4:13:20 Byron Sigcho-López: Thanked participants, said the ordinance is one of many housing initiatives needed, and…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The joint meeting of the Committee on Finance and the Committee on Housing and Real Estate considered a substitute ordinance adding section 2-44-160 to the Municipal Code to establish a not-for-profit Residential Investment Corporation that would finance, acquire, own and operate permanently affordable, mixed-income and environmentally sustainable housing under the green social housing program. Public commenters, most of whom supported the ordinance, spoke during the comment period, and the Department of Housing, the Mayor's Office and outside presenters from Montgomery County, Maryland and Atlanta described the revolving loan fund model and the changes made in the substitute. Members asked about board governance and removal, FOIA, Open Meetings Act and ethics oversight, board term lengths, proposed staff salaries, project size and citywide reach, acquisition and rehab, maintenance, and deep affordability; several members asked for more time and additional information. The committees accepted the substitute ordinance but did not vote on it, and recessed until Monday, April 14, 2025 at 12:30 p.m.
Topics: green social housing, Residential Investment Corporation, board governance and oversight, revolving loan fund, affordable housing financing, acquisition and rehab, FOIA and ethics compliance, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 19:25 Public comment period: discussed
- 56:00 Motion to accept the substitute ordinance establishing the Residential Investment Corporation: passed
- 55:32 Substitute ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 2-44 by adding section 2-44-160 establishing a not-for-profit Residential Investment Corporation for green social housing: held
- 4:14:31 Recess of the joint committee until April 14, 2025
Alderpersons who spoke
- Pat Dowell (chair): Said she had twice asked the Commissioner for a list of projects with pent-up demand and had not received it, and requested it. (1:57:45); Asked that the ordinance specify the Commissioner of Housing for the ex officio board seat, then accepted the Law Department's explanation. (2:26:12); Asked what percentage of the $135 million would be earmarked for acquisition and rehab. (2:42:39)
- Byron Sigcho-López (chair): Thanked participants, said the ordinance is one of many housing initiatives needed, and recessed the joint committee until April 14. (4:13:20)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked why the green social housing model would obtain lower-cost senior debt than private developers. (1:45:01); Asked whether the city-controlled entity, as majority owner, would be willing to evict tenants who do not pay. (1:48:15); Asked how the fund could be recycled within five years given expected rental returns. (1:50:01)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Asked whether senior housing is included in the 70/30 mixed-income model. (1:59:00)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Called the revolving loan fund approach innovative but raised concerns about governance of a nonprofit with 11 to 13 mayoral appointees. (2:00:06); Asked whether a future mayor could remove the board, and noted the board would write its own bylaws without council ratification. (2:03:28); Asked who would enforce ethics and conflict of interest rules and said FOIA and Open Meetings Act coverage must be written explicitly into the ordinance. (2:09:43)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said he wants to get to a yes but supported holding the item until requested information is provided. (2:27:46); Asked for clarification that only the $135 million revolving fund, not the whole bond, would be reused over time. (2:28:23); Asked that 'consent' of the City Council be changed to 'approval' throughout the ordinance. (2:34:06)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked how the program differs from current practice and what protections ensure promised development occurs. (2:37:26); Asked whether the city would still put up most of the money on a reimbursement basis. (2:39:15); Asked how projects qualify and whether the program affects other funds available to developers. (2:40:32)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Said developers identify access to capital as the main obstacle to development and that the program responds to that. (2:44:01); Noted that other city-created nonprofits are subject to FOIA and the Open Meetings Act and asked whether the same would apply here. (2:44:59); Asked how the resident advisory committee would work and how representation is divided. (2:46:45)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked whether the sustainable development policy was expanded by ordinance or by departmental policy. (2:51:02); Asked the department to model per-unit costs for acquisition and rehab, which he said would be cheaper than new construction. (3:45:28); Asked whether and how the corporation could be dissolved. (3:52:04)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked why a nonprofit was chosen instead of managing the fund within the Department of Housing. (2:53:59); Said she likes the concept but agreed more time is needed, and asked for a worked example of a project's capital stack and stabilization. (3:00:38); Asked how maintenance would be funded and whether the corporation would set minimum standards for properties. (3:03:43)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked how the program would help the 9th Ward. (3:14:13); Asked why the city could not hire department staff instead of creating a new nonprofit. (3:15:26); Asked whether consultants who helped design the program would bid to run it. (3:18:00)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Said the ordinance lacks explicit OIG, ethics, FOIA and Open Meetings Act oversight and that he will not vote for it until that changes. (3:24:45); Read proposed staff salaries and said such costs should be shared with all members. (3:26:42); Said five-year board terms are longer than other city entities and should be two to three years. (3:27:50)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Asked what other models cities use to address the affordable housing gap. (3:35:45); Asked about the Chicago Housing Authority's role in meeting housing needs. (3:36:50); Asked whether the entity could be dissolved if it failed. (3:40:34)
- Felix Cardona Jr. (alderperson): Asked how the affordable housing special assessment property tax program would apply and who would file with the Assessor. (3:59:47)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Said pausing for a recess after hearing questions would lead to a better document and that no colleague called it a bad idea. (4:03:09); Asked whether the tool could incentivize building where market rate is already affordable. (4:03:48); Asked what accountability exists if a property is poorly maintained and whether the corporation could sell a property. (4:05:25)
Exchanges between members
- 1:59:52 Alderman Brendan Reilly asked to be included on the distribution of the project list promised to Chairwoman Pat Dowell.
- 2:19:22 Alderman Brendan Reilly repeated Alderman William Conway concern about project size and said he was right.
- 2:25:40 Alderman Brendan Reilly asked the chairs to hold the ordinance at least another week.
- 2:26:07 Chairwoman Pat Dowell said she would take the request to hold the item under advisement.
- 2:27:46 Alderman David H. Moore agreed with Alderman Brendan Reilly that members want to get to a yes once requested information is provided.
- 2:51:34 Chairwoman Pat Dowell told Alderman Gilbert Villegas his turn for questions was coming soon.
- 2:53:28 Chairwoman Pat Dowell responded to Alderman Daniel La Spata that the program would not reach all of Chicago in the first ten years.
- 3:24:28 Alderman Scott Waguespack asked Alderman Anthony Beale whether he was seeking $19 million in bond funds to close his project.
- 3:24:35 Alderman Anthony Beale replied that might be a quicker way to do it.
- 3:26:42 Alderman Scott Waguespack followed up on the staff cost issue Alderman Brendan Reilly raised earlier.
- 3:39:09 Alderwoman Maria E. Hadden noted she worked with Alderman Gilbert Villegas on an earlier ordinance.
- 3:39:09 Alderwoman Maria E. Hadden noted she worked with Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. on an earlier ordinance.
- 3:50:34 Chairwoman Pat Dowell asked to add to Alderman Gilbert Villegas request for acquisition modeling, and he agreed.
- 3:52:09 Alderman Gilbert Villegas followed up on Alderwoman Maria E. Hadden question about dissolving the entity.
- 4:02:55 Alder Andre Vasquez Jr. credited conversations with Alderman Gilbert Villegas for improving the legislation.
- 4:08:55 Alder Andre Vasquez Jr. agreed with Alderman Gilbert Villegas point about the realtors' letter and cutting red tape.
- 4:12:53 Chairwoman Pat Dowell thanked Chairman Byron Sigcho-López for co-chairing.
- 4:14:19 Chairman Byron Sigcho-López thanked Chairwoman Pat Dowell for her collaboration and attention to detail.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error