good afternoon everyone and welcome to the joint committee on housing on real estate and the committee on finance and we are now calling the meeting to order we'll now have a call a roll call to establish quorum and now i want to pass it on to chairwoman dow good morning everyone thank you for coming out to the joint committee meeting we will now do roll call vice Vice Chair Conway, Vice Chair Mitchell, Alderman Laspata, Alderman Hopkins, Alderman Robinson, Alderman Hall, Alderman Harris, Alderman Beale, Alderman Lee, Alderman Quinn, Alderman Lopez, Alderman Moore, Alderman Curtis, Alderman O'Shea, Alderman Rodriguez, Alderman Tabaris, Alderman Fuentes, Alderman Irvin, Alderman Taliaferro, Alderman Cardona, Alderman Wagesback, Alderman Rodriguez Sanchez Alderman Cazada Alderman Villegas Alderman Mitts Alderman Spisato Alderman Vasquez I see you Alderman Vasquez Alderman Riley Alderman Knudsen Alderman Clay Alderman Martin Alderman Manat Hoppenworth Alderman Haddon, Alderman Silverstein, Chairman Dowell's here, Chairman Cichol Lopez is here. We have a quorum, we have 21. Oh, Alderman Hopkins, we have a quorum with 22. We, Alderman Moore is here. That's 23. Alderman Taylor, Alderman Burnett, Alderman Scott, Alderman Lawson, Alderman Mosley, and Alderman Ramirez have requested to participate remotely at today's joint committee meeting for reasons stated under the provisions of Rule 59. Can I have a motion to allow these Alderman to participate by remote means? So moved by Alderman Laspata. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And the motion carries. I just want to confirm Alderman Taylor. Alderman Burnett. Present. Alderman Scott. Here. Alderman Lomis, excuse me, Alderman Lawson. Present. Alderman Mosley. and Alderman Ramirez present. Okay, have all joined the meeting. I called him already. Alderman Mitts, we have you and we'll count you towards quorum. Alderman, Chairman Cicho Lopez. Thank you, Chairwoman. Alderman Robinson has, Robinson is in and we will count you towards quorum. Thank you, Chairwoman. At this time, we will begin the public comment period. The public comment period will be limited to 30 minutes. Out of respect for everyone's time, each speaker will be limited to two minutes so that we can accommodate as much public comment as possible. We're going to start with, and then we also have three callers that have signed up to speak remotely for today's meeting. We're going to count also Alderman Riley for the purpose of the quorum. And Alderman Nugent for purposes of quorum. You're not here? You're a non-member? You could be a member? We'll count you. So now we're going to start with the first public speaker, Samuel Beam. How's it going, everyone? My name is Sam. I am a volunteer for One North Side. It's a nonprofit in the north side of Chicago, supports community safety, housing and environmental justice. I live in Edgewater now, but I've lived alongside Lake Michigan basically all my life. But I don't think I've always been really aware of how much of a gift living in the Great Lakes region is. As the effects of climate change become more severe, as we've seen with the L.A. wildfires, I think more and more folks are going to be drawn to cities with a more mild climate and ready access to drinking water like Chicago. As the climate crisis brings more people here, and for the folks who are already here, we find ourselves short on housing with outdated infrastructure and subpar safety standards like poor indoor air quality. This ordinance is a positive step, and it's a positive step in improving that quality. We can do the right thing now by providing for the people who need it most, and we can also save ourselves in the long run by investing in green housing now rather than paying for long-term health expenditures and Band-Aid solutions in the decades to come. It's the right thing to do, and it is also in our best financial interest, and it will also provide construction jobs for the hardworking people of Chicago. I just appreciate your time. Vote yes on this ordinance, and thank you very much. Just want to acknowledge that we've been joined by Alderman Rodriguez, and Alderman Taylor, you have your hands raised. I'm here, Chairwoman. Got you. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Chairwoman. Next, we have Nikhil Basu. Hello, my name is Nikhil Basu and I'm a member of One Northside. My pride in Chicago stems from its history as a place where everyone can find affordable housing and build the life of their dreams. That's exactly what my parents did 35 years ago, and having lived in Chicago my whole life, I've been shaped by this city's rich and diverse culture. But as we face the realities of climate change and rising living costs, we need to ensure that Chicago remains an affordable and welcoming city for all by voting yes on green social housing. Climate change is no longer a distant threat. It's a reality that we face every day. Our city has experienced extreme heat and cold, heavy rainfall and severe storms, all of which disproportionately affect our most vulnerable residents. Green social housing provides a solution by protecting Chicagoans from these extreme weather events. These homes would be built with energy efficient materials that would reduce our carbon footprint and save residents an average of $594 a year on utility bills. They would create union jobs, reduce pollution and improve air quality in the neighborhood. It's not just about building sustainable homes, but about building a community that prioritizes the health and well-being of all residents. Last summer, I backpacked from Canada to Mexico across the Rocky Mountains. I stayed in dozens of towns across the West, and everyone I met from all political backgrounds said that housing access is the biggest challenge they face. It's amazing how widespread and severe the housing crisis is, from tiny towns in rural Wyoming to the largest cities in the country. Chicago has the chance to be a beacon of hope, especially as climate change worsens. We can lead by example by showing that it's possible to create affordable, high quality and sustainable housing for all residents. This proposal ensures that tenants have an equal say in their building's maintenance and governance, which is a crucial step towards making our housing system more democratic. That's the kind of Chicago I want to live in, a city that's inclusive, resilient and forward-thinking in solving its challenges. In conclusion, I urge you as members of City Council to prioritize passing and funding green social housing. Thank you. Thank you. Next we have David Sultan. members of the council i'm very glad to to be here today to see you talking about social housing this is something that i've been fighting for for six years of my life i have been working as hard as i can to make sure that we do this right. Unfortunately, I have to say this is not it. Housing is the fundamental human right of them all. Without housing, the house that we build on, the human rights and the civil rights upon which everything else is based, falls apart. everything from our public safety to our health care, as I know all too well as a disabled person who lost his leg because of homelessness. That's why this is so important to me. But we have to do this right. There are things that have not even been considered in this ordinance yet. Where is any provision to ensure that there are safeguarded funds for maintenance costs? We all know what happened in the plan for transformation. We cannot do that again. There's an advisory council for green provisions, which is wonderful. We need to do that. But where are the provisions for the accessibility? We can't just say, look at the rules that already exist we need to have people talking about this the racial equity where's the advisory council for racial equity and we can't simply stack the board with people who are appointed by the mayor or ex officio by the mayor because whether it's in two years or 200 years what if one day we don't have somebody as much of a champion of social housing as our current mayor is. We have to safeguard against that. We've seen what happens in Berlin when that doesn't happen. Let's take a moment and let's do this right. Thank you, Mr. Sultan. Next we got Leon Walker. Leon. Committee members, chairman, and aldermen. I'm Leon Walker, CEO of DL3 Realty Advisors, and I'm here in support of this ordinance. Government exists to solve problems the private sector cannot solve on its own. like rural broadband, for example, and unfortunately also affordable housing. This has been a decades-long intractable problem that we have not been able to solve as a society and a community. So I applaud this effort to bring an innovative solution, a financing tool that produces more housing and makes a commitment to 30% affordability in perpetuity. That is something the private sector cannot do. So government is needed to take the lead here. We also have other programs like the Low Income Housing Tax Credit Program. And that program we participated in as the first black-led development company, private developer in the city to execute on a 9% award. We've now executed in the 20th Ward, the 16th Ward, and the 7th Ward. And I can tell you, even though we still need the LIHTC program to be a part of the solution, it is not enough by itself. It is a trickle and we need a flood. So this is yet another tool to help produce more housing, which is ultimately the solution we all need. And I hope that the aldermen and those that have any concerns about this ordinance can come together so that we can pass this with a unanimous vote. Thank you. itself. That's why we stand here today. In green social housing, we at Palenka LSA believe we have a very good program. I'll say that. We believe that we need to put it forward to grow it and improve upon it. But first, you need that to be put forward. You guys have all been briefed on this a lot. So I'm not going to say anything you don't know, and I won't dwell on those points. You know that it's a financially efficient program at a time when affordable housing is very expensive to create. You know there's green building standards, which we badly need. You know there's tenant governance, which in many of the public housing projects we have, we go woefully short on that issue. And you know that in the Trump administration, no one is going to save us but ourselves. And Chicago needs to put forward a unit, a program that's going to create affordable housing without additional subsidy. So what I'm here to remind you of as a representative of Plank LS&A and the Green New Deal coalition is that this is a community-driven process. The Green New Deal Coalition has been represented by groups around the city. We have people from Community Recovery on the southeast side. We have Little Village Environmental Council. We have Palenka LSNA. Shout out. We have JCUA, One North Side. We have many more groups. This is a citywide coalition, the Jane Addams Senior Caucus. So I say on behalf of community groups, this is a difficult time in city council, but let's not let this get caught into that. Let's not mess around. The people in our communities need this too badly. so without blaming anyone we hope you can all work so we can get better at passing the legislation the people are in our community's need this included thank you thank you next we have julie working julie I'm Julie Dworkin, a community representative with the Illinois Green New Deal Coalition. As the former policy director at Chicago Coalition to End Homelessness, I worked for decades to create dedicated funding streams for affordable housing. Each time a new funding source was created, it could only make a small dent in the need for affordable housing. Over the years, the cost of building affordable housing has continued to rise to the point where a single unit can cost as much as $900,000 to build. With this pattern, fewer and fewer units can be built with available resources. This model is not sustainable. One of the primary cost drivers of affordable units is the use of federal low-income housing tax credits. This Byzantine program drives up the soft costs of building housing exponentially, with the long delays in putting deals together, increasing holding costs, fees, and costs for reports. It also demands retaining expensive attorneys and accountants to navigate the paperwork. On top of this, the program generates funds for affordable housing by selling tax credits to investors for 50 cents on the dollar. This means that half of our country's largest government funding source for housing does not actually go towards building housing. This type of inefficiency alone should drive us to search for another way. The other way is social housing. This model brings down costs significantly, eliminates the need for ongoing government support, and speeds up the development process to get people into housing more quickly, all while creating union construction jobs and forming vibrant, mixed-income, tenant-governed communities and housing that is permanently affordable without the use of ongoing subsidies. The funds for this program are already in place. We now need the structure in place to make it a reality. We can't delay putting funds into use that are waiting to house Chicago families. I urge you to vote yes. Thank you. Next we have Taiwan Sims. To the gentleman that said that housing is a fundamental human right, I don't think that's the truth because I'm the evidence right here. I'm still homeless after speaking at this podium for almost a year into the room where we're in the room right now with finance. So with an, I guess, estimated $1 billion shortfall already looming, this consistent fight with the federal government or with Donald Trump or whatever it is y'all battling with, with minus that $4 billion that will surely be needed, housing here in Chicago is abysmal. But black Americans ride the trains, the L's, they sleep in gang ways. Black Americans have been made the issue. Americans have been made the issue. Or the talking point. But how do we get past it? And how do y'all supplement any of this behavior in the fiscal year to come? That should be branding he says he's going to sue in regards to dei with what money how y'all gonna fund that corporate thought what's going on here and i'm still homeless hey cjo look up cjo this is your day i'm still homeless chairman of housing and real estate the chairman that has purposely pushed black Americans out since 2022. 72% of the homeless population is black American. But we just had people wait across the Rio Grande and they're housed and working. So for all the things that's going to take place in the near future that will cost us fiscally, attribute it to your initiative, whatever bias it is. Thank you. Next we have Jimmy Rothschild. Jimmy Rothschild, I'm the Housing and Economic Justice Organizer with the Jewish Council on urban affairs. We've been working to make sure our neighbors are housed securely and safely and without displacement in the city for 60 years. And we see this as a direct continuation of that work that we've been doing since Rabbi Robert Marx was fighting contract buying in the early 60s. But today, it's no secret that we're still facing that affordable housing crisis, and that we're also facing a climate crisis. And we need to be able to address both of those crises head on, especially with the federal government coming in and insistent on making both of those problems worse. We need a way that we can control the funding that goes to making sure working class, poor Chicagoans are housed, making sure that they're housed in a way that is transformative in new kinds of buildings that we haven't seen in Chicago before, kinds of buildings that have mixed income, that have real tenant governance, that have real commitment to sustainable practices. These are ways of not only housing people, but also transforming our communities and also making sure that those communities are long-term sustainable. We don't want to build for a future that we don't have. We want to build to create housing in a future that has a just climate, where we can all live and we can all stay in our neighborhoods. These are projects that are going to be built with union labor, and that's going to bring more money back into these working-class communities as well. I'm really excited for Chicago to be a leader in a common-sense but transformative kind of housing that we can model for the rest of the country. I thank you for your vote's aye today. Thank you. Next, we have Donovan Harvey. And while he's coming to the mic, I want to acknowledge that we've been joined by Alderman Wagesback, who will be counted towards quorum. Thank you. Go ahead. Dear members of the committee, My name is Donovan Harvey, and I'm here on behalf of the Metropolitan Planning Council, an independent 90-year-old nonprofit policy and planning organization dedicated to building equity in the built environment. And on behalf of MPC and our CEO, Dan Lurie, I am pleased to express our support for the ordinance to establish the Residential Investment Corporation to implement the green social housing program. MPC applauds the process by which the city developed the ordinance, a process which engaged residents, developers, lenders, and national experts to create a solution that directly addresses the needs of Chicago families struggling with housing instability. As Chicago families continue to face the twin challenges of residential segregation and scarce affordable housing options, this innovative approach offers real solutions for creating more equitable outcomes. funds have already been set aside for the program and establishing the RIC would enable implementation without delay, bringing immediate relief to families in need of affordable housing. The benefits of this program to Chicago residents are many, and I would like to name a few. First, the program would create permanent affordability, ensuring both current and future generations will have access to the homes, unlike typical affordable housing programs that expire after 30 years. Second, the program will lead to the creation of lasting housing stability for Chicago residents through a fiscally responsible revolving loan structure that will support the creation of new developments for years to come without additional funds. And finally, the mixed income model will allow other affordable housing tools, like the low-income housing tax credit, to be directed towards neighborhoods where deeper subsidies are required. Given rising construction costs and declining federal support, This innovative, financially sustainable solution offers Chicago families new possibilities. Similar approaches have been tried throughout the country, and we believe this program will be an effective addition to Chicago's affordable housing toolkit. Thank you. Next, we have Juan Sebastián Arias. Good afternoon, Chairman, Chairwoman, and Committee members. My name is Juan Sebastián Arias, Executive Director with the Citywide Coalition Elevated Chicago, and I'm here today in full support of the green social housing ordinance that is before you. Elevated Chicago is a multi-sector coalition of community leaders, developers, policy and research groups, and more. We come together to advance equitable transit-oriented development, or ETOD, across the city so that every Chicagoan can live in a vibrant, sustainable, healthy, and walkable community connected to transit. A key component of ETOD is building and preserving housing options, especially deeply affordable ones, so that everyone can experience the benefits of living near public transit. With this proposed green social housing program, we'll have a much needed new tool to enable the production of more permanently affordable and sustainably built housing. And if we build future green social housing near transit, we'll multiply the benefits for residents and for the environment by ensuring that more families are able to benefit from access to our public transportation system. Today, by enabling the Department of Housing to establish a nonprofit to implement this program, we have an opportunity to take a transformative step forward in addressing the city's housing and climate crises both. A nonprofit will allow for greater flexibility in leveraging local resources and ensure that future developments prioritize long-term affordability and the well-being of residents. And maybe most importantly, the self-sustaining program model will give Chicago more independence from increasingly uncertain federal funds. On behalf of Elevated Chicago and our coalition members, I urge you to support this meaningful step forward today. Thank you for your time. Thank you Mr. Arias. Next we have Rylan Rich. Good afternoon. My name is Ryland Rich. I'm with One North Side, a grassroots community organization, and I am so excited about this green social housing plan. I don't know about all of you, but this is one clear step towards a new future for Chicago tenants, working class folks, and our strong community here that needs better. We need better. Green social housing is a clear plan to provide this affordable, tenant-governed, healthy housing for Chicagoans. And it's also a way to provide good, clean construction jobs, union jobs for folks. Because these buildings will be built with cleaner materials, these clean union jobs are essential. They're a game changer. affordable housing is also particularly meaningful for me because i used to work at the early resolution program in chicago's eviction court every day i'd see the court overflowing with people facing eviction and landlords deciding whether to evict their tenants or lose their own housing because of the housing crisis we have in our city i've heard it from multiple people sharing today, their personal experiences. We have a housing crisis and we need to do better. I spoke with a woman who was being evicted. She had such a rat infestation in her apartment that her baby had been bitten by rats in its bed. The landlord wasn't doing anything. The city wasn't doing anything. The affordable housing we do have in the city is crumbling, infested, full of mold, or about to be sold to a new developer. We need better. We deserve better. This is our opportunity. Please vote yes for green social housing to provide tenant-governed, clean, affordable, accessible buildings, better jobs for all, and to set a new standard for affordable housing and for a new future for our city. Thank you. Next, we have Osvaldo Gomez. And while he's coming to the mic, I want to acknowledge Alderman Chico, Alderman Yancey, Alderman Coleman, and Alderman Nugent, non-members who have joined us today. Good afternoon, Honorable Counsel. My name is Oswego Gomez. I'm a resident of the West Haven community in the 27th Whart near Westside. I'm a member of the Westside Environmental Justice Alliance, and also a long-term member of One Northside. I'm obviously in support of the passage of the considered ordinance and resolution, and I want to thank the older people, Robinson, Clay, Manahalpensworth, and especially Burnett, who have championed this ordinance and have even taken it to the newspapers to highlight its necessity. I live in a mixed-income, city-supported housing neighborhood, and I can tell you from my own personal experience and the data that supports this, that makes income housing that is rooted in community works. It works because my community is thriving and the residents are safer and better because of it. Now it's time to expand that and make that a green possibility for the whole city. Now, I want to point out the most obvious fact that hasn't been brought up by any of the people that have spoken. The climate crisis is the biggest threat multiplier and existential threat facing humanity. Point blank, period, finito, punto. There's no debating this issue. Building and construction makes up 37% of all carbon emissions worldwide. And in Chicago, estimates project that 70% of our emissions come from construction and housing. That is unacceptable. We cannot be part of the problem. We should be part of the solution. And I think part of the solution lays in this ordinance. Aside from the facts that I've also pointed out, I'd like to move to thinking about the logic behind this ordinance, because data is not the entire picture. I know a lot of you may be thinking about how it's necessary to first invest in the neighborhoods that have been most blighted by disinvestment and lack of housing. I 100% agree with that. We can't just focus on the gentrifying neighborhoods. But this is actually a solution to gentrification because it allows us to protect residents and give them the rights that they deserve. Thank you. Now we're going to go into the last three public comments that are via remote means. We're going to start with Curtis Kimberling. Can you hear us, Curtis? Yes. Hello, yes. Go ahead. Hi. Hi, my name is Curtis Kimberlin, and I live in the 47th Ward. Very happy to speak with you all today. Thank you for being here and allowing for public comment. I'm with the One North Side. We are a community organization that builds power for working class people and people of color on Chicago's north side. The reason I wanted to speak here today and advocate for green social housing is that it is a type of affordable housing for people who come from a wide range of income levels. It differs from existing models due to the fact that it places the control of housing in the hands of the tenants themselves. Housing should be able to meet the needs of the people paying for it. I also think it's important because it addresses the health needs of its residents, not only because by making housing affordable, residents can afford things like health care visits and going to the doctor, but because environmental justice, to me, is a health care issue, environmental justice and health care justice go hand in hand. Green buildings improve indoor air quality and reduce exposure to toxins. these are all really important issues to me for a number of reasons but one i'll mention is that i'm from texas i'm not a native chicagoan i was born and raised in dallas given in my time down in the south i have seen the way in which infrastructure is not being prepared for climate change can have detrimental impacts on the people living there in 2021 when texas was hit with a massive winter storm texas was not prepared for it and they had power outages and shutdowns that cost lives. And the people in power there still to this day have not really prepared or done anything to change Texas for the better and to address the needs of climate change that we're currently living in. And one thing I really love about living in Chicago is that people in power here do do what they need to do in order to address climate change. And I think this ordinance is going to be a big factor in that and addressing climate change for the people who are living here. Yeah. Thank you, Curtis. Next, we have Jessica Rodnick. Can you hear us, Jessica? Hello. Can you hear me? Yes, go ahead. Great. Thank you. Hi, council members. My name is Jessica Rodnick. I'm a volunteer with One Northside as well, and I'm a resident of the 46th Ward. and I want to just say that I echo what many speakers so far have said. I want to see Chicago use this challenging moment that we're in as a country to be a leader, to be a beacon of hope, to show a path forward in an innovative way, to move the needle on two seemingly intractable issues for which we have an approach on the table here in front of us with the Green Social Housing ordinance. I've seen firsthand how affordable housing impacts my neighborhood where there are many subsidized housing buildings and affordable units and I think our neighborhood is better for it. We have an amazing cultural, economic, racial, and age diverse community that is unparalleled almost anywhere else in the city and it makes our neighborhood attractive and strong. And we also know that we don't have enough affordable housing. You can see that anytime you walk down a street in Chicago, anytime you drive down Lakeshore Drive and see major encampments of tents of folks who just cannot afford to live in this city. And we know from data across the country that the availability of affordable housing units is the number one predictor of how many unhoused folks you have. And so we as a progressive city can do better, so we must do better. I also know personally what it's like to live in a unit that is not climate ready. I, previous to living in Chicago, was living in California, where I was in a unit that had no air conditioning, despite the fact that my city dealt with many days over 100 degrees each year, which have increased in number. we've also seen as wildfires continue to plague both the west and the northern midwest that air quality is decreasing and we have more thank you jessica our last speaker is linda armitage can you hear us you're still you're i think you're muted linda can you hear us i think you're muted linda press star six to unmute can you linda can you try star six please still muted oh there it is thank you sorry i am can you hear me yes good afternoon um i am linda armitage i am a senior citizen and i advocate for senior citizens in public housing i want a city where seniors can live, age, and thrive with safety, health, and dignity, free of ageism, racism, and all other forms of oppression, including that of greedy developers and landlords. The Green Social Housing Coalition, through this ordinance, is working on these same goals. I was threatened with homelessness 10 years ago when a venal not-for-profit organization shifted gears and decided to sell its three Chicago senior properties to a market rate developer in order to enhance its upscale suburban retirement communities. 120 senior residents fought back. Our homes were ultimately sold to the Chicago Housing Authority, and we continue to struggle daily against neglect, disrespect, and the less than dignified living conditions that all of you have heard about from your constituents. The ordinance I am here to support embodies tenant protections and tenant participation, among other wonderful values. I am a proud citizen of Chicago. I was not born here, but I have lived here for a long time, and I am a member of the Green Social Housing Coalition. I urge you to support this ordinance. Green social housing is a public good. It's a major path to building a more equitable and healthier Chicago. It is up to you to take the next step on that path today and advance this ordinance to the full city council. Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. And this concludes our public comment period. We received numerous written public comments from various housing providers and advocates in support of the green social housing ordinance before us today. These were sent electronically to every member of these committees. I'm going to read off the list of those organizations in support. There were no written comments in opposition. Those organizations in support are the Latino Policy Forum, Abundant Housing Illinois, Elevated Chicago, Center for Neighborhood Technology, 548 Enterprise, the Chicago Community Loan Fund, People for Community Recovery, Access Living of Metropolitan Chicago, Jewish Council on Urban Affairs, Palenque LSNA, Julie Working, former policy director at the Chicago Coalition to End Homelessness, Santera Matthews, 48th Ward Concerned Citizen, Shaq Matthews, 48th Ward Citizen, Linda Armitage, and Juan Northside. uh chairman before we go further want to acknowledge alderman beal who has joined us and will be counted towards forum thank you chairwoman we have one item on the agenda this afternoon um this is a substitute ordinance amending municipal code chapter 2-44 by adding new section 2-44-160 establishing the non-for-profit residential investment corporation to address housing needs by financing, acquiring, owning, and operating permanently affordable mixed income and environmentally sustainable housing. Substitute Ordinance 2025.0015560. There is a substitute ordinance which has been prepared and sent electronically to everyone. Is there a motion to accept this substitute? So moved by Alderman Les Pada. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. in the opinion of the chair that eyes have it the substitute ordinance is now before the joint committee and will be explained today we'll uh we'll have um um commissioner uh lissette castaneda department of housing um to do the opening remarks good afternoon good afternoon chairwoman dowell and chairman cinchelopez and all members of the committees on finance and housing and real estate and all other alders present here today as you all know I am Lisa Castaneda I'm the commissioner for the Department of Housing today I am here to ask for your favorable consideration for the green social housing ordinance right now we are facing a critical moment a moment that will determine how we respond to the ever-growing national crisis here in Chicago and how we will shape our city's future more than 119 000 families in our city are struggling to find affordable housing. Over half of all Chicago renters are spending more than 30% of their income just to keep a roof over their heads. These figures are more than just numbers. They reflect the real-life burdens faced by our neighbors, our friends, and often our own family members. No parent should ever have to choose between putting food on the table for their child and paying rent. Federal support for affordable housing, especially through programs like the low-income housing tax credits is becoming less reliable with many states facing federal cuts to their housing budgets. With this looming national environment, Chicago cannot afford to wait for a solution that may never come. The Green Social Housing Ordinance is a critical step to addressing this crisis. It is an innovative plan that provides permanent affordability, supports mixed income communities, and promotes environmental sustainable housing without relying on overburdened federal programs. This innovative business model is designed for implementation citywide and allows for us to grow the pie, adding another tool and funding source to build affordable housing across the city. This initiative represents a unique opportunity to make a lasting impact, serving as a catalyst for change that will benefit future generations. These homes, built to meet the standards of the city's sustainable development policy, reduce utility bills for our residents and improve the overall health of our communities. The Green Social Housing Ordinance does more than just address environmental concerns. It directly responds to the affordability crisis Chicago and space. It lays the groundwork for the creation of an independent nonprofit developer, which will ensure the projects are built and maintained in a way that benefits the community for years to come. These challenges are not unique to Chicago. They are felt across the United States. But today we have the opportunity to lead as the largest city in the nation to adopt a green social housing model. We have the chance to set an example for other cities across the country, showing them how to respond to housing insecurity with innovative solutions that prioritize both affordability and sustainability. We have been developing this model carefully over this last year in consultation with other jurisdictions who are implementing similar programs, two of whom will make comments later in this presentation. And we have been proud to brief all of you over the last few weeks, a process that has made this ordinance even stronger. For example, with your feedback, we have made explicit that the Illinois Prevailing Wage Act and the city's WBE and MBE program both apply to all green social housing construction projects. We added preferences for disabled residents and veterans and established a governance structure that enables effective oversight of the program. distinguished committee members having outlined the many advantages that green social housing ordinance can bring to our city i respectfully request your favorable consideration in advancing this measure through the joint committee i greatly appreciate your time this afternoon thank you commissioner castaneda we also been joined today by jung yun the chief of policy of the mayor's office as well as matt stern assistant commissioner of department of housing young jung will now introduce the rest of the panelists here in the box as well as on zoom thank you chairman good afternoon good afternoon chairwoman dowell in the box i'm joined by zeb mclaurin ceo of mclaurin development partners daniel k hertz at from impact for equity demario green from chicago community loan fund and online we are joined by paul williams of center for public enterprise matt bedsell director of housing innovation from atlanta's mayor's office and montgomery county council chair andrew freetson who will be joining us virtually thank you so i'll start with the presentation overviewing what you have in the substitute ordinance today and then we'll pass it to the box for testimony good afternoon thank you so much for being here green social housing is our opportunity to accelerate mixed income development in chicago with the establishment of the non-profit residential investment corporation you heard pretty extensively in the public comment that we are really facing a housing crisis in this city both affordable and market rate is in short supply and the supply is just unable to meet the demand. We have a shortage of 119,000 affordable apartments than there are families in need, and over half of Chicago renters are cost burdened, meaning they're spending more than 30% of their income on rent and utilities every month. Right now, our main tool to address the affordable housing supply crisis is our federal allocation of our low-income housing tax credit, which is oversubscribed. We spend every single dollar every year, and it is not enough to meet the demand. So we need to unlock new pathways and new funding opportunities to finance housing development in our city so that we can prepare ourselves not just for the current crisis, but for the future uncertainty that we are faced with the federal funding landscape. It is a very difficult financial environment, and it is crucial that we find new ways to move projects that have stalled out, projects that are unable to move currently, and bring more housing to our residents. one year ago this body passed the 1.25 billion dollar housing and economic development bond that took a tiff that uses the sun setting tiff program that is an inequitable way to fund development and turned it into this really powerful economic development tool that can be leveraged all across the city. In that bond ordinance and bond book, you set aside $135 million for the Green Social Housing Revolving Loan Fund. And so since the last year, we have been working very closely with national partners, with community partners here locally, to understand what are the best practices and how we can best bring this to Chicago. Green Social Housing is leveraging an innovative and proven financing model to build mixed income housing development without further subsidies later we'll hear from montgomery county who is the pioneer of this model and how they have been able to leverage their revolving loan fund to bring permanently affordable and mixed income units to their county and we'll also hear from atlanta as well this model has gained a lot of national recognition it's won the ivory prize a national philanthropic prize on housing innovation it has been highlighted in several academic journals as well as under the Biden-Harris administration's HUD there are three main components that make green social housing work each one of them on their own would be a powerful tool but when we put them together we are unable we are able to unlock a lot of potential the residential investment corporation or the ric is the non-profit that we seek to establish through the substitute ordinance before you we'll own these buildings and operate these buildings in perpetuity and we'll go through the benefits of that they'll be able to leverage the low cost capital provided through the revolving loan fund as well as accessing below market capital options for debt products ric ownership will allow us to ensure that there is permanent affordability most of our other affordable housing tools have time expirations to them whether 15 or 30 years and then those units convert to market rate risking displacing the current tenants there under this model these units will be permanently affordable because this is self-contained within the developments. The RIC will be able to earn and recoup value created over time, both the cash flow from the developments as well as being able to pull out equity from our investments to invest it into new projects and deepen affordability of those current developments. This will give us financial independence so that we can produce housing with local dollars that does not rely on state or federal resources. Again, we will be following the existing Department of Planning and Development Sustainable Development Policy to ensure that utility bills are kept under control for our tenants. These will be good jobs with prevailing wage and MWBE requirements. The Residential Investment Corporation will form joint ventures with private developers for construction. This is a powerful way for government to work with the best of our private sector partners and leverage their efficiency while bringing in low-cost capital to unlock new developments. the ric will contract property management and will have its own staff to run the operations of these developments the ric will be governed by a board of directors on which we have five ex officio members the commissioner of the department of housing department of the environment department of planning and development our chief financial officer as well as the chair of our committee on finance eventually there will be a resident appointed to this board and then we will have five to seven appointments with council approval based on professional expertise related to or being an attorney practicing in one of the following areas market rate real estate development acquisition financing and asset management experience is key here we want to make sure that we are bringing good deals back to council for approval we will also be appointing people with affordable housing development and asset management experience affordable housing environmental sustainability advocates as well as a seat for labor oh i'm sorry these will be five-year terms that are staggered so the initial appointments will be staggered so that there is continuity and the five-year term limit is due to the life cycle of the investments so how do we achieve permanent affordability we do this through a mixed income approach cross subsidization within the developments allows for at least 30 percent of these units to be permanently affordable for families up to 80 percent ami and then 70 percent of the units will be at market rate. This will allow us to bring this affordability to the city without tapping into our scarce and oversubscribed subsidy programs. The RIC can then reach deeper levels of affordability by securing unit-based subsidies to especially reach our residents at the extremely low income below 30 percent ami we've also added language in the substitute to allow for in building income averaging to allow some flexibility for reaching those deeper levels of ami and affordability within the developments at the end of the day these buildings are cash flow positive allowing for the ongoing maintenance operations and repairs needed within the developments in order to really maximize the affordability here we're looking at development sizes at 75 to over 200 units per development to really get us economies of scale and maximize our affordability these developments will add to our property tax base they will qualify under the affordable housing special assessment program for some temporary relief just like our other affordable requirements buildings throughout the city the details of which are up here the revolving loan fund is this tool that really unlocks this model for us because the initial investment is a construction financing tool that goes into the developments for three to five years during the construction phase. Once those buildings are built, they're leased up, that financing converts to what we call permanent financing. That then pays back the revolving loan fund investment and we can use that money again and again and again. So the bond allocation this body approved last year will not just be used once but in perpetuity and through the RIC ownership again we can utilize future equity to be pulled out in a cash out refinance to contribute to other projects and or deepen the affordability within those buildings. Here's how the financing works. So on the left, you see a traditional market rate capital stack, where you have a developer putting in equity somewhere between 5% to 10% of the total development cost. And then they have to find an equity investor to come in with 15% to 25% of the total development cost. And then senior debt will make up the rest of the cost. What green social housing does is replace the equity investment, which demands very high returns, 20% or more, and replaces that with our bond-funded revolving loan fund, which only needs about 2% to 5% returns in order to maintain operations and account for inflation and the like. This dramatically brings down the total cost of development, and this is what allows us to achieve 30% of the units affordable in perpetuity without using a single other subsidy dollar. So you'll see here that, again, on the right, you see the construction side capital stack, which very much mirrors the market rate stack. With the developer coming in with some equity, the city will come in with, we can use land, we can then invest our revolving loan fund, and then we'll be able to access below market debt through tools like the Federal Financing Bank's risk share program. we can use volume cap there's also a lot of options through impact investors and other sources to bring down the cost of that debt as well again once this these buildings are built leased up and convert to permanent financing it then you take out what is you know more traditionally like a mortgage that takes out the revolving loan fund we could potentially also work with impact investors for a mezzanine debt product and then our our land of course and some equity would stay in the deal because we are following the traditional market rate capital stack and financing scheme these developments are going to mirror market rate development total development costs which we are seeing today around four to five hundred thousand dollars per unit in doing this we're going to be able to increase the department of housing's affordable or annual housing production by 50 percent annually without ongoing appropriations currently we produce on average 800 low-income housing tax credit units a year and this is a not a static number this is an average this fluctuates based on construction costs financing costs and the like we are very worried that this may be threatened by the current federal administration and funding landscape with green social housing we can produce an additional 400 mixed income units annually and increasing our total production to 1200 units a year over 30 years we anticipate being able to develop nearly 8 000 mixed income green social housing units as the commissioner mentioned earlier we have spent the last several weeks and months talking to members of this body talking to community partners talking to stakeholders developers lenders and labor and we have incorporated a lot of feedback that you will see in your substitute today and so i'm going to highlight some of the changes from the original ordinance as introduced first is we heard a desire to include acquisitions into this model and so we have added that to the purpose of this entity to be able to buy buildings as they come up in the market rehab them as necessary and then put them back into use doh is working to continue to explore additional funding sources that can help support the acquisition strategy we've heard feedback on ensuring that there is a strong and balanced board we have added an ex officio position to the board the chair of the finance committee we have added an attorney to the board as well as a labor spot we've heard a desire to ensure that there is continued council oversight over this program and so all projects will come to council or project funding approval we have added language to really clarify and underscore that the projects using bonds and recycled funds will come back to council for approval we heard the feedback to serve lower income households and so again i did reference this earlier but we have added income averaging language to allow for that flexibility to be able to serve deeply affordable unit units for our families whoops we heard feedback on adding accessibility and alignment with our arl so again all affordable units as well as 20 percent of the market rate units will be type a accessible and we have included a 10 of the affordable units will have a priority lease up for veterans we heard feedback on tenant governance and so we have added guidelines to ensure that a resident governance committee can give tenants an avenue to inform their decisions and raise concerns we've heard feedback on prevailing wage and mwbe so again we are continuing to make the implicit explicit in this ordinance to codify that yes these developments will follow all prevailing wage and mwbe requirements and again we have heard feedback on balancing the green standards with costs and so we have added language again to affirm that these properties will meet the existing Department of Planning and Development's sustainable development guidelines, noting that new construction and rehab have different standards and pathways to meet. And the Sustainability Advisory Committee will advise on how to achieve this. And we have ensured that there is also a spot for labor on that advisory committee. So how will ALDERS get to engage on this process moving forward once we establish the Residential Investment Corporation. The RIC, the Residential Investment Corporation, will identify potential projects and developers to work with through an RFQ, RFP process. There are three main pathways we anticipate. The first is using this financing tool for a stalled market rate deal. Often we see developments come before plan commission, and they have all of their entitlements, but they are unable to secure their financing, and so they never pull their permits that they never start construction. So we can offer our revolving loan fund as that equity investment and restart those projects. The second pathway, again, is the RFQ-RFP process for city-owned land. And then finally, again, the acquisition and rehab strategy as opportunities in the market arise. by using all three of these strategies we are confident that this model will work citywide and be able to meet the unique needs of each neighborhood there will be lots of opportunity to work with council on developing what those proposals look like and the proposals that are considered then the RIC will work with a developer a local alder and the community to shape that development going through their just normal community development process with a lot of automatic feedback there. Then the RIC will vote if they want to approve a project. After rigorous underwriting from several parties, both the RIC, the co-developer, and the lender, the board will review these projects, and if they pencil out, they meet the goals of the program. Those would then be passed through there, and we have, again, a council member on that board with a vote. Then it would go before the full council. If it needs a plan development, it would go before plan commission. If it needs zoning, it would go to the zoning committee. And then again, all of these projects go back to finance committee and the full council for approval before a single dollar is appropriated. After that, then the RIC can enter that joint venture with the developer to secure their permits and start construction so next steps include the authorization of the residential investment corporation the nonprofit developer to execute this program on behalf of the city again City Council retains control of these funds and must these projects must be approved by council no funding is approved in this ordinance I want to quickly give a highlight of what we anticipate an operational budget to look like for the RIC and really underscore that this is not a an actual budget but one for discussion purposes only this will be the duty and responsibility of the RIC board to establish and determine but what we anticipate is using up to three consultants in this first year until we can hire up employees we anticipate five employees in 2026 increasing up to 8 by 2027 and 11 by 2030 to effectively run this program including positions like a president a development analyst asset management team with other costs both administrative legal and consultings we anticipate a total of 3.5 million dollars to be sufficient to cover the operations for the first five years and that is the five years in total which is 2.6 percent of the 135 million dollars allocated to this program from the Housing and Economic Development Bond by 2030 this program is self-sufficient through developer fees asset management fees and cash flow from the building so again this is not something that the bond needs to support in perpetuity but just for initial startup costs and so with that I'm going to pass it to our virtual presenters first and then we'll move to our esteemed guests here in the box and so with that uh i'd like to introduce um paul williams from center for public enterprise thank you uh i i think we're going to pass to uh councilmember friedson first because i think he has a time constraint excuse me excuse me one second please all right um just to ensure that we do not we're not here all day. Can we start the clock? They have two to four minutes of comments. Thank you, Truman. Go ahead. Start at four. Good afternoon. Thanks for having me. I'm Andrew Friedson. I'm here in Montgomery County, Maryland, which is right outside Washington, D.C. I chair the Planning, Housing and Parks committee and really excited to share with you our experience with our housing production fund which is a model that is being considered there and i'm really excited to hear that so thank you commissioner castanada and the joint committee members for having me let's move to the next slide so just to give you a quick background montgomery county right outside washington dc it's very large 550 square miles we have about 1.1 million residents and not quite the size of the the city of Chicago. We're very racially and culturally diverse. Majority people of color, over 40% speak another language. Economically diverse, our median income is $126,000, but we have more students on free and reduced meals than the total enrollment of the District of Columbia's public school system. So it's a very interesting dynamic in that sense. We're urban, suburban, and rural. We have a large agricultural reserve, but we also have some of the most densely populated areas, in fact, more dense than the city of Baltimore, for instance, in the northern part of our state. And it's very expensive to live here, like it is in jurisdictions across the country and like it is in Chicago, and that's what we're here to address. Let's go to the next slide. The Housing Production Fund is really a different way of approaching it in terms of financing affordable housing. You heard the model that you're considering and some of the aspects of it, which is modeled in a similar way. Just to speak to that here, a traditional private development, we have for a 400-unit private development, 50 of those units would be dedicated at 65% area median income as part of our inclusionary zoning. The other 350 would be market rate units. To compare that, an affordable housing project through the low-income housing tax credit program, for instance, with 4% tax credits, would only be able to yield 120 total units, so you'd get more affordable units, but not the total amount of housing units overall. And those units would be restricted for 30 years through the low income housing tax credit program. And if you then look at the third model, the different approach that we have taken, the housing production fund, similar to the model that you're considering in the city of Chicago, that same 400 unit as the private development would still occur. But because it's publicly owned and because it's part of this mixed income model, 120 units would be affordable, like the low income housing tax credit entire deal, except you'd also then have 280 units on top of it that are market rate units that help to finance the project. In our model, 20% would be at 50% area median income, 10% at 60% area median income. And they would be permanently restricted because they're permanently held by our Housing Opportunities Commission, our public housing agency in Montgomery County. So you're really getting the best of both worlds, the total number of units, because it is a supply and demand challenge to produce more housing to address the affordability challenges. But you get rather than the 50 units that you would get in a private market rate development with inclusive zoning requirements, you get 120 affordable units and the total of 400. So it's really the best of all worlds. It's cost effective and scalable and it's publicly owned. Let's go to the next slide. So you heard what the benefits are and how some of these programs can be structured, but it's a revolving loan fund, which is part of the secret sauce to it, which helps make it be scalable. 70% are market rate. Those market rate units subsidize the 20% of the units at 50% AMI and the 10% units at 60% area median income. It is essentially a construction loan. And so once the project is stabilized, it pays back, in our case, it pays back at a 5% rate and then ultimately pays back the entirety of the loan. The benefit of that is that this is additive, not competitive. So this is in addition to all the low-income housing tax credit deals that we're already doing. It's in addition to some of the other affordable housing programs that we're doing. And nearly every other program that we are doing, they're competitive with one another. And so it limits the amount of affordable housing that we can do. Because of the benefit of the revolving loan fund, these pay back every four to five years in their entirety once these deals are stabilized. They're able to generate about 1,500 units in each of those four to five year spans. And so over the course of the 20 years, it is a total of 6,000 units that we're able to introduce into the market that are publicly owned, publicly held, and publicly controlled in perpetuity. So it is a very meaningful ability to address those issues. And after the 20 years in our case, it still revolves. It still continues to generate those units each and every cycle. And so it's generating those units each and every cycle, and we don't even have to pay the debt service on those bonds as we move forward. Let's move to the next slide. Thank you, Mr. Freidson. Can you wrap up your comments? Sure. I'll just quickly say, it's fast, it's simple, it's scalable. $54 million in taxpayer money on our end has helped us to create $2 billion in investment, which is just a huge return on investment. So far, we have already done three projects. We have a fourth project moving forward. We expect to have seven projects by 2030. And, you know, we're excited to see that you're considering this similar model and that jurisdictions all over the country are starting to adopt this model as well. Happy to answer any questions if you have any, but really appreciate the opportunity to share our success in Montgomery County and the way that all of us can tackle the housing crisis in a creative way. Thank you, Council Member. Thank you. Next up, we have Matt Betzel. Hi. Good afternoon. My name is Matt Bedsoul. I serve as director of the Housing Innovation Lab in the office of Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens. Our lab was created to advance new models of housing delivery, and we were instrumental in designing, launching, and now continuing to support the recently created Atlanta Urban Development Corporation, or AUDC, which is a new public developer for the city of Atlanta. AUDC was established in 2023 to build permanently affordable mixed-income housing on public land. Its mission is simple but ambitious, to deliver housing that's affordable, located in high-opportunity areas, and is financially sustainable. AUDC treats investments in affordability, not just as a public good, but as a pathway to financial stability, helping runners build wealth through housing cost savings and high quality, well-located homes. Atlanta created AUDC because we knew this model needed an organization that would wake up every day focused on making it work, a dedicated team fluent in a new kind of housing delivery. Unlike traditional LIHTC or public housing, social housing must compete with market rate development to attract market rate tenants and to be economically feasible. That creates real financial discipline. It also demands a public institution or non-profit entity that is nimble, entrepreneurial, and built to structure effective public-private partnerships. To support this shift, the city launched a $38 million housing production fund, which is a revolving loan fund that replaces traditional preferred equity, similar to Montgomery County's model, and committed a pipeline of city-owned sites to help AUDC build momentum and execute this model at scale. In just over a year, AUDC has led three major public land developments with strong early results. The projects are delivering at 20 to 30 percent lower costs than equivalent LIHTC developments due to the AUDC's ability to manage land, reduce costs, and also avoid a lot of the soft costs associated with LIHTC development. We've also used this opportunity to support innovative development models, including mixed income residential tower above a new publicly funded fire station and infill rental housing using small-scale multifamily buildings and walkable neighborhoods. One of the most valuable outcomes has been the strong partnership between the AUDC and the city. That coordination allows for a proactive pre-development zoning strategy, which has increased the value of our public assets, enabled our land to serve as real equity in new construction. And we have good news because the private development market has responded well. We've seen strong interest from experienced market rate developers and newly formed nonprofit organizations created specifically to work within the AUDC's public-private framework. That response validates this model completely, a public entity that sets the vision, it holds the land, and brings in mission-aligned partners while keeping long-term affordability and community benefit at the center. The last thing I'll say is, most importantly, AUDC is helping Atlanta build long-lasting public sector development capacity. It's not just a delivery vehicle. It's an institution designed to support sustained housing production through disciplined partnerships, innovative financing, and a long-term commitment to equity and inclusion. I hope Atlanta's experience offers a useful model for what public development and social housing can look like, and we're excited to see what Chicago can bring to this growing field. Thank you. Thank you so much to our virtual presenters. Next up, we're going to turn it here to the box. First up, we have Zeb McLaurin of McLaurin Development Partners. Good afternoon. I'm Zeb McLaurin from McLaurin Development Partners, Madam Chair, Chairman, members of the council and this committee, joint committee. I'm here as a local real estate developer who has worked with institutional partners for decades to bring institutional capital primarily to the commercial real estate development space in Chicago, but more specifically trying to find out how to better finance affordable housing units across the city. We have developed, own, and currently operate several hundred units of affordable housing over the past decade plus here in the Chicago market. I want to talk specifically about the math and the obstacles that developers face in trying to save and build new affordable housing in the city. The LIHTC housing program, which you're familiar, Federal Housing Program, which started as a result of the Tax Act in 1986 through calendar year 2022, has produced approximately 3,500,000 low-income housing tax credit slash affordable units nationwide. Over 30 years, over that 30-year span, that equates to about 100,000 units per year nationwide. Obvious of big gap based on demand and how to adequately supply the financing mechanisms for these types of units. As we endeavor here in the city to figure out creative ways, every tool that's accessible to the development community is another tool in our toolbox to try to appropriately finance these projects. When we were developing in the near north area decades ago, just after the plan for transformation, if a tool like this existed then, the angst that surrounded the Cabrini Green developments and the near north neighborhood may not have existed. I would venture to say the same for near the 606 and in the Pilsen communities as well. This type of asset and tool at our disposal, I think, will help defer some of those fears in areas where you can see development coming in an aggressive way to your communities and neighborhoods. East Garfield Park, some areas of Bronzeville, to cite examples. So I'm an advocate for this program. And more importantly, I want to underscore the local control, both here at this body, the board, and at the city council level to ensure that adequate resources are being placed in the appropriate communities where this valuable resource can be leveraged to spur additional economic development in our communities. Thank you. Next is Daniel Hertz. Thank you. Good afternoon, chairman, chairwoman, and members of the Joint Committee. My name is Daniel K. Hertz. I am housing director at Impact for Equity, which is a law and policy center here in Chicago. I'll keep my remarks brief, but I'm here to enthusiastically support this ordinance for many of the reasons that you've already heard spoken to. I especially want to underscore the critical importance of creating a program that can support affordable housing production if and when the federal government pulls back resources that the city is dependent on right now to operate our current programs, as well as a way to keep cranes in the sky and union workers working when market rate development grinds to a halt if there is an upcoming recession. But finally, I also want to raise something that is of particular interest to my organization, Impact for Equity. We have for a long time been committed to advocating for public housing that truly serves Chicagoans. And while this would be a completely separate program from the CHA, we know that it has the potential to serve as a capital contribution to match with a housing authority's rental subsidies. And we know this because other places like Montgomery County that you just heard from have already done it. What that means is an additional path to bringing back those deeply affordable CHA units that have been lost since the plan for transformation and that are so desperately needed in our communities. And for all these reasons, Impact for Equity strongly supports this ordinance. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Daniel. Thank you. Next up, we have Demario Green of Chicago Community Loan Fund. We have one more presenter, Alderman Beal. I'd ask for your indulgence, please. Hello, I am... Hello, I'm Demario Green. I'm the Policy and Government Relations Director for Chicago Community Loan Fund. On behalf of my organization, I would like to thank the City Council, the Housing and Real Estate Committee, and the Finance Committee for holding this hearing today on the Department of Housing's Green Social Housing Program. CCLF is a mid-sized community development financial institution serving Chicagoland since 1991. In that time, we've made over 670 loans, totaling over $390 million to the for-profit and non-profit community developers working to create or preserve affordable housing, commercial retail, community facilities, and social enterprises in low and moderate income census tracts across Chicagoland. Since our founding, CCLF has helped create or retain nearly 12,800 units of housing and more than 7,800 jobs and leverage over $2 billion in additional public and private investment in the communities that we serve. Based on our community development expertise, we believe that this ordinance would significantly uplift the communities that we serve and provide sorely needed forward-thinking solutions to close the city's affordable housing gap. This initiative represents a pivotal opportunity to foster economic diversity, improve neighborhood stability, and address the pressing need for affordable housing in our city by creating a dedicated source of support for mixed income housing development that community lenders, developers, and investors can rely on. CCLF has seen firsthand how these investments can transform communities, and especially historically underserved communities like the developments we've done in Woodlawn, bronzeville and east garfield park one of those developments that we are particularly proud of is the tree and non lofts located at 61st street and cottage grove avenue which offers 24 units of housing an additional 7 000 square feet of commercial commercial space and at its inception in 2018 it was the first mixed income housing development in woodland in over 40 years these types of developments go a long way towards strengthening the viability of small businesses as well, entrepreneurship and community facilities. Housing this program within a non-profit entity follows a pioneering but proven path to address one of the primary concerns within affordable housing, speed to market. With an anchored vision for the community that goes beyond immediate profitability, this can be extremely successful. This commitment helps to lower costs at a time when it's only getting even more expensive and time-consuming to do new construction and build affordable housing supply. Beyond this, it is our hope that the City of Chicago will use this program to help streamline other existing policies that may be hampering affordable housing development to provide much-weated relief to community developers. This ordinance also allows for greater flexibility in leveraging local resources, philanthropic funding, and public-private partnerships, including working more closely with community-lending institutions like us and the homegrown developers that we support to generate deeper investment. We also hope that this will encourage the city to continue to find innovative ways to support the creation of affordable housing opportunities for residents of all income levels, particularly those who are extremely low income, as part of its long-term strategic revitalization efforts. The current news cycle portrays our federal government in disarray on a myriad of issues, not least of which is affordable housing development. I, along with many of my colleagues and teammates within the community development space, have been to Capitol Hill multiple times this year, all ready to talk to our legislators on both sides of the aisle about the importance of affordable housing and supporting and protecting the agencies and programs that make it possible. And while they all understood its necessity, none of them were particularly enthusiastic or excited about the possibility that anything meaningful on the federal level will be done about these issues today or anytime soon in the near future. This makes it even more imperative that we champion locally-based solutions like GHSP and that do not rely solely on federal resources or large financial institutions who are often unwilling or unable to meet the needs of our most vulnerable residents. It is time for us to empower ourselves and do what Chicago has always done, lead. Thank you for this opportunity to comment on this proposed ordinance. We look forward to working collaboratively with you all in the future. Thank you very much. This concludes the presentation. I appreciate all the persons indulging us to make sure that the subject matter experts can present. I will just name who else also is available for questions during the Q&A. We have also on Zoom, Paul Williams Center for Public Enterprising. We also have Dr. Williams Towns, adjunct professor in Kellogg's Sustainability and Social Impact Program. Brandon White, Deputy Commissioner, Commissioner CFO's Office. James McDonald, managing Deputy Corporation Counsel, Department of Law. Joseph Arcus, project manager, Department of the Environment. Jared Policiccio, the deputy commissioner of Department of the Environment. Bradley Roback, coordinator of Economic Development, Department of Planning and Development. Chase Wheeler, financial planning analyst in the Department of Housing. And Erwin Ortiz Reyes, senior policy analyst in the Department of Housing. Now for Q&A, Chairwoman Dow. Thank you, Chairman. I want to acknowledge Alderman Irvin, Hall, Clay, and Knudsen will be counted towards quorum, and Alderman Cruz has also joined us as a non-member. I also have here that Alderman Martin has requested remote participation at today's meeting because of Rule 59. Can I have a motion to allow him to participate? So moved by Vice Chair Conway. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Opposed? In the opinion of the Chair, the ayes have it. Can you fix my mic, please? If you have questions, I would like you to raise your hand. And for those of you online, we will also ask for your hand we'll start today with the vice chair Conway different seat thank you uh first of all I want to thank thank uh you both as well as everyone in the box and the folks who presented online for everything you're doing to create housing and affordable housing in this city because we certainly have a huge shortage of it as you all know better than I. I have a few questions on the deck. Perhaps we go to slide 12. So I noticed there that our low cost debt has a 4% to 5% interest rate, while the private bank debt on the other side has a 7% to 15% rate. That is not something that I saw in the Montgomery county deck is is uh any idea what the reason is for that is the city going to be guaranteeing that debt why are why are we able to get lower cost debt on the green social housing side we'll turn that over to matt stern thank you for the question excuse me for the record uh matt stern assistant commissioner of department of housing um unfortunately our montgomery county colleagues have had to step away for other meetings um but it is our understanding that montgomery county does use their fund to offer below market rate debt using their tool uh the exact structure of their model is different from ours based on the source of their bond it's not it's not a general obligation bond that's sort of a a specific nuance about the source of funding but structurally speaking their housing production fund does also use below market rate debt to subsidize projects it doesn't But as the city, I mean, the collateral is the same. It's the development. So I don't quite see why the bank would give us lower interest rate. I'm sorry. Let me make sure I understand your question. Are you asking about the senior debt component or the smaller equity component of the stock? No, the senior debt component. Understood. Yeah. So the, so our revolving loan fund that is proposed to be funded by the bond last year, that's the green component on this slide. And that is similar to the housing production fund, the HPF, that Montgomery County uses. In both Montgomery County's context and our context, that revolving loan fund actually only covers a portion of the total development cost with a substantial component of the total development cost being covered by senior debt. That senior debt can be obtained on the private market. It can also be obtained through preferential programs, such as the Federal Financing Bank Risk Share Program. This is a program that we are interested in using in partnership with IDA and have worked in conversation with them to confirm that we would have access to that program for this. And it is one of the tools that Montgomery County uses as well for the senior debt component of their stack. So our low cost debt of 4% to 5% interest is predicated on a federal program. Is that correct? The 4% to 5% interest estimations on that slide can come from a couple of different sources. The FFB risk share program is a federal option. We can also use the city's volume cap to issue preferential debt if we wanted to. There's the possibility of preferential debt from community development financial institutions. and if none of those are available, we always could seek the same private senior debt that a private developer would have as well, in which case it would be more like the 7% to 15% you see on the left. Okay. Now, I noticed, and sticking on this slide, it looks like on the equity portion, the green, you know, the residential investment fund, which is presumably the equity, would be 60 to 80 percent of the total meaning that we would be the majority owner of that building are we noting that we're doing affordable housing here are we going to be willing to do some of the things that a building owner would do like evict people if they don't pay is that is that things that we will be willing to do out of city housing here i think that anytime that you have any sort of affordable housing right those are always issues that you have to go through we will have a resident on the board to ensure that the work that the board is doing and that the property management setup that we have is one that is fair and also does what is necessary we expect that the residents will be able to have a voice and being able to figure out some of the quality of life pieces for it and again property management will also work with folks depending on their needs and i think in that sense we would certainly operate the way that many affordable housing developers do which is that you work with people through the very end to make sure that we don't have to come to that and then if we do you have to take whatever options are necessary is this a decision that would be kept with the ric or would it be um with the management company so the property management company will answer to the RIC board okay okay great now if you could go to slide 11 please just one last all right so in looking at that if if I sense I'm missing something here because if we're let's say we spend half a million dollars to build a unit. And if we're getting, if investors in total are getting $2,000 back per month per unit, which is probably high, but over five years that, you know, my math is like $125,000. So clearly, how are we able to recycle the money in five years? I would have asked the same question to the gentleman from Montgomery County, but they've only done three projects. So I don't think they've encountered this either yet. Sure. So in a market rate transaction like this, it would be commonplace to obtain one set of debt for the construction period of the project and a different set of debt for the post-stabilization. And three to five years is the expected duration of the construction period debt. And so the concept here, as employed by Montgomery County and is supposed to be proposed here as well, is to provide that specialized low-cost debt for the construction period. It's a particularly expensive component of the stack. And then upon stabilization, it would be removed, it would be paid back by other sources, which would be adjusted due to preferential financing that is available once the project is complete, because the ability of the project to generate income at that point is guaranteed and known. If I may, I'd like to invite Paul Williams, who represents Senate for Public Enterprise and is online remotely, who has deep familiarity with Montgomery County model as well, to speak to this. point of information ultimately thank you can you just define for me what stabilization means yes absolutely so stabilization would refer to not only once the building is constructed but also once it is leased up to a substantial percentage and so that stabilization term is an industry term that refers to a high percentage of lease and once once the building is sufficiently leased up it is considered stabilized. Fire is sufficient. Is that something that we determine or that the RIC determines? How does that work? So I can give you the example that in our affordable housing deals, we are usually, investors are usually looking for 100% lease up after about three months. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Lee. Vice Chair Conway. Oh, yeah, but I think she was trying to yield to Mr. Williams, which, thank you. Hello, everybody. Thanks for having me on today and taking the time to have a hearing on this. Council Member on the question you asked about how the funds are able to revolve out of the deal at year five. So the takeout financing that Montgomery County's Housing Opportunities Commission has been able to bring in to take out those revolving funds, which they have done successfully on a number of mixed income projects using this model, is bringing in private mezzanine financing in to replace what was in there with the revolving fund because the projects have that market rate component and because they're only seeking that financing when the project is stabilized and occupied. It has not been difficult for them to find private mezzanine lenders to come and take out that financing, allowing them to revolve their funds and go into another project. Great. Yeah. You want to make sure I'm saying this right. So it sounds like between the permanent loan and the MEZ that you'll have a higher, much higher LTV than you would on the loan to value than you would versus the construction loan, which will allow to take out a lot of our investments? So yes, you could in between, when you stabilize, you could upsize your senior debt portion. That's typically going to be something that you'll see if you have a commercial construction loan and you're converting to, for example, an FHA insured permanent mortgage with a longer amortization, that's going to get you a higher loan to value. And that does happen in some of these projects. There are also opportunities, you know, if, for example, using the Federal Financing Bank risk share lending program, you can carry that full higher LTV all the way from construction through the permanent financing. Well, if you have to have the higher LTV, the right to pay in order for the money to revolve in that short a time, or what am I missing? So think about this. So if you have, say you have a hundred million dollar project, just to make the math simple, 70% LTV, you have a $70 million construction loan, and then you put 30 in from your revolving fund. Then you build the project, you stabilize it, you get it leased up. Then once you're stabilized and you have those market rents in the property, all paying. What you can often do and what Montgomery County has done is find a mezzanine investor who will come into that 30% position and they will take out the revolving fund. And you'll leave a small piece of equity in the deal, either the land contribution that was in or a small cash contribution is equity. But the mezzanine investor, when you have this much market rate component, can take out that revolving fund. No, yeah, great. Yeah. So when I said the LTV to the debt, that included the MES. So if the MES may take that, I'm not it. But you're right. I mean, in a very best case scenario, right, if you're able to upsize, get a higher LTV for the permanent, that can do some of the takeout for you, right? Right. That's the only other question. Slide nine. i saw the total unit count for development uh 75 to 200 units um i recognize the efficiency of doing that but also recognize that it seems like all the development in this city is happening in the 42nd ward 27th ward and perhaps my ward of the 34th ward and across all those words pretty much every development is 75 units or greater but most wards in this city there is you could probably count on one hand or there are zero developments of that size so how was that decision arrived at and how do you think this is going to help proliferate housing across the city we absolutely consider this to be a city-wide model and part of the very diligent work that we will do is the work of working with the alders to figure out what are the best ways to approach this i will also say that i think when we think of like 180 units we often think of like a high rise you know i know that there are parts of the city where there are 180 units i mean you wouldn't necessarily know it because of the way that the building is laid out right and so i think a lot of the work that we want to be able to do is work with the alder say like are you interested in this model do you have a site where this would work and then let's talk about what you think you and your community would like to see yeah that's all i have i do want to a lot of questions here but i but I do really want to thank you all for all the hard work that everybody's done and folks online as well. That's all I have, Madam Chair. Thank you, Vice Chair. Commissioner, I want to follow up on that because in the briefing we had, you mentioned that there was pent-up demand and you had a number of projects that you were looking at. I asked you for a list of those projects. and then in another meeting another occasion when you briefed me separately you mentioned the same thing i asked for a list of those projects and to date i haven't received that so can i get that list today yeah we can provide that through the chair we've worked with the department of planning and development who has identified six projects that would meet this criteria of like perhaps a stall deal that That would be the sort of model that we're looking at when we think of stalled deals. All right, because it's unfortunate that I would have to come into a public meeting like this to get the information that I have been asking for previously. And now that we're in the public, I'm going to get it. So I look forward to receiving that information. I want to go to, yes, Alderman. or is it do they include seniors in this model this 70 30 affordable mix senior housing included we could yeah the model is about it being mixed income it does not limit a population necessarily and so we certainly do affordable housing that includes housing for seniors. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Harris. Alderman Riley, I know I said that you were next, but Vice Chair Mitchell came in, and I'd like to have him go and then followed by you. Vice Chair Mitchell, you're fine. Alderman Riley, followed by Alderman Moore. uh thank you madam chair or chair people um i have a few questions obviously alderman conway asked a couple of them i'd also like to be included on the distribution list for the six projects that were promised uh to chairwoman dowell by the department um i'm going to take it in a slightly different direction for a minute i understand the value of revolving loan funds I used to work for the state of Illinois. They administer a number of them very successfully. I think this is a very innovative approach to solving a longstanding problem in Chicago. And I am genuinely interested in trying to put together a model here that works. I do have some questions, though, because this is a very different approach for the city of Chicago to be taking. And while we do have some proof points in other jurisdictions, you know, Chicago is unique in and of itself. Governance is something I'd like to talk about. The actual entity that would be created here, the nonprofit entity. Sadly, Chicago's history with such nonprofits has been checkered. We have some nonprofits that have been put together simply to skirt FOIA requirements and public disclosures and ethics statements and economic disclosures. and I won't name those out loud but in those cases we've seen transparency flushed down the toilet in some regard. In this case my concern is that this will not be a city of Chicago entity. I know exactly why it can't be and shouldn't be but we're talking about having 11 to 13 appointed members to shepherd this new nonprofit. All of those members will be selected by whomever the mayor is. And I just want to understand how did we arrive upon 11 to 13 board members? Thank You Alderman. I will go to that slide. So the design of this board is is really taking into account who has the expertise necessary to run a successful organization we really want to lean in here on professionals or attorneys working in market rate real estate development acquisitions financing asset management affordable housing development and asset management labor and of course our advocates to be able to ensure that these deals are both financially sound in perpetuity are being managed well and are meeting the purposes of this mission and so the board appointments would all be approved by council and the initial appointments are staggered so that we don't ever face a situation where there is total turnover the five-year term is the life cycle of that involvement or i'm sorry that investment so that the board members can see a development all the way through and you'll see in the substitute ordinance the two of those appointees terms expire in two years and another two expire in three years and that is how we achieve the staggering so that every administration will have a chance to make appointments but really the next administration will be saddled with this board correct? Can you, sorry, by saddled, what do you mean? So it's entirely possible in 2027 someone else will be elected mayor of Chicago. What if that mayor, what if he or she doesn't like the composition of this board or believes that there are incompetent members who've been seated here by the current mayor? Does that mayor then have the ability to go to city council and say, we'd like to remove this board wholesale and have it reappointed with your votes city council is that a possibility in 2027 or would that new administration be forced to work with a board appointed by the previous we will defer to law on that great jim For the record, I'm Jim McDonald. I'm managing deputy corporation counsel for the Department of Law. Once the corporation has been set up, it will be an independent legal entity that will be governed by its articles and its bylaws. There won't be, unless the articles and bylaws provide for it, a provision that legally says the mayor has the power to remove the board, dissolve the corporation, it would be governed under the Illinois Not-for-Profit Corporation Act. And so the articles and bylaws would dictate how you would change board members or dissolve the corporation if that were desired. So just, I appreciate the answer. And just so I'm really clear, I want to make sure I'm understanding what you're telling us, that once this nonprofit corporation is constituted and its board has been populated and less otherwise stipulated in its bylaws, future administrations can't tinker with this. A corporation would have a separate legal entity. It would be a separate legal entity, right? So not accountable to the city of Chicago, correct? There are, I should point out, as part of the board members, you have ex-officio city officials on the board. Understood. Do they have voting privileges, those ex-officio members? Yes, I think they would. And that's clearly stipulated in this ordinance? Yes. And will any of those board members receive, and I don't mean the ex-officio, will any of the non-ex-officio members be compensated with a stipend, cost reimbursements, any of that sort of stuff? No, no. No. Yeah. And just so I'm clear, because I want to hear it from the law department, if the next administration decides there are members of this board that aren't fulfilling the mission that new administration wants to pursue, that administration is stuck with these folks until their term expires, correct? It depends on how the bylaws are written. Okay. And who writes the bylaws? The board would write the bylaws. The board of the nonprofit corporation, right? Correct. Right. Does the city council ratify those bylaws? This ordinance does not provide for that. So we don't. So really, once the board's constituted, they can kind of make up their own rules, kind of, right? Isn't that how it works? Within the limits of the not-for-profit corporation. And within the limits of what this ordinance also provides. Very well. Where I'm going with this is that, again, I think the concept, the idea is a good one. but my god the devil is in the detail and i have some trepidation in handing over the keys to a very expensive car to a bunch of folks we don't really know especially knowing that once they've been seated on this board with the exception of a handful of bureaucrats we put on there as ex officio right who will live and die with the administration many of these folks won't be here if there's a new administration. We're saddling any future administration with these folks and their ability to write their own bylaws without the approval of this body. I'd like to see those types of things addressed in this ordinance before we do hand over control of what hopefully is a very impactful nonprofit to a bunch of folks we don't know or trust. And so that is an issue for me, and I'd appreciate the law department to wrap some more bumper guards into this ordinance so that we all have some faith that the board that is seated isn't going to go adopt a bunch of bylaws that run contrary to the assumptions we made in approving this thing. So again, I'm not criticizing the idea. The concept is a good one. But let's do this right because sadly in this building we have a habit of screwing up good ideas. If I might, Alderman. Yes. One of my colleagues has pointed out to me a section I did not remember that is in the ordinance that says at the end of subsection E that voting members, excluding ex officio voting members, will be subject to removal for cause by the mayor. So the bylaws would be need to be written to comply with that. To comply with that requirement. And so I'm clear. Okay. I'm glad you found that. You're one of the lawyers who drafted this. Is that correct? I'm one of the lawyers, but not the only one. Well, there have been so many changes made in the last 72 hours, it's kind of hard to keep track of what's in this thing and what's not. And so I'm not surprised a member of the law department who assisted in the drafting was confused as to what is in here and what is not, which I think makes the case for us to really make sure that we've gone through this thing in detail before we voted out. And again, I think this could be a great tool for Chicago, but we have to get it right. If I may make one clarification, one of the other things that's also in the ordinance is that there are going to be, because of the staggered terms, there will be expirations both in 2027 and in 2028 that will naturally come up for the board as well. Very well. And with regard to the board members of this nonprofit corporation, and I'm not sure if this also will be handled in bylaws or not, or if we have this stipulated in our ordinance. When it comes to, there's mention in the ordinance of conflicts of interest and kind of a vague referral to economic disclosures. But once this entity is created, this board is seated, who's in charge of compliance with ethics and to ensure that conflicts of interests are being noted and respected and people are not voting on matters that they could directly benefit from. Who is the policeman in this case for this non-profit entity? Because this entity is being created through the Department of Housing, this entity will be subject to things like FOIA, Open Meetings Act, and of course through the Department of Ethics to all of the same standards that the departments are also held to. Can you show me where in the ordinance that's all laid? I just want to make sure I can read that. Where in the ordinance does it say that? Sorry? It's not in the ordinance? So who am I relying upon for this to be true? I think that much like other matters like that we have made explicit that were implicit again I think that this would be something where Department of Law can confirm that anything that is coming from city funds public funds through the Department of Housing would be subject to the same rules a lot of purpose has looked at the structure of this corporation we believe it would, you know, the board, the corporation would be subject to the Open Meetings Act. It would also be subject to FOIA. Is that written in the ordinance? No, it is not in the ordinance. It needs to be. That's correct. It needs to be. Assumptions, I mean, we've got non-profit entities spending hundreds of millions of dollars in Illinois with no accountability to the taxpayer, and they're not even responding to FOIA requests. So it needs to be stipulated in the ordinance. that's how we know we're protected it's not in the ordinance so I would suggest a markup for that Alderman Riley can I ask a point of information to Mr. McDonald as well related to ordinance requirements is this entity subject to the Open Meetings Act yes we believe that this entity would be subject to the open meetings act leave or you know big difference it is a legal opinion lawyers have opinions it is our only just to be clear that we under the under the way this body is structured it would be subject to the open meetings act is that stated in the ordinance that creates it it is not stated in the ordinance explicitly okay well it needs to be it needs to be explicit not implicit. Okay can we talk about the revolving fund for a moment? Is there an award cap? I mean basically per project are we are we gonna put a cap on what any eligible project could qualify for with regard to the loan itself? We saying you know no project shall receive a revolving loan in excess of X amount of dollars or is that entirely subjective on a case-by-case basis? Because the total amount for this fund is somewhere in the range of what, $130 million or so? Is that right? $135 million, yes. Okay. So just to get a sense of how many folks will get a bite at this apple, knowing it's a revolving fund, right? So there's going to be some lag in returning these funds to it. I just wanted to get a better sense of how you've thought that through. Thank you, Alderman. The way that the revolving loan fund investment comes into the capital stack is that it takes between 20 to 25 percent of that total development cost so that 135 million we believe depending on the size of the development and the specifications of the design current construction costs etc will be will be able to be spread out over five years one to three developments per year so that i'm sorry one to three is that's right okay again depending on the size of the building that can then that way there is a continuous development pipeline of that 135 million okay now is there a hard cap so is there a dollar amount cap like 20 to 25 percent of total project cost up to um a certain dollar amount uh or and is there anywhere in the ordinance we actually say that there is a 25 total project cost cap uh or is that just kind of the intent? So there is no hard cost listed or cap listed in the ordinance, but every single development in its full will come before council for approval. So you will get a chance to see the exact dollar amount invested into each project and the details of that financial transaction. I understand. And look, you know, having been around here for a bit, you know, with a lot of experience dealing with real estate developers and having suffered through, I thought, a much abused tiff program when i first got here 18 years ago um you know if you build it in this case this revolving loan fund you know they will come right and and that's a good thing um but they're also going to come looking to hit the pinata right they're all going to come in saying i need a bazillion dollars um and so i just want to know if we have kind of an artificial barrier there to say well you can't come in looking for 100 million dollars um if you have a total project cost of 80 million, you know, come talk to us about 15 to 20. So at least you're kind of managing expectations and also probably on the back end saving a lot of workload for the staff that eventually populates this non-profit. Has any thought been given to that? Absolutely, Alderman. The way any public RFQ or RFP process would outline that based on the specifications of the particular development we seek to build. That is also why we are really looking forward to having market rate real estate professionals, affordable housing real estate professionals on the board to understand and be able to vet these deals. And at the end of the day, because this is not a subsidy but a capital investment, the deals need to pencil out and cannot come with overblown costs an expected taxpayer. Those deals just would not move forward and would not be approved by the board nor come before council for approval. And again, just trying to get a sense of who's controlling the decision making on the front end here. I think I know the answers. With regard to picking an actual master developer, contractor, contractors, subs, construction companies, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Who all has the final say-so on that? Would that be a staff recommendation when eventually when there's a staff for this entity that's brought to then the nonprofit board to vote yes or no? How are they picking their partners and actually doing these projects? How do you qualify to be on that list of potential developers, construction companies, subs, blah, blah, blah? blah, blah, blah. How does that work? Or is that gonna be handled in the bylaws that are adopted by the nonprofit after we create it? Those are all things that would be brought together the same way that they are in deals currently, right? You know, developers will do the due diligence of finding the folks that they wanna work with that are like best suited to working on the deal and that also meet the city's criteria around things like prevailing wage and WBE and MBE. Do you have a sense of what the cost per unit will be for these affordable units you're looking to construct? We look at a lot of the affordable, I'm not the only person who's been talking about this in the last few months, but the incredible cost to deliver an affordable unit in Chicago with lots and lots of soft costs baked into these things. My concern here is that if we're really looking to make an impact and address the problem head on, we can't have a lot of that fluff packed into these things. So what about that? A great deal of the cost with affordable housing has to do with the federal financing that is tied to them. In this case, there will be no federal financing. All the financing will be on our side coming from the Housing and Economic Development Bond through this fund and through other sources of private financing. are currently expecting based on the numbers that we have penciled out somewhere between four hundred and five hundred thousand dollars per unit and that's for the whole development not just the affordable units because it is it'll be mixed income well yeah the cost of constructing the market rate units probably brings your average down based on our recent experience no so these numbers are based on market rate deals yeah because this will operate like a market rate deal ish okay I think Alderman Conway brought it up I'd like to say it again you know when you look at this 70 to 200 unit range density of these projects I understand the economics too and that makes the most sense in a lot of cases and you're right we have different shapes and sizes of housing here and housing complexes are not all skyscrapers. But, you know, as you're looking at this pencil out, he's right. Only maybe a dozen wards are going to have the density with existing structures in place, which are the most attractive for these types of deals. When we know there's a demand and a desperate need for housing in all 50 wards, how do you solve that issue here? because we want folks to be able to live where they work or near to where they work. And while we have a lot of jobs downtown, they're not all here, and a lot of folks would like to have an affordable option within the neighborhood that they've grown up in. So help me understand what we're going to do about the other wards that don't have the blessing that comes with these kind of mid-rises and 70 to 200 unit type of structures. I wholly agree, Alderman. I share that vision that folks can walk and play and work in their ward, in their community, if they so choose. And so one of the things that is already part of green social housing is that acquisition strategy. And so there are neighborhoods in which acquisition will work better because you can pull together several buildings to get up to that number that you need in order to make this economically viable. that is definitely one of the ways. In general, green social housing is another tool in the toolbox. It is our strategy to grow the pie so that the resources that we do have available will go further. And so we are really excited for that part. The last part, and this is something that we heard a lot from developers, is that there are many communities in which private equity has not gone into yet because the market, according to them, is not ready. Because we are looking at different standards. we're confident that we'll be able to look at more communities beyond what the traditional market has looked at. Okay. Alderman Riley, you want to wrap it up? Can I ask one last? One more. Okay. I'll ask my one last question. It's a doozy. Only because you call me a bureaucrat. Oh, you're not a bureaucrat, Chairman. In fact, you're the only one on that list who's not. And God bless you, Chairman. and I know how you feel about them too. So my question is related to when it eventually gets there and I've been looking at the timeline for this new entity. You are anticipating having a professional staff and I understand why, right? The board itself needs a lot of support. These are complex deals. I get it, I get it, I get it. Can you pull up a slide that shows the compensation levels for these positions, please? I do not believe we have a slide on compensation. there was a proposed budget shared. And again, it's kind of broken down here. The budget will be the purview of the board. So what we provided were some examples and it's sort of just penciling out what we think it could look like when the board takes up the question of the budget. And so let's talk about that because I got a glimpse at a list of some proposed salary schedules. and I don't know if one of my other colleagues has that available or not, but I can ask you on the record to talk about it. At the top of the food chain there, I see a pretty astronomical salary associated, close to a quarter million dollars a year. The board is in charge of hiring and firing staff, correct? Correct. Right. And how will they go about vetting job applicants? The board will do so based on however they decide that they want to be able to move forward on that. It will be the purview of the board to set up the structure for what it will look like for them to hire and bring folks on board to the RIC. Okay. Well, even though you don't have a slide, is it possible for the record to please read into the record the proposed salaries for these, what is it, 11 staff positions? Is that right? We can provide that through the chair. We do not have that, again, because the budget that we provided as an example was an example budget. Again, the budget would be the purview of the board, but we can provide through the chair the budget that we provided as an example. Okay. Well, Chairman Diles made it clear my time is done here. I would request that information through the chair, and I think it speaks to a broader point to the two chairs here today that there's no rush to approve this thing right now. You can come back and do it in a week. But it does seem that the homework is incomplete. And the fact that one of the chair people presiding over this joint committee didn't receive answers that she requested ahead of today's hearing underscores that point. And I just want to be very clear here to all the folks here in the gallery who are excited about the program. I think this could be really good. And it is a program that I would like to vote in support of. But governance matters. And these kind of silly questions I've thrown out there today that didn't get direct answers are also very important because we are committing an act of faith here, putting a lot of faith in a board who we don't know is going to populate with an important mission. And I want to make sure that we do this properly. A couple of mayors ago, we had lots of great ideas flying out of this chamber. But when it came to implementation, the lack of detail and planning on the front end made some of what could have been great programs duds. And so if we're going to try and hit a home run here, let's truly hit a home run, not a single. And so I would ask to the chairs that let us get the information we've requested today, process that, get some more answers and clarity from law on some of the questions that I asked and Alderman Conway and others, so that when we do vote on this, we can do it with some confidence, knowing that those concerns have been addressed and that this will be a successful program. So that's all I've got, Madam Chair. But I would request we hold this for at least another week to work through these things. Well, I have a number of aldermen that have questions. We'll take that under advisement. Mr. McDonald, just want to point something out. In Section A and D, 1, where you talk about the ex-officio members, it has the commissioner or their designee. I think we need to be specific. that we mean the commissioner of housing because it could be the commissioner of streets and sanitation the commissioner of transportation so i just want to make sure that we give the commissioner of housing it's that be specified here um chairman it's a technical drafting matter this, you're reading what will become a section of chapter 2-44. So what you're reading will be the text in the municipal code. I'm looking at the substitute ordinance. I understand, but if you look at section 1 of this substitute ordinance, it is saying that we're adding a section to the municipal code. So within Chapter 2-44, the term commissioner is defined to be the commissioner of housing. That is why when we were drafting this, we did not put in commissioner of housing in that reference. Okay, then I stand corrected. Because this will be already defined to be only one commissioner, the commissioner of housing. I stand corrected. Thank you. Alderman Moore, followed by Alderman Taylor, followed by Alderman Laspata. Thank you, Chairman. I think as Alderman Riley stated, I think we want to definitely get to a yes on this item because it's a good two. There are some may want to get to a no on it. But we try to get to a yes if the things that we've asked for are provided. And I think there's been a conversation and several conversations that suggest that we should hold this item until those things are addressed. Now, with my questions, I would say, if you go to your green social housing frequently asked questions, on the back of that page or on page two, under is this an efficient and fiscally responsible use of public dollars, at the statement just above affordable housing is extremely expensive to build in Chicago. it says because GSH financial assistance provided in the form of a loan the funds from the housing economic development bond approved in 2024 can be used repeatedly over time to fund many projects. I'm not understanding that part when what page are you on? This was the green social housing frequently asked questions. okay thank you so when we said that the bond approved to and can be used repeat over time to fund many projects are we talking just about the 135 million that could be used repeal over time because I'm not understanding that the one point and it may not be in the ordinance and but now we got a substitute out I haven't gone through the whole substitute yet so I just wanted some clarity over there because the whole bond can't be repeatedly used over time so that that is correct alderman so the when we refer to using the funds again and again we are specifically referring to the revolving loan fund as was authorized through the bond ordinance that was passed last year the revolving loan fund and we can go to that slide um is a construction period financing tool that replaces about 15 to 30 percent of the total development cost as a equity investment into that development once the building is constructed and leased up in the field they call this stabilized that converts to a different type of financing so rather than construction period financing we move to permanent financing. Construction financing is a short-term loan, and then the permanent financing is more of a, again, negotiated 15, 20, 30-year loan product. Because that permanent loan then takes out the revolving loan fund investment that is made possible through that revolving loan fund, that money goes back into the funds to be reinvested again. As only a part of that 135 though? Correct. And not the entire part of the 135. The 135 million can be spread over multiple projects because it's not the entire cost of the development. It is a small portion. Right, but just, but I said, whatever that portion is of the 135, not of the whole bond. That is correct. I just wanted to make sure, clarify that there. Now question three is, is and it was i guess you just answered it um counselor and i i hope i was concerned um under the governess um when it said the commissioner or the designee so you're saying because i saw that it wasn't specified something like what commissioner so you're saying this in 1a means the um department of housing commissioner but you didn't want to say doh because what it because what this ordinance is doing is it's taking it's adding a new section to the municipal code so once that section is added to the municipal code you it's going to be a new section in what's called chapter 2-44 which is department of housing and if you look at chapter 2-44 it has another section of that chapter the term commissioner is defined to mean commissioner of housing. So we're adding a new section, section 160, this section. So when we use the term commissioner, it's within, it will be within chapter 2-44. So if we say commissioner, it's already defined to be the commissioner of housing because you're in chapter 2-44, which is only about that department of housing. It's not about other departments. That's why we did say for the Commissioner of Planning and Development, we spelled out the full name. Because within 2-44, Commissioner only means Commissioner of Housing. And so if we wanted to refer to the Commissioner of Planning and Development, we had to use the full name. It's a question of when you read the chapter, you see there are definitions. And the term Commissioner is defined to mean the Commissioner of Housing. So rather they confuse people, like why would I again say Commissioner of Housing? did I not mean what I wrote earlier in that chapter, that commissioner means commissioner of housing. I'm sorry if I wound up confusing it. Right, because she's about not doing it. Because it's part of the fact that this isn't a separate standalone ordinance. It's an ordinance that's amending the municipal code. I get it. So would there be a problem of stating that, though? No, we could. It would be unnecessary, but we could. Okay. people would tell me later it was poor drafting to use the full term when the term is already defined what the mother lawyer is going to say that um and um on and there's no page on this this is um under de governess and then two um and again i don't know if this was corrected in the substitute or not it said between five and seven additional voting members appointed by the man with the advice and consent of the city council. Why are we using word consent versus approval? We didn't, there wasn't an intent to have a substantive difference. I'm sorry? It's not intended to be a substantive difference. The consent of the city council, we would read as also meaning the approval of the city council. I would like to see it as approved because if I look at item J triple I, the word approval is there. So let's just be consistent. When I look up consent versus approval, even in the dictionary, it gives me pause. Even the definition in the dictionary is not totally clear. So I think we should state where we're putting consent in number 2E. I think it's in E. It's in a couple of places. 2E on board terms. a reappointment shall be subject to the consent of the City Council. An appointment and associated by City Council consent subsequent to the appointment of the initial voting. So anywhere we have consent, since you don't mean it to be different, let's put approval, please. And then on number nine, conflicts of interest, I reporting on a quality basis. It says the corporation shall provide to the department and to the chair of the committee on finance reports on all financial and legal transactions and to enter into during the previous quarter, the current status of all exist financial. So you represented it to the chair of the committee. why couldn't we have a quarterly reporting to the committee on this our intention is that the why could why couldn't because i you know as of course we we love the chair that we have and our chair is very fair but we may not always have that chair and so i would rather have a quarterly reporting to the committee versus just to a chair that may or may not share that with the committee in a in a meeting thank you alderman our legal objection there could all defer to the policy makers started thank you alderman um that was our intention is that the chair would disseminate that information but we are open to that right it's your intent and i and i have no doubt that this chair that we have here would do it i don't know chair number whatever would you know thank you alderman um And then city council. Oh, and same thing. Oh, I got it. That's it. Those are the only questions I have. Thank you, Alderman Moore. Alderman Taylor, followed by Alderman Lispada, followed by Alderman Lee. Alderman Taylor. Thank you, Madam Chair. Can we talk? how this is different than what we're already doing. If that's, because I feel like these are a lot of things that we already do. Can you explain to folks how this, kind of what the difference is and what are really the protections to make sure that we're actually developing what we say we're going to develop? Absolutely. Thank you for that question. So the way that affordable housing works right now is that through allocations of tax credits and other city soft funds, we are able to fund a project for a developer to go out and develop affordable housing, usually for a term of 30 years. In this case, we are saying that instead of being a grantor, right, giving the money to this development or loaning it out for a term of 30 years we will instead loan it out for shorten shorter amounts of time so that the fund is revolving and then we can use that money to go back into other projects in addition at the end it is expected that this has been discussed that the city would retain ownership and control over the over the end product over the actual properties themselves which again is also different than the way that it traditionally works where a developer is doing that separate from us and so really this is just giving the city the opportunity to play a bigger role in the way that this is being financed to ensure that we can build more affordability. Thank you, Commissioner. Can you talk about what is, because, so let me just talk about some of the deals I feel like have happened. It seems like developers put up very little of their own money. The city puts up loads of money. And I know a lot of that is reimbursement. Are we changing how we do that? Is it money up front or is it still on a reimbursement? basis? So in this case, we wouldn't be participating in the structure at all of a typical affordable housing deal. We would be participating in the structure of a market rate deal, which means that we would be going in and saying instead of taking a loan from an equity investor at this higher rate, you can have a loan from our fund at a lower rate and that will return to us and we will be able to recycle when they go into their permanent debt and be able to say, then we'll take that money and put that into a new deal. So ultimately, it's not about the money that is being put up up front, it's about taking the place of other private investment. How does a project qualify for green social housing support? So there's three paths that we've discussed are looking at, right? One is the stalled market rate deals. One is RFPs for our city-owned land. And the other one is acquisitions. It is our vision that the board will convene and we'll be able to look at projects brought to them. And we also very much look forward to working with our alders to say like, hey, there's a deal in my ward that might be a good fit for this, or there is a property in my ward that I think might be a good fit for this, and then being able to work with you to figure out what the right path is for each deal. My last question, Commissioner, is how does this, does the green social housing deal affect other monies that developers can get on a deal? So this is very much a growing the pie strategy for us. And so um i'm sorry alder woman did i cut you off oh go ahead oh um and so it's a growing the pie strategy so um many of you know that at the last round when we opened up for our light tech credit allocations we had about 34 applications and we were only able to fund 12. light tech is very very over subscribed and there is a lot of need in the city what we are doing with this model is being able to to say there's another tool in the toolbox. So maybe it doesn't have to be LIHTC or maybe this just allows us to let LIHTC stretch a little further because we can use this tool instead. And so we really think of it as just another way of adding opportunities to build affordable housing across the city. Thank you, Commissioner. Thank you, Chairwoman Dow. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Um, commissioner, you mentioned that this strategy or this model will also be focused on acquisition and rehab of existing properties. Is that accurate? That is accurate. Yes. Okay. Can you tell me what percentage of the $135 million will be earmarked specifically for that use? We do not have specific earmarks for any of the uses, but we wanted to make sure that that was an avenue available to us knowing that there are some neighborhoods in which that will be a better strategy to do the work with thank you alderman lisbada followed by alderman lee and then alderman deal thank you very much chair uh i really appreciate the presentation i appreciate the the myriad briefings and consultations and one-on-ones that the departments and the administration have offered to orders in various caucuses and groups of orders to talk about this. Because it's helpful for me when none of the information really that's put in front of us is new information. Like, we really have had many opportunities to learn about this. And I appreciate that. Even though I know that there's new information within the substitute. I will also add, and then I have a few questions. this is solving a problem that the market is directly asking us about. I mean, I was at the Crane's real estate breakfast last week with a number of my colleagues, the folks at my table and at various tables. This is literally exactly what I was asking them about. When they said, when I would say to them, what is the chief challenge of getting development moving in Chicago, it's one of the few times nobody has talked about the entitlement or the zoning process. They said that the challenge was getting capital moving into and through the city of Chicago and through these projects. So we have a, one of the few times that we can say this in this city, we have the direct answer to the direct question that the private market is asking us for. So I really appreciate that. I wanted to ask a question related to nonprofits, because I know that this is a separate nonprofit that we're talking about, but this is, to my recollection, it's not the first time that we've done this. So the Chicago Housing Trust, the Chicago Low Income Housing Trust Fund, these are separate nonprofits that at some point were created by the city of Chicago. Is that accurate? Yes. They are also subject to FOIA and to the Open Meetings Act. Is that correct? Yes. So it stands to reason that if this is another nonprofit created by the city of Chicago, if those precedents hold in any sense, that this would also be subject to FOIA and to the Open Meetings Act, right? Yes. Okay. I also know, because we're going to be voting on some of them next week, that these appointees to the board, when we talk about consent, that means voted on by a committee and by the full city council, as board members will through your committee, Chair Ciccio Lopez, next week. And I know we don't know them now, but if what I've experienced in the past continues to be true here, they're going to reach out to council members, as they did a couple months ago with their resumes, with offers to call us, sometimes having just found our phone numbers through IGA. And so while we don't know them now, it stands to reason the opportunity will probably be there to get to know them either on the phone or through the hearing of one or both of your committees. Does that sound right? We would certainly encourage that. Okay. That's helpful to understand. And just to have a moment to affirm it. So I just had two other questions. I was looking at the Resident Advisory Committee, and I was curious, like, is this for each development? Is this over the whole of the properties owned, operated, funded by the corporation? Could you speak more into that? And when we say equal representation of residents in the market rate and affordable units. Could you elaborate on that? Yes, happy to. So the resident advisory committee is intended to be a citywide body that will give advice to the RIC board. In terms of equal representation, this is a question of equity because 30% of the units will be affordable, 70% market rate, and we don't want residents in affordable units to have less of a voice as residents in market rate units so that was a measure to embed equity into that city-wide body there is also excuse me an ability to then provide a recommendation of a resident to that board seat so again this is very much to codify the tenant voice on the board and into this nonprofit structure. And then in addition, there will be an opportunity for each building to organize their own tenant governance council to address and elevate any issues that they may have at the development. So there will be plenty of opportunities to ensure that tenants feel a lot of ownership, a sense of community, and a sense of stability where they live. This is very comparable to like the local advisory councils that we see with CHA developments sort of like a tenant union. Does that sound right? Okay, fantastic. Thank you. My last question is related to the sustainable development policy because I know we've discussed this at length at the plan commission over the last 12 to 18 months, but it's only a small subsect of like alders who serve on the plan commission. I'm wondering if someone, either like on the DPD or administration side, can talk about what the sustainable development policy, was and kind of like the really, I would say, remarkable revisions that have taken place over the last year or so. Thank you, Alderman. We'll turn that over to Brad from the Department of Planning and Development. Great. Thank you, Alderman. Commissioner, thank you, Alderman Lospada, for the question. For the record, my name is Brad Roback from the Department of Planning and Development. One of my duties here is to look after the sustainable development policy. um so the biggest change we just went through uh with uh an update process in 2024 so it's been relatively recent that we updated it uh the policy started uh back in 2003 2004 as a green roof policy it's evolved over time to include things like energy efficiency that sort of thing it's also evolved to build in flexibility for developers to include sustainable elements and make it a little bit easier to improve the performance of buildings, but also for the bottom line, to make it a little more flexible. We've expanded the definition of sustainability over time. As I mentioned, we've included things like energy efficiency, wildlife protection, public health, even housing in the newer version of this. So we've added several strategies to the menu to reflect that and provide developers with more choices in how they comply with the policy and provide more opportunity for elements that would benefit the city and residents and that sort of thing. We also added things for like zero energy and other things. So it's been greatly expanded over time. It still remains a point-based system, which developments are required to get a certain number of points, but it's expanded how many options there are for developments to comply. I hope that answers your question. Point of information, Alderman Laspata from Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Madam Chair. The gentleman from DPD, you said sustainability, that it's expanded. Is it expanded via ordinance or via policy or promulgation of rules? Thank you, Alderman. It's a departmental policy, if that answers your question. It wasn't by award. So you've expanded the definition on sustainability through the promulgation of rules or policy, right? It's a policy, yes, that the Department of Planning and Development implements. Thank you, Alderman Villegas. You have questions coming up very soon. Alderman Laspata. To which I'll just say, again, I'm asking my own questions. Nobody teed these up for me. The room is wondering. I think it's really impressive work. I think it's worth looking at. I think for folks who have the free time, and who doesn't these days, looking at some of the planned developments that have moved through the commission in the last 12 months. Again, none of this is proscriptive. It's just giving more options, and I would say sustainability options that are more in line with the kind of development that a lot of us are looking to see in our wards these days. So I appreciate the fluidity of that, that there's not a one-size-fits-all strict sense of what green and sustainable means through these developments. but also being in a position through green social housing to bring more development in line with this policy, I think is really powerful and a smart move for Chicago. So I'm excited for what we're doing. I think if I were to say one thing constructive, and I know that the board would do this, right now you can, and it makes sense on the plan development side, to offer 10 to 15 of your 100 points for doing all of your ARO units. on site. I would say if you're already benefiting through this program and doing those 30% ARO equivalent units, probably taking those particular 10 to 15 points off the table is something I would encourage the board to do. But otherwise, I'm really encouraged by where we are, what this means for the housing market across Chicago, but particularly for getting affordable housing moving thank you thank you chairs thank you alderman lesbada it won't be across all of chicago but but uh at least not in the first 10 years um alderman lee followed by alderman beale thank you uh madam chair and thank you uh commissioner and and all of you who have uh presented today and for all of the work that's been put into this i know that this didn't happen overnight um i know for myself i needed a little time to sort of get through everything um so um please forgive me if any of these questions are redundant i walk out of the room a couple times here um can we start with why the non-profit route versus managing a revolving loan fund just within the department of housing i'm gonna tap in paul williams from the center for public enterprise here who's done this work across the country. Paul? Hi, everyone. So the question was on why going the nonprofit route. So I can talk about why a couple of other cities that we've worked with who have put a program like this in place have gone with that nonprofit route. In the case of Atlanta, Matt Bedsell, who helped create the program in Atlanta, is no longer here, but they wanted to give this entity a level of city control, where the city is appropriating dollars to create a revolving fund, much like it was proposed with the economic development bond and with this structure. but have the entity that's making the development decisions have enough independence to be able to move with the speed of the market. And that's what's really kind of key to this model working is that it really functions like a market actor and is not being delayed with all of the procedures that make, you know, for example, the low income housing tax credit program take a little bit longer to get projects to closing. If you want to work with market developers and work with market land and all of those actors, you need to be able to move a little bit more flexibly and with the pace of the market. So having an independent entity, but that still has municipal control on the back end is really the structure that facilitates that. And it also allows that entity to be a kind of separate corporation that can enter those joint venture agreements with developers where they're, you know, procuring contractors and so on and do that flexibly as well. Does that make sense? Yes. I think we can add a little bit more color here. Thank you. Yeah, thanks to Alderman. Again, for the record, Matt Stern, Assistant Commissioner of the Housing Department. This ability to move at the speed of the market is critical. This body, as many others have, have raised criticisms about the price per unit of projects and the pace of production. A part of that reality is the movement of government, right? And recognizing the value in participating in market transactions at the speed of the market is one of the things that allows us to move quickly and effectively. And that has two definitive outcomes. One is a price point outcome. And the other is just being able to move fast enough to capture opportunities as they exist. The chairwoman brought up acquisition and rehab and the importance of that as part of this model. When a property goes up for sale, you know, say a foreclosure somewhere on a 125-unit building that would be a wonderful addition to a portfolio for green social housing, our ability to act on that quickly is imperative. Otherwise, someone else may jump in and that property might miss the opportunity to become a part of the green social housing portfolio. And so a part of the value as Atlanta has recognized and Montgomery County as well, because of the way in which where their program is run out of both functionally operate, not like city departments, but as market participants that can move as a market participant would in the private sphere. So I get that LIHTC gets real clunky and it's expensive. This takes LIHTC out of the equation completely. And everything that I've heard here today and read still assumes that the council still approves every transaction. So I don't see where government is getting in the way if you still have to come back to council to get approval. So certainly there are going to be those trade-offs If council approval is a 60-day process and that's a part of the ordinance, it's been requested by many members of this body, there's absolutely a speed of the market tradeoff there. A different approach would allow the nonprofit to move even faster. Even with the ordinances written, we believe there's a wide variety of advantages. One is the ability to publish RFPs and RFQs at a rapid clip. You got me on that one. Quick turnarounds, yep. Certainly staffing, bringing on necessary contractors and consultants, hiring property managers over the long term. Those are all things that the nonprofit would have greater flexibility. I'll also point out, once the nonprofit establishes, say, a number of buildings in their portfolio, and, oh, I don't know, a heater breaks in the middle of winter, or there's a need for a rapid capital expense that was perhaps unexpected. There are things that happen in the day-to-day course of property management that also the nonprofit needs to be able to be very nimble to be able to act on, that are less sexy, let's say, than the selection of and council approval of the initial financing for a new project. I think there are pros and cons about that. And I think that you're not going to get disagreement from anybody in this room, the need for housing stock in general and affordable housing units and deeply affordable housing units. So just for context, of the 100,000, however many you said earlier, the need for affordable housing units how many of those are what what's the percentage of deeply affordable that's needed today the percentage of deeply affordable that is needed today we could get you that answer through the chair but it would certainly be a significant percentage of what of the shortage is do you feel like that's the majority of what's needed like i won't hold you to it like just you know if you had to give your best educated guess is it a third is it half is Is it a quarter? Is it 10%? I don't know that it is the majority, but it is certainly a significant need. I love the creativity of this and leveraging the loan fund. I think you've heard from a lot of our colleagues here today, just the devil is in the details. And I think that that is, it bears saying that I agree with some of my colleagues that I think we need just a little bit more time to iron out the details. and we're all very comfortable with how we are, you know, empowering a separate entity potentially to operate. I mean, the substance of the ordinance today is really about the creation of the organization and the governance. And, you know, much of what we've covered in the deck about what this will do is not covered anywhere in an ordinance. So I think that there's, it still leaves lots of questions about, you know, on the issue of bylaws and how people are removed, who gets to dictate those or how what sort of Council oversight or input will we have on that um I'm going to get to some actual questions but I wanted to just make a couple of those comments and just echo some of the sentiments of others here um is it possible chairs for anybody from DPD to come down and just tell us what those six projects are what would be really helpful to me is just to sort of walk through a real life example if there's a project that's like a 30 million dollar project that's it's got 300 units in it like walk us through how the the capital stack works and at what point when we meet the the stabilization point i i think i'm going to speak for myself but i would imagine that for others it would help to just sort of elucidate exactly how this piece of it works um because i'd also like to understand just maybe someone in the room could answer this um with existing mixed income developments um what is the average stabilization rate on that like how long does it actually take because i got a concern around depending on where these are located you need the market rate to support the affordable right and you don't get you don't get to use the loan fund until you hit stabilization and you start getting some of that money back generated by the rents i'm assuming so what happens if you don't if it takes longer than you anticipated then it's just tying up funds longer i mean i think these are all like possible scenarios. Yes, thank you. So I think we, because we want to show good faith, there's a lot of great questions. We've got a likely recess for Monday at 2.30, so we've got that information for you. That would be great. I think that would be really helpful. And actually, I think having a presentation on a project so we can see it. Walk through. Walk through something. We would ask the Department of Housing to choose one of those six. Yeah, we can absolutely pull an example to pull some actual um some numbers yeah I think that would be incredibly helpful just to to understand just the idea that these funds could be reused I think is really attractive one right and that it's really self-sufficient ultimately as you get things rolling it's the getting things rolling um and when when they'll get stalled so you know some of my my other questions um uh are around I think more specifically to when the the RIC has been formed um and the the policies that they'll develop over time um I was just when we talked about the when uh when we talked about the maintenance piece of this you know I lived in a condo before so we paid a an HOA these are all rental units um and the city through the RIC is then responsible for ongoing maintenance how is that built into the rents and is can there be consideration for a separate maintenance fund because I think that would be really important because you don't know you know it's inevitable that something will happen you don't know when but it could be some it could be something completely out of your control and if we end up in a position where someone mentioned earlier you know if a HVAC system goes down you have air conditioning in the middle of July, it's a really big problem. And like, who's on the hook and where do you get the money for that? I think that's a fair question. And again, I would like to go back to the nature of the RIC and the green social housing program is attempting to replicate the market rate housing model that exists today. And so the way in which that because we are looking at mixed income properties and because we are one investor to a larger investment stack that involves other folks who will be underwriting this deal confirming that it has the viability to to exist and and generate the rents that we expect it to have that that sort of multiple underwriting approach and that mimicry of the existing market rate development landscape is one of the things that creates the security and confidence in the long-term underwriting. And again, the value of the mixed income units, or excuse me, of the mixed income nature of the building is that the diversity of income sources in the building allows for each individual building to independently have a substantial operating reserve and capital reserve in order to keep that building sustained in perpetuity. So the organizing, from a legal structure perspective, The RIC would operate just like any other large property owner where each individual building is in a financially independent LLC that is a subsidiary to the RIC and that operates financially independently. Now, God forbid something occurs, you know, the RIC would have the ability to step in and provide that additional layer of financial support. But again, the purpose of the mixed income structure and the mimicry of the market rate landscape is that each of these properties is designed to be and implemented as financially self-sufficient, including capital expenses, operating expenses, etc. and thank you for that explanation but to be clear then the ric won't have some standards that would be required of any property that they are operating at the end i'm just wondering if there's going to be overarching standards that that every i understand everyone will will act independently but within within um each of those separate entities are there we'll call them core policies or standards that the RIC would then require that would ensure. And I think what I'm trying to get at is this sort of layer of transparency and confidence for anybody that's listening and for all of us to know that there is some minimum standard that is required based on RIC policies that then these properties would have to maintain, knowing that they have the latitude to do some things on their own? Yeah, sure. So in the industry, that would be referred to as a business's underwriting standards. And so the housing department for our LIHTC program has an underwriting manual that we stick to when underwriting our LIHTC projects. And any large real estate investor would similarly have underwriting standards. The RIC would establish those as well. And again, when we look to the proposed board composition and the reliance on people with market rate, uh real estate development expertise is specifically to be able to bring to the table and and to earn as stakeholders the long-term success of this program the very people who are best positioned to design and approve uh consistent standards like the ones you're talking about thank you um i know uh church lopez says we're gonna probably recess and come back on monday um and some more more information is going to come I just want to just I get get on the record a couple of the other things that I wanted to ask here um and I don't know how that the answer how we're going to answer this question even next Monday but again a lot of the the substance of of what we're talking about in terms of what the RIC will be doing it's not covered in the ordinance I think there's a there's an overarching question of really like what input and I know this is going to come through department commissioner um and I guess you know what I'm asking for is to ensure that we've got some partnership and really um that the Council has an opportunity to weigh in on what the policies of the RIC will be because we'll get one we'll get one shot at this if this is established as as uh as Jim rightfully said this is establishing an independent organization um and beyond just approving the projects that come through we won't have any influence beyond that um so I think take that as you as you will um I don't know how we how we get to that ultimately or how that needs to be codified if at all but um I think that's a big missing piece of this um definitely for me right now um and then just talking to some of my community partners you know that um looking at uh the need for the the deeply affordable one of the questions is how are we going to ensure that you know these projects do address some of the deeply affordable needs as well um I don't know if you want to take shot that yeah so one of the things that um we will be incorporating will be income averaging um so ensuring that if we need to go a little higher on some one end so that we can get deeper affordability on the other end will definitely be one of the things that we will be looking for and so that's part of what we have already started to put forth as to how we're going to address some of that there is also still the opportunity to work with partners like the chicago housing authority on vouchers the vast majority i learned this the other day i think something like uh 84 percent of um voucher holders at site-based uh wait lists are uh very low ami so 30 percent and lower um and so we would look to also figure out how to partner with the cha we have briefed them and there's a lot of interest and excitement over working with us on this thank you so for monday if we can also include just a current example of mixed income development um you know sort of take us through that timeline as well as again how do we get to stabilization um what percentage uh are at whatever levels of different ami because i i think seeing it in practice also really helps people kind of it will help me wrap my head around a little bit more of how the economics work out um is there anything else on here oh um would would any of these projects be eligible or come to city council for tiff assistance at all um the goal is that everything that is coming through here would come directly out of this residential investment fund which again is funded by the hed bond or the housing and economic development bond so we are not necessarily anticipating that it would use tiff funds okay yeah because i know on the economic development side you know the the way dpd talks about it you know everything's on the table it could be the bond money it could be the tiff money it could be lots of things i just wanted to clarify whether or not um so it's not intended to but it still could be i just want to make sure i you know i hate to close any door but i will say that this is fully like everything that we have modeled out is using housing and economic development bond money to put into the construction fund i can't even imagine right now where we would use tiff money and again the goal is to just be able to use this money to revolve that fund which i don't think would even be an eligible use for tiff sure is it okay if i have two just two more two more two more okay um in uh in the definition section under number four um so section under definitions um we reference under financial interests um it means an interest held by voting member an advisory committee member relative as defined below in an entity affiliated entity is defined below but it's not defined below so maybe that's just a scrivener's error and it was left out we just don't define what an affiliated entity is uh alderman would you repeat that again so i can make sure i have it um under number four we reference uh in the definition section under financial interests affiliated entity and it says as defined below but we do not actually define it below unless jim has a clarification for that okay you have to keep reading i'm sorry we didn't put it in that section but if you go to section g conflicts of interest of paragraph i we defined it there affiliated entity okay thank you sorry i should have put it in the definition section up front we thought it made sense oh you have another question alderman um you said two yeah i did say two um yes i do um on the um let's get to it on the last page on the representation of um equal representation of members and the advisory committees um does that include the the market rates of there's 100 units 70 is market rate 30 is affordable does that mean then you'll get on a 10 person committee seven market rate and three res three affordable just trying to understand how that works no this means that if it was a 10 person advisory committee five would be from market rate five would be from affordable okay got it okay thank you for clarifying that was it thank Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Beal, followed by Alderman Wagesback, followed by Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Good afternoon, everybody. Most of my questions were already asked by previous speakers, so I won't be redundant. But if somebody can just give me some clarity on how this would help me in the Ninth Ward. so i think that again once the we are able to look at deals in front of us you know we would look at deals in evney ward to figure out if they pencil out that's one way the other way is again we're growing the pie the idea is that if we can move away from having um these like all of our affordability come through one single source which is light tech basically then we can say great then um if we can use this opportunity in one place then there is more light tech and more of those sources available in other places okay so we don't have any really concrete um opinions on how this can directly just you know point to how it can help me i think our hope is to be able to work with every alder who is interested in bringing this model to their award to figure out if there are deals that would make sense, whether they be acquisitions, new builds, or anything like that. Okay. Creating this whole new non-for-profit entity that's going to be basically outsourced, what would prevent us from maybe just hiring two or three people in your department that basically concentrates on nothing but this, following the market, following different things, and save ourselves millions of dollars? sure the the only obligation of the ric won't be limited to simply hiring staff it's also a property management entity and asset management entity over the long term and so that involves a a wide variety of functions as an organization including uh selecting uh procuring uh contractors professional property development agencies uh making decisions about capital investments into individual properties, hiring staff, hiring consultants, all things that an independent nonprofit can do efficiently and effectively and at a faster speed. And we think more financially efficiently than the city can as well. Okay. So you say you think they'll be able to move it faster and more efficiently because we don't know that for sure. Based on who's running it, how it's being ran, how decisions are being made. It could basically be a hindrance versus moving things in an expeditious manner. We have a variety of models about how other jurisdictions have done this kind of program nationally to reference. We also have examples of other nonprofits similar to this that have been incorporated by the city for special purposes. They don't do exactly this, but they have a track record of doing what they're supposed to do efficiently and effectively. Okay. So are we looking to pull somebody with a track record that's not from Chicago? We have, you know, you've heard speak today a number of folks that we consult regularly around the country who are doing similar work to this. The Center for Public Enterprise is a national consulting firm that is supporting us on establishing this program. And they are very well situated with partnerships across the country, cities that are in a variety of states, of putting programs together like this, including actively working with both Montgomery County and Atlanta, who are the most furthest along in the production of this sort of model. So are the people who help put this together for you all, are they also going to be bidding to run these programs? Well, as we've discussed, there are very strict and clear sort of financial interest elements written into the ordinance that would limit anyone with a specific financial interest in, you know, bidding on or putting forward a project. So from an ethics perspective, I think that's very clear here. But when I talk about, if you're asking about the folks that I mentioned specifically, you know, two of those entities are other city entities who are already doing this in their own city. I don't expect the city of Atlanta would bid on a project to build in the city of Chicago. And the consulting firm is a subject matter expertise organization. They aren't, you know, general contractors or developers themselves. So no. So nobody that testified today is going to be bidding to potentially be the chosen one to implement this program? I don't believe so. And again, if, I mean, there are developers who have expressed interest and enthusiasm in this program locally, they would be eligible for the program unless they are appointed to the board, in which case they could not be both. Okay. All right. I know most of my colleagues talked about the board appointments. That's another problem that I have with this ordinance, that we don't have a good track record of appointees to boards thus far. and we're going to just turn over five to seven board members and then also whoever the commissioners appoint, which are also going to be basically the mayor's appointees. So basically this is a mayor-appointed project because all the commissioners are appointed or their designees, they're appointed, and he's going to appoint five to seven. Those are appointed. And so how do we get checks and balances? I think it's been um it is written into ordinance um all of the non-ex-officio members of the board will be brought before City Council for approval that they're going to be brought forward from the mayor's office we would certainly um again that will come from uh any number of sources in terms who actually gets put on there we have some very specific guidelines for what we're looking for again to the point earlier about making sure that underwriting standards and things like that are being addressed um certainly uh there will be the department of housing would have a hand in um ensuring that this is that the folks that we're putting on the board are the ones that we need in order for this to be a successful model okay that didn't really answer my question commissioner so you're saying that the department is going to be making recommendations or is it the the mayor going to be making recommendations or if the mayor will make recommendations through the commissioner so how's it going to work it is it is mayorally appointed yes and again brought to city council for approval thank you all right well let me just say I the concept is good I think some of the numbers are skewed and you know the whole question about the AMIs are raising a lot of concerns from my colleagues as well as myself. And I'm not sure how this is going to help me in the Ninth Ward. But I guess this is a long-term project where I'm, you know, maybe my successor may see some benefit from it. But, you know, we talk about tools in the toolbox, and I agree with that. We need tools in the toolbox. But basically, you know, those tools are not working for me right now. because we talk about affordable housing. I have over 500 units right now that are vacant that I've been trying to work with the department to get some financial assistance, and I can't get it. But yet I got a 300 unit where a developer is trying to implement $19 million, and we can't even get tax credits. And I got another unit that's about 45 units where we've been trying to rehab in the Ninth Ward. But if our goal is to put people in these units, if I got 300 ready to go, let's go. Why am I having to fight to get tax credits? Why am I having to fight to get approval and the contractor's ready to go? And I'm trying to figure out how we can get those projects going where we don't have to reinvent the wheel or something new. We can rehab something old. So help me with that one. Acquisitions are definitely part of our strategy, and we'd be very happy to work with you to figure out. Commissioner, I'm not looking for acquisition. I'm looking for tax credits because I have a developer with $19 million that has a shortfall to rehab 300 units in my ward, and I can't get assistance. I'd be happy to talk to you separately about anything that you're looking for for LIHTC. Again, I think part of the beauty for us of this model is it's an opportunity to ease some of the pressure of the oversubscription of the need for LIHTC across the city. Okay. Well, hopefully the next time we have a conversation, I can say something positive about a project in my ward that could benefit not only my ward, but the city of Chicago by bringing those units online. Because there is a huge need for affordable housing in my ward. and I brought that project to you guys and we haven't been able to get anywhere. So hopefully we can turn that tide. But until then, and hopefully my colleagues get the answers to a lot of their questions that they have. And I don't know why we need to hurry up and get this done come Monday. I think that's not going to be enough time for us to digest all the amendments and substitutes that we need to put forward. So I think this needs to be punted for at least another month or two so we can digest it. So thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Alderman Beal. Alderman Wagesback, followed by Alderman Villegas, followed by Alderman Scott. Thank you, Chairwoman. Alderman Beal, are you just asking for 19 million of HED bond funds to just close your deal? Yeah, that might be a quicker way to do it. Well, thank you, Chairwoman. And a lot of my questions have been asked and answered as well. I just wanted to go back to reiterate the point that we do have a problem with oversight of this RIC. Several of us do. You know, we just had a PBC member who, it was made clear to us in the Ethics Committee, who is involved in some other type of issue basically has no compliance required by ethics or by the OIG. And basically the same situation as this would create. So I don't understand where you guys think you're going to have OMA, OIG oversight, or FOIA oversight over this entity once it's created. And allowing this entity to create its own bylaws to possibly address this issue doesn't come close to what we need for oversight over this agency. So I just want to reiterate, there needs to be much more robust effort made to have people on this entity held accountable for the taxpayer dollars that are paying to create this entity. It's not just money that's floating around. This is taxpayers' dollars that was borrowed at a high interest rate, and with the next bond rating hit, is going to be even higher. So we have accountability to our constituents through the OIG, through the ethics, and through having bylaws and an ordinance that addresses that issue directly. Not implicitly, but explicitly. So you will not get my vote until there's changes made in that part of the ordinance. The other thing that I just want to address too is when it comes to the cost of this agency, Alderman Riley brought it up earlier, and I think you could probably share this with everybody during the committee. It could have been sent around, but I appreciate you guys sharing it with me. The payroll burden for this agency or this RIC is going to be 25%. percent. The starting payroll for the president is going to be $195,000. Senior VP, $175,000, and it goes a little bit down from there. $155,000, $155,000, $125,000, $125,000, for analysts, $125,000. Those are pretty significant salaries with the four percent COLA, annual COLA. That's the kind of stuff that taxpayers want to know about before they have us sign on to these types of ordinances. They're paying for it, not anybody else, at least in the short term. So I think it's important to make sure that you share that information with every alderman so that they know what they're voting for well in advance of sort of this rough draft that we've been given here, even with the substitute changes. The other issue I have is with the length or the term lengths here, the five years. Can anybody tell me what other entity in the city has five-year terms? Are you referencing for the board, Alderman? Yes, for the board. We could... It's zero, nothing. So over the last several years that I've been Alderman, we have created other entities. There are no private entities that were created in this similar fashion. They don't have the same type of term lengths of five years. They're all two to three, and that's what this should be as well. And that two to three year term is the standard for municipalities across the country. We don't go longer than that because we want to ensure that there's oversight. We want to ensure that there's avoidance of entrenched interests over a five year period. And that's what the ethical side of it is for. When you get to five years, you avoid all of that, and you miss the point of having elected body oversight over such an entity. Like I said, I think a lot of the other questions have been asked, but what are the long-term annual and then long-term costs for contracting for property management and professional development agencies that are hired by the RIC. Sorry, could you repeat that question? What are the annual and long-term costs of contracting for property management by the RIC? So outside, you mentioned professional development agencies, other types of professionals. I see lawyers on here, but there's sort of just not really any numbers. So what are the annual costs for that? I'm sorry, I want to make sure I understand your question. What is the annual cost of the property management aspect of the ongoing operations of the RIC? Yeah, so in both the presentation, it says, I can't remember which page that was on. Well, you mentioned professional development agencies and property management. So do you know what the costs are of that on an annual basis? So I want to restate what's been stated before, which is that the operating budget that's been shared is developed as an initial model for expected possible costs and salaries. It isn't a commitment to anything in particular. All of those things would have to be determined by the market and identifying the right candidates. the initial upfront costs. If you're referring to the initial costs of the legal and professional costs in the first two years, that's associated with a recognition that it will take the RIC time to find and hire an ideal executive director, for example. And so some work may have to happen and is probably actually best to occur through a consultant model because it isn't necessarily full-time work at the very beginning. before the RIC has a number of properties in its portfolio. And so we've attempted to make a fiscally conservative and thoughtful approximation of how the RIC might reasonably stand up and impact its operations. I'm not totally sure I'm answering your question. Please re-channel me. If the question is about property management in particular, those fees would be, again, to a previous conversation with Alderman Lee, structured within the individual LLC for each property and come out of the net operating income of an individual property would cover those property management fees. Correct, you did mention that. And then at the same time, you mentioned if an entity were not able to fulfill those duties, the RIC would step in. so if an if a tenants organization or developer says hey we can't fulfill the property management aspect of it or the legal aspect of it so is the RIC required to step in and fill that role the RIC is functionally the owner and asset manager of the properties in its portfolio over the long term. The positioning of each individual asset into an independent legal entity is common best practice within the real estate sector for both liability management and financial management reasons. But just like any multi-building portfolio owner would do, the goal would be for each individual building in the portfolio to be financially independent and financially self-sufficient but in the event that it wasn't then the RIC would take whatever action it needed to to keep that building you know a well-functioning member of its larger portfolio so if that's interesting so basically you you we could end up holding the RIC could end up holding the bag for a failed entities management program or for their failed management I think that part of what the goal is and the way that we've set up the board and the way we've structured how this will move forward is that the underwriting standards and all of those things will be safeguards in order to ensure that this is a successful model and so yes in the event of something catastrophic happening the ric would step in much the way that any developer owner steps in when there is an issue within the building however it is um our anticipation that again with the expertise we will have on the board with the underwriting standards that will be set and with the success we've seen of this model across the country that these would also be successful buildings okay um thank you um chairman i'll hold the other questions for that's fine i'm done you're done thank you um alderman viegas stepped out for a moment alderman scott has indicated that she doesn't have any questions so alderman hadn't it falls on you and when alderman viegas comes back in he'll be next great thank you chair um i want to thank uh commissioner uh your team uh young and all of our guests um want to thank our community supporters who have worked for quite some time to bring this forward and thank my colleagues for all the really thoughtful questions um i think one of the great things about this model is the success that we've seen in other municipalities and I think that you know we hear the questions today Chicago is gonna have to make this uniquely our own right like this is Chicago we're gonna find a path forward I think what what I'd like to lift up in this is an opinion but I'll ask a question as well of the commissioner and your team. Outside of this, outside of the social housing model, right, what other models are you seeing cities in the United States use to address the affordable housing gap? I think the most prominent way we are still seeing affordable housing being built is the way that it has been built for more than 30 years, and that is through the low income housing tax credits. As I have alluded before, it is oversubscribed, not just in the city of Chicago, but across the country. So I think a lot of municipalities are starting to grapple with this question of what's the next thing. This is a model that, again, is innovative, but has been proven across the country. And I think more and more places are starting to look at it. We have some municipalities where they have an ordinance, but they don't have the money somewhere. They have the money, but they don't have the ordinance. And so I think overall, we're really fortunate to be in the position where we are right here, where there is the housing and economic development bond. And there is the opportunity to work with all of you on really developing this ordinance and setting up this new model. Thank you for that. And can you, in our context, so here in Chicago, can you also speak to the role of, let's say, the CHA, right? So when we think about our ecosystem of housing, housing providers, and especially in the ecosystem of public, kind of built, provided, or funded housing, how is the CHA kind of meeting that need or not? um not to speak over broadly since i do not have purview over uh the ch i will say that certainly in our conversations with them um part of their excitement has been again to be able to participate on the voucher level to make sure that we can subsidize down to the lowest amis and we've discussed any number of possibilities and um including um even and again complete speculation but you know they have a lot of land figuring out is there a way in which we could work with them on some of those pieces um and i think that in general i would say that the public housing is a really important part of the ecosystem um the same way that everything can't be affordable and everything can't be public and everything can't be market rate it means that we need all of these things to work together to have a healthy housing ecosystem across the city thank you for that and you know i i think one of the one of the reasons why you know this has been I think an innovative model that I think the city of Chicago should pursue is in the 49th ward, around the city, in the six years that I've been in this body, we get our quarterly reports from DOH. We get information. We see projects that come our way. And I hear consistently that we don't have enough tools to meet our affordable housing needs. I hear goals that we have in the city of increasing our population so that we can have more of a tax base to share our burdens and of course you know welcome a few new people to Chicago since I can't say it like the mayor says it but it's a pretty awesome place right so with those goals consistently we know we need to build new housing and we need to create more affordable and accessible housing to meet the demand and I see in this and and getting to work with my colleagues uh gil viegas and and andre vasquez is one of the reasons we put forth you know um our ordinance in january and i think we've had really great productive conversations with you guys and we're happy to come with i think a better version of this ordinance than either of us had initially introduced i'm hopeful that some of of these kind of questions from colleagues will help us to further refine but i don't see a world in which chicago is able to meet more of the demand for housing without doing this social housing program like are there is that's why i was kind of asking is there something else like is there something else that we could be doing other than this that would help us to meet the housing demand that you that you know of i think that there's any number of initiatives and programs that the city is putting forth but i think nothing quite to this scale and also we need all of it we need to do missing middle on the west and south sides to create new opportunities for home ownership the same way that we're doing rebuild where we're acquiring properties and rehabbing them and turning them over we also need this in order to continue to build at the scale that we need to build for repopulation and um should we embark upon this endeavor and it fail we can dissolve it right yes okay um and i just i'm just putting that out there for people because i know like we're um we're in a space where it's hard to get 50 people to agree upon a thing it's hard to get our communities to to agree upon as well and we're not gonna have everything perfect i appreciate the questions that i think are going to help us refine this a little bit more and i know that the chairpersons have said hey we're probably going to continue this conversation over the weekend a little bit and come back on monday and i think that is in um i think that's in a good decision in the spirit of of collaboration here but our constituents need us to take action and And there are a few opportunities we have to take action. I will be supporting this ordinance in its final version because the constituents in the 49th Ward tell me that we need to provide more affordable and accessible housing options. And I want to be able to say, well, I didn't just cut down an idea because it wasn't 100% what I thought it should be. We need to be able to take action and try things. And this is in the context, i urge my colleagues to think about um we're going to have more burden on us the city of chicago we're already experiencing it we're in a climate where the federal government is not very favorable to anything humane or sane and certainly chicago is not their favorite city and so when i think about innovative ways public-private partnerships ways that we can extend our resources in a smarter way, this is an excellent opportunity for us to demonstrate how that's going to work. And we can't wait too long. I don't think we can falter on this. We can refine. And I hope everyone who asks questions, I hope those are questions that are meant to get you to a yes. Because the residents of the city of Chicago are counting on us to provide them with housing and to provide them with better quality housing as we look at the kind of rehab and acquisition piece like we can start doing some of this work within a year right we can start doing some of this work this year we could start housing people this year and going beyond what we were previously able to do and as we look at threats to the Department of Housing and Urban Development and other funding sources that we and the state rely upon. If we don't do this or some version of this, I fear that we are going to fall even further behind and be in a worse position. So I hope colleagues, you know, in asking the questions that you are going to be part of this discussion on Monday, I hope that you guys in the department are able to really follow up with people because i i heard some very reasonable questions here um and i hope we can get people the answer so that we can move forward because the residents of the city of chicago we we owe this to them thank you uh thank you alderman hadden uh alderman robinson is requested to participate remotely under the provisions of rule 59 can i get a motion to allow Alderman Robinson so moved by Alderman Manah Hoppenworth all those in favor signify by saying aye opposed and the opinion of the chairs the ayes have it Alderman Robinson you are in the meeting Alderman Villegas followed by Alderman Cardona thank you madam chair and first I want to give really a thank you to Emily from the mayor's office Jung Yoon Chase Wheeler Lissette and Jim McDonald as well as we had some discussions around this this ordinance and some of the changes that were reflective in the ordinance that you really took into took into account and then I'm glad that my colleagues had some other ideas as well because I think that we all trying to figure out how to to solve this issue. And that's why Maria Haddon, Andre Vasquez and myself had introduced something around acquisition. And what really started the discussion is the amount of units that we're, the cost of the units we're paying for. And as I mentioned before, there was a property in Uptown, three bedroom, 900,000. I went on Zillow and found one for 510 and started doing some research around what are other municipalities doing? And so I know that we focused primarily on the new construction. And I know that the new construction could take anywhere between two to three years. And the cost is about $400,000 to $500,000. Can you talk a little bit more about the acquisition? Because I think, for me, that's the low-hanging fruit. Because we're talking about repurposing. And from a green sustainability component, reduce, reuse, and recycle are the three R's when we're talking about sustainability. and if we're taking a look at using existing infrastructure, getting it up quicker, getting heads in beds quicker at a cheaper cost, I want to make sure that we're not losing sight of the new shiny object and taking a look at making sure that we're getting people in beds cheaper and quicker. So can you talk a little bit more about the acquisition and what do you think, if you've modeled out, what that cost per unit would be? I will say that there's an architect I know that will tell you that the greenest building is the building you already have so completely agree with the idea that we need to really look at acquisitions and figure out what the best way is for us to move forward on those pieces I think much like we're looking at for the other pieces right we would be looking to maximize the unit count figure out what the best way is to bring in together a couple of buildings right if we're talking about that 75 unit maybe it's a 30 unit building maybe it's a 35 unit building that we combine and say like, okay, great. Like, you know, we're getting up to that 65, 70, 75 range. And we can then begin that process of figuring out what, you know, what will it take to acquire? What will it take to rehab? And then what will it take to completely sort of come into this model? And I will let the team, somebody jump in on acquisitions and just sort of the way we've been thinking about that a little bit more. Thank you. Yeah, I think there are a variety of ways that we could target acquisition and rehab through this program. As I mentioned earlier, one way is looking for properties that exist today in some sort of financial distress. So something, for example, a foreclosure or tax sale type situation where we can jump in and quickly act. Another would perhaps be a property with, you know, existing affordable units in it, maybe from an older project that was previously funded by us or Ida that is leaving its tax credit compliance period and could shift from one program to another. And then there's things that are available on the private market, which, of course, are going to ebb and flow with the state of the economy and the availability of capital for market rate owners. So there's a wide variety of ways that we could play in that space. I think we're interested in all of them. One of the particular benefits of hiring independent staff and having an independent board with these very expertises is that they'll be able to identify for us what tables we should be at and how. We're also aware that there are, you know, it's sometimes a different financial model. So we've been talking about the sort of five-year loan cycle for the case of new construction that then comes out at stabilization. that looks a little bit different for a property that already exists and sort of it takes a slightly different form. So we're looking at all of that. We're very interested. We agree with you that it's an important addition to the program and look forward to having a staff that is capable of tracking down the good opportunities for us to participate in. Thank you for that. Now, could you do you have any type of estimate? because we see that there's a four to five hundred four to five hundred fifty thousand per unit and you use use the number do you have any modeling on what existing what what an existing unit i'm sorry strike the existing building would look like per unit i don't believe we have any specific modeling i can look though um and provide back sort of just what it's looked like through our acquisitions program just generally you know we still do acquisitions through light tech it's also not also all new construction. And I think part of the answer of that is going to be that there's gonna be probably a pretty wide range. You know, there's some that are going to be up for sale because the owner can't keep it up anymore. And, you know, maybe it needs a new roof, it needs a new HVAC system. There are some that it could have gone into foreclosure because of completely other reasons and perhaps the building is in much better shape. So the one thing I will just say there is that there will be a much wider range of what it could be. But again, I think our hope would be to still average out at certainly no more than what we think the average would be for now, for new. If you wouldn't mind doing that exercise, because you did it for the new side between $400 to $550, and that's a pretty wide range. You could do it on the acquisition. I would argue that it's probably half the price. And the reason why I'm saying that is because 70-30 mixed income could potentially allow for a greater percentage of affordability above the 70-30, unless there's some type of legislation or some type of requirement that restricts it. But I'm pointing that out because it's cheaper. I know it's cheaper. So if you guys could pencil that out. Excuse me, Alderman Villegas, can I add something to that? 100%. Yes, ma'am. And if you model that out, Commissioner, if you would be able to go a step further and identify a unit goal, a goal for the number of units you might be able to achieve using this model for acquisition, like you've done with the new construction, that would be helpful since you aren't able to identify what percentage of the 135 million would be directed in that regard. Is that possible? We will do some modeling and we'll come back with some numbers of what the different options would look like. Thank you. Alderman Villegas? I appreciate that. And the ordinance that Andre, Maria, and myself had, a lot more governance. and I think what you heard from the body is more governance and I appreciate the fact that you did incorporate some of the things, adding the chair of finance as an ex-officio, adding labor, adding an attorney, coming back to the body, whether it was recirculated funding or grant funding, coming back to the body for approval. Those are the things that we're looking at. It's not because of any administration, it's just because we have a fiduciary responsibility and I think it's incumbent upon us to ask these questions to make sure that the residents and the citizens of Chicago are getting the biggest bang for their buck. Now, the question was posed about dissolving, and I saw Jim McDonald raffling through some papers. So Jim, my colleague from the 49th Ward asked, at any time, could this entity be dissolved? As I said earlier, it's going to be an independent legal entity. There will be five members who are ex-officio board members. the city doesn't have under this ordinance at this point a right to dissolve the non-profit per se it could the city could as i also said earlier the voting members who are not ex officio can be removed under this ordinance and that will have to be reflected in the bylaws can be removed for cause by the mayor. So if this nonprofit started behaving in a way that the mayor could say, I have the authority to remove the non-ex-officio members for cause, the mayor could remove them. The ex-officio members, if they become the voting majority, could vote to dissolve the corporation. so there are pathways to do that under what's currently drafted however the mayor or this body doesn't have the ability this body or the mayor does not have the ability to dissolve it would actually have to be the appoint the appointed members that would actually have to decide whether to to dissolve it or not is that accurate well and as i also tried to be clear earlier the rules are going to be governed by the bylaws. So if the bylaws provided that the city had a right to dissolve the corporation, that could be a point in the bylaws. But under this ordinance, as currently drafted, there isn't given this, and that corporation's power, just to reiterate another point, corporation's powers as described in this ordinance are going to be those provided by law and not inconsistent with this ordinance. So the corporation's powers are going to be constrained by what this ordinance tells them they can do. So there would be a pathway to dissolving it if they were acting in a way that was inconsistent with their authority, which is constrained by the limits of this ordinance. That sounds like gobbledygook. Can you speak straight about how is this entity, can it be dissolved and how? Chairwoman, I can answer this and I'll try to be clear here. So the mayor has the ability to remove the appointed members. then all that is left is the ex officio members including the chair of the committee on finance and the commissioners as listed they could then vote to dissolve the corporation the other pathway is to functionally never approve a project because again council does retain authority over the funds and so the body would not be able to act without council approval over those funds so you retain control i appreciate that that was clear um yeah because when when my colleague from the 49th answered that you both said yes and then i saw jim rifling through papers so i just wanted to make sure that we were all on the same page um uh so i appreciate that i do also want to um acknowledge and and thank you for putting in the uh the 10 for veterans uh it's it's something that this body took action last year, went into effect this year, and I appreciate my colleagues for voting on that, and then also you incorporating this into this ordinance as well. The Chicago Realtors had put forward a letter regarding some of the things that they'd like to see, not related to the green social housing so much, but just like getting construction done quicker. I know that there's an effort under this administration to cut the red tape, which every developer has applauded. But at some point, we'd like to see what the final product is going to look like. So that way, there's some predictability. Because the way that we're going to get affordable housing is to build more. And the way we're going to reduce rents is by a surplus of supplies. We've seen it happen in Austin. And so we've got to really signal to the developers and folks that want to do business here that we are open for business. But when the realtors are putting forward a bunch of suggestions and we're not listening to them, like we've got to listen to make sure that we can get construction going. This year in 2025, I think it's gonna be like three or four cranes in the sky. Three or four cranes in the sky. When I first started in 2015 and 2016, there were 50 cranes in the sky. And so you have to understand that developers can do business anywhere. And they've chosen to do business in Phoenix, Nashville, and other parts of the country. And so we want to see some cranes in the sky. We want to see that friendly environment to get development going, because that's how we're going to create affordable housing and reduce rents for the residents of the city of Chicago. So, again, I love this idea of social housing. I love the fact that you took into account the acquisition portion and sustainability development points as to make the acquisition jobs, acquisition projects pencil out. I know there was some discussion initially around retrofitting units, and that was just going to make the deal unaffordable. So I appreciate the sustainability development points because those are policies that we've put forward. I heard from the gentleman from planning and development around sustainability and how that definition continues to grow. Would love to see where it started and where it's at now to see what has been identified as sustainability. Because the one thing as a legislator that I don't like is when bureaucrats like to creep, where there's an intent and then it just keeps going outside of the legislative process. so love to see where we started and where we're at now to determine that we're on the same path and we're all in agreement as to what sustainability means because there are some things that that we could do better in order to to to take a look at sustainability acquisitions and number one like I said it's reuse reduce reuse and recycle and so I think there's an opportunity there so look forward to continue working with you. Again, I support this initiative. We've worked closely together, but I appreciate all my colleagues bringing up concerns that maybe I didn't see. But I appreciate and looking forward to getting a better project and not allowing perfect to be the enemy. We're going to try to get it as good as possible and then continue to take a look at it as it involves so thank you madam chair thank you alderman viegas we have two other colleagues that have questions alderman cardona and alderman vasquez thank you madam chair um most of my questions have um been answered by my colleagues so i'm not gonna ask again but um i don't know if anyone could um i want to go to the deck on page 10 uh for property taxes i was wondering if you give more explanation on that absolutely i will turn this over to our senior policy analyst edwin uh good afternoon alderman uh for the record edwin artis reyes senior policy analyst department of housing um do you have a specific question on property taxes or just generally how they apply to this could you explain the duck because you got three brackets and you know and i would like to get a perfect explanation about it then i'll i'll have my question for sure um so the affordable housing special assessment program is a program that's run through the cook county assessor's office it was authorized by uh state law a few years ago and it creates a property tax reduction uh based on the assessed value of the property depending on how many income restricted units there are on that property so there are three different levels to this program the first one being for properties that are 15 to 34 percent affordable the second one for properties that have at least 35 if not more of their units restricted as affordable and then the third one and probably the strongest one is for those units that have uh restricted as or restrict 20 of their units as affordable but that also requires further council action to designate that community as a low affordability community okay um who's going to communicate to the assessor's office about this affordable housing that we are doing so that is the responsibility of the developer once they build the development um and file those uh the the the units restrict those units as affordable housing with the Department of Housing. They can then provide that evidence to the assessor's office and submit an application for the ASAP program. So the developer is gonna fill out the affidavits every year and file with the assessor so they could get their affordable assessment. That is correct. They also have to have a regulatory agreement or restrictive covenant filed for those units with the Department of Housing. Okay. because there's always been, in the past, there's always been a lack of communication between developers that do have affordable housing components with the assessor. And it's one of those things that they don't communicate very well with the assessor and it drags out for one, two, three years. So hopefully the developer is on his game and he will be filing those affidavits every year. I have no further questions. I was just asking how the component will work with the property taxes, but thank you so much. I'm done. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Cardona. Alderman Vasquez. Thank you very much, Chairwoman and Chairman, for hosting this. I had a couple of questions, but first wanted to give credit where it's due. I think having the conversations with myself, Alderman Villegas, Alderman Manhattan, as well as other folks who had concerns, I think it led to better drafted legislation that addresses some of the concerns we have. I think similarly, pausing it right now and having the recess after we've heard all the different questions people have, I think leads to a better document. And so what I do like about I think everyone who is here is I don't believe any of our colleagues said they thought it was a bad idea. I think everyone was like I like the idea I like the concept but I have questions about the language and the specificity us being explicit about the intent so there's no ambiguity later because I think we want to make sure we get it as best as possible knowing we're not going to get perfect so I said thank you for that um so I've got a question I know we're looking at affordable and I'm glad this slide is up we have parts of town where market rate is effectively affordable right that they don't get to kind of build that one would want to see would it be possible or is it has there been any thought process related to using this potentially as an incentive where the market rate is already affordable and building where we know we've had a lot of vacant land that it could be an opportunity yes yes thank you alderman um while we have been socializing this ordinance and model with developers one of the specific pieces of feedback we got was a real excitement because they knew that there were markets where this would work but they were unable to get the financing necessary to make the deals pencil because when you need to go to an equity investor that is demanding 20 percent returns that dramatically increases the cost of development and so by being able to offer this as a financial tool we will be able to bring this to places where the there is not as much of a difference between affordable and market see that's amazing i think also the question where people asked about tiff for example it's good that it doesn't limit the ability to create a funding stack in those parts of town where you need every penny you can get to pencil it out and so i'm appreciative of that and don't want to create any legislation where, you know, if you're in a hot part of town where people want to build, you can access that, but we still don't solve for the places that are bereft of that kind of activity. So I'm appreciative of that. Another question I have is related to post build sustenance, right? You fill the gap for somebody looking to build, they build the property and then not that one would want, but let's say they're a junkie landlord because lord knows we have enough of those across town what levers are there in place for accountability there once it's already been built if like the tenants are articulating that there's a problem do we have anything explicitly written to address something like that yes and i want to clarify that the residential investment corporation is the landlord it is the majority owner and therefore controls the upkeep and property management contracts and the like And then in this ordinance, we've added extra language to ensure there is both a building level and a citywide resident voice that can voice concerns and elevate those to the property management, to the RIC and to the board ultimately, if there are issues that need resolved. Okay. Is there ever a scenario where that body might decide to sell the property? We have written in a clause and let me speak precisely here. June are you referring to the ordinance now? Yes. Okay. Yes, Chairwoman. Can you cite the, when you get to it? so in section k conditions to receipt of funds from the city sub bullet six there's a clause here that reads the corporation shall ensure that any development that received city funds is not sold without the consent of the authorized doh officer as defined below who is authorized to enter into any agreements or record any covenants they deem prudent to protect the tenancy of current renters and maximize long-term affiliation affordability and the reason we added this clause is as a safeguard both to the corporation and to the tenants because there is while a very low risk always a risk of financial insolvency and so you need essentially an option but what we don't want is that option to harm the tenants there and so we want to ensure that those tenants are not displaced and that long-term affordability is protected through a covenant. Sure. I think, I think it's a good balance to think through in this scenario because even with the private market, we have concerns about what happens when somebody sells a property. And may I just build on that? One of the issues on financial insolvency in the private market is again, that high cost of debt and the total debt service ratio and the ability to repay those debt services. So by again, bringing down the total cost of development and potentially accessing lower cost debt options that risk is um you know shrieks as well yeah i i think because in the uh i'm being sarcastic the infinite wisdom of the resident of the white house and the tariffs it's going to make it that much more difficult for anybody to make things pencil out right as the cost of build goes up the cost the supplies go up that everything possible that we have at our disposal to allow that kind of growth to happen is kind of the mind space we need to be at so i think this is a good tool i think to to alderman viex's point about the letter from the realtors city-wide adu which i think a number of us have been talking about makes sense for those of the of us who have concerns you're going to stop growth uh i think looking at the vacant buildings and acquisition kind of the way we've been discussing uh proactively up zoning areas like we've done on the north side on western and finding places. And then I think to his point about the cut the tape, really getting assessment from those who are most impacted as to whether it's working or not is something we'd all like to learn. So again, thank you for all these pieces and for working with us. I think what I would ask of our colleagues, those who may or may not be here even on email, is for all the things that they brought up as concerns and objectives, if possible, to email those to the administration so that way you can work through that list and make sure that whatever gets drafted addresses the concerns because i i get that there's a pathway for the group to dissolve but that's making the assumption that the uh you know um the folks that have been appointed are gonna listen for lack of a better term and so i think there might be ambiguity there as we've seen sometimes there's a bit of independence out of the folks that run organizations agencies cps for example, that to account for the levers of what we might need for checks and balances is a fair question. So thank you for all of this. And I will wrap up so people can head home. Thank you. Well, you don't close the meeting. I just made my part. My bad. I just wanted to, I have one question and this might have been asked, but I just want a two year old answer. If a project has a delay in construction or the occupancy doesn't happen on time or they just run out of money, what happens? Thank you, Alderwoman. So there are a series of different tools at our disposal in a case of financial insolvency. The first is prevention through rigorous underwriting standards. The RIC will have underwriting standards. The co-developer will have underwriting standards, as well as the lender. And what those standards take into account are for those downside scenarios. those, maybe it takes a few extra months to lease up, what is the pro forma able to withstand. So again, we'll have three different independent bodies evaluating that before any deal goes before the board, much less before council to ensure that we can figure out the issues in that case. Okay, but what happens if something happens? In any in any deal and this is true this will be true for these deals and it'll be true for the affordable deals right there is something that you've already worked out as part of this and so likely like if you're not hitting occupancy standards which again we don't necessarily foresee giving both the market in the city and just what we know is the necessity for affordable housing but if you don't hit those standards then it'll be written into the way that it is underwritten what happens with each of the deals. I guess my question is, do you ever foresee an occasion when the asset would become an asset of the city directly? No, and this is a legal question, but no, because that is what the purpose is of the RIC. Well, I just wanted to say that I think this has been a really robust conversation this afternoon. um chairman cicho lopez and i have uh written down all of the uh concerns and comments and suggestions that people have and we'll be sharing that we'll be talking about it first and then we'll share that with the administration and uh it's been fun co-chairing with you Thank you, Chairwoman, and thank you, Commissioner. Thank you to all the experts on the box and Zoom. Thank you to all the council members that are here finding solutions to a dire and urgent issue like housing. I think that is something that we deal in all our communities in every single ward, and we need to provide solutions. This is not a civil wallet. there's a lot of housing options and housing initiatives that need to be put forward this is just one of them i just want to remind you on in may we'll have chay back in committee to convenio the oversight in the chay um we take the the comments on the cut the red tape and the many other initiatives that we need to continue to work on with the department of housing and many other departments. And again, the need to provide solutions also come from the feedback of the City Council members. So I appreciate Chewbun Mandow, your spirit of collaboration and attention to detail. So we have a lot of notes to compare, but I do think that we do have a sense of urgency and I think that we can come together. So without more to say, I would like to, for the Joint Committee on Housing, Real Estate and Committee on Finance, we'll recess until Monday, april 14th 2025 at 12 30 p.m here in the same um chambers uh city hall room 121 north la south street second floor and we'll be in recess until then thank you very much for coming and looking forward to see you then