Joint Committee: Pedestrian & Traffic Safety; Transportation & Public Way meeting, October 3, 2025
- When: Fri, Oct 3, 2025, 1:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Transcript: full text (14,558 words, automatic captions)
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The joint Committees on Pedestrian and Traffic Safety and Transportation and Public Way considered one item: an ordinance directing the Commissioner of Transportation to implement a Plow the Sidewalks pilot program and extending the program working group's end date to December 31, 2026. Seven public commenters spoke, six in support and one in opposition, and officials from CDOT, Streets and Sanitation and the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities presented a narrowed pilot covering two zones with a $500,000 budget allocation and about seven deployments. Committee members asked about costs, staffing, equipment, scalability, existing ward-level snow programs, and the city's potential legal liability, including an extended exchange with the Department of Law. Several members said they could not support the pilot given the city's budget deficit, while others expressed support for improving winter sidewalk accessibility. On a roll call vote, the chair announced that the motion failed.
Topics: Plow the Sidewalks pilot, sidewalk snow removal, disability access, city liability, budget deficit, Toronto comparison, ward snow programs, snow shoveling fines, remote participation
Agenda items discussed
- 28:25 Motions for remote participation under Rule 59: passed
- 30:10 Public comment: discussed
- 47:43 Amendment of Municipal Code Titles 2 and 10 to direct the Commissioner of Transportation to implement Plow the Sidewalks pilot program and extend end date of program working group to December 31, 2026 (O2025-0015574): failed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Daniel La Spata (chair): Said the sidewalk is the one part of the public way everyone uses and the one part the city does not clear, which drives the case for the pilot. (49:50); Described the history of the working group established in 2023, its report, the budget allocation, and the authorizing ordinance introduced in February. (52:16); Said the pilot is intended to evaluate feasibility of municipal sidewalk clearing on a small scale and does not propose citywide service. (53:20)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (chair): Asked the Department of Law why the city has not committed to clearing sidewalks now. (1:24:59); Asked whether responsibility for maintaining sidewalks and parkways is currently shared between the city and property owners. (1:25:51); Asked what type of liability the city would open itself to if it took responsibility for clearing sidewalks. (1:26:57)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Asked what happens if there are more than seven snow events and how residents would be informed when pilot funds run out. (1:06:58); Sought to confirm for the record that the city does not currently plow sidewalks other than city-owned property. (1:08:06); Asked how the time estimate accounted for needing two passes per block when houses are on both sides of the street. (1:09:22)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Raised concern about setting expectations under a pilot and then needing money the city does not have. (1:10:59); Said the city should improve existing services such as alleys and vacant lots before taking on sidewalk plowing. (1:11:28); Suggested expanding community groups through grants and considering property tax credits or fee reductions for residents who help neighbors. (1:12:52)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Drawing on experience in city services, said he runs a ward program for over 300 seniors but doubts sidewalk clearing is achievable at scale. (1:16:20); Raised concerns about uneven or gravel-covered sidewalks and ADA compliance. (1:18:50); Said he wants it to succeed but does not want to waste $500,000 amid a budget deficit and asked to see the plan. (1:19:02)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked how the $261,000 estimate for seven deployments was calculated relative to the per-deployment figures and equipment costs. (1:37:20); Asked whether the city has enough equipment for the pilot and whether it would need to buy more if the program went citywide. (1:38:55); Said the purpose of a pilot is to test whether to do a larger version, so the potential citywide cost is worth discussing. (1:41:17)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Said the pilot is meant to test scalability and would be a large unfunded mandate given a projected deficit over $1.2 billion. (1:43:14); Described her ward's Neighbors Helping Neighbors mutual aid snow program and suggested partnering with community groups. (1:43:55); Suggested identifying habitual non-shovelers and possibly increasing fines. (1:44:13)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked whether the working group considered increasing fines for failure to shovel. (1:51:51); Requested ticket totals citywide and by ward, broken down by commercial and residential. (1:52:12); Said Toronto's program began in 2022 and its departments were directed to reassess it due to liability risks and costs. (1:52:42)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked what machines would be used in the pilot. (1:54:31); Said the departments risk failure if equipment and routing are not lined up in advance and hand shoveling alone is insufficient. (1:56:06); Asked whether salt would be used and confirmed the estimate of about $50,000 per deployment. (1:56:33)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Said residents in her ward who rely on transit have raised the issue and she sees wheelchair users on streets in winter. (1:58:52); Asked each department whether the pilot is doable with current funding, staff and equipment. (1:59:46); Said the city too often prioritizes cars over people in public spaces and should do better for people walking or rolling in winter. (2:04:41)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Said understanding potential citywide costs is important given multi-year budget challenges. (2:06:04); Described his ward's volunteer snow program and asked whether funding could go to alders to buy their own sidewalk plows. (2:06:47); Raised concerns about constituent expectations outside pilot zones and the liability issues raised by Chairman Gregory I. Mitchell. (2:07:57)
Exchanges between members
- 1:10:22 Alderperson David H. Moore commended the chairs for their work on the proposal.
- 1:10:59 Alderperson David H. Moore thanked Chairman Michelle A. Harris for her question about funds running out.
- 1:15:41 Chairman Daniel La Spata asked Alderperson David H. Moore whether he had a question for the departments.
- 1:34:51 Chairman Daniel La Spata responded to Chairman Gregory I. Mitchell liability questions by noting broader sidewalk condition liability.
- 1:41:13 Chairman Daniel La Spata told Alderperson William Conway no one is contemplating taking the program citywide.
- 1:41:17 Alderperson William Conway replied that a pilot exists to test a larger version, so citywide cost is worth discussing.
- 1:42:17 Alderperson William Conway said his remaining questions were answered by Chairman Gregory I. Mitchell questioning of the law department.
- 1:43:14 Alderperson Samantha Nugent said Alderperson William Conway was right that a pilot tests scalability.
- 1:47:37 Chairman Daniel La Spata responded to Alderperson Samantha Nugent by noting alders' expense accounts and that no budget ask is being made.
- 1:48:19 Alderperson Samantha Nugent replied that ward funds are stretched and she is scrutinizing all proposals.
- 1:49:09 Chairman Daniel La Spata told Alderperson Samantha Nugent she was right and described the pilot as a way to ask the feasibility question.
- 2:05:41 Alderperson Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked both chairs for holding the hearing.
- 2:08:10 Alderperson Andre Vasquez Jr. said the liability concern raised by Chairman Gregory I. Mitchell was a concern for him as well.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error