Good afternoon, everybody. The Joint Committee meeting of the Committee on Pedestrian and Traffic Safety and the Committee on Transportation and Public Way is now called to order for October 3, 2025. We will now have a roll call to establish quorum. Chairman Mitchell, present. Chairman Laspata, present. Vice Chair Vasquez, Vice Chair Cruz, Alderman Hopkins, Alderman Robinson, Alderman Yancey Alderman Harris Alderman Chico Alderman Quinn Alderman Gutierrez Alderman Moore Alderman Curtis Alderman Mosley Alderman Rodriguez. Alderman Persson Fuentes. Alderman Moore is present online. Alderman Burnett. Alderman Irvin. Alderman Wagesback. Alderman Nugent. Alderman Knutson. Alderman Lawson. Alderman Martin. Alderman Monah Hoppenworth, Alderman Conway. Do we have any non-members? Okay. There are 14 members present. We do have a quorum. All right. Committee members Chico, Moore, Vasquez, Knutson, Lawson, Quinn, Puentes, Mosley, Martin have requested to participate in the meeting remotely pursuant to Rule 59. Alderman Chico, are you present? Present, Chair. Alderman Moore? I know he is, yeah. Alderman Vasquez? Alderman Moore is present, I'm sorry. Alderman Vasquez? Alderman Knutson? Alderman Lawson? present ottoman martin ottoman quinn here ottoman no i said present who said present it was lawson ottoman fuentes ottoman mosley Can I have a motion to allow Aldous Chico, Moore, Vasquez, Quinn, Fuentes, Moseley, Canuteson, Lawson, Martin to participate remotely? Alderman Irvin, so moves. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed nay. Everyone did not answer. So I think the only ones that would be allowed to be remote would be those that answered. Thank you. Right. Okay. All right. So we're striking Martin. Martin Influences. Vasquez didn't answer. And Moses. We're striking Vasquez. They could still come later. Right. So I got that. We got that noted. Alright. Aldous Chico Amozzi, Vasquez, Knudson, Lawson, our president. You guys made me miss my place. Aldous Chico Moore, so Aldous Chico, Aldous Chico Moore, Lawson, our president here today by video conferencing will be counted according for the roll call. At this time, Chairman, this is Alderman Martin. Apologies, I am present virtually. Okay. Adding Alderman Martin via rule online via rule 59. Okay. At this time, we'll begin the public comment period. Out of respect for everybody's time, public comment would be limited to 30 minutes, and each speaker is limited to three minutes. speakers in accordance with rule 58 the city council rules of order please refrain from profane language obscene conduct or disruptive comments to begin we have two virtual speakers the first speaker is katie schreiner hi did that oh am i unmuted can you hear me Ms. Schreiner? Hi, yeah, can you hear me? Yes. Okay, fantastic. Hello, my name is Kate Schreiner. I am a resident of the 39th Ward in Chicago, and I was wanting to speak to you committee members today on the Plow the Sidewalks ordinance. I would urge you to pass it. I think it is a very important opportunity for our city to show how wonderful and how friendly we are, making our city accessible for all residents and tourists. I know the city does a fantastic job of plowing the downtown neighborhood, but out in the northwest side and most likely other neighborhoods, it's not something that's been done in the past. And I think that it's an opportunity for us to make sure that the city is accessible to everyone. A couple of other things I'd like to mention is that fines don't shovel sidewalks, even if the city shows up and follows up with a complaint to clear the sidewalk later. Nothing's done in the meantime. People can't use the sidewalk safely when they need to. Some people can't shovel because they are elderly or disabled, don't have networks. They can't afford to pay people to shovel for them. They don't have a shovel if they live in an apartment or other reasons. and then maybe those people might be less likely to be able to cover the fines. Additionally, I think that it's important. So personally, I'm a mother with two small children, so I use a stroller. I carry my children. It's icy. We could fall. You know, not everybody gets out in time to shovel the sidewalk before they have to go to work. My mother is older. My brother's in a wheelchair. It makes it hard to get around when the sidewalks aren't cleared. So I think that in order to make Chicago a great city for everyone, the committee should consider passing the ordinance to plow the sidewalks. And I would really appreciate that. I don't envy the job you all have with having to go through all of these complaints and ideas. And I sincerely appreciate your consideration for this. And thank you for everything that you do to make Chicago what it is and to support the residents that you serve. And that is it. I end my talking points. I think that's what I don't know. I'm done. Thank you, Ms. Schreiner. Our next speaker is John Jones. All right. There being no more speakers, this concludes the public comment period. That's the online poll. I apologize. All right. The first one is Ada Zedden. Okay. Hello. Hello, my name is Atta Zahidi and I'm a member of the 46th Ward and a proud Chicagoan. I'm here to say today that the city needs to commit to plowing the sidewalks. I am tired of disabled people having to yell, plead, and consistently show up what should basically be a formality at this moment. We every year for the last couple of years, people with disabilities have been arguing for the case that we should not be excluded every winter at the first sign of snowfall. We are a consistent part of the community and we should be allowed to show up as we are when we want to. So Plata Sidewalks is a program that would benefit everyone, not just me, throughout the city, because everyone uses the sidewalks. No matter what mode of transportation you use, you always have to end up using the sidewalks. Whether it's someone who is a wheelchair user like me, or a parent with a stroller, or even just a tourist, it is the public space to be. You need it to go everywhere. I routinely cannot leave my home every winter so far that I lived here because of uncleared sidewalks that fines have not taken care of. Everyone should be given the opportunity to succeed and build the life that they want. It should not be seasonal dependent. And as a world-class city, it should not be seasonal dependent. It's pretty common sense there, I believe. Advocates are asking for the city to fully understand its responsibility in building an accessible city for all. I am tired of being told I have to rely on charity or volunteers when we should recognize that genuine community care is proactive and not reactive. We should clear the sidewalks like we do the streets every winter. We are a modern city of high caliber, and with that comes upholding our responsibilities with optimism for a better future for everyone. Anyone who does not want to be a part of that should move out of the way so that we can build a better future together. I generally believe that we can build systems that include everyone and enable them to build the life that they want. And I hope that the city council can recognize that this is a serious responsibility that should have been taken care of years ago. thank you I yield the rest of my time thank you our next speaker is Michael Michael Padres hello my name is Michael Padres I am a resident of the 48th Ward and I grew up in the 39th Ward um I'm a member of the board at Better Street Chicago the Plow the Sidewalks campaign calls the city to do something really simple which is adopt a sidewalk snow plowing program during the winter months and following heavy snowfalls. Doing this will make Chicago a more accessible city and improve mobility for all residents and at times when the city is accessible, least accessible and residents are the least mobile. Especially at times when people are also getting antsy to get out of the house. After working on this campaign for years, I can tell you all confidently that residents are excited by and supportive of plowing sidewalks. I have spoken with hundreds of Chicagoans directly who support plowing the sidewalks, and I've heard from thousands more who also support this. All of them see the value of plowing sidewalks and more often than not have an explicit reason for supporting it, often from personal experience. People told me about the challenges they faced ambulating during the winter, especially on snow and ice, following leg injuries, walking their kids to school, difficulty getting on buses, and concerns about parents getting injured shoveling sidewalks as they get older. The last one is a concern that I also personally share. It's also worth noting that according to AARP, that one of the top causes of heart attacks and injuries for seniors is shoveling sidewalks as they try to do their civic duty because our city fails to proactively make sure that critical services are provided. The city has spent significant resources researching sidewalk snow plowing and all the evidence available, which is extensive and much of which I led, points to this being viable operationally and financially. And we have gotten this support and this confirmation from many of the department heads that we have worked with. We have designed a pilot that is ready to go and simply needs the authorization from this body to proceed so that the Chicago Departments of Transportation and Streets and Sanitation can go ahead and start doing important and critical work for the residents of Chicago, work that residents appreciate and work that residents support. We have to stop litigating this and proceed. So please vote for Plow the Sidewalks. Vote yes on it. It is popular. It is viable. It is important. Thank you. Next speaker is George Blakemore. I'm totally against this ordinance. for the various reasons. You can't even keep the streets clean. Streets and sanitation. You can't even keep the streets clean, less known the sidewalk. Who's going to pay? Where are you going to get the money to include the sidewalks when this budget is messed up? How are you going to do this? The games are being played here. Why were you late? Why were you 25 minutes late? Why would you let these altars come here and COVID-19 is over? They should be here. Their presence is needed here. Why would you let them go virtual? Because you're corrupt. You're one-pointed government here. Like past is Germany, or communist China, or Russia. No checks and balance here. You're all Democrats here. A one-party system. No check and balance at all. At all. No rules, no regulations. It's something evil here. It's something un-American here. How will you finance this program? Will you use your tip money? Will you use SSAs, special service? Do you have more money to employ people to clean these sidewalks? No, you don't. You're bankrupt. You can't even pay your police pension. You're in debt. Why would you do this? Why would you make a promise that you know you cannot keep? Who does this? And where are the people? Where are the people here? Something is evil here. Something is corrupt here. And you are at fault here. I'm not going to blame it on you, the ultimate. But the citizens of this so-called global city, you are responsible. When this next election comes, it's not going to flip red. It's not going to go red. It's going to be all Democrats. It's a culture of corruption here, evil here. corruption, fraud, and abuse here. Where are you going to get the money? Where will you get the money to do that when you can't even keep the streets clean in the winter, the snow? And now you're going to add an additional fee and you're in debt. Even with this power program, how much is it going to cost the people? Where are you going to get the money? Mr. Blakemore spoke here. You're evil here. You started late here. You continue to do it here because the people let you do that. Don't come behind me. It's my getaway. Thank you. Next speaker is Laura Saltzman. My name is Laura Saltzman. I am the transportation policy analyst. For Access Living, you have heard from me before. In February, most recently, you have heard from members of our community and countless advocates express support for a Plow the Sidewalks pilot that several city commissioners helped design and which already has many allocated in the budget. I am here to ask you to allow this to move forward so the city can treat a small part of the city's sidewalks the way it treats streets and bike lanes. Let's just see if it works. because pedestrians on the way to transit, their car, or local business deserve to be able to safely use the sidewalk. Wheelchair users should not have to roll down the street to make it down the block or to the bus. I understand that for some of you, icy and snow-covered streets and crosswalks are not a big deal, at least until you slip and get a concussion or need to use a stroller or develop a disability yourself. But for many people with mobility disabilities, it means not being able to get to your job or to the grocery store. calling to file a complaint does nothing to fix an obstructed sidewalk or curb ramp in that moment and often nothing for future clearance the pilot should get a real chance this funded it has been designed because traveling the city in cold weather after snowstorm is something disabled pedestrians deserve to be able to do thank you thank you our next speaker is Paul Jacobs My name is Paul Jacobs, and I'm here to support the recommendation of this committee to implement the Plow the Sidewalks pilot. I'm one of the many people in this city who uses buses and cars to get around and rely on walking to and from stops. Due to the patchwork nature of our current system, there are frequently unplowed sections of sidewalk. While this is not a problem for everyone, many of our friends, family, and co-workers are unable to navigate these unplowed sidewalks and are forced into security, circuitous paths, or even trapped in their own homes. Unplowed sidewalks are a danger to everyone, from kids going to school to senior citizens going to the doctor. The existing system is simply not sufficient nor fair, putting an extra burden on those who are least physically able to do the work of clearing the sidewalks themselves. like everyone else these people deserve the right and dignity to independently navigate our city and thus i ask all of you to approve this program to plow our sidewalks thank you thank you uh next speaker is candace coleman Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Candace Coleman, and normally I'm up here as a disability advocate or organizer, but I'm here today as a citizen to ask for your support and plot a sidewalk I held from the south side of Chicago. And let's think about this for a minute. In your lifespan, at some point, you can or will become a person with a disability. And oftentimes, access isn't just for the disabled person. Yes, it's for us, but it creates access for everyone. And so I want to implore you to support Plow the Sidewalks because, one, everyone needs access to where they're going on the sidewalk, on the street, or anywhere. And oftentimes, we talk about all the issues that we care about that includes survivors of gun violence, that includes our senior citizens, that includes our family members who have disabilities, and includes you yourself. And so I just want to make sure that when we're thinking about this issue, it's just not a dollar thing, but it's an access thing. And it's access for not only me, but for you all as well. And so please consider supporting Plow the Sidewalks because we need it. We need to be able to get to transportation. we need to be able to get to the grocery stores, to our jobs, to our families, and to our homes. And so create access not only for me, but for everybody. Thank you. Well, this concludes the public comment period. The committee also received three written comments that were emailed to committee members. before I pass the committee over to Chairman Laspata I want to recognize committee members Vice Chairman Cruz and Alderman Knutson for purposes of quorum Thank you Chairman Mitchell we are moving on to items before the committee today we have one item on the agenda O-2025-0015574, Amendment of Municipal Codes Title II and X to direct the Commissioner of Transportation to implement Plow the Sidewalks pilot program and to extend end date of the program working group to December 31st, 2026. We will begin with a presentation on the Plow the Sidewalks pilot project. Due to capacity constraints ahead of the upcoming budget season, the Office of Budget Management is not able to join us in person today, but they have preemptively answered some questions we thought may come up, and those answers have been distributed in person today and via email. Here to speak, we have today Commissioner Cole Stallard from the Department of Streets and Sanitation. First, Deputy Commissioner Luis Cepeda from the Department of Streets and Sanitation. Acting Commissioner Craig Turner from the Chicago Department of Transportation. Managing Deputy Commissioner Sam Alexander from the Chicago Department of Transportation. Deputy Commissioner Sean Wydell from the Chicago Department of Transportation. Commissioner Rachel Arfa of the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. And Senior Policy Analyst Esther Gutierrez from the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. Committee members, we would ask you to reserve all your questions until after all speakers have gotten through their testimony. I will be leading off the slides and then passing them on. Thank you so much. There we go. So beginning with our presentation on the Plow the Sidewalks pilot program, you're going to hear from the folks in the box, the what, when, where, and why, and how of all of this, I want to speak to the why. So first I want to thank Audemann Gilviegas for his leadership and collaboration on this. The reason the working group on this was even established was through his efforts and his leadership and collaboration with many in advocacy spaces who do want to see greater accessibility for our neighbors during the winter season. The reason that this matters is driven by both universal use and equity. So lots of us drive, lots of us ride bikes, lots of people take public transit. The sidewalk is the one aspect of the public way that everyone uses. At some point, everyone will be walking down the sidewalk, particularly during the winter. It is also the one aspect of the public way that we don't clear as a municipal body. So we clear the streets, we clear the bike lanes, we are very diligent in that. The one aspect that we don't clear is the sidewalks. And we do have responsibilities for that as Chicagoans. Traditionally, although the city is responsible for the maintenance of the sidewalk as the public way, we have put it on our residents to do clearance of the snow from those sidewalks. The challenge is twofold here, which is that one neighbor either being unable or unwilling to clear the snow on their block in front of their house creates accessibility issues for everyone. If you have ever been disabled, if anyone you know has ever been pregnant or pushing a stroller or in a wheelchair, you know what it is to run into that one frontage mid-block that is not cleared. Responsibility remains, but again, as these pilot areas, as we've discussed, are specifically designed to reflect high percentages of residents who are seniors or disabled or have young children. It is that same population of Chicagoans who do have the greatest physical struggles to clear the snow in front of their walks, which again is part of what drives this program. For the background, this was initially passed in sponsorship by Alderman Villegas back in July of 2023 to establish the working group for Plow the Sidewalks. That body met over the course of the next 10 months and then released a working group releasing a report of recommendations. This is admittedly parred down from that report of recommendations, and we'll touch on that. That's also been in the package that folks received. There was an allocation in the budget for the Plow the Sidewalks pilot with the caveat that there would be an enabling ordinance to allow that funding and the pilot to proceed. The authorizing ordinance around that was introduced back in February of this year and was re-referred to the joint committee that we are in now. At this point, we'll talk briefly on the pilot goals and then I'll hand it on to those in the box. But again, it is to evaluate the feasibility, effectiveness and potential impact of municipal sidewalk clearing on a small scale. On a small scale. I know that there's concerns about how does this go citywide? Why if it goes citywide? That is in no way what is being proposed by this ordinance or in this room. And it's also to obtain insights for the city as it relates to the testing of various methods, risks, identifying potential challenges and refining those strategies. Is there another remote in the box or shall I pass this one on? All right. Thank you, everyone. I'm, thank you. Thank you. I'm Sean Wydell, Deputy Commissioner for Citywide Services at the Chicago Department of Transportation. I'm going to talk a little bit today about the pilot zones that are proposed that were in the report and then the narrowed scope that we're proposing to complete this year as part of the pilot. And then talk a little bit about the budget. Apologies. So the original recommendation in the in the original report was to focus on four pilot zones, about one and a half square miles per zone. And the maps were developed by some of the folks who are in the audience today, including Access Living, Better Street Chicago, Active Transportation Alliance, Palenque LSNA, Southwest Collective and other partners, AARP Illinois as well. The focus of that original ordinance and of the priority for developing the zones was to look at a number of different demographics around neighborhoods and communities across Chicago, including communities that had a large number of individuals over 65, large number of children under five, zero-car households, historic disinvestment, and then communities with a lot of folks with decreased mobility, including mobility aids, visual impairments, and other disabilities. With the budget that was approved, as Alder Laspata, the chairman mentioned, there's a $500,000 available in the budget this year. Snow removal in four zones will not be feasible. And because of that, we have collectively recommending we narrow that down to the south and the southwest zones from the report and that would the work this year would include up to seven deployments in those two zones and frankly those two zones were chosen for operational reasons because of their their proximity to c dot facilities and also to streets and sand facilities as well because the goal and the approach this year will be to manage these in-house as opposed to contract out the services. So the south side zone runs from roughly 59th Street to 67th, with State Street on the east and Racine on the west. And the southwest side zone runs from 43rd and Archer, roughly to 59th Street, and then between California and Lawndale. As I mentioned, there's a budget of $500,000 allocated for this under Finance General for Accessibility Programming. And our estimated cost based on the budget, which I'll go into in a little bit more detail, is about $50,000 per deployment. And as you can imagine, those estimate, those costs are dependent on the snowfall amounts, the timing. Is it a weekend? Is it an evening? Is it overtime for the folks who are going to be working on it? So there's a wide variety of variation in those estimates, but we came up with what we felt was the best estimate for this work with labor costs and equipment costs. This pilot will allow us to further refine those estimates and actual costs after implementation. So you can see the rough, the goal, as I mentioned, is approximately seven deployments, about four deployments, and the zones have not fully been decided, but four deployments for one zone, approximately three deployments for another zone, and that's about $261,000. And then that rough breakdown on a per zone basis is about $48,000 for that work. And that includes, you can see, the laborers, the motor truck drivers, the hoisting engineers, overtime, an estimate for overtime, as I mentioned, if it's an evening or a weekend, and then some equipment, some shovels, skid steers, and other safety equipment. And as I mentioned also, we are looking at this, we think about 40 employees to accomplish this work between our two departments, working eight-hour shifts, and again, time and a half pay for overtime. The tool quantities would remain the same, but because of the relatively modest scale of the proposed pilot this year, workman's comp and liability insurance will be covered by the departments as opposed to part of the operational cost. And with that, I will turn it over to Commissioner Stallard from Streets and Sanitation. Thank you. I can do it for you. You can handle that. Yeah, I got it. Cole Stallard, Commissioner of Department of Streets and Sanitation. As you can see, we're going to work with our labor partners for this pilot. We're going to work with our motor truck drivers, our Teamsters, our 1001, 1092 laborers from Streets and San and CDOT. And we'll be assigning people, managers, to assess and value and get a good idea of what this takes. We have done this. The Department of CDOT has shoveled snow. But we just wanted to get the particulars of what we had facing us. we're going to be using existing equipment so there would be no cost on that end in regards to us purchasing equipment we're going to cobble it together with the equipment that cdot has we're looking at the park district we have shovels again we're we're looking to see what equipment works best to determine possible options to do this in the most efficient manner uh clearance and enforcement all the sidewalks will be done in that area um we will not be enforcing in those areas i want to stress that it's in those areas we will not be enforcing we don't want to cause confusion when we go into these areas and these different wards in these different neighborhoods so we want to stay consistent with that we'll ensure that the the snow is removed in a way that doesn't obstruct pedestrian or vehicle traffic or access to emergency access points or other public infrastructure. In regards to our deployment it'll be two inches or more for this pilot program. CDOT and Streets and Sand we're going to work together on this. CDOT's the the face of it but but we understand at Streets and Sand that people are used to seeing us when it comes to snow. So we're going to work collaboratively like we do with aviation, like we do with the park districts, like we do with the schools through this process. It's kind of a team effort to the state, to the county. You know, we're all talking when it comes to snow. If the two inches is met, we will activate that program. We'll be notifying the alders to let them know that in this zone that the pilot program's been activated, and we'll ask people to opt in for those alerts. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm Rachel Dover, Commissioner of the Mayhouse Office for People with Disabilities. So as we develop this, we want to make sure that we understand how the program is doing with the impact on everyone, including residents with disabilities. So we have a number of evaluation metrics that we could use, including communicating with residents, getting feedback on how we measure and how we score the impact on being able to navigate the neighborhood or the broader community if we have research partners that we have with issues that we can build this out further once we know the final scope of services. I'm so with that, next slide, these questions. So I thank you so much all. Before we go to questions, we have one more testimony from a advocacy member of the working group, which is Ms. Alex Nelson from Better Street, Chicago, to speak with advocacy's engagement with Plow the Sidewalks Working Group. Alex, thank you for being with us thank you so much thank you for uh having me here today chairman my name is alex nelson i use she her pronouns and i'm an organizer with better street chicago um i just want to take us a little back to provide a little bit of context about the origins of this campaign in 2021 some fine young gentlemen went out and decided they wanted to shovel the bus stops in their neighborhood to try and improve accessibility for their neighbors and what they very quickly realized is that even with two able-bodied 30-something gentlemen, it was just not a feasible, sustainable way to maintain accessibility for the city at scale. And that's when a campaign was born. And it grew from there. In 2022, the campaign was renamed Plow the Sidewalks to reflect the growing coalition and the number of advocacy partners that had been brought on board, as well as to reflect the summary of the campaign ask. And then we move forward. In 2023, City Council passed an ordinance to design a pilot program, which created the working group. I was fortunate enough to be a member alongside the Departments of Streets and Sanitation, Department of Transportation, IGA, and other external advocacy partners. And then we presented that pilot program, or we're presenting that pilot program now, but in 2024, we were able to secure the $500,000 line item in the budget, which means here today, 2025, we are ready to go. Who this campaign is for? It's for everybody. Everybody benefits from cleared sidewalks. They are our most universal accessible infrastructure. This includes disabled and elderly folks who are dependent on mobility aids, parents with strollers and young children, essential workers, first responders, and more. It's worth noting that people who are dependent on their vehicles for a livelihood are also supporters of this campaign. The Rideshare Drivers Guild are endorsers and we are happy to have them alongside us. We have called for the city to plow the sidewalks because the current system, which has been in place that predates the invention of the light bulb, actually depends on the generosity and benevolence of individual actors. And even well-meaning homeowners get sick or out of town. And that ignores recurrent problem areas like vacant lots, bridges, overpasses, bus stops, pedestrian islands, and more. These are recurrent problem areas that impede path of travel for those who have physical disability and even those without. Universal sidewalk snow and ice clearance is good for the economy, it's good for public safety, and it's good for accessibility. More people out on the sidewalks in their neighborhoods means more eyes on the street, and that is a net good for public safety, and it means more people visiting local businesses and restaurants, which is good for the economy. This pilot program was designed over a year of meetings alongside officials and advocates. The intention to test operational methods to determine best practices that will maximize efficiency and affordability of this program. As you heard, zones are about 1.5 square miles designed with a series of metrics using a tool developed by the city. It is still available and BSC has a mirroring tool that is available on their website if you'd like to see intersections of qualifying metrics for yourself. Some of those that were taken into consideration when designing the zones include wealth disparity, residents with a disability, parents with children under five, no car households, urban form including density, street design, transit stations, infrastructure, schools, hospitals, and more. The coalition that has spent four and a half years working on this campaign believes in this pilot program presented today, and we're excited to see it go into effect. Passage of the Plow the Sidewalks pilot affirms that Chicago is a 21st century city that prioritizes the needs and mobility of all its residents by tending to our most universal, accessible infrastructure, sidewalks. Thank you very much, Alex. we will now move on to questions from the committee yes Chairwoman Harris good afternoon so we are doing we've narrowed it down to two zones right if I'm not I heard the presentation back we go back to the presentation especially around the employees but in the meantime so what happens if we have more than seven occurrences in the budgeted time and what's the education process behind informing the residents that we've used up all the money and we can no longer plow their sidewalk correct turner acting commissioner for c dot um yeah we have seven deployments that's um that's Budgeted and you know once that's done that's that'd be up to I mean City Council to either approve more But it's I mean once the money is gone. I mean, that's That's it for the it's a pilot program So that's what we supposed to you know get our you know get information on how we can scale up and scale down based on the information that we gather during that time Okay I just want to get clarification from everybody that we do not currently plow sidewalk In the city of Chicago. Am I correct on that? Other than city-owned property. CDOT only has authorization to do bike lanes. Which is to say we don't do sidewalks. I want to make it clear. Somebody said we plow sidewalks. One of our public speakers said we plow sidewalks. But we don't. And I just want to get that in the public record that we currently don't plow any sidewalks in the city. on a clarification also uh cdot will do bridges downtown downtown they'll do bridges over the river for point of clarification but i'm just being i'm clarifying the point on that we shovel downtown sidewalks and we don't those are businesses okay that's i'm it's a clarity question clarify that you said those are businesses a business is different than owners of property in the community? No, everybody's responsible to shovel their sidewalk, and the businesses downtown are responsible for shoveling their sidewalks. Thank you. And currently, and how we currently remove snow, is that we do a pass down the street. And I want to make it kind of clear that in this case we will be doing two passes on the street if there will be houses on both sides of the street so um how did we equate for the time that it'll take to be on a block given you have to do two passes on the street instead of the one with a truck moving down the street that's a close to our commissioner streets and that's what we'll be determining through this process is to where are we going to put the snow you know um that was one of the things that we discussed you know not every uh block has a parkway for example you know so that was one of the things that we would be assessing through this process okay thank you those are my questions thank you very much chair i know that alderman moore has his hand raised online Alderman Moore, you with us? I am. Thank you so much, Chairman Esqueda and Chairman Villegas. Let me first say, I do commend both of you on the effort and the works that you put into this. I am not, you know, in any ways not recognizing that, and I appreciate your efforts. I think everybody care about our elderly. Everybody care about our families with abilities. And, you know, my mom, who's one who has to navigate this as well. But let me just be real and honest here. First of all, thank you so much, Chairman Harris, for posing the question that you posed. Because yes, it's a pilot. And the next question is, when you run out of money, the hits that everybody's going to take from that. And I I don't mind taking hits, but it's a problem when you set expectations and come back for money. Money right now that we do not have. But even more importantly, here it is, you all. I want the city to do better at what they're supposed to be doing now. We have a wonderful commissioner in Streets and Sand and in CDOT right now. But especially in our communities, we are still trying to get the things that we need to do better, better from whether it's doing alleys, whether it's doing vacant lots. And so you're telling me what I'm hearing here is I got extra bodies and extra money to do something else, but I haven't done better for what my constituents are mostly complaining about, only to put something else that we may not even do better. And so it's a thing for me of let's do what, let's get, improve what we got to do first before going to something else that may cause a problem. Because as in everything else, and here's the truth to things, the inequities and communities and getting things done is still going to be there. And therefore now it becomes another fight, another challenge and another pull and push. And so let us do what we do better first before moving to something else and continuing to frustrate our constituencies. I would rather see us because I can present and see a problem, but I'm also solution oriented. When we got people like my block, my hood, my city, who's doing great things, let's see how we can help them. And whether it's through grants or anything, to expand the operations that they do. They've been doing some of the stuff not only for free, but just, you know, for whatever the small grants they're getting. Let's see how we can expand that through grant opportunities rather than burying us down with more budget responsibility. The other thing is the ordinance that we passed last year, Keep Chicago Clean, which I'll be revisiting as passed to put some money behind it, which is not a whole bunch of money, but it's towards people having a focus to do their own cleanup in their own community, not for me to go get streets and sand to spend more money to clean up in front of somebody's house. And so do we need to be creative in how we think about this? Is there opportunities for us to offer property tax credits for people who help their neighbors out or you pay less on your garbage bill, whatever it is, to help your neighbor out? I think before we take on this larger task, when we're not doing everything we're supposed to be doing well, to put something on the plates of our leaders when they're trying to do their best. And they're going to tell you, hey, we'll get to it, we'll work it. But I think it's putting too much on our departments and our department heads right now to do this. and it's going to be end up what, what something that's supposed to be good is going to end up being a negative when we're not doing the things right now that we're supposed to be doing better. And we're not, we're not even doing that the best we can, but yet we're going to throw something else in there. And so, uh, uh, I can't support this right now until we do the things that we're supposed to be doing right now better. And I appreciate the efforts that's been put into this. And whether it's a pilot or what, right now, I don't want to even just waste any money. We don't have money to waste if we're not looking towards moving something further. And right now, this is not ready to go further. Even if everything went and said, hey, we could do this, we could do that, it's going to be a cost to it, but it's also going to be a cost to finding the bodies to do it the best way we can when we're not doing the other things better. Do everything else better first, then let's come back and revisit this. Thank you. Okay. Thank you for the comments, Alderman Mort. Just for clarity, did you have a question for the departments? Okay. Thank you, sir. We had Alderman Curtis followed by Alderman Rodriguez. Oh. And then number three, Alderman Conway. I'll take stack. Thank you. Alderman Curtis. Thank you, chairmen, both. And I want to command everyone that had their hands in this project. I want to say, you know, out of my 30 plus years of government, I spent 22 years of it basically dealing with city services, infrastructure, and operations. And trust me, I got it down pat. there's nothing more that I would love to see as this project work. But I hate to rain on anyone parade, but I don't see it. I don't see it because of the 22 years that I've been doing this, I also implemented this into when I first became Alderman. And every single winter, I do 300-plus seniors. I have all the equipment. I have manpower. And, again, the same attachments that you see on some of those tractors, we've tried those too. especially when you get down to wards where you got over a thousand blocks, 2,000 blocks in one ward. How do you do it? It's impossible. When I was ward superintendent, when the trucks go to dump the trucks in the afternoon, we take laborers to the corners, we shovel the sidewalks. It also includes the water department laborers, sanitation laborers, general laborers. CDOT labors, we still don't reach our goal of shoveling the sidewalks. Do we get to some fire hydrants? Do we get to some corners? Yeah, we get to some, but there's no way. And I do feel sorry for, especially when it comes down to ADA. So this is something that we have to do, even on that federal level, where we're getting funds to help. Just the same as every street that we touch, we have to make everything ADA compliant. It's going to be the same thing for the sidewalks. What happens when you get to the sidewalks, when you're shoveling or plowing, when you get to the sidewalks that's not level, sidewalks that's not really there because they're covered by gravel. I want to see it happen, but I don't want to see it fail and we waste $500,000 when we're already in a $1.5 billion deficit. So I would love to hear the gentleman in the back right there that said that they had a plan. I don't know if it was the same scenario, but I would love to see what it looks like. And when it comes down to it, there won't be a guarantee that you will actually be getting on those blocks where people are disabled. I really need to see it. So these are actually really great questions. And to be clear, you talked about our budget gap looking at next year. There's not a budget ask for this in the 2026 budget. I want to be really clear on that. But in terms of the feasibility, that is actually something that's been discussed over the last two years now. And I'm wondering if folks can speak from the box, can speak to some of the other cities that you looked at and the actual logistical feasibility of bringing this program to Chicago. go okay uh sean whydell deputy commissioner for citywide services at c dot um the main city that we talked to is toronto it's probably the closest pure city to us i spoke with them i've spoken with them multiple times we spoke with them yesterday um just for context their snow clearance program was 111 million dollars last year and of that 111 million dollars about 20 was contracted services for sidewalks alone um and they also use in-house crews of about 270 people to do their work plus the equipment that they use for that as well um that's kind of the closest pier they they do they do that effectively it is something they do but it's also um as you can hear it's a it's a costly program on an annual basis for that city question so toronto do they only do the arterial streets or are they going into the neighborhoods also that is uh alderman that is everything that's all the city streets and all the city sidewalks and how much snow do they actually get from what i from my peer that i talked to yesterday um they last year was a 156 million dollars canadian which is about 111 million dollars um that was a bad year but it on average you know there over the last i did find this out too over the last five or six years it's cost between somewhere between 75 million and 100 million dollars us dollars uh for their snow clearing also deputy commissioner just for clarity that is for the entirety of their city that's correct that is correct and like i said the the snow the sidewalk portion of that is about 20%. Contract it out. Okay, one last question, Deputy, and anybody in the box can answer this. Let's say we do shovel that particular sidewalk, right? And as my colleague who also was a ward superintendent also, let's say we shovel that sidewalk and in the course of that day, it snowed twice, right? Or three times even. And sometimes we don't know what time that will be. If we shovel that sidewalk and let's say we get two inches, we get out there and do that 1.5 square mile, if a resident trips and falls after that sidewalk because it does become slippery, after that will did toronto or will the city of chicago be liable for that fall uh while they couldn't categorize sean again sean weidel with c dot um they couldn't categorize the full amount of the liability they did uh say yes there is liability not only for that in in toronto that they've covered but also for things like sprinkler heads that are pulled out and other damage to grass and turf and things like that. So, yes, there's potential liability. They couldn't give me a number for that, though. Okay. Thanks. I have a point of clarification. Deputy Commissioner, are you a lawyer? Are you legal? I'm not. Okay. So I just wanted to, you asked a question that you didn't get a legal answer. so if you want to hear a legal we do have someone from DOL here to respond to that I would love to hear it I mean will we be responsible or won't we I mean especially trying to do the right thing Hi Alderman Lindsay Sonenthal Assistant Corporation Counsel Department of Law we don't Due to this being a new program we don't have any information about what the liability would potentially look like but We'd be happy to get you some general information about tort liability through the chair Thanks, well, yeah, that'd be great Is right He has requested rule 59 participation Okay, the reason I'm asking, because I want to take this opportunity to liberty of the chair, if you don't mind. All right. Lindsay, why don't we plow the snow now? Why hasn't the city of Chicago committed to clearing the sidewalks now? Lindsay Sedenthal, Department of Law. chairman i i don't think that's a legal uh question really i there's uh there's i don't believe it's a legal reason it's perhaps are we responsible to clear the sidewalks at the moment we are not responsible to clear the sidewalks under uh mcc of the municipal code of chicago section 10-8-180 um every owner lessee tenant occupant or other person in charge of any building or lot is responsible for clearing their own sidewalks. Well, currently, isn't the responsibility of maintaining the sidewalks and parkways shared between the city and the property owner? And I assume this obligation is very fact-specific and legally complex. Yes, Chairman. I mean, sorry. thank you yes chairman um the the code puts the um responsibility on the property owner for clearing the sidewalk uh creating clear path at least five feet in width in front of their um building or ground um and there are probably certain areas or places where depending on the exact specifications of the lot. There could be some differences and you'd have to look at each fact. But in general, at the moment, it is every property owner who is responsible for clearing the sidewalk in front of their property. In your legal opinion, if we took responsibility to clear the sidewalk, what type of liability does it open the city up to? um again chair i i can't say because it is very fact specific what kind of liability exactly that that would open um the city up to uh as uh sean pointed out in toronto that there are um certain liabilities related to to torts of sorts but i can't give any specific information without knowing the facts so buying committing to supply the sidewalks are is the city essentially assuming control of the Parkway right now there the language is extremely loose with regard to who is obligated to between and I'll take streets and sanitation and see that there's a obligation to the some there's a duty to the public way right now the language is in our favor would you would you agree that if we were we enjoy a limited government toward liability by not saying we're responsible for the parkway i.e clearing the clearing snow as the ordinances is written that um that is before us today uh the change in the code is adding um is changing an exemption that had been placed in during the last um the last time this plow the sidewalks was brought up in 2023 there's an exemption for um the penalty for the snow and ice removal for for any owner in a residential building um for uh failing to comply with the removal but what this ordinance changes is that it makes clear that CDOT must provide notice to those property owners in order for them and provide notice in the location in order for them to actually be exempted from from the requirement. Wow, that's new. I didn't see that. So is that effort baked into the cost of this pilot? And what if we as Alderman, we have a problem giving notice to our own constituents. So how would that, and I don't think you can answer that, that would be a Streets and Sands and CDOT. How would that work out? You're going to give notice to the constituents, residents of the block and by giving them notice they're waiving their right to sue if they trip over the sidewalk that the city now has assumed control over i.e plow the sidewalk uh sorry uh chairman there's no waiver of right in in this situation that's what i kind of heard In this situation, it's more of the, at the moment, the way the law is written, an owner of a property has the responsibility to remove snow and ice from the sidewalk in front of them. There is an exemption for an owner or lessee, tenant, or occupant, person in charge of any residential building in the Chicago Plow the Sidewalks pilot program. However, what this ordinance would add is specifically only for the owner, lessee, tenant, occupant, or other person in charge of a residential building in the pilot program that has been provided notice by CDOT that they are in fact in this pilot program. So it wouldn't be a waiver of any sort of liability. It wouldn't be sort of a legal waiver What it would be is they would be exempted from the requirement That they remove the snow and the ice from their sidewalk. I'm glad you brought up notice Um Isn't city liability depend dependent on notice as an example If the city knew that's actual notice or should the city should have known as constructive notice if we're doing what you said we're we're admitting that we're responsible we're giving no so we're we're letting the owner know that we we know this is a potential dangerous situation so now we've just entered the world of liability in the lawsuit. So chairman for forever, for sort of every legal case, right? There it's going to be very fact specific. So the extent to which the city would be liable for, for anything that happens in, in the situations you're discussing would depend on, on the facts. Um, there may be possibilities of liability in certain situations having to do with notice, but it might not necessarily lead to liability in every situation. It really just depends on the facts. Might not necessarily. But right now, we don't have to worry about that because if we leave everything status quo, you don't have to worry about that. Fair? Is that fair? Again, you know, I can't go into every fact pattern that may be happening currently or has ever happened within the city, but as the code is written, the snow and ice removal is left to the owners of the property abutting the sidewalks. And because we enjoy that right now, the city's not specifically on the hook for liabilities. They have to prove their case, and it's going to be case by case. we assume responsibility for the parkway saying we're going to apply the sidewalks. If something happens on that sidewalk, our fight is a little weaker than it was otherwise we hadn't instituted this pilot. Is that fair to say? Yes, Chair. I think it's fair to say that perhaps there's a weaker case, again, depending exactly on the facts. Yeah. Okay. Thank you, Lindsay. I always love talking to you. All right. I'll mention, Chairman, can our commissioner, Cole, answer your original question? He was going, so I didn't want to put him on the spot. What's the original question I'm answering? His original question was, why don't the city file sidewalks right now? Right now it's homeowners responsibility and businesses responsibility. Thank you, Cole. I'm sorry. No, that's all right. And I would note it's really interesting to talk about liability on sidewalk because it really is ignoring the broader liability that we don't generally talk about where the physical condition of our sidewalks are concerned. where, I mean, that's an overarching liability that we seldom talk about, that we did talk about in the Pedestrian Traffic Safety Committee a couple months ago. So I appreciate your following up on that. Likewise, Chairman. Yes, I know. That actually is part of it because that, in my opinion, would lead to the limited liability we enjoy by uneven sidewalks, cracks in the sidewalks. Right now, acting commissioner, didn't we just settle a $750,000 settlement for tripping over a sidewalk that the city knew about for four years? Yes is okay. You're referencing this. He's referencing the stairs off of Lake Michigan. No, no. No, this is something else. well um acting commissioner craig turner um yes it was a settlement so yes all right i'm gonna back off no i appreciate it it's a massive liability that is huge already on our heads so i did want to speak to you we have a few folks who would like a motion for real 59 participation may have a motion for orders mike rodriguez present Sorry, guys, your names are skipping around. Alderman Mike Rodriguez, Alderman Halu Gutierrez are asking for a motion for remote participation, and I also see recognizing Jason Irvin, but may we have a motion for Alderman Rodriguez and Gutierrez? Moved by Alderman Conway, all in favor say aye. All opposed say nay. In the opinion of the chairs, have it. Thank you, Alderman, for joining with us. keeping stack Alder Mosley and Lawson we will come to you right now we have Alder Rodriguez says we can pass so we will go to Alderman Conway followed by Alderwoman Nugent Alderman Conway thank you if we go back to the I just want to make sure I'm understanding the budgets if we go back to slides 12 and 13 on there so is this is this what the $261,000 budget is that essentially everything from the prior page multiplied by seven but other than the equipment is that what that is the two six so that is actually the number all in for all seven deployments okay so it but i see it's not but if you look at 47 000 that time seven is not 261 000 but i think what it does it just says the equipment there once which would make sense you don't have to buy we go back shovel every time you know i can do this sean can you speak to the budget estimate uh sean weidel deputy commissioner for CDOT. I can get you, if you have specific questions, Alderman Conway, I can get you the Office of Budget Management and Mike Drake, who is our deputy for in-house construction, developed these estimates. Mike couldn't be here due to an emergency event that he had to attend, but I'm happy to get you any answers through the chair. But my understanding is correct that this is the equipment you only pay for once. That is correct. And then everything else is times seven, which I think that works out mathematically. Now, I think it was said earlier that the city would have enough equipment on hand to do the pilot program. So would that need to be included in here, included in this or not? Yeah, when we were working with the folks in the audience and at the table here with us, it was originally six zones, worked it down to four zones, and we got it down to where we agreed and understood the budget constraints. We got it down to two zones. As it was pointed out early in the explanation of, we literally did it to where it was close to our, our houses where, where we have the equipment and that was just so we can actually see what it's going to take to do this. We know there's alders out there that have these robust programs that go on that we tapped into some of those through this process to see what it takes to get this done. So we feel we have the equipment. I know it was mentioned earlier in regards to manpower. our slower part of the department season-wise as far as CDOT lets folks go when it's pretty much at this time where they've come over to Streets and Sand and worked with us during those times. So that's where we get those extra folks, and we felt that given that opportunity, we can see what it takes, we can analyze it, and then we can present to the group that we think this is going to cost X amount of dollars to expand this. If this program did go citywide in the future, would the city own enough equipment to take it citywide or would we have to buy more equipment? No, the reality of this is this would be farmed out for contract. That wouldn't be something we would take on in-house, but we would have knowledge going when we had to put together a plan for Alphabet. And Audemann Conway, to be clear, no one is even contemplating taking it citywide. Well, I mean, perhaps, but I mean, why would we do a pilot program if there's no chance we're going to take it citywide, right? Doesn't that seem like a nutty thing to do? I mean, what are we still doing? I hear what you're driving at, but that would be a significantly different conversation for the city council to have. I would not, so to speak, put that cart before the horse or before the plow. Well, I mean, the whole definition of the word pilot is to test something and see if we should do a greater version of that. So I think it's worth that having at least a little bit of a discussion what the cost might be in that. But I mean, the only other question I have was regarding Toronto. I just want to make sure I understood what you were saying is that the 75 million to 100 million for the whole city, that's like plowing streets and everything, and the sidewalks would be deemed 20% of that or 15 to 20 million. Is that? That is correct, Alderman. Okay. All my questions were all answered by Alderman Mitchell's brutal cross-examination of the law department, which I really didn't have on my bingo card today, but that's all I have. Thank you. brutal but friendly but professional to be clear also um i would ask a rule 59 motion for orders mostly ervin and vazquez who have joined us online so moved alderman curtis all in favor say aye all opposed say nay in the opinion of the chairs the eyes have it thank you gentlemen uh we will go to alderman nugent thank you chairman both chairman um I appreciate us having this hearing today and talking about this and as we were going into this you know I think it's important that we recognize that I truly believe that the intent surrounding this comes from a really like a really good place and um and I understand that but I'm really struggling to wrap my head around this I think Alderman Conway was right. The purpose of this pilot is to test something out to see if it's scalable for the city at large. And we are all up against a budget that is gonna have a deficit of over $1.2 billion. And this would really be a huge unfunded mandate for the city of Chicago and our residents. And contemporaneously, I did hear all of the folks that were making comments today during the public comment section. And they had very good points, and they were very relevant. And I think that we need to partner with the community more. A lot of us in the city council have programs to deal with snow and snow removal. In my own ward, we have a mutual aid program. We call it Neighbors Helping Neighbors. And anybody that has mobility issues or for whatever reason can't get out there, we go out and help them, and we work with community organizations. but it got me thinking that if there are habitual bad actors or folks that aren't aren't removing the snow and are causing the folks that were in in the audience today or the communities they represent let us know who those bad actors are and perhaps we as a body maybe we raise or increase the fines on the folks that aren't doing what they are mandated to do right now by the municipal code, because I think we have to, we have to represent our residents accordingly. But at the same time, I, I don't see how we can take on an unfunded mandate at this magnitude as we lead into this budget. And I heard, um, I just want to gut check a couple things. Um, question for commissioner Stollard. I, I saw in the pilot language, it looks like we might use skid stairs on the sidewalks, are they more damaging on the infrastructure of the actual sidewalk than just regular shoveling? What do you think about the potential for sidewalks on that? Thank you. Cole Stollard, Commissioner of Streets of Sanitation. We're looking at different pieces of equipment. Skid stairs could have different attachments on it, brushes, blowers. We're looking at you know there are people that do this you know we know that the park district does this so we're looking to tap into that we literally looked into um renting a couple pieces of equipment to see what we think would work best we know we're at the five hundred thousand dollar mark uh we we talked about you know let's try to do this you know at six o'clock in the morning where there is no overtime just to try to assess the situation now we all know we can't control when it's going to snow we i get that um i to respect to alderman curtis's comment of you know what if it snows again we we know it does that we've had been fortunate the last two years with 20 inches or less uh through this process but again we're here to assess what we think would work how it worked for us to be able to put something together to present to the body, to talk about moving in a certain direction. But to answer if we were to put a skid steer with a bucket on the front of it on a sidewalk, yes, we know that. We've experienced that when we've gone into blizzard-type situations. We know that. but as far as us being mindful of all those things through experience, we want to do what we can to achieve the goal. Thank you, and I appreciate that. Again, I think this comes from a really good place. I don't see how this pilot could become scalable citywide. even, let me just say, I don't see how this pilot could become scalable citywide without us placing a huge financial burden on the residents of the city and taxpayers. I'm happy to work with colleagues on mutual aid type programs that we can do throughout our ward offices to help folks with snow removal, but in its current form, I can't support this. Thank you. Thank you, Autumn Newton. I'll just add, like nothing is to take away from the valiant efforts It's done by our neighbors, through our offices, through mutual aid efforts. And of course, as it has been pointed out by the sheet that's handed out, alders are allowed to use their expense accounts to do sidewalk snow clearance. The goal here, also to be clear, no one is trying to, in case it wasn't clear earlier, no one is trying to put a budget ask into our 2026 budget that is already feeling less than manageable or trying to calculate the citywide costs. I just wanted to bring clarity on that. Thank you. I appreciate that, but I also, this is a pilot. The purpose of a pilot is to see the feasibility of a project and to make it scalable for the city of Chicago. I don't, and I, listen, if our colleagues want to use their menu money to go towards snow removal, of course that is their prerogative and they should be able to do that. I think I can speak for me. This menu money is, the dollars aren't stretching very far right now and we're doing the best we can, but I just want to be very clear that I am looking at every single thing that comes before my desk right now with immense scrutiny because we are $1.2 to $1.5 billion in the hole and I think we just have to be really responsible as a body politic. Thank you, Chairman. I think you're right. And I will say, when we talk about, as has been raised a couple times, whether it is feasible to do this citywide, we may ask that question and the answer comes back no. The kind of the crux of this ordinance is, shall we ask that question by doing the pilot? It's kind of like, would be my take on it. But the hands have gone down. I believe that they want it to be recognized for purposes of quorum and have been do we have any further questions in the room? I want to Scott one side come in I want to add clarity to Alderman Nugent it's not the menu it's it's it's it's the automatic expense account where it has been carved out where it's been approved legally approved that we based on 2-8-050 automatic expense allowance that expenses incurred to remove snow from the public sidewalks a courtesy walk for a resident with a demonstrated need for such services except for expenses incurred in the removal of snow from private property so to pick to elaborate on what you said we have we we have the ability to do this now i've instituted into my ward derrick curtis michelle harris jason ervin marty quinn on steroids we we we do this um so uh if you took ten thousand dollars out of each from each automatic uh expense that's the five hundred thousand dollars so we already have an ability to do that and it's the ability to do it in our wars the way we do it and it doesn't create a liability uh for the city we're doing it based on need of the person based as opposed to taking responsibility for the public way so thank you so uh we have others who have are requesting rule 59 participation which is oh yes i know i he has texted me as well to notify me of that hand uh alderman quinn you're We're in queue behind Alderman Wagesbach, but we have a Rule 59 motion request from Alders. Alderman Rodriguez, we got you before, but a Rule 59 motion for Alderwoman Cruz and Alderman Hopkins. Would we entertain the motion? Alderman Curtis, so moves. All those in favor, say aye. All opposed, say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. Alderman Wagesbach. Thanks, Chairman. When you were studying this, did the group look at increasing the fines for failure to shovel in the city? We had not during the working group. That is, I suspect that may come up over the course of the next two months in council, but that was not discussed through the working group. Okay. And then did we also look at the total number of tickets citywide and by ward over the last several years? I can't say I recall off the top of my head, but we can get you that information through the chair. Yeah, that would be total number of tickets, total by ward, and if it could be broken down into whether it was a business or a residence, that would be helpful. Commercial, residential, city as a whole, and by ward. Yep. Got it. And then, you know, just as a point of information, I know ours goes up to $500. Toronto charges up to $1,000 per fine, average being about $240. And then Toronto started their program in 2022. So it's a relatively new program. And they're already talking about, they've already instructed the departments to go back and reassess that program and potentially remove it due to the liability risks that it exposed the city to for having that program run by the city, as well as going back to pre-2022, to have businesses or corporations plow their own sidewalks again because of the burden that it put on the city of Toronto. So I just wanted to make that point of information. If we're going to use Toronto, we should know the full story there and realize that anything that touches the public way, we are responsible for. So to kind of soft pedal the fact that if we start plowing, we may or may not be responsible or liable for an injury, we definitely will. And we've seen that through so many of the lawsuits that have come through the law department over the last 15 to 20 years. And we've seen an increase of trip and fall cases that we have become responsible for to the tune of millions of dollars over the last several years. So I think to kind of brush that off as not possibly happening is something that we have to be very aware of when we're making this decision. With that, I'll hand it back to you, but I appreciate if we could get those answers. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Will do. I think we will go to Audemann Quinn. Audemann Quinn? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a quick question for Commissioner Stollard. In your proposed pilot program, what sort of machine are you calling for to be used? There are machines that we have available to us in CDOT, and we're talking to the park district to see what those best options are, and then we worked with Fleet to look at a possibility of renting a couple pieces also. Okay, so you're going to use like a Kabuta or a Polaris or something along those lines? I'm not going to call stuff by brand and do a promotion for anybody right now, but we are looking at what's available to us. There is lines for us to be able to rent equipment through fleet if we needed to, to try out and see what's working. And then again, we do have in-house equipment with CDOT. Streets and Sand doesn't have that kind of equipment, but we felt confident through the process that we were able to get equipment for this program. And then also by being a pilot program. Hey, go ahead. This is Acting Commissioner Craig Turner. As by being a pilot program, we can get through the chair the type of equipment that we do have on hand right now. Well, that's the point, is that if you don't have your equipment lined up or the specifics now, I think you're setting yourself up to fail on the front end. You can't just limit this to hand shovelers. You have to have your equipment lined up and you have to begin routing it and being prepared. Commissioner Stollard, do you plan on using salt also? No, that's not part of this. It's not part of this. Okay. Good question. Okay. And one more time, just so I'm clear, Commissioner Stollard, you're looking at $50,000 per program. That's what we came up with, yes. Okay. I've got no further questions. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you so much. Do we have any other questions? I have one more question. Yes, sir. Commissioner Starler, one of the benefits of the pilot, that it will benefit the handicap accessible, it will benefit the disabled and things like that. I'm having a hard time hearing you, sir. I'm sorry. the pilot is touted one of the benefits of the pilot is for disabled individuals to make it safer for disabled individuals is in our neighborhoods we install service walks and catwalks to assist them getting through the parkway to the curbs and to their cars is that part of this pilot to clear those and if so how would they know where they are when these people aren't familiar with the community? That's not part of it. It was the walkway in front of the house. One of the benefits is to help handicapped or disabled individuals. I would think that would be front and center and a part to make sure the things in the community that are for that are put there four to eight would be covered. So I find that a little disheartening that we would go through all this and we wouldn't even consider something like that. That's all the questions I have. Now the goal to see that included is one that we can take into account. Appreciate it, Chair. Auditwoman Manon Hoppenworth. Thank you, Chairman. I wanted to first thank the working group the other sidewalks working group this is a an issue that's come up in my ward in Edgewater and uptown because most of us are car light or car free and use transit quite a bit and too often in the winter months, I see electric wheelchairs going down the streets, not on the sidewalks, but on the streets. And many have come to me to ask about this program. So this is a program that I'm very interested in. And I know that the pilots are not targeted in my area, but I am interested in hearing a little bit more about, is this actually doable? The pilot as it is, with the money that there is, with the people that we have, and the equipment that's available now. And I was hoping to hear from each of the departments that were participating in the working group. Gentlemen. As far as like for CDOT, we will be using like our current resources and this will be additional tasks on top of everything else that we're working on, especially during a snow event because our department also assists Streets and Sands during snow events also. So this will have to be factored into it. And, you know, we can put together a plan and try to work the plan the best that we can. But by this being a pilot project, of course, this is going to be a learning experience so we can see what our capabilities, what works, what don't work. So, yeah, so, I mean, we can, it's a pilot program. We will scale it accordingly based on the funding. but I mean this is we you know this is um we do have resources but we will have to see how they can be reallocated or allocated during these different snow events and as Commissioner Stoller said the snow events are unpredictable so we don't know the magnitude of or you know until we get into a pilot right so so for the pilot for the seven incidents you have the people and you have the equipment well we have people but we may have to utilize overtime and other things to to try to accomplish the task and it is doable at is as as this is written um we can we can put together a plan based on the funding to do what to do what we can do with the money with the money that is allocated in this in this pilot yes yeah um i'll say it as far as this operation what what we're being tasked with with these two zones again the original ask we worked with the working group and we just said we can't do that you know we don't have the the resources at this point to be able to do that so we worked together to narrow it down to these two. We're anticipating seven. Seven events would get us through our 500,000. If everything was on a Sunday and we got six inches of snow, every program, obviously that number is going to get smaller. But again, we're trying to assess what equipment works, what manpower needs would be, to assess the situation to see if this is a possibility. I hope I answered your question. Yeah, so the question was, is it, as you work together in the working group on changes, as it is written right now, is your department able to handle with the people and the equipment that you have? And we sat to be able to present to you for this process of staying united and saying this, for this, for these two zones with this $500,000, we'll be able to have the equipment, we'll be able to have the manpower, we'll be able to assess this situation. We'll be able to have people out there with clipboards telling us how we're doing. We'd be able to do that. Now, as others have mentioned in here, you know, what's the point of a pilot is to see if it's feasible to move forward. We'll be able to present that also, we feel, but we'll also be able to gather and gain information because we are saying, if this was to expand, that we would have to go through the procurement process because we feel we wouldn't be able to take that on. so as this plan is in place that was agreed upon from everybody sitting at this table we felt confident that we would be able to provide answers thank you commissioners I appreciate that I also want to again give gratitude for the work that you all did together to put together this presentation and and i also i also want to express my frustration that there too many times the city prioritizes the cars that move through our public spaces um more than um people and and i would like to see us do better and i i'm glad that we're having these conversations about how we can do better on our public way for people who get around by walking or rolling or mothers who have strollers or those who use assisted devices to be able to get around no matter what the weather is in the city, especially in the winter months. I think we can do better. So I appreciate all the work that you've done. Thank you, both of the chairs, for having this hearing. Thank you very much, Audermon. We have Audermon Andre. Sorry, Andre. It's been a day. It's been a day, Andre. Audermon Andre Vazquez. Thank you very much, Chairman. So I do appreciate this conversation. Yeah, I think I'm kind of caught in something that the colleagues have been asking related to the scalability of it all. I think given the challenges we have, not just with this year's or next year's, but like the following number of years of budget, trying to figure out what cost looks like is important, right? Even if we're doing a pilot right now, trying to find citywide would be important as well as like options for people who want to take care of their neighbors while the pilot's going on, because I would anticipate that the pilot continues anybody who's not part of the pilot will have their constituents asking them when they get theirs taken care of and so i do think there's some level of concern and responsibility necessary there i know in the 40th we have volunteers we do about i don't know anywhere from 70 to 100 homes a year when it snows over two inches so i guess my question is if there were alders who rather than waiting for a pilot to expand when we don't have a date for expansion just wanted to get their own plows, could some of the funding go just to have all just get their own plows do it themselves? Because some of us do do that. So, so far, sir, the funding is directed towards accessibility initiatives. We could re-examine what that means coming out of this hearing. that that has not been i would say to andre this is that has not been determined as yet okay yeah kind of finding out when it would be would be important because again us being able to do it ourselves while the pilot's going on would add for accessibility right so if i had a little whatever those buggies are you can drive to the sidewalk and clear it myself i'd handle it while the pilot's still being worked out and getting the data. I just do anticipate, because neighbors are neighbors, they'll hear about a pilot, they'll hear about sidewalk clearance, and they'll wonder why their ward doesn't have it yet. And then we have to deal with that part as well. So I do think that's a concern. I do think what Chairman Mitchell raised up about the opening of any potential liability is a concern. So I think for me, through the chair, some of those questions and answers or what kind of methodology one would use to get to that would be important. I just, yeah, given our budget constraints right now, I think some of those answers are necessary because constituents are going to be asking us. So that's all I've got. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Audemars. Any further questions? No, that'd be it. Thank you. As a brief courtesy, may I ask for a motion for just a five minute recess? I need to ask, I move for a five minute recess. All in favor say aye. All opposed say nay. Brief five. I want to take one quick moment, sir. We will be, there will be two minutes. Okay. Reconvening. We are with no other questions. May I have a motion? Roll call. I was going there, sir. for a roll call vote on this item. Don't move. Okay. Alderman La Spada, yes. Alderman Hopkins. Alderman Robinson. Alderman Yancey. Alderman Mitchell. No. Alderman Harris. Alderman Chico. No. Alderman Quinn. No. Audemann Gutierrez? Yes. Audemann Moore? No. Audemann Curtis? Audemann Mosley? No. Audemann Rodriguez? Audemann Fuentes? Audemann Burnett? Audemann Irvin? Alderman Cruz. Alderman Wagesbach. Alderman Conway. Alderman Nugent. Alderman Vazquez. Alderman Knudsen. Alderman Lawson. No. Alderman Martin. all the women thank you the motion fails hold all the menurban votes no thank you all the menurban with there being no further business before the committee may have a motion to adjourn so moved by several all those in favor signify by saying aye we are adjourned thank you Yeah, it's only dynamite.