Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, October 17, 2023
- When: Tue, Oct 17, 2023, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576
- Transcript: full text (33,475 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 21:02 Public comment
- 24:35 Jason C. Ervin: Explained the hearing would use joint sessions, pairing the OIG with the Board of Ethics and…
- 24:49 Joint budget hearing: Office of Inspector General and Board of Ethics (2024 proposed budget)
- 46:32 Matthew J. Martin: Asked how restructuring the OIG's intake function would improve the process and reduce…
- 49:14 Matthew J. Martin: Asked about progress on a public tracker showing compliance with OIG recommendations.
- 50:44 Matthew J. Martin: Asked how increased nonprofit lobbying regulation would affect the Board of Ethics'…
- 55:55 Motion to allow Alderperson Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez to participate remotely under Rule 59
- 57:14 Matthew J. O'Shea: Praised the Board of Ethics director and noted the challenge of replacing retiring staff.
- 57:57 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the OIG should be in space separate from other departments and asked about progress…
- 1:01:01 Jason C. Ervin: Asked where the OIG is located, whether it has found new space and whether the budget…
- 1:03:30 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how many OIG positions remain open and requested an updated organizational chart.
- 1:04:36 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how much the OIG saved by not filling positions until late in the year.
- 1:05:39 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether vacancies created a backlog of cases and how large it is.
- 1:11:18 Emma Mitts: Requested that departments provide organizational charts during budget hearings.
- 1:12:14 Emma Mitts: Asked the Inspector General how many PPP loan cases across departments are being reviewed and…
- 1:14:47 Emma Mitts: Asked about the OIG's top findings and the work it is most proud of.
- 1:18:30 Brendan Reilly: Asked how the OIG divides its time among audits, misconduct investigations, police oversight…
- 1:20:59 Brendan Reilly: Asked both departments how they will raise their visibility and outreach in 2024.
- 1:24:28 Brendan Reilly: Suggested billboards in the central business district and free public service airtime from…
- 1:27:05 Samantha Nugent: Thanked the Board of Ethics director and Inspector General for their help to the 39th Ward.
- 1:27:24 Jason C. Ervin: Asked whether rising intake could come at the expense of the OIG's audit function and…
- 1:29:19 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether technology could reduce missed ethics training reminders, such as sign-in…
- 1:30:38 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether ethics fines go to the corporate fund.
- 1:31:08 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether aspects of the migrant crisis response, such as procurement and shelter…
- 1:39:19 Desmon C. Yancy: Asked about the OIG's role in consent decree compliance.
- 1:40:41 Desmon C. Yancy: Asked how successful the city has been in meeting the consent decree and whether data…
- 1:42:03 Desmon C. Yancy: Asked whether the OIG has audited violence prevention and intervention programs and noted…
- 1:43:18 Nicholas Sposato: Asked whether the Board of Ethics has an appeal process short of circuit court, citing his…
- 1:44:31 Nicholas Sposato: Asked whether the board uses progressive discipline for repeat violations.
- 1:47:28 Daniel La Spata: Asked whether reductions in OIG contractual services reflect efficiencies or the planned…
- 1:49:43 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked what protections exist for city employees who report wrongdoing and face…
- 1:51:15 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked why employees who report a supervisor are not automatically transferred.
- 1:54:26 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said employees who report problems should be able to move departments without losing…
- 2:00:23 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Thanked both offices, invited them to a 48th Ward ward night, and suggested…
- 2:13:14 Joint budget hearing: Civilian Office of Police Accountability and Police Board (2024 proposed budget)
- 2:31:44 Proposed FOP contract provision moving police discharge cases from the Police Board to arbitration
- 2:53:27 Daniel La Spata: Asked about the roles of COPA's proposed senior equity officer and director of mediation.
- 2:55:58 Daniel La Spata: Asked how the mediation pilot works and what its results have been.
- 3:04:20 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked when the FOP contract will come before council and why discharge decisions…
- 3:07:28 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Requested data on Police Board cases and outcomes and said the change appears to…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations held the first part of its October 17, 2023 budget hearings, beginning with one public commenter who spoke in favor of ranked choice voting as a way to avoid runoff election costs. The committee then held a joint hearing on the 2024 proposed budgets of the Office of Inspector General and the Board of Ethics, with members asking about investigation backlogs, the OIG's need for new office space, PPP loan fraud reviews, lobbying regulation, ethics training compliance and whistleblower protections. A second joint hearing covered the Civilian Office of Police Accountability and the Police Board, including COPA's caseload reduction, its People's Academy, a complainant mediation program and staffing vacancies, and the Police Board's concern that a proposed FOP contract provision would move discharge cases to closed arbitration. Members also approved a motion allowing Alderperson Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez to participate remotely. No votes were taken on the department budgets, and the committee recessed for lunch.
Topics: 2024 budget hearings, Office of Inspector General, Board of Ethics, COPA, Police Board, Police discipline arbitration, Whistleblower protections, Lobbying regulation, Ranked choice voting, Office space needs
Agenda items discussed
- 21:02 Public comment: discussed
- 24:49 Joint budget hearing: Office of Inspector General and Board of Ethics (2024 proposed budget): discussed
- 55:55 Motion to allow Alderperson Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez to participate remotely under Rule 59: passed
- 2:13:14 Joint budget hearing: Civilian Office of Police Accountability and Police Board (2024 proposed budget): discussed
- 2:31:44 Proposed FOP contract provision moving police discharge cases from the Police Board to arbitration: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Explained the hearing would use joint sessions, pairing the OIG with the Board of Ethics and COPA with the Police Board. (24:35); Asked where the OIG is located, whether it has found new space and whether the budget includes funding for a lease. (1:01:01); Asked whether rising intake could come at the expense of the OIG's audit function and whether that function should be separated. (1:27:24)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Asked how restructuring the OIG's intake function would improve the process and reduce the backlog of cases older than a year. (46:32); Asked about progress on a public tracker showing compliance with OIG recommendations. (49:14); Asked how increased nonprofit lobbying regulation would affect the Board of Ethics' workload. (50:44)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Praised the Board of Ethics director and noted the challenge of replacing retiring staff. (57:14); Said the OIG should be in space separate from other departments and asked about progress and whether the city is helping. (57:57)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked how many OIG positions remain open and requested an updated organizational chart. (1:03:30); Asked how much the OIG saved by not filling positions until late in the year. (1:04:36); Asked whether vacancies created a backlog of cases and how large it is. (1:05:39)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Requested that departments provide organizational charts during budget hearings. (1:11:18); Asked the Inspector General how many PPP loan cases across departments are being reviewed and the timeline. (1:12:14); Asked about the OIG's top findings and the work it is most proud of. (1:14:47)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked how the OIG divides its time among audits, misconduct investigations, police oversight and equity work. (1:18:30); Asked both departments how they will raise their visibility and outreach in 2024. (1:20:59); Suggested billboards in the central business district and free public service airtime from broadcasters. (1:24:28)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Thanked the Board of Ethics director and Inspector General for their help to the 39th Ward. (1:27:05)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked whether technology could reduce missed ethics training reminders, such as sign-in prompts. (1:29:19); Asked whether ethics fines go to the corporate fund. (1:30:38); Asked whether aspects of the migrant crisis response, such as procurement and shelter staffing, merit investigation and data transparency. (1:31:08)
- Desmon C. Yancy (alderperson): Asked about the OIG's role in consent decree compliance. (1:39:19); Asked how successful the city has been in meeting the consent decree and whether data problems contribute. (1:40:41); Asked whether the OIG has audited violence prevention and intervention programs and noted council questions about their efficacy. (1:42:03)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Asked whether the Board of Ethics has an appeal process short of circuit court, citing his own past probable cause matter. (1:43:18); Asked whether the board uses progressive discipline for repeat violations. (1:44:31)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked whether reductions in OIG contractual services reflect efficiencies or the planned move. (1:47:28); Asked about the roles of COPA's proposed senior equity officer and director of mediation. (2:53:27); Asked how the mediation pilot works and what its results have been. (2:55:58)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked what protections exist for city employees who report wrongdoing and face retaliation. (1:49:43); Asked why employees who report a supervisor are not automatically transferred. (1:51:15); Said employees who report problems should be able to move departments without losing pay, to encourage reporting. (1:54:26)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Thanked both offices, invited them to a 48th Ward ward night, and suggested cross-ward conversations on public safety data. (2:00:23); Asked when the FOP contract will come before council and why discharge decisions would move from the Police Board to arbitration. (3:04:20); Requested data on Police Board cases and outcomes and said the change appears to reduce transparency and accountability. (3:07:28)
Exchanges between members
- 1:38:27 Ervin followed up on a point raised by Vasquez by asking whether the council can direct the OIG to investigate a program.
- 2:01:58 Manaa-Hoppenworth suggested a joint public safety conversation with Taylor's office.
- 2:02:18 Manaa-Hoppenworth said she agreed with Vasquez about examining where city money goes.
- 3:25:06 Taylor said she had planned to ask a question similar to Yancy's about the connection between discipline and civil cases.
- 3:27:21 Ervin responded to Taylor that the city must protect taxpayers and handle employment matters separately from external proceedings.
- 3:28:01 Taylor replied to Ervin with an example of the city being sued after an officer was found to have followed the rules.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error