Also, I need to get breakfast Myself. But Good morning, uh, committee will come back to order. Uh, we'll start today with, um, public comment. Um, Abigail Nichols. Good morning. Uh, you'll have three minutes, uh, for comment. Thank you. Please proceed. Thank you. Good morning. My name is Abigail Nichols. I live in Ward two. I'm a member of the League of Women Voters and Reform. I'm sorry, uh, fair Vote, Illinois. I'm also on the board of Skyline Village, but my testimony today is for myself. I'm here to discuss the budget savings Chicago could reap from rank choice voting. Chicago needs money that's clear and rank choice. Voting in our municipal elections would save the city millions of dollars. Money is saved because rank choice voting eliminates the cost of a runoff election. Essentially, we have an instant runoff. Here's how it works. Voters vote for their favorite candidate. Just like now. If the first choice has more, uh, more, one person, one candidate has more than 50%, that's it. Just like now the second. But if nobody has a majority, the candidate with the least votes is eliminated. And the second choice votes of the folks who voted for that candidate are reallocated to the remaining candidates runoff. And this goes on, and I'm happy to talk at length with anybody who wants to hear more about rank choice voting. It's simple, but it sounds complicated when you try to describe how the tabulations go. Runoff elections cost the City of Chicago money to run the election runoff elections cost candidates who must raise money for their runoff campaigns and runoff elections cost voters too, they have to take off, may have to take off work, pay babysitters pay transportation, fair vote. Illinois currently projects 3 million, do at least $3 million savings from ranked choice voting and not having a runoff election. But since expenditures for the Board of elections this year are looked like 40, $56 million in your budget documents, your committee may be able to find more that the number is bigger than 3 million, and there are benefits well beyond the dollar savings. Rank choice voting improves collaboration by leading to less divisive elections. After all, candidates wanna be the second choice of supporters of another candidate. Winners have the clear support of at least half the voters Encumber Alder Alderman could campaign on their record of support for this change that saves money and helps the voter. Also pairing a, a vote on rank choice voting with a referendum on a tax increase might work. I worked the street on taxes and it's tough. You have tough decisions to make. I think choosing rank choice voting is one of the easier ones. Thank you for your attention and for your service to our wonderful city. Delighted to talk. Thank you, ma'am. Um, today, um, uh, we're scheduled to have, uh, six departments, uh, with us today. Uh, we have a joint hearing this morning. I, I told you while we were going to try some different things to, uh, see if we can make some adjustments to the process. So today we're going to have a joint hearing with, uh, the Board of Ethics in the Office of the Inspector General, uh, both of which have very broad, uh, authority over operations of the city, and its total totality. Uh, we'll have a second component of the hearing, which will focus more on public safety between COPA and the police board. But we're going to open this morning, uh, with the office of the Inspector General and the Board of Ethics. So, uh, whomever decides to go first, uh, please, uh, begin. I'll go first. You go first. Great. Good morning. Uh, good morning. Chairman Irvin, members of the City Council. Thank you for the opportunity to appear before the City Council Committee on budget and government Operations when I appeared before this committee in October, 2022 for the first time as city's Can't hear you. Yes, certainly use my outdoor voice. Sorry. Your outdoor voice. When I appeared before this committee in October, 2022, for the first time as the city's inspector General, I told you that in our 2023 budget, we had reflected plans for growth and progress at O I G. In 2023, we've implemented the substantial improvements and added the additional personnel and capacity for which we planned. We created a new section for information technology and analytics, moving the personnel devoted to that work out of our operations section, and creating a new position for a Deputy Inspector general for information technology and analytics, and several new staff positions. We've moved our intake personnel out of our investigation section and into a specialized unit with a devoted supervisor to better facilitate integrative interdisciplinary oversight. We added a new chief investigator, and in the third quarter of 2023, we're able to to add three new investigator positions to improve the timeliness of O I G investigations. To the same end, we've added two new assistant general positions in our legal section, uh, to build capacity and ensure the availability of high quality legal counsel across OIGs work. Because of the salvage rate built into our budget allocation for this year, for 2023, it's only in the last quarter that we were able to complete these improvements. Nonetheless, O I G has in 2023, built on its powerful legacy in the service of it, service of its mission to promote economy effectiveness and efficiency and integrity in the administration of the programs and operations of city government. In 2023, O I G maintained full compliance with its obligations under the consent decree entered in Illinois versus Chicago, the only component of city government to do so. Through the end of our third quarter, we received 6,481 intakes through emails, hotline calls, and our web portal letters, referrals, walk-ins, and our devoted O'Hare 21 tip line. We have 249 open criminal and administrative misconduct investigations, and we have closed 86 investigations this year to date. Among those closed cases, are those representing more rigorous enforcement of the city's ethics rules than ever before of the cases in the last 10 years, wherein O I G has successfully pursued a finding of probable cause from the Board of ethics, nearly a third of those have been in 2023 alone. Meanwhile, we've invested in advanced investigative training to ensure that our investigators are equipped with the most relevant skills. We've strengthened existing relationships and built new ones with our law enforcement partners at the state, county, and federal levels to date in 2023, our public safety section has published eight reports on programmatic inquiries into the Chicago Police Department and the police accountability agencies. The topics of those inquiries included CPDs enforcement of its rules against lying and its rules requiring members to report misconduct, as well as CP D'S search warrant practices. The public safety section has examined 1035 closed disciplinary investigations conducted by the Bureau of Internal Affairs and the Civilian Office of Police Accountability, and recommended the reopening of 10 materially deficient disciplinary investigations in 2023. Our audit and program review section has published six reports on performance audits and follow-up inquiries, examining efficiency and effectiveness in city programs, including recycling requirement enforcement, and outreach to unhoused encampment residents. We've also sent more than half a dozen advisories and notifications to city departments raising programmatic concerns, including the city's compliance with the law, requiring the appointment of an administrative officer for the City, city Council transitions and procedural fairness in disciplinary processes. Further, we have continued to meet and report on our obligations under the city's hiring and employment plans to ensure that in the post shackman era, the city follows the rules in making fair and transparent hiring and promotion decisions. Our information portal where we render city data transparent and available to the public, has received more than 101,909 page views by nearly 21,217 users. Both of these numbers have more than doubled from last year. Looking ahead to 2024, we are finally equipped and staffed to shorten our investigative timelines so that we hold more bad actors more accountable when they break the rules. We'll continue to pursue wide-reaching proactive investigative efforts fueled by data analysis, including around P P P loan, fraud by city employees and enforcement of campaign finance rules. We'll continue to do meaningful substantive outreach to members of all of Chicago's communities, both to raise awareness about O I G and our transparency and accountability work, and to ensure that we are hearing from Chicagoans about their concerns and suggestions about city government. We will continue to pursue our budget equity goals around formalizing and documenting a diversity, equity and inclusion centered perspective of all of OIGs work, including by bringing on a new diversity, equity and inclusion director earlier this month, and expanding our recruiting efforts and opportunities to foster workforce diversity. We are also working closely with other city departments to address our critical need for a new workspace. We are out of space in our current location with more positions than workspaces, and we need better physical security to ensure that o I G staff members are safe when they come to work because we have maximized what can be done in our existing space. And because of the sensitive and confidential nature of the work that we do, we are pursuing a lease in a non-city building. I wanna provide a few updates on the information on OIGs workspace that was provided in your budget books as of yesterday. We have eight positions vacant with new employees scheduled for onboarding to fill. Three of those in additional five positions are in the posting and interviewing process in 2023. We have hired or promoted people into 43 positions as of early this month, and with updates and corrections to the information that you have, OIG G'S workforce is 18% black up 15% last year, and 16% Hispanic. Our management team is 50% female, 25% black, and 18% Hispanic. The recommendation for OIG G'S 2024 budget is essentially flat to the 2023 budget other than increases in personnel costs, attendant to the city's reorganization of salary schedules based on current information, O I G will be funded next year above the mandatory minimum percentage of the city's budget set out in the municipal code. I look forward to the challenges the next year will bring and to working in partnership with all of you in pursuit of a city government that more closely resembles the one Chicagoans deserve. Thank you for your time. I look forward to your questions. Thank you. Director Weisberg. Uh, uh, hold on. Al, miss Rosado, Could you think we could waive everybody's opening statement? We have 'em in writing. Do we have to take five minutes for everybody to read their statement? We have 'em in writing. Would that be okay with you and the rest of the members? Um, we would like for them to give their opening statements at this point. Um, we'll be, we'll be okay. Okay. Well, we got 'em in writing, so yeah. Lunch isn't until, isn't until once now. Worry about lunch. So we've got a little time, so we'll, we'll be all right Nick. We'll be okay. I'll, I'll use my Joey host Suzu Voice, and I thought it was a good idea. Should I, should I? You could proceed. Steve. Uh, good morning, Mr. Chairman Irvin and honorable members of the Committee on Budget and Government Operations. I appreciate the opportunity to address you now in our 36th year, the Board of Ethics administers interprets and enforces Chicago's governmental ethics ordinance. We promote integrity, transparency, and accountability and city government by giving thousands of pieces of confidential advice each year, educating city employees and officials, vendors, lobbyists, and others, subject to the ordinance, regulating their conduct and enforcing the ordinance by adjudicating cases involving apparent violations of it. The board has five major program areas. The first is education. To date, 82% of the city's workforce, 54% of the city's appointed officials, 21 city council members, and all 854 registered lobbyists have completed their required 2023 online ethics training programs, which our board creates and administers. The deadline for officials and employees is before January the first of 2024. Violators are subject to daily $250 fines, and to having their names and violations made public. This year, we found 152 employees and officials in violation of the law for failing to complete their 2023 online training as required, and find them a total of $3,250. All new 2024, uh, training programs, one for employees and elected officials, one for appointed officials, and the third for lobbyists, uh, will be available in early 2024. And in early 2024. We will resume face-to-face classes for the approximately 3,600 city employees and officials that are required to complete them once every four years. Classes, obviously were suspended during the pandemic. We revise all of our educational programs annually, and by law, they all cover sexual harassment. We also offer personalized training for community groups, ward offices, vendors, city and city departments upon request. We also publish 35 educational guides on our website, and we revise these regularly in 2023. So far, we have published two new guides in 2024. We intend to produce ethics training videos in conjunction with the mayor's office and focus more on public outreach, offering speakers for neighborhood meetings and ward nights citywide. Second important program is confidential guidance, in my opinion, having been at this job now for more than 30 years, the most effective way to prevent misconduct and foster a culture of ethical conduct is to enable and encourage persons to seek confidential advice before they act. Thus, our advisory function when coupled with regular education is our most critical responsibility. Since October of 2022, uh, one year ago, we've issued 4,397 advisory opinions. That's a 26% increase over the same period one year ago. Three quarters of these went to city personnel. As a footnote, we issued the most to city council, then followed by the mayor's office, and third to the Chicago Police Department. 15% went to lobbyists or potential lobbyists, and the remainder went to attorneys, contractors, candidates, and campaign contributors. We also issued several seven formal opinions as required by law. We published formal opinions on our website with confidential information redacted out, which is a common practice among government ethics agencies. We have a searchable index and a summary of all 925 plus formal opinions ever issued by the board since its inception as an executive order board in 1986. It includes links to all opinions, full text. Most of the opinions, however, that we issue, the vast majority of them are informal. They're all confidential, and persons who receive board opinions can rely upon them in the event of an investigation. We work with other city departments and sister agencies on their own conflicts of interest or gift policies. We also meet regularly with ethics officers from our sister agencies and other government agencies, such as the C T A, the Chicago Public Schools, the city coun, the Chicago City Colleges, c h a Park District, cook County Assessor's Office, and the Cook County Board of Ethics. To discuss matters of mutual concern, the board continues to work on a package of amendments to the governmental ethics ordinance, which will be submitted to the mayor and the city council in the next few months. Third program is financial disclosure, 4,025. Employees and officials have already filed annual statements of financial interests for 2023. We distribute, collect, and make these forms publicly available going back seven years. Additionally, all candidates for a city elected office were required to file these forms. We contacted all candidates proactively and posted their forms on our website for 2023. We found 62 employees and officials in violation of the law for failure to timely file, assessed $16,750 in fines, and made their names, violations and fines public as required by law for 2024. We will continue to work with our ethics liaisons in every department and ward office and City Council committee to ensure a maximum compliance. Someday, perhaps we'll reach a zero violation level possible. Next program that we have is lobbying regulation. All individuals who lobby city personnel must register with the board annually. There is a $350 annual registration fee and a $75 client fee for every client after the first the board. However, waives by law all fees for individuals who lobby on behalf of not-for-profit organizations. Currently, 854 lobbyists are registered. We've collected $391,425 in fees since October of 2022, a year ago. 36. Were determined to have violated the ordinance for failure to timely file their re-registration or their activity reports, and we find them, uh, collectively, uh, three thousand three thousand two hundred and fifty dollars. Uh, last basic program is enforcement. Uh, there are several types of enforcement that the board engages in. The first is adjudications of Inspector General Investigations. Since October, 2022, the board, the O I G, has submitted seven completed investigations to the board. As my colleague has mentioned, in four of these, uh, the board has found probable cause. Three of these are awaiting a finding of probable cause. The subjects will meet with the board to attempt to reverse the board's finding of probable cause. Uh, there is lots of information, uh, about these matters that is posted on our website, so I won't get into the specifics of it. Uh, we will post something later today because as probably a lot of you're aware, the board met yesterday and the board meeting went late. But we will post more information on all of these matters later on our website. Uh, there are also board generated enforcement actions. The board finds probable cause in confidence where evidence made available to it al or already in the public domain, indicates that the governmental ethics ordinance appears to have been violated, but no factual investigation is required. After making that finding, which is not a finding of violation, the board affords the subject the right to attempt to rebut it. If that finding is not rebutted, the board can find violations and publicly settle the matter for fines or if no settlement is reached, make its determination public and impose fines. But all board determinations are appealable to the Cook County Circuit Court. Since October of 2022, the board has handled 58 such cases, and there is lots of information available on our website about the nature of those cases. Again, however, the board is unable to mention names by law until there is a final determination of a violation. Penalties for persons who are found to have violated the governmental ethics ordinance as of September of 2022, our $20,000 per violation last, uh, campaign financing database. As my colleague mentioned, the board of ethics and the Inspector General are involved in enforcing the governmental ethics ordinance campaign contribution limitations. I'm proud to say that in January of this year, the board working closely, very closely with the mayor's office and City Age Sister Agency personnel, rolled out a significantly enhanced database of persons who have done business with the city and or its named sister agencies, to aid candidates, elected officials and their campaign staff in identifying persons who are subject to the limits on political contributions in the governmental ethics ordinance. Detailed information about all of these enforcement matters, including minor violations, as well as the guide to board enforcement procedures are posted on our website and updated regularly. And I welcome your questions. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, director Berlin. Uh, next up we're going to have a, uh, quick financial overview, uh, of both departments by, uh, Kofa Chairman. Hello, chairman Irvin, vice Chair Lee, members of the board. My name is Daniel Fris Drumm. I am with the City Council Office of Financial Analysis, and we are gonna do a quick overview of the Office of Inspector General. So we have, uh, 14.2 million for the F Y 24 proposed budget. That's 1.179 million more than the revised f Y 23 budget. Uh, in the proposed FFY 24 budget, there are allocations for 124 positions. This is a decrease of one position compared to F Y 23. So the primary factor of contributing to the F Y 24 budget expansion would be personnel services category, which is set to grow by 1.79 million, representing a 9% increase compared to the revised F Y 23 budget. And if we look at the F by funds, these are, this is all derived from local funds. There is no grants. Uh, most of the funding total totaling 73.6% is derived from the corporate fund for FY 24. This represents a 9.25% increase compared to the revised F y 23 budget. With that, I will turn it over to our acting director, Janice Oda Gray. Thank you so much, Daniel. Again, my name is Janice Oda Gray, and I am going to be discussing a departmental overview for the Board of Ethics. Okay. Board of ethics, we have your fiscal year 24 proposed budget, 1.02 million of that 1.02 million. That's approximately $103,266 more than the revised fiscal year 23 budget. They have eight budgeted positions, and it's flat. Uh, they have no increases, same eight, no additions, no subtract. The funds are derived from personnel. $960,714 and nine personnel is a $59,111. All funding is derived from the corporate fund, representing little over 11% increase compared to the revised fiscal year 23 budget. Again, looking at the funding type, it's a hundred percent corporate funding, so there's not much to say there. Looking at F T E, uh, for F T E for 2024, there was an average F T E calculated. It's approximately 1 27 0.5 per f t e, and there's not a whole lot to say here either. I mean, they, their budget is kind of a financial person's dream. And this very last sheet is the same one I just talked about, so I don't have to go through that again. So that's it for this first segment from kofa. Thank you. Thank you. Uh, we will open around the questions with, uh, chair Martin, uh, chair of the committee on, uh, governmental ethics chair, Martin Proceed. Thank you, chair. Appreciate it. And good morning, uh, to the two of you and your, your teams really appreciate working with you in my new role, but also during my time in office. I think both of you are doing a terrific job, uh, steering your respective departments, albeit, uh, for different tenures of time. Um, uh, a few questions. Uh, I'll start with, uh, uh, the Office of Inspector General. Um, I noticed in reviewing the D budget documents that, uh, you highlighted a, a restructuring of the office's intake function. I think that's, uh, going to think really come to fruition in this final quarter of 2023. Um, how do you envision the restructuring improving the intake process, and do you think it could help reduce, um, uh, the existing backlog in particular for cases that are lasting for over a year? I appreciate the question. Uh, chair. The intake function at O I G historically has been a, a, a production of our investigations section, which is to say that when we have received information, we've cast a sort of binary lens on it. And the question we have asked when a piece of information comes through the door is whether or not it is su susceptible to either administrative or criminal investigation of misconduct. That is sort of where the intake inquiry historically has ended. Um, that has, from my perspective, left a lot of oversight opportunities on the table. We practice many different kinds of oversight within o I g under one roof. That's, that is sort of our inst our institutional and structural advantage, um, that as represented by the, the fine folks in the box here. We do many different kinds of things. And so we have situated our intake function kind of at the hub of the wheel so that when we get information in the door, we are better equipped to either find or build the best oversight hammer for each nail. And so if something comes in that looks like a misconduct investigation, then we send it to our investigation section. If something looks like a prompt for a programmatic inquiry about efficiency, uh, or effectiveness, we send that to our audit and program review section. We send police related matters to our public safety section. We send data transparency analysis questions to our, to our data section. And so in that way, I think we are more effectively capitalizing on our resources and we're doing the work in the, in the place and with the skills best suited to, to address each issue. Thank you for that. And I wanna compliment, um, in particular the people on your team who are working on the public facing dashboards, I find find those to be incredibly helpful, and especially with regard to public safety related conversations. I think your dashboard complimented by what the University of Chicago's Crime Lab has done, um, is very helpful as we look to get information out to people as we have constructive conversations around public safety. So please keep that up. Thank you. Um, also was curious, um, uh, I think your office has mentioned in the recent past, exploring the possibility of creating a recommendation tracker, um, where the public could visit the website and clearly see which recommendations and particular audits and reports have been complied with, similar to the consent decree tracker that is currently up. Curious what, uh, what, if any progress has been made with that? We continue to look at this, and I know that, that you and I talked a little bit about this at last year's hearing. Um, we are, we, we do follow ups on implementations of our recommendations in standalone reports. So when we make recommendations to a city department, we get responses to those recommendations. We then follow up usually about a year, sometimes a little, a little longer later to see what the implementation status of those is. And then we publish a follow-up report, so the information on the status of our recommendations is available in the form of those follow-up reports. But it is not all visible, all in one place at a, sort of, at your fingertips, uh, in, in a sort of at your fingertips kind of format. That is something that we continue to, to look at doing. And as we expand our dashboard work with our newly independent center of information and technology, excuse me, information technology and analytics, um, that is the sort of thing which I think we are better equipped to do, do we have some case management system challenges, which I think may improve on the kind of medium term horizon. So I, I continue to, to share the view that that would be valuable and, and we will continue to look for a way to do that. Great. Uh, director Berlin, a few quick questions for you. Um, uh, first, with regard to lobbying, um, uh, my committee, uh, your team, people at the law department and elsewhere have worked a lot in recent months around revisiting the issue of nonprofit lobbying, and whether it's, uh, passing something that's revised working to, um, more aggressively enforce what's currently on the books. We know that, um, going into next year, that, uh, your, your department will be doing more work around, uh, lobbying generally, and nonprofits in particular. I'm curious, um, how you feel that might affect your office's workload and how you are feeling, um, what is in this proposal in terms of positions, uh, how that would help you, um, uh, address, uh, a ramp up, uh, in compliance related work? Thank you, Mr. Chair. That's a very good question. Uh, the short answer is that we can handle it with current staff. Um, the longer answer is that, uh, one of our longtime staffers, in fact, just about everybody in our office, is a longtime staffer is retiring at the end of the year, and he is our main, uh, lobbyist data person. So we are in the process of having him do a brain download to a number of our other staffers so that we can handle the, uh, increased number of lobbyists that we expect. Now, how much do we expect in terms of, uh, not-for-profits? That remains to be seen, but, uh, I will tell you that, uh, years ago, uh, going back about 20 years, we actually had more registered lobbyists than we have now, although we had a slightly bigger staff. Uh, most of the work though, is going to come in education because the, uh, not-for-profit community is going to need, uh, a number of guides that we will provide both electronically, and we will make ourselves available to attend meetings to explain the requirements about, uh, filling out the registration forms and filling out the activity reports to try to minimize confusion. So in other words, what it, what it comes down to is the bulk of the work that we expect is going to be educational as opposed to actually regulatory. This is all abuse, uh, but we are prepared for it, and we are preparing for it. Great. Um, my last question is a follow up on that to get a better understanding, and if this is easier to provide for the chair, that's fine. Um, of, I think the, the eight staff members, I, I'm curious how many focus on outward public facing work along the lines of what you just described. And, uh, as we head into 2024, if you see whether it's with existing folks or working with other departments, um, additional work that needs to be done with videos, tutorials, and other things to continue, I think, uh, using our different, uh, uh, tools that are at our disposal to get the information out around what compliance looks like. Yes. Uh, currently on our website, at least for lobbyists, we have a number of guides to filling out the forms, but they're in PowerPoint. Um, what we intend to do is convert those to, um, videos in some fashion. Um, I'm also pleased to say that in the box, uh, is our newest hire, Delina Bailey, and Delina is, uh, program director and Delina is going to be assisting us with, uh, community outreach. So all of you will receive communications, uh, from Delina. We are gonna be happy to present at your ward nights. Uh, if there are not-for-profits in your ward that are, that have questions about whether their people have to register, we will make ourselves absolutely available to answer their questions. Great. Thank you. That's all I have, chair. Thank you. Thank you both. Thank you. Uh, chair. Uh, Martin, uh, my apologies. Uh, we forgot to introduce all of you, the members from your respective departments that are in the box, if you all can introduce the members and as they, uh, introduce you, if you could please stand, We go First. Sure. Uh, we have Tabba Richardson, who is our Deputy Inspector General for public Safety. Kayla Vasquez is our Chief Administrative Officer. George Lauder is our Deputy Inspector General for investigations. Nate Ackman is our general counsel. Eloise Markham is our Director of Personnel Services. Deanna Shaws is our Director of outreach and communications. Michelle Wright is our Diversity, equity, and inclusion Director. Melissa Vela is our Deputy Inspector General for information Technology and analytics. Darwin Jones is Deputy Inspector General for Audit and program review. Raul Valdez is Director of Special Investigations. Javier Santoyo is our financial officer, and I think that's everybody. And, um, Steve, You have no one Sitting in the box is, uh, Doha Jackson, assistant to the director. Uh, Doha is our main budget person. Uh, Lisa Eilers is our deputy director, and Delina Bailey is our program director. Thank you. Uh, thank you much. Um, two other items. Uh, number one, uh, we need a motion to allow for Alder Rodriguez Sanchez to participate remotely. Um, she has a qualifying, uh, a qualifying item under Rule 59. Uh, so we entertain a motion for that. So move alder Mitch. Uh, all in favors sign signify by Saint Aye. Any opposed? Any opinion of the cha? The aye have it, uh, Alder Alder Rodriguez Sanchez will be able to join, uh, remotely. Secondly, uh, I want to, uh, very rarely we get little ones in here, so we wanna welcome, uh, baby Alexander, uh, to our hearings today. And I see all the woman Nugent is, um, filling, I guess maternal today. So, uh, so we wanna welcome, welcome them to, uh, welcome them to Chambers. So, uh, very well, alderman Napolitano. Thank you. Mr. Uh, thank you, sir. Uh, just a quick point of, uh, information. Do we need to do a role ourselves? No, I, I've already taken care of that. Perfect. Thanks sir. You guys are good. Uh, alderman, uh, Mitchell followed by Alderman. Um, you good? Okay. Alderman, uh, osha, uh, please lemme know if you have questions for yg. Thanks, chairman. I'd like to point out that, um, Steve Berlin has never, ever had a short answer in the history of his time. I say that affectionately Steve, uh, appreciate, uh, your assistance and guidance these past, uh, several years during my time. Uh, I think I speak for everybody here. Uh, you are a true professional. I hope that, um, you got a challenge ahead. You with so many, uh, staff, uh, retiring, I hope that, um, you're able to recruit people that are just as effective as who you, you currently have. Thank you. Um, inspector, um, you, this isn't a new problem. Um, your staff outgrowing your space. This is, this has been an issue for a couple years, and, um, I think it's important that whatever space the Inspector General's office is in, it's separate from other departments, it's separate from, um, is not as accessible as, uh, other, we would want other departments who wouldn't want you in our building. Um, where are you at with identifying space, and do you feel that the city's doing enough to help accommodate that? I appreciate this question, alderman. I appreciate the opportunity to, to talk a little bit about this issue. You're right that we have had space challenges for the last number of years, and for the last number of years, we have, um, I think spent and not invested a fair amount of money in wring out the last drops of utility in our current city space. We are at the end of that rope. We have more people than workspaces. Um, and we have, I think, plainly inadequate security, both for our people and for our confidential work. Um, and so in terms of where we are early this year, we began a process with a i s of evaluating space options. A i s went through a process to identify a broker, which is used by the city. They identified a broker. We've met with those people, um, to identify some potential spaces. We've taken a look at some potential spaces, which are for lease and non-city buildings. Um, so I think that we are making, we are making a lot of progress. Um, I, in terms of what, you know, what we need, that there will obviously be a cost associated with a lease where we do not have leasing costs for our main space. Now, um, from my perspective, we, we need that to do our work in a safe and effective way. I wholeheartedly agree with you that separation from other city departments is really important. Um, we need physical security in a way that I think is different and differentiated from some of our partner departments. Um, and I have real concerns about our being in a city space where when the water pours through the ceiling and sometimes the water pours through the ceiling, we have city employees in our workspace where we also have confidential investigative material. Um, I would, I would very much like to see us in a leased space in a non-city building, which is appropriately secure, both for our work and for our employees. Well, I, um, myself and others here would wanna make sure that that is, um, a pressing issue, um, that other people in, in city government, uh, feel we need to get that done at a faster pace, um, to all of, uh, your staff, uh, in the box. Thank you for the important work that you do. Uh, no further questions. Thank you. Uh, alderman Oe, uh, I, I guess that raises a point. Um, so you, you all are currently where We are at seven 40 North Sedgwick. That's, oh, that's the other side of Florida Superior, correct? Correct. Okay. And, and you all have outgrown the space. The space is not meeting the needs of today, and your desire is to go to a non-city, uh, lease space. Um, how have you found something or where, where you, We have just as of last week viewed a couple of potential options, and a i s is in the process of, um, asking questions and kind of honing those options. So we're just in the midst of that process now. Okay. And you anticipate that happening this year, and has there been, and I, and I don't know the answer to this, has there been an allocation in this budget to facilitate that? Or is that something that you're asking for in addition to what is, uh, what's in the budget current In terms of timeline for the move? You know, my preference would be yesterday. Um, I think realistically with the way that leases for the city go through a city council process, I think that early next, early 2024 is, is a both realistic and desirable goal in terms of timeline for allocation. Uh, there is not a budget line item in OIGs budget, which is, which is, but for personnel costs flat to last year. Um, this, the anticipation of this cost has been included in the finance general category. Oh, okay. Very well, that was my, that was, I was trying to understand if we already, uh, pushed, pushed this, uh, out. Okay. Very well. Uh, what did I just do? Okay. Uh, next is, uh, vice Chair Lee. Thank You, chairman. Followed by Alderman mi. Any other, uh, questions? I, I have you, I have you. I have you got it? Okay. Thank you, chairman. Good morning. Um, inspector General Wisberg and Director Berlin. It's nice to see you both here. Um, appreciate all the really important work that you both do. Um, I think I call Steve a little bit more than I call you. That's probably not a bad thing. Probably good news. Uh, it's probably, it's probably the way it's supposed to work. Um, mm-hmm. I've got, I've got a couple of questions. I'll start with you. Um, inspector General Berg. Um, I know that you re very recently, you mentioned this in your opening, uh, remarks, um, just recently filled, um, three of those positions. Uh, and you've got, and how many positions open now? We have a total of, I believe we, this is, this is a little fuzzy because we had some folks start yesterday. Um, but as of yesterday, um, we have eight positions vacant with people scheduled to feel free of those people already in the onboarding process for three Of them. So still need to hire five then? That's right. And those are in various stages of the posting and interviewing process. That's great. Um, would it be possible through the chair, just, I know this is like a point in time sort of thing, and these documents and the budget documents where as of September 29th, so you've had a lot happen between, um, September 29th and now. So it'd be great if we can get like an updated, um, an updated, uh, org chart. Do you know, and again, this is not available now, but through the chair, um, what the, what this is reflect, what budget, um, sort of good guys are there as a result of you having these open recs, um, for most of the year. So how much money was saved by your department as a result of not filling those positions until later in the year? I see. So in last year's budget, we can certainly provide more specifics, but I can give you sort of an, an overview of that. In last year's budget, we added 10 new positions. So we had very significant additional personnel costs last year. Those were to reflect my initiatives, kind of coming in in a new administration to restructure the office a bit. We, we got those positions in our budget, um, but we had a salvage amount of approximately $750,000. And so in order to salvage that amount, we had, we staggered both new hires and refilling of the vacancies that we had at the beginning of last budget year over very nearly the entirety of 2023. And so that's why it was only in the third quarter Gotcha. That we were able to kind of bring all those people on. Okay. Understood. That makes sense. Um, uh, as far as the, the vacancies that you've been filling in this in the last month here, um, did that have any sort of real effect on the, the efficiency of your office? Is there a back, has there been a backlog of cases because of the open positions? The short answer is yes. Okay. There's been a backlog of investigations. Um, we report each quarter, both to you and to the public and to the mayor, uh, on all O I G investigations, which have been opened more than 12 months. Um, that number has been too high. Um, and it is starting to come down. Uh, it has been too high for a number of reasons, including, although not limited to inadequate staffing. So we have more staffing and investigations. We've added an investigative team and restructured the invest, the investigation section management. Um, and, and while those things have only been sort of finalized in the third quarter, and of course it takes a little while to see the results. Um, we published our third quarter report on Friday. That report does show the list of year old cases beginning to shrink. That's great. And so what's the current backlog of cases? There a number that you can share with us. We have 130 investigations, which have been open 12 months or more. Okay. Um, you started to talk earlier about the restructuring of the, uh, intake process and that team. Can you talk a little bit more about how that's helped and like how much, you know, how much more that's going to make an impact, um, on the cases that you're able to review? Absolutely. I think the, the real impact that we're seeing there is, um, is that we, um, we are doing a better job of drawing on our capacities to address various problems. And so, um, I think the, the most concrete way we are seeing that begin to sort of emerge is that we are making better informed decisions about our oversight work because we are, we are doing a better job of listening when people tell us what they're worried about. Um, it seems to me that all decisions in oversight are prioritization decisions. We are never gonna get done all of the work that needs doing. And so each decision that we make, each thing that we decide to undertake has an opportunity cost. It means we don't do something else, and we are best serving our mission when we make those prioritization decisions in a way that is as well-informed as possible, um, by the real concerns of, of Chicagoans. So now that we have built intake to be a better listening device, we are doing a better job of selecting things to look into, shaping our inquiries to get at not those things which are most susceptible to measurement, but rather those things which have the greatest impact on, on real people. And we are ensuring we are doing a better job of ensuring that the results of our work get into the hands of stakeholders and decision makers. Great. Thank you. Um, just to piggyback on your last just line of comments here, um, about prioritization, right? So does your office prioritize, um, complaints that may be time sensitive? Like if it's with candidates or competitive bid process? Can you get, talk to us a little bit about how that prioritization happens? Yes. The prioritization exercise is, is not an empirical one, sort of many. It's, it's a case by case decision. And there are many factors. Um, we certainly take into consideration. And, and I should also say this varies a bit across kinds of inquiries. So we, we make different kinds of prioritization decisions in misconduct investigations than in performance audits, than in police oversight work. But these sorts of considerations that go in, um, really have to do with where we can have the most impact. I often talk about the fact that in my view, the city of Chicago operates at a deficit of legitimacy with Chicagoans. And so we try to prioritize that work, which enables us to pay down that deficit fastest. That is by doing the work, which most impacts people, um, getting at the problems which most feed mistrust and distrust in city government. Thank you for that. I don't have, uh, just two, two more. Maybe one more. Um, just looking at the, at the budget this year, um, the highest spends on software maintenance and licensing, um, are the Department of Technology and Innovation, office of the Public Safety Administration, board of Elections, city clerk, and then the O I G at over a million, uh, across various funds. That's approximately $11,600 for each of the 90 employees. Do you know why they're, the spend is so high? Our spend includes not only information technology and infrastructure for our own use, but also the infrastructure for our information portal. So for our data transparency work, our IT infrastructure is in, is independent from the rest of the city. Okay. Um, and so that is, you're seeing that included in our, in our costs. Okay. Thank you. Um, Steve, I think I've got one question for you. If I've got time to, um, uh, line item 3 0 9 2 program director has a pay increase of over 50%. Can you tell, talk to us about, um, the, the rather drastic increase in that position? Sure. That position was actually vacant, um, until we hired delina, and Delina started on September the first. So congratulations. Um, and Delina came over from the Department of Family and Support Services. Gotcha. So that explains the, um, the huge increase. All right. Prepare a huge increase, but actually, uh, currently we have no vacancies, although, as I mentioned, we do have a predicted expected vacancy at the end of the year. All right. Thank you very much, both of you. Thank you. Uh, vice Chair Lee, uh, we will have autumn, mi, fall, Autum and Riley. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and good morning to every, each and every one of you. Um, I wanna start off by asking, um, Mr. Chairman, I'm missing something. The organization chart, if we can ask each department to provide that information, it usually help me with these budget process just to know who and the pastor inform on the staff. Sometime they do change and they're not the same. So it's a chart they usually pass out when they give the statement. I don't see the chart. The, uh, I'm just requesting it through the chair. The chart's in, in the book. Okay. The big book. Okay. Yeah. So why did they, uh, stop putting it on this sheet? Is it is just been practical. I think every, all of them are all in this big book. We have now every department's, their organization charts are in here. Okay. Uh, with, with a bunch of other frequently asked information of each department. All. Let me go onto my questions. Um, inspector General, you talked about the P P P loans in your report. Do you have a sense at all of, um, through the departments, the number that from various departments that have been you're looking at? We don't have a set a clear view at this point by department of how many cases we will pursue. What, what I can say, what we sort of, where we are so far, um, is that we have, we are doing both reactive and proactive oversight work with respect to city employees, city actors who have taken P P P loans. That is to say we are both responding to and investigating complaints that we get as usual in a reactive posture. We are also doing proactive data analysis to, on our own, identify potential misconduct by examining the, the available data on recipients of P P P loans. So in that proactive data analysis effort, we began with the pool of data from the federal government on approximately 350,000 P P P loans that were issued, um, through a, an analysis process kind of matching, bumping up that list of 350,000 loans with city actors under our jurisdiction. We arrived at a pool of approximately a thousand P P P loans that have been issued to individuals and entities under OIGs jurisdiction. Um, many though not all of those loans have some indicia of potential fraud. Um, we will frankly not pursue a thousand investigations to the sort of prioritization questions that we discussed with, uh, with Alderwoman Lee a moment ago. Um, but we will pursue many of them, um, and we will pursue them both administratively and criminally, which is to say some of those cases we will pursue as personnel rule violations, um, and potentially ethics ordinance violations as well around, uh, reporting of financial interests and others of them we are pursuing, uh, with our law enforcement partners as criminal cases. So what's your timeline? Do you have a timeline? Um, how much have you completed versus how much you need to? The quarterly report that we issued on Friday includes the first reportable outcome from that work. Um, there are many more to come. Uh, frankly, this is a long-term effort, uh, because of the scale. So I, I don't have a clearer sense than that, although I, I do anticipate, um, there, you know, I I anticipate they're continuing to be reportable outcomes as we move forward. As there was in our report last week, And you talked about the number of, of incidents that you investigate, what would be, um, your top three findings within the city departments? Um, in terms of sort of categories of misconduct? Yes. Well, I, I would say I've, I've talked a bit about this, um, and, and I actually appreciate the opportunity to, to share the diocese with Director Berlin here. Um, ethics ordinance ethics investigations are, are our priority, um, railing against unethical behavior in city government is not as good as enforcing the rules against it. And so, while I, I do not think historically ethics investigations have been a priority for O I G. They are a priority for us now, and they will be one going forward that it is, it is by enforcing the city's ethics rules that we will get a city government, which more closely resembles the one Chicagoans deserve. You also mentioned that you have, um, increase your participation this year since the last two years. What are some of the, um, um, what, what were some of the most important items that you worked on since the last two years that you are very proud of? I appreciate that question. Uh, on the, on the investigative front, um, that we have successfully enforced the rules against the abuse of public, the abuse of the public trust, the abuse of, of positions of power. I'm proud of that. That's what we're here to do, um, elsewhere in our oversight work. I'm deeply proud of the work we have done in our public safety section, both with respect to members of the Chicago Police Department who associate with hate groups. Um, and with respect to the enforcement of CPDs rule against lying. We, we cannot ask people to trust a police department that lets its members get away with lying. And, um, and I, I believe in, and I'm proud of the work we've done on that issue. Okay. Um, I have a question for Copa. Um, when we talked about cultural, give me your definition of cultural policing when you, when you were looking in terms of the, So that one, that'll be in our next session. Oh, okay. Um, Steve, I wanted to tell you that I think that you're doing an excellent job. It seems like every time we take the, um, ethics statements, I find a little something interesting that you done put in something new to make sure that we keep eyes, uh, aware of and knowing that, um, connecting the city and the state law as well. So, um, I'm very proud of the work that's being done and to keep it reiterated in us so that we can, uh, also make sure we abide by the rules as well. So, um, those are my questions, so thank you very much and I appreciate it. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Alder Mitch. Um, we will have, um, alderman Riley followed by Alderman, uh, Nugent. Uh, and I see that the Alderman hats caught the fever as well, so, um, we'll see you all in a few months. So, um, alderman Riley, Uh, thank you Chairman. Uh, good morning. Good morning. Um, like my colleagues, I have nothing but praise for both of you and your, your, uh, staff. You do important work for the city of Chicago, and I only have a couple of questions. Um, with regard to the Inspector General's office, I'm just trying to get a sense of, um, division of labor. You, you have a full plate. Um, you have areas that you spend a lot of time in, certainly audits or of particular interest to me. Um, but if you had to kind of divide that up into a pie graph, how much time are you, I know where your resources are allocated as far as salaries, but how much time are you spending on audits versus investigating criminal misconduct abuse versus C P d, best practices versus diversity equity? How, how does that all kind of shake out in the day-to-day at the igs office? Well, This is, I think in a, in a very good news story, hard to say in a concrete way because I think we are doing a better job than ever before at approaching all of those things in an interdisciplinary way, so that when we are conducting police misconduct investigations, we are drawing on the expertise of our police oversight staff. And when we are conducting performance audits, we are doing so with the input and insights of our data analysts. And so in terms of exactly as you say, dividing up the dollars in a pie chart kind of way, we have f t e equivalents that you can see by section. I think as a practical matter, in a day-to-day level, we spend more time together doing work across sections than ever before. And I think that that's really good news for the impact and the quality of the output. Very good. Um, I, in terms of subject matter, if I could just, sorry, please didn't mean to interrupt you had had one quickly. No, Please. Um, both our audit and program review section and our public safety section go through an annual planning exercise where they publish a list of potential proposed projects for the following year. And we post those drafts for public comment so that we can hear from all of you and all of your constituents on which things interest you most in terms of allocating those frankly finite oversight resources. Both of those draft documents will go up sometime in the next month or so. So I would absolutely welcome your feedback on them, feedback from your constituents. We would be happy to come out to your wards and talk about those documents, and more importantly, to listen to the insights of your constituents. So, um, please, please look for those. Appreciate that. And actually, uh, it kind of segues into my next question about outreach and engagement, but, um, if, if those are coming out in the next month or so, I'm sure my colleagues and I would love to help promote those with our constituents and stakeholders. We will take you up on that. Um, Thank you. And as far as outreach and engagement goes, you know, most of the folks here know exactly what you do, and this applies to both board of ethics and, and the inspector General's office. And I know that both of you, um, and your organizations have a mission in the coming year to improve on those efforts and get deeper into communities and raise your profile a bit so people know you exist as a resource. Um, that's kind of the stuff we're pretty good at too. Um, how do you plan, I guess I'll ask each of you separately, but how, in a short answer, Steve, how, how do you plan on executing that plan for 2024 for outreach and engagement? Um, are there areas you're gonna focus on more than you did last year? Um, how are you gonna go about doing that? I mean, I, I see that you referenced each of you in your narratives. You want to, you know, make better use of social media and these sorts of things. I'd like to see a, a higher visibility for each of your offices, and I'm not seeing quite as much as I would hope. Um, could you speak to that briefly? Sure. Uh, in our case, it would not be social media. I think our social media presence is, is, is pretty good as it is. There's, I don't see any great reason to expand it. What I do see a great reason to expand is to have our staff, um, come to your ward nights, for example. Um, if there's a particular community group that has reached out to you that, or, or reaches out to us, we would like to coordinate with each of the 50 of you. And we can do this in Chicago public library facilities, or we can do it in a space that you have for us to come out and meet with your constituents or, or certain groups of your constituents. So it really, in our case, we'd like it to be face-to-face. Got it. Good to know. Effective outreach and engagement is the lifeblood of the work we do. Many of you have heard me say that I will go anywhere where invited and some places we're not to talk about our work and to listen to what we should listen to people's thoughts about what we should be working on. Um, our work is only as impactful as we are effective at talking about it. We cannot do transparency work in secret, and accountability only matters if, if people are there to see it. And so we take outreach and engagement really seriously. I take the fact that we have a steadily increasing number of intakes as a very good sign in terms of people's awareness of us and how to get ahold of us. We, um, we are doing in-person outreach at events like ward nights and farmer's markets across the city. We are partnering with other, other city departments. We are doing, um, we have, um, awareness materials in English and Spanish on c t a buses and trains. Um, we have for the first time this year, so we, we, we map our community engagement. So we, we keep track geographically across the city of which areas, which community areas we are touching in our in-person and virtual outreach events. So this year for the first time, we, we looked at that map and identified some gaps in places in the city we haven't yet reached. And so as of the middle of last month, and this was in part I'll say in response to a question from Alderman Taylor, alderman Taylor at last year's budget hearing, um, we have billboards up for the first time that say, you know, your city, please contact o i g with concerns and suggestions and has our contact information. Um, I, I hope to do more of that, frankly, 'cause I think it's an effective way for us to reach people we haven't reached before for the moment. Um, those new billboards are in wards, 6, 8, 9, 17, 21, 23, and 38. Excellent. You might want to consider a couple in the central business district 'cause that's where so many folks are during the workday. Absolutely. To help with exposure. And the other thing I would just add, and I I'm gonna press this on pretty much every department this year, is that, um, you know, the broadcast stations in town as well as Comcast make available a tremendous amount of airtime for public service announcements and that's free. Um, so zero fiscal impact to the city. Um, I've suggested this for a few years now. I'm not really sure we've made a lot of headway, but with departments like CDOT and others that are, you know, public facing and, and have lots of important information to share, I think someone at the city, and it's doesn't fall on your departments per se, but someone at the city needs to do a better job engaging with our broadcast partners because frankly, there's free airtime for us to push all this really important information out for free. So, um, I had just one subject matter question. It's for you, Steve. Um, and it came up in a conversation I was just having the other day. Um, do registered lobbyists have a legal obligation to report city hall corruption or illegal activity to the board of ethics if they personally witness it? The, an the short answer is no. The longer answer is they should, and we will recommend that a number of years ago when that provision was added, it first covered only city employees and city officials. Then, then it was extended to city vendors, um, steady contractors and subcontractors and their agents. But lobbyists are not yet covered. And, um, that's one of the recommendations that we'll be making to the city council. Why is that, Steve? Why, why aren't lobbyists currently covered? Uh, It's probably just an oversight on the part of everybody who drafted and looked at this law. So, And when was that passed? Uh, during the Emmanuel administration and, um, and then it was, um, uh, the obligation to report was amended to extend to vendors and their personnel about a year after it was initially passed. So it was part of the, um, uh, mayor Emanuel's ethics reform task force. Uh, so it was first enacted in 2012 and then it was amended in 2013. Thank you. That's all I've got. Uh, thank you for answering my questions and keep up the great work. Thank you, chairman. That's Just a very quick follow up. I apologize. Alderman Riley, I know you submitted some questions, uh, yesterday. Would you just like those answers through the chair? That's fine. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Alderman. Uh, Riley. Um, alderman Nugent. Alderman Vasquez. Sure. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, I can be very brief. I would just like to, uh, thank Director Berlin and Inspector General Wisberg for, um, all of their help. Uh, they're very good resource in the 39th Ward and, um, we're very grateful they always take our calls and provide good, good advice and counsel. So thank you very much. Thank you Autum and Nugent. Um, question, you talk about your intake steadily increasing. Is that long term to the detriment of the, what I'll call the internal audit function of the office? And if so, um, might there be a need to separate that function from the office and do something different if the intake as your community engagement increases, um, make that a, a separate arm or make that a function that's, um, done through finance or another department that deals in the area of audit then not oversight, but more audit, uh, intense stuff that you, your office does? I think the first thing that comes to mind there is that there's certainly financial auditing and performance auditing are different kinds of work and they have different roles to play. Certainly from my perspective when it comes to the performance auditing the work we do at O I G, um, quite to the contrary, I think it's very much to the benefit of that work that we hear more from more people. We are doing better informed, more engaged, more impactful performance auditing work because we are doing it in a way informed by what we hear from Chicagoans Vesquez. Thank you Chairman. Um, I'm sorry. Follow bottom Altman, Uh, Yancy. Sure. Uh, thank you. Uh, thank you both for all the amazing work you do in the interest of time. I won't go too far into how much we appreciate what y'all do. 'cause I've got a a bunch of questions more for the ig, uh, than, uh, for Steve. But I've got a question for Steve. So, um, I've had staff past and present that have had issues, um, with kind of some of the notifications and reminders, uh, when it comes to the training. And I want to thank you for your patience and understanding through some of that. Um, do you think there are perhaps other, um, tech solutions that can minimize like the missed emails? Like for example, if you weren't allowed to sign in to City of Chicago unless, you know, you got a heads up about the ethics. Have y'all thought about like, different ways besides the emails? 'cause I know I get flooded with the emails and I miss 'em as well. I just wanna get your thoughts on that. Um, I'd love to talk with you further about that. We have not actually had those discussions, but, um, it's kind of analogous to garnishing somebody's wages. Um, but I'd love to talk to you about that. Yeah, yeah. I think, I think, right. Yeah. You know, uh, 'cause I'd worked in, um, uh, different companies prior to being in government where like, even as you're trying to access, you know, immediately get the popup of like, Hey, you know, you got three days left, right. That, you know, I'm happy to, to have those discussions. It's A great idea. I know that we get those now during, uh, open enrollment for health insurance. Yeah. But I think that, uh, if we can get an ethics blip on people's screen, yeah, that Would help. I mean, you guys might not get as much revenue outta that, but I think it might be, it would help on the other end. Um, uh, so, uh, I guess, yeah, this is, this is a more general question. I, I don't want to sound pointed, but let's say when you, there are, uh, findings of violations and fines associated with them of certain amounts of funds, do those go back to corporate fund? Uh, is that, so are they, are those folks that violate in ways helping our corporate fund? I guess? Yeah. All all fees and fines that we collect go into the corporate fund, so. Got it. The board of Ethics pizza fund is self-funded. Nice. Nice. Good. Good, good. Good to know. All right. So I, um, uh, I've got a bunch for, uh, the inspector. So given, uh, the migrant crisis, we're currently finding ourselves in the amount of spending, uh, seeing some of the challenges related to like solution effectiveness, whether it's procurement hiring and shelter staffing. Are there areas you think are worthy of investigation so that we can improve how we respond to a crisis like this? And I'd say the same thing, um, as far as like data transparency about what the city's doing. I, you, you've sort of, um, front run my, my answer there. I think there are two things to say about crisis response in terms in from a good government perspective, one has to do with preparedness. Each crisis is its own adventure. But there certainly are steps that can and should be taken in the interest of preparedness. That's true for unanticipated budget needs. That's true for large scale police responses. That's true for lots of the kinds of things which foreseeably arise in municipal government. Um, we have looked at some of those preparedness questions before. We'll continue to do that. The other piece is around transparency, as you said there, um, we cannot have windowless rooms in city government and we cannot be spending tax dollars in the dark. And so from my perspective, the first step when it comes to large scale spending, for example, is to make sure that the taxpayers of the city of Chicago have a clear view into where their dollars are going and, and how effectively they're being used. Yeah. So I guess I'd follow up as well, um, not only with the funding, but let's say you've got shelter location, staffing, like all that kind of data. Um, is there, is there a concept such as being too transparent? No, is probably too straightforward an answer, but, but no, um, information about how Chicago runs belongs to Chicagoans. Yeah, no, I, I appreciate that. And I also think, like, to your point, you can't improve how you do things without looking back to see what exactly was done, both good or bad in a way to learn from it. So I just wanted to check on that. Thank you. Um, so, okay. Can you comment, um, onto investigations or are there any, uh, um, involving like how efficient the our IT and digital the city is, right? You've got different departments where they're using different technology, it's silos, it doesn't speak to each other. Like is that something that, um, your office would take on? Right. It's, it, it feels more techy, but it's also just about communication. Uh, it infrastructure across the city is, is one of the things that's reflected in our portfolio areas for our, our performance auditing work. I would be interested in your thoughts on how that does and does not manifest in the annual plan for next year. I'll also say that those kinds of IT issues and challenges are ones that come up in nearly every project we undertake with respect to the police department. We find that nearly every product coming out of our public safety section includes some discussion of, or some recommendations around the state of data collection and data storage in the city's public safety operations. Yeah. You actually were segueing into, like another question I've got because we were just at a, um, ethics committee hearing about the Rule 14. And in talking to some of the folks who were testifying, they were, uh, communicating to us how challenging it is to even get the data and information necessary to get those investigations. And similarly, we know that you're, we're using about 40% of the corporate fund into a department where we don't know how those dollars are being used and if they're being effective. So if you're going down the path of wanting to audit the, to Chicago Police Department independently, um, how would you recommend going about that? Like your departments would be involved? 'cause it, it's obviously a huge undertaking. I just wanna get thoughts around that. 'cause I do think it's necessary. Agreed. Um, and in fact both financial auditing and performance auditing to our discussion earlier, I think, I think would, would serve us well. There are structural limitations in, in data analysis in the police department because of the, the quality of the data that's collected, the completeness of the data that's collected. We have all kinds of legacy information systems built on top of each other that are poorly integrated. Those pose tremendous challenges. I will say they pose oversight challenges to us. They pose operational challenges to the police department, right? We cannot improve what we cannot study. And so the quality and the completeness of the data that's collected across our public safety operations is an area of enormous concern. So how would, I guess what I'm trying to, to get that there is, even in you stating it, the enormity of it feels very challenging, right? One wouldn't know where to go, what a framework looks like, how you even point out what the, the darkest corners are where you can't see this stuff. Um, if somebody from council were to ask like, Hey, can we get that going? Where would you start? What would that team like? Like how long would you think that would take? I Think the path forward there starts with thoughtful front-end investments. This is another area where I would draw the distinction between expenditures and investments. Yeah. Where we are paying out settlements and judgments and not improving our risk analysis strategies and our risk management approaches. Those are expenditures where we are spending money to improve data collection and record maintenance and transparency. Those are investments we should be making thoughtful front end investments. Our public safety section published a report by way of example, I think it's an important one. We published a report in, uh, an a couple of years ago about the Chicago Police Department's record maintenance records management practices, where we found that the department is, is plainly not equipped to ensure that it can meet its legal and constitutional obligations around the identification and production of records information in its own possession. That's costing the city in a big way. It's costing us dollars and it's costing us legitimacy. The solutions there. We made a series of recommendations in that report. Uh, reform takes resources. The solutions there will cost money. We should be making those investments so that we are making fewer expenditures. Yeah. If, if you could do the chair, kind of share that one. 'cause as much money as we keep putting into C P D, we should be putting into those buckets to actually get better output. Um, I think that makes perfect sense. Um, I've got two more. Uh, have, have there been, are there any investigations into like the ARPA spending as to where it's going? Right, because we get certain things through like budget appropriations, but we don't necessarily see the other end. And it would be unfortunate, but probably a reality if similar to the P P P loans, we would see misuse and fraud there as well. Uh, not within those four corners. And I won't take up more time now, but I'd be happy to talk about that offline. Okay. Uh, okay. Uh, that's actually all all I've got. Um, thank you for all the work that you do. At some point we'll follow up to see if like we can do, uh, an, an investigation into our budget process to see if we can get this thing a little bit tighter because it has its own improvements to be found. But, uh, thank you so much for all the work, both y'all. Thank you, min, thank you Altman, uh, Vasquez, um, I I a point he, he brings up, raises a question. Do we as counsel have the ability to ask you to do an investigation on a specific, uh, program or does that reside with the committee? Um, or the council itself? We would welcome feedback from any and all of you on issues that you think are important. That there are No, No, that's not my question. My question is, can we direct you to do an investigation, Cannot direct o i g to do an investigation? No. Cannot direct you to do an investigation. Correct. Okay. Very well. Um, we're gonna have, uh, I think Alderman Yancy followed by Alderman Spto. Good morning. Um, thank you all for doing this really tough and important work to inspire confidence in confidence. Our city government, um, this is for Inspector General Richburg. Um, what's the OIG G'S role in supporting the city's compliance related to the consent decree? And if you can give some context on like, how we got here and, and like Thank you. O I g has sort of a dual role with respect to the consent decree. And one part of that role is, is sun setting, sort of as we speak. And that is that o i G was among the city entities with obligations pursuant to the consent decree. We had our own set of obligations, um, in our police oversight work. We have completed those obligations. We are in full compliance with our obligations under the consent decree. That positions us to transition to the second and longer term role that we play with respect to that process, which is that the consent decree, the, the monitor is a temporary structure. Um, O I G is a permanent structure built into city government. And so as the city progresses down the road toward the end of the consent decree, there will be a sort of rolling over of some of the oversight responsibilities that currently sit with the monitor to the Office of Inspector General. It is not a perfect analogy, but that will look a little bit like what happened with the Shackman decree, where there was court oversight for a period of time. And then when, when the city reached substantial compliance with the shaman decree, the remaining work of ensuring that the city continued to follow the rules came to rest Within O I g I anticipate a similar sort of path forward. Can you talk a little bit about how, I guess, successful the city has been in meeting the consent decree? Not very. The, the, the measure, the appropriate measure of success with respect to consent decree compliance is those requirements with which the city is in full operational compliance reform happens on the street, not on the paper. The, the way the consent decree is built in, the way compliance is measured is that there are three levels of compliance. There is preliminary compliance, which the city reaches by writing a policy saying that it intends to comply. There is secondary compliance, which means the city has trained people on the policy, which says that it intends to comply. And then there is operational compliance, which means that they've actually made the change required by the order. It is that third step which matters to Chicagoans in uniform and out. Um, and with respect to that level of compliance, the city is in double, uh, excuse me, single digit percentages. And would you say that the issue that you talked about a few moments ago regarding, um, how difficult it is to get data to drive the work that we're trying to do is playing a big role in the single digit compliance? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Um, let's see. Uh, have you had an opportunity to audit any programs that fund, uh, violence prevention and violence intervention efforts, either through Chicago Police Department or D fss? Not directly. Um, but I would welcome any conversation about that, either coming off of or in addition to our 2024 project plan. Yeah, you might hear some talk from the council about that. I think that there's some, you know, concern at least questions about the efficacy of the program, the amount of spend compared to what we're actually getting back from folks in the community. And, uh, let's see. I think that was it. Thank you. Thank you both. Appreciate It. Thank you. And Altman Yey. Altman Spto, follow Alem and lada. Thank you chairman. Uh, thanks Deb. Thanks Steve for coming out today. Um, I never have many questions 'cause I could call either one of you time. Steve and Lisa, don't feel bad. I haven't called you much the last six months, so you probably suspect something's going on. Hold On. Alderman Sdo, if you can talk into the mic 'cause they're doing transcription and you, you're not coming across the, uh, audio. I'll To lean forward a little bit then. Is that a little better? Thank You, Sir. Yes. All right. Well thank you. Thank you once again. So I said Steve and Lisa, don't, don't feel like I'm mad at you 'cause I haven't called you much lately, but all's good between us. So, um, Steve, I did see a little something in your report. I didn't have any questions for anybody today, but I did see a little something in your report under the board generated enforcement actions that I have a question about, and I guess I could ask anytime, but I noticed there's an, I know there's an appeal process with the, with the Cook County Circuit Court. So as a person that was a, uh, a subject of a probable cause investigation, um, that ended up being, uh, no actions were taken, but had there been actions taken, and I'm just making this number up. Let's just say I got fined $2,000 for putting that proud and historic picture of myself in, in my, uh, fire coat in front of a firetruck. Um, it, it's, it's, it's pretty cost prohibitive to, to go to the courts to appeal. So my question is, is there any appeal process through the board of ethics to say, Hey, can you guys reconsider anything like that? So yes, The board does have, um, reconsideration rules, and in fact, people have taken advantage of that. So a person can, once the board makes a determination, the person can appeal directly to the board for reconsideration. Our rules do say however that, uh, for a reconsideration to be valid, there has to have been either facts that were not at the board's disposal when it made the determination or a change in intervening law. Okay. So no information. And then, and then the next question will be, is there progressive discipline? So when I put that proud and historic picture of myself on my Facebook page, if I took it down like I was supposed to, but then if I put it up again, there was no fine levy the first time with the complaint that was filed against me. But then if I put it up again, then I would understand, I would be fined. So is there a progressive discipline for any, anything? Or is it is a case by case determination? There isn't really progressive discipline that's written into the law. I will just tell you two things. Number one, if the board makes a finding that somebody has committed a minor violation and this is actually in the law, and then we receive, or the Inspector general receives a complaint about the same, uh, conduct, then it's no longer a minor violation. Um, the second thing is that, uh, and this is extremely rare, I will tell you, is that, uh, if somebody, uh, is found to have disregarded the board's advice, then the board takes that very seriously. And I can only think in my 32 years. 30, 30, well not 32 yet, uh, my 30 plus years of being with the city, I can think of two instances where that has happened. Neither was in this decade, uh, or in the previous decade. But in both instances, the board recommended that those employees be terminated. And they were, Well, in my, in my case, the letter I received was, it said I may have committed a violation. It didn't say, alderman, take it down, or Nick, you committed a violation. So then obviously I took it down. But had I not then would that, I know that would've been a worse deal for me, but it did say I may have committed a violation that you did take a violation, take it down. Well, yeah, we'd have to deal with these on a case by case basis. I mean, it, it really depends on, um, what the board's initial advice or the initial, the initial conclusion is, and then what the subsequent facts are. Okay. So, All right, thanks. So, uh, new information you can appeal. No new information, you can't appeal. Well, you can always appeal. It's just a matter, right? Whether the appeal's gonna be successful's The same stuff, it's gonna go nowhere. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, thank, thank both of you. Appreciate you. Appreciate you. Thank you, chairman. Thank you. Alderman Sdo. Alderman Laa, followed by Alderman Taylor. Do we have any others after Alderman Taylor Altman, manna hopping, I you to the list? Altman. Hey, thank you so much, chair. Very few notes. I really appreciate everything that you do, Steve, particularly the past four years, you've been such a good source of counsel from a, in terms of not only not having ethics, uh, violations, but knowing the lines around ethics violations that keep you from getting close to that point, which I think is really the standard that we all wanna be holding ourselves to. Um, my only real question, um, comes onto, uh, for the Office of the Inspector General looking at under contractual services, and I apologize if you've already answered this and if I missed it, but there's places where I, I'm not sure if it's efficiencies or if it's doing less with less, but particularly when I look at the professional and technical services line, not so much from 2023, uh, but from 2022 to 2023, also, when I look at lease and purchase agreements, are, are these reductions related to efficiencies? Are they related to moving to and looking for a new space? How, how should we interpret this? Those are largely related to, um, frontend investments, sort of periodic investments in things like IT infrastructure where we may need to renew or update a system. And then there's some associated cost with that, um, which then comes down in the following few years. So we will, for example, with a new case management system, and a couple of years ago we made a large investment in upgrading the system that was accompanied by some additional service costs, which then come down in the following years. That is very helpful to understand. That was probably my big question. Otherwise, thank you very much genuinely for the work that you do. And I'll give a shout out to the public safety dashboard, particularly for the OIGs team. It is really helpful in creating very clear and accurate zero spin information in terms of, uh, what public safety response looks like in the first ward. So thank you. Thank you. Altman la Spot Altman Taylor, follow our Altman Manna Hopper Award. Thank you, chairman. I, um, my last four predecessors went to jail, and so I called Steve a whole lot. I'm like, Steve, they're giving me t-shirts. He like, if they under $25, you're okay, or leave 'em in office. Um, I hope that the new alderman here really use you to their advantage. And I've appreciated just being able to pick up the phone and call. Um, question, um, folks in the c in these committees or in these different departments who whistle blow, what is the protection for them? Because I've had a couple of folks kind of complain to me about events and they're literally under attack and they're being told, unless it's something bodily harm, call the police. But there's nothing we really do. What are we really looking at to do that? Because we want employees to be able to come to us and say when they see something wrong, but we also need some way to protect them. There is, uh, and it was added during the Emmanuel administration, there is whistleblower protection in the governmental ethics ordinance. Now, I will say that we have not had many cases on it, but it's section 2 1 56 0 1 9 of the law, which provides that members of the public or city officials or city employees that have had retaliatory action taken against them because of a report that they have made, either to the office of the Inspector General or to the Board of Ethics, that they can get their job back. They can, uh, receive their seniority and they can get back pay. So, uh, that applies to persons who come to either our office or the Office of Inspector General. Uh, that's, that's as, that's as far as my answer can go section again. Pardon? Can you gimme that? Oh, sure. It's, uh, section two dash 1 56 19 and it's entitled Whistleblower Protection. And so does that, so let's say I report somebody in the department, they know I reported them because questions have been asked, do, why do we leave that person there? Why is there not an automatic transfer? Why is there not a move for them? What are we putting in place to protect those people? Because imagine reporting your supervisor and then you're sitting there every day and they're looking, trying to figure out how to get you fired on your day off. Yeah. You know, I think that's a, that's a slightly different question, um, than, you know, this law does not cover that. Uh, I, I think, you know, I'm speculating here. It would seem to me that those really become more human resources issues, uh, as opposed to ethics issues per se. Um, maybe, maybe my colleague can speak to that as to her insights. But, um, I, I can't really say that our ordinance speaks to protecting the person other than the fact, uh, that if they made the report and they are being retaliated against because of that report, then they have remedies available to them. But as to protection in the interim, this law doesn't speak to that. I would just add two things. One, in addition to there being a section of the governmental ethics ordinance, which speaks to retaliation, there is also a section of OIGs ordinance that is at, um, the municipal code section two dash 56 dash 100, which says that no person shall retaliate against, punish or penalize any other person for complaining to cooperating with or assisting the Inspector General in the performance of our duties. So there's an additional protection there. There's also the Illinois Whistleblowers Act. There's state law which prohibits, uh, retaliation for protected disclosures. And how would folks get, how would they obtain this information? Because it's not given to folks when they're making these reports. And I feel like some of the wastefulness that happens in these departments, somebody reports, but because of friendships, 'cause of who they work for, for whoever, I feel like sometimes they're overlooked and you wind up, we actually wind up losing good people because they, they're being targeted and they just can't take it anymore. I, Steve, I don't know if you have additional insights here. I would say we regularly have conversations with people who call our tip line and send us emails and so on about these issues. People have well-founded concerns about retaliation. People do get retaliated against. I take that seriously. People are worried about that because it's very real. Um, we regularly have conversations with folks about that. We would be happy to, to speak to anybody who has those concerns. I, I imagine Stevie would be as well. Yeah, I mean, I, I would just say that our standard response, when somebody, uh, wishes to file a complaint with us, that's, that's essentially a, a whistleblower complaint. Number one, we would of course refer them to our colleagues at the O I G. But number two is that, um, as a lawyer, and I know this sounds kind of trite, uh, I will always say, hire a lawyer. You need to pay, you know, two things, paper it, and hire an attorney to protect yourself. And I know that's costly, but there are resources available to people. Um, as far as finding legal representation where money should not be a barrier. I often feel like we wind up on C B Ss or, or Channel seven or something because we ultimately didn't listen to the people who actually work in these departments who are coming to complain. And so I want us to take a look at like, that person actually being moved to another department. They're not losing their pay, a lot of those things. 'cause I don't think we take those in consideration. And I think a lot of things that are happening in departments that shouldn't be happening, we would have more people say, yeah, that is how they operate. That is how we do. Um, if there was some protections in place, I'm not gonna report somebody and then have to sit, look at my supervisor every day. 'cause I know what's gonna happen. Eventually they're gonna push me to the, the point of acting up or I'm just gonna wind up quit. And I feel like we're starting to, and I don't know what you all are seeing, but I'm starting to see people say, I've just had it. I can't take it no more and quit. How do you, to your point, how are you connecting with, uh, the Department of Human Resources when it comes to complaints like these? We don't, we don't really have, uh, we don't really connect that much with human resources, except when a person does file, you know, wishes to file a whistleblower complaint, which for us is, is not prob it's probably not as common as it is for, uh, our colleagues at the O I G. Um, we will tell them that you can reach out to human resources and confidence and let them know, um, how a transfer might be affected, though, I think goes beyond the board's purview. Um, but you raise a, a very real concern. I agree. I I, I take all of those concerns. Um, and this is a complicated corner of city government where we have o I g on the board of ethics and the Department of Human Resources, e e o arm there, there's a lot going on here. And while we can't give people legal advice to Steve's point, we would be happy to talk through those structures with anybody who is trying to sort them out. So, um, I would encourage your constituents who have these concerns to reach out to us, or if there's an easier way for us to reach out to them, I'd, we'd be happy to do that as well. We could have a, a conversation. What do we do about non-disclosures? So there was this conversation amongst us about asking folks that we hire to sign a non-disclosure. Is it legal or is it illegal to ask employees to do that? Uh, it it, I'm gonna have to, I'm gonna have to, uh, hunt intelligently on this one. Okay. Um, meaning that, uh, non-disclosure agreements are not, not within the purview of the board of ethics. So, um, you know, that's, we would probably, uh, refer those types of questions to our colleagues in the law department. There needs to be some coordination between you all and, and human resource and the law department. Because I feel like, and we, we talked about this before budget. I'm asking you a question that you might not necessarily have the answer to, but you all should be working together so that we're providing not just better service to the people we are paid to represent, but to the people who actually work for us. Um, I, I want to see some protections or us to have a conversation about more protections for our workers. Um, we all get a lot of those emails that they send out to all 50 of us and they complaining about a certain department. I'm sure somebody forwards it to you. I ain't gonna say it's always me, but they get forwarded to you and we don't really know where that goes. And so last year we had a department that seemed like it fired everybody. And so that concern was brought to us as a caucus. And so there was not enough feedback for me to say that you all actually looked into it. And so I want to, I want us to talk about how do we implement stuff that makes this look different, where we're just being transparent. And I don't think it's a thing of, I don't think there's a thing of such too much transparency. 'cause I was gonna ask y'all, where did y'all go for $5 in this report and say, y'all spend $5 and 30 cents on travel, I want to know what y'all walk up the street. Where, where did y'all go for that $5 in, they said, but just, just asking in general, if that makes sense. I, I wholeheartedly agree that good and better coordination among city departments serves chicagoans better. Both both residents of the city and and employees of the city. To the transparency point, um, there is some balance striking to do, certainly in our work. And, and I think with the board as well, there's, there's balancing to do between confidentiality and transparency. In fact, part of how we protect whistleblowers is by faithfully abiding by our confidentiality obligations. There's certainly balance striking to do. Um, wherever we can be transparent, we must be. Last question. I heard the beep. Great. Are you all, so one thing that I've appreciated is that I've had the opportunity to have both of you all in my office to talk with me and my staff on a array questions. Are you all gonna continue to do that, especially with a bunch of the new artists? 'cause I feel like there are a bunch of things that we are calling you and ask you. Like me, I would've benefited from you being in my office early on, but I'm sure after me calling you 5,000 times asking about pens and pencils, you are like, I'm just going to our office 'cause I've had enough. And so I think that that would be great for my new colleagues. Absolutely. Thank you all both so much for your transparency and just being honest. I know we sometimes, and I know I'm gonna speak for Ottawa Taylor, ask some of the craziest questions. I just appreciate you entertaining me for a minute and answering those. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you. Uh, Altman Taylor, uh, Altman, uh, manna Haworth to any other, uh, questions for this panel? Alright, honor Amanda Hopper, work to close. Thank you Chair. Uh, on behalf of, um, my team from Edgewater, Andersonville and uptown the 48th Ward, we, we want to thank you, um, inspector General and also, uh, steep Berlin for being available and accessible, um, to our office. Um, and I also welcome you to come to one of our ward nights. Um, I'm, look, I'm just looking at your website now and, um, a lot of questions I think can be answered just by looking at your website and maybe taking the time to, um, show us what's on there would be a really great opportunity for us. Um, and at the same time, I'm, I'm, you know, I'm listening to all of the questions and I'm learning so much. And I think that there's also an opportunity to learn from each other because public safety is on the top of mind of everyone, especially in the 48th Ward and across the city of Chicago. But, uh, we all see public safety in many different ways. Um, I think that data is gonna help us get there. And so I'm excited for our new IT office and seeing, uh, ways that we can incorporate all the good work that I see on your website into that office. Um, and also, um, having meetings across the city to talk about public safety, um, so that we're not in our silos because if we are safe in the 48th ward, then everyone should be safe everywhere no matter where they live. So I would, I would welcome opportunities to, for instance, have a conversation with Alder Women Taylor's office at the same time or any other office, um, if that's something that people would be interested in. Absolutely. Anytime. Um, I also wanted to say I agree with, um, alderman Vasquez in, in terms of where our money goes and, um, when we are talking about budgets as moral documents, um, I would also like to, to continue conversations about how, how we are, how we are doing that in the city of Chicago. So I just, again, I just wanted to thank you so much for your work on that end. Um, and then again, just say thank you for being available and, um, for all the work that you do as, uh, one of the new, uh, council members here. Um, every day we fight the notion that government does nothing for the people. And I think that, um, I think that you are doing really the work to shine the light on, on the things that we do best. So, um, anything that we can do to support you, I'm here for Thank you. Thank You. Was that a question or, Um, the question is, when are you going to visit the 48th ward for Ward night? And also, um, how can we incorporate all of your team members to help, um, in the work that we do in the 48th Ward and to help you do your work? Alderman, if it's okay with you, our community engagement folks will reach out to your office and we will get a date on the calendar. Well, yeah, I'd have the same answer is that, uh, Delina will be reaching out to you. Nicole and I have, um, had a number of communications about, uh, us coming to your either ward night or just to your office, and we'll, we will, we will set a date, but Delina will reach out to you for more community, uh, outreach. Great. Thank you so much. Thanks, chair. Thank you. Um, well, uh, thank the two of you. That was painless. It, it wasn't as bad as we thought. Uh, but nonetheless, I do thank the two of you for, for joining, uh, with us in this joint hearing today. Uh, your, uh, area, uh, does, does definitely overlap as we we saw, and, and again, uh, continued, uh, success in the work that the two of you all do as you all are the police of us all, uh, as it relates to being, uh, good stewards of, uh, the public and the public resources. So, again, uh, I, I can't recall where this statement came from, but, uh, this is a slightly joke. It said, don't call us, we'll call you. So, uh, you all have a good one. We're gonna be at ease for a minute while we bring our next group in. Thank you. Thank you, chairman. Thank you. Uh, we're back on. Uh, good afternoon. Welcome to the, uh, COPA and Police Board. Um, we're going to, uh, start with a, uh, short, um, a short presentation by our Council Office of Financial Analysis. Um, go ahead. Daniel Strom, council Office of Financial Analysis. So we're just gonna do a quick overview of the Civilian Office of Police Accountability. So their budget total, the f y 24 proposed budget is 16.76 million. That would be a 1.72 million increase over the revised f y 23 budget. In the proposed F Y 24 budget. There are allocations for 157 positions making an increase of three positions compared to the F Y 23 budget. We look at the funding. The primary, the primary factor contributing to the f y 24 expansion is the personnel services category, which is set to grow by 1.72 million. This represents a 13% increase compared to the revised F y 23 budget. Uh, the personnel expenses are on the rise while travel. Um, travel is budgeted to decrease. And, uh, is that decrease is equivalent to about 25% reduction. It is possible to adjust this. The legibility of the graphs is very challenging given the design. If that is, I cannot, it's very hard to understand what the graphs are trying to illustrate to Council. I, I'll, I'll offer some feedback through your office, but the, the three D version of this line is very challenging. Good thing we'll take that, uh, we'll have staff make some adjustments going forward. Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Okay, so really fish, um, following, following up, um, all funding is derived from the corporate fund. Uh, and this is representing an 11.45 increase compared to the revised F Y 23 budget. There are no grants within CPA's budget. Good morning. My name is Janice Oda Gray with Kofa. And thank you for saying that because I have glasses and I'm going like this. I appreciate you saying that we're gonna, we're gonna definitely update and change that for you and for us. Okay, let's look at some highlights for, for the Chicago Police Board. Fiscal year 24, proposed budget is $601,190, and that is the change year over year from fiscal year 23, 13,004. They only have two budgeted positions. What's so unusual about that is they've had those same two people for the past 10 years. The primary factor contributing to the F y 24 budget expansion, of course, is personnel services in the proposed fiscal year 24 budget. The allocations for two people, again, no increase. That's just amazing for 10 years. Going to the next slide, and this is one that I'm sure you're going to love. This is just saying funds by year. And it's only one fund. They, they're only in the corporate fund. So all the money that, um, they use for the year that's allocated is in the corporate fund. Next one is FTEs. They only have two of them. So, uh, the budget for the FTEs is 300000.6. Uh, F T E grew by $6,500, 2.2%, and that is more than likely because of the increases that everyone's been having. And the last slide is the appropriation category. Uh, oh, let's go back a little bit. Appropriation category, the appropriation categories. We have only a few of 'EM, personnel services being the biggest one. And we also have a little and contracted services. No, actually it's almost equal to personnel services, small amounts in travel, commodities and materials and transfers and reimbursements. We have nothing. Only what, a thousand, $1,500. That's it for Kofa for this segment. Uh, we'll see you next time. Thank You, uh, Kofa. Um, and again, welcome to our second, uh, joint hearing of the day, uh, with, um, COPA and the police board. So, uh, first we'll have the director, COPA, followed by our, uh, chairperson of the police board, uh, executive director. Do you have anything to add after that? Okay. Very well. Please proceed. Oh, before you, uh, during your introduction, please introduce the members of the, uh, of in the box that are with your respective groups. Thank you. Thank you. And good afternoon, chairman Irvin, vice Chair Lee and members of the Committee on Budget and Government Operations. Um, I'm Andrea Kirsten, chief Administrator of the Civilian Office of Police Accountability, copa. And I do have with me a number of our leadership team. Um, I'll just start closest here. Jay Weea, chief of Staff, deja McDaniel, director of Administrative Services. Justin Escamilla, deputy Chief Administrator of our policy research and analysis division, Sharday Jackson, deputy Chief, uh, assigned to investigations. Angela Hart's Glass, also deputy chief assigned to investigations. Robin Murphy, our general counsel, Matthew Hanham, another deputy chief assigned to investigations. In the back we have, uh, Carlos Rivas, director of Public Affairs and Community Engagement, director of Investigations. Stephanie Reno and Director of Information, uh, services. Adam Pondexter. Happy to be supported by such a talented team. Um, so it has been six years since COPA became part of our broader accountability system here in, in the city of Chicago. And our mandate was given to us by city council, by all of you, as well as by the residents of the City of Chicago. And that mandate is to investigate allegations of police misconduct within our jurisdiction, determine whether those allegations are well-founded, and identify and address patterns and practices of police misconduct to make policy recommendations that will improve the Chicago Police Department and thereby reduce incidents of police misconduct. The mandate that we gave ourselves is embodied by our vision statement, which is to be the leader in police accountability by conducting thorough investigations to advance the culture of policing and build trust in civilian oversight. This year in 2023, we also selected a theme for our agency that guided our collective efforts to make our vision a reality and forces us to look at ourselves and who we are as an agency. And our theme for 2023 is advancing our culture because it's important that we not only look externally, but internally. Being an accountability agency must mean that we're willing to hold ourselves accountable as well. And as I sit before you today, COPA has made significant strides towards upholding these mandates set forth by us and for us. Over the past two years, I've had the privilege of leading one of the city's best agencies, staffed with some of the most talented, dedicated and committed staff. And together we've remained focused on our mission, regardless of public pressure or changing sentiment regarding civilian oversight and police accountability. What is often lost in the very polarizing nature of our work is the impact that we continue to have both locally and nationally. During my tenure as Chief Administrator, COPA has benefited from having consistency in leadership. Consistency in leadership has led to increased consistency in our operations progress towards addressing our investigative caseload, improving our recruitment and retention of staff, and creating a shared vision for the future of the agency as well as better outcomes for the communities that we serve. However, the better outcomes we desire, which span far beyond our core responsibilities as an investigative agency, cannot be accomplished by COPA alone and require effective, transparent and collaborative relationships with the Chicago Police Department, the Civilian Commission on Public Safety and Accountability, the independent monitoring team for the Federal Consent Decree, the Office of Inspector General, and many other city, state, and local agencies, as well as the public itself. We have spent considerable effort and resources in developing these relationships this year and continue look to continue this work, which is so critical to our success. Uh, one of the keys to enriching these RA relationships has been the work of COPA Communications and External Affairs Unit led by First Deputy E from ed, uh, so far in 2023. This unit has had numerous meaningful engagement and partnership opportunities and has actually touched over 26,000 residents so far this year. That's a nearly twofold increase over years prior. Uh, and we've been in nearly every neighborhood in Chicago and virtually every ward. I think we have about five left, five wards left to touch by the end of the year. So we may be reaching out to you. Um, we've also launched our first ever COPA Peoples Academy, uh, which made available to the public free of charge at the Joint Public Safety Training Center, uh, classes that you could either take in person or online to learn about the training of copa. How are investigators prepared to do this job? Um, and some of the rigors and challenges of civilian oversight of policing. Uh, the very first iteration of that was very successful. We had, uh, both many members of the community that were there, both in person and online, as well as cities from around the country having practitioners of civilian oversight, law enforcement officials and others, uh, tuning in to see the work that is going on here in copa. Uh, this year, COPA has also focused on the issue of wellness that is, as it impacts law enforcement, our communities, and our own staff, understanding that wellness is an essential component of public safety. We've been intentional in creating sustainable wellness practices in every aspect of our work, including with officers with complainants and impacted families as well as COPA employees. These practices include trauma-informed interview techniques, partnering with NAMI Chicago to provide mental health education and services to COPA staff, and importantly to families that have experienced loss or trauma involving police officers. We have also raised awareness, uh, of the need for the city to provide a more holistic approach to supporting families who have lost a loved one, uh, in a police encounter. And we look forward to partnering in those efforts in 2024. Historically, one of the most challenging areas for COPA has been the length of our investigations and our overall caseload. Last year, I assured this body as I sat before you at our budget hearing in 2022, uh, that we would make significant reduction in our caseload by this year. And I am pleased to announce that we have achieved that goal and our continuing down that path. Uh, COPA currently has just, oh, just under 1,900 and I believe 76 open cases, uh, that includes intakes as well as open investigations. That is the lowest number since the agency launched in 2017 and an over 40% reduction from our budget hearing last year. Uh, this progress is the result of improved investigative operations, collaboration with stakeholder agencies and direct engagement with the public that we serve. But beyond closing cases, we've made numerous internal operational adjustments to ensure that our caseload remains manageable and that we're able to close all of our investigations within our goal of between six to 18 months appearing before city council. Over the past two years, it's been clear to me that when we are afforded resources through this annual budgeting process, those resources must be utilized to address area of improvement within our agency. Uh, and I remain committed to following through on those, those improvements. Two years ago, city Council improved a budget that enabled COPA to create our first dedicated video release and transparency unit whose sole focus is to get information to the public quickly and responsibly. Because transparency is foundational to public trust, and the work of this unit has benefited the public time and again, as well as improved our internal operations. Last year, COPA approved a budget that enhanced our ability to conduct meaningful policy research and analysis, taking the lessons that we've learned through our investigative outcomes to better inform C P D. This unit is staffed with a research associate, data scientists to performance analyst, and a program manager whose focus is, is to identify patterns and practices, uh, of police misconduct with the goal of advancing the culture of policing. This work is where truly principled, data-driven reform can begin to take roots and lay a foundation for transformational change within the police department. Our policy efforts are publicly available on our website, and we look forward to continuing to expand this work as we grow this unit. And lastly, this year, if Approved CO's budget will largely be focused on building and resourcing and expanded complainant officer mediation program through two new positions, as well as furthering our internal efforts to build on equi build and equitable and inclusive workplace and work product. As in years past, I'm confident in our ability to be good stewards of these requested resources and to utilize them effectively as we continue to build a stronger, more efficient copa. Our vision is to be the leader in police accountability and time again. Over the last two years, we've demonstrated that leadership as we continue to lead the city in the investigations of police misconduct allegations. We will also continue to listen to the communities we serve and continue to aspire to live up to the mission and mandate that we've been given as an agency. I look forward to your feedback and collaboration in those efforts, and I'm prepared to answer any questions. Thank you. Uh, director Kirsten, uh, chair Foreman. Right. Good afternoon. Chairman Irvin Irvin and members of the Chicago City Council. I'm Gion Foreman, president of the Police Board, and we're a small mighty army like Gideon. So I'm here with Max Caponi, our executive director. The police board continues to be fully committed to the goals of the consent decree, which include ensuring lawful and constitutional policing and building trust between police officers and the communities they serve. Of the 14 consent decree paragraphs in the police board is responsible for implementing the independent monitor's. Most recent report found that the board to be in full compliance with 11 paragraphs and in preliminary compliance with three paragraphs. Chicago has the most extensive civilian oversight of a police of any major US city, with each of our four civilian agencies playing a vital role in the city's police accountability system. We speak to you today as one part of a complex and rigorous accountability system. One of the primary duties of the police board is to build public confidence in the accountability system by serving as an impartial decision maker of the most serious police disciplinary cases. These cases range from charges of unjustified police involved shootings to other significant allegations of misconduct, such as use of excessive force, illegal searches, and sexual misconduct. For more than 60 years, the police board has the sole responsibility for deciding cases in which the superintendent of police recommends that a sworn officer be discharged from the Chicago Police Department. The board has performed this duty with independence and openness. The public can stay informed through the police board's process for considering these cases because the board places a high value on transparency and makes a great deal of information available to the public. The arbitration process, on the other hand, takes place behind closed doors. Charges brought against officers are available on the board's website. They're not made public in arbitration. All of the board's disciplinary hearings are open to the public. The arbitration hearings are closed to the public. The board takes final action on all cases in public at its monthly meeting where each of the board's members vote is announced and recorded. Arbitrators make their decisions in private. The board posts on its website. Its written decisions, which include detailed explanations of the reasons for the board's findings. Arbitrator's decisions are not posted on a city website. In addition, the board publishes monthly, quarterly, and annual reports of cumulative data on its decision, which enables the public to evaluate the board's work. Overall, the nine members of the police board are a diverse group of Chicagoans and are committed to performing our duties with independence, integrity, and fairness to all involved. Each board member is required by City Council ordinance to read the full transcript and watch the complete video of each hearing and then attest to having done so. Cases typically include up to 12 to 15 hours of video, and the board often considers more than one case a month. Like this month, we all live in the city and, uh, come to the board from different perspectives and backgrounds and professions. I believe we represent the people of Chicago very well. The Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability. The mayor and the city council are all involved in selecting police board members. Arbitrators, on the other hand, are not required to live in Chicago and are a much less diverse group. They're selected by mutual agreement between the F O P and city attorneys. According to an Inspector General report, 90% of recent cases were decided just by three arbitrators. The role of the board is to be an impartial decision maker that makes decisions based on the evidence that are made a part of the record at the disciplinary hearing, which is open to the public. Both the superintendent and the accused officer has a, have a right to due process. They each have a right at the hearing to present evidence and to cross examine witnesses. Impartiality due process and transparency are essential values of any police disciplinary system guided by these values. The police board strives to promote accountability and increase the public's confidence in the process for handling allegations of police misconduct, police accountability. And ultimately, the people of Chicago will suffer if the most serious police disciplinary cases are removed from the police board's jurisdiction, which is what will happen if the arbitrator's decision is allowed to stand. Thank you very much for your consideration of my comments and the board's budget and, uh, not in my notes. I see goodbye to some of you guys last time, but this is my final meeting for sure. Uh, I, uh, is, my term is up and so probably sometimes in the next two months we'll, we'll see how it goes. Uh, so it's been, it's been an honor to be able to serve. Well, first off, I want to thank you for your service. Uh, I, I've known you, we, we went to grade school together, so I've known you for a number of years and I really appreciate, uh, your service to the city and, and overall for the work that you've done, uh, with the police board on the last, what has been 10 years now, 13. 13 years. 13 years has been a member of the police board. So, uh, definitely your, your work is, is noted and we appreciate the sacrifice that you've made, uh, from your family and, uh, on behalf of the community and of this, uh, of this great city. So again, thank you for your, uh, service, uh, to the, to the citizens of the city of Chicago. Thank you. Alright. Uh, we're going to open, um, alderman MITs, uh, is going to open any other, uh, members wishing to have questions. If you could raise your hand so I can note you for the record. Go ahead, chairman. MITs, Thank you. And good morning still. Oh, good afternoon now. Thank you. Um, just wanted to, um, let you know that I appreciate the work that you're doing in the community with copa. Um, and I know that there are several been at the training campus, uh, that recently opened up with the residents and constituents. I assume that was the, uh, program that you were talking about, um, the People's Academy, that that was there hosting the meetings. Yes. What, what have been your high most that you're most proud of and your low in terms of what you need to work on? Sure. Uh, I'm sure you have some goals in mind. Um, yes, I appreciate the question. We have certainly have a lot of goals in mind. Um, and I'll start with the easy, uh, what we're really proud of. I think Copa People's Academy is one of the things that we are truly most proud of it brought together. Um, and, and I'll give credit to first Deputy e from Ed, who's up here on the day's with me. It was his, his baby. He calls it, um, his idea to take the, uh, really critical and substantive training that our staff gets when they're onboarded. We have our own COPA Academy that our investigative staff go through. And, uh, so when we went and presented at the National Association of Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement last year, it was in Texas last year. This year, those people are coming to Chicago because that's how much interesting stuff is happening in the city of Chicago's accountability system. But when we presented to them on our training, people were blown away by how we approached civilian oversight, um, amongst our peers nationally. And so, uh, his, his design was to take a little version of that program and make it free to the public. And then we also advertised and promoted it to other practitioners nationally. So law enforcement, civilian oversight, um, government mayor's offices, and people like that from multiple cities, Boston, la, Arizona, all over the country, frankly, were joining in online. In fact, Oakland, California even flew out for some of it because they wanted to see the Joint Public Safety Training Center in their work. I told you they was gonna be, I knew they would be. Yep. Yep. Beautiful. Um, and then we had many local Chicagoans, including members of C P D, which is perhaps one of the most important parts, right? Really getting to explain who we are, what we do, and why we do it to the entire community. We serve, I use the word community a lot when I talk about CO's work, but that includes our officers. They are part of the community that we serve. And so making sure that, you know, residents in all of our neighborhoods, officers, uh, stakeholders such as yourselves, elected officials, that everyone has the opportunity. Many of you had staffers that came to this People's Academy and learned important information. So we're actually running it again right now. It's on Tuesday nights. I'll be there tonight from six to eight. It's a six week program. Uh, and just really tremendous, I think, opportunity for us as a city to really sort of lift up the complex issues, um, that attend, you know, the concept of police reform or police oversight and make it tangible for people in the public, um, which is important. I'm also incredibly proud of our caseload. It was in my opening remarks for a, a reason. Um, you know, Copa started in 2017 and inherited a backlog of nearly a thousand cases. We have less than that in our building today because of the work of our entire team, frankly. Um, everything from investigative operations who laid out an, an ambitious plan, uh, for how we could drive that caseload down to each and every member of our agency, um, that had to step up and make sure that we could do that work. Um, because being able to resolve these cases critically is everything in this business officers deserve to know, um, if they've made a mistake, why and how, and how to move forward from it. Members of the public who are complainants or whose families are impacted by these losses deserve that closure. So we simply don't have a choice, but to be faster, um, and more consistent in the way that we approach that. And I'm really, really heartened by where we are at as an agency. Um, far more. We even exceeded my own expectations for where we'd be based on where we were last fall. So that's tremendously exciting work. Um, I will say, um, as we move forward, kind of a low, you asked for, I think we're at a another watershed moment, um, president Foreman's remarks, uh, as a city, a watershed moment, president Foreman's remarks really talked about the need as a, as an, as a community broadly, to talk about and have conversations around this, this arbitration issue, the police port issue, and all of the centers around, um, the potential ratification of the proposed, uh, new f o p contract. Uh, these are important questions. Uh, much like issues of transparency are really, uh, important questions. We have to have them out loud. We have to understand what's at stake. Um, you know, I think all of us have opinions and thoughts, but by and large, we wanna make sure that the public is educated about what these choices are. Uh, and so I, I think it's not necessarily a low for us as an agency, but it's an important moment, I think, for everybody to sit up and pay attention to what's happening in accountability, police accountability specifically, uh, right now for us as a city. So, are, are you working along with the, um, with all the law enforcement, uh, um, the new, new, um, ambassadors? Yes. So the, you, I, I believe you're referencing the, uh, commission Yes. For public safety and accountability. Yes. The Community commission. Absolutely. So we work, I meet monthly with members, commissioners, um, some of the interim commissioners that are on the actual commission, uh, to, to provide updates on our goals and our progress, uh, towards meeting those goals and answer questions they have about our process, et cetera. Um, and then also, obviously every police district has their elected officials, their local district councils. Uh, so we have a legislative affairs, uh, manager, Mac Thurmond. He's also here with us today, who has just like, he provides updates to, to all people, uh, on any of our cases that are pending. We're very intentional about doing outreach to those local district council members as well about, you know, cases of interest in the, the district that they serve, or data specific to the district that they serve. And then I've certainly, um, been invited to speak at, and so have other members of our staff, a number of their monthly meetings, et cetera. So yes, we are engaging with them, um, and learning sort of about how they're evolving as, as an, an entity as well. Um, and it's been a, it's been an interesting and productive process. Just curious to know, are you getting any, uh, information from the police districts? Am I gonna give, I'm sorry. Can you repeat that Question? Are you getting information from our districts in regards to, uh, the circumstances they're working around with the migrants? Um, so with respect to migrants in particular, yes. Uh, particularly while we were investigating earlier in the summer, a high profile allegation, uh, involving new arrivals. Yes. We were in contact with members of the local district councils from both the 10th and the 19th district, as well as, uh, commissioners from the commission that had and, and der older people as well, um, from this body that had or potentially had investigative leads with respect to that. Um, we, you know, and we continue to make sure that whoever has information about any of our pending investigations knows how to contact us, and we try to provide, you know, as much briefing as we can, um, to the public as well as to elected officials and other stakeholders. So, do you have any cases pending? I'm sorry? Do you have any cases pending? We Have approximately right now, um, there have been, in addition to the high profile sexual misconduct allegations, which have been concluded, uh, we did not find sufficient evidence. I wanna make, uh, make sure everyone's clear on that, did not find sufficient evidence to move forward in a full misconduct investigation for officers from 10 or 19 based on sexual misconduct. So that has been concluded, uh, uh, since there have been new arrivals staying in police districts over the last few months, we have had a number of complaints by people who identify as new arrivals, and that number is just under 30 total. Uh, and of those about 14 have been retained at copa, and the remainder have gone to the Bureau of Internal Affairs for their investigation. And the kinds of complaints that we've seen are verbal abuse, um, profanity a little bit, um, a few excessive force, but nothing causing injury. Um, and I believe there's at least a handful of Fourth Amendment type violations as well. But the majority of them have been, um, discourteous treatment, profanity, verbal abuse types of cases. And the total is less than 30. Have You made any recommendations? Um, we did, and the, when we concluded, um, the high profile investigation into the sex misconduct allegations, our policy research and analysis division, um, actually did make some recommendations to the department, uh, as to their newly revised sexual misconduct policy that went into effect earlier in the summer, I believe, around June. And although the allegations, you know, that were subject to this particular investigation did not prove to be founded, or we couldn't, we could not identify sufficient evidence with which to move forward. There was still some takeaways from, um, potential policy gaps in that policy, uh, both on, with respect to that case, as well as some of our other sexual misconduct investigations, not involving new arrivals, but just other sexual misconduct investigations. So we took the opportunity at the conclusion of that investigation, um, the end of September to make some of those preliminary policy recommendations, uh, to C P D as well. And then, you know, I've been in communication, uh, with both mayor's office, um, as well as the Deputy mayor that's specifically tasked with handling, uh, response to new arrivals. Uh, and it's, it's not information that I think would be un un anything new, any new revelations, but just challenges that we faced were around record keeping of people that were staying in the police districts, um, and, you know, making sure we had a, a good sense of all of the service providers that were in and out of those areas so that we could try to really reach everyone in trying, uh, to identify whether there was a victim of the underlying allegation. So that, that information has been fed back to the mayor's office as well. And there are things that they were well aware of and I know are taking steps to address. Okay. Well, thank you, uh, Ethan, I see you're hiding behind. So I finally saw you back. I was wondering where you was at, but, uh, good to see you. Thank you so much. And, um, thank you Yon too for your service. Uh, you've written it to us and we, um, where we may miss you at. We know you're not gone, so thank you very much. Looking forward to seeing you around. Absolutely. It's a great city. Thank you. Thank you. Thank, thank you, alt Mitch, uh, vice chair, lead, followed by Thank you chairman. Uh, thank you all for being here. And I mean everybody, for all of the hard work that you do, um, I, I see very frequently the COPPA team at our community events. Um, your team is amazing. Um, MAC has been to a lot of meetings. That community engagement, um, has come to both of, uh, actually all of my job fairs. So I, I really, no, and I appreciate their presence there, because I think we don't talk enough about the work that you're doing and how important it's, I think, you know, more focus on that is, uh, is wonderful. Um, I have a couple like little odds and ends questions, um, and they don't, they don't tie together with a theme. But, um, just questions, looking at the budget, um, salary increases and, uh, schedule salary adjustments. Can you talk a little bit about, um, how the, um, schedule salary adjustments are, are, are sort of coming together, how many positions that's affecting? Sure. Um, so two things to understand. We are a largely union environment. Mm-hmm. So the majority of our staff are union employees. So they're obviously on their, on schedule. Yes, exactly. Um, now the city also undertook in this last year, um, a salary study to try to rightsize, um, a lot of issues, compression issues that existed across the city. This isn't unique to COPA at all, but, so any of the salary adjustments that you see to non-union employees are the results of, I believe it was a joint, uh, venture, the study between D H R and O B M, uh, through the assistance of an outside consultant. So they would be best situated probably to answer the specifics of why, um, certain positions were identified. Um, but my role as leader of this agency was to say, here are some positions where I know that people that, um, that these supervisors manage either have eclipsed them in salary or are due to in a number of years. And that has been a particular challenge in, um, internal promotions often because you will have vacancies at the management level and people not wanting to te step into those roles 'cause it doesn't make financial sense for them to do so. So I think the city's approach to this study, uh, understanding that phase one was non-union employees made a lot of sense. And I, I believe, uh, that there will be continued study into all of the union salaries as well. No, I, I appreciate that, and I'm glad that we took the steps that we did, uh, to address the wage compression issue. Um, I didn't realize it was impacting your department as well, so I'm really happy to hear about that, because I'm sure it's also contributed to your ability to fill positions Absolutely. In general. Absolutely. Um, we're, we're just trying to get the aldermanic staffs as part of that study. It seems fair So odd that we haven't been included in that. Anyway, let me get back to the, the topic here. Um, the academy I think is a great idea. Do you, how many people do you anticipate in the first cohort and how many annually are you, uh, trying to run? Yeah, however you wanna Actually, um, this year alone, we have registered, um, almost, uh, 200, um, amazing, uh, uh, people in the, uh, in Copa Peoples Academy. We, um, hearing the mayor's initiative, uh, around young people, we included one, even though over the summer, uh, that had 50 youth, uh, that participated. And, uh, that, uh, includes as, uh, chief Ton mentioned, residents of the city of Chicago. It has, uh, also had enrollees of C P D B I A, uh, have, um, um, some of the district council members and practitioners from around the, uh, around the country. And we look to expand that to a, uh, an, uh, um, a version almost like a 2 0 1 version next year. Uh, and we'll continue to roll it out. And then we may also do some subject matter, uh, focused, um, um, offerings. Uh, for example, if people just exclusively want to know about, um, um, investigations into search and seizures mm-hmm. Or sexual misconduct investigations, we may isolate some of those sessions to really go in depth and help people understand. That's great. And, um, so going into next year, where would I find those expenses in your budget? I wanna make sure you, I mean, like, this is great stuff, but like, yeah, I'm just looking. So a lot of it is blood, sweat, and tears of our personnel. So, I mean, the majority of our budget is obviously personnel costs, right. Salaries and benefits. Um, and this content is all being generated by the subject matter experts that you see before you there, as well as others. Um, 'cause they only let me bring 10. So, um, there's even more people that have contributed to that. Uh, we also have some promotional, um, budget line item for promotional materials. Mm-hmm. Uh, we got notepads and water bottles and things like that, but really it's a free academy that we're running using city resources by being at that location. Okay. We were intentional about doing it at the joint public safety training center, number one, to be in the Austin community, which, uh, is one of the communities that is most impacted by our work. Mm-hmm. Uh, was really important to us. Number two, I think it's really, really needs to be clear that civilian oversight and accountability is a part of public safety. Uh, we all, we all know public safety includes first responders, but our robust accountability system is part of that. And so we are doing our own training of staff at the Joint Public Safety Training Center, and wanted to make sure that the, uh, public version of that, the academy version of that for the public, was also taking place in that space. So really there isn't any, um, dedicated, uh, budget line item for any increased expenditures. We're just taking money that we have and using it to make sure that, uh, it's as resourced as possible. So responsible of you, you might, for 2025, if all goes well, I can, uh, assume that it will. You, you might wanna consider adding something to your budget so that you can memorialize this. I mean, we, we have technologies for you to record some of these things so that, you know, you can get, uh, share it with a wider audience. Well, and I'll add that this year we were able to purchase, um, a significant upgrade to our technology. That's how we're able to do the hybrid model. So there can be an online version and then, um, amplification and, and recording capabilities for in, in-room, uh, attendees as well. And that same equipment we're utilizing to really start thinking about community engagement differently too. We did our first ever, I was super embarrassed to do it, but first ever kind of recorded video to talk about our timeliness initiative. The reason we got these cases, uh, down to the number they're at, is because of our intentional approach to that. We recorded that, put it on our website, uh, made sure that there was, uh, language accessibility, uh, around it. And, and really trying to recognize that that's a whole nother way to reach people, um, besides some of our traditional forms. So, uh, but to your point, yes, we need to make sure we're getting credit for the work that we're doing. Yes. Well, congratulations on the reduction in the caseload as well. Um, in the last three minutes that I have, I'm just gonna move over to the police board. Ian, nice to see you. Yes, ma'am. Um, fellow dolphin in the house here. Um, shameless. I know. Um, so as, as you're wrapping things up, and I, you know, I know you kind of said goodbye last year and you're still here. Hopefully we won't see you next year. Hopefully not, not for any other reason other than you. You've, you've done your time here. Um, I think given your 13 years of experience on the police board, um, what do you see, like, what words of wisdom are you gonna leave us with in terms of like, where are the places we need to be looking to, to do more, um, to, to move this, uh, to move this work forward? Um, you know, the biggest thing that I, that I think that I've learned, which, which go hand in hand with the words of wisdom, is that this is, this is really complex. It's really hard. Um, the police board, I've forced myself to be as neutral as possible. We all have biases, right? So you have to be able to see from both people's perspectives, and both people most of the time really believe that what they saw was what they saw and the way that they experienced it. And so, it's our job to kind of go through the way both sides present that information. And we like, like what we see on court, it's beyond a reasonable doubt. That's not the standard that we have. We have a standard of, what is it called? Prep preponderance of the evidence. So if it's a hundred sheets of paper in this stack, 101 sheets of paper in this stack, that's the preponderance of the evidence. And so sometimes it's that close. Um, you know, the, the, the, the things that our officers deal with, it's, it's a part of society that they deal with, right? So we have to think about our officers' health, their mental health at the same time, you know, they're responding to some of the things that the community is dealing with, right? Some of the situations that community is dealing with. And, and, and so it's all of our responsibilities, city, council, police, individuals, right? To make sure that we have a, a, a city that can function as, as, as, as good as we can, right? It's, we're always going, there's always going to be a need for a police board, right? Or someone to, to look at these kinds of things. This won't, this work won't ever go away. Um, we can improve systems, but this work won't ever go away. Things like the consent decree are tools that, that we have. Um, and we have to think about continuous improvement. And I think that if I had to boil it down really simply, it boils down to, at Chicago, how does everyone in this city get peace, health, and prosperity? Because those things impact everyone differently. Thank you very much. I'm done, Chairman. Thank you. Uh, vice Chair Lee, um, alderman Lepa followed by Al Manhattan Came on quick. Uh, thank you so much. Great to be here with you, chief Administrator. Kirsten, um, Gian, uh, I, to be brief, I was curious about a couple positions listed here for copa. What, what does the work of the senior equity officer look like and comparably under the legal team on page 2 38, what would a director of mediation do within copa? Um, I'll, okay, I'll start with the senior equity officer. So, um, you know, citywide, all agencies were asked to participate this year in the racial equity action plan process. And our team, uh, I was really excited about the number of folks that we had that wanted to participate in that, that it was a big commitment. It was a lot of weeks of, of information gathering and really collaboration. Um, and so this position comes out of sort of a direct ask of that internally led process, um, and our agency reap, which I know you have access to all of the different agencies. So I would, um, welcome you to review copa, but focus on a couple of things. Um, one was more external, uh, public safety action plan. And then another external was the community engagement, uh, action plan. But the third goal was about our work, our workplace action plan, and really wanting to make sure that there are promotional opportunities, uh, and equitable workplace. Um, for all that come to copa, we, we function best as an agency when we represent and reflect the city that we all serve. Uh, and so wanting to make sure that we had someone to spearhead and sort of safeguard those efforts within the agency was a priority for that team, and therefore a priority for me and the leadership team, uh, in our budget request this year. Um, with respect to the director of mediation, so Director of mediation was a, uh, it's tied directly to requirements of the consent decree, frankly. Um, under the consent decree, the city, not necessarily just copa, but COPA and b i a, and it's technically a City of Chicago, paragraph, meaning the mayor's office has to help and support us in this, um, are required to offer a complainant's mediation program for, um, resolving certain kinds of, um, misconduct allegations. And we have been in a pilot phase of that program. The Inspector General did their first audit of it. Uh, it was a relatively small sample size of cases. Um, but what we've really learned is that we need the resources to be able, uh, to, to do this on a broader scale. And so having the person in-house and not having to pull from right in over the program, uh, the pilot program, we've pulled investigative resources, specifically one of our directors of investigations, uh, to handle that work. Um, that role can't be splitting time between the intake of our cases generally, and the identification and, um, institution of potential mediation of cases. So that's really what, what that's about is supporting those efforts for consent decree compliance. Can I ask more about that? Because I, please do, I, I must admit, I did not know that we were doing that pilot. What does that look like when a case comes forward that is eligible for mediation? How does your team engage and what, what has the result of that pilot look like? So, The result of the pilot, um, was a pretty small, uh, scale, I'll say that. Yep. And so I would definitely recommend you take a look at the OIGs, uh, report on it, uh, published earlier this year. But, so what the city did essentially in, um, seeking to, to come into compliance with this paragraph was first start in sort of a nationwide search of best practices for mediation in police misconduct cases. And there's various versions of this. In certain cities, you'll find officers where their collective bargaining agreement requires or mandates that they participate in mediation. Uh, there's others where you can mediate absolutely any kind of infraction or misconduct allegation up to and including a fatal shooting. Um, and of course, I should back up and say the concept of mediation is rooted in principles of procedural justice and might not have any, in fact, won't have any penalty of a disciplinary nature associated with it. So, um, so that's kind of the outcome of mediation, is that both sides get to come together and try to understand one another's perspective through a guided conversation with a trained neutral mediator, not a COPA employee, not a C P D employee. In fact, for the pilot, it was an external vendor. Um, so going forward, uh, you know, originally the, the pilot program had some pretty stringent criteria for the kinds of cases because while some cities are mediating things up to an, including fatalities in Chicago, we decided we weren't ready for that and maybe, maybe never will be. But we're gonna start on a small scale. Um, and so certain kinds of sort of, um, unintentional fourth Amendment type violations, discourteous treatments, um, things of that nature, nothing involving serious injury, um, but potential like bias based policing, uh, where there may have been a misunderstanding about the reason for a stop, but the person that was stopped felt that they were stopped improperly, et cetera. Those kinds of scenarios. Um, and the way that it's functioning in the pilot program, because COPA is the clearinghouse for all complaints. We receive B'S complaints and, and our own, any complaint of misconduct has to come to copa. Uh, so we have sort of the, the view of everything that's coming in the door. So we're best situated to be the, the entity that is tasked with identifying eligible cases for mediation. Um, so we were doing that and calling all of the cases that were coming in the door to see what met the criteria, and then making a referral to this outside vendor, um, who was then in charge of contacting both parties. 'cause both parties have to voluntarily agree and follow through with the mediation, uh, in order to, to successfully complete it. So that's handled by the vendor. Um, but setting us up in the future, um, as we look to expand this, having full-time staff dedicated may mean that we have an ability to take on more responsibility than what was contemplated under this pilot. So that, It's really fascinating. I'll have to go back and look at the O I G report as well. Uh, two other quick questions. One for you and one for the police board. Um, number one, we have listed 26 total vacancies for copa, which looks to be roughly a quarter of the workforce. And I know from previous years, sometimes this is noise accurate. Sometimes it represents positions that have been posted, folks who have already interviewed and like are, are coming on board. But does it, do you feel like this is close to the actual number? And if so, what does, what does the hiring plan look like to, to bring y'all up to speed? So Right off the top three of these vacancies are for positions that don't exist yet that we're asking for next year. Still a large number, uh, when take away three of what remains of these vacancies. Seven already have candidates that have been offered jobs with potential start dates. Um, and they're going through the background clearance. 11 of these positions involve, um, interviews that are either in process or the job has been posted, et cetera. Some of these vacancies are going to be converted to other positions, uh, so that we can move forward. And that process has been initiated, uh, with O B M and D H R. Um, so, but overall, it's not a quarter. 'cause we're, our headcount is 154 currently, but it's a significant number. It's a significant number. And that's been a challenge for us as an agency. Um, we've reduced the amount of vacancies over time in the last couple of years, and the number of staff departing city service, uh, from COPA has decreased over time. Um, but this is about us, you know, I talked to my opening remarks about us kind of advancing our culture. We've had a need to really stabilize as an agency, and I think that work is happening, uh, and I expect to be able to report on even more progress on that in the coming years. Um, but what I'll say about hiring is D H R is a challenge for all city agencies. Um, and, you know, we, we directly compete, uh, with potential job applicants. We, we are competing with the Office of Inspector General and others whose pay scales may be different, or like with the ig, they don't have to go through D H R, they have their own hiring plan. So they're able to engage applicants directly, directly. Uh, we don't have, we don't have that flexibility. Um, and this is, d H R does an incredible job for the work that they have. Um, but the, the way that we approach hiring as a city, uh, definitely impacts the timeline for us and being able to fill these vacancies A conversation I'm sure we'll be having in a couple days. Uh, last question. So I, and we've kind of talked about this before, but why not take a public forum to talk about it? When you talk about a preponderance of the evidence is a term that we would find in a courtroom, is it a statutory term? What does that actually mean in, in terms of determining, um, punishment? So preponderance of the evidence is what is used to determine a finding of whether something occurred or Not occurred. Yes. Sorry. So it's not necessarily relevant for the punishment of any or the recommended discipline for any of these cases, but that's the burden of proof. That's the standard, uh, by which we have to make our case and prove it. If something is to be sustained, and it is a defined term under the law, but it's one of those fuzzy ones where, uh, different courts in different cases define it slightly different, differently. The most, uh, commonly used description is that it's more likely true than not. True. Ian was referencing sort of that 51% on the scales of evidence, more likely true than not, that something occurred much, much less, uh, high burden of proof than beyond a reasonable doubt in criminal court. Correct. And that's what I always really try to explain to members of the public, to, um, city council, to officers, uh, that you can have, you can have something that is sustained misconduct, and that same, that same set of facts might not be sufficient to satisfy criminal misconduct. Right? You can have different outcomes, and you see this often where, you know, an officer involved shooting that, um, is controversial to the public, the state's attorney to declines to file charges. But we may still sustain, um, various policy violations because we're applying a different burden of proof. Uh, and also the policies themselves are different than criminal law. So that's, that's where it becomes really important, I think, for the public to understand that we, we are number one, um, beholden to a different burden of proof. And then number two, the rules that are governing the conduct that we're looking at are the rules and directives set forth by the police department that's separate and apart from criminal code and, and other venues. And may I ask one quick question to avoid around two, is it the same standard that is utilized in the determination by the police board or what? Yes. We also utilize preponderance of the evidence. Okay. Appreciate it. Thank you so much, sir. Thank you, chair. Thank you. Alderman La Spota, uh, Alder Manhattan, followed by Alderman y Thank you chair. Um, and good afternoon, you guys. Um, uh, Gian, thank you so much. Um, I wish you the best as you, uh, move on. Uh, but we will miss you. Okay. Um, uh, I, one I'll say Andrea, just to echo the, uh, kind of, uh, COPA Academy, I think it's been fantastic and I really appreciate the COPA team. I think you guys do a fantastic job engaging with our office being a resource. Um, so up the good work. Um, I wanted to ask, um, uh, Gian a little bit more, um, from your statement about the issue around the, um, F O P contract and the arbitration piece. Um, one, I guess just for the record, and I don't know if, if anyone here knows this, but, uh, when would this potential decision, this contract come before council? Do you guys have any idea? I, I don't. Thank you. No, that's, uh, well, yeah, we don't know it. That's, that's, yeah. No, yeah. So just, just putting it out there. Um, and I really appreciate this breakdown, but I'm wondering, um, maybe do you have, um, a sense of why this, uh, I guess request is being made to switch decisions from the police board to the, uh, to an arbitrator? Have you heard anything? Anything you might, uh, suggest? Thanks, Anyone from, alright, I'm leaving. So I'm gonna say what I heard. So one, it's, it's negotiation contract time. It's a lot of issues that's being negotiated. This is not the only issue that's being negotiated, right? Mm-hmm. So if I'm negotiating a contract, I'm putting everything out there. Mm-hmm. That's just my personal opinion, right? I'm gonna put everything out there and I'm gonna try to get the most that I can get in any negotiation. But number two, what we've heard is, is that this is not just the Chicago issue. This is something that's taken place around the country, right? There's a lot more civilian oversight happening around the country. And the F o P is looking after their members and saying, well, wait a minute. Everybody else gets to go to arbitration. I wanna go to arbitration too. Right? The, the, the challenge is, is that everybody else is not, doesn't necessarily have the ability to take someone's life, right? So that's where the challenge comes in, right? Mm-hmm. And this is where, you know, we're trying to create this system where the public doesn't see the police as opposition. And so from sitting in this neutral position that we have to sit in, that's in contrast to me, to put it back behind closed doors. A lot of times if we make one decision, if I go to the grocery store, the public is mad at me another time, the, you know, the police are mad at me, right? Mm-hmm. We can't win. It just kind of depends. And so to be able to put that out there, to be able to explain to the public, this is why the decision was made, go read it. You might still not agree with it. Half of the time I disagree with other members of the board and they disagree with me, right? That's what happens. But we can, we can have a dialogue about it. But I think that this is not just the Chicago issue. This is, uh, kind of a national issue. So I'm, thank you for that. Um, I have a former coworker who used to love to say, you can do anything you want on your last day. Um, um, this could be through the chair, could you provide for us, um, maybe, I don't know, the last couple of years, uh, you picked the timeframe, but in recent history over the last few years, um, maybe the number of cases that have come to the police board, um, and then, you know, what the outcomes of those cases have been. I know we could look it up ourselves, but it'd be nice Sure. Um, to get it through the chair. And, and with this, I'm just trying to get to scale, right? Because I, I definitely have had constituents reach out to me with concerns about this change. Um, to me it seems alarming that we would, in fighting for much more transparency and accountability, right? Like, we've got these goals of trying to make sure that we are rebuilding trust, right? With our city within government, within our departments, with the police department. And this feels like a backslide to me, right? Like less transparency, um, and less accountability, especially to the public feels like this would be detrimental. Um, but it would be helpful to understand the scale, right? Like, okay, well, how many, how many cases are we talking about? Um, I think it would also be interesting, um, and this is maybe something that either of you might want to comment on. So, you know, is it just, it's just the things that come before the police board, which are usually it's around dismissal, right? And I'm wondering, are there, um, to your knowledge, other instances, um, where they're trying to expand and use arbitration that, um, don't come to the police forward, or, yeah. Yeah. So I, I'll let Max go into a lot more detail. Um, so of the thousands of complaints that cope with gets every year mm-hmm. We might see 15 cases a year. So we're not talking about like, you know, every complaint that's coming to us. And, you know, so, so from that perspective, you know, again, if this is one item of many that I'm negotiating over, this really shouldn't be one of the, the bigger ones. In my opinion. Maxa has some specific data, but Max, as you give the data too, can you also talk about the change that happened? We used to see cases 30 days all the way up to, uh, determination, and then a change was made where an officer could choose arbitration. So Yes, and I have some data, uh, that I brought with me. So going back five years, um, fall of 2018 through this fall, um, there have been 103 cases filed with the police board where the recommendation is to discharge the officer from C P D. Um, about 90% of those, so 92 out of 1 0 3 involve, uh, rank and file police officers, so f o p members. Um, so about, again, 90%, our expectation would be that, um, very few, if any of those cases would come to the police board if this change takes effect. The reason we say that is, as president Foreman mentioned, um, back about 10 years ago, uh, f o P members, um, won the right to choose arbitration or police board for suspensions of 31 days through 365 days. Um, we've had exactly one case come to the police board in about the last 10 years. So that shows what the decisions would likely would be. So bottom line, I think about 90% of our docket would, we would lose that if this change took effect. Um, we currently have 27 open cases, uh, before the police board. 25 of those involve f o P members. Um, five of those cases are unjustified police shootings, that that's the charge, that's the allegation. Another two, uh, involve a shooting, but involve false statements. Um, we have three other excessive force cases, uh, five cases of gender-based violence, domestic altercations, um, two cases involving fatal crashes. So very, very serious cases likely would not be coming before the police board would be going to arbitration. Where the process is much different as, as president foreman mentioned, behind closed doors. Uh, so that gives you a sense of, of the scale that we're talking, Talking about. And if, if I might just to, to, to make it personal. So some of you guys know that I was struck by a police officer and it went to arbitration number. So if I just put myself in the shoes of everyday person, right. It took a long time. Right? So you're wondering what happened? I kind of forgot about it a little bit. Un until people ask me about it and then it went to arbitration. I still don't know what happened. Right. So it seems like it's a different standard. Mm-hmm. Right? Just from just a everyday person perspective. It, it just kind of doesn't seem fair that the police have a different set of rules than every, if I hit the police officer, you guys are gonna know what happened to pretty much right away. And so that's where I think that it has to be some give and take. I don't, I know I used to look at police as them and community as us, and I don't do that anymore. I look at police as a part of community, right? And so I think this would be a big mistake not for just for you guys to vote for this, but even for the police to, to say, this is what we want. I don't think it advances our city. Thank You. Thank you both for that. And, uh, that's all for me. Chair. Thank you. Alderman Manhattan, uh, alderman Yance, you follow Alderman Taylor? Uh, good afternoon. Um, thank you both departments for all the hard work that you do. Um, many of you know, I've spent a number of years as a police accountability organizer and really understand how important it is to inspire more trust in our public safety system. Um, had a question about the People's Academy. Can you gimme a little bit more about what the motivation behind that and like what the ultimate, uh, what, what do you consider success in that? Sure. Um, I think the motivation was we really understand what we're, what we're doing is unique. Uh, and again, it was appearing at that national conference last fall, uh, where we presented on COPA Academy, the onboarding for our, our staff, and realized, oh wait, nobody else is doing this across the country. There's 300 and some versions of civilian oversight across our country. Um, but an academy experience like the one that we're offering each and every one of our staff members isn't really existing anywhere else. Um, so that was one component of it. Um, there's often been a disconnect between what we know we are nationally, um, and what I think residents of Chicago think about COPA and specific and civilian oversight. Um, so really wanting to bridge that gap is, is one thing. Also, you know, we have to serve a diverse population. As Dion just said, we consider community to be officers. We want officers to understand, um, that we don't come to this work with, uh, you know, absolutely no understanding of the role they play, the rules that they're supposed to follow, how they're trained. We come with investigative skill sets, we come with legal backgrounds, and we spend a lot of time making sure we understand the expectations on officers. So getting to show all of community, including the police and parts of the community that are very much in support of police and not as supportive of civilian oversight, who we are and what we do and how we do it, um, was really important. You wanna add anything to that? And, And I would just also say, um, um, alderman, um, a few years ago, there was a situation when an incident occurred as an officer involved shooting that led to, um, disinformation being spread quickly and widely, and people responded obviously with, with high emotion. And we even saw in that moment that if the public is better informed, the more the, the, the more transparent we can be about our investigations. Because after an incident occurs, often it goes silent because the work has to be done. If people aren't aware of what's happening during that silent time, di that silent period, then distrust, um, uh, frustration can settle in. And so it was also about how do we make sure that the public is aware of what's happening when we're not talking about it? Not that action isn't occurring, but that it is, and this is what you can, uh, understand and feel confident in. Also, we are secretly trying to, um, build ambassadors, people who, um, are taking that information and then regurgitating it to others because they feel like they, they, they, they are sound in their knowledge of investigations and things of that nature. So we also are doing that. And then, um, to what Alder, uh, person, uh, Lee mentioned even about the recording of it. Uh, part of it is to be able to, uh, capture this information and eventually brand it so that we can put Chicago on a higher profile in terms of the work that we do. And we've partnered with young people in the past to pro, um, uh, civic studios, uh, uh, uh, directly, who have created some promotional videos. And I, uh, invite you all to visit our website. You can see the videos that they made. They made a five year video and another promotional video, even giving them an opportunity, uh, to create promotional videos around content like this. And so it can be an opportunity for young people. So those are just a few of the layers. Thank you. And then the youth that were involved this summer, I think you said, can you tell me what communities they came from? Uh, It was more Pilsen in back of the Yards if, um, little Village, I apologize. Uh, we piloted in Little Village and, uh, we, uh, have already identified, um, a, uh, school on the south side, uh, to, uh, uh, potentially do another pilot in the spring of next year. Yeah, I'd like to welcome y'all to come to South Shore, um, you know, particularly black community. I think your records say about 49% of police misconduct claims come from members of the African American community. So I would implore that you all come, uh, and you'll be welcome in the South Shore community. Uh, another question for Copa. Can you gimme some info about your community engagement work that you're doing, how you're letting the community know about not just People's Academy, but how they can be, uh, involved either as complainants or witnesses or et cetera? Yeah, it's been a multi-pronged approach, uh, always. And I will probably let you from really, uh, color in the lines here, but I would like to just make it clear, uh, that it's unique to have a first deputy of an investigative agency whose portfolio or profile within the agency is communications and external affairs. That was intentional. That was, uh, me signaling and the agency signaling that anything that we do investigative wise doesn't matter a lot unless people understand it, uh, and understand who we are and trust us with their experiences, uh, or as an officer trust that we're going to be fair and understand the process that we engage in, in order to be fair. Um, so, but I, I think Efram, if you'd like to really explain more of the approach, I'll say this. Um, part of the strategy is first we looked at where complaints were coming from initially, and those were from black and brown communities as you could imagine. And so we put mo much of our resources there in terms of staff participating in community events, ward events, uh, beat meetings, um, anything at the ground level. We've definitely used billboards and things of that nature before, and we'll do it in the future, but Chicago is such a grassroots city that, that eye to eye, hand to hand, sitting down with folks, eating with them, uh, sitting in the places where they are familiar does us far better than any billboard will do. Um, and so that has been our approach to work with faith communities, community providers, activists, uh, obviously law enforcement, uh, to be at as many places as possible. And so we, we did that with a lot of, uh, meetings and presentations and then created our own platforms where people could come to us. And then we also did that, uh, by expanding to, uh, not just where complaints were coming from, but after the murder of George Floyd, there was much more interest. And so we really expanded our outreach to all, uh, um, all around the city. And it was very important that we get not just our, um, uh, staff, uh, where, um, director, uh, Carlos Rivas and his staff do a a great job in getting out to the public. But getting our investigators out, getting our supervisors out, getting our leadership out. It is one thing for folks to trust us with the complaint. It's another thing for them to see us in their neighborhoods, in their community. And so much of our engagement has been a grassroots effort, getting people out of the office so people can feel comfortable and familiar with us. Uh, because they've sat with us, they've eaten with us, and we've been in their neighborhoods to participate in their events. 'cause we, we want not just to be a place where people bring a complaint, but we want to be a city agency that is partnering with the community and not just seeing as showing up when something happens. We wanna be a resource as well, uh, as a place where people can trust us. Yeah. So again, I value and appreciate the work that y'all have done. Uh, Copa Copa feels much different than Emper. And so, you know, I applaud the, uh, uh, increased work that your team has been doing and it's definitely showing, um, out in the community if you could share through the chair, um, how many new cases for 2023, um, the racial ethnic background of the complainant of, of those cases as well. And then, um, just pivoting to Chairman Foreman. Thank you, uh, for, Can I add just one piece? Just I, I forgot to mention, we also, um, have reconstituted our advisory council, uh, which is community folks who are advising us around along the way, uh, doing that with the youth advisory as well. Uh, and then we have also implemented some surveys to get constant feedback and have a, uh, policy working group that is community members that are also giving us feedback. I apologize. I've got That. Good, sir. Thank you. I'll, I'll just add, I do have some of that information for you. So, so far for the year, uh, we've had 3068 total complaints. 528 of those have stayed under copa. Um, and that's relatively consistent with where we were at in 2022. I don't believe I have the racial ba uh, breakdown present with me, but that'll be easy to provide through the chair. Okay, thanks. Uh, chairman Foreman again, you know, thank you for what you said. 13 years. Yes sir. Tough job, brother. Uh, you'll be missed. Uh, but I'm sure that you'll find someone to help fill those shoes on the other side. Um, uh, and this is probably a through the chair question. Um, are you able to identify the number of cases that, or that 31 day or more threshold, um, and, and or have resulted, I'm sorry, that have been resolved in 2023? Are you're gonna be looking at that Look, I'm sorry, lemme back up. Cases in 2023 that, and I'm not sure what your measure is that either have resulted or real result in a punishment that exceeds 31 days or goes towards termination. So, so we only have the purview of, well, I shouldn't say that. Generally speaking, we have the purview of one year and above. Okay. There are some cases that come if there's a disagreement case between COPA and the superintendent, it could be below one year. Um, it could be below one year if it's, uh, a supervisor position. But for the most part we're one year and above. Okay. That would be fine. Yeah. And those cases are extremely rare. One, um, we have one case where the recommendation is a suspension of, uh, more than one year. Every other case that's before the board. Uh, the recommendation is to discharge the officer from c P d. Okay. Thanks. And then just one last, uh, through the chair, um, cases that resulted in or were connected to settlements, police account, mis police misconduct settlements of over a hundred thousand. That is data that we do not have, we're not part of the process that is involved in having cases in civil court. And that's settle. Um, and oftentimes that information is not made part of the record in the police board case. So the only thing that we're looking at are, was there a violation of C P D rules of conduct and if so, what the discipline should be. But we don't get involved in the, um, monetary settlements that take place in civil court. So we wouldn't have any information about that. So, So that's that. I, I just want to add on that. So, so from being the person making the decision, sometimes that's where members of the public feel like you're not doing your job. There was a settlement, but it wasn't a part of the case. I could have Googled it to see if that happened, but that's not what I'm supposed to do. Right. So if I'm following the rules that, that I can only follow what was introduced as evidence in the case. Okay. So one last question just to kinda help me understand where, who, where does the mechanism reside that helps connect those two pieces? I, I was actually gonna tell you to email that to the committee. I think that's probably more appropriate for the Department of Law to answer and, uh, provide that information in that respect. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. No problem. Thank you. Okay. Uh, alderman, I'm sorry. Uh, well your time's up or you need round too. Good. Okay. Uh, alderman Taylor, followed by Alderman Manor. Howorth. Thank you, chairman. So I'm gonna say thank you for, uh, I go any, and Gian ain't going nowhere enough. He, he, he got some more work to be done. Um, so I was going to ask the question, the same kinda question that, uh, alderman, Yancy asked, what bearing does, what you all say have on those civil cases? I feel there's a disconnect there because it's so if we find an officer not guilty on your end, on this end, we still wind up giving that person maybe millions of dollars for something you found. So I'm confused on why we haven't and why you all are not part of the conversation. Yeah. So usually it's the other way around. Okay. Usually you guys do it first or criminal first or, or the civil first. Um, and a part of, so this is an employment. We are employment, like we're not figuring out money. We're not figuring out criminal, this is an employment status that, that we're looking at. So whether they should still work for the city or not, it's kind of correct your role or, Or even if or should they be suspended or still work for the city. So, so it's a little bit different, but there's also, I got my lawyer sitting right here so she can answer it. There's also some things that if you say in a criminal trial or if you say in our employment trial, maybe you can't use it in a criminal trial or civil trial because officers have to, they can't take the fifth in our case, right? So we happen usually on the back end of it. Um, and so a lot of times people say, well, why don't you guys fire 'em now? Well, because there's another case that's going on and you don't want to jeopardize that case over the employment case. So we're usually on the back end of it. I don't think it's one versus the other. I think it's, and and both, because I also feel like, so my other question was, and you can give it through the chair, how many officers actually quit before they go through this? 'cause we get that, that that actually happened in a case that we talked about where the officer left before you all ultimately made the decision whether nay or yay. And I feel like as much as we spend, um, in police misconduct, you'll learn if you ain't had no pension. And I know that's not a decision that you all get to make. I, I've had this conversation with you all before, but there has to be some and, and both, not one versus the other. And I don't know who could kinda, I'm gonna, I'm gonna jump into this, uh, a bit. And I, I think we have to understand that the city, and we also have a fiduciary responsibility to protect the city and protected the taxpayers at the same time, and then deal with the employment or separation issues separately. And I know sometimes those two, I, I get your point, but also keep in mind that we have to make sure that we mind our fiduciary responsibility in that respect as well. So I get, I understand what you're saying, but I also think we have to understand our roles in, in both of those processes. So you say that, and so let me, let me just give you what I'm thinking in my head. You say an officer followed every guideline by the rules. He did nothing illegal, but you still got a person that's suing the city. Even after you said, we looked at everything, we looked at every rules, they followed the thing by the book. We still get sued as a city. And then what you all kinda came up with is not even part of the discussion. And so we wind up paying both ways. We paying with time and energy, and then we're paying with taxpayers money. And so that's why I'm kind of going with this. Well, Actually as he said, it's in reverse because we, we don't put, put the city in a position where an officer or someone has to answer questions on the record ev evidence that may be used against them and us as a city in that, in that respect. So generally, whatever in external proceedings happen, if they're criminal or civil take place first, and then we come back and deal with any internal disciplinary or other processes the city has after the external processes are adjudicated. And I get, I do get your point, but, uh, you know, it's set up that way ultimately to protect taxpayers, even though it has a, it may sometimes have a somewhat adverse effect the way that a lay person may look at that. May I just add one thing? Go ahead. Just to follow up on, um, some of what you were asking about Alder Taylor. Um, so far this year we've had four officers resign on cases that were pending before the police board or were with d o l preparing to go to the police board. So that's just so far in 2023. Um, also our policy research and analysis division, um, recognizes that this is a, this is a bigger problem than we might realize. And so that's one of their current projects that they're focusing on is just kind of getting arms around the scope of resignations and retirements, uh, investigative barriers that exist because of, uh, oftentimes you have one officer, but then you might have other officers that are still on the job. And so we have to finish this investigation, but now we don't have access to somebody that's retired. Retired or resigned. Um, and then additionally what happens, um, there's a credential that can be conferred to a retired officer. What happens when someone resigns or retires rather under serious allegation, um, should that retirement credential be impacted? Those are questions that we have. Um, and that work implicates not just COPA obviously, but, um, p ss a, uh, as well as C P D and they're much broader questions, um, than even we've touched here. But that's kind of an area of focus for us. Yeah, I would love for a pension board to be having a conversation with y'all. 'cause ultimately for egregious stuff. So we gotta pay you on the front end and the back end and the back end. That's, that's matic for me. Um, my next line of question is how are you all coordinating with the new councils? Or are you Sure? Um, so for the commissioners themselves, or seven commissioners, um, they kind of delegated themselves, sort of divvied up responsibilities. So two of the commissioners are working with COPA specifically. And so I meet with them monthly. They were instrumental in CPA's goal setting process for this year, 2023. And we'll be instrumental in my, um, self-evaluation and evaluation as chief administrator, as well as setting our goals for 2024. Um, and then we've also, you know, when we approached this timeliness initiative, we did that in partnership with, uh, C C P S A. I've appeared at many of their public meetings to answer questions, some of them hard questions, um, about challenging issues that we're facing as an agency, but really in an effort to just be transparent with the commission and try to be as collaborative as we can be. Um, the local district councils, there are 22 of them. Um, and so we have to engage in each, they're, they're each a separate body, so we have to engage with each three member council separately. And that's largely, those efforts are largely led by Mac Thurmond, Mackenzie Thurmond from my office. Um, most of your staffers know him as well. Um, but we take much the same, same approach. They are elected officials in those district. And so just like we would, uh, reach out to your office if something in your ward happens, um, that was high profile in nature or whatever, we're trying to make sure we're giving, uh, equal information to the local district councils as well. And also being responsive when they have requests of us, whether it's public meetings or just information, um, and trainings. I was gonna say specifically, we've, uh, we've already presented at eight of the 22, uh, district councils. Uh, uh, but they are also receiving, uh, monthly reports from us, uh, as well as, as she mentioned, as incidents occur, uh, we provide a briefing to to, to those district council members so that they are aware. How are you all bringing young people in this space? Uh, Gion would've been 10 years ago, considered a young person or offense, Guion, maybe 20. Absolutely. But like, how are we bringing young people into this space to talk about how we look at policing and how we make a bunch of these decisions? 'cause I feel like they're the group that's left out of these conversations the most, but based on some of the things that happened, especially since the riots, the young people were there, yeah. They're leading these conversations, frankly, uh, and driving this issue for us as a city. So, um, I'll start and Fram, I know you're gonna add to it, which is great. Um, one thing to note is one of our only, um, non-personnel increases in our budget is geared towards internships and paid internships. Bringing young people in the door to our agency is something that we've done, um, on a volunteer internship basis level. But we wanna expand that. We want people who are concerned about public safety, community safety to understand that this is a viable career path. Um, it's, it's a way to contribute to your community. And so that's something that we're making concerted efforts to. We also are going to be creating a first ever youth advisory council. Um, we have an advisory council that we're reconstituting. Um, the very first chief administrator had one initially. Um, that's something that we're doing this year. But, uh, Ephraim is leading efforts to make sure that we also have a youth advisory council, if you wanna add to that. And then also, um, uh, um, on top of the Youth Advisory Council, um, we have done, uh, almost 200, uh, community events and, and included in those community events. We are in a lot of Chicago public schools, charter schools, uh, talking to, uh, young people. One just about careers. Uh, often they are, um, have those innate skills and abilities that may lead them to law enforcement, uh, but may not have a a, an interest maybe at the moment. Uh, and so we introduce, these are other ways that those same investigative skills and things critical, uh, thinking skills could, uh, also be of use. So we spend a significant amount of time, um, honestly our, uh, commitment to young people. It really comes out of one as we look at a lot of the reforms that occurred. It was after the murder, uh, of Laquan McDonald. And, uh, and as being a kid from the city of Chicago, I am sitting at this di dayus right now because the contributions that were made to me, and that is the same for many of the staff. And so we make that commitment back to young people to ensure that we're pouring into them providing opportunity internships. Uh, we also, uh, have done mock investigations and trainings at, at, at many of these schools with the young people and have invited them to come to our office and spend a day. We do mock briefings, let them talk to any of the staff leadership. Uh, and so we look to look forward to joining some more of that, uh, going into next year. I wanna See us do that citywide. And that's something I'll be willing to do, uh, uh, with you all. A shameless plug, we're having a hiring fair this Saturday, next Saturday at the City colleges. I'll make sure to see you all. We'll Be there. We'll be there. I'm sure we already are. Appreciate it. Y'all scare me with this presentation from kofa. 'cause it's like two budget positions. I'm like, who is that in the box then, if it's only two of them? But I realize that those are all, those are union, uh, positions. Is there anything that the city can do to help you expand this work? Um, there's lots of things that the city can do to help us expand this work. I do, I think, as I was mentioning in my comments, uh, with Alderman LaSpada, our hiring, um, and the city's hiring process in general, that's not just a COPA specific thing. Um, but that does definitely impact us when some of our competitor agencies don't have the same hurdle. So that's one thing. Um, we are also, uh, very interested in, uh, expanding much like the Office of Inspector General, our space, we've outgrown. Um, so that's something we're taking a different path. I think we're much more interested in being located, more rooted in community that we serve. Uh, so we're kind of have been exploring some op options that including in Alderman Burnett's word, potentially. So looking to see if there are Yeah, we can come to your ward too. We'll come wherever. Absolutely. Um, but I think, you know, those are the the ways in which I think I see us growing as an agency. Um, we're putting in the work to, to live up to the potential I think that we have, um, to really start creating transformational change. And I just, I, I hope that city council and, and really all Chicagoans wanna stay committed to this issue. This is one of those pendulum issues, right? That when, when we care because something explosive has happened, everybody, it's all hands on deck. Um, but to Ian's comments earlier, like, this is always going to be necessary work. Um, and it just has to be consistently cared about, um, and cared about in ways that embrace our officers and make sure that they feel heard and understood. Um, and ways in which our community feels that, you know, this version of government here at copa, what we're doing is something they can trust and believe in. It's gonna be different than, than what was before as Alderman Yancy was saying. Um, so, you know, those are the ways I hope to see, um, increased support going forward. But always appreciate your engagement in particular Alder women Taylor. So thank you. So I wanna say, if I could just thank you, this brings another level of transparency to some of the issues and trust that did we don't have with police. This, this body actually, the work that you all doing actually makes this better for us. 'cause that means a, somebody is listening and there's somebody, to your point, Gion, that's looking with a level of, I gotta take myself out of this. Mm-hmm. And so it, it was, it was heartbreaking to see that this happened to how does the police board president get hit by the police. Mm-hmm. So that says something about the system we have, but it also says something about you wanted to stay in that work 'cause I would've quit on my day off, but you're a better band than me. But thank you all just for being transparent and being honest and being able to give that, that, that information to the community. 'cause too often the community does not know they, we don't get to see those. And so I appreciate you all in your level of transparency. Thank you, Mr. President. If I, if I can also add, I think one of the other places that, um, there's a significant need is, uh, support, uh, for impacted families after post an incident. Uh, often the trauma that families are experiencing, uh, they are not surrounded by a lot of resources. We have tried to fill that gap for the city, uh, but is much larger than what we can provide. Let's talk. I got you. Thank you. Um, just for clarity, I have Alderman Vasquez, Chico, and Manna Howorth. Do we have any additional alders wanting to ask questions in this session? Okay. With, yes. We, I was talking about our need also to increase office space, um, and really wanting to engage, uh, in location, location that serves the community that, um, comes to us for, for, uh, the work that we do. And so wanting to make sure that it's a location that makes sense, has to be centrally located, has to be accessible by public transportation. Um, and so we are exploring options with respect to that. There's nothing on the immediate horizon because there is too much need and not enough money, uh, for us as a city. And so we recognize that and we are gonna continue to do what we can with what we have. Um, but we're also looking to build, uh, for the future. Um, like I said earlier, just echoing Ian's comments, this, this work and reform, this is, this is ongoing. Um, and we're trying to build something sustainable, uh, for future generations and for ultimately a healthier Chicago police department, which will mean investing, um, more permanently in, in physical space, uh, for this agency and other accountability agencies. Alright, with that being said, I think we're going to, uh, break at this point, um, for, uh, lunch since we have more than one or two left. Um, we're gonna break and come back at two 30. Um, you all are, uh, you and the staff. Uh, feel free to join us on the third floor. Uh, but we're gonna take a break and we'll be at ease until two 30.