Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards meeting, September 17, 2026
- When: Thu, Sep 17, 2026, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1227517217
- Transcript: full text (26,638 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 34:02 Approval of remote attendance requests under Rule 59
- 34:25 Mayor Johnson's ordinance deferred at sponsor's request
- 34:51 Public comment
- 1:03:25 Gilbert Villegas: Said all members share the goal of protecting renters and expanding housing, voiced…
- 1:05:09 Amendment of Municipal Code to strengthen standards and enforcement mechanisms for residential buildings…
- 1:06:13 Gilbert Villegas: Walked through changes in the substitute, including removing the tier concept, banning…
- 1:16:19 William Conway: Raised concerns that PRO creates a new bureau before budget season and that FAIR adds…
- 1:17:11 Gilbert Villegas: Said a trailer ordinance would raise the foreclosure registry fee to generate about $8…
- 1:18:52 Jessica L. Fuentes: Pointed out that the revenue source described is not in the ordinance under…
- 1:20:27 William Conway: Asked why the office was placed in the Department of Buildings rather than Housing.
- 1:21:04 William Conway: Said he shared unfunded mandate concerns but would vote yes so conversations could continue.
- 1:22:24 Daniel La Spata: Asked whether the Department of Buildings provided feedback and what staffing the new…
- 1:24:07 Daniel La Spata: Raised concern that requiring tenants who lose to pay landlords' legal fees would…
- 1:25:47 Bennett R. Lawson: Noted that the eviction legal assistance program is funded through 2027.
- 1:26:02 Daniel La Spata: Said as a small housing provider he does not understand the need for move-in fees and…
- 1:27:24 Anthony J. Quezada: Asked that the Buildings and Housing commissioners be allowed to testify and moved to…
- 1:30:22 Anthony J. Quezada: Said placing RLTO enforcement in Buildings would stretch the department thin and asked…
- 1:34:46 Anthony J. Quezada: Said about 90 percent of landlords but 10 percent of tenants have lawyers in eviction…
- 1:36:32 Bennett R. Lawson: Said added costs get passed to renters and explained that some landlords use small…
- 1:38:23 Bennett R. Lawson: Objected to portraying LLC ownership as inherently bad while agreeing owners should be…
- 1:51:05 Jessica L. Fuentes: Asked why a registry fee schedule was not included in FAIR and why it does not ban all…
- 1:53:58 Jessica L. Fuentes: Asked the Buildings commissioner whether her staff can currently enforce the RLTO.
- 1:57:21 Timothy R. Knudsen: Flagged the change awarding legal fees to the prevailing party as a risk that could…
- 1:59:06 Timothy R. Knudsen: Said most changes to FAIR were good, the two ordinances are similar, and hoped for a…
- 2:02:00 Brendan Reilly: Asked the commissioners whether the mayor's office directed them to attend and questioned…
- 2:05:30 Brendan Reilly: Said approved housing units fell from about 9,500 in 2023 to 4,900 in 2025 and attributed…
- 2:10:37 Brendan Reilly: Said he would support FAIR because it removes unnecessary fees and moves renter protections…
- 2:13:38 Ruth Cruz: Raised concerns about tenant legal representation and asked whether the chair would compromise on…
- 2:15:53 Ruth Cruz: Asked what new benefits FAIR provides tenants and whether the Department of Housing could play a…
- 2:20:43 Byron Sigcho-López: Said property taxes, interest rates, lending standards and insurance costs drive the…
- 2:23:20 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked how many briefings and hearings were held on FAIR and which stakeholders and…
- 2:29:39 Byron Sigcho-López: Called FAIR budget negative and asked about the scope and timing of the software RFP.
- 2:38:08 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said a rental registry is widely agreed on and questioned why mediation and relational…
- 2:43:57 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said any ordinance needs specifics on staffing and funding rather than leaving costs to…
- 2:44:57 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked why specific methods for notifying tenants of landlord access were removed.
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards, chaired by Alderperson Gilbert Villegas, held a hearing on the FAIR ordinance, a substitute that amends the Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance, adds fee limits, creates a rental registry and places a new Office of Rental Housing in the Department of Buildings; it was presented as an alternative to the mayor's Protecting Renters Ordinance (PRO). A separate item sponsored by the mayor was deferred at the sponsor's request. Sixteen public commenters spoke, with housing providers generally supporting FAIR and tenant and legal aid groups opposing it. Members questioned the ordinance's funding and whether it is an unfunded mandate, whether the Department of Buildings or the Department of Housing should enforce it, a change that would let the prevailing party recover attorney's fees, and the lack of a codified right to counsel; the Buildings and Housing commissioners testified after Alderperson Anthony J. Quezada asked for them to speak. The substitute ordinance passed out of committee on a 12-6 roll call vote, and several members said they expected negotiations between the FAIR and PRO sponsors to continue.
Topics: FAIR ordinance, Protecting Renters Ordinance, Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance, Rental registry, Move-in fees and junk fees, Department of Buildings enforcement, Tenant legal representation, Housing supply
Agenda items discussed
- 34:25 Ordinance sponsored by Mayor Johnson, deferred at the sponsor's request: deferred
- 34:51 Public comment
- 1:05:09 FAIR ordinance: substitute amending the Municipal Code to strengthen standards and enforcement for residential buildings and rental housing: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Gilbert Villegas (chair): Said all members share the goal of protecting renters and expanding housing, voiced concerns about costs in the mayor's proposal, and said Chicago lags peer cities in new construction. (1:03:25); Walked through changes in the substitute, including removing the tier concept, banning certain pet, utility and service fees, aligning deposit caps with the Cook County ordinance, and creating an Office of Rental Housing in the Department of Buildings. (1:06:13); Said a trailer ordinance would raise the foreclosure registry fee to generate about $8 million to fund the registry and Department of Buildings staff. (1:17:11)
- William Conway (alderperson): Raised concerns that PRO creates a new bureau before budget season and that FAIR adds responsibilities to the Department of Buildings, and asked how enforcement would be funded. (1:16:19); Asked why the office was placed in the Department of Buildings rather than Housing. (1:20:27); Said he shared unfunded mandate concerns but would vote yes so conversations could continue. (1:21:04)
- Jessica L. Fuentes (alderperson): Pointed out that the revenue source described is not in the ordinance under consideration and called it an unfunded mandate. (1:18:52); Asked why a registry fee schedule was not included in FAIR and why it does not ban all junk fees. (1:51:05); Asked the Buildings commissioner whether her staff can currently enforce the RLTO. (1:53:58)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked whether the Department of Buildings provided feedback and what staffing the new office would need. (1:22:24); Raised concern that requiring tenants who lose to pay landlords' legal fees would discourage complaints, and asked why right to counsel was not codified. (1:24:07); Said as a small housing provider he does not understand the need for move-in fees and invited explanations. (1:26:02)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Noted that the eviction legal assistance program is funded through 2027. (1:25:47); Said added costs get passed to renters and explained that some landlords use small nonrefundable move-in fees instead of security deposits. (1:36:32); Objected to portraying LLC ownership as inherently bad while agreeing owners should be identifiable. (1:38:23)
- Anthony J. Quezada (alderperson): Asked that the Buildings and Housing commissioners be allowed to testify and moved to allow it, saying the ordinance places an unfunded mandate on Buildings. (1:27:24); Said placing RLTO enforcement in Buildings would stretch the department thin and asked the commissioners for their analysis. (1:30:22); Said about 90 percent of landlords but 10 percent of tenants have lawyers in eviction court and asked why right to counsel was not made permanent. (1:34:46)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Flagged the change awarding legal fees to the prevailing party as a risk that could deter tenants from bringing cases, and suggested restoring the original language. (1:57:21); Said most changes to FAIR were good, the two ordinances are similar, and hoped for a near-unanimous compromise. (1:59:06)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked the commissioners whether the mayor's office directed them to attend and questioned the Buildings commissioner on permit volume. (2:02:00); Said approved housing units fell from about 9,500 in 2023 to 4,900 in 2025 and attributed much of the decline to the Affordable Requirements Ordinance. (2:05:30); Said he would support FAIR because it removes unnecessary fees and moves renter protections forward, while seeing room for compromise. (2:10:37)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Raised concerns about tenant legal representation and asked whether the chair would compromise on a registration fee to fund it. (2:13:38); Asked what new benefits FAIR provides tenants and whether the Department of Housing could play a role. (2:15:53)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Said property taxes, interest rates, lending standards and insurance costs drive the housing slowdown and argued limiting tenant rights would not increase supply. (2:20:43); Asked how many briefings and hearings were held on FAIR and which stakeholders and departments drafted it. (2:23:20); Called FAIR budget negative and asked about the scope and timing of the software RFP. (2:29:39)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Said a rental registry is widely agreed on and questioned why mediation and relational disputes would sit with the Department of Buildings rather than Housing. (2:38:08); Said any ordinance needs specifics on staffing and funding rather than leaving costs to the budget, and that he would ask the council's budget office for cost analysis. (2:43:57); Asked why specific methods for notifying tenants of landlord access were removed. (2:44:57)
Exchanges between members
- 1:16:19 Conway asked the chair how added Department of Buildings enforcement would be funded.
- 1:17:11 Villegas answered Conway that a trailer ordinance raising foreclosure registry fees would fund the registry and staff.
- 1:18:52 Fuentes asked the chair to confirm the described revenue source is not in the ordinance.
- 1:19:33 Villegas disputed Fuentes's characterization of the ordinance as an unfunded mandate.
- 1:20:27 Conway asked why the office was placed in the Department of Buildings instead of Housing.
- 1:21:04 Conway said he shared the 26th Ward alderperson's concerns about an unfunded mandate.
- 1:22:17 La Spata said he would build on Conway's questions about the Department of Buildings.
- 1:24:07 La Spata asked the chair why right to counsel was not codified and about the legal fee provision.
- 1:25:47 Lawson offered a point of information that the legal assistance program is funded through 2027.
- 1:27:33 Quezada asked the chair to allow the Buildings and Housing commissioners to testify and moved to do so.
- 1:28:50 Villegas said the administration's last-minute engagement was frustrating before agreeing to bring the commissioners forward.
- 1:34:27 Quezada thanked the chair for allowing the commissioners to speak.
- 1:34:46 Quezada built on La Spata's point about right to counsel for tenants.
- 1:36:57 Lawson responded to La Spata's question on move-in fees by explaining why some landlords use them instead of deposits.
- 1:51:05 Fuentes asked the chair why FAIR lacks a codified fee schedule and does not ban all junk fees.
- 1:55:34 Fuentes agreed with Lawson that LLCs are not inherently bad but said they should be transparent.
- 1:56:15 Villegas responded to Fuentes that staffing would ramp up as under PRO.
- 1:57:21 Knudsen asked about the intent behind the prevailing-party attorney's fees change.
- 2:00:33 Villegas told Knudsen he would continue talks with colleagues toward agreement.
- 2:10:37 Reilly thanked Villegas for his work and leadership of the zoning work group.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error