City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, one, when entering or exiting the gallery, two, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose, or three, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Propane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms may lead to a breach of the piece or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the Sergeant-at-Arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12. 5. Are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the Sergeant-at-Arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027 Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the Sergeant-at-Arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, 1. When entering or exiting the gallery. 2. When providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or 3. When asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the Sergeant-at-Arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair. Here we are. Here we are. or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027. Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the sergeant-at-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. when entering or exiting the gallery. 2. when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or 3. when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms. Such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago, City Council, Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027. Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times, that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except 1. When entering or exiting the gallery. 2. When providing public comment during the portion of a meeting, set aside for that purpose. Or 3. When asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, may lead to a breach of the peace, or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair, or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers, or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023-2027. Pursuant to Rule 58 of the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, the sergeant-at-arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public. These rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the City Council or any of its committees. All individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request. Individuals must remain seated at all times except, 1, when entering or exiting the gallery, 2, when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose, or 3, when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the City Council. Profane, threatening, harassing, abusive, or defamatory behavior, or speech, which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting, is not permitted. Disruptive or distracting actions, such as the stomping of feet, waving of arms, throwing any item, whistling, booing, shouting, or other loud utterances, are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant-at-arms, such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting. Any item that poses a potential safety hazards, as determined by the sergeant-at-arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1, any pointed objects, including knives of any kind, 2, banners, flyers, or other forms of signage, 3, food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters, 4, backpacks, large bags, and sealed packages, clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search, and 5, firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant-at-arms. City of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings 2023 to 2027. Pursuant. to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the city council or any of its committees all individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request individuals must remain seated at all times except one when entering or exiting the gallery two when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose or three when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council profane threatening harassing abusive or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the meetings chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting is not permitted disruptive or distracting actions such as the stomping of feet waving of arms throwing any item whistling booing shouting or other loud utterances are not permitted when in the judgment of the meetings chair or the sergeant at arms such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting any item that poses a potential safety hazards as determined by the sergeant at arms is prohibited in the gallery such items include but are not limited to one any pointed objects including knives of any kind two banners flyers or other forms of signage three food and beverages including in glass or metal canisters four backpacks large bags and sealed packages clear bags not tinted in color that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12 are permitted and subject to search and five firearms ammunition fireworks laser pointers stun guns tasers mace pepper spray and toy weapons cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode can only be used while seated and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant at arms city of chicago city council rules of conduct for public meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the city council or any of its committees all individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request individuals must remain seated at all times except one when entering or exiting the gallery two when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose or three when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council profane threatening harassing abusive or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting is not permitted disruptive or distracting actions such as the stomping of feet waving of arms throwing any item whistling booing shouting or other loud utterances are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting any item that poses a potential safety hazards as determined by the sergeant at arms is prohibited in the gallery such items include but are not limited to one any pointed objects including knives of any kind two banners flyers or other forms of signage three food and beverages including in glass or metal canisters four backpacks large bags and sealed packages clear bags not tinted in color that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12 are permitted and subject to search and five firearms ammunition fireworks laser pointers stun guns tasers mace pepper spray and toy weapons cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode can only be used while seated and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant at arms city of chicago city council rules of conduct for public meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the city council or any of its committees all individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request individuals must remain seated at all times except one when entering or exiting the gallery two when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose or three when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council profane threatening harassing abusive or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting is not permitted disruptive or distracting actions such as the stomping of feet waving of arms throwing any item whistling booing shouting or other loud utterances are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting any item that poses a potential safety hazards as determined by the sergeant at arms is prohibited in the gallery such items include but are not limited to one any pointed objects including knives of any kind two banners flyers or other forms of signage three food and beverages including in glass or metal canisters four backpacks large bags and sealed packages clear bags not tinted in color that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12 are permitted and subject to search and five firearms ammunition fireworks laser pointers stun guns tasers mace pepper spray and toy weapons cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode can only be used while seated and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be subject to removal from the remainder of the meeting by the sergeant at arms city of chicago city council rules of conduct for public meetings 2023 to 2027 pursuant to rule 58 of the chicago city council rules of order and procedure the sergeant at arms sets forth the following rules of conduct for members of the public these rules shall be in effect at all times that a viewing gallery or room is open for a meeting of the city council or any of its committees all individuals and their belongings are subject to search at entry or upon request individuals must remain seated at all times except one when entering or exiting the gallery two when providing public comment during the portion of a meeting set aside for that purpose or three when asked to rise and be acknowledged by a member of the city council profane threatening harassing abusive or defamatory behavior or speech which in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms may lead to a breach of the peace or disrupt the orderly conduct of the meeting is not permitted disruptive or distracting actions such as the stomping of feet waving of arms throwing any item whistling booing shouting or other loud utterances are not permitted when in the judgment of the meeting's chair or the sergeant at arms such actions are disrupting or impeding the orderly conduct of the meeting any item that poses a potential safety hazards as determined by the sergeant at arms arms, is prohibited in the gallery. Such items include, but are not limited to, 1. Any pointed objects, including knives of any kind. 2. Banners, flyers or other forms of signage. 3. Food and beverages, including in glass or metal canisters. 4. Backpacks, large bags and sealed packages. 5. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 inches by 6 inches by 12, are permitted and subject to search. And 5. Firearms, ammunition, fireworks, laser pointers, stun guns, tasers, mace pepper spray, and toy weapons. Cell phones and other small handheld recording devices must be placed in silent mode, can only be used while seated, and can only be used in a manner that does not interfere with the ability other individuals to view or hear the proceedings. Individuals or... Hopkins and Roofproof. Morning, everyone. It is 1030 on September 17, 2026, and the meeting of the Chicago City Council's Committee on Zoning Landmarks and Building Standards is called to order. We'll start off with a roll call. Nicole, please take the roll. Alderman Laspata. Alderman Hopkins. Alderwoman Dowell. Alder Hall. Alder Harris. Alder Beal. Alder Ramirez. Alder Moore. Alder Mosley. Alder Cito Lopez. Alder Fuentes. Alder Burnett. Alder Cruz. Alder Conway. Alder Casada. Alder Riley. Alder Knudsen. Alder Clay. Vice Chair Lawson. Chair Villegas. How's it? We have David. Oh, and David Moore? We have a quorum. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we have a quorum. Alderwoman Nugent. Thank you, Chairman. Pursuant to my role as President Pro Temp under Rule 36, I intend to participate and vote on matters as an ex-officio member. Thank you. Thank you. Committee members, we have a quorum, as I stated. Aldermen Hall, Beal, Dow, Clay, and Mosley, and non-committee member Rodriguez Sanchez have requested to attend this meeting by remote means under the provisions of Rule 59. May I have a motion to approve the Alderman's request? Alderman LaSpada makes that motion. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? Nay. Impinant the Chair. The ayes have it. Before we get to public comment, I'd like to note that the sponsor for document number 02026-0025391, Mayor Johnson, has requested a deferral. Alderman Vice Chair Lawson makes a motion to defer. All in favor, please say aye. Opposed? Nay. And Impinant the Chair. The ayes have it. And the item is deferred. At this time, we will begin the public comment period in accordance with the City Council Rules of Order and Procedure. Public comment will be limited to 30 minutes. Since there are more than 15 speakers signed up to speak, public comment will be limited to a minute and a half per person, and speakers will be chosen by the lottery. How many do you have? 15. 15. You need to get it. Here's your first three. Our first speaker will be Sheila Dantzler, followed by John Koslowski. Good morning, Chairman, Zoning Committee members. My name is Sheila Dantzler, past chair of the Chicago Association of Realtors, public policy coordinating committee, and member of Chicago Association of Realtors Board of Directors, and a proud resident of Bronzeville. I know this committee is considering the fair ordinance today, but I want to speak today about the pro-ordinance, a policy designed to benefit tenants, but in my view and in the industry's view, will likely achieve the opposite effects. Much of the conversation around rental housing focuses on large corporate landlords, but large investors have options. When the cost or risk of investment in one market becomes too high, they can take their capital elsewhere. Small housing providers like myself do not have that same flexibility. We are mom-and-pop owners, teachers, firefighters, and immigrants with two to ten units who have invested in our communities, often to build towards retirement or to create something for the next generation. And despite what you may have heard, small housing providers are not broadly exempt from pro. If there is a certain exemption, the exemption applies to qualifying owner-occupied properties. Many small housing providers do not live in their buildings and will still be subject to these new requirements and costs. Pro makes it harder and more expensive for those small housing providers to stay in the market. In addition, in pro, security deposits would be capped at one month's rent, and moving fees are effectively prohibited. Thank you. Mr. Kozlowski, followed by Mr. Sam Goldman. Good morning. My name is John Kozlowski. I'm with the Chicagoland Apartment Association. While we appreciate that FAIR takes a more thoughtful approach than the mayor's pro-ordinance, we still have reservations. Yes, FAIR provides meaningful protections for renters. It provides these protections while limiting their deterring effects on crucial future housing production and avoiding additional rent pressures associated with PRO. PRO's only claim to affordability is banning fees that cover real costs for landlords. In reality, the mayor's PRO just reshuffles these fees into rent and pushes one person's move-in costs onto long-term existing tenants, doing nothing for affordability. FAIR allows properties to cover real move-in costs without spreading them around to existing tenant rent. If the fees are disclosed up front, they comply with state law and are related to the actual cost that they cover. Importantly, FAIR also addresses an issue aldermen have consistently identified as a top priority, having a clear mechanism to contact building owners and address problems at individual properties. FAIR's rental registry does this without taxing tenants and providers. Housing policy is hard. It requires thoughtfulness and a genuine desire to get it right. We appreciate that FAIR works to avoid some of the unnecessary burdens included in PRO that make housing more expensive and drive up rents. No ordinance is perfect, and we continue to have concerns about over-regulation. We know that the only way to deliver affordability and better outcomes for tenants is to build more homes and offer more choices. That is where our focus should be. Thank you. Next is Mr. Goldman, followed by Mr. Jonah Karsh. Good morning. I'm Sam Goldman. I live in Wicker Park, and our family has a few hundred units in Chicago that we own, build, and operate ourselves. I'm speaking both on FAIR and PRO this morning. Briefly, my biggest concern with PRO, as constituted, comes down to security and safety of information and the rental registry component. In March of this year, there was a cybersecurity incident affecting the ARO application intake email account at Department of Housing. I'm concerned that they have not yet implemented appropriate guardrails to security. cure sensitive tenant data. Similarly, the city should collect only the information necessary to accomplish its regulatory and enforcement goals. Before requiring anyone to report vacancy or occupancy data, the City Council needs to consider whether the information is actually necessary for enforcement. It's the City Council's duty to ensure adequate safeguards exist to protect both the data as a practical matter, vulnerable tenants, including survivors of domestic violence and stalking who could be harmed if their residency or occupancy status gets into the hands of third parties. That's a major concern. Thank you. Thank you. Next speaker is Jonah Karsh, followed by Rakeem Ughad. Good morning. My name is Jonah Karsh. I'm with the Metropolitan Tenants Organization, Chicago's oldest citywide tenants rights organization. We appreciate some of the changes that have been made to the fair ordinance. Unfortunately, after reading through the ordinance, and I know it's constantly being updated, we have still noticed numerous places where it's taking away rights from tenants. And I know that Alderman Villegas has committed to fix some of them. I'm just going to name some more that we still found. Fair changes the language that entitles tenants to statutory damages when they are locked out of their units illegally from a shall to a may, which means that under recent appellate case law, judges may have discretion not to award tenant any damages or maybe even not to let them back into their unit if the landlord is found to have locked them out. Fair changes attorney's fees shifting from prevailing plaintiff to prevailing party, which means that if a tenant sues their landlord and they don't have representation, which unfortunately is most often the case, they could be left with thousands of dollars in attorney's fees for their landlord if they don't prevail. So this ordinance still needs a ton of work and it takes away rights. And I hope that the Alderman of the City Council will not go on record with a vote that takes away tenants rights. That said, we have to negotiate to get to something that doesn't do that. And I look forward to that. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Karsh. Next speaker is Rakeem Ukhad, if I hope I'm saying it correctly, followed by Ron Abrams. Good morning. Hi, everyone. My name is Rakeem Ukhad. I'm a South Sider and a resident of Chicago's Third Ward. I wanted to come out this morning to urge this committee to vote in favor of the Protecting Renters Ordinance. In my ward, nearly 50 percent of residents are renters. In the South Loop, where I live with my kids, nearly 75 percent of residents are renters. And we deal with a market that has not nearly enough housing and comes with all of the hurdles and strings that we are familiar with. Move in fees, deposits, etc. I believe that housing is a human right. I believe that we have failed to prioritize the development of housing in our city. And it has made young professionals like myself settle into a perpetual cycle of high rents and high fees while the dream of homeownership slips further and further away. I am lucky to have a private rental relationship with someone who I find fairly reasonable. But I've dealt with the horrors of renting through a large rental company. I have paid thousands of dollars in move-in and move-out fees. I've paid hundreds of dollars in application fees. I've been forced to sign an NDA after discovering that my child was being feasted on by bedbugs. All of this after being assured that they had treated the apartment before I moved in. Corporate landlords have so much control over our lives and well-being. Our government should be fighting to protect Chicagoans and not the wealthy out-of-towners who fill some of your campaign committees. The Protecting Renters Ordinance strengthens the position of renters in our city. It offers the support to renters instead of rolling back protections that have been in place for 40 years. This city is mostly renters. I think you all can decide which side you're on. I would encourage you all. Thank you. Our next speaker is Ron Abrams, followed by Julie Dorkin. Hi, I'm Ron Abrams. I own and manage approximately 2,000 units in the city of Chicago. I'm not bringing notes here. I'm not going to read off a piece of paper. I'm going to tell you the facts. The facts are, if PRO passes, tenants will pay more in rent. The costs that go up, such as not having any fees, capping fees, creating a whole new bureaucracy that's going to charge each building a fee, those fees are going to be passed on. Much like taxes, property taxes go up, rents go up. The other thing that's really troubling from yesterday is we heard from the Department of Housing that they're going to create 28 new jobs. They're going to charge $22 million. I tell you right now, and I'm a betting guy, I'd love to bet anyone here, they will not spend $22 million. They'll spend $100 million. And they're going to create 28 new jobs. Who's getting those jobs? We already heard that there's four people that are already in line. Is that a promotion? Is that patronage? Who's going to give them those jobs? Once again, we are making housing more expensive, not more affordable. The Department of Housing, Department of Law, they all can do things for us right now. It's kind of like saying the fire department can't put out a fire. So let's make a second fire department to take over what the fire department isn't doing in the first place. This is crazy. And I'm upset because I know my renters are going to pay more. Sorry. Thank you. Our next speaker is Julie Dworkin, followed by Barice Uxel. Sorry. Morning. I'm Julie Dworkin with Institute for the Public Good. We're here today because tenants in Chicago are struggling. Here are some of the facts. 90% of tenants lack legal representation in eviction court, which leads to three times the eviction rate than when tenants have representation. There are currently no limits to what a landlord can charge a tenant to move in or move out. And ownership of large apartment buildings by LLCs is nearly quadrupled, leaving tenants with scarce information on who to contact when things go wrong. The fair ordinance is not a fair and balanced approach to strengthening tenant protections. It is not a compromise. It is a rolling back of tenants' rights that will cause significant harm. It will no longer allow tenants who must live in terrible conditions due to landlord negligence to collect damages based on the fact that the value of the apartment has been diminished. It creates a vague standard for when landlords can be held accountable for a lack of essential services when they're not directly responsible for the loss. And it requires tenants to pay attorney fees if they take their landlord to court for things like an illegal lockout and they lose due to a lack of representation. For those of you who think the pro and fair ordinances are essentially the same, they are not. Fair will not provide legal supports to tenants going through evictions. It will not ban move-in fees. It will not provide full transparency in ownership of properties, and it creates an aspirational office of rental housing that is subject to appropriation without fees to funds to pay for it. For those of you who think that a yes vote today is a strategic move to leverage a compromise, let me be clear. A yes vote today is a vote against Chicago's 600,000 renter families. I urge a no vote. Our next speaker is Boris Uxel, followed by Ileana Harvey. Hi, my name is Marty Lunkus. I'm a lifelong Chicago resident. I live on the north side. And I'm here to ask questions about both the pro and fair proposed ordinances. And my question center around three issues being openly discussed in the chamber about both proposed ordinances. And just a quick comment here before I get started, I'd like to compliment the elders of both housing and zoning for engaging in this robust discussion on housing. We haven't had that under past administrations. So moving on, three issues real quick, the rental registry, fees and fines that would fund this new office of rental housing assistance, and the premise that Chicago is an outlier to other sister cities. Okay, the rental registry. The Department of Buildings on their website dated in 2017 is when they shut down the building registry. There used to be a building registry. And the reason for no longer requiring a registry is because they said they had the technology to be able to find the owners. So this discussion about LLCs is kind of not really holding true because the city is able to do that. They were able to do that with Susie, the owner of all those properties. They found her with the lots around the city. They found her and unraveled her LLCs. So they were the Department of Law here was able to do that. And she's fine hundreds of millions of dollars now. Secondly, fines and fees, $22 million, 28 new jobs. What is the city's record on collecting parking fees? Thank you, Boris. Our next speaker is Ileana Haven or Harvey and then George, followed by George Blakemore. I'm a lifelong resident of Chicago, passionate about the creation of deeply affordable and accessible housing. I've lived in many wards and neighborhoods in my lifetime, such as Logan Square, Humboldt Park, Hermosa, Belmont Cragen, Little Village, and now near Westside. I also own a condo unit, but the one issue I continue to see across the spectrum is that renters continue to deal with unhealthy living environments, often facing a retaliation for speaking up on the conditions they have been forced to live in. Folks with disabilities, as well as seniors and veterans, frequently struggle to locate deeply affordable units that match their specific needs, and we're also more likely to rent. And there's a large lack of those accessible units. Unfortunately, if FAIR continues to advance, I fear that the promise not to roll back our current tenant protections will be lost in the fight to win against PRO. Frankly, tenant protections should have been considered by this group and communicated with housing advocates long before PRO was introduced. We should not be excusing the lack of time for poor policy measures. I sincerely hope that FAIR does not leave this committee today for the sake of the disabled community, our seniors, veterans, and other marginalized residents of Chicago. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Mr. Blakemore, followed by Jeff Weinberg. Where are you? The zoning committee. Yesterday, it was the housing. So I was expecting to hear something particular about zoning. You can zone anything, anytime, anywhere, with the zoning in the city of Chicago. It's pay to play. So my white brothers and big head Trump is not here. The zoning, the zoning in the city of Chicago. To clean up this democratic small. They can't Trump is doing this. You, all of y'all, got all of these, whatever they call themselves, that represent you. They need term limitations. It's too many of them. 50 of them. New York only has $25. And term limits. You stay two times and you get your A out. This has to change. This is a sex fool here. A democratic sex fool here. And Big Ed Trump didn't have a damn thing to do with it. The white ones, the black ones, the Hispanic, the Asian are all corrupt. They 69 each other. What? Mr. Blakemore, you're using that kind of language. They look good. They speak good. They talk good. They dress good. And they're not a piece. And they're all a piece of it. That's right. And you all are. So to have them, to represent you, to misrepresent you. Thank you, Mr. Blakemore. Our next speaker is Mr. Weinberg, followed by Leah Levenger. Hi. Good morning. Thank you for having this session today. My name is Jeff Weinberg. I've lived in Chicago. My entire life for 63 years. My parents were born in this city. I love this city. I'm a housing provider on the north side of the city. I support the FAIR ordinance. The last-minute removal of key provisions, like just cause eviction, makes one thing clear, that the PRO ordinance is fundamentally half-baked. FAIR avoids many of the worst excesses of PRO and should advance to provide an alternative for continued negotiation. A $22 million starting budget for the Bureau of Rental Housing services won't keep pace with the reality. Regulating Chicago's 626,000 rental units requires massive administration and infrastructure. And as rental registry expands, the Bureau's bureaucracy and operating costs will inevitably balloon. $40 to $60 per unit will also balloon. A frequent response from supporters of PRO is that renters are willing to pay the fee. When it grows and drives rent even higher, will they still be willing? Will the majority of good renters who have good landlords be willing to pay the expenses needed by the few? Most housing providers provide good, safe, and affordable housing. They take care of the residents. If you only operate with a stick and beat down all the landlords, renters will lose. You can't make housing more affordable by making it more expensive to provide housing. FAIR represents a path towards minimizing the new added costs of providing housing. It's time for the city to sit down with all stakeholders and address the real problems and implement the solution that addresses the housing shortage. Thank you. The next speaker is Leah Levenger, followed by Mike Glasser. Good morning, Council Members. My name is Leah Levenger. I'm an attorney with Legal Action Chicago. We are a nonprofit closely affiliated with Legal Aid Chicago, the largest provider of legal services, providing free legal services to over 30,000 Chicago residents each year. There is significant concern among the legal aid community about the language and FAIR. We oppose FAIR because it will take away longstanding tenants' rights, even in its modified version. I appreciate that the sponsors of the FAIR ordinance say they do not want to roll back existing tenants' rights. I do not know your intentions. I cannot look into your hearts. I cannot look into your minds. What I can do as an attorney with a law degree from Yale Law School is conduct a legal analysis of the text of the legislation that was available as recently as 9 a.m. this morning. And I can tell you that objectively, that legal language will have the effect of taking away rights that tenants in our city have had for the last 40 years. Under the language made available to the public, landlords will be able to get away with illegally locking out tenants out of their home without the possibility of police intervention to restore tenants to their lawful home. FAIR also significantly reduced the likelihood that landlords who engage in illegal lockouts will experience a consequence from the legal system, even if a tenant goes to the hardship and expense of suing after being illegally locked out of their home. FAIR also imposes new risks for tenants who do try to use the legal system to vindicate their rights. Under FAIR, if a tenant has experienced a violation of their rights under the RLTO and takes action against their landlord, but is ultimately not able to prove up their case decisively to win, which can happen for numerous reasons, that tenant will incur the landlord's legal fees. Practically speaking, you are closing the door of the courtroom to tenants who have valid claims against their landlord under the RLTO. Thank you. Thank you. Next speaker is Mr. Mike Lasser, followed by Cassie Armia Warren. So this week, I have two things going on. One is I had to bring my automobile in for repair, and I'm dealing with these ordinances. And there's a weird similarity. My car had some major problems. Opened up the hood, and there were a lot more problems and warning lights going off. This week, we seem to have resolved two major problems with the pro-ordinance, and that is lifting just cause and lifting relocation fees. We learned that earlier this week. But bring the hood up, and there are still major significant problems with the pro-ordinance. Now, as a housing provider, we always like to say that good housing laws come about when the housing people are consulted and brought into the process. Thank you, Alderman Villegas, for bringing us in to the process of negotiating and discussing what it's like to own our own units and what problems we have. The pro-ordinance eliminates our ability to take move-in fees, which is a major component of how we do business. And we've learned that tenants, half the tenants at least, would prefer a lower non-refundable move-in fee than a security deposit. This is input that only comes about from us interacting and being part of the process. And we appreciate the aldermen for including us in the process of discussing this ordinance, and we look forward to fair passing so we can continue to work with the city council and get a proper resolution to these issues. Thank you. Next speaker is Cassie Armia-Warren, followed by Fianne Meccano. Good morning. My name is Cassie Armia-Warren with the Metropolitan Tenants Organization. The alders-backing fair want you to believe that they are helping to meet in the middle, to improve upon pro in ways that benefit both tenants and landlords. That is simply not true. Fair erects new obstacles for tenants seeking justice and allow those who violate laws to evade accountability and responsibility. The fair proposal will make it worse for tenants and families renting in Chicago as the fair ordinance takes away existing tenant rights. Our eviction prevention program serves 100% low-income tenants and families, of which 60% or more are women and the majority are black. If you are thinking that a vote for fair is a politically savvy move to block pro from advancing, I urge you to consider the lives of your low-income constituents, black constituents, and women constituents in your ward. A vote for fair is a vote to further disenfranchise low-income tenants and families, black people, and women in the neighborhoods you have promised to support. Please vote no. Our next speaker is Fianne McConnell, followed by Tracy Scanlon. Thank you for the opportunity to speak about housing in Chicago. I'm urging you to vote no on pro. My name is Fianne. I'm a resident of the 32nd Ward. Thank you. According to U.S. Census Bureau Bill and Permit Survey of 2025, Chicago produced just 3,916 housing units, ranked just ahead of Omaha, Nebraska. We are dead last among 21 jurisdictions with a population of more than 1 million. Smarter people than me will argue that we need to address the zoning code. Others will point out to a building code that needs reforming. Fin田��. Thanks. You. I'd like to add one additional reform, and that's for a better, fairer RLTO. But I'll have more on that in a bit. How biased is the RLTO? Turbo Tenant recently compiled a list of the eight worst states to invest in real estate in 2026. I'm happy to report we aren't number one. We have a strong showing at number four. Cook County, home to Chicago, is Illinois' biggest and most active real estate market. Landlords can benefit from high rental demand, but effective property tax rates have skyrocketed in recent years. Multiple reassessment cycles often blindside the state owners with unexpectedly high bills, considering that Illinois has one of the nation's most underfunded pension systems, and property taxes have historically filled that gap. In other bad news for investors, Chicago's residential landlord tenants is one of the most tent-friendly municipal codes in the U.S., requiring a lengthy eviction process. Yesterday, we heard from Mayor Johnson's representatives on how eviction counseling will save money, and the evidence says... Thank you, Mr. McConnell. Our final speaker is Mr. I'm sorry, Tracy Scanlon. I'm sorry. Mrs. Tracy Scanlon. My apologies. I'll respond to anything. Good morning. My name is Tracy Scanlon. I'm a lifelong Chicagoan. This is where I live, where I work, and I serve my community. I'm a housing provider and the president of the Women Housing and Income Providers. I'm also one of the few women that does this work professionally. Most of my clients are small building owners, retired teachers, working families, people who have full-time jobs, who hire me because Chicago's housing laws have become too confusing to navigate alone. The days of the mom-and-pop landlord are disappearing, not because they don't care, but because staying compliant now requires professional help. Renters deserve safe homes, but Chicago already has the right-to-counsel program for tenants facing eviction, and illegal lockouts are already prohibited under the RLTO. When neither pro nor fair creates a single new apartment or lowers the cost of property taxes, insurance, utilities, labors, or repairs, you cannot regulate housing into becoming affordable. More fees, paperwork, and legal risk become higher rents, stricter screenings, and fewer improvements. When small owners like me give up, their buildings are often purchased by multinational corporations. It does not preserve affordable housing. It wipes it out. I'm in favor of fair. You cannot protect renters by driving responsible housing providers like me out of Chicago. Please help us preserve affordable housing and make small housing providers who make it possible. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, that concludes the public comment period. I'd like to acknowledge Alderman Cicho Lopez and Alderman Riley for the purposes of quorum, non-member Alderman Andre Vasquez, and then also would like a motion to accept Alderman Hopkins for Rule 59. Alderman Riley makes that motion. All in favor, please say aye. Opposed, nay. Impenitude, the ayes have it. Thank you. So ladies and gentlemen, I'll start off with a statement. We have a PowerPoint, and then we'll get to the questions that everyone's so anxious to ask. So good morning, colleagues. I want to begin by acknowledging that everyone here and the city council as a whole has the same goal, protecting renters, increasing housing, and making our city more affordable. The question and discussion being had, which is a good discussion, is how. Chicago's housing affordability challenge is real, and our focus should be on policies that expand housing options while keeping costs manageable for residents. I have concerns with the mayor's proposal, and that's why we put forward an alternative, particularly provisions that could increase the cost of operating for rental housing. I am happy that the administration recently removed the proposed just cause eviction provision, which was one of the concerns raised by city council members, as well as the absorbent amounts of relocation fees. Illinois also continues to face challenges in housing construction and permitting. Chicago is dead last amongst its peer cities for new construction, and Illinois is second worst in the country. Only Alaska is worse than us. If we want greater affordability, we need to increase housing supply, encourage responsible development, and remove unnecessary barriers to construction. As someone who worked on economic development, zoning permitting, and housing issues, I believe development and housing operations have to be considered together. We should all work together to pursue policies that protect residents, while also encouraging investment, new construction, and more housing choices. The goal should be simple. More housing, more choices in Chicago, where families can afford to live, and businesses can continue to invest. Thank you. As I stated, we have only one item on the agenda, which is document number 02026-0027202, the Amendment Municipal Code Chapter to the Strength Standards and Enforcement Mechanisms for Residential Building. This item has a substitute ordinance. All committee members will find a copy of the substitute ordinance in the shared drive and before you. may have a motion to accept the substitute. Vice Chair Lawson makes a motion to accept the substitute ordinance. All in favor, please say aye. Aye. Oppose. Nay. And appear to the chair. The ayes have it. The substitute is before us. So, ladies and gentlemen, this is a hearing on the ordinance fair. And what we'll go through is what the original introduction was versus what the changes were. And then we'll have the Director of Legislative Reference Bureau here to answer any questions from members of the zoning committee as well as non-members. So, as we submitted fair, we were removing the tier concept because we heard both from tenant organizations as well as housing providers that the tier portion that we had submitted was just not a good approach. And so we listened and so we removed that, as well as including applicable definitions and other related provisions. We are retaining the existing exclusion for units in owner-occupied buildings with six or fewer units, subject to the additional RLTO section under the introduced ordinance. And we're removing broad disclosure requirements for all marketing material, application, and leases. Next. We're also removing the provisioning, allowing the landlord to recover possession through no-faultification related to occupancy by a qualified relative, debilition, substantial rehabilitation, removal for residential use. Recovery of possession for those purposes will be treated as non-renewal, subject to the applicable prior notice requirements. We're retaining existing RLTO notice requirements for non-renewal and rent increases, 30 days for tenancies of six months or less, 60 days for tenancies between six months and three years, and 120 days for tenancies of three-plus years. Again, we heard from both the industry that this was something they wanted to see, so we went ahead and – tenant organizations and industry both agreed that that was – should stay there, so we went ahead and accommodated that. We're prohibiting landlords from charging both one-time pet fees and monthly pet-related fees, prohibiting landlords from converting unpaid late fees, pet fees, or utility charges into rent, including for the purposes of an eviction proceeding. Again, that's something that we heard from folks that we were engaging with. Prohibiting landlords from applying rent payments to not-rent charges. Prohibiting landlords from charging any markup on utility bills. Another thing we heard from tenant organizations. Prohibiting leases from imposing fees for service calls and maintenance requests, unless the condition – unless the condition was deliberately or negligent caused by the tenant or a guest. Prohibiting non-disparagement clauses in leases. Clarifying that following an insufficient or defective notice of non-renewal, a tenant may retain possession of the unit through the later of the expiration of the lease or the required minimum notice period of receiving a correct notice. We're retaining the existing CPD enforcement of prohibition lockouts, but subject to the higher fines included in the introduced version of fare, between $25,000 and $5,000 plus $1,000 per day, as opposed to between $200,000 and $500,000 per day under the RLTO. So we've increased that fee to make sure that we're making – we're taking care of the tenants. Next slide, please. We're incorporating the recently enacted state junk fee ban, including by incorporating the prohibitions on specified junk fees and the related transparency and disclosure requirements under state law. Clarifying that disclosing or renaming on otherwise prohibited fees does legalize the fee. Aligning cap on security deposit and move-in fee requirements with the Cook County RLTO, including by imposing a cap of one-and-a-half months rent and security deposits. Removing the prohibition on requiring both a security deposit and a move-in fee and requiring move-in fees to be reasonably related to estimated costs associated with the tenant moving in, such as additional security or trash removal. We're also incorporating and aligning provisions regarding the $50 cap on application fees, the process for a landlord to seek reimbursement for excess costs, and acceptance of reusable tenant reports, each under – the State Landlord and Tenant Act, which recently passed, extending various cure rights to align with corresponding cure rights under the Cook County RLTO and other provisions of the City RLTO, including for failure to attach a summary of the RLTO to business days and compliance violations related to security deposits of seven calendar days, removing provision imposing liability on landlords resulting from a landlord's inability to access a unit in alignment with the State Landlord and Tenant Act and the Cook County RLTO, removing broad provision granting tenants the ability to pay any fee in installments without limitations, and clarifying landlord may seek to recover possession and unpay rent in accordance with state law and similar to the Cook County RLTO. Removing a rebuttal presumption that a landlord retaliated through a non-renew or rent increase that is materially larger than increases on comparable units to avoid potential unintended consequences and conflicts with existing rebuttal presumptions, which are consistent across state law, the Cook County RLTO, and the existing City RLTO. Retaining the existing protections for tenants joining a tenant union, clarifying that professionals engaged by tenants to perform minor repairs must be insured in addition to being licensed. Aligning landlord disclosures with information required for registering the unit so tenants have consistent sources of information to know who owns the building, who manages the building, where to send required notices, and who to contact for repair and maintenance requests, and requiring landlords to post the above information in an accessible common area on or the exterior of the building. So this is information related to the rental registry. Clarifying the requirement to disclose the use of certain software and services to focus on the use of dynamic pricing or non-public competitive date in setting rent and fees as opposed to disclosing whether the landlord utilizes undefined third-party revenue software or service. Again, we're concerned about that. Establishing a new Office of Rental Housing within the Department of Buildings to administer the RLTO, receive complaints and issue citations for the several violations subject to fines on the RLTO, and mediating disputes and offering referral services to legal aid and other pro bono assistance for both tenants and landlords and landlords. The powers of the duties of the Office of Rental Housing include maintaining the new rental registry, including a searchable record of documented violations, administering the RLTO and where applicable, investigating and issue citations for violations, offering a voluntary mediation service to resolve dispute between tenants and landlords to minimize potentially costly judicial enforcement, providing referral services to both tenants and landlords for pro bono legal and counseling services, providing outreach and education about the RLTO and related laws and rules regarding rental housing, recommending policies in order to the city council to increase housing supply in the city, in the city. Expanding and clarifying the framework for various policies and programs to increase city's housing supply, clarifying that the commissioner of building will develop and propose legislation to the city council to establish these policies and programs, clarify expanding proposals streamlined approvals to include the adaptive reuse of non-residential structures in addition to conversion projects, adding projects containing 40 units or more and removing language requiring approvals to be quasi by right. Again, we've got to get to the root cause of the affordability issue. We need to build, build, build, and supply has been the lack of supply has been the main driver of why we've continued to see rents increase in the city of Chicago. Adding a seven-day cure period for failure to register a unit following the ordinance's effective date to encourage voluntary compliance as opposed to potentially costly enforcement actions. The new cure period does not apply to knowing misrepresentation of information. Extending the rental registry period every two years to align with the other city renewal timelines. Adding provisions detailing city council's expectations for implementation on the ordinance, including requiring the commissioner of buildings and the commissioner of housing to develop a transition plan to establish the office of rental housing, including the reassignment of employees, any budget implications, and the transfer of records and equipment. Requiring the commissioner of buildings to submit proposed legislation. Implementing the programs and policies to increase the city's housing supply. The committee on zoning landmarks and building standards within 180 days of the effective date. Requiring the commissioner of buildings to report on such proposed legislation before hearing on the committee of zoning landmarks and building standards within 30 days after submission. Again, why the changes? We've heard from the community. We've heard from stakeholders. And we've heard from our colleagues as to how to try to get to a compromise. And by fair. Again, we deal with the making sure we're protecting renters, setting forward a solid path for housing providers, as well as encouraging those folks that want to invest in the city of Chicago a pathway. So we're going to address root cause of housing unaffordability, encourage growth. Again, we need more housing units in order to cap some of these, strike that, to make sure that we're creating more competition, which in turn lowers rent. We've seen this work in places like Austin, Nashville, and Phoenix, where they've had a huge supply. And in turn, rents have stabilized, in some cases have gone down. Maintains and enhances ROTO protections, fair compromise that addresses needs and does not limit growth opportunity. All right. And with that, I'll open up to any questions. We do have, as I stated before, we do have Director of Legislative Reference Bureau in the box, Michael Hollett, to answer any questions. Alderman Conway, followed by Alderman LaSpada. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I certainly feel for the plight and rights of renters. I, myself, my mom and I moved into a rental apartment when I was eight years old, right in the heart of the 44th Ward, in fact. And now I'm 48 years old. I managed to move out, but my mother is still renting the same apartment. You know, a concern I have about the pro ordinance that passed housing yesterday is that it seemingly creates a new bureau and new jobs on the eve of a budget season where we are going to have to make some tough choices. But, you know, the other side of that coin, a concern I have about this ordinance is it seems like we're adding a lot to a lot of responsibility to the Department of Buildings. But, you know, so how do we think about the additional funding that it may take to enforce some of the things in here? And Mr. Chairman, that can be to you or to Mr. Hollett or however you choose. Yeah, so I'll answer that answer that question. And if Director Hollett would like to chime in, he can chime in. So we have proposed a trailer ordinance that will be introduced and will be introduced rather September 23rd. That will take a look at requiring on the rent on the foreclosure registry, a seven hundred dollar every six month fee for the registry. And based on our analysis, that has the ability to generate approximately eight million dollars. And that funding will be used to stand up the registry as well as provide any type of revenue for any type of staff that the Department of Buildings needs in order to carry out the duties that we're putting forward. Listen, when we talk to when renters are having concerns and complaints, typically they're building code violations and building issues. And so that's why we feel that this is the proper department to house it in. And so we'll be working closely with our Department of Building and also our Department of Housing where applicable to make sure that those departments have the necessary resources in order to make sure that we are protecting renters. Also making sure we're putting a path for housing providers, as well as signaling to those folks that want to invest in the city of Chicago that we're prepared to accept those investments. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I wasn't quite done. I don't know if that's. Oh, OK. I'm sorry. I didn't hear. Anyway, Alderman Fuentes has a point of clarification. The the revenue source that you're discussing does not exist in the ordinance that we are discussing today. Is that correct? That's correct. But it is under the powers of duty where we talk about the ability to to provide a an opportunity for the Department of Buildings to issue an RFP to seek that software in order to provide that that up, that that process to to collect that revenue. So we are putting forward giving the Department of Building Commissioner the authority to to seek that type of technology. But in this case, we are we in this ordinance, we have an unfunded mandate. No, no, we don't. It would be what we're going to do is utilize the existing staff while the Department of Building is entering into the RFP. No different than what Pearl was doing with their with their bureau, whereas the first year they were using existing staff. And then as they continue to build up their system, that would in turn require additional staff. The there there is technology out there, given if I was the former chairman of economic capital. The last U.S.C.I. momentary understand that чуть-ч year has been under a radar basis. Unavionate. I'm sorry. technology, and when the rental registry was discussed in pro and also in fair, there were a lot of companies throughout the country that reached out to talk about this type of technology that's currently being used in different states and municipalities. And quite frankly, there's an opportunity there to collect that revenue a lot quicker versus the three-year ramp that the pro ordinance is recommending. Alderman Conway? Yeah, the second question I was going to ask, which I think you pretty much answered, but if you want to add more as to, you know, what made you decide to put this in the Department of Buildings versus the Department of Housing? You did speak to that in terms of building code violations, but sure. Thank you for that question, Mr. Conway. That is correct. The majority of calls for services related to renters' issues are building-related, and so we wanted to make sure that was there. Now, as we continue to work through this, if the Department of Housing needs to be engaged, then we'll make sure that that department has the necessary resources to also be a part of it. Right. You know, I share the concerns that the alder person of the 26th Ward gave about an unfunded mandate, but I do appreciate that you put some thought of this. And I will be honest, because of concerns, I thought about voting no on both pro and fair. But despite those concerns, I am going to vote yes on this ordinance today so that the conversations can continue. And as those conversations can continue, I hope that we are balancing concerns of disincentivizing development, which I appreciate, Mr. Chairman, that you said in your remarks, as well as concerns about adding to city bureaucracy at a time when we're stretched on the budget side and we're stretched on the obligations, you know, the obligations that we have. So I'm going to vote yes on that, but I certainly do have concerns about how this is going forward, and I want to thank you for your work in this area. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Conway. Alderman Laspada, followed by Alderman Quesada, followed by Vice Chair. Let me write this down here. Hold on a second. Alderman Laspada. Thank you very much, Chairman. I appreciate the work on the ordinance and the conversation here today. I'm going to, to a certain extent, piggyback off of Alderman Conway's questions. I'm curious if anyone is here today representing the Department of Buildings or if Department of Buildings provided feedback on the ordinance? They did provide some feedback, and the members of the committee should have received that information from the Department of Buildings. Can you summarize that feedback? Excuse me? Can you summarize that feedback for those of us who don't have it in front of us? It is in the shared drive, but we'll get that to you. I feel... Commissioner is here. You can ask her a question. Commissioner Hopkins is here? No, she's not here. Well, that's what... Yes, she is. She's right there. I'm not trying to ask a gotcha question. I'm really not. Okay. Let me continue to move in this direction. So do we have a sense of what the head count is that's needed to administer the new Office of Rental Housing as being proposed? So, again, what we're proposing is the Office of Rental Services, since we think that the majority of calls related to rental complaints are often building departments related. And so we'll be working closely with the building department to make sure that that department has the necessary resources. And so we're waiting to see what requests that would be. But we do have a funding mechanism to make sure that we can fund whatever necessary staff that the Department of Buildings would require. Do we have a sense of what that staffing capacity is? No. We'll have discussions with Department of Building to see what current staff's there and what type of other potential positions you would need in order to carry out the duties. Okay. I have a question related to a couple of pieces related to legal representation, because I know that this, I don't want to, no pun intended, I don't want to relitigate yesterday's vote. I do want to speak to you today, because I know that the ordinance in front of us does not include a codification of the right to counsel program. It does say if you're a tenant, and for whatever reason you fail to prove up the claims, that you are then responsible for your landlord's legal fees. Understanding as well that landlords, 90 percent, tend to have legal representation. I'm concerned that this will have a chilling effect on bringing up complaints related to your living conditions. How would you speak to that? Well, I think that, you know, the city has utilized CDBG funds in order to provide that legal defense, and I think that there's still an opportunity to continue to use CDBG funds in order to provide those same legal services. It's not codified in the ordinance, but definitely we're looking forward to seeing how we can incorporate that into the budget. Can you speak to, like, why it wasn't included in your ordinance? Because there isn't... Well, because there's... We've historically used CDBG funds to provide that services, and so the thought was to continue using CDBG funds in order to provide that service. That would be a budget decision when the budget comes around for us to vote on. Alderman Lawson? Thank you. Just a point of information. My understanding is that that program is fully funded through 2027 using CDBG funds. So it's... Right. Arpa. Right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, sir. I want to get to my colleagues' questions as well. As someone who, like, used to be just a homeowner, now a housing provider, the conversation around move-in fees, at some point, someone will have to enlighten me a little bit further. Because we have tenants moving in this week. We're not charging them a move-in fee because it strikes me that they're already bearing all of the cost of moving into the first floor apartment. I mean it so seriously. Like, the notion of charging them $500, $600 to essentially, like, open the door or having their moving van pull up is genuinely baffling to me. And maybe that's how I experience it, and on the scale of a two or three flat, if there's folks who, I mean this sincerely, want to email me on the economic necessity of move-in fees, perhaps on larger buildings, I'm happy to educate myself further, but I genuinely, like, and particularly in talking to my wife, I do not grasp it. So, I just wanted to make that point, and I'll yield the floor to colleagues. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Casada, followed by Alderman Lawson, followed by Wentman. Thank you, Chairman. This proposed ordinance clearly talks about and establishes a lot of responsibilities for the Department of Buildings. I know that Commissioner Marlene Hopkins is here. Has she been allowed to testify on this matter? Can she testify today? No, we will provide, whatever questions you have, we will provide through the chair. But she is here. I know that the Commissioner, Commissioner Castaneda of the Department of Housing is also here. I understand that. Can we allow both commissioners to testify on this ordinance? Any questions that you have, we'd be more happy to get them through the chair. Listen, this ordinance has been introduced for well over two months. At any time, those commissioners could have engaged, tried to figure it out. You are putting an unfunded mandate on this department. The RTLO has nothing to do with the building code, and you are making someone do work that their department is not available to do, and you're also preventing them from speaking in this public forum to help inform the public about this ordinance. Are you refusing to allow the commissioners to testify? We're not preventing anyone. If you have any questions... Can we allow the commissioner to testify? When we have any questions, we'd be more than happy to get these... I make a motion to allow the commissioner to testify. All right. We'll get a second. You don't need a needle, sir. So, no problem. Again, we're not trying to hide the ball here. The frustration is that this ordinance was introduced in July, and the lack of engagement from this administration now at the last minute to try to play games is frustrating. We're trying to protect renters... Mr. Chairman, you said not to bring politics into this. I'm asking for the commissioner of the Department of Buildings to speak. I will get to that after I speak. That being said, again, there's been ample time for this administration to engage, and the fact that 30 minutes before the hearing, they want to have the commissioners available is frustrating. So, that's my frustration. If we want to sit down and talk about putting forward an ordinance that's balanced, I'm all for it. But stop playing games here. Please get the commissioner. Let me get the commissioners, Emily. Go ahead, Emily. I'd like the commissioners to come speak. Yeah, they could come in. Ladies and gentlemen, in the box we have the Director – I'm sorry, strike that – the Commissioner of Buildings, Marlene Hopkins, as well as the Commissioner of Housing, Lissette Castaneda, along with the Director of Legislative Reference Bureau, Michael Howlett. Alderman Casada. Thank you. So placing RTLO, administration and enforcement, in the Department of Buildings will leave the Department of Buildings stretched thin and the city without the tools it needs to ensure renters actually benefit from the most critical protections. Commissioner Hopkins, can you speak to your analysis on this fair ordinance? Good morning, Chairman Villegas and members of the Zoning Committee. I forwarded an email or a memorandum to you on last evening that explained that the Department of Buildings' core mission is the issuance of building permits. We're working on numerous reforms to increase the time to permit issuance. We're also responsible for the administration of the Chicago Construction Codes, performing inspections in response to complaints that we receive regarding living conditions that are not in compliance with the Chicago Construction Codes. We receive almost 20,000 311 complaints in our Conservation Bureau regarding alleged building code violations. When our inspectors go out to do those inspections, only 20% are actually code enforcement, building code-related violations. There are a number of conditions that tenants do bring to our attention that are not covered under the provisions of the Chicago Construction Codes. They are typically violations of the RLTO, which our department does not have the skill set or the expertise. The inspectors are trained by the various building trades. They are carpenters. They are electricians. They are plumbers. They are mechanical ventilation, mechanical refrigeration inspectors, construction inspectors for cranes, as well as for iron. So our level of expertise in addressing what is known as a typical landlord and or tenant dispute is not something that we have the skill set for. We realize that the ordinance is on the books, but that there has not been an agency or department in the city that was really charged with the administration of the RTLO. But that is not something that our department has the knowledge or the skill set. Because I have building trades, I have architects, I have structural engineers, and none of them are trained in this level of administration of this ordinance. Thank you, Commissioner. So would you say that this ordinance provides you with the funding or support that you need to get that job, this newly assigned responsibility done? This ordinance would require us to really work very closely with the Department of Housing, who has a lot of the oversight of the rental landlord-tenant related issues. And that is who we actually work very closely with today when these issues arise. And I know that they then work through a lot of the third parties, such as metropolitan tenant organizations and lawyers for a better housing committee to address these issues. Thank you, Commissioner. I would like to ask the Commissioner of Housing, Commissioner Castaneda, to please provide an analysis on the fair ordinance. For the record, this is Castaneda, Commissioner for the Department of Housing. We have looked at the ordinance, and generally we are, of course, really excited to keep working with City Council on the Protecting Renters' Ordinance. We do think that the provisions of the Residential Landlord-Tenant Ordinance need to be enforced by the Department of Housing, as that is where the expertise lies. As Commissioner Hopkins has stated, her team is not equipped necessarily to do this kind of work, whereas we are able to do the work of enforcing the RLTO if we are granted the ability to do so through PRO. Thank you very much. You know, and also, Chairman, thank you for allowing the commissioners to speak on my request. I believe it's important that these commissioners who are leading these departments speak and help provide public testimony for all of our colleagues to better understand both of the pieces of important legislation that stand before us. Just to kind of piggyback on what Alderman LaSpada had mentioned earlier regarding the right to counsel, I think it's really important to know that approximately 90 percent of landlords are represented by attorneys in eviction court, but only approximately 10 percent of tenants are. When a majority of my tenants come to my office who are facing evictions, they are left without the legal support that they need. So not only is this piece of legislation unfunded and an unfunded mandate, it does not establish the right to counsel as a permanent city program. Could you elaborate again why that was not like why are we not doing that just proactively when we know that working class tenants are struggling with it with record rates of evictions? Right. So, again, it's as was stated earlier, there's the current contract runs through to 2027. So we will revisit that at the next at the next budget. So we don't have an answer for it. I just provided an answer for you. Yeah, maybe not. May not the one you want to have, but it's the one. This is really unfortunate, chairman. I yield. Thank you. Thank you. Next is Vice Chair Lawson, followed by Alderman Fuentes, followed by Alderman Knutzen. Thank you, Chair. I appreciate the time. And, you know, there's a lot that's gone into this. And I have some questions for the commissioners as well. I was a renter until five years ago. I have lived in every type of rental situation. I've had really great, large corporate owners of buildings and really so, so smaller landlords, actually, who lived in the building. And I've heard that from my neighbors. I have one of the most rental heavy wards in the city. We're over 60 percent, and I have seen those costs go through the roof in the last five years. And so I was very, very concerned when we started having these conversations about what we're doing to rental costs. Everything we add gets passed on to the renters. We just have to understand that and know that. And even then, we're going to have costs that will be passed on, and I may be advocating for some. But looking, you know, and we've had conversations with other colleagues about security deposit reform in the past. And to my colleague from the first ward, a number of landlords in the city have moved away from taking a security deposit because they find it too risky if something goes wrong. The damages on it are high. It has to be in a separate account, which is a pain, and you have to calculate interest to the penny. It just comes out to pennies on what is often, you know, a 12-month lease. Instead, what they have started to do is take a nonrefundable move-in fee of a couple hundred dollars, which across the spectrum of the building or their units will pay for the damage that right now security deposits are covering on a per-unit basis. As someone who was a renter, it was way easier for me to come up with $250, $300 than the $1,700 a month rent that sits in an account and that I don't have access to until well after I move out. So it was actually a bit of a cost savings that made it easier to do the move-in fee. And then again, that's why landlords and housing providers have gone to that model. I think going forward, if we wanted to talk one or the other, I mean, people who charge a security deposit generally are not charging a move-in fee or vice versa. And in some areas, that makes it easier. In others, it may be more of a burden. Or to the type of building, too, the size of the building. I think that the rhetoric on this has been a little thick on all sides. And there's a lot of demonization of folks. You know, the idea that an LLC is a bad thing. I'm just going to take umbrage with. We would want every business to be in an LLC. Every building that's owned as a rental should be an LLC. We should be able to find the owner. There's no question about that. But to malign the idea that it's a corporation that owns a two-flat or a three-flat is disingenuous and misleading. I also want to go back to some of the things that we've done on enforcement before. So I do appreciate the commissioners being here. Commissioner Castaneda, your department right now, what code enforcement does your department work on right now? So, again, Lisa Castaneda, commissioner for the Department of Housing. So currently, whereas we have expertise in the residential landlord-tenant ordinance, we do not have enforcement ability over the residential landlord-tenant ordinance. And so that is something that we are looking to be able to do. So my question, though, is actually what code enforcement ability do you have at all as a department? That is, in terms of code enforcement, there is none necessarily. Right. So my point is this would be new for your department as well. You are not a code compliance department right now. You don't have inspectors right now. So maybe it's even more of a lift to stand it up in a department that doesn't do code enforcement than one that already does. While I have you, one of our public commenters mentioned that. There was a data leak on the ARO database. I want to give you an opportunity to address that while you're here. I'm sorry. Can you repeat that one more time? One of our public commenters mentioned, with concerns about security, about any type of registry, that there was a leak of the ARO database that put several people's information at risk, and I wanted to allow you to address that since it came up earlier. I would have to get back to you all through the chair on that. I am not aware of that. The ARO database, as it currently stands, is only the publicly available information of where ARO units are. That is all public information as it goes through the Plan Commission, but I'm happy to look into whatever other leak is. The commenter mentioned that there was a leak that disclosed private information. If you could follow up with that, because that's concerning. Obviously, city data we have to protect, and we take that seriously if we're putting departments adding any more, certainly, too. For Commissioner Hopkins, I think I wanted to ask you right now, so we talked about enforcement of the RLTO, the complaints that come in. I would think the vast majority of those complaints are buildings-related, or they may fall under health or streets and sand. You mentioned there's 20,000 complaints annually. About 20% go to court enforcement. But of those 20,000 complaints, how many are RLTO-related? Do you have a sense of that? We all know that a renter will call on a bad landlord, and there may be some code enforcement. It may be a correction. It may be that it's in compliance. But do you have some sense of that number now? I don't. Marlene Hopkins, Commissioner of the Department of Buildings, I don't. But I will do some research and get that information through the chair. But what I will say is that from the building code standpoint, I think that clearly there is a lack of understanding of what is truly a building code violation complaint and what is really a complaint against the actual condition that a landlord is required to conform or comply with within the RLTO. What I will say is that we do see an influx of calls once there has started to be eviction proceedings where the tenant is starting to call the Department of Buildings for alleged building code violations. Whether they exist or not. That is correct. So, I mean, nobody wants to use our departments or our code compliance as a retaliatory tool for anyone. And I think we've all heard those stories, too, in our wards that are not helpful. But you guys are part of a task force that goes out and inspect new businesses along with fire and liquor and there's probably some other people. ACP, public health. Right. And so I'm looking at RLTO. It's very similar, right? It touches a number of departments. I think a lot of them are going to be buildings. A lot of them are legal. A lot of them are going to be public health or streets and sand related. I'm not sure where housing comes in, right, because we're outsourcing the legal work right now. You don't have attorneys on staff doing legal work on behalf of eviction. So maybe for Commissioner Castaneda, like, what is it in the enforcement piece that housing does now? Thank you for the question. So under the provisions of PRO, part of the updates to the RLTO would include the ability to do enforcement work on the RLTO provisions. But you're still going to have building inspectors working for you. I know it's part of sort of a task force again, right, a group working. Right. So there is work that we will do together with the Department of Buildings, particularly on inspections related to the Chicago construction codes. However, it is certainly still possible to have someone who might go out to check in on other provisions of the code that would not be related to the construction codes. As Commissioner Hopkins has alluded to, many of the complaints that they get are not necessarily something that you can enforce through the construction codes. It's something that may need to be enforced through the RLTO. So I'd like to get to that, too, because I'd like to understand what it is in the RLTO that we would be enforcing that's outside of construction, that's outside of public health, streets and sand, or law specifically, right? So and do you work? I mean, the horrible situation my colleague from the 26th Ward mentioned yesterday should have been inspected and dealt with by public health or some agency. I mean, we have the ability to enforce our codes when something that horrific is happening, right? I'm sorry. I'm going back and forth between commissioners. Thank you. No, no problem. Commissioner Hopkins, Department of Buildings. So one example I will use is that we've cited a building code violation within a tenant's unit for, let's say, something, the walls or leaking faucets or water infiltration. So the owner is attempting to make that repair, but the tenant doesn't cooperate to allow the owner in. The building department would have to go through the court proceedings to ask for a mandatory order for the owner to be able to gain access. However, in the RLTO, it clearly states that tenants cannot prohibit an owner from being able to come in to address conditions in their unit. I can't – I don't have the – that's not a building inspector or a plumbing inspector's area of expertise. That is more of an administrative, technical responsibility. So that is where the relationship working with the Department of Housing would come into play because then they could enforce that provision. Currently, our department doesn't have the ability to – and I'm just using it as an example. We don't have the ability to enforce it, and none of our workforce, i.e., because they are building trades, would be able to cite that as a building code violation because it's not a building code. Sure. A hundred percent. That's what I'm saying. I know there are other violations there. I'm not sure that housing is the one to do it either, you know, where it should perhaps fall under a different department that has the authority now. So right now, there is no ability anywhere for the city to enforce the residential landlord-tendant ordinance. Part of what we are adding in is the ability to do that enforcement. The reason why these things have traditionally been outsourced to partners in, like, the legal field specifically has been because currently the RLTO is set up where the only way that you can exercise your rights is through a court process. What we have – And that includes the city. The description that Commissioner Hopkins just mentioned, right, the tenant is refusing access. We would have to go to court in order for the landlord to make repair. Correct. It is my understanding. So how will that change going forward, then? So part of the updates that we have proposed to the RLTO would give the ability to have enforcement in the Bureau of Rental Housing Services. But how does that – I understand we'd have enforcement, but would you still have to go to court? Would you be able to – what new things is the department going to do now that is different from what's happening now going forward? The idea is that staff from the Bureau could go out and do an investigation, issue a compliance notice to force the party to cooperate with whatever is happening with the RLTO. So then if that does not work, then there would be escalation through the Department of Law and the Department of Administrative Hearings. And so those are all things that would be new because currently you cannot do any of those pieces. So, again, I feel like this is what we're currently doing. We're just adding another step with another department that doesn't do code compliance. And I've made that point, I think. I have some concerns by that. We have a Troubled Buildings List and a Troubled Buildings Initiative still within the Building Department? The Troubled Buildings Initiative lives within the Department of Housing. It is. Okay. And how do you get on that list? So the Troubled Buildings Initiative, we work closely with the Department of Buildings, work with alder people to identify buildings that are in particularly troubled condition. We work through our partner in the Community Investment Corporation. Usually where that ends is in the most extreme of cases where the Department of Buildings is recommending a receiver be put in place. And then that work gets done through the courts. How does one get on the Troubled Buildings List? They're usually buildings that are identified through the Department of Buildings and with the alder person. So I understand why housing would be involved on the cure side. But why on the front end? Because the money is budgeted through the Department of Housing and because it's generally part of the work that we have done in order to ensure that we are putting all housing back into productive use. We have any number of programs that we run that go towards that end. Fair, fair. I appreciate it. It is where the money goes. Fair enough. Then we have a Building Scoff Law list as well. Yes, Alderman. The Building Scoff Law ordinance lives under the jurisdiction of the building department and that is updated twice a year. So what's the difference between the two? So SCOLF Law is essentially highlights or identifies building owners with numerous buildings that are in the enforcement process and they have failed to bring their buildings into compliance within 18 months. And it also prohibits any of those building owners from receiving any funding from the city. Right. I think that might be it on all my questions. You know, I want to thank everybody for working on this and coming to a place where I think two ordinances. are pretty close together and there's an opportunity for a compromise to do something that moves forward. I've had constituents ask me to vote yes on one or the other or to vote no on both. What I'm going to do is vote yes today so that we can continue the conversation, knowing that we're going to have a deferred published next week at council and we can continue to put something together that we can fund. You've all heard me say, I think we should have a building's registry in the city. We should register every building. We can use it for code compliance across multiple departments and we should charge a small fee for it. That would be the cleanest way to do that and to update the technology to do that I think we would be able to do. So I look forward to seeing what happens as we move forward. Again, I do appreciate everyone's time and work on this because it is a lot. It is important that we are realistic about where we are. The most pressing factor being the cost and understanding how we build more has always been a focus of mine and control costs whenever we can. So thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Vice Chair Lawson, Alderman Fuentes. Thank you, Chairman. So I understand this software and the revenue piece that you were talking about from the Department of Buildings, although the commissioner has sent a memo that she doesn't believe it should live within her department. We still, as a body, would have to codify a fee schedule. Why make the decision and not including that in your fair ordinance? Say it one more time. I'm sorry. The last part. The revenue component that you were discussing in terms of the registry itself, while the department has procurement power, that is true. We would have to codify a fee schedule. Why not do that in your ordinance? Look, under the powers and duties section of 2-2-2-2-0-5-0. We're going to provide that authority to the commissioner as it relates to that IT technology. And we can continue having further discussions during the budget process as to how those funds will be appropriated. So again, these are budgetary items. We wanted to provide the tools necessary to create that revenue in order to make sure that we do not have unfunded mandates. Thank you. And can you walk us through why not ban junk fees? What's your rationale and your position? I think that we do ban junk fees. We just don't ban all of them. I think that the state of Illinois just recently passed a public act that bans junk fees. And we've incorporated not only the state ban, but also some additional junk fees that would be banned. Listen, at the end of the day, when we're talking about fees, there's a cost associated with it. So the question is going to be whether or not that cost is going to be upfront, or is it going to be buried in the rent? There is no, it's just economics. So the question is, why not be more transparent around those fees instead of hiding them inside the rent? And what part of the pro ordinance do you think is not clear enough in terms of what junk fees are allowable and what's not? Well, I think that the there was a list that I think Department of Housing or someone produced that put a side by side comparison of all the fees. And for the most part, out of 20 of them, seven of the fees that were banned under pro were not banned under fair. So you can see that almost two thirds of the fees that were identified, we have similarity with. And so again, any fee that any fee that's not identified or transparent ultimately gets passed on in the form of rent. Thank you. This has been asked in a couple different ways. And I think the Commissioner has answered it in a couple different ways. But Commissioner Hopkins, can you just simply answer, is your staff trained and able at this moment to respond to RLTO violations? At this time, we are not in the position to enforce the rules of RLTO. largely due to the fact that it is outside of our department's technical expertise. Thank you. You know, my biggest concern with this is that we will have enforcements give more responsibility to a department with no revenue mechanism in the ordinance as it stands before us today. Right. That's putting more work on people with with no additional pay, no hiring of additional people. And I think if we if we want to ensure that we are enforcing RLTO, that we are protecting tenants, that we have people that are trained to do so, that that requires real revenue and should be packaged with the ordinance. And that's why I think this is an unfunded mandate. Right. I'm extremely concerned that there's no revenue for the things that we are saying needs to be done. And my other concern is I think we have continuously moved the goalposts. Right. The concern was just calls. It was removed. The concern was relocation fees. It was removed. And we continue to move the goalposts on the concerns of the ordinance. And, you know, for me, we have to be able to take very seriously the the conditions that tenants live in. Look, and I agree with Vice Chairman Lawson. I don't think LLCs are inherently bad, but I do believe that LLCs have responsibility to be transparent, to be accessible. The the largest, you know, the largest concern is holding folks accountable and being able to get them out. I do believe there are some very meaningful pieces that are missing from fair that I do think gives tenants what they need while ensuring we're protecting small landlords. We're not demonizing LLCs. And, you know, we have to be very clear that tenants don't have all the protections. Right. And so, therefore, I cannot support the fair ordinance, particularly on the premise that this is an unfunded mandate. OK, I appreciate that. Just to respond, just to respond as it relates to some of the staff, the same way that Pearl is going to have a ramp up of their staff in the first year, they'll be using existing staff in order to provide the services and also in their in their department. They'll need to have some code experts as well. So there's going to be a learning curve on everything. And so we look forward to working with our partners in the Department of Housing, as well as the Department of Building to make sure that we are protecting renters, setting a path for housing providers. And again, signaling to those folks that want to invest in the city of Chicago that we're prepared to accept those investments with predictability. So thank you for your questions, Alderman Fentes. Alderman Knudsen, followed by Alderman Riley. Thank you, Chair. And I've got a question on a specific section that just came up in my review to the fair changes from yesterday, which I know there's there were a lot of people that this morning trying to digest. I think I've digest most of them, but this is around attorney fees. So it might go to Mike Howlett. There was a change in the attorney's fees section where the prevailing party would now be owed court costs and legal fees, where the previous version of fair was that the plaintiff would be owed. This sets up a situation where, you know, potentially it's a risk for somebody to bring a case forward because of the fear of if you lose the case, you might owe an expensive legal fee. I know it says reasonable fees and that's good because a judge can determine that. That's better. But I was just wondering if we could, if anyone had an overview on like the intent to this change, just because I felt that most of the changes that came into fair were actually really good and really substantive. And I'll touch on that later. But this is one that just came up as a reg flag. Director Howlett? Mike Howlett, the director of the Legislative Reference Bureau. I would defer to the sponsor on the intent behind the policy change. Thank you, Director Howlett. I think it's more, again, reasonable making sure that there was a reasonable approach to this. And so that's where in discussions with all the stakeholders try to figure out what a compromise is. This is where we landed. Okay. I think it is worth considering going back to the original language. I mean, you don't want to set up a situation where a renter's nervous to bring a case forward because of the risk here. And legal fees can become extraordinarily high. And I know it's not always a David and Goliath situation, but sometimes it is. So this was a red flag for me. I do want to note, you know, similar to the vice chair that I thought a lot of the changes went in a good direction. I do feel that both of these ordinances are moving into a very similar direction. And my hope is it with fair, you know, potentially coming out of committee today that we continue this conversation. It is starting to feel I can only speak to my for myself, but I'm talking to a lot of activists and stakeholders as well. It's starting to feel like the ordinances are getting to a point where they are similar enough where if this was a truly functional body, we could iron out some of these issues and vote near unanimity on something that really helps Chicagoans in a week or two. And as somebody who really believes in the discomfort of negotiations and compromise, I'm hoping that we can get there. I understand that fair. Coming out of committee today is really the only way for negotiation to continue. I also understand that, you know, it'll be it would be thrown out at this next council, very likely. My hope is that we get there. I we are close enough. We could be sending a message to Chicagoans that, you know, near all 50. It's never going to be all 50 of us really strongly believe in updating this important section of the code that impacts people's lives. So that's just where I'm at. Thanks for the clarity on the attorney's fees. It's not exactly the response that I hope for, but I think that we can definitely change that back. Thanks. Thank you, Alderman Knudsen. Do my my word that we will continue talking with colleagues to try to figure out how to get to a spot where, to your point, we can demonstrate to the city of Chicago that there is an agreement around protecting renters, putting a clear path for housing providers, but also signaling that we need the housing supply in order to bring down the stress of the housing crisis, as well as create new revenue for the city, which we desperately need. So you have my word that we will continue the dialogue, Alderman Knudsen. Yeah, we'll do it together. And, you know, like there's a lot of us very committed to doing it, despite the overarching presence of budget season and elections. We really need to filter out these substantive issues and really not, you know, focus on those things. So thank you. Thank you, Alderman Knudsen. Alderman Riley, followed by Alderman Cruz. Thank you, Chairman. Alderman Riley, one second. Could we, Alderman Riley makes a motion to accept Alderman LaSpada under the Rule 59 provision. All in favor, please say aye. Opposed, say nay, nay. Aye. And if the charity ayes have it. Alderman Riley. Good noon, commissioners and colleagues. First, I wanted to ask just a couple of questions of the commissioners. It's a surprise to see you're here today. Thank you for being here. Commissioner Hopkins, let's start with you. Were you directed to be here today by the mayor's office? I was asked to be present so that if there were any questions that I would be able to answer. Thank you. I assumed it was the mayor's office who sent you. And who in the mayor's office asked you to be here, Commissioner? I've been working with IGA. IGA. Okay. Government affairs. All right. Commissioner, a colleague earlier suggested that your department is too busy issuing permits to take on or shoulder any additional responsibilities. And I, having had the good fortune and pleasure of having worked with you over the last nearly 20 years now, know you to be a commensurate professional, highly capable, one of the best commissioners we have in the city of Chicago, who is also blessed with a very capable and talented staff. And I was one of the folks who was eager to support you in this role. So I'm surprised that that would be a comment, a take by one of my colleagues. And certainly I can appreciate that if we ask a department to take on more responsibility, it would be responsible then that we address those needs through our regular appropriation process, the budget process, which is just around the corner. Commissioner, historically, when you've been tasked with taking on additional responsibilities, or broader scope, how have you gone about assembling the resources necessary to meet the goal and accomplish the task? So as in the capacity as commissioner of the department, we have not had to take on any additional roles or responsibilities. Our core mission, which is the issuance of permits, the performance of inspections, as well as updating the provisions of the municipal code, have been the key focus of the Department of Buildings. We, the department, as it is currently structured today, our core function and core mission, as you know, is development, economic development, permit issuance, and ensuring that families are living in safe, sound, and habitable living conditions, which are covered under the provisions of the Chicago Code. And I, and I, and I appreciate that commissioner. And again, I appreciate the work that you and your staff do. If, if we were to take a look at some recent statistics, say, let's start with the beginning of the current administration in 2023, and to compare it with the most recent full year of data. Um, is the Department of Buildings, did the Department of Buildings issue more or fewer permits in 2025 than they did in 2023? I don't have the permit data with me. I do. Okay. I, I asked the question because I knew the answer. And the answer is no, many thousands of permits fewer, um, thousands of permits fewer, um, in 2025 than 2023. Um, to the commissioner of housing, um, I'd ask you the same question. Were you directed to be here by the mayor's office today? I was asked to be here to ask, to answer questions. Correct. Yes, is the answer. Okay. And commissioner, are you familiar with how many housing units were approved in 2023 in the city of Chicago? I do not have the number for overall housing unit. I do. 9,500 or so new housing units were approved in, in 2023. Do you know how many were approved in 2025? I do not. I do. Uh, 4,900. So between 2023 and 2025, we have seen a 48% decrease in the number of housing units approved in the city of Chicago. Do you know why? I think there are a lot of factors. There are a number of, there are a number of inputs, commissioner. That is correct. We're not, we're not looking for a call-in show here. Um, but, but I can tell you this, I'll cut to the chase. I don't want to go through a lengthy conversation here, but if you were to just do some basic Google searches and news searches, um, about the issue of, uh, housing generally nationwide in large cities. Um, here in Chicago, um, many analysts across different platforms point to one input that has had a significantly chilling effect on, uh, people seeking to build new housing here. And it's the ARO. Um, are you familiar with the nine unit pivot? Are you familiar with that term? Um, I understand the reference. Yes. The developers choosing to do less units so they do not have to meet the ARO obligations. It's actually now regular jargon in the real estate community. It's actually everyone who, who builds or develops in the city of Chicago knows that term well. Um, and it is used freely in conversation. And for those folks who aren't in real estate or development, the nine unit pivot, um, is, is a maneuver that developers that are not, you know, multinational mega developer corporations use to avoid triggering the ARL. So while we have developers who would like to develop multi-unit buildings, 24 units, 36 units or more, they know that they have economic certainty and they can get better financing deals if they build fewer than 10. So as to not trigger the 20% affordable requirement. And everyone in this room knows that we are in a massive, massive shortage of affordable housing in the city of Chicago. No one here disagrees on that. We have very, very serious disagreements on how you go about doing that. And while the ARO was incredibly well-intended, that policy has had a disastrous consequence on the creation of new housing in the city of Chicago. And that is why the city of Chicago standing is horrid. We, we are at a historical per capita low for building inventory. We have 1.36 units per 1,000 residents being created a year. And how does that stack up? The city of Chicago stack up against the, the other 10 biggest cities in America. We rank dead last by a lot. And I would argue, I'm talking about 2023 to about now, because it's this administration's policies that are coming home to roost. And now here we are debating two similar ordinances, both well-meaning, both intended to protect renters. And I think everyone in this room wants to do that too. But the consequences of some of these policy choices are similar to the ones that this body has made, I think, irresponsibly in the last several years. And so I, I think it's important for us to have this context when we're having this broader conversation, because if, if we're seeking to create new housing, which is ultimately the way you, you reduce the cost of rents, competition, supply, we all, we all know macroeconomics. Um, we cannot make it virtually impossible to get financing or to so totally disincentivize or discourage people from owning multi-unit buildings and renting to people. Um, this will only accelerate the downward spiral that Chicago is in right now. And you don't have to take my word for it. We have heard from every different component of the building sector, the folks that actually develop and deliver these units. And they have all raised red flags here for us. And so, again. I respect my colleagues for wanting to make a change here. I represent many, many renters myself. I am actually currently today a renter. And I can tell you, yes, there is room for improvement. And I am glad that this conversation is occurring here today. But we are in a bad place here because well-meaning policies did not prove to be the successful approach to deliver what we are all seeking here, which is affordable housing so that working families can afford to stay in Chicago and lead productive lives and hopefully realize eventually the American dream. And so, Chairman Villegas, I do appreciate all the work that you've done. I do wish that the administration had been more engaged with your work group that you led as the chairman of zoning. I do think that there have been some positive changes made to the pro ordinance. And I give my colleagues credit for that where it is due. But I will be supporting this ordinance as well because I think it does move the ball down the field significantly to protect renters. It does take out lots of unnecessary fees. And I can tell you, as a dog owner, I was thrilled to see one of those provisions also included. But, look, I do believe that Alderman Knudsen and others are correct here. I think that we are within the realm of possibility of achieving a compromise that does good and does right by renters without further exacerbating a housing crisis that exists here in Chicago. The disagreement that occurs in Chicago, the disagreement that occurs in this chamber is really about the solution. What is the recipe for success? And I think we all want that. And I don't think either group that has worked on either of these competing ordinances has the premium on wisdom on this. I think that we can, between these two drafts, I think, eventually come to a place where we're all comfortable and happy knowing that we've made tenants' rights a priority again in the city of Chicago. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Riley. Alderman Cruz, followed by Byron Cichel-Lopez. Thank you, Chairman. I just want to say thank you for the collaboration. I believe so many ongoing conversations back and forth has forced negotiations and compromise across the board. And as my colleague just mentioned, Pearl has made some significant changes, something that has been a concern from homeowner occupied to non-owner occupied when it came to the just cost or relocation fees. So I think, again, we're heading in the right direction when it comes to making sure that there are compromises that helps everybody across the board. I also want to thank the commissioners for being here, but it is important, and I ask the administration that this happens every single time for all matters because the only way we're going to make the right decisions is when everybody is on the floor, on the table, and not just certain occasions. So I think this is an example of this should be happening at all times. So going back to the ordinances, it's important that we're not rushing and we take this as a priority as we want to make sure that we are not forcing our neighbors to become unhoused. We see it across the board. We see it in our words every single day when we see more of our neighbors being unhoused. So when it comes to your ordinance, I do have some concerns when it comes to the legal representation for tenants. Landlords have their legal representation. Our tenants don't, and at times we have families where they don't know where to go. Are there legal assistance? Yes. To get the help that they need, it takes a long time before they have to be, when they're asked to leave the apartment. So when we're looking about compromises, and this is something that you have been asked several times, but I'm going to ask it again. Will you, in good faith, compromise a registration fee so this will allow legal representation for tenants and create that much needed assistance that they need that we're seeing in other legislation? Thank you for that question, Alderman Cruz. Listen, everyone that knows me knows that I'm always willing to engage and willing to have discussions to try to get to a compromise. I don't allow perfect to be the enemy. However, in having discussions with stakeholders, these are some of the solutions that were provided and agreed upon. Those folks that were supportive of a fair, but I'm always willing to engage and willing to continue dialogue to continue to move the needle. I think it's been mentioned multiple times that there is some similarities between the ordinances and there's some differences. And I think the only way to really get to the point where there could be an opportunity to get more support is to continue to have those discussions. So you do have my word that we will continue to have dialogue to figure out how to put forward an ordinance that can get as much support as possible to make sure that we are taking care of the residents of the city of Chicago. Because the restriction will really help to create that extra additional. And I know there has been discussions about, you know, Department of Building being the main one focused on this one. But I do think that the Department of Housing does play a big role on both legislations as well. And bringing additional funding that does not rely on a budget, it is important to also reconsider. So those are the things that I ask you. And just overall, when I read through a lot of this, again, it's the emphasis is a lot, you know, on landlords. But overall, like, what are the new benefits that you bring with FAIR for tenants? What are the benefits of FAIR for tenants? Right. So under our ordinance, there's a lot of codification of state law where we are banning junk fees. And then we went above and beyond what the state had put forward as it relates to fees. So we are codifying that. And so there are a number of them. Yeah. I gave you the handout that has this. Do you want me to read you that? No, I just wanted you to recap it. I have it here, but I want to be like, this is it. Like, this is what we're bringing to tenants. Yeah, of course. To ensure that we are protecting them. Right. So removing the provision and allowing the landlord. We've removed the tier concept, right, for that. We're retaining the existing exclusion for units and owner-occupied buildings with six or four. That's for landlords and strike them, sorry. Prohibiting landlords from charging both one-time pet fees and monthly pet-related fees. Prohibiting landlords from converting unpaid late fees, pet fees, or utility charges into rent, including for purposes of eviction proceeding. Prohibiting landlords from applying payments to non-rent charges. Prohibiting landlords from changing any markup on utility bills. Prohibiting leases from imposing fees for service calls and maintenance requests, unless condition was deliberately or negligently caused by the tenant or a guest. Prohibiting the non-disparagement clauses in leases. Clarifying that following an insufficient or defective notice of non-renewal, a tenant may retain possession of the unit through the later, which is important, of the expiration of the lease or the required minimum notice required period after receiving a correct notice. And retaining existing CPD enforcement of prohibition on lockouts was subject to the higher fines included in the introduced version of fare. So those are just to name a few. So going back to with the Department of Housing and the Department of Building, will you also consider not just having this to be with the Department of Buildings, but also bringing the Department of Housing to play a role within this legislation? Well, I think that will – I think we can continue dialogue. But right now, the majority of the members feel comfortable that the Department – the duties and the issues related to tenants belong in the Department of Buildings, but always looking forward to continuing dialogue to see what you're thinking about as it relates to the ROTO and some of the issues that you're thinking about and where you think Department of Housing and Department of Buildings. So look forward to continue working with you to figure out what you're thinking about. Bottom line for me is, like, how do we have legal representation for our tenants? I think that is something that they need. I mean, that is one of my main concerns because we hear it, we see it all the time, and we want to make sure that we say this is a department that's not going to help you rather than just keep calling and we get in the list. And I know there is other – like county has also, but I think creating something that is accessible and easier for people to use and also have the legal representation, it's key. But I appreciate it. I appreciate it. Thank you, Alderman. Oh, I'm sorry. Alderman Byron Cichol Lopez, followed by – are there any other members of the committee that wish to ask questions? I see none. After Byron Cichol Lopez, our final person for questions will be Alderman Vasquez, non-member. And also I'd like to acknowledge Alderman Quinn as a non-member of the committee. Alderman Lopez. Thank you, Chairman. Alderman, and – and – I am always open to the conversation and dialogue. I think our renters or tenants, as well as small homeowners, deserve that level of conversation. It's been 40 years since we updated the RLTO, 40 years. And I am optimistic that we, as city council members, can really work on the best centers of the city. And those who are looking up to us in a time of a serious affordability crisis, the open has been, or door has been open in committee, has been open in committee. Chairman Villegas knows that. We want to work on that. In fact, one of the biggest hurdles for small homeowners are actually property taxes, high property taxes. That is one thing that we should focus on. Time after time, I'm going to Springfield to talk about that. And I do think that this council follows the logic of why we need to tax the many millionaires who keep moving to the city of Chicago. They're coming from the suburbs as a people who are being displaced. We need to tax them. That is the way that we stop the bleeding. But in terms of like this ordinance, and I do hope that we have a serious conversation here. I do want to point out in terms of, and I do hope that we do follow the macroeconomics. Because the slowdown in housing supply has done because of macroeconomics. In fact, the interest rates just went up yesterday. It's going to get even worse. And what we're talking about here in city council is infringing on tenant rights to pretend that we're going to address the issue of housing supply. That is a fallacy. I'm sorry, but this is a fallacy. And I would like to start by pointing out the need to come together in this moment. One of the, outside of the, you know, and I want to point out, high borrowing costs, higher lender standards, skyrocketing insurance premiums. Those are some of the main reasons. In fact, in city council, in the housing committee, we had a hearing where we talk about this and talk about the state addressing it, supported a bill to make sure that we address high insurance rates, talking about property taxes. But I hope that we're not protecting here what the White House is doing, because we got to point out that that administration is creating a lot of issues for the city of Chicago. One of the issues as well is the loan permitting window, the cut in the red tape. I'm afraid that we are just going to make that worse with these fair ordnance. That's where my first question is, because if we're talking about increasing housing supply and being more effective, why are we infringing on tenant rights to put even more burden on the Department of Buildings that is already struggling? And I do appreciate, Commissioner. I know that you take directly calls. You yourself take directly calls to make sure that Chicagoans are served and go after those landlords that are putting tenants in inhumane conditions, including when rats have been biting tenants while they're asleep. That is unconscionable. And we're going to make it worse unless we get this together. So my question to Commissioner, how many briefings have we had on these ordinances? How much coordination have we had on FAIR? And also the question to the chair, how many briefings, how much conversation have we had on something that we already, it seems like we're ready to moat on? I tell you, with the pro, it took us two years. Subject matter hearings. We had to have town halls, conversations. I'm yet to hear what are the stakeholders who drafted these ordinances. Because the departments, it seems like they were not even involved in this. So I want to know, how many hearings have we had on this? What departments or what are the entities that developed this plan? It is clear to me that this is not ready for prime time. But I want to hear from the commissioner how this will delay the permitting process. How will this actually help us or not with creating the housing supply that the chairman is discussing? And then who has been involved in these hearings? Because I'm yet to hear one briefing. One briefing. Please, Commissioner. Good afternoon, Commissioner Hopkins, Department of Buildings. Alderman Cicha Lopez. As we have, our department or my department is responsible for the issuance of building permits, as well as performing the inspections that are associated with the permits, with licenses, and, of course, with any complaints that are received regarding unsafe living conditions that are tied to the building code. That is the function of the department. We work very closely with housing when we do encounter circumstances that are more in line with the RLTO, and they are then able to work with the tenant on the next phase or step in the process as it is related to the RLTO. My staff does not have the subject matter expertise or knowledge of the provisions of it from an enforcement standpoint, and that is why we work so closely with the Department of Housing. Alderman, how many, or Chairman Villegas, like, how many briefings have we had on this ordinance? Well, Alderman, again, this is something that, unfortunately, we did not have the same runway as the administration. The administration has been working on this for over almost two years. And, unfortunately, once we got the details of what the ordinance looked like, a bunch of our colleagues got together to figure out what are some of the other ideas that may be in play that we can talk and coalesce around to figure out how to protect renters, put forward a path for housing providers, and also signal to folks that want to invest in the city of Chicago that their investments will be welcome. And so we tried in the last two months since the introduction, matter of fact, during the August break, had several meetings, a couple of meetings with the housing providers, a couple of meetings with the tenant organizations, and one meeting with folks that ultimately will invest in the city of Chicago to kind of get a sense as to what type of ordinance would try to strike that balance. And as a result of those meetings is the ordinance that's put in front of you that's had multiple revisions since the introduction in July. So our discussions have been with the stakeholders over the last two months to try to get to a position to have this debate. And so, unfortunately, we did not have the same runway that the administration had. And so here we are to talk about an ordinance that is similar, however, has some differences. And so, again, this is what the debate is about, and we're here talking about it today. So, Chairman, you know, and I understand the administration, you know, I'm talking about the housing committee and real estate that I represent. I'm not speaking on behalf of the administration. Chairman to chairman, I tell you that my door has been always open to reach a compromise. I think that the briefings that we had, and we have multiple, including when after we made any changes, our committee have had briefings, even before we presented anything in front of the committee. Why not working with our committee? We talk about tenant rights to talk about how we reach that compromise. I'm still yet to hear what are those stakeholders. I'm talking about aldermen. I'm talking about departments. I'm talking about who are the stakeholders, who is drafting this. Because I tell you that we build this on briefings with aldermen. We build the pro on discussions with the departments. We build this on town halls with tenants and small homeowners. That's what we reach after many, many discussions of compromise. I am just worried about that we are going to vote on something where we don't even have simple answers as that how big is the RFP, the request for proposals, the RFP for the software that we talk about? What kind of software? How much money is that into? This isn't an unfunded. We're talking about an unfunded mandate. And yesterday in committee, I heard how much discomfort there were in committee for any unfunded mandates. Yet we're here going to have people that are ready to vote on an unfunded mandate where we don't even have a simple answer of an RFP. What kind of RFP? When does the RFP goes out? We have in pro, as you know, a timeline of implementation, a whole timeline implementation. I'll tell you that we have sold this as something that is bad for landlords. And this is my next question. Just as simple as this. When we talk about mediation, this is the difference. We're talking about saving small homeowners and tenants the huge, huge burden of going to court, of spending in attorneys, in making sure that people understand their rights. We're actually talking about small homeowners and tenants. Yet, here in this ordinance, we think somehow that pitching them one another, I don't even know who is going to pay for the fees at the end of it. So, to my question is, my question, Chairman, is simple answer. We are ready to vote on something. You saw it yesterday. You're a member of the housing committee. We disclosed how we implemented, when we implemented, how much it cost. It was budget neutral. This is budget negative. Because we are going to put burden on a department that is already burdened. And we're going to say that we're going to build even more effectively. Chairman, with all due respect, I need to insist, because committee members are ready to vote. I heard Alderman Knutson, I shared the same concerns about legal fees. Our solution is having mediation, mediation with the departments that can help us prevent them to go into court. Good for small homeowners, good for tenants. What is the RFP saying in this? What kind of RFP, one of the RFP goes out when it comes to putting extra burden on the buildings department? Simple question. Well, there was many there, but I'll answer what I think. One, because I want to make sure it's simple. No, no, I want to make sure. I don't know if that was a simple question, but I will attempt to try to go ahead and get to what I think you're asking for. So similar to Pro, where the first year, it is the utilization of current staffing as they continue to build up. It's a similar thing that we're taking a look at as it relates to FAIR. The RFP that you're talking about is utilizing a technology that would support the trailer ordinance that we're introducing this month that will, in essence, double the foreclosure registry from 700 every year to 700 every six months. And due to those pre-foreclosures and foreclosures, our analysis shows that it can produce $8 million. And it's not going to take the three years in order to get to the full revenue. It could take as quickly as three to six months in order to realize that. So while we're still working in the 2027 budget with the current staff, that RFP and those dollars are preparing us for the expansion of the Department of Building staff in 2028. And Chairman, don't you think that we should have that in front of housing committee, zoning committee members? Yeah, so right here, it's under the Office of Rental, Housing, Supplies, Powers, and Duties. The Minister of the Residential Registry established under Section 552, including procuring, contracting with the third-party IT vendors. Right, but you're making projections, Chairman. What I'm telling you is that you're making projections. But these are projections based on numbers. I mean, this is $700 right now. We're doubling it every six months. And more importantly, big banks are going to be the ones that have to pay for this fee. I think something that a lot of our colleagues in here would agree. So big banks will be paying this fee and not housing providers, which will ultimately be passed down to renters. We're talking about big banks and mortgage lenders that will be paying this fee. And this is projections. So we have approximately $9,000, $8,000 to $9,000 pre-foreclosure and foreclosures. Multiply that by the $1,400, and that's how you get to the number. Right. I get that. Look, we're talking about foreclosures here. We're talking about – I'm going to refocus on – But the foreclosure and the rental registry will be in one, be the same registry. So that funding will be utilized. Listen, this is no different what other states and municipalities are doing throughout the country by using both registries for foreclosure, vacant lots, rental. I mean, these are a database that's utilized. I get that. But look, we're not talking about apples and apples here, right? We're talking about like, look, PRO is designed to make sure that we have full transparency. Right? I think that when we talk about limited liability companies, LLC, that are hiding without entities, how many of us have to go through hurdles just to see who is the owner, who is responsible of a violation? So when I talk about – I understand what you're telling me. But the premise of this ordinance is saying that we are very similar. And what I'm telling you is that I fundamentally disagree with that. I think that we are equating tenant rights with housing supply. And fundamentally, I have an issue with that. And I'll tell you another thing that I have an issue with is that we are asking people – I mean, Alderman Knudsen's answer is barely – I think there's not even an answer yet. So what I'm asking here is that while we're rushing into putting something – like you told me very clearly, you have an ordinance that is taking two months. I think that that is inadequate time for what we're voting on, T. What we're voting here is a major – I mean, what we're talking about is a major change where we are not even providing any evidence in some of the things that you're projecting. So what I'm asking here, what I'm asking you, Chairman, is you don't need to put a competing ordinance to have a conversation with us. You don't have to. I'm asking you that we are equating tenant rights with housing supply. I'm just showing you, Chairman, how these ordinances make it even less effective to achieve the goal of housing supply. If you want to increase housing supply, this is not it. You're taking from the buildings department to make it even more difficult. And in the process, Chairman, in the process, what we're doing is undermining tenant rights because now we are completely subjective about what we mean by junk fees that are burdened. This is a serious issue of affordability. In my word, there was fees that accounted almost to $1,000. $1,000. We don't even know what those fees are. So what I'm telling you, Chairman, is you have the open door. You are a member of the housing committee. We have, I think, the same goal of serving tenants and small homeowners. I'm telling you, you know, right now we have a way to help both. I'm telling you, this is going to stop. There are already members talking about deferring and publish, meaning not doing anything in a time when we need to act with urgency for both tenants and small homeowners. You know the big benefactors of all of this? Big companies, big companies that are going to continue to do as we please. So, Chairman, I'm asking you, please, you know, consider we don't have a lot of this answer. I'm telling you about documenting fees and fines, LSCs, the legal issues. I mean, there's so many holes in this ordinance. There's so many holes in this ordinance that I think that we, we in good consciousness cannot say that this is equivalent to pro. We cannot say that in good faith, Chairman. Chairman, what I'm asking you, what I'm asking you, what I'm asking you publicly is that, look, I want to help small homeowners just as much as you want to help them and tenants. I'm asking you to put this on hold because we can reach an agreement. We don't need to rush on something where we have not provided evidence. It already happened in the projections of the last budget. And where are we today? So, today, Chairman, I'm asking you chair to chair. This is not about administration. You have my open hand to work for small homeowners and tenants alike. This isn't it. This is not it. So, Chairman, I hope that you publicly accept my open and my actions in committee. We made compromises. We made changes. People in the city of Chicago, tenants and small homeowners need our leadership. I'm committed to you to talk about red tape and whatever we need to increase housing supply. I understand 18,000 units on the last three years is not enough. I want to reach to the over 120,000 units that we need, including affordable housing. But this is going to stop all of it. All of it. So, please, Chairman, open arms. Open arms today. The city needs us to work together. You have my commitment. You have my commitment. Let's not put competing ordinances. We cannot put this infringement on tenant rights and tell it that we're going to build more housing. It's not going to happen. Please, Chairman, let's work together. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Vasquez, followed by Alderman Riley. Thank you very much, Chairman. I just came in not being a member of this committee to kind of get a better understanding of, like, all of the conversation. And so, to some extent, I hadn't seen all the changes that occurred in FAIR, but I'm looking at what's presented to us now. It appears to me in listening to all of it, and this has been since, I think, the beginning of the end of last term, I thought there needed to be a registry period because whenever we try to find out who the landlords are, that's its own challenge. And so I think there's large agreement on that. And FAIR does have that, Alderman. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm not even – this isn't even a for or against the end. Oh, no, no. I just wanted to make sure – But what I'm saying is I understand the need for that. I understand the need for updating the RLTO as well as, like, the council and everything else that's needed. So I do recognize they're all coming closer to each other. There seems to be, in the beginning of the hearing, a little bit of a dissonance or a disconnect related to the departments that deal with it. It does appear to me that when it relates to building code enforcement, it makes perfect sense for department of buildings to do that. I do think having them also take on, like, mediation and what appears to be more relational conversation doesn't really fit under that purview. That, in effect, you're having the person calling the balls and strikes also being the person trying to convene the different parties in a way that doesn't really make sense. So I'm curious as to why there's such an aversion to having the Department of Housing address that component of what these relationships are. I didn't even have a point. I appreciate it. Again, the majority of the call of the issues related to tenants complaints are, in our opinion, related to buildings. And we're going to get that information from the Department of Buildings. The commissioner stated 20,000 plus complaints on an annual basis. And she's going to break down what that looks like. But based off our interactions with. constituents, the majority of the time that they're engaging with our offices or 311 is related to building code issues. And so we feel that they have to play a bigger role. That being said, I mean, there's nothing prohibiting us from continued dialogue around what that looks like for, to your point, the interaction between the Department of Housing and also rent as well. So we can continue on that. That's what it appears to me, right? I think when I get stuff, when neighbors are coming to us, if it's related to the building specifically, right, a landlord is not taking care of the property, DOB goes there. When there seems to be more of a relational conflict between like a landlord and a tenant, I'm not going to Department of Buildings for that, right? Like that to me seems like it needs to be a completely separate party to talk through. And so part of what you have on the one sheet that I think I question, in the Office of Rental Housing within the Department of Buildings that's proposed to FAIR, right? You mentioned offering voluntary mediation service to resolve disputes. That would require staffing. And I know we've had the hot conversation about funding and I'll get to that. But the other one says providing referral services to both tenants and landlords for pro bono legal and counseling services. Is that written as though it's something new? Because currently they come to our office and we send them the numbers. And I don't know that there's anything that's added by that. It's just codified. So basically it's like, hey, I'm going to send them to a department that's going to give them some phone numbers I could have gave them in the first place. Is that what the referral service is? Is that what it means? No, I think there's existing organizations that provide that type of assistance. So it would just be a matter of providing that. Yeah. I guess the reason why I ask that is like, it feels to me like it's saying it's going to do something that it doesn't actually do. In effect, it's just a website page that just says, here are the phone numbers and places to go. And the reason why I say that is, I could see a department of buildings having that as a reference point. I can't see them being the person who then has to like, almost like go with someone on their journey as they're having a conversation with a landlord. So I think for me personally, again, not in a committee, it makes sense that both of these departments have something that are relevant to the matter. But department of housing clearly has something there related to relationships. Now, I'll say I have a bit of a concern, and I think the vice chair voiced something similar, maybe not explicitly, about the implementation of things. So even though you've got different departments in charge of it, how they implement the problem. Like if I've got a building that's ARO and it's got ARO units, it takes forever to try to figure out somebody who needs an affordable unit to get to an affordable unit or for a property that I've approved through zoning to then become ARO. Those are different questions related to implementation. I'm just curious if that might be a concern as to why department of housing, why some people have a different take on why they should or shouldn't be a part of the equation. Does that make sense? Vice Chair, do you want to comment on that? I mean, you did bring that point up. So Vice Chair Lawson. Yes. To answer your question, yes. And I wasn't going to bring that up, but I've heard some stories that have made it very, very difficult to get some simple things done. And I want to make sure we're not adding that to anything we're creating with new. Yeah. And like, and that's a fair concern. And I think even the folks who are raising up the concern about DOB taking on that level of work are in effect having the same point being made. Regardless of what department we're talking about, are they actually getting the job done? Are they doing it in an expeditious manner? Is there a way to have accountability in place to know that it's actually getting done? And so I think that regardless of whether we're talking about fair or pro, if we just write something with an intent, but we're not doing anything to have accountability in place, you're not actually getting it done. And so I think that the critique that some of our colleagues have related to fair, not having specificity on who would be hired, where the funds are coming from, it, anyone can point to each other about what's cooked or isn't finished or complete, but we're saying the same thing as a council. It is one thing to have an idea about what can work. If you don't have the things in place to give the specificity on how to execute, we're just not going to be good at any of it. And so I think that in the conversations that feel to me like are going to continue post this hearing, really putting in more specificity in place, because I will, I know this for sure. The idea that we're not going to talk about what money is needed, and we're going to figure it out through budget, is acting as though we haven't just had the last three budget cycles here as a council. We could barely figure it out last year, just on a regular budget. So thinking that you're going to think, well, it depends on who passed it. I think the budget did actually pass. But I think the challenge is, you say you're going to figure it out on budget, and that sure as hell isn't what happens. And so it makes more sense that if you're going to put legislation forward, that we figure out the cost. So I have, and will continue to reach out the COFA to ask for cost analysis on anything being proposed, because I think that makes sense. There's a couple of things in, or in separate from all of that, because I think that's all been discussed with everyone. Landlord responsibilities. There's a part that's struck, or stricken, related to notice to a tenant. It says, such notice should be provided directly to each dwelling unit by mail, telephone, written notice to the dwelling unit, or by other reasonable means designed in good faith to provide notice to the tenant. That's all just removed, and it just says 48 hours. I'm wondering why. Can you point to the section? Yeah, I'm sorry. It's 5-12-050, landlord's right of access, and it's a larger section B under landlord responsibilities. The landlord shall not abuse the right of access. Then it says the previous legislation had different methods through which communication had to be delivered, and that's being removed, and I'm curious as to why, because I think that would lead to less responsibility to actually communicate. I guess what it seems to me is it's removing things that feel like are explicitly written as far as mail, telephone, written notice to the dwelling unit, and in that world, one would not have to be required to do so, and if someone says, hey, I let everybody know because I put a notice in the middle of the building, even if the tenants didn't see it, I did my part. So, oh, yeah. Michael, did you want to? Yeah, I just wanted to, sorry, Mike Howlett, director of LRP. That language is also stricken from pro, and I believe there is a separate notice section, but I'm looking for it right now that handles how that would work going forward in both documents. I appreciate that because I think the specificity around that is important, right? Like someone could say, hey, I tried, they just didn't get the message, and I think that's a problem. Alderman, if you, it's under section 90, landlord disclosures, D, disclosure of address for written notice, and it addresses that. Okay, and there is, would that be the same thing addressing, and I'm sorry because I'm bouncing from the legislation to the one-pager, that says removing broad disclosure requirement for all marketing materials, applications, and leases? No, that is a, sorry, Mike Howlett, Legislative Reference Bureau. No, that's referring to an addition in pro that won't, wouldn't show up in your version in front of you. It was added to section 20, which deals exception, exemptions, and it required that all landlords who claim that a unit is exempt from the chapter prominently state this exemption on marketing materials, rental applications, and rental agreements. That's what it says in pro. As I, as it was related to, relayed to me when I was making that edit, there was concerns about extensive disclosure on all, any and all sorts of marketing materials, like Instagram posts, stuff like that. Fitting a large disclosure on a small box, yeah. Okay, no, I appreciate that. And then there's similarly, and again, at the Municipal Code, so my apologies, there's a point on the one page about clarifying that disclosing or renaming an otherwise prohibited fee does legalize the fee. That's a typo. I was praying it was a typo, because I was like, what the hell does that mean? Like, just because I said I'm doing it as legal now, it's not Municipal Code, okay. Yeah, if you go to, it's 51285, and then in particular, the last sentence of A, and specifically the last sentence of, yeah, sorry, the last sentence of A. Okay, no, thank you, and I'm glad I was reading enough to catch the typo. I would say this, I appreciate that our colleagues are trying their best to figure out a balance. This is a deliberative body. I know there's politics behind every single thing everyone's thinking through and talking about. My hope would be that, as it appears, this would be moving forward in committee, I don't know, I'm not on the committee, that rather than waiting for a DNP, people gather over the weekend and resolve their differences, so we can just keep it moving. We have a parking meter deal we still have to figure out, and budget, which we're just about to start, that it would be better to have the party sit down and resolve those differences ASAP, because what do we have, a couple days to figure out a parking meter deal? There's a lot more important matters that I think deferring and publishing one or both of these things doesn't help us as a body, so I would urge anybody involved to just figure out how to resolve this thing before we get to even this council meeting. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Riley, our final. Thank you, Chairman. I just wanted to wrap up by closing the loop on our. conversation, and it's my apology to my colleagues for making the mistake of bringing up economics in this chamber. And a previous speaker brought up a whole bunch of different cost inputs that do absolutely have a direct impact on the delivery of new housing units across the country. I don't dispute those. Things like rising interest rates, tighter lending restrictions, tighter mortgage requirements, I don't dispute those as resulting in having a chilling effect on the development and delivery of new housing. But I think it is important to mention that all of those inputs that were mentioned, those impact every single housing market across the entire country. Those are not inputs that that only have a negative impact here in the city of Chicago, every city, every big city, all 12 of our 1 million plus population cities have to deal with those pressures. And I don't dispute those one bit. So it begs the question, then, why is it that Chicago among the 12 cities that have a population of 1 million or more, why is it that Chicago ranks dead last in new housing units permitted per capita? Chicago holds its spot as the third largest city in the country by overall population. Its rate of new residential construction lags far behind all of the other major metropolitan peers across the country. And I can tell you, why does that matter? Chicago ranks last in adding inventory despite having highly profitable rental markets and strong demand in its central core. It has created a massive supply and demand mismatch. This slower development pipeline is the core reason why home prices and rental rates in Chicago have climbed rapidly over the last few years, three, even while high construction cities in Texas have seen their rents stabilize or drop. That is a fact. And that is undisputable. And that data can be found at the U.S. Census Bureau's building permit survey and also through Chicago's open data portal. And so I wanted to make sure that we understand here. I think it's been acknowledged the nation is facing a housing crisis, but all big cities are facing the macroeconomic pressures. The big difference is the policies that we have in place here in the city of Chicago, which are not working. The one area where I absolutely will agree with my colleague and we never agree is is the fact that property taxes. George, can you guys please keep it down? The fact that the fact that property taxes are a major input, especially when it comes to rents. And I think the landlord community would tell us that that's resulted in 8 to 10 percent rental increases in recent years because of those those incredible costs that come with our rising property taxes. Ironically. The solution to that problem is to deliver more inventory to broaden our tax base. People are getting their tax bills late again. Thanks, Cook County. Late again this year. And what they're seeing are dramatic increases in my office and many of my colleagues are receiving phone calls from their constituents saying, what the heck is this after that's because of our limited housing supply in the city of Chicago and our underperformance of commercial properties here. So we can do two things at once, colleagues. We can protect renters and there is need for greater protections for renters. No argument. But while we do that, we can't unintendedly further chill the housing market here, which is struggling mightily and is, again, ranked ranked dead last among cities with a population over a million people in the United States of America. And so it's my hope we move this out of committee today, Chairman. We will have two active ordinances out of committee. It is my hope that Alderman Vasquez and all of us can sit together in an expedited fashion, see if we can come to an understanding, an agreement. But having these two ordinances out of committee is effectively the same thing as a conference committee report in the General Assembly or in Congress, you have two competing ordinances. People can pick their favorite flavor or we can blend them. And maybe that's a possibility. So I do want to thank the leaders who have worked so hard on the pro ordinance. I do think that that ordinance has improved dramatically from its original form. But I also want to thank you, Chairman, for your hard work in assembling a equally credible proposal to help prevent the abuse of renters in the city of Chicago. And for that reason, I move to pass. Thank you, Chairman. Okay. Thank you. There's been a motion to move. And Alderman Harris has requested a roll call. We have a roll call, please. All right. Alderman Laspata. Alderman Laspata. Alderman Laspata votes no. Nope. Alderman Hopkins. Alderman Hopkins votes yes. Alderman Dow. Alderman Dow votes yes. Alderman Hall. No. Alderman Harris. Alderman Beale. Yep. Alderman Ramirez. Alderman Moore. Alderman Mosley. Aye. Alderman Cecil Lopez. Alderman Fuentes. Alderman Burnett. Alderman Cruz. Alderman Conway. Alderman Quesada. Alderman Riley. Alderman Knudsen. Alderman Clay. No. Vice Chair Lawson. Chairman votes yes. Pro Tem Nugent. Thank you. All right. The vote is 12 to 6. This motion passes. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, there being no further business in front of the committee, Vice Chair Lawson makes a motion to adjourn. All in favor, say aye. Opposed, nay. Opposed, nay. Opposed, nay. Chair, the ayes have. Thank you.