Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, November 7, 2024
- When: Thu, Nov 7, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576/video/1027848779
- Transcript: full text (79,679 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 6:06 Public comment
- 46:41 2025 budget hearing: Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities
- 1:09:38 Samantha Nugent: Thanked the MOPD commissioner for meeting with students and interns and asked what else the…
- 1:11:58 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether the roughly $5 million reduction in MOPD contractual services was related to a…
- 1:14:28 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether the Cut the Tape initiative would shorten wait times for disabled parking…
- 1:17:13 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how many people are waiting for home modifications compared with the 188 completed and…
- 1:22:32 Raymond A. Lopez: Requested a list of MOPD delegate agencies and the service impact of a $200,000 cut.
- 1:23:28 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked whether MOPD has analyzed accessibility of older public buildings such as City Hall,…
- 1:24:32 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked why MOPD software licensing increased from $7,000 to $150,000.
- 1:33:49 Daniel La Spata: Said real-time captioning had dramatically improved from the prior year.
- 1:35:12 Daniel La Spata: Asked whether bond financing is going toward home modifications and how to shorten the wait…
- 1:36:04 Daniel La Spata: Asked how MOPD works with CDOT on public way accessibility under new federal guidelines.
- 1:40:27 Maria E. Hadden: Asked the initial and ongoing costs of MOPD's housing locator platform and noted its…
- 1:41:55 Maria E. Hadden: Asked how many disabled Chicagoans live in nursing facilities or group homes versus in the…
- 1:43:04 Maria E. Hadden: Asked for more formal accessibility training and standards for aldermanic offices.
- 1:44:53 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked for an example of how delegate agencies are held accountable to measurable results.
- 1:47:16 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked about the nature of litigation over accessible pedestrian signals.
- 1:49:34 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked MOPD to identify its language access coordinator and provide a breakdown of…
- 1:52:01 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked about MOPD travel reimbursement line items.
- 1:54:01 Jeanette B. Taylor: Questioned salary increases for a deputy commissioner and a disability specialist at a…
- 1:57:41 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked how many MOPD staff are dedicated to seniors after the Department of Aging's…
- 2:05:39 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked how aldermanic offices are doing on accessibility.
- 2:06:04 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked how the city is doing at recruiting and hiring people with disabilities.
- 2:09:08 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Said she was disappointed the budget does not include sidewalk snow plowing.
- 2:13:51 Derrick G. Curtis: Asked whether MOPD has staff dedicated to former Department of Aging functions.
- 2:14:42 Derrick G. Curtis: Asked for MOPD and CDOT help with curb cuts in front of homes of wheelchair users who…
- 2:18:14 Ruth Cruz: Asked what initiatives MOPD plans to further reduce employment barriers for people with…
- 2:20:38 Ruth Cruz: Asked about upcoming accessibility projects in public and private spaces.
- 2:23:59 David H. Moore: Asked how MOPD reaches students with disabilities at CPS schools beyond specialized schools.
- 2:26:59 Emma Mitts: Asked about representation of people with disabilities on transit boards and Pace pickup times.
- 2:31:40 Brendan Reilly: Said he sends standard budget memos to each department and expects completed responses…
- 2:32:50 Jason C. Ervin: Said he had not yet received departments' answers to the pre-submitted questions and…
- 2:37:36 2025 budget hearing: Chicago Commission on Human Relations
- 2:40:11 Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: Asked how the Commission on Human Relations budget will help it meet community…
- 2:43:15 Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: Asked whether the commission is worried about federal funding changes under the…
- 2:43:45 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked for year-over-year hate crime and hate incident numbers.
- 2:45:21 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked whether hate littering is being tracked yet.
- 2:46:27 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked what the commission plans to do proactively next year to keep communities safe.
- 3:04:37 Jessica L. Fuentes: Asked the hate crime victim advocate to describe his daily work.
- 3:06:40 Jessica L. Fuentes: Asked how many hate crime specialists the department ideally needs.
- 3:09:59 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked what resources are available to communities affected by a hate incident involving…
- 3:27:02 Timothy R. Knudsen: Thanked the commission for its work on hate littering and antisemitic incidents in his…
- 3:28:06 Jason C. Ervin: Noted that the Human Relations commissioner's salary was only about $250 above her first…
- 4:20:35 2025 budget hearing: Chicago Department of Public Health
- 4:39:12 Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: Asked how CDPH is prepared for the new federal administration and the decrease in…
- 4:51:24 Pat Dowell: Asked about the responsibilities of CDPH's environmental permitting and inspections division.
- 4:52:53 Pat Dowell: Asked how CDPH can address the cumulative impact of data centers proposed in her ward.
- 4:55:50 Pat Dowell: Requested a list of CDPH programs by funding source, noting which lack funding past 2025.
- 5:12:27 David H. Moore: Urged CDPH to make sure HIV resources reach organizations on the ground in African American…
- 5:13:07 David H. Moore: Asked how CDPH and DFSS conduct outreach to seniors on long-term health issues and what it…
- 5:20:40 Nicholas Sposato: Thanked the CDPH commissioner and liaison and said he had no questions.
- 5:33:10 Byron Sigcho-López: Raised concern about significant cuts to CDPH, especially contractual services, given…
- 5:33:59 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked whether CDPH monitors environmental requirements of city contracts.
- 5:35:57 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked how environmental violations by city contractors are communicated for enforcement.
- 5:43:46 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked about the plan to get to zero new HIV cases by 2030 and why cases are rising among…
- 5:46:30 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked whether grant money can be used for education by Black-led organizations.
- 5:48:23 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked whether CDPH works with housing, workforce, education and county agencies on…
- 5:53:49 Matthew J. Martin: Asked how many vacant CDPH positions are proposed to be cut and how long each has been…
- 5:55:36 Matthew J. Martin: Asked whether CARE team hours will expand beyond weekdays in 2025.
- 5:57:26 Matthew J. Martin: Asked whether any CARE team members or members of the public have been assaulted in…
- 6:05:18 Emma Mitts: Asked about progress slowing a new drug circulating on the West Side.
- 6:08:15 Emma Mitts: Asked how many food inspections CDPH conducted and how much citation revenue was collected.
- 6:54:16 Anthony Beale: Asked CDPH to review a past permit denial for a recycling facility on the far South Side,…
- 6:57:59 Ruth Cruz: Said she was disappointed with CDPH's response to a mental health situation in her ward and an…
- 7:10:38 William E. Hall: Asked whether CDPH tracks data on health challenges facing young people.
- 7:11:59 William E. Hall: Asked how CDPH reaches young people outside school.
- 7:13:58 William E. Hall: Offered to partner with CDPH on a youth-focused pilot in his ward.
- 7:30:22 2025 budget hearing: Department of Buildings
- 7:50:27 Michelle A. Harris: Asked whether Department of Buildings fees were raised in this budget.
- 8:17:29 Monique L. Scott: Thanked the Department of Buildings for responsiveness on complicated situations in her…
- 8:29:53 Stephanie D. Coleman: Raised concern about funding for demolition of dilapidated buildings and asked how it…
- 8:33:24 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked whether the department has assessed buildings marked with red X signs for first…
- 8:58:48 2025 budget hearing: Department of Family and Support Services
- 9:19:00 Michelle A. Harris: Asked DFSS to explain how the new shelter process will work for a homeless family.
- 9:23:03 Monique L. Scott: Thanked DFSS for its work during the migrant response.
- 9:23:36 Jeylú B. Gutiérrez: Thanked DFSS for its response to people living under bridges and in alleys in her ward.
- 9:24:56 Jessica L. Fuentes: Asked about sharing CPS documentation so young people can get identification needed for…
- 9:57:16 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked the cost of Senior Fest and suggested lower-cost venues.
- 10:17:21 Jason C. Ervin: Asked how much the budget includes for accelerated moving events for encampments and how…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations held a day of 2025 budget hearings, beginning with a 30-minute public comment period in which 15 speakers drawn at random urged more corporate funding for the Chicago Department of Public Health, $11.2 million for the Flexible Housing Pool, continued funding for community violence intervention, child care and mental health services, and a senior bill of rights. Members then questioned leadership of the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities, the Commission on Human Relations, the Chicago Department of Public Health, the Department of Buildings, and the Department of Family and Support Services. Recurring topics included hate crime staffing, the expiration of COVID-era and ARPA grant funding, hard-to-fill clinical and environmental inspection positions, the CARE crisis response program, air quality monitoring, building enforcement and ownership transparency, and the move to a unified homeless shelter system. Many members requested follow-up information through the chair. No votes were taken; the hearings were discussion only and the committee stood at ease until 10 a.m. the next day.
Topics: 2025 budget hearings, Disability services and accessibility, Hate crimes and human relations, Public health funding and grant expiration, Mental health and CARE crisis teams, Environmental permitting and air monitoring, Building permits, inspections and enforcement, Homelessness and the shelter system, Gender-based violence services, Senior services
Agenda items discussed
- 6:06 Public comment: discussed
- 46:41 2025 budget hearing: Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities: discussed
- 2:37:36 2025 budget hearing: Chicago Commission on Human Relations: discussed
- 4:20:35 2025 budget hearing: Chicago Department of Public Health: discussed
- 7:30:22 2025 budget hearing: Department of Buildings: discussed
- 8:58:48 2025 budget hearing: Department of Family and Support Services: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Said he had not yet received departments' answers to the pre-submitted questions and expected more information the following week. (2:32:50); Noted that the Human Relations commissioner's salary was only about $250 above her first deputy's and said salary compression for department heads should be addressed. (3:28:06); Asked how much the budget includes for accelerated moving events for encampments and how much more could be done with additional funding. (10:17:21)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked whether the roughly $5 million reduction in MOPD contractual services was related to a reserve appropriation. (1:11:58); Asked whether the Cut the Tape initiative would shorten wait times for disabled parking approvals. (1:14:28); Asked how many people are waiting for home modifications compared with the 188 completed and what limits expansion of the program. (1:17:13)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Thanked the MOPD commissioner for meeting with students and interns and asked what else the office needs and how to engage more with youth. (1:09:38)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Requested a list of MOPD delegate agencies and the service impact of a $200,000 cut. (1:22:32); Asked whether MOPD has analyzed accessibility of older public buildings such as City Hall, schools and libraries. (1:23:28); Asked why MOPD software licensing increased from $7,000 to $150,000. (1:24:32)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Said real-time captioning had dramatically improved from the prior year. (1:33:49); Asked whether bond financing is going toward home modifications and how to shorten the wait list. (1:35:12); Asked how MOPD works with CDOT on public way accessibility under new federal guidelines. (1:36:04)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Asked the initial and ongoing costs of MOPD's housing locator platform and noted its possible expansion to list affordable units. (1:40:27); Asked how many disabled Chicagoans live in nursing facilities or group homes versus in the community. (1:41:55); Asked for more formal accessibility training and standards for aldermanic offices. (1:43:04)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked for an example of how delegate agencies are held accountable to measurable results. (1:44:53); Asked about the nature of litigation over accessible pedestrian signals. (1:47:16); Asked MOPD to identify its language access coordinator and provide a breakdown of language access services. (1:49:34)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked about MOPD travel reimbursement line items. (1:52:01); Questioned salary increases for a deputy commissioner and a disability specialist at a time when departments are asked to cut. (1:54:01); Asked how many MOPD staff are dedicated to seniors after the Department of Aging's functions were split. (1:57:41)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked how aldermanic offices are doing on accessibility. (2:05:39); Asked how the city is doing at recruiting and hiring people with disabilities. (2:06:04); Said she was disappointed the budget does not include sidewalk snow plowing. (2:09:08)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Asked whether MOPD has staff dedicated to former Department of Aging functions. (2:13:51); Asked for MOPD and CDOT help with curb cuts in front of homes of wheelchair users who must use the street to reach pickup vehicles. (2:14:42)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Asked what initiatives MOPD plans to further reduce employment barriers for people with disabilities. (2:18:14); Asked about upcoming accessibility projects in public and private spaces. (2:20:38); Said she was disappointed with CDPH's response to a mental health situation in her ward and an unanswered email. (6:57:59)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked how MOPD reaches students with disabilities at CPS schools beyond specialized schools. (2:23:59); Urged CDPH to make sure HIV resources reach organizations on the ground in African American communities. (5:12:27); Asked how CDPH and DFSS conduct outreach to seniors on long-term health issues and what it costs. (5:13:07)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Asked about representation of people with disabilities on transit boards and Pace pickup times. (2:26:59); Asked about progress slowing a new drug circulating on the West Side. (6:05:18); Asked how many food inspections CDPH conducted and how much citation revenue was collected. (6:08:15)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said he sends standard budget memos to each department and expects completed responses before hearings so information is on the record. (2:31:40)
- Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez (alderperson): Asked how the Commission on Human Relations budget will help it meet community needs in the coming years. (2:40:11); Asked whether the commission is worried about federal funding changes under the new administration. (2:43:15); Asked how CDPH is prepared for the new federal administration and the decrease in COVID funding. (4:39:12)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked for year-over-year hate crime and hate incident numbers. (2:43:45); Asked whether hate littering is being tracked yet. (2:45:21); Asked what the commission plans to do proactively next year to keep communities safe. (2:46:27)
- Jessica L. Fuentes (alderperson): Asked the hate crime victim advocate to describe his daily work. (3:04:37); Asked how many hate crime specialists the department ideally needs. (3:06:40); Asked about sharing CPS documentation so young people can get identification needed for summer jobs. (9:24:56)
- Ronnie L. Mosley (alderperson): Asked what resources are available to communities affected by a hate incident involving flyers posted in his ward. (3:09:59)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Thanked the commission for its work on hate littering and antisemitic incidents in his ward and said the team needs more resources. (3:27:02)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked about the responsibilities of CDPH's environmental permitting and inspections division. (4:51:24); Asked how CDPH can address the cumulative impact of data centers proposed in her ward. (4:52:53); Requested a list of CDPH programs by funding source, noting which lack funding past 2025. (4:55:50)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Thanked the CDPH commissioner and liaison and said he had no questions. (5:20:40)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Raised concern about significant cuts to CDPH, especially contractual services, given declining life expectancy. (5:33:10); Asked whether CDPH monitors environmental requirements of city contracts. (5:33:59); Asked how environmental violations by city contractors are communicated for enforcement. (5:35:57)
- Lamont J. Robinson (alderperson): Asked about the plan to get to zero new HIV cases by 2030 and why cases are rising among Black gay men. (5:43:46); Asked whether grant money can be used for education by Black-led organizations. (5:46:30); Asked whether CDPH works with housing, workforce, education and county agencies on wraparound services. (5:48:23)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Asked how many vacant CDPH positions are proposed to be cut and how long each has been vacant. (5:53:49); Asked whether CARE team hours will expand beyond weekdays in 2025. (5:55:36); Asked whether any CARE team members or members of the public have been assaulted in encounters. (5:57:26)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked CDPH to review a past permit denial for a recycling facility on the far South Side, saying the city faces significant lawsuit exposure. (6:54:16)
- William E. Hall (alderperson): Asked whether CDPH tracks data on health challenges facing young people. (7:10:38); Asked how CDPH reaches young people outside school. (7:11:59); Offered to partner with CDPH on a youth-focused pilot in his ward. (7:13:58)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Asked whether Department of Buildings fees were raised in this budget. (7:50:27); Asked DFSS to explain how the new shelter process will work for a homeless family. (9:19:00)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Thanked the Department of Buildings for responsiveness on complicated situations in her ward. (8:17:29); Thanked DFSS for its work during the migrant response. (9:23:03)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Raised concern about funding for demolition of dilapidated buildings and asked how it can be fully funded. (8:29:53); Asked whether the department has assessed buildings marked with red X signs for first responders. (8:33:24); Asked the cost of Senior Fest and suggested lower-cost venues. (9:57:16)
- Jeylú B. Gutiérrez (alderperson): Thanked DFSS for its response to people living under bridges and in alleys in her ward. (9:23:36)
Exchanges between members
- 1:22:32 Lopez said he was following up on matters Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee had raised about MOPD.
- 1:42:58 Hadden seconded a point La Spata had raised about accessibility support for aldermanic offices.
- 1:47:16 Vasquez followed up on La Spata's question about accessible pedestrian signal litigation.
- 2:05:24 Manaa-Hoppenworth said she wanted to build on Hadden's interest in making aldermanic office communications more accessible.
- 2:05:39 Manaa-Hoppenworth built on Lopez's request for accessibility audits of public facilities.
- 2:23:46 Moore noted Lopez had already asked about One Summer Chicago participation.
- 2:31:40 Reilly called the chair's attention to the budget memos he sends departments ahead of hearings.
- 2:32:50 Ervin replied that answers to Reilly's questions had not yet been received and more information was expected.
- 3:01:56 Taylor added on to Hadden's point about hate crime staffing and resources.
- 3:25:08 Hadden sought clarification on the commission's answer to Lopez's question about a position moved to the corporate fund.
- 5:06:09 Hadden followed up on HIV funding questions Dowell had raised.
- 5:08:03 Hadden added to Dowell's request for a list of expiring grant-funded programs.
- 5:11:14 Dowell asked that Hadden's information request be combined with her own.
- 5:21:34 Sposato asked Lee to note to the chairman that he had been present for quorum.
- 5:21:41 Lee said she would leave a note for the chairman.
- 5:53:40 Martin followed up on La Spata's line of questioning about CDPH vacancies.
- 6:35:47 Lawson said he wanted to build on Taylor's concerns about unlicensed food vendors.
- 6:51:32 Lee said that, like Manaa-Hoppenworth, she lives in an area without consistent CARE coverage.
- 7:20:28 Lee thanked Taylor for her question about youth access to cannabis and hemp-derived products and said regulation is needed.
- 7:42:27 Moore deferred his turn to Mitts, citing her seniority.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error