We will get started momentarily. We have 30-plus people who have signed up for public comment. However, our period of public comment is only for 30 minutes in its entirety. What I'm going to do is I'm going to ask the sergeant at arms to bring the drum out. We're going to do 15, which would be two minutes per person, and we're going to pull them right out of the drum. So that's how we're going to do that. We cannot do all 30 public comments right now during this time. So we're going to pull them out at random. Make sure that you've had yours in. The Sergeant at Arms has given me 30 of them, and everyone will have two minutes, and we will do 15 individuals. Thank you. Chairman, this is Kamal. We have one person in Zoom also. Mr. Blakemore, Mr. Blakemore, if you continue with that same language, you will be removed from the chamber. That's number one. That's number two. Say something else. 2023 to 2027 pursuant to the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, Rule 49, the Sergeant at Arm sets forth the following rules of conduct to be followed during the public comment period and the duration of all committee and city council meetings. Profane, vulgar, threatening, abusive, or disruptive language is not permitted. Demeaning, discriminatory, or harassing behavior and speech directed towards others is not permitted. Disruptive behavior. including disruptive or disrespectful conduct during others' presentations, is not permitted. Banners, flyers, or signage are not permitted. Backpacks, large bags, and sharp objects are not permitted. Clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 by 12 by 6 inches, will be permitted and are subject to search. Health food and beverages, including in metal canisters, are not permitted. Cell phones must be placed on silent prior to entering the meeting room, individuals must remain seated, public comment speakers are permitted to stand only when providing public comment, small handheld devices may be used only while seated and the user must refrain from interfering with the view or hearing of other individuals. Individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be asked to cease such disruptive conduct and failure to comply will result in their being subject to removal from the meeting by the sergeant at arms. yeah one virtually you Good morning. We will begin public comment. Our first speaker is Wesley Epling. Wesley, again, Sergeant at Arms, please remove the gentleman. I gave him three warnings with profane language. Please remove him. We will begin with Wesley Epling. Are you on? Yes. Can you hear me? You may begin. You have two minutes. Hello. Can you hear me? Two minutes on the clock. All right. I'm going to start. Good morning, all there's some. Thank you for the opportunities to testify. Hi, I'm Wesley Epplin, and I serve as Policy Director at Health and Medicine Policy Research Group. I urge you to increase corporate funding for the Chicago Department of Public Health by $25 million in FY 2025. This would bring total corporate funding to CDPH to about $102 million. CDPH is understaffed in significant part due to being underfunded. More than 80 organizations signed on to our August letter requesting this increase in corporate fund dollars for CDPH. Mayor Brandon Johnson has proposed a reduction in Chicago corporate funding for CDPH for FY2025 in the amount of $770,000. Yes, Chicago has a difficult budget situation, but it is unacceptable that after decades of underfunding public health, after CDPH was understaffed and underprepared for COVID-19, and after health inequities have been getting worse in Chicago over the last several years, that after all that, the city of Chicago would invest less rather than more to public health. At the same time this is happening, COVID-related grants are expiring with an overall reduction to CDPH's budget of about $140 million and 124 fewer FTEs. In the shadow of the federal election results this week, we should expect that at the federal level there will likely be budget cuts to public health in the years to come and broader attacks on public health functioning. CDPH is heavily reliant on federal funding, so such cuts will worsen the health of your constituents. Even if those cuts don't come to pass, today CDPH is already woefully underfunded and understaffed. The bottom line is this, we need you to increase local funding to safeguard public health in Chicago. CDPH cannot fulfill its public health mission and lead efforts to eliminate health inequities without additional funding and staff. What happens when our elected officials underfund our health departments? Quite simply, public health problems go unaddressed. So I call on you as Chicago's elected officials to increase corporate funding for the Chicago Department of Public Health in the amount of $25 million in FY 2025. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Eppling, for your comments. Sergeant at Arms, I've asked for the removal of Mr. Blakemore. Please follow through on that notion. He's used profane language on several occasions in this conversation. So I've asked him, you all, to remove him. Okay? if you all want to continue down the same path, you all will be put out. Okay. Again, Call the lieutenant. Receive your feelings in my order. Call the lieutenant. The next speaker is Mirror Bird. Mirror Bird from West Montrose. Mirror Bird. My apologies, Myron. You're next. Followed by Carolyn Hatchet Myron followed by Carolyn Hold on Are you Myron? No, that's no No, ma'am. Myron Byrd. No, I did not. I called Myron Byrd. The gentleman. Go ahead. No problem. No problem. So you have two minutes for your comments. Can everyone hear me? And I just want to say this before I say something, please. Please. Please. Let's be respectful when someone is speaking, okay? Because if you want to speak, you don't want nobody to be talking over you. So, I'm a 56-year-old man with a lot of respect for all of you. Let's let someone speak. You too, sir. Let's you too, sir. Come on, Mr. Blakemore, please. Please. Please, please, please, please. Please. Could you restart the clock please for this gentleman go ahead will you start with two minutes sir all right good morning to mayor johnson and members of city council and to those are seating here today my name is myron bird and i'm with the chicago coalition to end homelessness i'm here to address the issue of homelessness in the city of chicago I know it's budget season and things can be stressful, but when it comes to the budget season, we want to highlight the need to find permanent housing services, to raise awareness of homelessness, specifically with the flexible housing pool. Investing in long-term solutions like the Flexible Housing Fund, which provides permanent housing and services to over 1,400 people, and to have dedicated revenue for permanent housing. So our ask here today is, we need dedicated revenue to successfully address this problem. In the meantime, prioritize permanent solutions to homelessness and fully fund the flexible housing pool for 11.2 million. This is what my ask is today. We know we got a homeless situation here in Chicago. You may have know of me because I was down here before of last year when we fought as Chicago Coalition for the Homeless. Now we're a Chicago Coalition to end homelessness. And I would love for members of city council, as well as the mayor, to work with us on trying to end this problem and find a solution to this situation. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Bird. Next, we will have Carolyn Hatchet. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on a second. We'll get a microphone for you. Can you come to the mic, ma'am? Okay. I'll bring you a mic, no problem. You have two minutes, Ms. Hatchet, and you'll be followed by Joshua Coakley. Very well. Hold on, ma'am. Hold on, turn the mic on. Hold on, no. It's okay, but hold on one second, man, because there are others who are listening online and they won't be able to hear you as you speak here. That's good. Thank you sweetheart. Good morning to each and every one of you all that's on the council today and to the guests. My name is Carolyn Hatchett. I greet you from home organization. I am, we have what we call a senior advisory council representing. We also represent the bill for the seniors. We know today that the seniors are being left behind. They need to be put in front line. We have a lot of things that the seniors and the disabled people are missing. We know the stores are being closed. We know they can't get to the medical facilities. They don't have this and that. The tenants' rights, if they speak up, then they're getting put out or threatened by the management. That's not right. We need to be respected as citizens, as seniors, as disabled people. And we need you all to hear our bill. We got a lot to offer. We would like to be able to interview the management, whether it be the city of Chicago or private. We need to know that if we say something, that it stays in mind. That when we give our information, that nobody runs and give it to somebody else. so when we get ready to move somewhere, people say, oh, well, you know that person is a problem. Not necessarily. We just want to be respected and honored for who we are. We are seniors. We are people. We're somebody's mother. We're somebody's sister. We're somebody's father. We're somebody's uncle. We're somebody. We're people. We need you all to hear us. We got a bill that we need to have instructed. and we're asking y'all to come forth and help us. Thank you, Ms. Hatchett. Next, we will have Joshua Coakley. Joshua Coakley, if you step to the mic, followed by Louvenia Hood. Ms. Coakley-Pleche. Good morning. Good morning, everyone. Can you hear me? yes sir please so good morning everyone my name is joshua i represent target area development corporation uh i'm here to speak on behalf of cvi for those who may not know cvi the acronyms are community violence intervention um i represent community violence intervention we are asking the mayor to hold study on his commitment to continue to fund community violence intervention and guaranteed it in any new version of the budget. Primarily what we want our aldermen to know is what CVI does. At Target Area and the areas of Auburn Gresham and Englewood, we have served over 300 individuals, high-risk individuals who are likely to be shot or likely to be a shooter, those who have been underlooked and over-served. There are many high-risk individuals that we serve on a daily basis. These are individuals whose social services in schools cannot even reach. We utilize our CVI pillars of behavior health, case management, education, and job training. We also utilize a program called FLIP, better known as Flatline Invite, Inspiring Peace. This gives individuals the opportunity to become peacekeepers in their own community. I often say this all the time, it's going to take us to save us. There is not enough polices to police our communities. So we must continue to support these community violence interventions. We're not just telling them to put down the guns, but we're telling them what to pick up. A lot of times our children are suffering from mental illness. We have to educate them and get them wellness so they can make righteous decisions. And the only way you do that is to meet them where they are. And we do that through street-level intervention, through credible messages. Those who have LTO, license to operate in these communities, from these communities, and creating change in our communities. My name is Joshua. Thank you. Lavinia Hood. My name is Lavinia Hood, the Executive Director of Mothers Opposed to Violence Everywhere. I want to thank you all for listening to me. Society is judged by how it's treated. Its most valuable means that a society more character and level of humanity is best measured by how it cares for and protects its weakest members, like the elderly, the disabled, and the homeless. MOVE has members in 15 senior buildings on the west side and two on the south side. Our members, along with our citywide coalition, that's here today, some of them, members have adopted the Senate Bill of Rights. We are asking every alderman to support this bill. And let me just say this. I myself get calls from seniors who are bed stricken. Some of them are in wheelchairs and on crutches. They can't get around. I have to hold on to their green cars to travel from different food pantries to different food pantries getting food for these seniors. And some of them can't even get in and out of the building because there's others pushing in before them. Winter and summer. Sometimes snow is on the ground and it is raining outside. Those poor seniors are stuck out there in wheelchairs, got to wait for somebody to come and give them some assistance to get into the building. And I'm going to just say this. Some of y'all that's sitting here yourself is a senior citizen. You're just more well off than a lot of those senior citizens who are in need for help. Now, thank you again for your ears. I talk fast and I talk loud because I'm a preacher. But they need help. We need you all to help them. you can afford it thank you thank you for your comments next we will have brian roger followed by dominique choose Hi, everybody. My name is Brian Rogers, and I represent Chicago Coalition to End Homelessness. How many times have we been down this road when it comes to housing? How many times we have to sit here and have these same arguments, these same discussions about funding, about getting support of permanent housing, how we're going to get it, how we're going to travel down that road? and quite frankly a lot of people are getting tired of it and I'm one of those who are getting tired of it I represent a population of re-entry populations that come from Illinois Department of Corrections and you probably have family members or such that have been down the same road who get out, who do not have supportive housing and they go back to the same thing because they don't have a stable permanent home And when they don't have a stable permanent home, all types of chaos and disruptions occur time and time again, and they're caught up in the prison industrial complex. And along with that, our seniors, our veterans, our CPS students, all of these individuals need flexible housing pools. They need money. Simple and plain as that. You do it time and time again. we sit here in these same seats. When is it going to end? When are you going to start doing your job? This is why we put you all in these seats. Time and time again, we elect you to do the job of the people. And when you're not doing the job of the people, quite frankly, you can get replaced. Nobody wants to hear that. But again, like I say, we need that money. $11 million to the flexible housing pool can be just a chip in this big problem. And you know you have a big problem here. You got Venezuelans here now, along with our Chicago population. And quite frankly, if you don't do anything, you're going to have a real big problem on your hands. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Next up is Dominique Chuse, followed by Leola Lewis. Vice Chair. Okay, my name is Dominique Chu. I'm the Housing Policy and Advocacy Manager at AIDS Foundation Chicago. I'm here today to ask you to fully fund the flexible housing pool within the Department of Family and Support Services budget for 2025 at $11.2 million. This funding will maintain the housing and wraparound supportive services for Chicagoans who currently receive housing and supportive services through the FHP. And without this funding, 1,400 participants, 500 of whom are children, could be at risk of returning to homelessness. For those of you who may not be as familiar with FHP, it's a collaborative effort of the City of Chicago and other entities across Cook County, which started in 2018. FHP began as a partnership between several cross-sector stakeholders to focus on a new approach to end homelessness among people cycling through public crisis systems. FHP braids together funding from multiple sectors, such as managed care organizations, foundations, and the private sector, reducing the burden on housing dollars. The FHP uses a housing-first approach, meaning that we make sure that participants are linked to safe and secure housing first before addressing any other health or wellness concerns. The FHP has been very successful in reaching significant milestones and achievements. These include, to date, serving over 1,500 participants, including youth, adults, and families with children, reduces the cost of crisis systems by $1.4 million over a two-year period, and has a 94% success rate in retaining individuals and families in stable housing for at least 12 months. and an evaluation that found that between 19 and 37% reduction in several areas, including reduced mortality among participants, reduction inpatient days, and visits to the ER, as well as a reduction in jail registration. The FHP has had a significant impact since its inception and has proven to be a great model of service to end homelessness. Oh, God, I have great tickets. And the administration to work together to fully fund the FHP at $11.2 million. We'll stop there. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Lewis. Our next speaker is going to be Carla Johnson. And after her, Jessica Proctor. Good morning. My name is Leola Lewis. I am a member of COCO, a resident of Paul G. Stewart. I am here and an advocate to speak on the senior bill of rights. As a senior, we deserve the value and respect and the dignity. We need the Department of Aging back. We need not to have to pay for lockouts. We are in senior buildings, and that's why I say it's senior building, okay? Because a lot of times people forget and get locked out of their apartments. We need to have 24-hour protection in our buildings. We need to not be afraid to speak up. I am on the Tenant Council. I'd like to thank Alderman Pat Dow for coming and helping us with our Tenant Council. I'd like to thank Ms. Alderman Jeanette for sticking with us on the Bill of Rights. we also need to not be afraid to speak up when it comes time to speak up to think that we are going to be put out because we speak up for ourselves yeah we also excuse me got a little more time okay seniors should not be afraid to organize we should be able to organize when it's time for us to organize. We should not be afraid that we are going to be sent out. And we ask you to please bring back the Department of Aging. Help us to have lawyers to help us with management. I should be able to go to my management without telling me to email my management or to call them and then tell me that I cannot talk to them or do not call me and look me in my eyes and tell me something and then tell me no I did not say that when yes you did I am not have Alzheimer's. Thank you. Okay. Thank you for your comments. Carla Johnson followed by Jessica Proctor. Good morning. My name is Carla Johnson. I'm a grassroots leader member of the Chicago Coalition to End Homelessness. I'm also a member of the Cocoa Kenwood Oakland community. I'm also a member of the Metropolitan Tennis Organization. I'm also a senior in the Pioneer Village Senior Citizens Apartments, where I am the vice president on the Tennis Council. So I'm here today to ask that the Bring Chicago Home campaign that did not pass on the March referendum ballot, which would have generated $100 million revenue for homelessness, didn't pass. Well, it was going to be for everyone that was unhoused. Since that didn't pass, we would like for the council to look into the flexible housing pool, which is a program, as we just heard from Dominique, that is successful, that is working, that just needs an increase to maintain the progress that they're making right now. We're asking that you all support that flexible housing program and help us with the situation of the 68,000 people that we still have homeless in the city of Chicago, not counting the asylum seekers that have also come here. We support our mayor. We want this to work, and we need that support. I'll resume the rest of my time. Thank you. Jessica Proctor followed by Criola Kizart Hampton. Good morning. My name is Jessica Proctor and I'm a policy analyst at Alternative, a nonprofit that supports Chicago youth to build safer communities through a combination of restorative justice and behavioral health services. While we applaud the mayor for his support of treatment not trauma and a 1.5 million increase for mental health services through the Office of Emergency Management and Communications, this is not enough to adequately address the mental health needs of Chicago. Reflecting on today's testimony and the urgent need for accessible public health services resources, I'm reminded of a 15-year-old client we serve whose family faces immense challenges. His mother, without health insurance, has struggled with untreated mental health needs and a chronic illness. As a result, he's taken on responsibilities far beyond his years, balancing school while providing emotional support to his family and caring for his mother. If she had access to affordable treatment, it could bring stability to not only to her life, but also his, allowing him to focus on his education and development during these formative years. This experience is all too common and exemplifies a broader truth. The health of one individual profoundly impacts the well-being of entire families and communities. And while our team at Alternative is dedicated to supporting families like his, without expanded public health resources, the need will continue to outpace what we can provide. This is why CDPH needs full, sustainable funding to ensure families can access the support they need without barriers or limitations. Over the last several years, the Chicago Department of Public Health funding has relied upon comfort, relief, and ARPA funds. We cannot allow the loss of federal funds to prevent health department from doing their work to support the health of the city. The city's residents deserve a fully funded Department of Public Health. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Next, we have a Crayola Kizart Hampton, followed by Derek Lyons. Good morning. from Creole, Kizart-Hampton, and I am board chair for the Black Leadership Advocacy Coalition for Healthcare Equity, a non-profit organization comprised of 21 organizations across the state of Illinois. I'm a lifetime resident of Chicago and currently living in the 21st Ward. And we are here because for the last two decades at least, the Chicago Department of Public Health has allocated only between one to eight percent of its $43 million budget to African-American-led organizations while black people comprise 50% of new HIV cases and 52% of existing cases. This report has been so stunning that it was reported in the Tuskegee Institute on Public Health three years ago and cited the Chicago Department of Public Health for its public records on the inequity of funding while HIV AIDS continues to rage in black communities. Though black-led organizations have pushed for change in multiple meetings with CDPH commissioners and deputy commissioners, including the former Allison Arwadi and under Dr. Fregurte and Dave Kern, systemically racist barriers to funding for equity still have yet to be dismantled. Currently, Dr. Ege is finally committed to giving $2 million a year to HIV AIDS black-led organizations, but is saying that those organizations must be led by black gay men only. How sad that is when there are 18 times more black women who are HIV positive than white women. We are demanding today that the city council consider an ordinance to allocate $3 billion a year, just like the state of Illinois is doing, to go to African-American-led organizations. And we have the support of Alderman Maria Haddon. We have the support also of Jeanette Taylor as well as Sophia King. And we have in the past had the support of Pat Dowell. allocate funding to black led organizations. Racism is a public health issue. Funding equity is demanded. Thank you for your comments. Next we will have Derek Lyons followed by Cookie Delgado Ramirez. Hello everyone in the council. I'm Derek Lyons. I was part of the flexible housing Pool Program participant. I was homeless for over 10 years. I was sleeping outside on the trains. I was sleeping in the parks. I was sleeping in abandoned buildings. I slept in abandoned cars. I had felt that I had no hope. And I was actually called by Flexible Housing Pool for housing. And with that, I've been housed for a while. I've also been back to college. I'm also part of the Chicago Housing and Health Board and the Flexible Housing Governance Board. And we're asking that you fund Flexible Housing Poole with at least $11.2 million. And thank you. Thank you, Mr. Lyons. Next we will have Cookie Delgado Ramirez followed by Gabriela Pesero. Cookie Delgado, are you here? Cookie Delgado Ramirez Okay, we will pass on that one Gabriela Percero Followed by Constance Hatchet Thank you. for children, for all, right? Health mental. We take care, we take care, we take care of people to help them to help them. My children, sometimes they don't have money to pay, or people who take care of them to help them to help them. They take care of them to help them to help them. We take care of them to help them to help them. We take care of them to help them to help them. We take care of them to help them to help them. children, that we don't have much in the street, vandalism, violence, that we have to take care of our children's funds for our children's health, we require $7 million for our children's health, for day care, We have 25 million in the mental health department. The mental health is essential for everyone, especially for adolescents. I will briefly translate. My name is Gabriela Piceno. I am a member, a community member of the Little Village community and a leader with Kofi Power Pack. I am here because our children need daycares. We need, in my community, we have a big need for child care centers of people that are trained. It's something that we don't have very much of and we don't have safe places for our children to be. And so we also need mental health services for our children so that they're not involved in violence and vandalism. And that's something that we need. And so we're requesting $7 million for child care services and $25 million for mental health services in our communities. Thank you for your comments. Constance Hatchet. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm a member, a resident at Netley Simon House, a senior home who helps a lot of elderly and senior. and we are integrational resident where we have some young people, but we are concerned about the fact that we need during the winter time, we need some support where they bring in and move the snow. And by the bus stops, they need to move the snow where the seniors that want to go out, make a clear walkway for all the seniors in the senior areas. We need you to definitely bring back Department of Agents because we need that. We need the help from them. And we want you to please just help us and help the seniors get around. We need, like during the wintertime also, when you stop the bus transportation, have a bus to go around certain areas and pick up the seniors and make room. because too, it's not fair when people are sitting at the bus stops in the senior areas. And when we need to catch a bus, the bus go right by and not, we're not able to get on that bus because the people that are not supposed to be there are there smoking and they just drive right by. Please make sure that we get the assistance we need as seniors. And remember, we are, you going to be a senior too one day and some of you all are seniors already. We have to respect. Yeah, we are all seniors. So please, that's what I'd like to see happen. Thank you, ma'am. Cookie Delgado Ramirez is not here. I'm going to take one more to round out our 15. Give us one second. I thought the box was behind me. Our final speaker is Tinny Gross Our final speaker is Tinny Gross Tenny Gross Final speaker Good morning I'm Tenny Gross from the Institute for Nonviolence Chicago Like Josh, we are a violence reduction organization in Austin, West Garfield, back of the yards. Last year, 2023, we had 314 mediations that probably prevented shootings. Our team of outreach, job readiness, reentry, and victim support supported 922 individuals. 316 victims were supported 176 victims became program participants doing workforce and other services to help restore post-trauma what they're going through the frontline outreach workers and victim advocates responded to 391 shootings 24 hours a day in those three neighborhoods in 2023 The team of outreach workers created 40 peace and non-aggression agreements in 2023. Just in Austin, we have 52 rival groups, just to give you a bit of an idea of what they're dealing with. I want to say the story of Marcus. Marcus started as a participant in Hubbard Park, grew up in a family that had a lot of drug dealing, a lot of arrests, cost the taxpayer a lot of money, participated in the Ready program, did CBT, did the workforce, then he went to Flip. Again, guarding in Hubbard Park, just so that spot would be safer. Became a supervisor in Flip. And when I interviewed him to be an outreach worker eight months ago, I said, why are you doing it, Marcus? He says, the passion, the fact that you're doing light in the night in Hubbard Park, the fact that you outreach workers came to our neighborhood to do i never seen that before i said i wanted to be part of that i wanted to be part of that solution so thank you to the city council and the city for supporting us we have about 2 000 people now with backgrounds in the city either employed or stipend thank you thank you mr gross we will begin uh today our first department is the mayor's office of people with disabilities. We will start with Council Office of Financial Analysis. Director Oda Gray will give a summation, followed by introductions from Commissioner Arthur. Chairman Irvin, Vice Chairman Lee, all other persons, and guests. Good morning. My name is Janice Oda Gray. I'm the Director of COFA. I'm doing an overview now on the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. For the older persons that have a COFA book, it's on page 33. You can follow me on page 33 if you have a COFA book. The total proposed budget for FY25 is $14.8 million, which is a 1.3% decrease compared to 24. Personnel services have increased from $4.38 million in FY24 to $4.46 million. The FY25 budget includes a reduction of only one FTE. Contractual services for fiscal year 25 have been cut by 54%, decreasing from $9.9 million to $4.6 million. And the department is funded through corporate funds at the rate of 22.3%. The budget allocation includes $4.5 million for personnel and $10.4 million for non-personnel expenses. Going to the next page, you're going to see appropriation by category and millions in budgeted FTEs by funding type. And you can look at all the different categories and see for year 24 and 25 the budgeted FTEs by funding type. On the next page, there's appropriations by funding type. That's a historical walk from 2016 to 2017, and you just see the difference in local funding, CDBG funding, and grant funding by year. And the final page is a budget appropriation by funding type for the years 22, 23, 24, and 25. And it's just a walk on the appropriation by funding type. You can see grants at the first part of it and then local and then CDBG. And it's just from 22 and all the out years through 25. Thank you. Thank you, Director Gray. Commissioner, if you could introduce yourself and members of your team, after which we will begin into questions. Thank you, Chairman Irvin. I'm Commissioner Rachel Leifert of the City of Chicago Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. Thank you, Chairman Irvin, Vice Chair for the Mayor of Patrick Charleston, and other members of the City Council. I'm going to turn it to Esther who is to my right. Hi everyone. I'm Esther Gutierrez, senior policy analyst at the mayor's office for people with disabilities. And I'm going to pass it to the agency box. Good morning, everybody. Good morning, Chairman Irvin and Vice Chairman Lee. My name is Tom Cieschelski. I'm Deputy Commissioner of Compliance for the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities. Hello, my name is Mark Nobreghe. I'm a Program Director for our Home Mod Program. Good morning. My name is Christina McLean, Deputy Commissioner at the Mayor's Office for people with disabilities. Good morning. My name is Lauren Huberman. I'm the director of the Career Center for MOPD. Good morning. My name is Nina Campbell. I am the executive assistant to Commissioner Arfa and I also coordinate sign language interpreting services for city departments and events. Good morning. I'm Frida Morales, accountant for MOPD. Good morning. I'm Jocelyn Ramasanta. I'm a disability specialist for the Career Center. Good morning, I'm Pamela Palmintera, a program director with the Disability Resource Unit. Good morning, Claire Stanhope, training officer. Good morning, Portia Seals, project coordinator for the Disabled Survivors of Gun and Community Violence Project. Thank you. We also have some additional members of my team here who are providing American Sign Language interpretation I'm sorry, go ahead. You gotta speak more into the mic. Is that better? Thank you, I appreciate the feedback. Everybody here, let me know if I am talking, closing up, so please let me know that. So we also have members of our team, our staff, American Saint-Leguich interpreters, who are working hard to provide, make these proceedings accessible in American Saint-Leguich. and even doing probably common trilingual interpretation in English, Spanish, and American Sign Language. So their names are Walter Matthews, who you see standing on the diaries here behind me, and then he's teaming with Samantha Taplin, and then directly in front of me, Esteban Estamaro, and then Jennifer McElroy. We also have real-time captioning available today, so you can see it up on the screen, I also have a website link through members of City Council if you would like to follow using that captioning link. That was some very important feedback thing I got last year, and we worked very hard to make sure that we moved away from automatic captions to real-time captioning. And I'm really pleased that we've been able to do that, and I thank the Office of the City Council for their partnership. So first, I just want to thank my hardworking team at the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities for all of their hard work and dedication, both people who are here today and who are in our offices. It is such a privilege to work alongside each of you. And I want to thank everyone who worked with us to make the City of Chicago the most accessible and inclusive city in the world. We do not do this work alone. We do this work with you. From the mayor's office, to members of city council, to our city departments and sister agencies, and of course, our community members, we are collectively advanced accessibility. There's evidence of MRPD's far-reaching impact in both visible and less visible ways. In today's statement, I will share examples of our impact. Obviously, one example of a visible impact is for the captioning site language interpretation that you see. Our interpreter provided communication access this year so far for over 1,000 and 547 hours for mayoral press coverage and city engagement events, city services, city festivals in Moore. The Mayor's office is city department and sister agencies are also partners in our city wide accessibility, including Sylvica's access officer, which ensures a parade person on public basic accessibility in every city department and sister agency. We complete our access officer every month this past year, and as a result, departments collaborate to share ideas and solutions. They provide increased accessibility. One example I would like to highlight, we worked with Commissioner V at the Department of Aviation to rule out the disabilities there at the yard. So anybody who wants to travel through the airport and has a not visible disability, but would like some services could wear this. And I have some additional ones of these, if you would like to take them back to your offices, that you know about this. But we know that that makes air travel more comfortable for people with not visible disabilities. We also partnered with BACP to host an event for Uber and then drivers to raise awareness about service and animal best practices. We've also built a robust training team. This year, we had more trainings than ever before, providing 60 trainings to over 2,049 attendees. We had seven trainings for our automatic offices attended by 31 words. So thank you to you and your teams for attending our trainings. And then we also had four trainings to the mayor's office, as well as employers in our community organization. Topics of these trainings were on disability in access, how to host accessible meetings and events, service animal best practices, inclusion hiring practices. This matters because we know that one in four adults in Chicago has a disability. This is one of the many data findings due to our partnership with the Chicago Department of Public Health Research Team at the Healthy Community Survey. Not surprisingly, the number one highest population of people with disabilities is people over 65 because we know that people often acquire disability as they age. The second highest group of people with disabilities is people between the ages of 18 to 29, which only reverses our priority to serve youth and young adults with disabilities. We have released a two-page summary that's available on our website. If we are finalizing a lot of report, we see the page that will be published. You can download this two-page report at MLPD's website, and I'm holding up right now. We also now know how many people with disabilities are in each of our neighborhoods. For example, we know that in the Austin neighborhood, one in three people have a disability, who are exactly 25,609 people. We also know that young people with disabilities were out of work at the career center is now celebrating his two year anniversary, it seems youth and adults with disabilities here supports career readiness, causally called disability disclosure, reasonable accommodations, mentoring. 40% of our clients are young people with disabilities between the ages of 16 to 26. We also bring together job seekers with disabilities and employers. For example, we hosted a network affair in October, bringing together over 32 employers and over 150 job seekers. We continue to learn about. Ma'am, ma'am, please, Laura to finish her testimony. Ma'am, this is, this is, I, ma'am, okay, I understand what you're saying, okay? Okay. We'll work with them to fix that particular issue if you can't see the captioning. I understand, ma'am. I heard you. I hear you. We'll see what we can do to fix that, okay? All right. Mr. Engineer, could you turn up the volume? Thank you Ma'am, ma'am, ma'am She has a disability That is her speech And so please Please Understand, please Please You okay? Alright, go ahead Go ahead, Commissioner I told you that Thank you Go ahead. I can't do that. Kamal? Yes, Chairman. Can you increase the font and the caption, please? Yes, we just did, but we'll increase it more. Could you increase it a little more, please? Okay, we're doing it. Can you just make it as large as you can? Thank you, Chairman. Go ahead, Commissioner. Our career center also has our own podcast, the All Access podcast, which also has captions, captions, and a miracle-signing rich interpretation. We used our podcast to highlight issues about disability employment. We also support city and Chicago employees with disabilities. I am so proud to serve as the executive sponsor for the Disability for a Wanchai Employee Visitors Group, which is the first employee visitors group of its kind at the city. if we bring together disabled people and allies. Our video honoring October's National Disability Employment Awareness Month was at the City of Chicago's main page last week. We also launched a voluntary survey to collaborate with employees with disabilities to identify opportunities to continue building and retaining our disabled workforce if we continue to collect responses. We also support students with disabilities and families and partner with our technical agency, Ada S. McAlee Community Services to launch a new $5 million cash assistance program this year funded through the American Rescue Plan Act. In 2024, we are distributing $500 to over 8,000 students with disabilities agrees critical to do 12, green who live in Chicago, yet meet income guidelines. Our application deadline is November 15, 2024. I also have a flyer here that I'm holding up about this program. If we have additional copies, if you would like to help us get the word out. I will say that we have already awarded awarded 48% of our funds to over 3,825 students with disabilities who live on all 50 rules of our city. Our city has been in a city-wide effort to engage a few members of city council, city department, sister agencies, partnering with Chicago Public School, office for our students with disability, Joshua Logue, community stakeholders, your music, radio, and your social media. We also attended for Pura Khan Pickup this past Monday at 14 Chicago Public Schools. We talked to students and families. We are on track. The mean average goal of reaching over 8,000 families by the end of this year. Clearly, we have over 13,288 applications from over 12,000 unique households. Many of these families are learning about MLPD and city services, who are the first time if we intend to continue to build these relationships long term. Another way we built relationships this year is through the launch of our program to serve people who acquire a disability through gun and community violence. Senator Duckworth, Chair, put this earmark, which was successfully funded through the United States Department of Justice. We prioritize areas, it measures people's plan for our community safety at the Austin Eagle Fund, South Alder, Lutter Village, and east of West Garfield Park neighborhoods. If we meet regularly in each of these communities, with leaders in organization, We believe that people with disabilities can live independently and out of our communities and a home modification program makes this possible. In 2024, through a record-breaking through a $48 million investment, we are on track to make 188 homes accessible. The typical accessibility modification is to make the entrance to the home accessible by adding a link to the entrance. It also means we also make bathrooms and cations accessible. This program is funded through CDBG, CERPA, CHA, and Department of Housing Dollars. The average cost of each modification is about $21,000. We will continue to seek additional federal, state, local fund to meet these increasing demand. We also provided six hours of personal assistance weekly to 83 people with disabilities to be able to live independently in their own homes. MLPD is also a contributing member to Mayor Joseph's Cutter Tape Initiative. Under my leadership, we have double our Accessibility Compliance Unit, which includes a Deputy Commissioner, Uncle Tech, two project coordinators, and two accessibility inspectors. I am pleased that our 2025 budget includes adding a much-needed second Uncle Tech for position, which further demonstrates that our city values accessibility in our permit review process. Our team completed 222 pre-permit plan reviews and 407 permit reviews this past year. We also completed 41 city-front multi-family housing development reviews, and we continue to partner with the Department of Housing and serve as a contributing member of the DOH steering committee to vote on to reviewing housing policy. Our team also answered over 150 requests through our technical assistance from the public, architects, and developers. This year, MLPD also launched the Chicago Housing Locator on our website, which identifies available and accessible rental housing and needed resources through a disabled housing sequence. Since March in April, our locator has averaged about 27,000 site visitors every month. Finally, MOPD partnered with 2FM and the Public Buildings Commission to complete over 85 assessments of city buildings that are public facing as part of our ongoing priority to ensure that city programs and facilities are accessible. Thank you for the support of the mayor's office for people with disabilities. I look forward to continue our work and accomplish even more in 2025. Thank you for your opening statement. We will open... the questions uh first will be uh president pro tem nugent followed by vice chair lee anyone else have questions for mopd yeah if y'all would have looked at your phones you could have been first that's why she ended up coming up so uh nugent followed by vice chair lee again i've asked i'm Jesus Christ. Nugent followed by Vice Chair Lee. Thank you, Chairman. And thank you, Commissioner Arfa, for your continued work. It's so impressive. Thank you. Good morning, Commissioner. I just want to thank you for coming out to our ward and meeting with the students at Northside Learning Center. And also for my colleagues that didn't know this, Commissioner Arfa spoke with all of our interns this summer in a really impressive forum over at the Cultural Center. And I just want to thank you for that. It was really impactful. My only question is, what else do you need? And can you talk me through how we can interface more with youth and any ideas you have on how we can be more supportive of that? Well, thank you. I'm ultimately new to you. And it was really great to get to talk with you this summer at the panel. And Northside Learning Center really has a phenomenal program. The second question is, how can we work together to interface more with youth? So one of the ways that we can do that is through our compliance center. We are supporting young people with disabilities. So for example, this summer we supported over 130 young people with disabilities to apply through our up well summer, Chicago. One of my first jobs was when I was 15, I worked for a gallery 37, which was the city program. And I think there's nothing more important than helping young people, including those with disabilities, to get that first job experience. It began to build your career. But many times, young people with disabilities don't know what it means, how to advocate for yourself at a job, what kind of accommodations you may need, and that's one of the ways that we partner with the MSS and the Mayor's Office to support young people with disabilities, to be with them to continue to expand on that, because once you know those skills, that will help to continue to set you up for success in learning, how to advocate for yourself for the rest of your career, so that could be one great opportunity. do thank you i appreciate that and thanks to you and your team for all you do that's all i have mr chairman thank you president pro temp vice chair lee followed by alderman lopez thank you chair uh good morning commissioner nice to see you thanks for being here you and your team um as always um let's get a few questions looking at um your your budget this year looks like contractual services has the biggest reduction at approximately 5 million can you talk about what services are being or has that been transferred to another place because i think there's also a 5 million a 5 million dollar appropriation 5.7 million out of the reserve balance that's funded by multiple grants i'm just trying to understand if those two things are related absolutely so the five million is our cash assistance program for our students with disabilities. And those $5 million have been obligated. And we are on track to spend all the $5 million this year by the end of the year. So that's why then those dollars do not appear in the budget for next year. Okay. And is that the same as contractual services? Because that COFA noted that there was, that was your biggest reduction, was a $5 million reduction in contractual services. I see the five million dollars is um Ada S McCurdy Community Services in the medical agency um I still do what it added on yes there's um a few different kind of fund codes in there and some of them will appear in the reserve balance the 909A account okay so those two are kind of washing each other out okay um that's good to know I just wanted to make sure we weren't actually five million dollars in services um can you talk about what the what moPD's top three budget priorities are for the coming fiscal year um i will have three budget priorities um but first next year we are um adding a contact rule to our accessibility to the cup of ideas unit So we're absolutely thrilled about that because it would allow us to really expand our build capacity in our program and support, sorry, to be able to meet the goals of Cototape, which is to help everyone, and I'm going to talk to the public through the system as quickly as possible and dramatically reduce the amount of time but also allows us to be able to provide technical assistance to support it work collaboratively both internally to the city and externally as well. Does any of the cut the tape initiative include reviewing requests for disabled parking? I know this is something we've talked about in the past past and the the amount of time that um people with disabilities who are applying for disabled parking um have to wait from start to finish is quite long um which i think is really challenging because these are the people that need the the parking um the most so you've got any um you know comments on how your department or maybe initiatives with cdot um and the transportation committee might be working together to shorten the amount of time that people with disabilities are waiting to get approvals yeah but i think then i was saying i'm going to tell this over to nina cable on my team who um oversees our um disabled party as well um under nina's leadership we've been able to since you came to mrpd we've been able to reduce the amount of um time it takes for mrpd to review party appeal if you also work with the department of finance you see that and identifying other solutions that cover to the type of Nina Kaliab as in the parking appeals that I'm a PD to the average amount of time that we takes to review them. Could you please identify yourself for the record please? Oh sorry Nina Campbell. The only time that we review parking appeals or any type of disabled parking spaces or poses when an applicant applies and they get denied. And then they have the option to appeal. And that's the only time that we come in. Once we receive an appeal, we review it and we send our determination back to Department of Finance every week. So we do like a bundle every week and we scan them and send our decision to Department of Finance. And from there, Department of Finance generates a letter and mail it out to the applicant. And that typically could take 30 days. Can we get through the chair, the number of denials that are sent your way for review on an annual basis? I can tell you also how many people this year we've done. 494. 94? 494. thank you i'm gonna switch gears here and talk about the home mod program i i know you said in your opening remarks that um there uh you completed 188 home modifications in this last year um i I know it's a really popular and impactful program, and I've learned over the last couple of budgets or what it takes to get that done. I'm wondering, I assume that the wait list for the program is still quite long. Can you comment on how many people have requested the service versus the 188 that were completed for the year? I'm just trying to get a sense of what the what the what the need is versus what we're able to accommodate. Absolutely, sir. I heard your rate. It is such a popular much-need in the program. We can make every effort to serve people as we can application. I will read those numbers at 700 presently. And then they're completed on a first-come, first-served basis? Yes. I would totally, sir. But Mark, who could explain more about the process? everybody introduce yourself first oh my name is mark nobriga um so we do have a growing wait list obviously the wait list is longer than the clients we serve so it's going to be an ever growing wait list um like rachel said and commissioner arfa said uh the late wait list does grow and uh this could you speak up a little bit please sure so this year with our completions of we're going to probably come in right around 188 as was mentioned um we'll always have people get added to this list and is it done on a first come first serve basis it is so we have a rolling wait list essentially so we're i think the oldest person on the wait list is from 8 23 so the next and currently because we're preparing already for the next year we will be taking the people that are from basically been waiting from 2023 the latter part of 2023 and we'll probably get into somewhere the early 24s and those are the people that have been waiting the longest and they will get be served first in 2025 and then from there we'll continually build onto the bottom of that wait list as we go on and how much funding do we have for that this year going into this budget do you know what the funding level is um i'm going to have to pass that to esther to make sure she get we get that number right currently let me get that information for you and then I'll just follow up with the second question too then um relatedly the six hours of personal assistance um I think you said we we provided 83 um people with that service is that six hours in total or is that six hours like on a on a rolling basis So for this year we have 83 people who are getting services and they can up to six hours. Up to six hours per person. Every week they can assist us with anything from shopping, meal preparation, to cleaning, managing, additional tasks. six hours per week for 83 people I just wanted to clarify that yes great yeah you can give that to me through the chair Esther if you don't I can give it to you through the chair okay that's great I just I I know that there's a great need for it I'm trying to get to what what are the biggest challenges with us like getting more people through the program? Is it a matter of having enough money is one thing, but having enough contractors to do the work to schedule that sort of thing out as well. What do you think some of the biggest challenges are with expanding that program? It's, it's always going to be the money for us. We have a great contractor pool right now. We have, you know, this program is one of the largest of its kind in the nation. So we have the pool of getting our materials and supplies at a reduced costs at a quicker time frame um our vendors are already ramped up to accomplish what we've accomplished this year which is our greatest amount of projects we've ever done in this program we're rest we're closing in on 200 a year which is if anybody's paying attention is roughly one new construction project every 1.1 day of the year throughout the entire year so our contractors are there our staff is there we're ready to do what we can um it's limited simply by funding yep well thank you and i i know i'm out of time i just want to say thank you to you and your staff for all that you do um for the people of the city of chicago we get plenty of requests um from folks and we're trying to refer people to you as we can and i appreciate that your team's always ready and willing to to help us out with anything that we need at the ward level so thank you thank you chair thank you vice chair lee alderman lopez followed by alderman moore thank you chairman and good morning members of the committee i have um a number of questions um and feel free i'm going to email this to you so you don't need to try to write them all down um but i following up on some of the things alderman lee mentioned um first off if you can provide us a list of what all of your delegate agencies are for the department and what this 200 000 cut from 2024 to 2025's budget uh will impact with respect to service i would appreciate that um i'm particularly interested in the uh compliance review review unit um i saw and read and heard that we need an extra investigator uh included uh and hired um has that position received any support from human resources is Is there a hold? Is there something that we need to help put pressure on to make that a reality? Excuse me. I'm really interested to know if MLPD has conducted any type of analysis of accessibility on public buildings, schools, libraries, things of that nature. I know that we've had discussions about accessibility at bus stops and intersections. but I think that we've never really addressed whether or not we have to do any kind of investments on some of our older buildings that we operate for example City Hall and feel free if you want to interrupt me at any point hold on you got to give her a second to respond it's up to you I'm giving these as through the chair because I know I've got only 10 minutes. I'll use all 10 just for the questions. So I'll... I was actually very interested... And Commissioner, if there's something in particular you want to answer now, feel free. I'll stop gladly. I've seen that the software licensing has exploded from $7,000 to $150,000. Is there a particular reason for that? Absolutely. So first I want to address the $250,000, which was allocated this year to us a program to provide transport of power wheelchairs after somebody, after the person who uses the chair needs to be transported to the hospital for medical emergency. We have done some incredible work on a solution for that. And we are pivoted to a different long-term solution because that was, so we've not really built in a solution. And I'm very excited about that. So that was that reduction. The second, assessing our public spaces, our public facing city projects is a top priority. We have made incredible progress at that every year. This year we partnered with 2FM and the Public Works Commission to do about 83 assessments. But overall we've done approximately 218 assessments. and we will be preparing this more public engagement in the coming months to have a final Deputy Commissioner Tom to add anything if you like, but it has been a top priority, and I'm so proud of the progress we have made at that progress, it was made possible by positions that were granted through the past few projects, so you could include two accessibility specters, including our two project coordinators to be added to our accessibility capabilities unit, to be a C or to back impact of those positions being added. Tom, did you wanna add anything? Thank you, commissioner. I echo all your comments and thank you, Alderman Lopez, for the question about public buildings and our city buildings. Yes, I would say we're at a very good point to be able to issue to the city and the public really good report. Front and center are facilities like you mentioned, the public libraries, for example. We have surveyed all the public libraries, all 90 plus facilities in the city of Chicago, and we will be able to even provide cost estimates of those facility improvements that will be required based on our MOPD observations through those assessments. Thank you. To the public in the back, we got to keep your conversations to quiet of having members moving because they can't hear. So please, please, please be quiet. Thank you. Go ahead, Alderman. Thank you, Chairman. I want to commend the department for the great work that it does to provide ASL during many of our public events. But one of the questions that I have is, do you have recommendations or can you provide recommendations on how we can bring that service to city council, as well as to our city committees? That is something that we've talked about numerous times. And I don't think we do a very good job of making sure that sign language is at all of our public hearings and meetings. And that could be through the chair as well. If you could also provide a list of the home modifications, the number of applicants and awardees by ward, I would appreciate that. And then I have two questions for the community's participation, both in One Summer Chicago, as well as in the City Key. Do we track or know how the disabled community, the self-identified disabled community, is represented in either of those two categories? What's their percentage involvement in both the youth summer jobs program as well as the free city identification? If you know that, if not, we could get it through the chair. It's fine. Yes, I can say that through the chair. I'm happy to also provide a response to other two licensing agreements. agreements. First of all, the first one is to pay for a new housing locator, which we launched in April. April already see that this is providing a really incredible service. And then the second one is through a Colorado software. The software called Colorado. It will help us to track and compile data accessibility, including communication access, and they define communication access, for example, captioning and consigning interpreters, providing audio description, and a number of other accommodations. So we will be able to track that. Using the software will be efficient because we attempted a number of other ways to do it. And this is where we completely leverage the technology to compile data much more quickly and at a much faster rate so that we don't need to use our staff type much more efficiently. So I think this is a very worthwhile investment for us. Thank you. Also, just two more things. One, if you could also provide the cash assistance numbers by demographic and ward. I would appreciate that. And then lastly, with regards to there's a mention of the home services that we provide. Can you expound on what coordination, if any, we have with ensuring that individuals who are able to enlist family members for home health care, what are we doing as a city to try to partner with the state to make sure that those individuals know that that is a resource that can be funded by the state to ensure that those who need help are getting those familial members employed in helping them? Absolutely. to these around home, have a personal assistance program does. We added a new program to be able, for people who receive services, to be able to have a family member or a trust that were trained and to provide those services. I'm happy to have Christy to appear on the show about that, but we find that that's a really great way for people to choose who they may grant, but also to address the nationwide health care worker shortage they're receiving. I don't care. Hi, I'm Pamela. I'm the program director for the Disability Resource Unit. We have in our current program, and we offer to all individuals who are seeking personal assistance within the six hours if they have a family member or friend who's willing to be trained as the personal assistant they do need to do an application engaging a background check and a drug trust and one weeks of training which half of it is virtual and half of it is in person once they all those eyes are dotted they can be the personal assistants for that individual we do make referrals to Department of Rehab Services when the needs exceed the six hours per week. And we recommend that they, it's called preferred worker, that they apply for the preferred worker program. Awesome. Thank you. And Cameron, I just would add that we also have another staff member that's actually laying on the floor who probably needs to be identified as well. How did we miss that one? As a follow-up, the program that you speak of, what is the funding sources that locally funded state or federally funded hi this is aster that the sources of that funding is the community development block grant cdbg okay very well thank you uh alderman where did alderman more go okay all right alderman lispada followed by alderman hadn't thank you very much chair thank Thank you, Commissioner, so much for being here with us. I know I'm way off on the side. I wanted to know first, because you brought it up earlier, the closed captioning is dramatically improved from last year, and it is greatly, greatly appreciated. It was deeply frustrating to see how your words were garbled last year for the public, and this is fantastic. It's sincerely fantastic, and I just wanted to note that. I had a couple quick questions because I know that we were talking about the home modification program, the backlog on that. Do we have a sense of how many people are currently on the waiting list for home modifications? Thank you, Altamon. I want to make sure that you and everyone here understand that we put in a request for real-time captioning to be provided at our scheduled budget meetings. So this is important. We are so proud. We will continue working to make it better. So I appreciate your feedback. I know a number of others here also said that. that second home at we, there's 700 people. Currently 700, okay, I appreciate that. As I look at, if you can strike that. So my question that I would ask, and maybe this is for you or maybe someone on the broader budget side, are we putting any of the bond financing that we passed earlier this year towards home modifications? I would love to understand both on the staffing level and on a funding level, how we improve your capacity to get these modifications done to shorten the time that folks are on the wait list. This is Esther. There currently is no bond funding for the HomeMod program. The funding allocations for HOMOD include corporate dollars, CDBG dollars, grants from the Chicago Housing Authority, and an allocation from the Department of Housing. Okay. It sounds like a conversation that council can have. I appreciate it. I did want to ask if you could talk about collaboration and cooperation with CDOT in particular, where it comes to accessibility in the public way. For instance, we know that there were new pedestrian right-of-way accessibility guidelines or pro-ag guidelines released in 2023. how does MOPD interface with CDOT and others to make sure that we're improving the accessibility on the public way? Thank you Alderman for the question. We work very closely with Commissioner Carney and CDOT, do you wanna talk more about that? Thanks Commissioner. Thank you Alderman for the great question. I was selected to answer this question because I am very hands-on on this issue with CDOT, have worked with Commissioner Carney, but also have worked with a number of people, including engineers on the side of CDOT. So as an example, I'm aware of course of the ProAg rulemaking that we immediately had conversations with CDOT last year about that. CDOT is engaged with the federal side right now in harmonizing our requirements with ProAg. But on the sort of practical side, I have been part of meetings at new city CTA bus stops and islands that CDOT is working on, for example, or protected bike lanes. Even elements like protected bike lanes and intersection of different varieties of transportation here in the city that are really new and not even addressed in ProAg. So we are definitely active, very active in, you know, boots on the ground types of activities with CDOT, CDOT engineers. And I think we have quite a bit to contribute to that. And I hope to be accurate when I say they value our partnership. I appreciate that, sir. If I could lean into that for a moment, and then I'll probably cede my last four minutes. Something of continuing concern is improving signalization for disabled Chicagoans at crosswalks. It feels like a pressing issue for many. It feels like something that we're not moving on as quickly as we could. How does MOPD bring collaboration and accountability to that need for disabled Chicagoans? I would like to answer this as adequately as possible, but unfortunately there is active litigation around this matter as we speak. And I am not really at liberty to share too much detail other than I am involved in, for example, in specific requests by ward or through the Alderman Office and the CDOT liaison to add accessible pedestrian signals at specific locations in a neighborhood per constituent request. I am involved in that. I appreciate that. I'm going to lean into the broadest interpretation of my fiduciary responsibility to the city and save the rest of my thoughts for myself. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Chair LaSpada. uh next we will have alderman hadden followed by alderman mitts thank you chair and uh good morning commissioner i um wanted to ask and this could be a through the chair request unless you have the information handy. But as you mentioned, the website around housing that the department launched, I was wondering if you could share with us what the initial cost of developing that platform and getting it set up was, as well as what ongoing costs and kind of staffing costs and, you know, non-staffing costs that MOPD has to maintain that housing portal. I'm happy to say that. Fantastic. And just for, you know, for your knowledge and for my colleagues, I ask because that platform is a fantastic tool. And we've had some conversations with the department of housing and that they are you know talking to mopd and looking at the possibility of expanding that platform to be able to also have it list all of our city affordable housing units so i think that it's fantastic i'm glad your department has taken leadership on this and you know just kind of looking at the cost so i want to see um so thank you for that um i'll also So just ask, is there, does the department track or do you guys have numbers on how many disabled Chicagoans that we have currently that are in nursing facilities, you know, group homes, SELAs, as opposed to living in community currently across the city? Thank you for the question. I know that through our research with the Chicago Department of Public Health, we identified a number of statistics pertaining to land. I will double-check those data to see the degrees that were in land. I will let you know through the gym. Okay. Thank you for that. um and then i will also ask um this has been this has been asked in a certain way i know my colleague alder lisbada kind of mentioned it i'll just put a second to this um i think we've mentioned this in previous budgets um a style guide right like that kind of support your office is always available to support i know aldermanic offices when we are you know wanting to review our own processes and communications to be more accessible. I do think that having something maybe included in, as we think about our new class of alders, you know, maybe some type of more formal training, more formal things, and especially as we have, we have a lot of leeway as alder people on how we run our offices, but would love to see something a bit more standardized that, you know, would provide a better experience for Chicagoans, I think, no matter which aldermanic office they were going to as far as communications and accessibility. So just putting my plug in for that, and Chair, that's all I've got. Thank you, Chair Hatton. Any other committee members with questions? Audubon Vasquez, and then we'll go to non-committee members. I'll go ahead. Audubon Vasquez, followed by alderman um taylor hoppenworth and curtis uh thank you very much chairman uh and thank you so much for being here uh i really appreciate the work that you all do and i think being in council has helped me have a greater understanding that when we talk about disabilities it's somewhere we all will eventually uh end up right whether physically or other things as we we get older, it's something that we all have to think about forward. And so whatever we do in government takes into account not only people that some might view as others, but literally all of us. And so I thank you for the spirit of that work. Last year, I had asked questions about the different delegate agencies and the contracts, and to get an understanding of how best delegate agencies were held accountable to measurable results. And we didn't really get a lot of detail. We were told, well, they're held by the invoices that can be held if they're not meeting results. I'd really like to get a better idea and see if there's an example of maybe a delegate agency or contract to understand how they're held accountable to metrics and actually executing on goals that are set by the department. If you could provide an example. And anyone from the team. We can have our program director, Mark Nobrega, talk about the two delegate agencies under the HOMOD in which goals are set in advance for the calendar year. And of course, those are tracks. So, Mark. Hi, this is Mark Nobrega. Our goals are really defined by our budgets. So our goals are set based on the metrics from previous years averages, and that leads us into how we would treat future construction projects, the cost of those. And that really gets us our data from our client sets for construction as far as from a client perspective. We're really trying to generate as much product as we can. By product, I mean the type of work we do. we're trying to do efficiencies we're trying to do economies of scale for our construction and leverage all those things to provide the largest amount of product we can for the least amount of money sure if you could do the chair kind of provide maybe some of what that communication might look like to some folks who are you know um vendors or contractees just to get a sense so we have a better understanding and i guess separate from construction if it's like service related. Are there examples of that that you could share? Like, we just want to get a sense of who the delegate agency is, what those measurables look like, and how we have a conversation about, you know, what percentage or how they've met certain expectations. That's kind of more the sense. If anything could be shared to the chair, it would be great. My next question kind of follows up to what my colleague, other person, Laspata brought up. And so I get that there's litigation. To the best of your ability, are you able to share the nature of what that litigation is in a way that you're able to, clearly? If you're not, I totally understand. I figured I'd ask. Okay. So I think the way to possibly answer this question is that we are advocating for accessible pedestrian signals, as we certainly know that in the modern infrastructure of the city, of our city or any other major city in the United States, it's a need. It's a specific need for the part of the disabled community that has to navigate the streets who are blind and low vision. So as a technology, or as a set of technology solutions, we are also aware of various technology solutions that are out there that could help with this issue. That said, there's also the compliance issue and how the ADA, the law, sees APS today, how it should be according to the federal government. So there's a certain conversation going on about the needs of the end user, the people who are disabled, and the compliance side, right? Which is basically the law, right? And that is where we can hopefully mediate and advocate for the installation of APS in as many locations as is possible. We are also aware of the real-world costs, of course, of that effort. Got it. Thank you. That is helpful. I mean, clearly, as we see with a lot of legislation, the intent of what's written down compared to what the reality looks like on the ground begs for more conversation and clarity, so thank you for that. The last question I have is, can you let us know who your language access coordinator is and provide a breakdown on language access services used in 2024, as well as plan for 2025 by functional and sectional units and where that is reflected in your 2025 budget recommendation? And that could be through the chair. I'm just really proud of the model that we have built to provide language access, including communication access. I would say about a month ago, we had an interview with one of our sign language interpreters, that we were able to provide communication access for a member of the deaf, internal community, incredible community leader, Nate Kieran Macias, who is from Mexico. She is a native user of Mexico's sign language, their specific neighborhood, LSM, and our team is able to provide effective communication through American sign language, English, English, Spanish, so I'm actually really proud of how we have made every effort to remove barriers, whether it's through the hard work of our sign language, a terminal team through using capsules, making sure people know that assistive listening devices are available and so forth. I mean, I think that those are good matters for us to experiment on in 2025, but these efforts have got it awkward. It builds trust that people know you can come to us for help and you will not experience those communication access barriers. Yeah, no, I really appreciate that and I think we want to learn from what you all do because the city itself and trying to get language access has its own challenges has been behind the ball and to think about somebody who is deaf but also doesn't understand the language and figuring how to close all those gaps so there is that kind of connection understanding is crucial and so anything you can share that can help make us better as a city and where you need that support um we definitely appreciate it so those are the questions I have thank you so much for your work and thank you chairman thank you Audemars Vasquez Audemars Taylor followed by uh what'd I say Hoppingworth thank you chairman um how you doing commissioner um reimbursement and travel where y'all going We didn't go from the 2024 budget. I believe that that was removed from the 2025 budget. There should be a reduction in reimbursement to travel from the 2024 to 2025 budget. Let me pull up the specific details. because one says reimbursement of travel the other one says local transportation so local transportation there was a decrease but the other one it stayed the same page 268 There's a reimbursement to staff for traveling between different sites or different site locations that is what we that is what the line item is for so there's local travel that's not to the states that's not there's no kind of like international national uh long distance travel within the department so go to the next page there are two um positions one is a deputy commissioner that increases 15 000 and then if you go down to a disability specialist that's the eight thousand dollars are those union positions or what's the justification for because they raise is bigger than the commissioners so it's on 269 it's on the next page one says executive administration that line that says deputy commissioner and then if you go down where it says employment one one went from 96,000 to 105,000 the one at the top went from 122,000 to 138,000 some of those positions are so the deputy commissioner position is not union but they are subject to the step increase and any um cost of living increase 15 000 okay same thing for the one at the bottom that's 8 000 because if you look at the commissioner's position she didn't get that much of a raise I believe that that position was put on a salary schedule this year. I will double check on that. But then I know the disabilities, Robert, the second position, the disability specialist to that position is a human position. So based on the number of years that a person works in that position, they are according to the collective bargaining agreement they get both um and increase um cost of living according to the terms whatever the terms are specified in the conduct of bargaining agreement so those two positions are union position the deputy commission position is not a union position okay so in times where we asking everybody to cut their budget we giving out 15 000 because that's the amount that is but i'm gonna go to my next question well let me let me hold the time for her um last year the department of human resources put a lot of individuals who were in what they were called rated positions where the salaries were stagnant and subject to only a council approval and increases put them on a schedule because they were having challenges with retention and recruitment of high quality individuals to serve in these positions. So most of those deputy commissioner, Shackman exempt individuals have been put on a salary schedule similar to any other employee in the city. And they have steps and increases just like any other position in the city. So some of them, because they are larger, maybe 2%, well, 2% of a larger number is a larger number, right? So depending upon what step they are and what lane they are on that particular schedule, it's all commiserate to whatever the schedule has been set for that position. Do you know the percentage? That I do not know. What we can do is get the actual schedule from Human Resources. I think it's called the AX schedule or something like that. We can get the schedule so that we can see exactly where many of the, I believe, the assistant commissioners, deputy commissioners, and those types of positions were placed on that type of a schedule. Thank you, Chairman. Commissioner, can you talk to me, can you talk about how does senior support show up in the Office of Disability? You had a lot of seniors here that it seems like when you all got rid of the Department of Aging, it was separated between the Office of Disability and DFSS. Can you tell me how many staff members that you all have just dedicated, if any, to just seniors in your department? And if so, how many calls of service do you get around modifications for seniors, not just people with disabilities, but seniors in general in your department? So to the outdoor maintainer first, with that split habit, MLPD early got verdict to serve people up to age 59. However, we have done, I've worked to find ways where we can continue to serve people who are over age 59, and we also partner with the Department of Families, support services we also partner with the department of housing but let me tell you about an incredible change that we have made that created efficiency and um better serves as you know if that is our partnership with um the department of housing and i also want to um thank commissioner castaneda but this is well because the department of housing has given us a million dollars in 2025's budget for our home modification program at the average age of people within our home modification program, the average age is 59. And I would love for Mark to talk more about that, but we do invite a high percentage of people that are over age 59 are coming to us. If that was the result of this collaboration that we worked out over the past two, three few years with the Department of Health Services instead of having to stop a program, we now have one program that serves people people who have a disability of any age. Mark, I don't know if you want to add to that, but this is the number one way that we could keep people with disabilities in our homes and in our communities, simply by adequate. And I'm so proud of this work, this collaboration that we have to serve anybody with this disability, including senior citizens with disabilities. I'm turning to Mark to add anything. Hi, my name is Mark Nabriga. So we did add and we actually modified our program slightly to accept clients of all ages. So now we do actually serve seniors in our home mod program. A majority of what we do for seniors is accessible modifications. So a priority for our seniors, obviously, as we discovered here today, is getting into and out of their homes. It could be bathing. It could be one of many things. and we provide all those modifications to our seniors within the city of Chicago. It's wonderful just to see some of our clients thank us after we provide these modifications. Some haven't left their home in many years, and the program like HOMOD that now serves seniors as well as people with disabilities provides that service to get people out of their home in case of egress and ingress, in case of emergencies, in case of doctor's appointments. beyond that we recognize that seniors do have a limited income and we've expanded our program to not only provide the service of providing that accessible modification but we give lifetime warranties on all our work so if we do happen to provide a senior with a lift or a ramp to get into their home if that lift or ramp ever breaks within their lifetime or the lifetime of the home we placed it in our staff and our vendors go out to fix that for free parts service everything is free including the installation and the maintenance, the ongoing maintenance of all of those jobs. Through the chair, can we get war by war? How many folks are waiting for those modifications? My last question is, I want to know what type of relationship you all have with Chicago public schools. We know there are a lot of students with disability, autistic young people, and that never really shows up in city hall or i've never seen it can you talk a little bit about how you all work with chicago public schools um yes absolutely so um the chicago public schools um change the name of the office they serve um that serves people with disabilities used to be called ODLSS, the Office of Diverse Learners and Support Services. But they selected a new chief, Chief Joshua Locke, who used to be a principal at South Sine Occupational, and he's been a game changer, and we have a very close working relationship between MRPD and what he also did. Chief Locke worked with a number of stakeholders stakeholder to change the name to the Office for Students with Disabilities. It is so important to do that name because now more of our families can find out about the services and be partnered in a number of ways. I shared about how we support young people with disabilities in the program. The CLEAR Center also has a number of, we've had a number of of our teaching mentoring. And I also brought the one who permitted Christina to share about our career center. We also host two assisted each students at our career center, so they know about our services. So for students getting ready to think about what their players are for after high school, they know they're not career center here. You are the students. We also help to connect students with them to provide you as a partnership. but it is a top priority for our department to continue to expand that. And I believe I'll go to a number of Chicago Public Schools that have a number of students with disabilities, but also our cash assistance will give it $500 to students with disabilities if they're families. If this makes a big difference to the families and students. I just want to finish up. So what I'll say is we do have a lot of students who come to that 18 and they graduate out of Chicago Public Schools. And a lot of times those programs that they are pushing don't actually work. They don't get actually young people trained. And so I will be interested in working with your office to talk about how we make sure that people get access to those programs and to know that the office is available. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Chair. Audemann Hopperworth. Thank you, Chair, my commissioner and team. Thank you for all of your work. I know that there is a deadline coming up through ARPA. You're offering cash assistance to folks with disabilities. and just please let us know how we can help with that, because that is coming up on November 15th. And also, Alder Haddon expressed interest in how our offices can help with communications, make it more accessible for others. And I would like to build on that as well, um related to alder lopez's request for public facilities to have accessibility um audits i i would like to know how our offices are doing how our automatic offices are doing in terms of accessibility we are on the front lines and um and people should be able to walk or roll into our office, no matter where we are in the city. I had also a question about hiring practices generally. I would love to work with your office more so that we can be recruiting and making it more accessible for everybody, no matter their ability. And can you comment a little bit more on how the city is doing in terms of recruiting and hiring those with disabilities. And also, if you do work with HR in terms of the questions you might ask or the applications generally across the departments, do you work with HR on that? Thank you, well, Chairman, for your questions. Absolutely, Yopin, I'm going to have Top of the Commissioner, and Christina McLean share that. And we also know that there is a number of people that do disclose their disability for the apply for jobs as well. But we work very closely with the Department of Human Resources because we want people, our disability community to know and to apply to city of Chicago jobs. I would love nothing more to see an increased number of people with disabilities here at the city. I'm going to turn it over to Christina. Okay, Christina McGlame, Deputy Commissioner. Yes, we work very closely with the Department of Human Resources to increase inclusion within the city of Chicago as an employer. We know it's important that we serve as a model. I also oversee our career center, so we're often asked what the city of Chicago is doing to increase disability employment. so we have done things like our employee resource group which is not only you know important to bring employees together who have disabilities to talk about shared barriers or just things that are working out well here in the city but also build inclusion and give people a safe place to come to talk about some barriers that they have we do receive we do work with dhr and receive several applications, hundreds of applications, I think it was close to a thousand last year, of people who self-ID as having a disability. And we've recently put out a self-ID survey, so the city of Chicago can better understand how many employees we have with disabilities here, and some of the barriers they're facing within their employment. Thank you. Thank you for that. I know that there are many vacancies across many agencies, and um and also we want to again in our own ward office be able to attract and recruit everybody um no matter if their ability so we will we would like to work with you more on that um I just have a comment I'm very disappointed that this budget does not include um plow the sidewalks uh Edgewater is uh trends older adults and is very walkable and we're also very transit rich um it is great the things that you're doing within a building but people need to be able to get out of their buildings and also get to public transit and um without accessibility on the sidewalks no matter what the weather is it makes it very difficult um i know our ssa you know voted last year to not plow the sidewalks until it was four inches you know that seems like a lot to me especially the The weather turns very, very frigid and it turns icy. Again, we trend older adults and a lot of people use power wheelchairs. Look, we are on Sheridan Road and a lot of those folks walk over to the Mariano's and I find them in the actual streets because the sidewalks are not clear. So through the chair, if you could just give me your comments and concerns about that or how we're moving forward to try to make our public way, including our sidewalks, accessible all year round for everybody, no matter how they get around. The last thing I would like to say is that I, you know, with the, again, I observed polling places, our ward is very vertical. And so buildings are actually precincts in themselves and is very different, precinct to precinct, the accessibility of these voting sites. And it is alarming for me to see long lines of older adults in wheelchairs and using their walking-assisted devices because the lines are very long. So I'd like to just comment that I would love more coordination between this body and also Board of Elections on how we can make our voting sites more accessible for everybody, no matter how you get around, especially our older adults. I'm very concerned about what's to come with a new federal administration and i um i know that in times of crisis um those that get left behind are often our older adults and those with disabilities and so i would like to understand a little bit more about how we as a city are going to protect our most vulnerable Thank you, Dr. Wimmy, for your comments. All right, so thank you for your comments. I appreciate you sharing your thoughts on each of those issues. I would like more. I would like to hear more on how we, as a city, are going to protect our most vulnerable, including our older adults, and especially those with disabilities, under a new federal administration? I understand, and we will do what the cover says that we are able to continue to provide services. next year we will continue to do our very best to be able to do that and i think that we we have to think uh we would just continue to make sure that that is um a priority and i know for me that is my priority here and i'm repeating it that's very important to me thank you Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Manor-Hopperworth. Alderman Curtis? He'll come back to me. We get it. Okay. I was just saying if Alderman Moore, you know, he was right there. Alderman Moore, remember, he gave up his spot. But we're going to get to him. All right. Thank you. My question. That's all right. uh thank you chairman um good morning where is it um i'm sorry good afternoon uh commissioner um always admired the work you've done all these years um got a just a couple of questions um so when when the when your department merged with Department of Aging, did some of the Department of Aging employees, do you still have anyone that's basically dedicated to the Department of Aging? Pardon me. I just want to clear up any confusion that there may be the mayor's office for people with disabilities did not merge with the Department of Aging. No, so I just want to clear up any confusion that there might be this body. The Department of Families is providing services. Okay, great, great. I knew it was one of them. I'm sorry. So the only thing I have for you, Commissioner, is, and I've worked with Department of Transportation on this. At the beginning of the year, if I could have a person, a liaison from your department and a person from transportation to work with us on a curb cut, maybe right in front of a resident home with a disability that's in a wheelchair. because a person that's in a wheelchair, we have a lot of streets now that are one ways. And when they have a vehicle to come pick them up, that door is on the other side of the street. So they will have to travel all the way to the end of the block to go out into the middle of the street, to drive down the middle of the street to get inside the handicapped vehicle. So we have to come up with a solution for someone to maybe cut a curb cut right at their courtesy walk for them to enter the disability van right at their address. Anyone understand what I'm saying? Let me stop you with that one. unfortunately that's actually a federal rule whereby you can't put a cut in unless you have a receiver on the other side. I got it, but it's more dangerous if they walk, if they, if they take a wheelchair, drive to the end of the block, go in the center of the street, drive down the center of the street to... No, I get your point. I'm not disagreeing with you. We as government can't put a curb cut in now. If Ms. Jones put two pieces of wood and create her own curb cut, that's a different conversation. But we as government can't do that because it would violate current, even though it's kind of backwards, it violates ADA rules. Right. Yeah, I do understand that because anything that, you know, we have to have a receiver on the other side. And we did have that conversation. but maybe there need to be someone on that federal level that's in there also in that meeting. But I do believe that we need to come up with a solution for that. And that was my only thing. Thank you, Alderman Curtis. Thank you so much. I've got Alderman Cruz, and then I'll have Alderman Moore. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Commissioner. Before I ask my questions, I want to say thank you to your department. You all have been wonderful and supportive to my office for community events. A special shout out to Bernardo. He is a talented gentleman and he has a bright future. So, and again, just wanted to say thank you. Following up with my questions, MLPD has make significant strides in enhancing employment opportunities for people with disability through its workforce development programs. I'm interested to know what additional initiatives are planned to build on this success and further reduce employment barriers. Thank you. We're very proud of our success. Bernardo is also wonderful. He is actually the community-saved, the CSCC as well as the mayor's office, community engagement, but he certainly works with many departments, and he works with our IPDURA visuals group as well. In terms of IPDURA, we have a number of great programs in our career. So I would love for Christina to share. Thank you, Commissioner. Christina McLean. Yes, we've had a lot of success in our employment center over the last two years. We continue to have various different opportunities for our job seekers with disabilities, including a networking event like we had a month ago or early October where we brought over 150 with disabilities together to network with different employer partners. We have a computer class that we partner with Access Living on to provide computer instruction with different accessibility as well as at the end of that program, the individuals receive a free laptop and hotspot. So that has been something that we've done for, I think we're on our third round of classes. Our mentorship program is something that we continue to build and grow from. So if you ever have any staff members who are interested in being mentors or individuals that you think would be good mentors or mentees, we'd love to engage them in that as we feel like we have brought good connections of people together to learn about different networking or just experiences that individuals have as disabilities, ways to advocate for themselves or different ways to promote themselves. Thank you. Another main question is when it comes to accessibility across the city, infrastructures have greatly increased mobility for residents with disability. Can you share any specific upcoming projects? there will be continued expanding accessibility in both in the public and private spaces yes absolutely I'm done some incredible work in assessing our city projects for accessibility I would have time to share about that any other other thoughts this is Tom Chichelsky deputy commissioner so the next phase of our evaluation of physical accessibility at city facilities that have public programs will be to have a good cost estimate of the funds required to make the modifications and remove the barriers and those funds are already allocated through bond funding and we will have actual projects at city facilities starting hopefully in 2025 through our partnership the city's partnership with the Public Building Commission what will be some of those projects I know you said city and you give us a sneak peek of what that would be if you can if you cannot that's okay I understand I'm sorry I didn't catch the last part um if you can if you do you talked about how some of them will be coming um next year can you give us um a sneak peek of what will those projects be where would that be but if you cannot share that information i understand but all right so i cannot share specific locations yet but i can say that they would be similar projects to um what could have been done for example through previous projects at city libraries where community rooms for example are polling places right so similar to that we would widen doors provide automatic door openers or perhaps update older facilities that have restrooms that need more accessibility those are the examples okay perfect thank you those are all my questions thank you chairman thank you alderman cruz i'll be more follow alderman riley thank you so much chairman um most of my questions have been um asked and answered it was around the employment so uh on the other part i have that before i get to that question uh commissioner i appreciate the um your team and especially you but you make your team accessible and you're you're always there um not only to answer any questions but you're proactive to making sure that if we need anything and asking um proactively so i just want to appreciate the work that you're doing and the work that your staff is doing i think alderman ramey lopez already asked through the chair about the summer one summer program and how our students i'm a wait to see that that was going to to be one of my questions then uh the another the other one around is what is our relationship with cps more or less because i have south side occupational in my ward and i know the work that they do to try to get our students prepared for the workforce but are we working closely with cps i look at simeon and i'm asking because there's a lot of students with disabilities at simeon that right now not getting that same interaction that a south side would get because of the type of school it is i know that difference but how are we doing that outreach with those schools um those cps schools with our students with disabilities is there direct relationship and connection um in which we're trying to make sure that they are um have the things that they need without having them come to just fairs are there any other um interaction with our cps schools Thank you, welcome, for the nice comments. I really appreciate it. And I got to do this because of my team every day as well. So we do, we build many relationships with Chicago Public Schools. I would check out our outreach with Simon, but it'd be on that, but there, see me on, but it'd be on that, but there, we would make sure to go out there to learn more about this program. But I'm really proud of the close relationship that we built with Chicago Public Schools, officers, students with disabilities, if we really be able to include how we support young people with disabilities, including about how to disclose your disability or what kind of a commentation to help you might need at the job, is learning how to ask and self-advocate, and I think that's a critical piece of that. We've also worked on with CPS and with Cine Colleges around the After 22 program, which is opening up opportunities for students who leave high school to continue their education as Cine Colleges who may not be able to meet the strict admissions requirements, But this is a way to remove that barrier. So earlier this year, I was so happy to call the graduation for the first after 22 program class that completed the program. So we're continuing to find ways to continue to expand opportunities for more education and for job opportunities as well. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. That's all I had. All other questions were asked. Thank you. I have a Hall, Chairman Mitch. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I just wanted to know if someone could answer for me, and I didn't know if this was asked or not, Mr. Chairman. Regarding the pace, how many people's on the board for people with disability, if anybody sit on the other companies with metro or pace buses that ride thank you ultimately so as part of my rule by statue um i sit at the border pace um so i attend those meetings oh you do attend the meetings for pace Yes. So have they got any better with their time in terms of picking up their patient, their customers? Yes. Let me just put up my notes. So what are the strategies that police worked out for some helping riders with disabilities increase use after the pandemic. And sorry, go a second. And the ownership is, yeah, so ownership is up on pace, is 83% of 2019 COVID levels. If that's one of the options for people who have a pass-through, pays, is they can also use the taxi access program where they could take a taxi for $2, and they could go, the taxi driver, but make up to $30 to put it at a location. If that has been a successful strategy, putting more accessible cars at the road. At that is up for 150% of COVID levels. Before in 2019, the monthly average of that was 20,000 to 30, but in 2024, that use of that program is now about 83,097. So that's been a great way to help make transportation more available for more people. So we also work closely with business affairs and consumer protection of wheelchair accessible taxes as well. So we believe that all of these services have really grown and are able to better meet more people's needs. Is there a need, did the need increase since the pandemic or have it decrease in terms that arise? for people with disability. Those numbers that she read off, can you get them through the chair, Mr. Chairman? Because I didn't really catch all of them. No, then we will do. Okay. I'm happy to say that through the chair. Okay, thank you. I think the part of the challenges was to the pandemic, many people didn't go leave their houses as much. Of course, many of us, including people with disabilities, would use PACE to go to any doctors or programers, but that as things opened up in 2024, 2022, people began to go out more and resume more of the activities that they had previously. So I would cut about that information through the chair, but I completely say that PACE is really pretty able to meet those needs as where we are in 2024, and I think they know that. Do you have a number of calls that's been received in your office of what are your top priority calls that you get for people with disability? I consider that information through the term. Okay. All right, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Chairman. It's on O'Reilly to close. Thank you, Chairman. And in the interest of time, I'm not going to ask a lot of questions. A lot of them have already been answered. Good afternoon, Commissioner. Appreciate the work that you and your lean and mean staff do for the taxpayers every day. I just wanted to call attention, Chairman, to the budget memos that I send ahead of these proceedings to each department. most of the questions I ask of each department are standard and my hope is that completed responses will be delivered to the chair prior to us having folks present their budgets to this body my interest in having these answers sending pre-submitting my questions is so one the department doesn't feel that they're being blindsided or ambushed but also that they come to these proceedings armed with the information they're going to be asked for. That does not mean that I'll be asking each department to read the answers to my written request on the record, but there will be occasions, not with this particular department, but with others where I will, because I think that that information is important for the public to hear on the record. So, Chairman, I will forego asking questions of MOPD, but just wanted to kind of put a bright line on that for you chairman so that future departments coming before us are prepared in a timely fashion okay the uh the questions that we that we have that you've sent to the commissioners i have not received the answers for those questions specifically mind you uh those were most of them i think you sent out on monday so i'm assuming that as we go further in, we'll get more information. Maybe they may not just be in right now at the early portion of this, but I'm sure next week we should see some voluminous information on your request. And I appreciate that. And so I would just encourage those departments that are yet to come before us after lunch and certainly for tomorrow to expedite those requests. And to be clear, these are not new and exciting or different questions than the ones that I submit to them each year. I'm surprised that they don't have them memorized. They should have them memorized at this point after 18 years of doing this. But thank you, Chairman. I appreciate it. All right. Very well. Thank you, Commissioner, for the work that you do and the service that you provide to the citizens of the city of Chicago. With that being said, the committee will stand at ease to allow Commission on Human Relations to come in. afternoon. Now we have before us the Chicago Commission on Human Relations. Commissioner Andrade is joined with us today. We'll have a brief, a very brief opening from the Council Office of Financial Analysis, after which Commissioner Andrade would introduce her staff. We'll forego the reading of the opening statement and go straight to questions. Director Older Gray. Chairman Irving, Vice Chairman Lee, all other persons and guests, good afternoon. The Chicago Commission on Human Relations has a 2025 budget recommendation of $2.8 million, a change of $284,000. They're corporate funded 53%. They have FTEs budgeted at 20, and it's the same as 24. Additionally, overtime costs for his fiscal year 25 is level with fiscal year 24 at 1.4 budgeted. And it would have been nice if I would have shared this with you. For those that are looking, for those older persons that have the book, it's on page 22. Thank you. Commissioner, if you can introduce your staff and we will begin with questions. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. I am Nancy Andrade, Commissioner and Chair of the Commission on Human Relations. To my right, I have First Deputy Ken Gunn, Kenneth Gunn. In the box, I have Deputy Commissioner Joanne Newsom. I have Danielle Serrano, who is our Director for Intergroup Relations. seated next to his right we have norman white who is our hate crime victim advocate uh special specialist and seated to norman's right we have alexander chavez who is our public relations representative thank you commissioner uh we'll forego the reading of the opening statement it will be incorporated into the record uh opening today will be chaired commission uh i'm sorry committee on health and human relations do I have any other questions beyond chairperson Rodriguez Sanchez thank you mr. chair hello Commissioner I'm over here very good to see you and and your team and I'm very grateful for the work that you'll have been doing and for the collaboration with our committee I have one main question for you all. I want to contextualize that we are going to be facing some very hard years ahead. We already know what happened eight years ago and I really want to know that our Commission on Human Relations are going to be ready to step up as we are probably going to need a lot of help and support to be able to protect our communities how do you feel that this particular budget will help you meet those needs and what are the main programs that you see that we're going to be able to use as resources for for that moment thank you thank you a chairwoman of the human relations health and Human Services Committee, also known as Alderman Rosanna Rodriguez-Sanchez. Thank you so much for that question. So we at the CCHR are poised and ready and have always been ready to address any form of hate that arises. The climate right now in this country in particular is one that we are well aware of. The results of this past presidential election can influence absolutely 100 percent the current temper the current climate that we live in right now um but do know that with this new with this budget for 2025 we stand even more prepared to address any hate racism or bigotry because we are we are hopefully adding on an additional hate crime victim special advocate basically someone to work alongside with norman white right now he's the only person who is out there on the streets, running, literally running at times to work with CPD, to be there at scenes and on neighborhoods where hate crimes have happened. He is there leafleting the neighborhoods with information about the CCHR, how to report a hate crime and a hate incident. This morning, He was at court. He's there to basically provide some handholding, emotional handholding, to victims of hate crimes. We have a wonderful and very strong relationship with the U.S. Department of Justice, with our counterparts at that level, their Community Relations Division. And through that relationship, we also have a relationship with the U.S. Attorney's Office, as well as the state's attorney's office, our counterparts at the state level, which is the Illinois Hate Crime Commission, and together with various stakeholders throughout the community. So we stand ready and poised and positioned to address and to be there not just reactively, but also proactively. Do we have any worries about changes in federal funding at all with the change on administration? No, we don't know. We are not aware of anything. We'll just have to wait and see what happens once the new administration is sworn in and any changes are made, we will hear about. Thank you. That's all for now. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Chairperson. Honorable Lawson, any other questions? Yes. Great. Thank you, Chair, and good morning, Commissioner. I know there's been, since we were here last year, a real increase in the number of both hate crimes, I believe, and certainly hate incidents since we started to track them. Do you have any numbers year over year or year to date that you can just share with our colleagues? We do. We do have some. Compared to last year, we actually have a, up until November 1st, we have had 223 hate crimes. Last year at this time, last year in total, we had 303. So the year is not over. There is still the month of November and the month of December. We also, however, although there's been a decrease as of now, right now, in the number of hate crimes, There has been an increase in the religious-based hate crimes, primarily anti-Semitism. Last year, for all of 2023, we had 50. This year, as of November 1st, we have 72. And all this information we have gathered from the CPD dashboard. And do you have this information on your website as well? In our hate crimes report. Okay. Not the day-to-day. We don't have the day-to-day. We can have a link to the CPD dashboard on our website, and that would lead people to that website. Right. On the hate littering ordinance or hate incidents, have we started to track the hate littering yet, or is that still coming online? That is still, with regards to the ordinance, I believe, and I defer to, I think, the law department, or I don't know if Alderman Knudsen is here. I believe there's some fine-tuning left, if I'm not mistaken, with regards to that particular ordinance. However, with regards to hate incidents, we have had 216 hate incidents to date. of those hate incidents, 40 actually meet the qualification or definition of a hate incident. And if I may take it a step further, of those hate incidents, 10 have been referred to the Department of Public Health through the Mental Health Expansion Initiative. Great. So I guess then the only other question I have is, as being proactive, right? What are we looking at as far as next year, as we try and keep all of our communities safe and bring people together? And what I think my colleague acknowledges may be going to be a more difficult environment. What are you looking forward to? What can we do to partner with our communities to, to help stamp out hate everywhere? Thank you. Thank you for that question. So an immediate reaction, and this is particularly in response to the incident, the shooting incident that happened in the Westridge neighborhood. We are working together with Alderman Silverstein, the U.S. Department of Justice, their Community Relations Division, as well as the Illinois Hate Crimes Division, as well as the state's attorney's office, local rabbis, and Jewish organizations to hold a listening session in the community within the next two weeks so that the community can openly share their concerns and continue their grieving process. We are also rolling out the hate crime pilot program, hate crime reporting pilot program. We have a soft launch of that in January. In the interim, we have begun to meet with our community-based organizations that are partnering up with us. So we have everything teed up and ready to go. Another component of our work is just our strong relationship with the Chicago Police Departments, in particular the Civil Rights Unit. But forecasting for 2025, I have had deep conversations with my counterpart at the state level, Alana Khan, for the Illinois Hate Crimes Committee. We are going to be having a, I guess for lack of a better title for right now, it's just we're having a hate crime summit or a hate crime forum to open it to the community in general, to have experts to talk about and to talk about hate crimes, hate incidents. What is it that we can do collectively as a community? And it also gives an opportunity for the community in general to express their concerns. Well, that sounds great. Whatever my office and my colleagues can do to be helpful and amplify your work, think we all stand ready to do that um keep it up and uh that's it thank you chair thank you thank you thank you i'm lost and uh vice chair lee fellow balder in hatton thank you chair um hello commissioner how are you always great to see you um in the in the team um the small but mighty team mighty mighty as you guys are because we see uh we see norman in the ward um probably more often and then we'd like to see him for professional reasons, obviously. But with the new hate crimes legislation that we passed in the last year, unanimously by the council, and with the rise in hate crimes and incidents that are reported, what's the impact been on your department? What's the workload been like? What have the challenges been? That's kind of an open-ended question for you. I'd just love to hear how that legislation has impacted your work. We are very, very busy. We are very busy. As I mentioned before, Norman is a one-man show, and we are very much looking forward to having an addition to Norman so that we can be much more impactful and much more. We are available as much as we can, and by that I mean I'm available 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and it's our relationship building. also with the different community stakeholders, which helps us to get our word out about our work. Also about the amended hate crime ordinance and the 311 reporting mechanism for hate incidents. I would, would you like to? I would just say with the hate incidents, we're able to track what's going on in the city. We see what the numbers are, but as the commissioner mentioned, out of the 200 plus that we've seen so far, 40 fit the definition of a hate incident. So those are the ones we really have to look at and see if they manifest themselves into potential hate crimes. Target those communities so we can know where to do our education work. Of the other 160, 70 that don't really meet the qualifications for hate incident, what are we seeing that people are reporting? General comments, people make phone calls and say somebody said something. But when we look at it, it's nothing about hate. You know, there's no hate element to it whatsoever. So 311 is getting inundated with these kind of things. What about graffiti? With regards to graffiti, we have had graffiti incidents. I'm going to pass that particular question over to my colleague, Daniel Serrano. He'll have a little bit more insight on that. Good afternoon, Danny Serrano, Director of Intergroup Relations and Outreach. uh regarding graffiti hateful graffiti uh we did see as a result of the amendment to the ordinance and i'm getting feedback i'll stand back here can you hear me yeah okay um after the amended ordinance had passed graffiti was added to that ordinance there was no really directive as to what does that mean? But the fact that it was included in the amendment meant we need to take a new look at graffiti. So obviously graffiti is already a crime on the state level, but on the city level, the city had been treating graffiti, treating it as a public nuisance for a long time. Graffiti would go up and then whether it would come from an alder's office or from someone in the community, graffiti would be reported. And then the graffiti blasters, the Department of Streets and Sanitation would go out there and take it down. No questions asked. Once it ended up, graffiti ended up in the amended ordinance, we realized hateful graffiti needed to be treated as the crime that it is because a hate crime is, of course, a crime that also has a hateful bias-based motive. So once we see graffiti that has hateful content, we know it's not just a public nuisance, it's actually a hate crime. So we worked out protocols with CPD and DSS to have it be that before that graffiti comes down, CPD needs to go out there and document it and make a report a hate crime occurred here at this location, right? Then the graffiti can come down. There was some concern initially from some of the alders, like this might slow down the taking down of the graffiti, which is an important service that we provide to the community. But the good news is that I think because of the fact that we talked about it a lot and had lots of trainings with the aldermanic staff and also between the departments, it's actually been a pretty seamless experience so far. Now, I cannot tell you like in terms of numbers that's not showing up in the 311 at this point and that might be something to look at how we can track that data but we do know that it's coming down fast we haven't been getting any complaints from the alders regarding that thank you um chair if i may i just have one last question um with regards to uh vacancies i know we lobbied hard last year because we we've known you've needed more people for some time um the how where are you in the process of hiring somebody to be on norman's team at this point have you extended an offer to anybody or no no so there there's been a hiring freeze and um we're anticipating that the budget gets passed and with the budget being passed uh the second hate crime victim um special advocate will be on that budget so once it's approved and the hiring freeze is lifted we will begin that process immediately and then we're we're going to steal Norman's keys so he can't leave, right? Correct. Okay. That's all I've got. Thank you very much, Chair. But I want to say thank you, Alderwoman Lee and all your other colleagues who really vocalized support for our desire and need for an additional staffer for the hate crimes unit. So thank you so much. You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you, Vice Chair Lee. uh chair haddon followed by ultimate chair chair taylor uh thank you chair um commissioner uh it's great to see you as always and my question is pretty straightforward is one additional position enough um right and i'll say my question would be i would like to see uh through the chair what it it would look like to add more than one additional position so if through the chair you could get us what that cost would be and and i say that only knowing um as colleagues have mentioned and you've shared the numbers we have seen a rise in hate crimes and hate incidents we are you know working and with your leadership in your department and with the leadership of other colleagues here in council to do better as a city and do more and actually addressing them. And unfortunately, with the behavior that we've seen from, you know, folks kind of supporting, you know, president elect Trump, anticipate we'll see more like we know what happened last time, from Muslim bans to ice raids and all kinds of threats to diverse people in our community. um communities were really we were on our heels um you know we were seeing residents attack people we've seen him stoke this type of hate um at the beginning of the pandemic anti-asian hate um um i don't want us to not be prepared and we know what we the election's over we know what's coming we know who we're dealing with and i feel like our department needs to be prepared so i would like to see what those numbers would be for more support so in addition to that additional staffer and the cost of that you know what are what are other things other than personnel costs that are involved in the work that you guys are doing and would love to see that request through the chair please absolutely thank you so much thank you thank you chairhead and uh chair taylor follow valdman for instance thank you chairman can you all talk about what constitutes a hate crime First of all, a hate crime is a crime like assault. Could you identify yourself for the record, please? Again, I'm Kenneth Gunn. I'm the first Deputy Commissioner. But a hate crime, you have two elements. First you have to have a crime, which is typically a misdemeanor. So a hate crime elevates it to a felony. So you have a simple battery, assault, criminal damage to property, those kind of things. But when a hate element is added, let's say somebody uses a racial slur or something of that matter, when they commit the crime, then it becomes a hate crime. Whereas the hate incident, you don't have the actual crime. You just have that hate element. So somebody says something, but there's not an attack along with it. You all had $4,000, I think, in advertisement? Right. Yeah, y'all got rid of it. Why? Well, that money was used for the CTA campaign, you may have seen, the Think Before You Hate campaign, when we had ads on CTA buses and trains and stations. but in order to kind of balance off our budget we're going to have to rethink how we do that next year we may have to cut down some of the sites because we really tried to make it city wide and particularly some areas where we saw a lot of hate crimes like the 50th ward we had a lot of ads out there through the chair can you get hate crimes um by ward and once you receive an email. So I got one about two or three weeks ago. What's the expectation of us? How do we present that to our community? I missed the first part of your question. No, I said so once you all send out those hate crime notifications, so I've probably gotten four since I've been in office. How do we communicate that to our communities? Do we take what you all send us and kind of email it out to the community? or what's the expectation and then what is the follow-up after you could you all give us an initial what kind of happened what you kind of do but I've never gotten a follow-up email to say this is the conclusion of the crime that was committed yeah and because Norman White is our hate crime specialist he's one that sends you those letters I'll let them talk about that a little bit okay can you hear me yeah what we do is whenever there was a please identify Identify yourself for the record. Oh, my name is Norman White. I'm the hate crime victim advocate for the Chicago Commission on Human Relations. What we do is whenever we get a report from the police, we notify each alderman at office, and it's by sending a letter, which you've gotten. Previously, what we would do is we would send it via old mail. Now we email it so that if you want any additional information on the hate crime as to what took place, who the victims were, what was the bias, you could call us, and we're more than happy to give out the information. Some of the things that we also do is we like to work with the aldermanic offices, for example. If you see that there's certain hate crimes that are coming your way, we're available to go to your aldermanic offices or go to the public speaking to your community to let them know what a hate crime is. Because one of the things that we do know is that most people don't know what the definition of a hate crime is. You know, so we feel that it's very important to go out there and educate the public, educate the residents on what a hate crime is. So that's just to let the aldermanic offices know that something's happening in that ward. And once we communicate, because I've, you know, I've talked to some of the aldermen and some of the staffers, and we've been invited to speak at the forums. because, like I said, we feel that it's very important to let people know who we are and what we do and what a hate crime is, especially in this day and age. Thank you for that. My last question, Commissioner, is kind of to add on to what Aldo Woman hadn't said, thinking about that hate crimes are now going up and you having more staff and you were talking about cutting advertisement. Does it make sense? have you all kind of said to the administration like hey we we kind of need this because we're seeing a rise in these things happen and we need more because i feel like it happens more often than people are talking about and they just don't know who to talk to or what you're doing i would be interested in you all coming out to my office to talk to me and my staff around hay crafts we will be there absolutely we will follow up with you offline to set up a time and day to visit you and your your community with regards to um advocating for more funds for cta thank you so much for raising that thank you so much um we need we need we need your support and the support of the city council here because it is not a luxury it is a necessity but we had to comply with the exercise for the budget process and and in to comply with the budget process we had to identify 3% that needed to be reduced and that was we're a small department There's a 19 of us if we if we fill the Additional hate crime victim advocate position. It will bring us up to 20 honestly, there's very little for us to cut and other than staff and we desperately need staff and so the line that was identified that could meet the X the expectations of that budget exercise was our are advertising on the CTA. I'll just say, Chairman, to finish up, there's justification if you all are seeing the numbers up. It's common sense. And so I would hate for you all not to have the staffing or be cutting staffing or budgets to anything, and we're seeing the numbers rise. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you. Thank you, Chair Taylor. Alderman Fuentes, followed by Alderman Lopez, followed by closing with Alderman Mosley. This is $1.8 million. We got three more departments to do today, people. Major departments we got to do. I just want you all to just keep that in mind. That's all. But go ahead. No problem. We'll add you. Just understand. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Commissioner Andrade. And Norman, you are godsend. Norman, can you articulate to the room what your day-to-day job looks like? Well, that's pretty interesting because it varies. I mean, I could start my morning in the gay and lesbian community, and I can end my day in the Jewish community. It all varies. Like I said, one of the things that we do is we try to do a lot of outreach. For example, last Friday, first of all, we have a great relationship with the civil rights unit of the police department. So sometimes if we do have to go out and meet with victims, they sometimes we can do it in tandem also but one of the things that we also try to do is we try to build relationships for example on friday we're at the 24th police district that the next day that's when the shooting happened uh in the westridge neighborhood so what we were doing there at the 24th police district is we were getting to know the folks that worked there uh we were meeting with community leaders and seeing what their issues were and how we can help them too. One of the things that I also wanted to point out in terms of the training, which I forgot, is that if you have constituencies that speak Spanish, we can do presentations in Spanish. So for example, right before coming here, I was scheduled to come here originally. With this hate crime that happened in Rogers Park, I had to run out to court. So I'm running back from court and thank goodness that I was able to make this so that I could express that to you because I'm the only one that's doing that right now. I know that there's hate crimes right now. I check my phone that are sitting on my desk. So one of the things that we try to do is we try to build partnerships in the different communities in the city of Chicago so that we know where we need to be and what the particular issues are. Thank you, Norman. Commissioner Andrade, we all know Norman's great, right? We don't want him to go anywhere. He will need to rest at some point when he chooses to retire, and we will respect that. In an ideal world, how many hate crime specialists does the department need? If we could have a total of three to four, that would be very, very, very appreciated. um as Norman says he does a lot and myself first commission first first commissioner um Deputy Commissioner Penn and Danny Serrano the three of us we pivot and we help Norman which means that sometimes um other items that we are working on are put to the side because of the importance and the impact, the profound impact that has happened in a community. So for instance, yesterday, on election night, I was actually contacted by one of our community stakeholders, by the AJC, the American Jewish Community. They reached out to me because they had received word from the victim from the Westridge shooting. The victim had reached out to them inquiring as to what services are available to him and his family with regards to having experienced this hate crime. The AJC immediately knew that they could contact us. And we then set up a call with the AJC, a conference call with the victim. And we had a really good conversation and spoke with the victim, offered our support in terms of going to court, which is precisely why Norman was at court this morning, not to be there in lieu of the victim or formally represented. He was there as a CCHR just to know what was happening so he could inform the victim. But we also connected the victim with the state's attorney's office hate crime unit, and we are forever thankful with our great relationship with CPD because I was able just to pick up the phone, call the folks at CPD and say, here's the situation. We just got off the phone with the victim from the Westridge shooting and they need some handholding. They are not really aware of what the next court date is. They don't know what to do. What are their expectations? CPD immediately got on the phone. State's attorneys called the victim within 30 minutes since our initial conversation with them. they so long story short the victim was so so thankful for the hand-holding from the city and from the state's attorney's office that um we were just very happy that we were able to do our work but you know we drop everything whenever there's any sort of a situation that requires us to do so um but it would be nice to have a lot more normans so we can continue the pace of the other work with regards to hate incidents, hateful graffiti, and hate crimes. Thank you, Commissioner. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Alderman Alderman Mosley. Thank you, Chair, and good afternoon, Commissioner. Good afternoon. I'm wondering if you can share more so what resources are available to those who are impacted. We had a hate incident in a black war where there was advertisement and put on public property and as we move through the process making sure that it's reported to CPD it gets recommended if the city or the state's attorney's office is going to take it there were a lot of folks that were just unsettled about not full awareness of it and what do we do with the trauma that was caused by this when did this happen um just a few months ago norm was great in terms of the responses always but this happened I can get you the date we are we are here to work with you we are happy to go out to your ward our services include accompanying the victim to any court proceedings if the victim has unique circumstances if they don't feel safe if they whatever circumstances they find themselves in we want them to feel comfortable with us to share that with us to share their needs so that if there is a way that we can help them and connect them to city services or to community services we are there to do that so that those are the sorts of resources that we have directly for the victim. With regards to your ward, we are happy to go and we can canvass your neighborhood. We can put leaflets in people's mailboxes about what is the difference between a hate crime and a hate incident. And our goal is to really start building trust with our new hate crime pilot program. It's a mechanism to really instill trust with the CCHR, with the Chicago Police Department, and with community-based organizations and the local aldermanic offices that you can do this. You can reach out to us. And we would much rather have people who are unsure just to call and report it, even if it's not a hate incident, but at least it puts it on your radar and our radar that something might be brewing. And we're there to help you in case it escalates into anything else. Right. This is around September 2nd in the High Park area where flyers were pasted on city light poles. All right. We will follow up with you independently so we can go out to the community. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Mosley, Alderman Manor, Hoppenworth, followed by actually closing with Alderman Lopez. After Lopez, anybody else? After that, we're going to break for lunch. Anybody? Anybody? Anybody? Anybody? All right. Thank you. Go ahead, Alderman Manor, Hoppenworth. Thank you, Chair. Hi, Commissioner. Hi. I didn't want to miss a chance to thank you and your team and Danny and Norman and everyone in the box for all your work in the 48th Ward, which is one of the most diverse wards in Chicago, where we are struggling, as many are, with the results of the elections. So you're very important to us, and we would like to continue to find the funds so that you can do the work and reach more people. Through the chair, can we get a breakdown of the number of hate crimes per ward and a brief description of the type of hate crimes? We can definitely provide detailed information through the chair's office. We can do that. Thank you. Can you tell me how many languages are spoken amongst your staff members? I have a lot of different languages spoken in the ward, 60 in our public schools. can you answer that and also how do you handle mediation when there are multiple languages spoken so we have through the city the city has a contract with language line which offers interpretation services for free in any literally there's hundreds of languages that are available in in our office we have native Spanish speakers who are there to assist in Spanish with regards to other languages through the use of our smartphone we can connect with language line and provide instantaneous interpretation if the need is there we have had scheduled language line sessions with folks who come in to file a discrimination complaint and they speak a language other than Spanish and English and through LanguageLine we are able to assist. So we do not feel that not speaking English or understanding English is a barrier for us to help and serve the public and we stress that as much as possible. We will continue to do so. And should we be given the opportunity to hire additional staff, it would be great if we can hire someone who speaks an additional language other than Spanish. Thank you. And of course, my community and many others are concerned about the promise of mass deportations. You know, I remember in 2016 and speaking to the principal of my neighborhood school where my kids were at the time, and I said, how's it going? She said, the families are just disappearing. They're just, they don't tell us they're leaving, they're just gone. And we're very concerned about that. And I understand how you are set up to be very reactive, but I would love to know, you know, are you proactively working with the Office of Labor Standards and also with our schools to educate our community about why it's important to have a diverse community to live in? And is that something that your office does? Do you have the capacity to do that? Well, we do through our outreach and education. So we go to as many different communities as we are invited to, and we also do outreach to the different communities. We are there to educate people about discrimination in general. Our work is really about calming fears in terms of if you face discrimination here in the city, you do have an option to report and to receive some justice from our department, regardless of one's immigration status. And that is something that we are very very vocal about. You do not have to have any sort of legalized residency granted status in order to pursue us for help. Yes, I appreciate that. And again, thank you for the work that you do and would love to get to the point where, you know, your department is actually not needed because we have the conditions where people are getting along and understand how to behave in a in a great city like chicago so thank you commissioner thank you danny and norman thank you autumn autumn lopez thank you chairman and good afternoon commissioner and everyone here a couple a couple things first off if you could please provide me with an itemized breakdown of what your due subscriptions and memberships are i think it's almost 20 000 and and an increase in your budget this year, I'd appreciate it. How many students were trainees this year? Are student interns? We had a total of, was it six? We have three right now. We had, I'll let Joanne, Joanne and Danny. Yes, in the summertime we had two interns who were working in the hate crimes unit specifically, although we kind of toggle back and forth so that they can get exposed to everything that the agency does. And right now we have three. The ones that we had in the summertime were paid interns, and we had another paid internship that was in the pipeline. We were interviewing for that, but then the hiring freeze happened, so we pivoted and were able to find three unpaid interns, and they're very dynamic. We get them involved in our work. That's good. Thank you. Sorry. Love to hear more, but I only got 10 minutes. And a hangry group here. Why was all of their salaries eliminated from this budget? Again, unfortunately, we had to comply with the budget exercise. So I want to make sure that I'm understanding, because I know you told my colleague that it was the ads that were responsible for the budget, but it's also the pipeline you're creating for this wish list of three to four people you'd love to hire. it seems like you had three to four people who would have been perfect set to segue in transition whom we just fired for next year correct correct thank you thank you um our financial office states that has shared information and I see in your budget as well that we are going from, excuse me, our OBM shared in this book, the overview that we're having one employee go from grant funding to corporate fund. What is that position? That's on page 139 of this book where it says community block grant full-time employee. There was eight in 2024 and 12 that were on the corporate fund. Now there's 13 on the corporate fund and seven on the CDBG. Who went from CDBG to the corporate fund? Well, we're working from a different budget right here, but I think what you're looking at, we had a human relations specialist as one of our outreach program that person that position was switching to the hate crime victim advocate so we can have an extra hate crime person okay with respect to my colleagues what is what is your point the point of clarification so that position hold on hold on a point of clarification relates to a parliamentary matter if you have a question I can put you on for questions but that's not a all right then add me for a second round chair no problem this could be a really quick clarification though again we want to try to maintain and keep some water please go ahead Alderman thank you chairman with respect to my colleagues who are worried about whatever is gonna happen to come January 3rd what I didn't hear a lot of discussion about is the fact that 43% of the hate crime, that we've seen a 43%, 46% increase in anti-Semitism and Jewish hate this year, in the first 10 months of the year. We've seen, as you mentioned, the Westridge shooting, where I was also with my colleague, but also we just seen yesterday, a few days this week in DePaul. And we've seen time and time again on our universities and campuses here right now. I don't have to wait till Trump takes office. Right now, our Jewish population are under attack by the rhetoric that we're hearing national and even locally in this very room. What are we doing to address that proactively? And how are we connecting what your mission is with your limited scope, granted, which oftentimes is very reactionary because you only have one man running around? But how are we tying in, for example, what's going on at our public and private universities, our own board of education and public schools, and those areas where we know that the hatred is festering before it manifests in ways that we have to eventually respond? I will answer this as quickly and as quickly. You don't have a time limit. I do. As long as I get it in before you take your time. So with regards to the universities, the universities are private campuses primarily. We do outreach to the campuses, but the campuses also have the discretion to say thank you. No, thank you. We have reached out. We have not. We will continue to be out on campus. But because there are private universities, their private security detail addresses those issues. They know that we are here. They understand that. And I believe that is the reason why, perhaps in this most recent incident with DePaul, the students did reach out to the City of Chicago Police Department, and they also reached out to the Jewish United Fund. The Jewish United Fund immediately contacted us to let us know that they had heard about the incident at DePaul. So we do have our network there with regards to the private universities via CPD and via community stakeholders. So our presence is there. We would love to, with more staff, we can do more outreach with those universities. With regards to CPS and at the elementary school level, we agree with you 100%. There should be some sort of a platform at the elementary school and the high school level. That, in fact, was one of our recommendations at our hate crime and incident report that we submitted back in July. We have begun conversations with CPS and Pedro Martinez's office to begin a dialogue on how we can implement something like this in the Chicago public school system. So that is on the radar, that is in the works. With regards to, I'm sorry, what else? No, no, that's fine. public and private institutions. Awesome. Thank you. And if I'm just real quick. Can we just one thing for through the chair? That's all it is. Just a list of the community relations complaints by ward and outcomes. Thank you. All right. Chair Hatton, you had a question? Yeah. Thank you, Chair. So sorry. I'll give you a moment, Commissioner. It's dry in here. um this was a clarification uh so in in response to alderman lopez's uh question about the shift from the cdpg uh grant fund to the court fund your response was that that was someone um working in a different role and you've moved that position to supplement the hate crimes division so was that the additional position that you referenced earlier yes so you're not really adding a position to your department you are adding a position to the hate crimes piece so where are you losing that position could you tell me what was that role doing before again part of that's part of the intergroup relations team that's a human relations specialist human relations they help deal with community tensions and mediation and some education work so like a kind of conflict management piece okay and so i want to amend my through the chair request um so i know my through the chair request was what would be the cost for an additional staffer to the hate crimes piece what i would like to see is what would be the cost for that two additional staffers to the hate crime piece bringing you up to three positions while also maintaining the human relations piece um uh and then of course i said the supplemental things and thank you through alder fuentes's questions um the advertising budget things of that stuff um restored so thank you for that and thank you chair thank you all the man had all the men canutzen i said canutzen could newton not new gent people say The canugent. Canugent? All right. Canugent. Yeah, no, thank you, Commissioner. I just wanted to, Alderman Lopez brought up the potential hate crime that occurred at DePaul that we're investigating right now. And I just wanted to take this opportunity because we've worked quite closely this year on the stop hate littering legislation and different hate incidents that have occurred in the 43rd Ward, particularly related to anti-Semitism. And I just wanted to thank your team. I strongly believe that your team is very hands-on, that your team could use a lot more help. And our ward, it might be different than other wards, we hear about hate incidents and potential hate crimes tied to hate speech and fear related to that as much as we do other parts of public safety. So I view them hand in hand. And I think that getting you the resources to really execute the great policies and programs you've implemented is important. So I just wanted to say thank you, and I'm going to keep working together with you guys weekly. Thank you, Alderman. All right. That's all we have for the Commission on Human Relations. I do have one question for you, though. Is your job full-time? Yes. And beyond full-time. You're beyond full-time. Okay. I'm just saying this just to be saying this. I find it very interesting that there's only about a $250 separation between you and your first deputy. I thought you may be in part-time, given that salary differentiation. So I think that's something that we talked about, salary compression. I think that's something that needs to be addressed as it relates to somebody leading the department and then the salary of those that they are supervising. Nah, I don't know. I mean, that's what the book says. And I'm looking at it, and I don't think that's necessarily fair to her as a commissioner to be leading the department in that way. So, again, just putting it in the ether. All right. I understand. It is what it is. All right. We're going to break. We're going to break for lunch. It is now 1.30. I hear we're having sandwiches, so it shouldn't be that. can we do a half an hour please you're all laughing at a half an hour 45 minutes all right we can do 45 minutes 2 15 thank you all thank you Could you please clear the chambers until 2 15? Clear the chambers until 2 15 please. Thank you. the chambers till 2 15 please thank you welcome back everybody we're going to go ahead and get started with our next hearing uh the um department the chicago department of public health we have with us uh here at the dais commissioner igay um commissioner would you like to introduce the folks that you have with you yeah thank you um vice chair lee uh i have here with me uh our first deputy okay for kurti wagao and and our chief financial officer uh mary emmanuel and um we have in the box are deputy commissioners and some of our program leads. You can go ahead and read your statement if you'd like. Thank you, Vice Chair, and good afternoon, everybody and members of the City Council. I am Dr. Simbo Ige, and I'm the Commissioner for the Chicago Department of Public Health. And I want to start today with the three P's of public health. Public health is about prevention, it's about protection, and it is about promotion. And as a local... Dr. Ige, hold on one second. Can I ask that in the gallery, can you guys take the conversation outside? People are having a hard time hearing. We good? Okay, go ahead. Thank you. So we are mandated to prevent diseases, to protect the environment and ensure food safety, to promote health and link it to care. And because prevention is often invisible, today I want to start by shedding some light on how we detect and mitigate threats to the health of Chicagoans. So let me start with preventing disease. CDPH was trusted to keep thousands of delegates safe during the Democratic National Convention. We always like to present the counterfactual because when we prevent things, they're sometimes invisible. So hundreds of thousands of delegates in our city, and we had to prepare the healthcare system to handle scenarios ranging from bioterrorism, and that included 16 trailers of antitoxin that we had to store and warehouse and prepare a continuity of government plan. We also had to take samples of wastewater from all of the different locations where delegates were housed twice a day to ensure that we were tracking every possible disease that could emerge. We were tracking diseases from every country around the world that could potentially come to Chicago. And we also ensured that food was safe. More than 40 different restaurants were involved in this event, and we were doing continuous monitoring every two hours to ensure that the delegates were safe. We prevented any outbreak. You did not hear of any disease outbreak because we prevented it. This year also, we had a measles outbreak, the largest of its kind, in 30 years and the largest in the country. And we were able to limit that outbreak, even though more than 2,000 people were exposed to measles, to just 57 cases. It could have been hundreds. And we worked tirelessly, hundreds of people working together, to ensure that the disease did not spread. This prevented school closures. It prevented the economy from being unencumbered. It prevented the city from being shut down. The city remained safe because of the work we do in prevention. This response earns national recognition for promptness and effectiveness. Every day, there are 70 mandatory diseases that we must monitor, and we monitor them. This year, we have responded to 261 outbreak notifications. And we set ourselves a goal this year. If we get an outbreak notification, we will be on the ground in 24 hours. And I'm proud to tell you that 100% of these cases, we were on the ground in 24 hours. This is how we keep our cities safe. We have responded to outbreaks in healthcare systems, including microbial resistance outbreaks. We have responded to outbreaks in long-term care facilities, in correctional facilities, in schools and in daycare, responding within 24 hours and containing every instance. You did not hear any of this in the news because we prevented it. Now let's talk about protection. How do we protect our communities from health risk? It requires detection and also understanding what the health hazards are that face our community. When parents consent, we go to their homes and ensure that if you're a new parent in the city of Chicago, you are offered a chance for a home visit by a public health nurse. When that person visits your home, they will not just assess the health of the mother or the child, they assess the conditions of the home as well. This year, 2,200 families have benefited from this support. Several hundred sudden infant deaths have been prevented because now families know how to ensure safe sleep practices. Do you know the numbers of sudden infant death is now down to 175 in the entire city? Our goal is to get that to zero. And we're working hard to ensure that all health hazards in the home are remediated, including lead. This year, as at August and the end of August, we inspected 768 homes for lead. We get a notice, a child has lead in their blood, we're there on the ground, again, as quickly as we can. And we inspect the home. If we find lead, we remediate the lead at no cost to the family. And we have successfully remediated lead in 245 homes just this year alone. We keep homes safe. We keep families healthy. We keep communities thriving. We have ensured that in our city, the 15,000 licensed food establishments are safe. We have ensured that several hundred food vendors at special events adhere to food safety. I was at Lollapalooza. I was at NASCAR. I was at Taste of Chicago. We do two-hour monitoring, checking food temperatures, making sure food is handily safe. And that is why there were no food outbreaks. And this is what makes us proud, ensuring that our city can continue to be the tourist hub that it is. We have prevented hundreds of foodborne outbreaks, and we have contributed to the economic vitality of our city. One of the reasons people come to Chicago for tourism is because of our food. As a result, businesses have continued to serve Chicagoans and our city continues to thrive. Safe food tourism contributes to the reason why Chicago has been voted the best big city for eight years in a row, because we keep the food safe. Every day, we also ensure that the air is safe and that our homes are safe. We have already received more than 7,500 service requests through 311 this year. People ping us, we respond. Mostly, the concerns that we get in CDPH are related to food and environmental concerns. And do you know, as of this morning when I checked that 311 dashboard, our number was already at 88%. When I wrote this, it was 87%. We respond to 88% of the requests we get through 311 within seven days. Our city is safer because we have a robust public health department. Now, my final point is about promoting health. Our summer opioid response this year led to a 23% reduction in overdoses and almost 50% reduction in premature mortality. People dying from opioid reduced from more than 1,000 to about 500 this summer. We came before you earlier this year to present a plan for how we want to address opioid overdose, and we delivered on that plan. And now we have all kinds of press releases and national recognition because we have reduced overdose incidents in Chicago by almost 23%. We want to say a big thank you to the 40 community organizations, the mayor's office, chairwoman Rodriguez-Sanchez, members of the Committee on Health and Human Relations, and the Westside Alders who partnered with us. We canvassed 1,300 blocks. We went from door to door. I was out there door knocking with my colleagues. And these are the success stories we have. All public schools in Chicago have benefited from oral and vision and sexual health services. Do you know more than 50,000 students can get their eyes checked while at school, can get their teeth checked while they're at school, can have sexual education at school, and that is because of the work we do in CDPH. And so these kids are better able to focus on their studies. We have a supplemental nutrition program for women, infants, and children that has provided nutritional support to more than 17,000 families. And this does not impact the ability to also have SNAP, complementing and supplementing the nutrition that families need. During the summer, more than 30,000 children participated in PlayStreets. Why is this important? When kids are active, they're mentally sound, they're physically sound, they develop social skills. This is how we promote health. Promoting mental health requires developing social skills and mental health also requires being able to be physically and emotionally active. And that is what PlayStreets provide, physical, mental and social skills. We have collaborated with many stakeholders and we are grateful for their commitment to bring mental health expansion to life. The mayor's office has had our back. They have provided support. Chairwoman Rodriguez Sanchez, the Health Committee, the Budget Office, Human Resources, Fleet and Facilities. It has taken a village and the Public Safety Department have worked together with us. Hundreds of community partners. We have hired new staff. We have expanded mental health services in three locations. We have even expanded our Behavioral Crisis Response Team to ensure that we have citywide coverage. These are the accomplishments in just this year alone, 2024. Critically, all of this was accomplished without disrupting provider continuity for folks receiving care through other systems of care. Outside of mental health, the majority of our work is supported by grants. More than 82% of CDPA's budget comes from federal grants. More than $500 million of our work is supported by one-time grants that will end in 2026. And so sustainability has been a top priority for CDPH. We have been planning for this scenario from day one. When you get one-time funding, you have to start with a sustainability plan from day one. And that is what we have done. In anticipation of the end of this grant, we have started to explore creative solutions in partnership with community organization, collaboration across government, and I look forward to continuing to work with this body and our county, state, and federal partners to ensure that public health services continue post-COVID one-time funding. Looking forward, we have also developed action plans to address identified community health needs with a focus on health equity and closing the racial life expectancy gap. Our city continues to be impacted by premature mortality. That's death before the age of 65. The number of deaths before the age of 65 and the gap in life expectancy in Chicago is double that of the national average. This must be a priority for us in public health. And the reasons for this premature death are chronic disease, especially heart disease, homicide, opioid overdose, infectious diseases, and infant mortality. And we remain resolute to address these issues. We also recognize that mental illness contributes to premature mortality, and this is why it continues to be a priority area of action for us. In 2025, we will address the six drivers of life expectancy gap, especially in the most impacted communities. There are some communities in our city that not only have lower life expectancy, but that the life expectancy is declining. We must prioritize them. The history and persistence of racial segregation in Chicago has limited access to resources, creating obstacles to health. And we must help to remove these barriers. We will ensure that the south side and the west side neighborhoods where the lowest life expectancy are concentrated must benefit from all of our programs. We are poised to layer our intervention, not one disease at a time, but all of it at the same time. We will implement a data-driven, asset-based, hyper-local, collective impact approach. And the reason we know this works is because we tried it this summer for opioid overdose and it worked. So we want to replicate this in more neighborhoods. We call this precision public health. We want to go to where the problem is and remove the barriers. And we know that it works. We have experienced it this year. And so our action plan for 2025 will leverage the existing resources and partners in the following way. We want to work with community health workers and community partners to increase access to chronic disease prevention. Remember, we're in the business of prevention, we're in the business of promotion, and we're in the business of protection. And so we must ensure that there's access to more nutritious food, physical activity, and smoking cessation support. We are also going to be disrupting cycles of violence through hospital-based intervention for survivors and highlighting place-based community safety measures like vacant lot greening and tree planting. Tree planting contributes as much to mental health as antidepressants. There is proven scientific evidence for place-based intervention and its impact on violence prevention. We are going to be further reducing the opioid overdoses through hyper-local engagement and promoting the use of safe medication that minimizes craving, lessen withdrawal symptoms, and reverse overdoses. And we're also going to be limiting the spread of communicable diseases. Every day, we are detecting are responding to communicable diseases. And now we have a plan for how we can do that even better in communities that are the most impacted, especially with respiratory viruses. And we're going to be doing tailored messaging to communities of color. Promoting infant and maternal health is a priority. We are going to be increasing access to nutrition, support through our week enrollment, data modernization, and increased staff support. And finally, we are going to be promoting mental health, not just addressing mental illness, but promoting mental wellness. And we will be training more community leaders to identify dangerous signs and work with us to connect loved ones to care. I look forward to working with you to make our work more visible and sharing the progress next year. I want to end by thanking my CDPH team. I have a fantastic team in CDPH. nationally recognized, nationally accredited. We're one of the big cities that receives funding directly from the federal government, very similar to the state. And that is a pride and a privilege that we want to keep going forward. We want to thank the mayor's office and we want to thank the city council. We have approached you several times this year to present plans and trainings, and you have participated and worked with us to bring services to your community. we will need your help as we go into the next year. We want to thank our public health system partners. There are more health systems in Chicago than in many states, and they are always willing to support and respond to our call. And we want to thank our community-based organizations, researchers, advocates, many other collaborators that have kept us on our toes and partnered with us to ensure that public health is really inclusive of the public. We are resolute. We are committed. We must ensure the health of Chicagoans are protected. And we are in this mission to support the health and well-being of all Chicagoans. And we will be looking forward to sharing updates with you in 2025. Thank you, Vice Chair Lee, and thank you, everyone, for listening. Thank you, Dr. Ige. We'll raise your hand if you've got questions. I'm going to provide a courtesy here to our Chair, Rodriguez Sanchez. If you'd like to open, you can go ahead, and if you'd like to ask questions, please raise your hands. Thank you, Vice Chair. Thank you, Dr. Ige, for all the work that you have been doing on your team. it is a privilege to be able to work with all of you in the mission of public health and education for our communities and for our colleagues and for our offices and promoting well-being. I'm going to start with a general question and I'm going to be sending many of my questions through the share because they're very specific and technical and I don't want to be here for too long because I know that we still have a long way to go. So we're going to have a new context in January that we know very well because we already went through it. I would like to hear from you. Are we ready and how are we ready to meet the needs of our community with this new administration that is coming in at the federal level in January and with the dramatic decrease in COVID funding. Thank you, Chairwoman, for that question. There are two types of funding that we get through the federal government. There is funding that comes through us through routine appropriation to CDC, and then there's funding that is supplemental funding. So supplemental funding is often one-time funding, And many of the funding that is supplemental, we are notified that it is one time they're not renewable. So during COVID, we got a lot of supplemental funding, several hundred millions of it. We are not anticipating that that funding will be renewed because it is supplemental. However, we are up for reaccreditation this year. And we are working very hard to ensure that we remain a low-risk partner so that we can continue to benefit from federal grants. And we are working with the Big Cities Health Coalition to make recommendations to the new administration about public health priorities that impact health security and impacts the economy. And so we are optimistic that even with the new administration, those appropriation dollars that we get routinely as recurring grants will continue to be recurring grants and we will continue to benefit from it. What is the timeline for accreditation? The decision, the budget decisions are usually made in September, October. This year there has been continuance. so we are still waiting for what the final approval of the CDC budget will be, but we don't have a timeline for when that is going to happen. Okay. Can you talk about the decrease in funding that we're seeing in CDPH? I understand we've had a conversation and I was briefed about how the opioid funds were now going to be eliminated from the corporate fund because we do have an opioid fund from settlements. Can you go into more detail about how we are funding the opioid response? And apart from the opioid response, what other programs are seeing cuts? Yes. So this year, our budget went down by about $140 million. That is mostly a function of the reduction in our available grant funding. When we receive grants, we get it, you know, up front. And as we spend, the money goes down. So we were at the peak of our funding in 2024, where we had, you know, upwards of $966 million total. And as we spend down the money, the money that's available for us going forward is lower. So that $140 million difference that you see is because of the reduction in the available grant funds. Now, the opioid settlement dollar varies. I will not say that it is a reduction, really, because it varies over time. So we have the opioid settlement dollars that support our opioid response. The activities that it can support are very specified. So we have to ensure that our legal team, everything is compliant. so we don't anticipate much of a reduction in the opioid settlement funds this year. But the grant funding is where we will continue to see a decline. This is the first year of that decline, and it will continue until 2027 when all of the COVID-19 era funding will have expired. Thank you for that. Can you talk about the Roseland location for the Mental Health Center and how are we going to see resources used there from this particular budget? Yes. So the main investment from CDPH into mental health clinics is really the staffing. So this year we're very grateful that the Office of Management and Budget allowed us to hire the required number of personnel to run these clinics. So the three new locations we've added to our inventory of clinics, that is the Pilsen site, the Roseland Clinic, and the Legler Library, we have the staff hired to be able to start operations there. For Roseland, though, there's also need for some repairs work that is under the Department of Fleet and Facility Management. but for the staff that is required to run services there we have those staff hired and do we have a sense of what kind of programming besides what we have talked about therapeutic services we have seen roseland as a hub that can have more resources for people and not just the therapeutic services do we have a sense of how much of that we're going to be able to accomplish with this budget It is work in progress. We have a sexually transmitted infection clinic there. We anticipate that we will also be able to provide vaccination services there, similar to Pilsen. And we also hope that we will be able to have a community health worker partnership helping to navigate people in addition to the mental health services. We are continuing to explore what additional resources we can link closer to the community as we go. But, you know, as our funding evolves, we will know what the final scope of services will be. But at a minimum, we believe that those services will be available when the clinic opens in December is what we're hoping. So for the Roseland location, when it opens in December, we are still going to have the STI testing. and we are going to have therapy and then we're going to build on that after. Is that what you're saying? That's correct. Okay. Can you talk about our ideas or plans for the integration of the mental health crisis response, the care component with the mental health center work? Yes. So our outreach team, we've looked at the data and looked at the profile of those they're engaging and what kind of services are necessary. What we have noticed is that about majority of those they are engaging need social services. They need housing, they need food, they need clothing. Some of those issues can be resolved by connecting them to other services. Mental health services, there are a few instances when people have severe mental illness and need to be stabilized. so we are working with existing stabilization units that are closest to where people are found to connect them to services and the reason why that's important is that severe mental illness requires ongoing support it's not a one-time thing so we want folks to have community assets that can continue to provide that wraparound support for them after we have resolved in the moment so we leverage our community partners that have living room services there. What is required to integrate living room services in our facilities right now is quite significant, especially in terms of space and the staffing, because it requires 24-hour coverage. So it will require significant staffing, significant space to be able to replicate a living room model that will be certified by the state. So in the interim, though, we are working with partners. We've already identified the partner, and the state is funding for new CCBHC, and we've already started negotiation and partnership with them. I'm looking forward to working with you to accomplish that from the city, because I think that's really a big dream for us to be able to use our mental health centers in that way. I'm going to ask one more question. I'm going to send some through the chair. You talked about the need for awareness about the mental health services that we are providing. Can you talk a little bit about what CDPH is going to be doing about that? Yes. We found from the annual community health service that we do that there are people who have moderate to severe psychological distress that are not connected to services. And the question is always why. Is it because they're not aware of those services? Is it because they don't want to come to those services? is because there are other barriers. So we continue to explore the reasons why people are not connected to services. But for our services, we've done some community engagement and focus groups. And we have found that the physical condition of our services can be unwelcoming. Our services are not always updated. They don't always look as pretty as other locations. Engagement with staff and providing clarity of information. So we have taken this finding and worked it into the design of our clinics now, ensuring that our spaces are welcoming, that they incorporate design and art in our spaces, that our spaces offer people options beyond just therapy. They can have medication management. They can have yoga. They can have sensory therapy, et cetera, so that people have options when they come to our spaces. and we are also even going as far as having open houses so people can come and see the space and so that by word of mouth we can share that word. We are also doing canvassing, door knocking and going around from door to door, letting people know that we're here in our community. We have a list of all community partners so they know that we are bringing services to the community. So we are working hard to ensure that people know that we're there and we've listened to them and we have created welcoming spaces for people to come. And if we're not able to provide what people want, we also have now an inventory of partners where we can actually do warm handoff, not just a call, but we can actually track in the system if they have been connected to those services so that we are a one-stop health center for our community. Love the idea of the city knocking on your door to actually offer a service. I already know several people that have made appointments at the Pilsen Clinic, and they're very happy. So thank you so much for your work, and you will get the rest of my questions through the chair. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. Audiment staff. Thank you, Chairman. Hello, Dr. Ige. We have not met, but I see that you share a characteristic of Dr. Arwadi, which is a long answer. So I would ask you to try to keep them short for me because I only have 10 minutes. The environmental, first of all, I want to just say, even though we have not met, I want to just acknowledge Alfonso, who keeps me abreast of what is going on in your department since we have not really connected. So I just wanted to say that. But can you talk to me about your environmental permitting and inspections division? There's 34 individuals there. I really want to know what their responsibilities are. What do you see as the vision for that? And then I have a follow-up. Thank you, older woman. So our Office of Environmental Permits and Inspection has four main responsibilities. We do permits for new operations, new industries, and that includes reviewing the air emission potential of those new facilities. We do inspections. So when we get requests through 311 and people have concerns about any operation, we check that. We oversee demolitions and anything that has the potential to emit dust or other particulate matter that is of significance. And those demolitions, we can categorize them as environmentally complex or not. And if they are environmentally complex, we also organize the community engagement to let people know what to expect. And finally, we also collect data and do monitoring on the air quality, remediate chemical, radiation, and other environmental hazards. Okay, the reason I ask that is because over the last year and a half, I've been approached by at least three different data centers, and there seems to be a growth of that in our city. And I'm wondering the extent to which your department can address that. I mean, we want that to happen in our city because it means more tax dollars for the city. But the proliferation of them, the cumulative impact of them, what is your department doing? Our work right now is guided by the Air Quality Ordinance of March 2021, and that limits our authority to consequential facilities, certain types of industry. Data centers are not included in that list at the moment. We are open to supporting the review of any potential environmental hazard that could result. Our main concerns are related to the use of generator and noise from those centers. And right now, they have some plans about how they will solve for that. But we will be interested in just seeing in real time as these data centers are established what the environmental impact is. But right now, we do not currently have authority under the ordinance to oversee or regulate data centers. So how would you suggest I deal with the impact, the possible impact in terms of particulates? And who is going to help me make those kind of decisions? on whether to support something or not? We typically start with the U.S. EPA standards and regulations and if there are some guidance there. Data centers are relatively new right now, so it's really in the exploratory state for now. And we're hoping that over the next year or so there are opportunities to actually collect data and see what the impact is, how much emissions are they generating, and how much that's really through the use of their generators, how much those generators emissions are coming from there. And then if there are any other potential hazards, I think the generator component is what we are most interested in. All right. So maybe after this, I would like to sit down with you. And I know Renate is gone, and I believe David is taking his responsibilities, but I would like to sit down with you and see how to address this pending good problem, perhaps, in my ward. I wanted to get through the chair a list of all of your programs by funding source and indicate which do not have funding past 2025, if I can get that through the chair. This morning we had someone from the public who, Creole Hampton, Creole Hampton, Creola Hampton, who said that you were going to give Black-led HIV organizations $3 million a year, and I just wanted to know if that was accurate. The number, our HIV funding, they're different grant funding. I believe that the reference would be to the Ryan White funding. It is a federal funding. That funding, 75% of it must go to medical services treatment, and then 25% to community treatment. This year, because of our goal to get into zero by 2030, we have started to look at which groups of people are not moving along as fast as we want to. And that is the black gay men and black transgender men, black and Latino transgender men. So we have requested to focus some funding on engaging those communities that are likely to be the most. That is non-Ryan White funding, you're saying? That is Ryan White funding. You don't have any other source of funding for that particular health problem? We do. We have HOPWA, which provides housing. We have CDC prevention grants that also provides HIV funding. I think we have about five or six different HIV funding. Can I get that through the chair so I can get an understanding of what that funding stream looks like? All right. I noticed in the budget that you spend almost a million dollars on your own human resources division. And my question is, why does CDPH have their own human resources division when we have a department that does that? It was a response to the many grants that we got during COVID. We managed about 80 grants. And because of the short-term nature of the grant, it becomes necessary to hire people really quickly. And our Department of Human Resources supports 40 departments. So during COVID, the Department of Health had particular need to staff up really quickly. And all of those funding will be going. So that size will be shrinking as a result. But that was a response to the COVID era funding where we needed to hire. So do we need it for, you know, we're trying to find ways to make the dent in our budget. A million dollars is a million dollars. Is this something that your department could do without? It is grant-funded positions mostly. So when the grants end, those positions will end. I believe I saw that in the corporate budget. Correct? Yes, please. Am I wrong? Is it not in the corporate budget? It is. Please state your name. Fikurdi Wagau, First Deputy Commissioner. Older woman, we've had an HIV division before COVID. Dr. Ige was referring to the growth in our HIV unit to support. Not HIV, HR. I'm sorry, human resources to support the growth in our staffing. We can talk to HR, but our human resources provides a lot of hands-on support for our employees, processing leaves, payroll, et cetera. And I think to Dr. Ege's point, as our one-time COVID funds shrink, we expect that a lot of our shared services will also shrink. Okay, I'm putting that in the parking lot because that might be some money we could claw back. Your settlement funds, what's your long-term plan for when those funds run out? We have the settlement fund for about 10 years, I believe, and a lot of our work is grant funded, so we always plan for the duration of the grant and when the grants end, if we don't have a recurring grant or another grant, then the work will transition either to county partners, state partners, or community partners that are in similar areas. Okay. And do you know how many settlement funds you're working with right now? I know that there's vaping and opioid epidemic. I know you have some for epidemics. Do you know how many of those settlement funds you're working with right now? We have two settlement funds, the vaping settlement fund and opioid settlement fund. Thank you, Ms. Chairman. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman. Alderman had and followed by Alderman Moore. And anybody else? Okay. All right. Thank you, Chair. Good afternoon, Dr. Ige. All right. I'm going to try and run through these questions pretty quickly, too, because I got a few. So I just want to start off. So thank you for your comments. and prepared remarks today. It's good to hear about all the kind of progress that you guys are making, especially on these core health services. I know that the Department of Public Health has always been important, but certainly these last few years have elevated departments of public health around the country just into spotlight all the time. So we appreciate you guys and the entire team. Certainly we've gotten to know you better than we might have otherwise. I've got a few questions more on the environmental piece. So, you know, wondering if you could speak to the air quality monitoring program. I know there's supposed to be a thing tomorrow with, you know, kind of the deployment plans. And is that happening tomorrow? And could you speak to the air quality monitoring program? Yes. The meeting tomorrow has been postponed until after a budget hearing when we can reset. The air monitors have been procured. They have been calibrated. So our advisory governance team, the advisory buddy is working with us to identify the locations for the installation of the monitors. So that is the next step and we will be scheduling that meeting. So I would love if you could, you know, please loop in my committee team on the rescheduling of that meeting so we can just kind of make sure to be on it and participate. And we want to make sure that happens and to continue to work with our community partners to let us know that there is still that commitment for that program. um um i'll say a similar question just around the tree advisory committee and wondering if there are any updates um on that and um you know if we're going to continue to see work on this in 2025 same uh plan uh we are postponing the the next meeting until after our budget hearing and um a new date will be sent we sent a notice to our community partners to just give us some time to find a new date for the tree equity meeting. So the air monitoring, tree equity, all existing work will continue. We're just fine-tuning dates and when we'll be able to regroup. So similar requests on that one, particularly in chairing my committee, we also serve on the Urban Forestry Advisory Board. So we'd just love to be, just keep me in the loop, let me know when that's happening so we can also work and with our community partners on that um and then same question around the heat preparedness initiatives same answer yeah okay all right um so we'll continue to follow up on that and you know these are all very important parts of the work and especially on the heat preparedness um you know what what does 2025 look like in your department position commitments for the cumulative impact work So the cumulative impact was started with a data collection and recommendations for both action and policy. Some of those actions we've already started implementing environmentally complex community meetings, asking for additional data when our industries are submitting for permits. There are some policy recommendations that are outside of the Department of Health that requires the mayor's office, Department of Environment, Department of Law to move forward. And so we are waiting on that for when that will be finalized. Okay. And just to clarify, so currently for that work, you're waiting on direction from the office of the mayor and the Department of Environment on next steps. That's correct. Okay. All right. Thank you for that. um i know chair dow mentioned this but on the hiv and aids funding i know i did reach out to you you gave me some good information that was pretty robust on the uh ryan white part a funds um this is just a clarifying question so for the for the portion i think it was around two million um that um uh black the advocacy groups of black-led organizations working in this space for HIV and AIDS care. You know, they said that the 2 million was set aside for organizations who have EDs that are black gay men. I'm wondering, is that specifically true? Organization that serve black gay men. Okay, that serve black gay men, but it doesn't have to be led by a black gay man. We are not able to restrict that way. uh we we wanna we're able to say these are the most impacted so if you serve that community then you're eligible okay and are there any any similar focus points permitted within that grant structure for um black women who are suffering from hiv or aids i i will look into that and and get back to you with specific um the increases we've seen is mostly in the black gay men community and also the transgender community. So there are two components to this, preventing new infections, uptake of PrEP and all of that, and also ensuring that people are staying connected to treatment. So we will look at our data and see where we will have justification to designate in that way. um and then uh nothing so sorry they're all rapid fire questions and we're just going to go all over the place um uh chair dow asked for kind of a list um through the chair right of um programs that might be expiring through uh 2025 for cares funds um I'm I'm gonna ask um in addition to that if you could, through the chair, provide positions that would be a limit are going to be eliminated at the end of 2025 or sooner as well that are tied to CARES or ARPA dollars, that would be helpful. So the titles and kind of numbers of the positions, what that budgetary impact is going to look like, if we could get that through the chair. And I know just like off the top of looking through some of these budget impacts. You know, I see funding for community health workers, for behavioral outreach, community mental health, expanded street outreach, the link up and link match program, like a lot of those are funded through CARE. So I'm assuming, you know, looking at even just that pot of funds, it's like $12 million there that we won't have after 2025. and I'm assuming those programs will go away. But I guess my question is, are you currently in planning with the budget office or the mayor's office to be able to give us through the chair a list of programs that you plan to continue or seek other grant or corporate funds to continue after the CARES and ARPA funds expire? Thank you, Chairwoman. Our corporate budget right now is 76 million. Our one-time COVID funding was over $800 million. So we anticipated that it will be a big drop-off. So we've mostly focused on programs that we either had before, expanded, and then we'll contract. The new initiatives we started were designed to be like proof of concept that we could shop around after. We have been in close conversation with the city about which of these can transition. So we have about 347 positions that are on one-time COVID funding. All of these positions where we were clear during hiring that they were in one-time positions because they're grant funded. We have been able to identify recurrent grants for about 40 of those positions. but as of today, 214, 15 of those positions we haven't identified alternative funding for. So our plan going forward is really how do we connect with county and state to see, and maybe philanthropy to see which of those programs we can transition or get additional funding for. I'm going to go do it with the chairman. Excuse me. Hold the time. Oh, it's, I'm, she can use the last 48 seconds. I'm good. Thank you, Dr. Egek. Yeah. Bottom and down. Thank you, Madam Chair. I just want to ask Alderman, what's your name? Maria. Alderman Haddon. Thank you. I had a senior moment. If we can get that information that you just asked for, and the information that I asked for together so it's not separate. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Alderman Hatton, Alderman Hatton, you're good? All good. Thank you. Thanks, Dr. D. Thank you. Alderman Moore, Alderman Lopez, you're next. Perfect. Come back to you later. Oh, great. Okay. Thank you. All right. Look, you're a non-member, so I got to wait to the end. What are these other members here? Thank you so much, Chairman. I appreciate it. Alderman Moore. Thank you so much. A couple of my questions have been asked and answered. First of all, I want to thank you and your team for your service. I know we don't interact a lot, but I do see you periodically. And I just want to thank you for, well, at least thank the work that Alfonso was doing because he keeps us in a loop and always being proactive to anything that we need. I just want to echo so you know it's important, and I know things have been asked for through the chair, but so you making sure that organizations that's on the ground, that's interacting with HIV patients, and especially in African American communities, are making sure that they are getting those resources, so to speak, like we're doing with violence prevention, where they're trying to get it down to the level of those organizations. So I want you to know that that's a critical piece and things that we're hearing in our community. And so I just want to make sure I echo that as well. The other part has to do with, and this may also go towards to DFSS in terms of senior service, but I want to know how you all are working together in terms of outreach and your dollars for outreach. We, you know, we got our seniors are living longer. We, I mean, we're doing events where, man, resolutions, somebody turning 104, somebody turning 105. And our seniors are living longer, some healthier, some not. Are you doing outreach programs to inform seniors and families of how we deal with, you know, long-term health care issues? Or is that a DFS thing? Or are you doing outreach? And if so, where is it in your budget that you're doing, you have the funding for that outreach? Our funding is typically tied to particular issues rather than particular populations. So the issues that particularly impact seniors during COVID respiratory viruses, yes, we do outreach in collaboration. We DFSS, organize vaccination events with them, mental health issues, also ensuring that we are reaching that population. We just had, you know, an AARP meeting that I was on with the director at the state with almost 800 seniors on the call. So we do reach out for specific health related issues that impact seniors. And that's in collaboration with DFSL. And what are some of the main issues that you are seeing with our seniors? What are some of the top three? And I'm not talking about just doing around COVID, but, you know, just as they're living longer, what are you seeing? Infectious diseases particularly impacts those who are 65 and older. And we see a lot of that. Most of the disease outbreaks we see, nursing homes, long-term care facility, mostly seniors. Then chronic diseases, heart diseases, diabetes, again, seniors are the most impacted there. We do not right now have, we have very little for chronic diseases. So we don't do a lot there. But it is an area where we're collaborating with community health centers and healthcare systems to just better reach and engage our community. And then mental health. The isolation from COVID is a challenge. And what we do there is our partnership with the Community Health Response Corps. We have a hotline where people can call and get information, and we also do outreach. That's on-the-ground canvassing, getting to faith-based organizations, other organizations that serve seniors to just get information to them. So, and now let's get into the infectious diseases. Is there one that stands out more than another that you're seeing amongst our seniors? Right now, respiratory viruses are the main problems. pneumonia from all kinds of causes is always a thing every year. Flu hospitalization from flu, hospitalization from COVID, RSV, all of those really disproportionately impact seniors. So and so then to my question where I started out at how are we reaching our seniors to talk about this? Is it left upon DFSS or is it coming out of your department as a shared responsibility? How are we reaching out to our seniors to inform and educate instead of them? Because most of them just run into the doctor, right? What are we doing from the city standpoint to say, hey, this is how, you know, we can, you know, or things we can do or services that we can provide? It comes from CDPH. We collaborate with DFSS for locations to go to their senior centers to get a list of the senior centers so we can go there and get information to them. And the three ways we get information to seniors, most seniors have a primary care provider. You cannot be 65 and not have a health care provider. So we use our Health Alert Network to get providers to proactively reach out to their patients and say, this is necessary. You're due for XYZ. That's one pathway. Then engaging senior centers, that is collaboration with DFSS, and then faith-based outreach. So we have partners and we do engagement with houses of worship and go there to provide information, which is also another way that we get to seniors. And then our community health workers that just canvass neighborhoods and engage people as they see them. And so your budget for that outreach, because I visit a lot of churches and not that you're going to be there the Sundays I'm on there or that I'm there. when I think about when I was at the Board of Review, every time it was around for tax appeal, we would do community outreaches for tax appeals at churches, and we would hit these churches, and you knew it was coming constantly throughout many churches. And so I'm not hearing about this, and I'm connected to the church base. So what is the budget, and how many churches are you hitting? I mean, if you don't know that number, you can provide it through the chair, but just give me some. Because I'm not saying that I see, you know, other, you know, organizations with health organizations, companies trying to get people to sign on and they're showing up and they're doing that. But I don't see the city of Chicago out there at those churches. And I'm not saying out there, I probably missed it, but. You may be seeing our delegate agencies. We'll get you the information. It may not be City of Chicago staff, but our delegate agencies, our community partners, should be engaging, and we'll get you that information. We have events in all 50 wards. We have a long list of scheduled and outreach events in every ward. So we collaborate with our delegate agencies, so they may be the ones you're seeing. We have Gold Star, that is the faith-based partner. We had the day of prayer last week across many different houses of worship. But we'll get you the detailed list of the outtakes. Yeah, so just provide through the chair, you know, the delegate agencies and, you know, they should have a list of where they went, right? and provide, you know, where they went last year so I can get a good feel of, you know, how these seniors, this information is getting to the seniors. Thank you, Chairman. I appreciate it. Thank you. And your questions, Alderman? Thank you. Alderman Sposado followed by Alderman LaSpada. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Dr. Commissioner. How you doing? We've also never met, but that's really a good thing. So if we don't have to meet with you, so you have a guy, your IGA guy. So he certainly keeps us informed. So I just want to let you know that. So if I ever have to knock on your door or call you, I'm sure there's a problem. But with him here, it sure does help us a lot. And I know I'm repetitive from what the rest of my colleagues are saying, but we really appreciate them. I don't have any questions. I just want to say thanks for doing what you're doing. I'm a little bit of a bearer of bad news. Our former commissioner doctor was terrorized by a woman who just happens to be on the school board right now. I hope this same lady doesn't do this to you. Come out and protest at your house and wreak havoc upon you if you're doing something that she doesn't agree with. So with that, I just want to say best wishes to you. Keep up the good work. And we're behind you. And just keep that guy around and keep us informed. Thank you. Appreciate you. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm not sure if I ever got credit for being here for part of the quorum so if you can leave a note to the chairman I greatly appreciate it I will leave a note for the chairman thank you very much thank you so much for being with us today across the board the work that your department is doing is so integral to the health of our communities and I've benefited directly I really appreciate particularly the work that your department did on our recent COVID and flu vaccine clinic in the ward. So thank you for that. Truly, like in the interest in seeing you all be successful, the persistent vacancy rates are really concerning. And we're lower than we were a year ago. I think a year ago we were at 493 vacancies that we're carrying over. this year we're at 280 and about 41 of those look like the same titles that we saw vacant last year and as much as we're talking about departmental HR city-wide HR what what do we need to be doing to help you all staff up on these positions I think particularly around some of the mental health clinician hosts that have been vacant for a long time Thank you, Alder. We have worked really hard this year to address those issues, and there are a few things that we found. We actually did an assessment of the rejection rate when we make an offer to candidates, and they say no, thank you. We had 103 rejections this year when people say they have better offers from other places. So that's one factor. The second factor is there are some positions that are just very hard to fill, especially our clinical positions. For three years, we've been trying to hire psychiatrists and psychologists and clinical therapists, three, and public health nurses, supervisors, sanitarians, environmental engineers. For example, as psychologists, we offer about $90,000. Those psychologists can make $300,000, $400,000 in private practice. So we're not very competitive with clinical positions. So that is also something that we wrestle with. And then finally, there is just a nationwide shortage. We are part of the Big Cities Health Coalition. This trend is in pretty much every health department. Just this challenge with getting people into public health And so we are exploring creative solutions for how can we pivot our work? How can we be more attractive? We have looked at retention rates. Also, where can we do better to retain people so we're not constantly having vacancies? But those are by far the three major factors that we noticed. I appreciate that. I want to dig in for a moment where you're talking about psychologists, psychiatrists, the Clinician 3 program, because when we talk about mental health, when we talk about the care program, it doesn't work at all. If we're not able to hire for those positions, what is the solution there? Like if the solution really is that we need to offer more competitive salaries, I think council needs to hear that because there's no point listing a position if it's just for show. Like if there's not a world where we're going to be able to fill it at the salary that we're offering. we've we did an actual report with Cook County on the mapping of just the behavioral workforce and what will be necessary to fill the gap it was a collaborative efforts with Cook County Health because they're having the same problems so there's been a lot of work done to just identify what the staffing needs are to meet the needs in our city for just behavioral health workforce so there's been some thinking into, but we do know that the needs and the supply of workforce just far outstrips our ability to generate the pipeline to meet the needs. So we've begun to explore creative ways to better leverage the resources that we have. So when we talk about our Family Connects program, for instance, where we have public health nurses, can those public health nurses be trained to identify postpartum depression and connect people to services? That way, we don't need another step of a clinical therapist. Can we look at other ways that people can get mental health support? So the healing arts, for instance, we now have a collaboration with D-Case. This is now a nationally recognized program where non-therapy, non-medical options are being offered to people that have been proven to be effective. and now we have about 50 community health workers that are certified providing those services. So those are some of the strategies we're exploring to continue to meet the needs while we'll figure out how to close this workforce gap. And I know I've eaten up my time, but it matters to me. So one final lens on this. The Roseland and Pilsen clinics that we're talking about Are they fully staffed? And if so, how are we successful in staffing of those clinics? It has taken us DHR. We have biweekly meetings. We have reached out to every platform, every place where we can to get those staff on board. We have also had to make some changes. We have had to recruit clinical therapist two instead of clinical therapist one. We have had to recruit psychiatric nurses instead of psychiatric doctors or psychologists. So there are some ways that we have just explored solutions to staff these clinics. And we continue to, again, collaborate with others. sometimes it's part-time staff that we can have because they are working in three or four other locations. But those are some of the strategies we've used. But it was a lot of intensive effort, outreach. I'm posting on LinkedIn. I'm posting on Facebook. Everybody's posting in all their networks. I'm trying to get the staff. Okay. In the meantime, we'd see a reduction in the funding for the care pilot of yes i would guess around 11 what is the impact of on that of the level of service that we're able to offer through the care program um the care program right now is mostly upper funded um so it is one of the programs that's on on this short one-time covet funding um so we are continuing to be in conversation with the mayor's office about how to sustain this program. In the interim, however, we are working with the state. The state also is funding behavioral crisis response team to collaborate with them. We're working with the county. There is now a behavioral crisis hub for the city organized by UIC that we're collaborating to make sure, again, that there are no gaps and we are complementing rather than supplementing. The good news is that there is now more investment and resources in this space than ever before. So it's not just on us as the city to meet the needs, but we will continue to strategize about sustainability of the program going forward. Do I remember accurately that there is either a Medicare, I believe like a Medicaid reimbursement rate for certain forms of behavioral health intervention? That is correct. That is something that is in the works at the moment, the 1115 waiver. We do not yet have a timeline for when that will be active, but the state is moving that forward and we're very excited about the potential for reimbursement for some services. Okay. With my last two minutes, can you give us, let's say, a conservative timeline for when council won't understand the deployment plan for their air quality monitors that we've purchased and are now working on? No, the purchase is done. Calibration is done. When should we see a tentative plan for the deployment strategy? Our goal, the timeline for this to be launched was January 2025. So what is pending right now is just agreeing on the locations. So we don't expect that that timeline is going to change. We don't expect. So I feel like you just said that the timeline is still for January 2025, but we don't know where the locations are going to be. Yes, because we're waiting on advisory, the air monitor governance body to finalize where the locations will be. And the next meeting of that board has been postponed, correct? Do you think we're going to hit the January 2025 launch date? I am hopeful that we will. We are not pausing or stopping the work. Okay. My last question that I'll get in is, I did not know until we were in this committee meeting that we had a tree advisory committee because I thought, surely she's talking about the Urban Forestry Advisory Board. But there are two different things. One that seems led by Department of the Environment, the other by yourself, Streets and Sanitation doing Parkway trees, CDOT doing like arterial streets. What is the locus of collaboration where our urban forest sits? Can you explain how these different organizations and groups interface with each other? I will talk about the tree equity. I'm not as familiar with the urban forestry. I know our staff members sat on that, but I don't think it was something that was led by CDPH. The tree equity work, our staff convened that meeting, again, mostly providing technical support and convening the work, the tree equity work and the funding for that. It's a collaborative effort among many different departments, but we convened that the tree equity meeting. I can get you additional information on the urban forestry, but the tree equity is where I'm most familiar. Urban forestry, I'm aware of. If you can provide, through the chair, more details on the particular roles of the tree advisory committee, I'd appreciate it. Will do. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Cicho Lopez, followed by Alderman Robinson. Thank you. Thank you, Chairwoman. And I thank you, Commissioner, also for your efforts on the missiles vaccination and to work to reopen a desperately needed mental health clinic in our community. I appreciate all of that. My concerns in terms of the budget, right, is a significant and budget cut for a department that is critical for the city um we've seen the life expectancy uh among especially black and brown chicagoans declined significantly and i think public health is is is critical for us so uh it seems like a lot of the um cuts you know seems like a 77 77 percent for what the report of office management has is in contractual relation contractual contracts that the city has with the public health so i have some questions around that and we have had issues with procurement one of the issues also that is very important for us in environmental justice as you know i know you're sharing the responsibility with the new Department of the Environment. But does CDPH monitor the environmental requirements of the city contracts? And I know that there's been issues in the past, but I think that some of it cuts in terms of inspections and that stuff that will have significant effects in the oversight of these facilities, the polluters in particular. Thank you, Alderman. I'll start with the changes in the budget. Like all departments, we were asked for a 3% reduction, and the non-personnel cost, especially in the professional contractual services, is where we recommended a reduction. So that's what you see there. Those were areas where we feel like there might be other sources to cover the services or collaborations to cover the services to ensure there are no gaps. with regards to the procurement and our engagement there. Our work is guided by the Air Quality Ordinance of 2021. Procurement services is not within that scope at the moment. So we do not have an authority to oversee environmental issues related to procurement by the city of Chicago. We have oversight for large recycling facilities and other consequential uses, but not for procurement service. Thank you. So that's my follow-up question. So CDPH and then in some instances, the new Department of the Environment will be tasked with enforcing the city environmental ordinances. Is that correct? That is correct. Okay. Since because it's a new department, I understand that there will be shared responsibilities. I just want to make sure that things don't fall through the cracks. So let's say if a city contractor is cited for breaking an environmental law, does CDPH communicate this to procurement or will it be the Department of the Environment? How will that be communicated to the city, per se, so that there can be enforcement? So if there is an ordinance that has been violated, if we get a request from 311 to go inspect something and we go and inspect and see a violation, we will issue a citation to that organization and ask them to fix the problem. If they do not fix the problem, then it escalates, and we will notify that organization. They are not going to be able to continue until they fix the issue or they issued a fine. So those are the measures we have for enforcement fines and citations. if there is no compliance, then other measures can be taken. We inform the organization itself of those issues. If an organization has a violation with any other regulatory body, there are some things we don't regulate that IEPA regulates or US EPA regulates. They are obligated to share those violations with us, or we can actually reach out to those organizations and ask if they have violations. So we are aware. We do not currently have a process of informing the city if one of their vendors has a violation. We inform that organization directly when they have a violation and they have to comply. Otherwise, we can resort to legal means and other measures. Thank you. And what I mean, what is important, because last year there was a report of that city awarded asphalt contracts worth several hundred millions of dollars. And I think that there will have to be some kind of mechanism for, you know, the post-award documentation to make sure that there is control and oversight. So, you know, it would be possible to get commitments to have this documentation being submitted or have a protocol? Is that possible to have? Because my concern, again, is like, for instance, air monitor. Let me just give an example of that. In terms of air monitoring, right? I mean, I think that here we have at least three positions that would be maybe lost around environmental inspections, right? So my concern is what around, you know, and that's what I ask. And I know that we already asked for a meeting about air monitoring. That's something that is part of a community impact study. So that's what I'm asking, because we do have in the southwest side a serious issue with environmental pollution. This air monitoring is critical for us. So that's why, you know, it's very important that we continue with that. I know that I already requested a meeting with you to discuss that. So I'll just wait for that meeting to happen so that we can discuss the more particulars, because I want to be mindful of the time. but I do like to request through the chair that information. The other one is around the tree advisory committee. The issue with heat and extreme heat in our cities is serious and across the board. It is only going to worsen, I think, with the new administration at the federal level. So I think that with the efforts that you have with the tree advisory committee, is this included in the CDPH plan, the tree advisory committee and their plan? Is that part of the efforts? Will this continue? Yes, tree equity work is part of our work in CDPH and will continue. Heat preparedness and response is an interdepartmental activity. The Office of Emergency Management and Response is the lead for response to emergencies. So it falls within that. There are several departments that have roles. CDPH has a role in ensuring that we're monitoring data and that we are providing content to help people, vulnerable populations, protect themselves from heat. DFSS also has a role. OEMC has a role. Other departments have a role. So that's coordinated from the mayor's office right now. But we do have a city of Chicago emergency operations plan that details the different responsibilities of every department in an emergency, including the heat response. Thank you. Yeah, and just following up with the heat preparedness initiatives, and I want to commend your team and all that you've been working with DFSS, I believe, for this response. And I think the importance of collaborating, you know, and continue to expand with community partners. I know that we've been working closely. So my last point, I know that we don't have a lot of time, is around the coordination between CDPH and the new Department of the Environment around enforcement. I know that we do have, as you know, pending permits. We do have inspections that need to continue, yet a much smaller budget. And that is affecting especially this area and the budget that I can see. So a commitment to work and maybe have reports, regular reports on this heat preparedness air monitoring that is very important for us. And the coordination between the departments, I do think that is going to be critical. Given the number of need, I just look at the budget in particular. I've received several letters from advocates and medical research advocates around, there has to be an increase for mental health in terms of like air monitoring and other needs. I do think that the budget, I know there's in contractual relations, We have almost $140 million in cuts. I do think that we need to ask, that we collaborate to find within maybe the two departments another $25 million somewhere. I just think that these cuts can really hurt some of these oversight, monitoring, especially air monitoring and health-related matters. So that would be an ask, and maybe just a question, I mean, at the end is, will this be something that we can work? I know that we are certain in, you know, we have a deficit, but I do think that cutting on mental and public health, it can be costly in the long run. So that would be an ask, you know, of finding that. And again, the coordination between the Department of Health and the new department environment, making sure that these positions actually can be worked out to deliver ultimately an oversight. Thank you. Alderman Robinson, you're next, followed by Alderman Martin. And then our last speaker for the committee is Alderman Mitts. Chairwoman, thank you very much. Commissioner, good to see you. Two pieces of the puzzle here. Number one, I want to commend Alfonso on your team, as well as Mr. King, who I see in the box, to a gentleman that I regularly have conversations with that continue to do amazing things for your department. And so I just wanted to share that with you. You mentioned getting to zero, which is in 2030. What is the plan in the next five years to get there? and then also why do we continue to see decreases in HIV but increases as it relates to black gay men? Thank you Alder. So the 90-90-90 is the target that we're hoping to get to. 90% of people knowing their status, 90% of people getting connected to care, and 90% of people staying in care. And we saw we have had a steady decline over the last 40 years to a point where we had less, about 400 new HIV cases. And then COVID hit and things, you know, started to spike a little because that connection to care became broken. So our hope is that going forward, we can catch up and sustain the progress that we have made. We know now that post-exposure prophylaxis, pre-exposure prophylaxis are so important. adherence to treatment is so important. But we also know that meeting people's basic need is so important, and that's why housing, our HIV programs do not just provide HIV treatments. They provide housing. They provide support for chronic illnesses. They provide mental health support. They even address substance use needs. So these wraparound services are available, but we don't see as much engagement in some of our communities. And that's what we're trying to figure out. How do we ensure that everyone takes advantage of these services? HIV is one area where we have funding, where we have resources. So the disconnect here is not in the availability of resources, is how do we better engage our community? And so we have looked at the communities that are not as engaged, and that's how we identify the black gay men, black transgender men, where we saw an uptick in the number of new infections, how do we ensure we can get more folks engaged in getting PrEP, getting PEP, and what outreach opportunities are there. And Antonio is here. If Antonio would like to say a little more about some of the efforts that we're undertaking to just close the gap there. Thank you, Commissioner. before Mr. King speaks, can we utilize our grant money specifically for education, right? A lot of our grant money is very restrictive, particularly to black-led organizations. And so I hear what you're saying, that we need to more educate this community. are the grants and the grants are we allowed to do just that? Some grants that's not a huge pot of money like what is available for the others but we do have education activities right now we are funding 18 organizations to do education and outreach I think some of the barriers the folks who are most connected to the communities that can do that work, we have some systemic barriers because our grants are reimbursement models. You do the service and then we pay you after. So there are some organizations that would like to participate, but that is a limitation to them because they have to have the financial liquidity to be able to do the work first and then get reimbursed after the work has been done. And that's one area where we have been really brainstorming about how we can do that. There are some organizations that are coming together as coalitions, but they need that financial cover to be able to do that. Our grants don't allow us to pay people first. It is a reimbursement model. So that's one limitation that we've seen. But in terms of being able to fund organizations for outreach and education, we're able to do that. But it's a very, very small percentage of what we have. Most of what we have is for treatment and housing. Thank you. Commissioner, are we working alongside of DOH and city colleges and workforce development agencies and also county care? because what I heard you mention is that, again, we see the numbers increase, particularly in this community, and all of the one, two, three, four agencies, right, workforce, health, even education, housing, are all components of this. So are we reaching out to, again, services that we have in the city and the county for a full-on throttle wraparound services? Yes. We leverage work very closely with county for HIV, they are a primary partner in that space, and we work with Federally Qualified Health Center. We have actually explored alternative, not primary HIV funding, ELC funding, that has allowed us to redirect some funding so that we can engage federally qualified health centers to also be a part of our network from next year. So we are exploring opportunities and avenues to just meet people where they are and not just ask them come to, you know, locations that they may not be familiar or comfortable with. So county and FQHCs are some of the partners that we're working with. Great. Thank you, Commissioner. Mr. King, I have about three minutes left. Well, thank you, Alderman Robinson. Good afternoon. Antonio King, LGBTQ Health and Outreach Liaison. Good afternoon, members of the City Council. Because the highest rate of new infections of HIV is among black gay men, black trans, same-gender loving men, we have continued and continue to make our program robust and to provide more funding to our delegate agencies as well as our subcontracted agencies and community partners, such as through our community development grants for Chicago Black Gay Men's Caucus, Project Vita, some of the other agencies that are Alliance Care 360. These are agencies whose clientele are specialized in same-gender loving black men, as well as, as Dr. Ige stated, trans men and trans women. We are working on the west side with Life is Work, another agency in Alderman Midt's board, I believe it is, as well as Brave Space Alliance in the Hyde Park area and on the Project Vita on the southwest area. What we've done is, outside of the grants that these are funded through those delegate agencies, The community partners that are not part of our directly funded agencies also are eligible for innovative sponsorships, where we provide thousands of dollars for them to continue programming for outreach and testing, as well as screening for STIs through newer agencies on the West Side, such as Task Force Prevention Services on Cicero, as well as School of Opulence. These are individual agencies and programs that have a direct contact with same-gender loving black men. Mr. King, thank you very much. Commissioner, have we given any thought to working with the AIDS Foundation or Northwestern or University of Chicago, some of the large organizations that maybe can take one or two of these black-led organizations and work with them specifically around funding, right? So the funding is out, is put on the front end, and then the reimbursements on the back end. Again, my thought is that we can work alongside of some of the larger organizations that have the resources, so that way that we can, again, get to our goal of getting to zero at 2030. Thank you, Alder. I think those are opportunities for us to explore. Right now, AIDS Foundation does that. they are able to provide that financial cover. And that has been going on for a while. And that way they're able to support, I think, 18 or so organizations, give them the funding up front. And then when they get paid, they get reimbursed. We haven't yet explored Northwestern and their capacity to do that. but we can also look into if there are other organizations that are ready to provide that kind of fiscal support to the smaller organizations who are closer to the community. Thank you, Commissioner. My last question is, you do not own any of your buildings, correct, Elise? There are some of our buildings that are city-owned. Okay. Through the chair, is it possible that you can look at some funding to purchase a building? From my understanding, you need a space for your staff. And so if you look at leasing versus ownership, can you please, through the chair, look at what that cost analysis is for us, please? uh we will work with 2fm uh they they are the lead for leases and and build city buildings uh but we can get you that information in collaboration with 2fm thank you commissioner uh chairwoman thank you thank you alderman um alderman martin followed by alderman mitts and then we'll go to non-members thank you chair and good afternoon everybody wanted to follow up on alderman lesbada's line of questioning around vacancies so uh and apologies if this was shared and i missed it earlier how many um vacant positions are being proposed to be cut uh in the proposed budget from CDPH of course in the 2025 budget we have a reduction of 124 positions got it however of the corporate positions that we have because of the hiring freeze we have 17 a 77 zero vacancies under corporate that are on hold as well so 70 positions separate from the 124 that will be a part of the one it is a part of the 124 120 okay through the chair no no no I'm sorry Fakur Diwagao, First Deputy Commissioner. Alderman, we have a net reduction of 124 positions. The 70 positions, the corporate ones that are on hold with the hiring restriction are part of that 124. Understood. For those 124 positions, can you provide through the chair the duration of time that each of those positions have been vacant? and just for context what I'm interested in is getting a little bit more specificity to the point that Alderman Laspata was making about which positions are persistently vacant versus which positions are newly vacant. With the care team so I'm covered primarily by the 19th police District, a lot of our residents have been very pleased with the work of the care team. One of the frustrations, nevertheless, that they shared was that since its inception, it's generally operated just weekdays, 9 to 5, approximately 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Are you envisioning in FY 2025 expanding those hours either to go later into the evening and or into the weekend. Yes, we are looking at expanding hours and duration. Matt, do you want to give specifics? Can you hear me? Matt Richards, Deputy Commissioner for Behavioral Health. Thank you for the question, Alderman. So we did a labor analysis looking at the most efficient way to expand hours and basically the most efficient way to do it is to have two teams working four days a week in each of the districts so you would have one team working monday through thursday one working thursday through sunday that gets you seven days a week and then it extends time and field because they're only working four days rather than five so that's ultimately the plan uh that has to be balanced against expanding districts too which is another priority that we have within the constraints of our our budget so we right now uh have enough funding to essentially operate 10 teams. And so it's finding that balance between how much are we focusing on extending in the districts we're already in versus opening in new districts. Understood. So fair to say that you have not yet locked in what the potentially expanded shifts would look like in particular districts. You still want to make sure you're filling all those positions that are vacant and you'll take a look to see the best spread. Yes, sir. That's correct. Okay. Can you provide through the chair, whether since the CIT officers have left the teams, if there have been any instances in which a member of that team has been assaulted or battered by a member of the public, and then conversely, whether a member of the team is alleged to have assaulted or battered a member of the public? I do not believe that we've had any such incident. If they're concerned, if our team are on the street and they're concerned about violence, they can call for police support. And we have also worked very closely with the police when they're out on the field and they believe that there is a behavioral health component and they are able to patch us in. One of the success stories that we have for CARE is that over 1,500 people have been supported and we have not had to resort to arrest or use of force in less than one case, I believe. So I don't believe anyone has been battered or attacked in line of duty. Yeah. And to be clear, that is both members of the public. What about members of the teams themselves? That is correct. Same. Okay. So one to our knowledge. Okay, great. Shifting gears to, and this is going back over a year, there was a construction and demolition debris recycling report, an audit that the Office of Inspector General conducted. It found, again, this is over a year ago, that since 2018, CDPH did not have any personnel dedicated to monitoring commercial and demolition projects. Has that changed in terms of what you are proposing in FY 2025, will there be any employees who spend at least part of their time monitoring this projects that is correct i believe we have one staff position for that now okay and is that one position is that part of their overall responsibility or their sole responsibility their sole responsibility okay um the same audit also found that the city had not created a construction and demolition debris management fund, which was required previously by the Environmental Protection and Control Ordinance, has that fund been created? Yes. And how much money approximately do you anticipate the fund will bring in in FY 2025? $500,000. $500,000. So, and would it be fair to say that that is anticipated based in part on that one position and the work that that individual would be conducting? That is correct. Have you given any thought to whether that position, which presumably earns fewer than $500,000 with salary and benefits, should be expanded in numbers? Because I'm thinking, my math is right, that if we added even just a few more, that could bring in perhaps a million or $2 million in additional revenue. That is correct. Our Office of Environmental Permitting and Inspection needs a lot more hands to be able to meet the needs, including the construction and debris management. We also do have challenges feeling for supervising level staff there, especially environmental engineers, but we have required a lot more people than we have now to be able to meet the demand. And that's something that we've been in conversation with the mayor's office on. We are excited that this year we have an additional six positions within our budget for environmental, the Office of Environmental Inspection and Permitting. So we are happy with the progress that we've made there. But will any of those additional people focus on commercial and demolition? debris? Not solely, just the one. Have you given thought to whether you should have more than one position that could, if the numbers hold, bring in more revenue than it would cost to compensate them? We can look into it. Our Office of Environmental Permitting and Inspection is considered revenue generating, but we can compare the differences in the revenue potential across the different streams of work that one position is it currently filled uh yes okay i i think that would be good both in this instance and just generally we're obviously looking under the couch cushions for revenue and if we have positions that are few in number but mighty in terms of the amount of resources they're bringing in i think it would be good for your team to consider um where we could responsibly add numbers. Lastly, in March of this year, there was an advisory that the inspector general's office put out involving the city's complaint-based approach to providing services. So obviously a big advisory. One of the things they found was that per IDPH, Chicago was the only jurisdiction in Illinois that failed to comply with the state's inspection frequency and that the department, CDPH, is required to submit a corrective plan to IDPH. Approximately when was the most recent corrective plan submitted and what was IDPH's response? The corrective plan requires hiring a lot more than we have right now. We get about 5,000 requests for environmental inspections a year, and we process about 2,000 permits. And we also have to be on site doing environmentally complex demolitions and also review permits. Uh, so the workload per person right now is huge and our ability to, to balance all of that requires almost triple what, what we have at the moment. So we've been in conversation with mayor's office and office of budget. i'm so sorry i'm going to interrupt you and just ask through the chair if you could provide a summary of um what idph's response was to your proposed plan and then if you can also provide how many sanitary positions are currently budgeted and which of those uh are vacant for fy 2025 thank you okay thank you um alderman mitts are there other aldermen that would like to speak before we i got you in the next group okay alderman cruise followed by alderman cruise alderman mitts and then alderman cruise thank you madam chairman and good afternoon commissioner you over this way mm-hmm Let me just start off by saying thank you for coming out to a community meeting and visiting with the community, giving us a shock of our lifetime. So now you can just tell me I never could pronounce the name of that drug that affected the West Side where we all met. I never could. I would try to explain it to someone, but I don't know the name of it. So just tell me now how we're looking in terms of slowing down that particular drug, that particular one that's coming into the neighborhood. Thank you, Older Meade. And you can pronounce it if you know how to pronounce it. Yes, it's methidone. We found that. You all got that methidone-edine? Yes. Yes, we found metidomidin for the first time this year circulating in the West. And we are very happy to say that the numbers has declined. We haven't seen any more of that in the last month or so. There are other ones, nitazine, that we've started to see that we're also working very hard with our intergovernmental task force. What's not to do, and if you can give me just a little snapshot of what it do different from? Yes, these are all animal tranquilizers. They are synthetic drugs. They are just cooked up in the laboratories and pushed into the supply chain. So because we have a community drug surveillance system where we just continue to check what is in the supply, We keep detecting all the new synthetic drugs that are infiltrating our city. And once we detect that, we can mount a response and send out the alert. And we're excited that we're able to control methadone. And now we're looking at what we can do different for the other adulterants. So then you're working close with the fire departments and the paramedics. when the overdose take place? Yes, we're working. We work very closely with FIRE, making sure that when there is an overdose, there is reversal. And then when people are taken to the emergency department, we are working now to ensure that they get the treatment. This can help reduce withdrawal, reduce craving, and reduce, you know, increase the opportunity for recovery. Because what we're seeing is that people can overdose multiple times because of the craving. So there's medication now that is available that can help reduce the craving and ensuring that people are introduced on that medication is what we're working on now. And we have seen an increase in the use of that medication, which is why we're now seeing almost 50% reduction in death and 23% reduction in overdose. But we want to bring the number down further, and we're working with FIRE and our hospital partners. And I know you're working with a lot of the organization out on the west side to make sure that they're educated. So maybe that is helping as well. Do you have a number in terms of inspections that's been done in terms from the health department? or this year, what's your number? How many inspections? We have our one pages that show the inspections that have been done in each ward, but total number, if you say food inspection, it will be around 15,000 is where we are. I will look up the number for your ward. Now, when they do the food inspection, are you giving a citation that they have to pay? Yes, we have numbers. What's the dollar amount for the city for 2024? We will check that. We track how much income we generate. Again, it doesn't come to CDC, it goes to the city, but we can get those numbers for you. Yeah, I would like to know what those numbers are, if you don't mind. As we're looking to try to find ways to balance the budget, all cards are on the table here. So we're just looking at that. In terms of a virus, can you tell me what virus that is running rapid now? What virus is it that the highest hospitalization, I don't know if that was asked earlier before I came in, but I just, I had to step out. Yes, it is still COVID. That is the number one cause of hospitalization followed by flu. It started to tick up around June. It's on the downward now, so we're happy about that. And we're happy to say at least 30% of our seniors have gotten their vaccines. So we want that number to be towards 70%. So we have a number of vaccination clinics, about 200 scheduled before the end of the year to get the numbers up. And things are moving along. Dr. Sloboda? Hello? Yes. Hi, I'm Dr. Alex Sloboda. I'm the medical director of immunizations and emergency preparedness for CDPH. and so yeah we've scheduled or have completed over 200 vaccination events throughout the city of Chicago including 47 wards so far so thank you all for working with us to put on those ward events they've been very successful and we've also at those ward events we've had an increase in vaccination compared to last year which we're really excited about at the ward events it's a 12 percent increase in doses compared to last year and overall for all of our events and a 20 percent increase so we're we're really excited about that was there another specific question or that's that's all it's mostly covid and flu that are the major causes of hospitalization so we want people to get both and we're very um excited to see that the numbers are much better this year than last year? I just feel that there's still a lot of the covert that's still running out here. And I don't hear enough of preventing the covert. So I don't know, is it something I'm missing? Or if it's more of an educational again? that we need to be pushing on this. But is there a certain time you wear your mask again, when the pee come up? Yes. We continue to encourage people to wear their masks, especially if they're 65 and older, and if they're going to be going into a crowded space indoors, and if they have chronic illnesses. High blood pressure and diabetes are the commonest co-morbidities that have led to increased hospitalization. So we encourage folks who are at a higher risk of severe illness to continue to wear their masks if they're going to be in places that are crowded. Vaccination continues to be the most effective tool. I keep telling people that, you know, there was a time where we were seeing 800 deaths and over the last month or so, we haven't had any deaths from COVID. And that is because there is higher level of protection now. and immunity. So we don't want to take our eyes off of that and go back. Let me get to another question. I'm watching the clock. The flood that happened in my community, and we talked to you about this when we came out and told you it was a health issue. Have you visited any of those homes or anyone from your department visit anyone out there? In fact, you got a young lady in the hospital now that a lungs collapse last week just from mold still being in the homes, and that is a health issue. Yes. Thank you, older woman. Yes, I did follow up on that. The Department of Buildings, I believe, got an additional $1 million to respond to the mold issues. I believe they will have some detail on if that work has already begun. And our work in CDPH, we now, through city funding, now have opportunity to also address mold as well as lead. So we are primarily in the lead remediation space, but additional funding from the city now allows us to do more than lead when we're in homes. So that will start next. That stays in the budget. So we're going to work together so we can see how we can bring these departments because it seems like people are working in different spaces and it's not coming together as a whole for the community. So if you don't mind working with me and let's see what we can do. Thank you, Madam Chairman. I didn't want to run up my time, but I had to get that part in. Thank you. And thank you all for all your work you're doing. Keep up the work. Thank you. Audemann Vasquez. Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Thank you so much for being here. In order to make the most of the time, I'm just going to go into questions. Thank you. Okay. So a comparison of payroll data and the 2024 budget shows that inspections and permitting was allocated 26 full-time positions. As of September, nine of them are vacant. One attorney, six environmental engineers, a senior environmental inspector, and a supervising environmental inspector. Roughly one in three positions allocated for environmental inspections and permitting aren't filled right now. What is preventing it from being fully staffed? It has been quite challenging to get accepted offers. We have interviewed, we have made offers, offers have been rejected, environmental attorneys, supervising sanitarians, their salary compression issues. We are working with the Department of Human Resources for what we can do different, but these are positions that are, they are on a list of our hard-to-feel positions that we're working with DHR on the way. So to understand it, it's basically competitive and we're not, we're not competitive with the market. That is correct. Okay. Last year, the city awarded asphalt contracts worth several hundred million dollars. Those contracts specifically allow the commissioner for public health to request post-award documentation from the winning vendors, including a traffic study, an air quality impact study, a fugitive emissions control plan for continuous fence line monitoring of pollution. But according to local reporting, they have not been requested as far as that post-award documentation. It seems like this might be an easy way for the city to get important data about the environmental impact of the city projects and it's also budget neutral with the cost of the studies paid by vendors that won multi-million dollar contracts uh can you discuss why the department hasn't requested this documentation from the winning vendors and if you commit to working with us to formally request that documentation i i will follow up on that and get details to the best of my knowledge cdp does not have authority to to request those documents but if there is documentation saying that we're required to then i will follow up on that it was before my time but i will look into yeah i think I think a follow up to that is if it is the case that you're not able to request it, then who is, if there is the porcelain word documentation, because we want to make sure that a lot of folks who are getting all the city money are being held accountable to results as well. So yeah, if you could send that, that'd be greatly appreciated. Okay. As the pilot care teams are being provisioned, how are they being connected to the coordinated entry system for unhoused people currently? and what is the plan to train and engage them with the one system initiative as these mental health first responders are sure to interact with many unhoused people in the regular course of their work so for example in the 40th ward we're doing a conversion to create non-congregate shelter on lincoln and when we were told about the process it's the cares team that they're going to interact with um and similarly as we're moving to one system initiative like how are they going to be brought up to speed as to what that's going to look like. Yes. So our team, behavioral health team is closely connected to all of those. We call them resources and support services. So when we interact with people during our outreach, many of them need housing or shelter. The way the shelter system works right now, if someone requires shelter, they have to go into the coordinated entry and be on the wait list. So our teams are trained to refer people to whatever local services are available. There are some services that are not connected to coordinated entry. Most are. And so we refer them to how they can get shelter. If they're available beds in anywhere, we will refer them there. But many times there are no available beds and they have to go in through the coordinated entry and be on the wait list there. So they are they are in tune with how the systems work. I appreciate you saying that because I think something that's probably for another department that we're going to ask is we've got the funding for beds and that's only 6,800 beds and then we're going to do rapid rehousing but if the beds are maxed out where do we rapid rehousing to and I think I appreciate that that's kind of some of the challenge you're seeing as well. So next one I've asked this before and there hasn't seemed to have been a lot of movement on it. If a city contractor is cited for breaking an environmental law how does cdph communicate that to the department of procurement services uh can you like how do they how are they basically held accountable right if you got to talk to procurement um what does that look like and why we haven't collected money from people that have been violating on those because it is revenue and also we want to curb that behavior um this is one area we will we will discuss with the department of procurement services it's not been a part of the scope of our work in the past overseeing or regulating contractors to the city but we will look that's come up also older sicho lopez has also flagged that and we will look into that and and see where there might be opportunities for us to collaborate yeah i think the challenge there is we asked this question last year we still haven't gotten a response and so asking it this year and say we're going to look into it like what i don't want is coming back next year saying we're going to look into it some more who's the person to contact who's the best person to hold accountable that would be the one that would then reach out to procurement is there someone on the team who would be like the point for that um i believe the the transition in leadership might have contributed to that now we have a commissioner in cdph and there is a commissioner in in dps and i will follow up okay yeah and we will follow up with both because i think sometimes of just syncing everybody together. Okay. There was a CDPH staffer who presented last week at the City's Advisory Board of Health around CDPH's highly anticipated air monitoring plan. There was some contentious discussion with Pastor Smith on the board who did not see this as a useful focus of the CDPH's resources. Since that meeting, this employee no longer works for CDPH and I guess it is rumored that Pastor Smith will be elevated to the board's new president. Does CDPH consider this air monitoring project a necessary use of city funds, and will you be proceeding with this project that environmental justice groups are relying on? That is correct. The air monitoring work will continue, and we will assign staff to ensure that the work continues. Okay. The other thing we'd like to know is who the language access coordinator is for the department to provide a breakdown on language access services used in 2024 as well as plan for 2025 we've been doing work just across the city trying to get language access improved it is abysmal even though we've got the language line contract which i think hasn't been fully re-signed and so just wanted to know what the plan is for cdph knowing that we're talking about communities on the southeast side for example where you're going to need spanish translation to get more information so what's the plan for language access The language access line is coordinated by our public information officer. That's the central coordinator. But we're very proud to say that 33% of CIDs' PH staff speak Spanish. Over 36 languages are spoken. So in all of our clinics, they're Spanish speakers. So we haven't had to depend on that as much. But we have it as a resource, and it's coordinated by a public information officer. but our communication team also includes a number of spanish speakers and then um yeah if you get through the chair also give a breakdown like you mentioned 36 languages and kind of percentages i think knowing that would be really helpful because some departments don't have that much and so to know that this is actually a really good thing um how does cdph plan to continue to expand its efforts around addressing the issue of extreme heat and urban heat urban heat islands in chicago we have pending legislation for outdoor workers that seems more pressing to get passed now especially given the election results and knowing that there's maybe not the emphasis needed on the environment and with the incoming administration would you support passage of legislation that would support the outdoor workers and is there a plan for like addressing some of the extreme heat and urban heat islands in Chicago yes we've been working very closely with the CDC around the impact of heat on health. So we have robust data. We also have partnered with L.O.V. Chicago to document the impacts and recommendations from communities about what options there are. I believe the operational implications and the resources that are necessary for us to fully live into that is where we need to really better articulate how do we mobilize the resources that we need to make this happen. But in terms of the impact of heat and the work that needs to be done to protect our community, we have been at the forefront of that for many years collecting the data. The resources that are necessary to start implementing those recommendations is where we need to explore options. Okay, thank you. And last question I have, and I'm sure it's been asked before, but I think through the chair is kind of what would be helpful to us is the department's largely grant funded. I mean, we all know that this incoming administration, if it was looking to attack, for lack of a better word, it would gut funding across the board. And so any information you could provide to us that's funding, that's programmatic, that's policy-wise, that we can start looking at in advance of what could be coming would be extremely helpful. I'm also very concerned about any data or identity collection that the department might have if the federal government decides to start moving. So any protections that you all would recommend, if you could send to the chair um we greatly appreciate it thank you so much thank you uh thank you share one thank you um our non-members alderman taylor followed by alderman hoppenworth and alderman bill and alderman cruz thank you chairwoman um i heard you say that the COVID numbers went back up and then they're slowly going down. I didn't, there was nothing sent to our offices. I didn't see on TV. None of that happened. I'm gonna say to you what I said to Dr. Awadi. I do appreciate the work that you do. Sometimes it ain't about being vaccinated. Sometimes it's about how do we eat healthy, things that we could eat, things that we could take. Medicine is very expensive. And so I want to see you all do a better job and use the access to the advertisement, the TV, because Dr. Awadi during COVID was on TV every day. And I said to her the exact same thing. And I'm going to challenge you that on every budget about us talking about not just being vaccinated, us talking about being healthier, us taking care of ourselves in a better way. Because there are plenty of people in our communities that are not going to get vaccinated. They're just not. And so how are we teaching them to take care of themselves? I never saw the mask mandate go back in. And so I don't want us to get away from, because we're not on COVID punishment, and that's just what I call it, that we're still not being COVID conscious. Can you talk about that? Yes. COVID funding allowed us to do a lot of work. If we had the same kind of funding for all of our programs, we will have seen a lot of progress. COVID funding is very restrictive to COVID. You can only talk about COVID and you can only talk about. So these are some of the restrictions that come with federal dollars. Chronic disease, like we have identified, is the primary cause of death in Chicago. And that's related to food and access to health services. Right now, grants funding does not include anything that allows us to do chronic disease prevention writ large. So these are some of the limitations we have. We are looking at how we can do a better job engaging. and one of the opportunities we're exploring now is collaboration with a network of health service providers. They are doing food as medicine, and what we are doing is providing them data. These are the communities that we want you to focus on based on the data that we have. There are state partners that are now being contracted to work on health equity. We are sharing data with them and say these are the communities that are most impacted. They're not giving us the funding, but we are contributing, helping them to prioritize how communities can get better access to food and get better access to physical activity and get connected to the services that they need. So it is true. We need to do more than talk about vaccination. And the reason we have just talked about vaccination is because those are the requirements of the federal funding that we have. So the requirements say you have to push the vaccination and nothing else? that we can use funding to educate around vaccination and COVID prevention writ large. And our COVID prevention strategies include masks and washing your hands and other clean air, etc. But vaccination continues to be the number one way to protect communities. At some point, I want to have a conversation with you about us just pushing medicine and vaccination, because that's not working for a lot of people. You wind up on the medicine 20, 30 years and nothing changes your body. I'm not going to be the dead horse about the HIV, but are you all noticing that the number of black women, the HIV numbers are going up? And can you give us that war by war? Same thing with the COVID numbers. I want to see war by war, the COVID numbers and COVID deaths. Yes. We don't, we, we never kind of unpack that during COVID time. And I know now we're starting to see more people go back into the hospital because of COVID. My other question is, how are you all working with the EPA to hold the railroads accountable? I probably got one, two, three, four railroad land takeovers in my ward. And I'm starting to see the number of bronchitis and asthma go up and folks who live around that. How are you all holding them accountable? Because what we have is trucks that idle down the streets. So literally the railroad is by a school. They literally have trucks who idle for hours in the street. That's polluting the air. You have trains in that same community that idle in our community and are polluting the air. And there has never been. And I had this problem with Awadi. And I hope I don't have it with you, that there is no accountability. There is no talking to nobody. And I'm literally told I got to go to the feds. That ain't my job. I work for the city, and I want to be able to work with you all to say how are we holding them accountable, how are we making sure that their trucks are not lining up our streets and just idling for hours until they can check in. And I ain't telling you what I think because I don't live too far from it. I'm telling you what I know. Emissions from transportation, I believe, is one of the areas that we identified as contributing to the environmental impact. So we have been working with the Department of Transportation, Department of Environment around what the recommendations can be for the city in terms of regulatory authority. The environment right now, it is the National Ambient Air Quality Standards is set at the national level. States are required to comply and then cities are required to comply. So the Department of Transportation will oversee transportation-related. We oversee industry-related, like large recycling plants. But we have been part of the conversation in terms of documenting the impact of all of these emissions. And then the next step is what policies need to be enacted to hold folks accountable. We can't hold people accountable without the policy. There has to be the policy first, and then we then go and enforce the policy. But for transportation, it will be the Department of Transportation. So I'm going to challenge them. As a matter of fact, I'm going to put you all both on the email because their recommendation to me was to take money out of my menu to put signs on those streets to tell trucks, You can't idle down these residential streets. So I'm going to take money that I can get my sidewalks done. I'm going to get my streets done to say that you can't idle your trucks here. That doesn't seem fair to me and my community. CDPH needs to take responsibility along with CDOT to have some type of regulations and to work and say, what's the ordinance? What's the work that we're doing to hold them accountable? Because I'm not doing that. I'm just not. And they get more money through the federal government. I wasn't in office when Norfolk Sutherland took over Inglewood. But now I'm dealing with what we didn't take care of. And so they're not holding, they're not even making sure that they follow the RDA. And so who helps me hold them accountable? Because that last administration did nothing. And I'm just, I don't want to call nobody out, but I will. And so I don't want to be in a position where I got to answer to my community about why the trucks get to do this, why the trucks get to do that. can you through the chair look at the last four years of bronchitis and asthma cases war by war that have went up since forever because they've been there longer than I have and they continue to expand which I have no say so in it so it's funny they're allowed to expand and take over communities but then when it comes to accountability of the community getting sick I'm left holding the bag STIs and senior buildings how are you all working with, I got 18 senior buildings. I had 22. And the one thing that I know for sure is the STI numbers are very high. How you are working with automatic offices and senior buildings to make sure that we're talking to seniors about using protection? I will follow up with you on that. We get notification of infections that are occurring in the city. And so we will look into the data and see what is going on there and work with your ward on how we can address that. So through the chair, I would like to see the number of STI per boards that we're kind of looking at because those numbers, according to, I want to say the dashboard that I'm looking at, during the summertime, they seem to be very high. Then in the winter, they seem to be very low. But I want to talk about how we're educating. How do you all deal with businesses who sell food who aren't supposed to and the community gets sick? How do you all coordinate with BACP? We get reports through routes, 311. If we get a complaint, we are obligated to go out and check it out and see what is going on. There are standards for mobile food. Um, when those standards are not met, BACP and us can go out and enforce, um, folks are not supposed to be selling hot food or cooked food that is not prepackaged to reduce the impact of contamination. And if that is going on, then BACP or us can go out and, you know, enforce that. So there are standards for pushcars. There are standards for mobile vending when it comes to food. Now, if there are foodborne outbreaks, we also investigate to find out the source. Sometimes it is food vendors, and that also we investigate and respond. You all need to do a better job to go out with BACP at those vendors that set up. They don't have editor's license. They're selling food. and then you got a community full of folks that are sick because they don't have access to running water or they are selling food that they're not supposed to be selling. Thank you, Chairwoman. Thank you. Auderman Lawson, do you have questions? I'll be brief. Thank you very much. And actually, I just want to piggyback on what Alderman Taylor was saying. We have an issue that we've been working with CDPH, BACP, Fire and Police, people who have never been licensed and can't be for the food operations, and they're just cooking on the street. with, and I introduced an ordinance actually last week to go after the propane, which may be the most dangerous. In addition to salmonella, of course, a propane tank exploding is a real problem. So we need your help on that because people are going to get sick, people are going to get injured, and it's a citywide issue, clearly. Most of my questions have been asked and answered. I'm a proponent of LGBT health, obviously, and I want to thank Antonio and all the work that you guys are doing there. I really wanted to thank you, though, Dr. Ige. you and I were at Getting to Zero 2.0 together. And I had never heard you speak maybe on HIV or speak so passionately. And I really appreciated your remarks, your experience in this field. Maybe just, again, this will be my only question. Talk a little bit about 2.0, what that looks like, how that's being impacted in our budget and our partnership with the state and the county. Yes, it's one of the most exciting areas of my work. Just the thought that we can actually get to zero in my lifetime. It is quite emotional for me. And we know that it is now possible because now we have less than 600 new HIV cases. And our hope is to get that number to zero. So we have been working with state and county very closely to better deploy the resources that we have. One thing that is innovative is not just looking at those who are living with HIV, but those who are vulnerable to HIV and making sure that it is wrapped around. The concept of syndemic started with HIV. We're not just looking at HIV alone, but all of the other social factors that can impact people. So this is where we want to concentrate our effort. I've challenged my team. We have to get to zero. We want to be able to do that in a way that is equitable. So we are working with our partners to see where can we do better. So we're open to feedback, you know, from you, Alderman, where are there opportunities for us to collaborate and do an even better job? But we must get to zero. And now we can see the light at the end of the ton. Thank you. I appreciate it. That's it, Madam Vice Chair. Thank you, Alderman Lawson. Next, we are going to have Alderman Manah Hoppenworth. Thank you, Chair. Oh, hold on one second. Can you hold her time for a second? Go ahead. I just want to make a correction on record about the mold remediation. It is not in the Department of Buildings. That information will be provided about the department that is leading the work. Say that one more time. Do you know which department? It's department. Mayors, IGA will provide that information. Jen Vitus. Yes, we also do some mold work. Jen Vitus, when will that start? I'm Jen Vitus, Deputy Commissioner, Chief Program Officer at CDPH. The question is about work we're doing with respect to mold. Yes. So the department has funding, well, it's through our lead poisoning prevention, and Health Prevention Early Childhood and Healthy Homes Program. And we've got a mix of funding from HUD. It's largely responding to reported cases of lead poisoning in children. But when we have reports of those cases or when we have community members reach out to us because they have concerns about lead and other health hazards in their home, if they're eligible for the funding that we have available from HUD, from HUD, excuse me, and now expanded funding that we have, thanks to city council and to the administration through bond funding, we are able to do pretty extensive work in homes that addresses not just lead hazards that may be found there, but mold and other health hazards in the home. Yes. So the difference is that CDPHR entry point is lead, but if there is mold as well as lead, we're able to support. Is that correct, Jen? That's correct. Thank you. Alderwoman Mitts. Yes, thank you. Can we have that information? Now you all know I'm very serious about this. And I don't want to be playing. We got some money mess around. We have people in my community who are dying. I don't need to be playing around from one department to the other. I just want to get the money together so that we can help folks. We will work with you. You all have reached out to me for that. We'll do. Thank you. Alderman Manaha Benworth. Thank you, Vice Chair. Hi, Commissioner. I had a question about the CARES program. Is it still a pilot? I will not describe it as a pilot. We tested this model. We know that it works. So it is the concept is proven. We are testing out a new model, which is public health-led model, which is a different expression of the work that we've done in the last two years. So in some way, it is a new expression of the work, but it is no longer a concept that needs to be proven or a pilot in the traditional sense. Okay. And that was funded through ARPA? That's correct. And so this new program will not be funded by ARPA? We are working on what the pathways for sustainability will be. Right now, the program is on ARPA until 2026. I do want to say that I support the program, but we're in Edgewater, 48th Ward. So it's wedged between two communities that receive access to the program as it is right now. So we don't get it. We have a lot of need in our area. And so I would like to see it expanded. And I was just curious about the movement forward for that. Right. One of the options that we are exploring with this new model is a citywide team. So some districts may be able to have dedicated teams if they have high numbers of 911 calls, but the rest of the city will have a citywide team and that way we can serve the entire city and no longer just be restricted to a few districts. Thanks. In addition to the mental health needs that we have in our ward, we also have issues around substance abuse. So I was curious to know, related to the opioid and settlement funds. Guys, can we just have you quiet down just a little bit? Thank you. Thank you. Related to the opioid and settlement funds, how are you all doing to meet your objectives and how are you measuring success? Yes. So we want to harm reduction and prevent overdoses, especially death from overdoses is one of our core goals. And to do that, overdose reversal, naloxone, just making sure the city is saturated with that. So all public libraries, we have vending machines, all schools, community partners, all demonic offices. Whoever wants naloxone, we want them to be able to get it. And in some communities where numbers are high, we're actually doing door-to-door distribution. So that's our main strategy. The second main strategy is the medication for over substance use disorder. That medication is available through telemedicine. You don't need to go into a hospital. You just need to call the number and it will be delivered to you. And the numbers there has been low. So we've been really educating about this option. What this medication does is reduce withdrawal and reduce craving. So we want people to use it. So that's the second strategy. And then the third strategy is just education, education, education, letting people know what a substance use disorder is. It alters your ability to self-regulate. So folks need support and need treatment and encouraging loved ones, family members to ask for help. We have a number. We have a hotline. If there are folks who need our support, please call us and we will respond. Thank you. And we are an aldermanic office that participates in the NARCAN program. So thank you for that. Um, related to, um, staffing adjustments for expanded, you all do so much, um, with increased funding for mental health and community response program, there are expansions in associated staffing. How are you balancing the need for additional staff with budget constraints? And are there plans to explore, um, more partnerships as, as a cost effective alternative? how does that work for you? Yes, this is our primary strategy for sustainability. Again, we were very aware that this is one-time funding. This is not recurrent funding. So part of our sustainability plan from the get-go is building partnerships to ensure that these programs or services can continue to be available. And we're doing that for violence prevention, collaborating with county. We're doing that for mental health. There's now more federal infusion of funding. There's county. We're collaborating with county. We have regular meetings now to coordinate. We're doing that for opioid prevention. We have an intergovernmental task force. We're doing that for behavioral crisis response. There's now a behavioral crisis hub. So we are working to synergize and again, making it clear that this responsibility should not just be on the city of Chicago. We need all tiers of government to support this work. And so that is the work that we're doing right now to ensure that our community continues to get services even after COVID-era funding expires. Thank you for that. I appreciate it. And does that also include the violence prevention? Does that also include gun violence prevention? That is correct. Because we've had such a high number of incidents of gun violence associated with our youth around our schools. And so I appreciate the work around that. I had one more question about, we talked a lot about enforcement. So I was just curious, how much of your work is around enforcement related to environmental issues? A lot of our work. I have numbers for the inspections that we do, but we get a lot of 311 requests. to date more than 7,500 requests for environmental or food-related inspections. So it is a huge part of our work. So sometimes we go out and there is violation and we issue citations. We will get you the numbers of how much revenue we get from that. But enforcement is a huge part of our work for both food and environment. In environment, the issues relate to emissions or chemical or radiological hazards, but emissions is really where people are most worried about, especially dust and that's particulate matter oversight. So that's a huge part of our work. I'm just wondering, and I don't know where this conversation could happen because I feel like it needs a little bit more attention. How much of your work can be shared with our new Department of Environment? because i i feel like i've heard several times today that you're having trouble filling really important roles towards this end of uh you know enforcement and i i need to look into the history of the department of environment but i just can you speak a little bit on that like is this a new thing for your department that you've taken on? It is not a new thing. There is environmental public health, and environmental public health is focused on environmental hazards that have a public health impact, lead, asbestos, air pollution, et cetera. That's a part of public health work and part of our accreditation requirement. The Department of Health Environment, I believe there is a plan now and the scope of the work we work very closely is being defined. But currently, oversight of public health-related hazards, food, air, environmental hazards, falls within CDPH. The challenge we have recruiting is also the general challenge we have with the healthcare workforce and public health workforce. Those who are inspectors are environmental engineers. It is a secondary degree. A lot of certification is required. We have looked at different opportunities for how we can recruit people and retain people. Compensation is one of our biggest barriers. There are salary compression issues, there are retention issues. Yes, I remember hearing about that earlier. So it's been a longstanding problem. I hope we can consider as a city, like how to spread the work. It's a very important thing. You know, enforcement is very important. It's important for the health of everyone. And if we have these, like you say, we have these policies, but we're not able to enforce them, that's our failure. And that's 80% of the time that policies fail is because we can't actually implement them. And it sounds to me that we're not able to do that because we're always short on staff. And so I just wonder if it's just a marketing thing. What if it was marketed through a different department, but it's the same work? I don't know. I just want to appreciate you and your work. You all do so much around mental health, around substance abuse, you know, around the environment. It's a lot. And I am worried, as many of my neighbors are, about what's going to happen in the next four years under a new president, what kind of regulations are going to be lifted. And so I just call upon you to work with us to figure out ways that we can show the city that we are working together to protect everyone, including the rights of living in a community that has clean air, water. So please, I hope that we can continue to work together. Thank you. Thanks, Chair. Thank you, Alderman Manaha Benworth. I just have a couple of follow-up questions to chime in here. um Dr. Ige you mentioned regarding the the care program um that we're working towards citywide coverage um do you do we think we're gonna arrive to that place in 2025 I know that the pilot was in certain areas and I know that we're we're growing that at this point obviously the um the wards or the districts that have the most nature have the most consistent care but uh like Alderman Manahop and Worth my I I don't necessarily live in one of those areas I know that there are several us that sort of fall into this category where our problems are not severe enough or frequent enough that those resources are super readily available so i'm curious about the timing for citywide coverage yes we are hoping to roll that out by 2025 january um our staff have been hired we have 10 teams now they are completing their trainings and we hope that we'll be able to launch in in january great thank you um and then you mentioned requests from 311 for inspections um did you say 7500 yes that's so far this year that's this year okay um what's the do you and through the chair is fine but what's the average time from like receipt of the 311 report to actual inspection um i guess it depends on the yes um most of our environmental um inspections will we respond within two days, but 88% of our 311 requests will respond within seven days. There are some requests that are harder to respond to, like the volume of the mobile or push card. They are a lot. So those take us much longer to get to just because of the volume of other requests that we have to deal with. So we're working with BACP on how to accelerate response times there or where we can collaborate like older women have been worth talking about. Because the demand for service is quite high and the staffing that we have, there are so many different. It's challenging. I know that across every department. I wasn't here earlier, so I apologize if this has already been asked. anybody asked for uh through the chair a list of violations by ward with citation dollars that have been collected uh we can get that information i will uh by ward we can we can track by ward yes yeah through the chair would be great um and then i'll go to our last two questions alderman beal and then alderman screws thank you madam chair i just got a couple of questions uh before i start i just wanted to also thank you for coming out we did do an outreach um covet um expo service fair out in my ward and uh you graced us with your presence i appreciate that it was a great event and uh we a lot of people got some shots that day so and i was one of them so thank you all right um You know, this predates you, but I want to see if you can kind of research and maybe reevaluate the permit that was denied for political reasons for the recycling facility out in the far south side. I think that right now the city of Chicago has an exposure of about maybe close to probably 400 million dollars worth of lawsuits that we could potentially be exposed for. Because we played politics with a company that spent 100 million dollars for a recycling facility on the on the far south side. and they spent 10 extra million under the direction of the city of Chicago at the time. Again, this was predating you. This is the past administration. But this company spent $10 million extra because they wanted to go above and beyond what the requirements were to make sure that their building was environmentally safe as far as emissions and everything else. and they followed the lead of the law department. They followed the lead of the department. They did all the right permitting. They did everything right. But then at the 12th hour, they were denied for political reasons. And I think it's going through the court process, but your department was the one that denied it, and I'm asking you to look into it and review it because eventually we're going to lose that lawsuit and they're going to come back and they're going to sue the city and they're going to win and we're going to be on the hook for probably $400 million for political reasons. And so I'm asking you to go back, review it, and look at it and do the right thing and minimize the exposure that we're going to have Because at the end of the day, it's going to come to this body, and we're going to have to sign off on a new bond to pay a huge lawsuit that we could have, it could have been avoided. But the past administration saw fit to play politics right before an election to deny that permit. And I think it's wrong, and I think we're going to be exposed. and hopefully you can look at it and again, review it and see if you can minimize the exposure because I'm warning everybody in this body right now, we're going to be on the hook for over $400 million if we don't do something right now and settle and minimize the damages. So that's all I have for you, but thank you so much. And I appreciate everything that you all are doing to help continue to keep our city healthy. Thank you. Thanks Alderman Beal. we're going to go to uh alderman cruz and then we're going to wrap up with alderman hall if there are no other speakers alderman cruz thank you vice chair um i want to start off by giving a special shout out to somebody who is always from your department willing to help us he goes above and beyond to troubleshoot and that's alfonso so we always can i say he's my lifeline i can always call him and he is always a great of service. Something that, you know, I want to bring up to your attention and really share my sentiments and my disappointment with your department is when we encounter a mental health situation in my ward, I was at a point begging for assistance. and it wasn't to be there to provide information about an individual. It wasn't to do anything besides really listening and being there for my community, community who had been asking for help regarding the situation for quite some time already. And again, it was just disappointing that I was just begging for one of your staffers to be there. Eventually, we were able to get someone and she was wonderful. She was what we were looking for. Somebody who had the experience, somebody who can talk to the community, explain how complex the situation was. But again, it took a lot. It took a lot for us to get there. And, you know, when we talk about mental health, it's not only the individual who is unfortunately going through, but also affects the community. Until this day, we don't have a solution. and to this day the situation is still happening. I sent an email a couple months ago, about two months ago to be exact. The response was, we'll get to you by the end of the week. It never happened. Two months later, I still haven't heard back. But I hope those things changes. And to my point about mental health, let me ask you this. I know there's a proposed budget allocating $20.18 million for mental health. Could an increase in the funding allow the department to further expand beyond the current seven-city-run clinics and offer accessible trauma-informed services in neighborhoods facing highest levels of crisis calls? Thank you, older woman. and I will follow up with my team on that incident. I was aware that we responded, so I will follow up and see where things got lost in transition. On mental health services, we have been really exploring solutions for how we can meet the needs of our community. Brick and murder options are one of the options available. Brick and murder options also come at a high cost, and especially now where there's just constraints on every side. So the first step in addressing that is how can we bring services to where we already have services as a first step? Are there opportunities to do more? Yes. And some of those we have been exploring, how do we take services to people's home when we're visiting them with our public health nurses? schools, public library, other options that are not as cost intensive, then how do we contribute to services that already exist as a federal regulation to integrate services rather than have standalone mental health services? So we are continuing to explore that. What will be possible in the future will depend on the resources that we have available, but we don't want to wait and limit our options to just brick and mortar. So we are exploring all options, including partnership with our other tiers of government. Behavioral crisis is also the same. We just heard that the state is funding some organizations to provide crisis response. We are also doing crisis response. We now have an intergovernmental agreement with them. How can we collaborate and ensure citywide coverage? So where we are and they are not, where they are and we are not, so that we can ensure citywide coverage. So these are some of the strategies we're exploring, knowing that the city alone cannot solve for all the problems. And so where can we partner and synergize to ensure services are available? So those are some of the things that we're doing now. We will be open to doing more. Resources are limited, as you know, for all departments. So we are trying to be creative in our solutions. Thank you. I know one of our state representatives, Lindsay LaPointe from the Northwest side and myself we're we're looking at how we can transform some of these things into a wraparound services and how do you know we combine city with state but let me ask you this and this might be an option may not be may not be i'm not really sure but as we talk about other funds and you talked about it's hard because of funds is there any such a thing as like the opiate uh settlement funds, can that be used as funds for low-barrier housing with supportive services? Some options exist, but the opioid settlement fund is also limited. The volume of need there in itself is huge. Opioid overdoses, death related to opioid overdoses right now exceeds gun violence plus road traffic accident combined. So the likelihood that we can use opioid fund for other things is limited because the need in opioid response also is so huge and it's all over the city. So we are exploring options, but it's not likely to be a huge pot of funding for additional services. Makes sense. And, you know, as you've talked about, like, it's huge. You know, those numbers are huge. And it seems that Chicago last year saw an increase of like 15 percent. And to that extent, how could we, how could additional resources be used to expand substance use preventions and treatments across the city? Yes, and that's the primary use of the opioid settlement dollars right now, just expanding the opioid response programs. And we were very excited about the progress we made this summer and that we have brought that down by 23 percent because of some of the activities. And we hope to even bring it down further. The Naloxone saturation plan, the medication plan, the recovery support services. and we're now exploring the synergy between mental health and substance use disorder so that in our clinics, you know, addiction services and other support services can be provided as well. Real quick, I'm looking at my time. Another question, and I'm going to ask you from this book we have right here for the MBEs and WEs contract data. There's a significant drop. I mean, it's a huge drop from, you know, year to year till this day for Hispanic and MWBs. Can you tell me, is there a particular reason, like what happened from one year to the next? Yes, the funding, our grant funding has been slowly going down. So you will see also the decline in our professional and contract services. as well. The specific around MWBE for Hispanic communities, I will look into that additional data. But during COVID, we were not really hitting any of our targets for MWBE at all. And that was because were moving so fast. Many of the contractors and professional services were not eligible for that designation. And the federal dollars did not allow us to designate funding that way. So we were not meeting those targets. We are doing a better job now that we're out of that emergency mode. And so I will look into it again and see what factors contributed to that and what The significant decrease is only for Hispanics. So just wondering on that. But one more question. I also want to give you, you know, last year with the daycare centers, between the total request and the average day time, I see like there's a huge improvement. You know, last year the average days was 308. This year we're at 45 days. So I think that's huge. What changed? We have been paying a lot of attention to our process improvement and just looking at customer service overall as a priority for CDPH this year. That is a priority for me. We want people's experience of government to be positive and we want to be responsive. So we have looked at all of the barriers that we have. How can we be a bit more efficient? How can we respond faster? So we are continuing to clean up. Our major limitation is just staffing. and our ability to get through all of the requests that we have. But we are doing a better job with expediting manual processes for our permitting and other activities so that people can respond faster to the 311 requests. Thank you. You good? Just one quick follow-up from the MBWBE question. I understand that during COVID you were moving at such a fast pace and only certain vendors qualified knowing that now what have we done and if you don't have the answer we can get this through the chair but I'm wondering what we're doing to better equip or build capacity in those same vendors so that they're not in that position again should something else happen these are areas where we've been Mary do you want to say something mary emmanuel deputy commissioner for finance grants and contracts and also the chief financial officer so you know just to give some context into this we were not meeting that goals before because there were a number of factors there it was because of covid the practicality of going through contracts. It was also because we did receive waivers from DPS. It was also because some contracts were not MBE-WBE eligible. So keeping in mind all those factors, we have been working with the department, the DPS procurement department, to make sure that we do align with the requirements of MBE, WBE requirements. And so the goal here is to make sure that we have vendors who also meet with those compliance requirements and working in tandem with DPS so that these goals are also met by them. Train before an emergency happens so that vendors are pre, they are compliant. Yes. Because in the emergency, they will not be compliant. So how do we ensure that the information is provided? I know DPS is doing some trainings so that they are pre-certified. We have enough people that are certified. Not everyone is even going through the certification. So these are some of the, I think, activities are necessary to ensure that we have a pool of eligible contractors to even tap into. Yeah, I'm glad to hear that because that's something that's really important. We shouldn't just be ticking a box if you are eligible for just one type of contract, but if we can prepare during blue sky days for the potential gray skies, everybody will be able to benefit from it. Okay, our last and final questions here are going to come from Alderman Hall. Thank you so much. You're doing a great job, first thing first. And thank you for the information that you share with us. And then we've had two years of great flu shot, COVID shots, partnering with New Covenant and using Sunday morning and then throughout this year with the senior group. So thank you. Office was on point. My first question is about young people. Young people are just different in this generation. Are you all keeping track of as it pertains to any of the health challenges, anything from STDs to like, are we keeping an accurate count or accurate amount of data, rather, pertaining to the health challenges of our young people in Chicago? Yes. We do annual health survey. We do youth behavioral risk surveys. Our maternal infant, child, and adolescent health team works very closely with young people, especially CPS. We have a sexual health program with CPS. We have a condom for school program with CPS, 277 schools that we support. We have mental health initiative with young people. Sexually transmitted infections, mental health related issues, violence. These are some things that predominantly, that disproportionately impact young people and that we're working with them. So, yes, cycle breakers is the other one. So, no, the approach of school is great. Outside of school, though, and it's a built-in audience and it's needed for sure. School is social services in addition to education. No doubt about it. Outside of school, when school buildings are closed, what pathway pertaining to messaging and marketing and what resources are available if a kid doesn't go to school that might need some of the services that you just mentioned? What's the approach, number one? And then number two, where are the places that after you're a teenager and you need some assistance, you know, whatever that you all offer, where do they go? So two-sided, the approach and the place. Yes. Approach outside of school is still limited. Places outside of school, also limited. Um, we have, our work has been designed very narrowly around particular issues, you know, because that's how funding comes. So we always explore where is a captive audience? Where can we readily engage with young people? Uh, but we do have youth serving organizations that we engage with, um, to get information to young people, especially around mental health. We have, um, an unspoken campaign, mostly online. We have a vaping initiative, also mostly online, because that's sort of like the way to get to young people mostly. So we are exploring TikTok now and social media as opportunities. But this summer, we tried something new around vaping with a marketing team to just try and engage people at parks. So I was at Grand Park saying, you know, I broke up with Nick. So they had a youth breakup kiosk where people can come and get information and provide information. But that's new work, and we are trying to see how we can expand there to further engage young people. We have not really, I don't think, maximized the opportunity there yet. I want to offer a solution in making time. However, we need to communicate. Email would be great, and I put my team together. I would love to partner with you going into 2025 on various ways to, with the resources from your department, ways to engage young people with solutions, maybe piloting a program where we set the goal, whatever the issue is that young people are facing. And we have a plethora of organizations within the ward, faith-based community in the ward, and just people who care about young people in the ward. And we would love to work with your entire department on piloting something specific using a community-based approach beyond the normal agencies and CPS. The other question that I have is what trends are you beginning to see pertaining to young people as it pertains to dangerous health trends that we need to focus on with our young people? And young to me is under 30. So 30 and under, what are some trends that you are seeing that we need to begin to do a better job of engaging with solutions? So suicide is something that we are seeing ticking up. It used to be white, middle-aged men predominantly. That is changing. We're seeing younger black men being impacted. So that is a red flag for us. in what we're seeing there. Vaping, we already talked about vaping, like traditional tobacco getting better, but vaping is just a new problem. And it also has the same health impact as tobacco and addictive even more than tobacco. So that's something that we've just started the campaign there. And then mental health. One out of every seven, I believe, young has anxiety or depression. So how do we engage our youth with coping skills to deal with the challenges of living in, you know, just really challenging times? And those are the skills. We don't want to wait until they're sick and then we give them therapy. How do we equip young people with coping skills to navigate a difficult world? So these are some of the issues. I think the top three issues that we're seeing impacting young people, especially the change in the suicide numbers. So we've been training community volunteers in that QPR question, persuade, and refer. What do you do? How do you identify someone might be suicidal and what do you do? So we've trained about 500 people to date and we would like more community members to be trained, at least to know because young people don't always talk. They don't always engage with adults. So how can you know when there is a call for help and do something? So I offer again the training that you just mentioned. Definitely in this next meeting away from here on the agenda is how the Sixth Ward can help with reducing suicide rates for black men. Last thing in concluding is, you know, you have a budget. It is what it is. But we have the medical district and so many great medical institutions in the city. 79th and Cottage, my colleague who just left, there's a partnership with Chicago State with Gift of Hope. The old Shore Bank building is now this hub for health, conversations around health, rather. Is there a strategy in place with limited restrictions in budget and grant, all of that? Is there a strategy in place to take more of those types of partnerships with the city using anchoring universities and medical institutions to do micro type of engagements in community through partnership. And what I mean by that is, for example, using Chicago State on 95th and King Drive, huge campus, have a nursing program. There's a pathway of some sort, right, with anchoring the university, community, and the city. So is there a strategy of some sort that, you know, is in place or you're considering to anchor our health institutions with the city to do a micro reach in communities. Yes, and yes, yes, yes. I keep saying to people, we have so many health institutions here. We have 350 federally qualified health centers. We have public health departments. We have hospitals here. We don't have to do this work alone and we cannot fund it alone. So we are open to all and every idea around partnership. That is going to be the future of our work. we saw during COVID, we need this partnership to work. And now more than ever, with the resource constraints that we have, we just need to leverage the networks that we have and build those relationships. So if there are institutions that are open, we are open. So in concluding, again, thank you, the entire dream team of how you all have engaged. The numbers are there. So again, thank you. And our next steps is a pilot of some sort to help with reducing suicide in the sixth ward. Secondly, developing some partnerships with proximity of medical partners in the Sixth Ward in the city. And then last but not least, if there's anything that we can look at with new partners to, you know, co-labor and be good ambassadors, we have figured out via the Sixth and the city. So, again, thank you. You're doing a five-star job and keep up the great work, you and your team. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. If there are no further questions, oh, Alderwoman Taylor, go ahead. I'm sorry, I meant to ask you this earlier. With the legalization of marijuana, are you seeing cases of young people getting access to this going up? This summer I had an incident where some young ladies bought it at a convenience store. It was hanging up, it didn't have nothing on it, they bought it. And those young ladies were high for three days. and so I want to at some point I would like to meet with you to talk about regulating that to smoke shops and not just convenience stores but can you are you seeing that in a trend can you talk about it for a second yes we're keeping an eye on on some of the numbers our poison control numbers and and even younger than five getting access to to some of this we're seeing those numbers so that's that's a concern that we are we're seeing can you send us the number word by word about what you're saying and then talk about what we could send out to constituents and put on our our websites and send out a newsletters about safety all right thank you thank you yeah and thanks for that question over uh chair taylor that's something i think we we all need to talk about in terms of just the red how readily available um non-cannabis items all right, THC, Delta 8, and other like hemp-derived products. And I think that's a revenue opportunity as well. But we definitely need to talk about regulation for that because they're way too available and there's no regulation around it currently. I know that's a lot that's got to be done at the state level, but that's something we should be taking up. With that, I think we're done. I'm looking around. There are no further questions, Dr. Yigay. Thank you to you and your staff. The committee's going to stand at ease until 5.30 while we transition to the next group department of buildings we're going to go ahead and reconvene welcome back everybody next up is the department on buildings i'm going to let uh dan from kofa um go ahead and give their report before we turn it over to the commissioner all right good evening uh next up we have the department of buildings my name is dan fristram with the council office of financial analysis for department of buildings the proposed budget for fy25 is 39.7 million which is a one percent decrease compared to the revised budget for fy 24. the budget includes funding for 280 full-time equivalent which is 10 ftes fewer than the f fy 24 revised budget additionally 80.9 percent of the department's funding comes from corporate sources the budget allocates 34.74 million for personnel expenses and 5 million for non-personnel expenses thank you very much we have with us this evening uh commissioner marlene hopkins and her staff from the department of buildings would you introduce your staff you have to talk and wait good evening to my right is john scott first deputy next to him is Lolita King, Deputy Commissioner of Finance and Procurement, in the box. Grant Ulrich, Managing Deputy Commissioner. Carl Byrd, Deputy Commissioner of Technical Inspections. Martha Reynoso, Deputy Commissioner of Express Permits. Hal Hutchinson, Deputy Commissioner of Permitting. Irma Rodriguez, Chief Building Construction Inspector, Conservation. Latoya Vaughn, Deputy commissioner human resources and mike puccinelli director of public affairs thank you um would you like to read your statement sure good evening chairman irvin vice chair lee committee members and aldermen i'm very happy to be here today to discuss the department of buildings 2025 budget requests it has been seven months since my confirmation as commissioner and i am grateful for the opportunity to serve mayor brandon johnson and collaborate with each of you the members of the city council together we are working to enhance the safety and quality of life for all chicago residents through the enforcement of the Chicago construction codes by promoting equitable economic development in every neighborhood. Before we discuss the budget requests in detail, I want to emphasize how grateful I am for the dedicated Department of Building staff who have the incredible responsibility to come to work each day to protect the health and safety and welfare of all Chicagoans through enforcement of the the Chicago Construction Codes. I am honored to work alongside these men and women every day on our core activities, issuing permits, conducting inspection, and issuing trade licenses. The Department of Buildings is committed to fighting for those who lack the resources to fight for themselves through aggressive enforcement of the health and safety standards set forth in the Chicago Construction Codes. In the past year, DOB inspectors have responded to over 46,000 311 calls. DOB's experienced supervisors review every 311 request that comes in and prioritizes those with immediate life safety implications, especially when children or seniors are involved. In the winter, we especially prioritize calls for buildings without heat. And since 2022, we also prioritize calls regarding violations of the cooling ordinance. When building owners do not promptly correct violations, DOB works with the law department to file enforcement cases, both in the Department of Administrative Hearings and in circuit court. DOB inspectors are true first responders who provide the critical protections that's most needed in our most vulnerable communities. Through September, the department has issued a total of 26,000 233 building permits and collected 22 million in permit fees. Mayor Johnson's bold and aggressive Cut the Tape initiative is already removing bottlenecks and accelerating approval timelines in the development process. The Cut the Tape strategies are straightforward, build faster, build everywhere, and build together. The department committed to reducing the time it takes to get a building permit and making the permitting process more transparent. We implemented several reforms this year, including sending more frequent reminders to architects and expediters that have outstanding corrections that they have not addressed and resubmitted, providing free virtual code correction mediation meetings with the design professional and property owners for projects with open corrections after two rounds of plan review. Inviting the property owner to attend the correction mediation meeting provides them with an opportunity to learn about the status of their projects while holding the design professional accountable for getting the project resubmitted in a timely manner. There is also better inter-departmental collaboration with the Department of Planning and Development, Department of Transportation, Department of Water Management, and the Department of Public Health. Every day, we report the average time for plan-based building permits issued during the past two weeks on our website. At the end of October, the average time with the Department of Buildings was 21 days, and time with applicant or design professional was 50 days for a total time to permit of 71 days. As you can see, more than two-thirds of this time is spent with the design professional. We realized that our customers were relying on their design professional or expediter to provide them with the status of permit application, and sometimes we're not getting the accurate information. As a solution, in March of this year, we launched a significantly improved website that provides owners with direct, real-time access to the status of their projects in the review process. In addition, we continue to promote our longstanding self-certification program. Many small and medium-sized projects are eligible to use this program as long as they are working with one of our more than 600 registered self-certification professionals. Self-certified projects bypass most building reviews and are subject to field inspections. Many self-certified permits are issued in less than 10 days. Last year, 41% of our plan-based building permits were self-certified, and we expect that number to continue to grow in the coming years. In November of 2023, we launched our express permit program, transitioning from a paper-based system to a majority online-based permitting program, which expanded our online payment options for permitting. I'm very excited to announce that as of mid-September, through our close collaboration with the Department of Technology and Innovation, two-thirds of the permits issued by DOB on an annual basis are now issued through the City's multi-department permit inspections and licensing platform, IPS11. We expect to retire our existing 20-year-old Hanson system by the end of 2026. This fully web-enabled platform allows our customers to check application status, pay fees, and view their inspection progress and results all from the comfort of their homes and offices. This real-time transparency gives customers and contractors more control of the process than ever before. One of the biggest enhancements is the ability to automatically suspend or expire issue permits due to the permit holder not requesting required inspections pursuant to the provisions of the construction codes. The department's 2025 initiatives include continuing to work with DTI on the modernization of our permitting, inspection, and licensing system, the modernization of the construction codes, with a focus on the mechanical provisions, which is inclusive of ventilation, refrigeration, boilers, and natural gas. After this, we will be focusing on updating the building, electrical, energy conservation, fire prevention, plumbing, and rehabilitation code provisions over the next 15 months. Our goal is to make sure that Chicago is ahead of or at the very least aligned with the latest industry standards as laid out by the International Code Council. We will further enhance our online guide to building permits, improve our online inspection request process, and require online training for the contractors that we license. The department will continue to work collaboratively with the Mayor's Office for People with Disabilities and the Department of Housing to ensure that projects submitted for various housing types are designed and constructed to accommodate individuals with varying impairments. impairments. The Department of Buildings is grateful for the partnership and support of the City Council, and we look forward to working with you in 2025. Thank you, Commissioner. Questions? Raise your hand if you... Taylor? More? Nobody else? Okay. Alderman Moore. Oh, sorry. I'm sorry. I didn't see you. Paul, anybody else? Okay, hold that thought, David, please. Vice Mayor, why don't you go ahead and start? Thank you. I don't have much to say. I just want to thank you and thank your staff. Every time I need to help someone in my ward with building challenges, you know I call you sometimes at night I call Carl sometimes at night you guys are Johnny on the spot you take care of it really appreciate it appreciate everything you all doing you know coincidentally on the plan commission happened to be in at the plan commission a developer that's rehabbing a building on Michigan Avenue I think it may be in either in Conway's ward or Brandon rallies ward bragged about how quick it was for them to get permits and everything and how quick the cut to tape things are happening and he said it publicly here at a plan commission meeting and is actually a developer from out of town and he was just uh saying how easy it was and how refreshing it was so i just want to commend you and your staff and everyone that's involved everything that you guys are doing keep up the good work thank you alderman uh thank you vice mayor um alderman more since i called on you first i'm going to let you go and then we're going to go to alderman mitts next alderman miss we go still by seniority anybody but you called me first she's been here she's got seniority so she go next thank you for for that alderman mitts You're good. Somebody respecting seniors around here. Well, you're both my seniors. Thank you and good evening, Commissioner. I really think that your department do some awesome work when it comes to taking care of our community. But I do have just one issue that I want to bring to your attention. and I've been working with a metropolitan tenants organization. There's some property in my ward on Madison, 5200 block, and they've sent several requests to the department. It's been taken over by a new owner, and when the new owners come in and take over, they have a company that they hire, and the tenants don't know who the owner is, and there are violations in the building. We did a press conference I've been working with, and I don't know who the owner, nobody came to see me, but they're saying that the building is a multi-unit building, lots of apartments, and people are living in infestation within the building. they'll complain about plus they done went up on rent like triple the rent now you know that ain't right I mean they I had to leave city council to go out and hold a press conference with them just to say let the tenants know somebody see what's going on here and I need your department to either go in and figure out get this landlord I don't know who it is so we can find out. Don't be misusing people. And they've been there all this time. Now you're going to double the rent on them. I don't know if you're experiencing any of that situation, but I have a huge issue. Thank you, Alderman Mitts. Yes, we have encountered this happening in various parts of the city. But what I assure you of is once you give me the exact address, we will be there. We will do a comprehensive inspection. We will find the ownership information and we will also deal with the property management company. Any violations that are cited, we will definitely refer that matter to circuit court where we will hold that building owner accountable. One of the commitments you have from me personally is to ensure that landlords who are collecting rents from tenants are ensuring that tenants are living in safe living conditions that are in compliance with the code requirements pursuant to the Chicago construction codes. And I will go to court personally if I need to. I appreciate that because I really do hate to see folks who've been in this building all these years, and now they've got to send their money to somebody who they don't even know they're sending it to. And if you've got new owners that's coming in, they're trying to evict someone out of the building if they complain. It's just not right the way so many folks are doing. And so I need the city's help and to help to make sure that we are looking out for the constituent residents of the city. People's been here. I don't know what their goals are. I'm here from my community. There are a lot of homeowners who have had tenants. Now they're trying to evict the tenants out so they can get, allow the migrants to come in. I'm just saying they got money and they can pay the rent so they want to up the rent and they want to evict everyday citizens out of their homes and I have people who came to me with these concerns you know we just I need your help you have my commitment and I will also talk with Corporation Counsel Mary Richardson, Lori to see legally if there are some other remedies that or measures that can be taken. But you have my commitment to working with you in your community. Okay. The address they just sent it to me is 5334 through 5362 West Madison. We put our schedules together on Fridays for the Building Safe Community Initiative Team. So we will have that on the schedule for next week. Okay, very good. And thank you so much. Thank your team for all the work that they're doing. And let me ask you this. Do you have inspectors out on weekends? So we do not have inspectors that work on the weekends. If there is an emergency prior to the, right now, because of overtime, we are not, inspectors are not responding. The senior staff is responding to any emergency. So if there's an issue that arises over the weekend, don't hesitate to reach out to me directly. And either I'll go out or a member of my senior staff will go out. You know what? I wasn't thinking of an issue. What I'm thinking about how to fill in this budget, this deficit that we're in. And I know that because when people want to do wrong, they know the city don't have nobody out. And I guarantee you, you got way more folks working on weekends out here in these communities now. And our tax dollars, we paying for it while they do the work, fly down, on vacant lots, whatever. Because ain't nobody watching over. Just like the criminals. If you don't watch them, they're going to keep doing stuff. And we're losing a lot of revenue right in that area because we don't have people out. Just thought I'd bring that to your attention. Thank you. So what I will say is that we do respond to, like, as I stated in my statement, we respond to over 46,000 311 requests. Of that number, 55% of them are no cause. 6%, we actually refer to court. And 7% to administrative hearings. So several years ago, what requires a building permit changed. So you can do up to 32 sheets of drywall, repair, replace. You don't need a building permit for that. If you're doing plumbing work, replacement in kind, you don't need a permit for that. So there is a list of projects or things that a homeowner or a building owner can actually do that doesn't warrant or require a building permit. So if someone calls in a 311 request and they see it closed out as no permit required, that's because the work that they were doing didn't require the permit. But again, feel free to call me if you're observing or see something that's happening on the weekends. And I don't have a problem with jumping in my car and going over to check it out. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Maddie. Thank you, Alderman Harris and then Alderman Moore. Thank you. I'm up here next to Emma Mitz. I moved around a little bit. first of all I want to say big thanks to the building department which is one of the most efficient departments in the city of Chicago under your leadership thank you commissioner for all that you do and Carl Berg is like our go-to person in the office and Barbara said that if I didn't say say that out loud to you Carl that I would be in big trouble so thank you Carl for everything that you do. Were fees raised in your department? Were any fees raised for this budget? So in 2025, there is an inflation fee increase for building permits. Okay. And what's the dollar amount that it currently is and where is it going? I will submit that to you. Okay. Just send it to the chair because it's probably, just let me know in that what you all raised in 2024 year to date and then what the inflation is estimated to be for 2025. No problem. Okay. All right. Thank you so much. Thank you, Madam Chairman. Thank you. Alderman Moore. Thank you so much, Madam Chairman. And to this team, almost outside of police, or it should be inclusive for police, you all have one of the most challenging jobs and you guys, Commissioner, under your leadership, have been responding in a great manner. So I just want to thank you and your entire team for what you do in making our ward a better and a safer place to live. I know I call upon you a lot, but my staff definitely call upon Ernestine. And they, you know, won't let me leave here without, you know, because Sharon's a beast. That means Ernestine is even beastier because she's getting stuff, helping her get stuff done. And I just want to thank you and your entire team, even from whether it's buildings or businesses. that we deal with. You and the deputy, you all are just doing some great work and I appreciate you all so much. I also wanna take this time and just really say thank you in terms of when I took an initiative to go camp out on West 72nd Street in a very dangerous area, a place we've dealt with over the years where we've done what we call it the all city response task force out there whatever you call it but what you did during that time and being responsive we were able to get some buildings down in a timely fashion where these guys are hiding guns and everything and it really crippled their operation is not totally you know gone but we stopped a lot of stuff and And trust me, I still get calls and the residents are grateful for what you all did. I stood, but you all acted. I stood, you all acted. And for that, I am forever grateful. So thank you so much. As I get into more of this question in terms of a scenario, I'm going to have to ask both by a scenario. And I think we've addressed it before, and I can't remember if I followed through on it. But if we have to do something from an ordinance standpoint. So vacant buildings, because they're supposed to have a sign-up where we can contact the manager or owner or whoever is responsible. And so if our war supers or anybody else continuing to write fines, but they are paying them or not responding. So I guess it's two scenarios. The non-response, the non-response, what happens in that situation? And if they keep paying them, but yet keep still violating because they get the money, what is it is at our disposal to do? So it's two different scenarios, basically. One, we can't seem like are we first of all, are we able to always get in touch with somebody? Because sometimes we can't get in touch with people, right? It depends. So if the building is registered, there is a point of contact. We have the name, we have a phone number and we have an email address. and this earlier this week I sent to each of the ward all each of the alders a listing of all of the registered vacant buildings in your respective wards you will be receiving that report every first Monday of the month for every building that was registered in the prior month and that is to ensure greater transparency and that you're you and your teams have that information available to you. The posting is a requirement. It is not one that we actually issue a citation for because they are in compliance with the vacant building ordinance as they have registered the building. But we can go back and talk, you know, amongst ourselves about the posting of the signage on the front of the building. So if I got a repeat offender and they've paid their fine, what is it are two bucks that we can do if they're still just as long as they're paying their fine there's nothing we can do so they're paying the registration which is what they're required to do they're required to pay the registration if they're failing to post the signage or to keep up with their property so or to properly maintain it so they are required to maintain the property and so if they're failing to do so and we're responding to the 3-1-1 request but our inspectors are finding that, we can work with the Department of Administrative Hearings to start a call to do enforcement for failing to maintain the property in compliance with the vacant building or registration. It won't warrant enforcement action in circuit court, but we can definitely look and work with administrative hearings to create a call for that. Okay. And for the ones where they're not registered, I should say. So those that are not registered and have counts where would warrant enforcement action in court, we will process those for the vacant building demolition call in circuit court to have to take the necessary enforcement action. For those that are vacant and secure or not demo worthy, we write those currently and refer them to administrative hearings. Okay. All right. No, thanks. And it's getting, you know, from a response standpoint from your department, it's there, but it's just dealing with these, you know, these constant bad, you know, apples. and especially when if in cases where you got a building in some cases vacant lot i'm get i'm assuming that's dpd or somebody because we can't go on private property and you're dealing with situations you can't find anybody and you got miss jones that lives next door she don't have any money to cut down that neighbor's tree or overgrown weeds that's not you know but yet you know there's times from a city standpoint we can't go on that property and cut that tree down on that you know house or vacant lot so it's tough and one of our other options also is to work with the tribal buildings initiative so that would be another pipeline that we could explore so if you have properties like that that you want us to take a look at by all means send the list to me and we will address it. Thank you. Thank you so much, Commissioner. I truly appreciate you all. And I had to stay here as tired as I am and got other things to do. You're worth that and more. And I just appreciate you all for what you do. Thank you for your support. Thank you, Alderman Nemar. Next we have Alderman Sikha Lopez. Thank you. Thank you, Vice Chair, and thank you, Commissioner. It's good to see you. And thank you for the work that you do for the City of Chicago. So I think some of the questions that I had already being covered, I have some specifically relating to residents with disabilities or disability matters. In terms of inspections, how many inspections for disability accessibility were done last year? And how many resulting on citations? I don't know if you have those numbers. If not, we can go through the chair. So our department does not do inspections for disabilities. If there is a building permit, we do do the inspections to verify that the contractor has completed the work in compliance with the approved plans. So if the approved plans show handicap accessible restrooms, handicap accessible light switches, handicap accessible features in the building, our inspectors will inspect to verify that the contractor has completed that work in compliance with the approved plans. But as it is related to doing inspections for accessibility, we do not enforce those provisions of the code. Got it. Thank you. Maybe this is maybe a follow up question then in terms of inspections that maybe were requested to check for violations for Section 504 of the Fair Housing Act as amended. Is that something that the department does? We do not enforce those provisions. So that would not fall under the Department of Buildings. Yeah. And I mentioned this because, again, in our community, we have, for instance, many requests that go in terms of accessibility to businesses or accessibility in general. And I do think that perhaps it can be a way for us to work with the different agencies, BACP, CDOT, buildings, in order to us to ensure accessibility, right? perhaps not in a punitive way, but certainly in a way that addresses accessibility. For us, you know, in many buildings, as you know, in Pilsen, we have a really old housing stock where we have vaulted sidewalks that still need to be repaired, and we want to continue working with residents and buildings department to ensure not only code, but accessibility. My next question goes around inspections for, or the code that had been maybe changed around implosions and other kind of codes that require environmental coordination between the Department of the Environment and the Department of Buildings. I know in the past has been, perhaps there was no other structure, I would say. There was not a Department of the Environment. What has the department done in terms of coordinating with the Department of the Environment to ensure that such work that requires maybe coordination between the Department of the Environment and the Buildings Department is done to prevent the situation like the Hillco implosion and others of similar nature? So we have a category of demolition that is known as complex. And then there's the environmentally complex side of the demolition process. So the two departments work collaboratively together through the review process. The health department does their comprehensive review to ensure compliance with all of their code requirements as it is related to dust, asbestos, and lead abatement. Upon the completion of their review, they send a memo to the building commissioner informing me that their review has been completed and that everything is in compliance. For those demolitions that are environmentally complex, there's a building inspector and an inspector from the Department of Public Health that is on site the entire time the demolition is in progress. The building inspector is there to ensure that the contractor is demolishing the building structurally in the correct manner. The environmental inspector is there to ensure that the contractor is in compliance with dust mitigation as well as their air monitoring requirements. So we work very, very closely together. On the new construction side, when our inspectors are doing permit inspections or basic building violation inspections, if they observe that the owners or contractors are doing abatement of asbestos and have not secured the proper permits from the Department of Public Health, we notify health immediately so that their investigators can go and vice versa. If they're responding to a 3-1-1 request regarding asbestos abatement and they observe work that's being done without building permits, they notify us so that we can collaboratively work together to address those conditions. So since 2020, we have worked very closely together to strengthen the relationship and the partnership between our departments. Thank you, Commissioner. And I'll start for the record. I know that you you came to our community to present. I just want to make sure that, you know, the people know that there have been changes, and that's what I welcome and support, the creation of the Department of the Environment so that we have better protocols. And I appreciate your collaboration and coordination on that. Finally, I know that you have, you know, there's a slight decrease, like there's a 1% decrease in your budget for what I can see in the report from the management office. There's about 10 full-time positions that are fewer from what I understand. I want to make sure that in terms of that we have personnel that is adequate to conduct the inspections. At the same time as, you know, we want to, as you know, have an effort to cut the red tape, improve the processes around permitting, you know, similar to other cities where we see processes being expedited, being more efficient, and cut the time. I know that in the housing committee, we recently by just cutting some of the red tape and paperwork we reduced the planning commission time or proposals but about 30 to 60 days i'm not sure if you have any other suggestions or things that can be done again i know that you're going to work on a tighter budget but we also want to ensure that the safety of the buildings the the environmental efforts and as well as the efficiency of the of our processes is intact so not sure if you have any anything like that i know that you've done a lot of work and I really commend you for your efforts in this line as well. Thank you. So as I stated in my statement, we have reduced the time to permit. We are at 71 days. It's the reviews in our department is 21 days. It's 50 days spent with the design professional. So two-thirds of the time is with the design professional addressing the open corrections. In the past, we would issue corrections it would sit with the design professional until they decided that they were ready to make the corrections we've now start to send reminders to them to remind them you have had this project for this amount of time you need to get these plans you know corrected and resubmitted we are doing mediation meetings online so not having to come into the office but we're able to set it up via Zoom. And we have staff that works with the design professional, but we also invite the owner to be a part of that process so that the owner is aware of what the status of their project is. As you mentioned, we did reduce our positions by 10. It was a lot of middle management titles that were reduced and one inspector position. And I think one, two administrative titles. So we did not lose any of our building inspectors, any of the electrical inspectors. We are carrying 29 inspector vacancies into 2025, and that we are working closely with human resources to fill those vacancies. We recently completed interviews for plumbing inspectors. They're on the sewer fund. So we were able to continue our hiring process there. And so we are going to continue to fill vacancies so that we can continue to deliver the services that are needed to the community whether it's for permit inspections responding to 3-1-1 requests working collaboratively with the department of environment as to do the job that we are charged to do for the city thank you commissioner and um yeah just let me end you know with um you know definitely i think there is a lot of um um a lot of help that a lot of small homeowners need especially seniors i appreciate your sensitivity towards that and helping making sure that people are up to code. Perhaps we can work together. I know that many small homeowners would like to legalize their basement attics and coach houses. I welcome the opportunity to work with housing, finding maybe some resources to do so. It is important to be, you know, up to code. And perhaps, again, we can figure out a way here in the city council so that, you know, corporations, bigger entities, you know, big developers can contribute a little bit more I think small homeowners are really struggling right now I'd love to work with you to help those in need and making sure that our buildings are safe as well thank you Commissioner thank you thank you Alderman six Joe Lopez is Alderman Scott still in the room anywhere okay sure Taylor thank you chairman hey black girl magic that is my name for you and it's because the 20th Ward is gentrifying as I sit and breathe. And to what Alderman Mitt said, we got residents who wake up the next day and they getting a text to say, zero me your rent, I'm the new building owner. And so we got to take a real look at how we give folks when they're transferring the building. When folks register their properties, do they pay? And if they don't, would it benefit the city to have them pay a fee to register. And so even if they transfer it over, because I'm seeming to find a lot of properties that it say is one owner, but it really ain't that person. Is there, you think there's a benefit that would help in this department so that we don't cut you all at all? And so if we go into something for a registry, I feel like that money should go back into buildings so that you have more inspectors and more folks to go out to these buildings. So we used to have the multiple dwelling unit registration When we updated the code and converted from the old building code to the International Code Council, we repealed that requirement. We are cognizant that there is a lot of changing of ownerships that is occurring. And so as we are in lock, let me digress. Hanson 7 was not designed to really help us automate that process. As we are working through the modernization of our system, we can definitely revisit implementing or putting back on the books an ordinance of some sort to obtain ownership information and ensure that it's an automated system so that we are able to do so. So we'll work with the law department on that process to come up with language and see how we can implement that because we have that same challenge that, but we rely a lot on the Cook County Recorder of Deed site to really find ownership information, but reinstituting or recreating a registration for multiple dwelling units is definitely something we can look at. Are you all in the works of thinking about a dashboard? So think about people calling 311 and they say the heat is off. And them knowing that they actually, it got reported and that we are going out to inspect. And I'm going to add a part two to that question. What are we doing with landlords? Every year I have a handful of landlords who wait until after October 1st to turn on their heat on. or when it gets very, very, very, very cold, they picking and choosing whether they're going to turn on the heat. Is there some conversation about us upping the fees on those repeat offenders? So part of the challenge with that is this past fall, right? We had Indian summer days, then we had some cold nights, then we had the temperatures that went back up. So it's hard in some instances to really determine when to cross over your system, depending on what type of system you have in the building. We can definitely talk more about that, but the weather fluctuates. So it's just difficult to really pinpoint when is a good time to cross over and turn the furnace or the heat on. But what I will say is for our seniors, we definitely are calling those building owners. We actually did a call last week with a building ownership team to discuss the fact that we were getting a high number of calls from their seniors regarding their not being heat and so I think we got their attention and they understand what they need to do because I was gonna say I got a senior building at my ward because the unit is on top of the building so every time it gets a certain degrees the seniors are called cold and they call and they complain and of course you go out but we've been doing that for six five going on six years with this building owner and so it's like when is because it costs for you to have folks come out they look at it they I don't know what they do to it but of course because you put the feet under their fire they do something they don't get away with doing anything and so how do we get to those folks before it gets that zero below zero degrees so we we try very so some of our chiefs and supervisors actually have a list of those building owners and they pay them a lot of frequent visits, but we will work closely with the law department to determine what is the best course of enforcement action. It may not be circuit court because it's not extreme cold. It may be that we need to put them into administrative hearings for insufficient or inadequate heat. So we can definitely have a conversation with the law team to determine the best course of action for those repeats. How are you working with DHS around, not DHS, DOH with building owners who kind of need support so you go into a building because one of the tenants called in because it's having issues and you know that they are one building landlord or they live in the building and they can't really afford the upkeep are there some recommendations are there some programs are there some things that you help provide to the buildings department to say hey is there a bucket or is there a program is there a grant program is NHS I don't know that could help some of these small landlords. Because I get some of them, they live in their buildings and they've had them for a long time and they need some upkeep, but they really can't afford it. But they charge affordable rents. So we do work very closely with the Department of Housing when we find situations like that where it's an owner-occupied building, senior needs some assistance with some work or some repairs, and we try to find creative solutions to give them that assistance so that we are not taking enforcement action, but rather trying to help them. Is there a program for people who want to demo their properties who can't afford the large demolition fees? So are you talking about for their building or for a garage? So owner on King Drive bought that vacant building and he just, what they're charging for the demo, he just cannot afford. but he's put money aside so that he could you know create a business or make it storefronts that are come but he he says it costs too much to upgrade it's better to demo and just knock it down so if the city does the demo the city will file a lien on the property and the city will pursue the cost recovery through foreclosing on that lien so right now there aren't any programs that allows the city to do demolitions without the property owner having to have that lien filed against the property. Last question. Are there, are there instances where owners have done rehab to their building and they didn't have a permit? Do you all tear them down? Are they asked to tear them down? Can you talk about that a little bit? So I got a situation in a war where, and it wasn't in my war. I just received it in the remap where they feel like the porches are right here they're right next to each other and it looks crazy to me because i'm not a building inspector i didn't take architecting school i don't know any of that it looks crazy to me but somebody approved that somebody allowed that to happen and so can you talk about kind of like what people could do or like how how am i even because right now i'm the bad guy because i won't make them tear down i was like well i didn't tell them to build it up there but i can you kind of talk through that just a little bit and kind of let's have a conversation about what we should be doing when folks, because you did make the statement that for certain things they don't need permit. What happens when they do the work without the permit? What does the city do? If they have built a porch without a permit, we will process that for enforcement action. And the violation will order them to obtain the necessary permits to legalize what they have built without permits. If what was built is not in compliance with the current code, they may need to make modifications to bring it into compliance with the code. But we would have to go out, do the inspection, make the determination if, in fact, there weren't any building permits on file for the structure that was built. The likelihood of them being required to tear it down is unlikely, but requiring them to modify it to bring it into compliance with the code definitely. Because there is some neighbor dispute now that is starting to happen and I'm asked to intervene and I ain't really good at that. That ain't my thing. I just want to say that was my last question. Thank you all. I know if the head is not strong, the body is weak and y'all definitely got a strong head in this department. I just appreciate what you all do for our war because too often those folks get ignored. They'll complain about the heat or the ceiling leaking, and nobody ever comes at it, and that's never been what I've experienced since you've been in that space or even before when you just working there. But now I just appreciate you all in this department, and I want to see you all take no cuts because we need you all to make sure that our people live in places that are safe and road and free and where they can actually have some peace. Thank you, Chairwoman. Thank you, Commissioner. Thank you, Chair Taylor. Alderman Scott. I'll be brief, but I just wanted to say thank you. Thank you. I call I probably email you once a week, twice, and I appreciate always you responding to the call of duty. You know, the challenges that I have and you never stop or never cease to combat some of those challenges that I have. And if it takes you and the district 11, 10, it gets done. And we've had some real complicated situations in the ward. And so thank you. And thank you to your team. You may get a lot of calls from Coach Charles in my office. And I appreciate you all, every last one of you. That's it. I typically try to save some of my neighbors and not call when they have, you know, I saw a situation last year where this one of the constituents called and thinking that she was helping a resident, but they got moved within 24 hours. So I try to do them a favor sometimes and not until they can find a better solution because my motto is if you call buildings, you don't want to live in your place anymore because they're going to do what's right. and you know we have to do what's right to protect our residents and you do that and so thank you thank you thank you alderman scott does anybody else have any other questions alderman um and i'll happen with thank you thank you chair hi commissioner hi it's good to see you i want to shout out to your supervisor frank and ernestine and your whole team um we also rely on you and call on you a lot I also want to remind you that it's okay. You don't have to pick up the phone or respond to texts at midnight. It's okay. I wanted to ask just a couple questions related to service. And I'm asking because I'm curious to know if it would work at all to work on a grid system to, especially when we're talking about routine inspections for, I have a lot of buildings, as you know, tall buildings and older buildings, like we maintain the trees. Is that ever been considered? I'm talking about elevators and just regular maintenance, especially of older buildings. So the code provisions does require us to do annual and or periodic inspections at the discretion of the commissioner. So our elevator bureau do conduct bills, annual inspections. The city is basically on a pretty much like a three-year rotation. So they are covering various parts of the city annually. And so they work themselves in a three-year rotation for elevators and for our conservation bureau, which gets 41% of our 311 requests. If the building is a building that requires a periodic inspection while they are there responding to that 311 request, they are also doing the periodic inspection that is required. Okay, great. Do you have, this might have been asked before, your website is great that you can report complaints on there and also do 311. I'm wondering, is there a way for us to see where things are at? in terms of response times and resolution of issues? So we would have to work with the Department of Technology and Innovation to see if there is a way to build an interface, to have Salesforce, an interface onto our website. Currently there is not one. And I'm sure as we're working on upgrading our permitting, inspection and licensing system, that that is something we can definitely look at incorporating so that we can have greater transparency. Yeah, I'm really glad to see that you're working really closely with the Department of Technology to upgrade all those systems, efficiencies, reduces frustration, of course. And I'm wondering if you have ever considered, I guess, in terms of generating new revenue through specialized permits by expediting permits or premium inspection service? I don't know what kind of services we can offer. Is that something that you have ever thought of doing? So for example, with special events, if they are applying for permits and the event is less than 14 days out, we triple the review fees. So that is one form of increased revenues because those permit fees are pretty costly when we have to triple them for special events. Our self-cert permits, we have not looked at a special fee or increase in a fee for that, especially, you know, increase in the fees for that, but that may be a process or something for us to take a look at. I think for standard plan review, those fees are on, there is an inflation schedule annually, and I'm going to be providing that through the chair, so we'll ensure that you receive a copy of that as well. for any after-hour inspections or weekend inspections for permits that companies want done, they are required to pay reimbursable overtime for those inspections. So they are currently covering the costs of the inspector. Okay, great. Around the idea of cost effectiveness or incentivizing building compliance, have you considered ever implementing a tiered fee structure for repeated violations or delinquent inspections to increase revenue and encourage compliance? So the fees, our fines do have a tiered system. So for the first time, a violation, the minimum is $500. The max is $1,000. For the second violation, it is $1,000 minimum, $6,000 maximum. And for the third violation, it is $6,000 to $10,000. And so we have been discussing internally utilizing that mechanism for repeat offenders of stop work orders. So we issue a stop work order. You violate it the first time, you receive the minimum. You violate it again, we can go to tier two. and you violate it again, you go to tier three. So we have definitely talked about implementing that as a way to increase some of the fines that we collect. Great. And you've just mentioned overtime costs and the budget reflects overtime for certain inspector roles. I was curious if there are alternative approaches to reduce overtime or is that not avoidable? Could you expand full-time positions or create hybrid roles to serve multiple inspection needs? So a lot of our overtime costs is spent responding to emergencies. So fires, building-related emergencies, when cars go into buildings, when buses hit buildings, trees that fall into buildings, coping that's falling, broken glass that's falling in the central business district. So those are emergencies that we don't have any control over and we respond to them, you know, accordingly. So that is where a large portion of our overtime cost goes to. Now, as I was explaining to Alderman C.T. Lopez, we are also doing inspections for the complex demos. Well, those demo projects that go after hours, those contractors are required to pay reimbursable overtime. So if they are going, let's say from 3.30 to eight o'clock, they're paying the overtime cost. If they're working Saturday and Sunday, they're paying that overtime cost for the inspector. So that's not cost that's coming out of the city's overtime budget. It is actually reimbursed. They're paying us for that overtime. Okay, thank you. I want to pivot to mold. We We talked about mold in the last subject hearing, but what would it take to add mold to the building code? So mold is not covered in the building code because it is really a source of dampness and or moisture, which is what causes it. So the root of it is water infiltration, which we cite building code violations for dampness in the wall because of deficiencies. We cite the building code. We do cite violations. We just don't cite it for mold. We cite it for what is causing the mold, which is the water damage. Okay. Just to clarify, when it is to the point where it is a mold problem, where does that fall under? Who does that fall under? So we receive 311 requests all the time regarding mold. When we go out to do the inspection, we are looking for what is the source of it. And it is the source is water. So we're looking at the foundation wall if the mold is in the basement. If we see that it's coming through the drywall, we know that there's something going on with that exterior wall that the owner needs to address. If we are finding it on an outside wall, let's say on the second floor, third floor, it still is indicative to us that there's something going on on that exterior wall. It may be that they need to do tuck pointing. It may be that they need to have some extensive masonry work done. So the cause of the mold is the water. So that is what we are addressing, the building code violation. Now, they are required, of course, to then replace, repair any wall sections on the inside, removal of drywall, to abate those conditions on the inside. But the building code is addressing the cause of it, which is the water. Is there, just to clarify, because I think what you're trying to get at is who's responsible and is there an ordinance or something in a code someplace that would require the landlord to replace and remediate or abate the mold? There's no provision in the building code for that, specifically for mold. It is, the code requires you to be, your building to be in compliance with the minimum standards. But we can definitely talk more about this and if it's something that we can do in conjunction with the Department of Public Health. yes by all means we would be willing to do so terrific thank you so much commissioner thank you chair it was it was a little vague earlier when we were talking about mold with the health department okay um there are no other questions but i have a couple so you're not quite oh you too uh president pro tem please no go ahead i'll close no problem commissioner hopkins and the entire DOB, Mr. Bird over there. Just so grateful for you and what you have and continue to do for the 16th Ward. I like myself. Ironically, the three of us are sitting together because I'm sure I have the same Department of Building issues that Alderwoman Scott here on the West Side has. And I know Alderwoman Taylor with us sharing 59th and 63rd. I am concerned about your budget for demo. Too often times, especially in Englewood, Lawndale, and I'm sure back of the yards, wood lawns, certain areas. I want to make sure that the department is fully funded for in case of emergencies, but sometimes they're not just emergencies. We have dilapidated buildings in our communities that are a hazard, a public hazard, especially for our senior community, especially for our business community. And if people fear coming on the block, they're definitely not going to move into our community and certainly not support our neighborhood. So what does that look like? Because if my memory serves me, prior administration cut your budget. And if you can explain, how do we get back to making sure that that's fully funded? So we have been working closely with the budget department, with budget director Guzman and her team to ensure that we are properly funded for our demolition and brought up activities for 2025. What does that number look like? So we were at $10 million during the prior administration, and that is what we are working towards for this current budget year we're going into. Has construction and price of tools and equipment affected that price prior pre-pandemic? No. Well, the average cost of demo is about $31,000. Roughly $20,000, $21,000 is the actual cost to demolish the building. It is the water cut and seal fee that is high because that's about additional almost $9,000 that's added to the cost of demolition, but it requires the cut and seal of the water and sewer services when we do demolition activity. So the pricing really has not drastically changed. We've just seen small increases because the fees for water has increased and increases annually, but nothing to the extent that it is impacting our ability to do demos. In your expertise, because I think you wrote the book, the ordinances the cults is that enough money it is because the reality of it is we can't demolish our way out of vacant buildings we want to see the reinvestment in our housing stock especially our mason our brick buildings yeah and so what we are doing is working with the department of housing as well as the department of law on a program that will enable us to work through the circuit courts to actually put these buildings into the hands of individuals or investors that have the financial ability to make the reinvestment in those buildings so that they can come back onto the tax rolls. And we also work very closely with Cook County Land Bank. Yes, yes. The masonry's for sure. And I know you have helped between you, Ms. Black, have helped save some of our brick buildings, but those frames that have been, you know, past fires, and it just seems like, okay. We're paying attention to those, and when the, as the inspectors are observing them, when they're out there notifying their supervisor so that the supervisor can put those out to bid, because we realize that they pose an imminent hazard, not only to the people that live in the community, but to our first responders. Amazing. Speaking of first responders, some of the X's, I don't know if anyone has brought up, I know that the X buildings, the red and white X, I know that that is a signal to first responders. Has buildings taken an assessment of the quality of those buildings? So the Red X program was implemented, I want to say in 2010 or 2011 through a grant that the Department of Fire received through their Bureau of Fire Prevention. And at that time, they used our inspection information to determine which buildings would actually have the red X affixed to it. And so it is an indicator to first responders not to enter. If there is, in the event of a fire, they are basically to fight it defensively from the exterior and not going to the inside because there's some condition that poses a threat to their safety and well-being. And last year we had an inspector who was actually conducting a regular court re-inspection and the interior stairs gave way and he fell into the basement. And had he not been there with our board up company who was able to call 911 immediately, I don't know if he couldn't have gotten to his phone, we would have known where he was because we would have had a notification from our GPS system letting us know that he was at the stop for an extended period of time. So we are cognizant that vacant buildings pose an imminent threat to everyone. Yeah, even your staff. Our inspectors who know and are familiar with these buildings, but you don't know when something on the inside is going to fail because of the rate of deterioration. But thankfully, he's good. He's healthy. He's back at work. And we are blessed. And thank God the Border Up Company was with him. Thank God. Whoever the company was, thank God for an angel. Yes. Thank you, Commissioner. By the way, on 61st and Racine during our 16th war visit, all those cars, they're all gone. I noticed that the other day. So thank you, Marlene Hopkins. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Alderman Coleman. I'm going to close out and I promise sure go ahead Alderman Taylor I wanted to just take a moment to acknowledge one person on my team Irma Rodriguez could you stand up Irma is the chief of conservation it is her inspectors that are the ones that are responding to all of our occupied building complaints whether it's no heat no air the problem with the masonry, infestations, you name it. It is her team that actually goes in and does those inspections. So I just wanted you to see the person behind the scene that is actually making sure that all of your requests for any of your occupied buildings, she is the person that is actually ensuring that her inspectors are being responsive to each of you. Thank you. Just a couple of questions. I know there's been talk of a building registry. uh for property owners who are landlords um but it sounds like a building registry in general would be something that would be really helpful um for the city in general because I know that when we get complaints about buildings we've got to go do all the lookups and everything and like you said um true Taylor you know buildings are changing ownership so quickly and then you know you get a notification I'm your new landlord well how do I know that right so I don't know um you might be something for us to look at in terms of legislation to ensure that there's proper and due notification to renters about when properties are handed off or if there is something then we should be enforcing it um so i'd be all very supportive of that and with with the technology um on the conversion way uh retiring hansen um what sort of modifications are we seeing today that are making a difference for you? The fact that the permits are being issued online, that we built in a feature where the contractor actually has to accept or acknowledge that they are the contractor of record, which is reducing the number of instances where applicants are just putting down a contractor's information and then we're receiving notification from that contractor that they're not the actual contractor doing the work. So the new system allows for or requires, I should say, the contractor of record to acknowledge that they are the one doing the work to ensure that we are actually reflecting the correct person. One of the other great enhancements is the feature that was built in to suspend and or expire permits that have had no permit inspections. As you know, our older system was not designed to notify us of that. So having that mechanism in place has been tremendous. Two thirds of our permits are actually in the system now. So we are excited to work on moving our plan based permits, our inspections, and our licensing, the other portions of our licensing into the new system. And are we charging anymore for these advanced services that are making the experience so much better? So we are, I mean, again, there's the inflation fee that is assessed every year for permit fees. So that is one way of it, of doing so. But as we continue to move our programs or processes in there, we will be looking at our fees to see where we can increase. Yeah, I think we should start taking a look at them for this budget. I mean, honestly, um I in talking to people that are in the in the industry they've I've had people say to me I would pay extra just to cut a month out of the process for an expedited service so I think especially because we do have modernization that has already benefited everybody and these systems cost money so at a minimum I feel like in addition to the inflation we should be passing along the cost and I think that because we're providing faster service at this point that's something that uh on the other side would would likely be more than happy to to cover um so that they don't lose time we know how much um losing time costs people in the process as well with increasing supply costs and materials um and then on the flip side of that too for the permits that have expired or haven't had inspections um what happens with with those like if they've gone past a window like what happens today so for those permits that are suspended there is a reinstatement fee that is assessed and that permit can be reinstated for permits that have expired meaning that it is beyond the time of reinstatement unfortunately they have to start over okay um through the chair can you and i one of the questions i was asked earlier is just the fee schedule but um can we add to that when the last time any of these fees were increased that would be great um and then the last bit that i have is just on language accessibility you know i've got i've got the first asian majority ward in the city i've got a lot of uh got a lot of non-native english speakers um and very regularly i'll get people coming in with a building code violation notice that they've had to have their children translate for them or they're not responding to them in a timely fashion because they don't really know how to how to just figure out what needs to be done or even understand that um i know that a building registry would actually really help this because you could opt into a language preference. Do we do any of these notifications in multiple languages today? Today, we do not. Okay. I'd love to explore that with you somehow, even if we can pilot that in my ward and maybe in Spanish-speaking wards, to just see how that helps to get people more engaged and on top of things. I think half the time, people don't understand what they're obligated to do, and when they don't know, they're failing to do things, and then they're paying thousands of dollars because they're in violation of these codes that they just don't really understand. But the language accessibility piece, I think is really important and I think may actually help at the end of the day to get people into compliance more regularly. We would love to work with you on that. Yeah, we did that with Streets and Sands with the door tags for warnings. So we asked for one and we have one in English. And in addition to English and Spanish, we have English and traditional Chinese. So I'll work with some of my colleagues and let's figure out how we can pilot something like that. I'd love to do that. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. Alderman Gutierrez. Yes. Thank you. Just wanted to thank you and your amazing team because every time we've had something in the 14th Ward, you've been always so responsive. And also your team, in a matter of hours, sometimes we get the answers. And if not, let us know how is it going. So thank you for your work and your team. And I keep learning, right? from all my colleagues and thank you all for your questions because i know it's really important to continue to advocate for our communities especially right for the people that rent and sometimes those apartments are not in the conditions that they should be you know the amount of calls and and requests for inspections that we get into our office is it's uh it's tremendous the number of them that that we receive and kudos to your team because you guys are doing an amazing job thank Thank you. So finally here, thank you for all that you do. And I'm just gonna join in the chorus of accolades because you all are amazing team. Every single person that's here in the box, there's never a call that I make that does not get answered and responded to. And I know under your leadership, because you're the type of person who has always cared about not just making sure that the codes are enforced and the people are safe. You want people, especially our seniors, be taken care of. So the extra care and extra mile that you go is totally noticed and does not, it's not lost on us how lucky we are to have you leading this team. And for everybody that's here, Carl, you're always picking up the phone and responding and taking our calls. I feel like I've got to get to know the rest of your team. So I'll start calling everybody else now. But thank you all. I know it's been a long day. Thanks for your patience, but thanks for all that you do. and we look forward to continuing to support your work. Thank you. We will be at ease for about five minutes while we bring the other department of DFSS is next. Good evening. we have the department of family support services with us this evening uh we have to my right commissioner brandy canazi if you can introduce your staff and the members in the box and we will wave the reading of the opening statement and then go straight into questions thank you good evening chair and good good evening members of the city council with me this evening to my right, I have First Deputy Commissioner Maura McCauley. Next to her, I have Managing Deputy Commissioner Raymond Barrett. In the box from left to right, we have Andrea Chapman, Deputy Commissioner of Homeless Services and Gender-Based Violence, Danny Castaneda, Deputy Commissioner of Human Services, Shadra Lane, Deputy Commissioner of Youth Services, Margaret LaRavie, Deputy Commissioner of Senior Services, Saretha Burgess-Burnett, deputy commissioner of children services and mark sanders ii deputy commissioner of workforce development on the second row starting from left to right we have managing deputy commissioner frankie shipman amuo christina medina deputy commissioner of human resources and facilities yolanda curry deputy commissioner of senior services and kevin givens deputy commissioner of contracts it and programmatic monitoring thank you uh if you would like you want to give a brief opening statement Perfect. Good evening Chairman Irvin, Vice Chair Lee, and Honorable Members of the City Council. Thank you for the opportunity to present the Department of Family and Support Services budget for 2025. I want to start by recognizing and thanking Mayor Brandon Johnson, the Office of Budget and Management, and the City Council members here today. In a time of financial constraint, when the needs of Chicagoans are significant, you are tasked with making difficult decisions which will impact hundreds of thousands of lives. Our department's work is dedicated to serving the most vulnerable in our city, and I want to thank you for your support of our mission. You will see strategic investments in this budget that will continue to help and connect Chicagoans to the services they need to thrive. DFSS and our partners are champions at making the most out of difficult situations, and we continue to come together to innovate with our programming and create solutions for our clients. We pride ourselves on both providing efficient and effective services to Chicagoans with the highest level of need and moving the needle forward on creating a better, stronger, and a safer Chicago for everyone that calls Chicago home. This budget prioritizes programs that have demonstrated their value, investing in powerful, life-changing outcomes for Chicagoans. To help illustrate this point, I just want to highlight a few of our programs that we have achieved this year. first one is the chicago emergency financial assistance program for survivors of gender-based violence it is the largest cash assistance program in the nation dedicated to survivors it provides a one-time one thousand dollar assistant payment to survivors to date through a 10.7 million dollar investment we have helped over 8 000 survivors and their families this fund will continue next year through a 3.95 million dollar investment and allow us to serve an additional 300 survivors. Another pivotal program is the Spring Forward Pilot, which serves returning residents by pairing housing with workforce development and wraparound services. This initiative has successfully provided housing to 200 households, benefiting 263 individuals who are justice involved. In addition, 239 participants have completed job placement programs currently 59 clients are enrolled and 1 000 i'm sorry 106 participants have secured permanent employment another way we do this is for chicagoans facing homelessness through our rapid rehousing program since we started the program in 2020 i'm pleased to say that this proposal has provided 3 000 households with housing and we will continue with the seven million dollar investment in 2025 that will allow us to support 360 new households and maintain 1 000 households another investment is a 36.6 million dollar investment in homeless services bringing our total investment for homeless services to 115 million we'll continue to work to ensure equitable access across populations and to build a long-term resilient homeless response network We have also been able to support 74 people this year with scholarships through our Community Service Development Block Grant Scholarship. We will award 74 people scholarship grants between $1,000 and $5,000 to cover tuition, books, and other school fees for low-income families. And most importantly, we are able to say that this year we were able to serve nearly 28,000 young people through our One Summer Chicago for youth ages 14 to 24. This is 4,000 more young people than we had at the beginning of the pandemic. The 2025 budget provides a new investment of $19.9 million to support an additional 2,000 youth, bringing the total to 30,000 young people next year. And it includes 200 peacekeepers in the program. I just want to take a moment and recognize that our department's hardworking staff, they are the magic and the glue that make this work happen. The box today is filled with people who many days work late into the night and give up their weekends to get the job done. And they are really the magic and the people that we are just grateful to have. And along with our 340 DFSS staff who are not here in the chambers with us, who are deeply and personally invested in serving Chicagoans, we are lucky just to have this team. So I want to thank you for allowing me the opportunity to serve this great city, to represent the people that I care about most, those who are unseen, unheard, and sometimes forgotten. And I just look forward to taking your questions this evening. Thank you, Commissioner. First, Vice Chair Lee. Thank you, Chair. Commissioner Kennazzi, welcome back. Thank you. Great to see you and your team. I'm going to cover a couple things here. As chair of the Women's Caucus, we have a really great interest, and one of our biggest priorities for this budget was around gender-based violence. can you talk a little bit about what DFSS is doing around gender-based violence how many how many staff you have dedicated to it and if any of the cuts that that came with reductions impacted this work yeah so for our gender-based violence team we have a new investment of $400,000 next year that will support us to be able to provide training to frontline staff. So that includes people who are at our community centers, staff at departments who are frontline workers, shelter staff, anyone who comes across them that will allow us to provide that training and it's an enhancement on what the team has been doing this past year. So we've already done several departments, including the Department of Procurement Services. We also have a $100,000 for teen dating violence that will continue next year, as well as $400,000 will be allocated for the CDBG RFP that comes up in spring 2025 for legal services. So that will also be in the budget for the upcoming RFP. Starting this month, we just awarded a million dollars for DV coordinated response. WINGS is the provider and they will be able to support with UI Health 300 survivors in a hospital setting and helping them get a safety plan. We did see a decline in our home share fund, so I do want to just call that out of about a 1.1 million dollars. The home share fund is a revenue generating fund, and so due to the sensitivity around the hotel market, we've seen more people take up hotels than the home share stays, and so we did make reductions there, but we balanced that based off of actual expenditures and services used so we just brought agencies more in line with where they were spending so those funds from the um the home share funds it's meant to do um rapid rehousing for domestic violence um survivors so they're getting out of situation they need some place to say as i understand it that's what those funds are are meant to fund so did we utilize everything um or how how much have we spent so far this year You want to take the rapid rehousing? Or I forgot how to do it. So we had this year, sorry. We had $4.2 million allocated for rapid rehousing. To date, we have expended $1.6 million, so about 35%. That's 4.2 for this specific fund? For that specific fund. And so the service to date, we have housed 187 households old and 283 people are in case management what's the biggest barrier um I'm trying to get an idea of what the need is versus what are a capacity to to provide resources is seems like we have enough money but are there enough places to put people for housing or in these situations for the sort of in the immediate aftermath. Maura McCauley, First Deputy Commissioner. So we use a couple of different strategies to help survivors who are fleeing, need to flee their homes. We, through the Illinois Domestic Violence Hotline, which is a statewide hotline, housing and shelter is one of the greatest numbers of calls or chats or texts that the hotline receives. And so we have shelter beds that are available. We have about 162 shelter beds, including hotel shelter beds that we have recently added online. And then the rapid rehousing that is funded by the city through ARPA and Home Share is another way that survivors are able to quickly get into housing. The Chicago Continuum of Care also provides about 355 units of rapid rehousing for survivors. So it really takes multiple tools and approaches, not just from the city, but from multiple funding sources and partners. The other thing is the emergency financial assistance, the one-time cash assistance is really important because survivors reported using it to pay their rent, to pay for other things that was able to help them maintain their housing. So we know we need a number of tools to meet the need that we see. And how much is the emergency financial assistance per survivor, per person? It's $1,000 one time. Really not that much. But it's better than nothing. I think what, here's a couple things. It proves that cash works. We know that survivors are using it for their rent, right? On average, we see that survivors may have low income. And so this is helpful. It's helping them with their rent, with their food costs, and their utilities. So it's what we know about cash assistance that is a flexible form. Sometimes survivors are like, I just need to fix my car, or I need to be able to do X. And it allows them the space to get out of the situation they're in and get to safety. Great. Thank you. Sorry, my computer just went to sleep. Um, so a couple of us have, uh, uh, Alderman Fuentes has asked this question along with Alderman Haddon. Um, we are, we have asked if, uh, if that surcharge can be increased. We know that, uh, we know that, you know, people going to Airbnbs has gone down. Um, but we don't necessarily want that to impact negatively, um, the, the number of dollars that are available for this program. so hopefully we'll be able to make that happen so that we can make up that share of the um of the funds that were that we lost in this last year um can you you know um the the one system initiative um that we're we're moving to now um what do you think are going to be the biggest challenges just sort of out the gate for you know having i know we've been talking about a unified system for some time, Commissioner. And it's great that we're finally at a point where we are moving forward on that. In the next year, what do you think your biggest challenges are going to be? So maybe let's start with some of the things that we're going to be able to just, what's going to do for us. So for as long as I can remember, we've had 3,000 shelter beds in the homeless system. We're going to more than double that and go to 6,800 beds. So we're going to have more capacity in the system. And that's really going to help provide more resources, more options. I think the other piece to that is in partnership with the state, we're going to stand up. I can't think of the name. An access point. And the access point is going to allow people to have a place to go so you can have one central location so you can request shelter. And that's just really important so that people know you go to this location, you can request shelter. And so we won't have the situation where right now, if you go to a location, for example, you want, maybe you can't wait for shelter, right? So you'll be able to have those resources. And we're going to be able to leverage the best practices we have in our homeless system that we've always had, as well as the best practices in our new arrival system. I think bringing the system together, we're going to see better data. We're going to see better technical assistance. and with our new providers, we just recently awarded our shelters to Clio and Brightstar. They're going to be part of our delegate agency community with our 51 shelter partners. And so everybody will be part of that team learning, growing, and achieving together. I think what you'll see in the beginning is anytime you do a new system, right, it's the storming, forming, norming before you get to performing. And so there's always just challenges of things we don't think of. I think we have a very dedicated, smart team. But, you know, in the beginning, there may be hiccups on it as we work with shelter placement and making sure that we have beds in order to do that. And so I think those are things that we'll have to work through on the ground. And that happens anytime you do any new program. It doesn't matter if it's homeless, if it's youth, if it's senior services. Whenever you're setting up a new program, there's just growing pains that you have to work through. But I think what we're going to be able to do is what we'll see is between the $2 million that the state is putting towards resettlement, we're going to be able to work to resettle families, right? Reconnect them with family and friends, do diversion. And so that's going to help bring the population down in the shelters. We also have the new $7 million investment in rapid rehousing. That's going to help to support individuals and get them housed. we've seen great success with that. That's how we got to the 3,000 households. So those two interventions on their own will create space in the shelter that will allow us to bring more people in and take up shelter. The second piece to that is the $30 million that we have, which is an investment from the Department of Housing and Commissioner Castaneda. And so her and her team have been really aggressive in helping us bring on 300 new shelter beds. So next month, we have Northside Housing, they're opening their new shelter through that program, 70 beds for men. Former shelters are going through the process. La Casa Norte recently closed on their site. So as we turn over, these are shelters that are going to be non-congregate. When it's a non-congregate, more people are coming in. Plus, the $40 million we have at DFSS for shelter renovations will allow us to take 10 shelters and renovate them, improve accessibility, and take them from congregate to non-congregates. So that's going to be another thousand beds. So I think all of these different strategies will support one system. And so, yeah, it's going to be a little painful when you start, you know, and as we're getting going, but I think by first quarter, beginning of second quarter, we're going to start to see the fruit of this labor. And I think things are going to start to pay off. Chair, if I may, I just have one through the chair request and one last question. You told me you had two questions. And then like more questions popped up on my screen. I can't help that there's like a gremlin in here. You got somebody, somebody feeding you nonsense. Go ahead. Gremlin named Zoe. Okay. The through the chair request is, can you provide through the chair, just all the things that you just rattled off with the shelters that are coming online and the shelters that are closing and then when they're closing. My next question is just, are we looking at different types of shelters? low barrier shelters shelters specifically for families I'm thinking of a lot of the people that we run across that you know are are living on the streets now and I'm not talking about migrants at all I'm talking um specifically about you know it might be a homeless veteran that has a dog um and doesn't want to part with the with with their pet um and that's the thing that's keeping them out on the street um so I just wanted to ask a question about how are we approaching that and You know, how does that, how will that manifest itself in this new one system? So with the shelters that are staying online for the 3800, the majority are family shelters, and that is where we see a need. I think we'll have to work with our shelter partners and resize based on what the need is as we get into this in second quarter, right? We have to work with what we have now because the majority of people in shelters are families. But I think as we transition, we'll work to make sure that the shelter type is meeting the needs of the people who are actually seeking shelter. Because we don't want to have beds, but then we have beds, but it's not the type of people who need them, right? So we want to make sure that there is a match and a fit. We love low barrier shelters as a team. We have one, and I think we're really likely to have Franciscan as a partner. Low barrier shelters are very hard, and they're more costly because they're low barrier. And so when we released two RFPs last year and the year before, we didn't get any takers. And so I think we have to help shelter partners turn the corner on the pandemic. They have talked about the cost of shelter beds and having the rising cost of their infrastructure and their operations. And then being able to retain staff. You know, nonprofits have seen across the social service sector just have been decimated just because people have been really burned out. And so I hope we can try it again. I just don't know if it'll be in the 2025 year. Got it. Thank you very much. I'm done, Chair. Thank you, Vice Chair. We're going to roll just in straight order here. We'll start with Chair Harris. I don't have a lot. I don't have any questions. I have been briefed on this like this be my second time. So but I want to say thank you so very much for all that you all do. You are a very hardworking department. And I will say that everybody that works for you has the spirit of getting things done. So I am so appreciative to all of you for coming out and being out here so late with us tonight. And thank you for all that you do. This has been very difficult for us to coming out of the shelter issue and creating a brand new program. Now, tell me the brand new program I think you just told, just give me a a brief, brief kind of summary, because they done talked to me three times about this. And I kind of know the answers, but I do want other people to know what we're doing in terms of creating a new process that works for everybody. And so if my staff is listening, not that they are, they probably at home in a bed asleep by now. But if you could just kind of go through, if I call you and I say, I have a homeless person or a homeless, I'm going to use a woman with children, and what that process now looks like in our new program. So good news is you will still call 311, right? Individuals will call 311 for shelter and shelter placement. By the end of the year, December, we're going to stand up a temporary access point in partnership with the state. So we will also have a physical location where people can go and request shelter and wait for shelter. We're working through the hours of that, right? temporarily, it may be just eight to eight. But long term, our goal is to get to 24 seven, but we've got to get there, as I was telling Vice Chair Lee, right? And so the goal is that it will not be you go to the landing zone for new arrivals, and then you call 311. If you're an existing Chicagoan, it will be everyone will go through one point, we will go from 3000 beds in the shelter system to 6800. We've never been able to more than double our capacity. People are asking, how will we get there? How will you go for? So what we've seen, as you recall, beginning of the year, we had 15,000 people in our new arrival shelters. Over the course, we have stood up over 40 new arrival shelters. We're bringing that down. We're phasing out shelters and we will have three shelters that we're maintaining from the city. The state will maintain two. That's how we get the extra 3,800 capacity. all of those beds will be part of one system. So people will go, they'll call, and they will request shelter in the order that they come in. Part of what we'll look through of what the team will do with our shelter providers is think through how do you prioritize people, right, based on the length that you've been homeless, your age, your medical vulnerabilities, if you have children. So those will be things as we get through how we kind of shape this out. But beginning, it'll be first come, your first come first serve in line and we will get through those additional prioritizations is there anything you want to add more that's it thank you thank you for all that you do again this has been a big deal standing up the the new creating a very new process that's going to be new for the entire city council in my career this will be like a first for me to have wanted to have that want to have this many beds and so I'm really happy about having the additional beds and I think that as we go through it as a city we may not be able to end homelessness but we certainly will be able to get people that want to be housed out. And one thing I'll just add is that the shelters that we have as we transition the ones that will be staying online we have RFP'd for those and so So we have Brightstar, so Pastor Harris, we have Cleo, Tori Barrett. And so they will also participate in our active contract management. They will be in our meetings with our other homeless providers. And so it won't be this shelter versus that system. It'll be everyone's coming together and we're looking at the same goals, the same outcomes. And I think what people have always wanted here was the feeling of equity that as a citizen, and that's been here for a house here for a long time, that no one comes behind me or in front of me and gets steps over me, that I have the same rights as anybody else and that I have the right to experience those benefits. So I think that this creating this new system really works for the city. Thank you. All right, thank you, Chair Harris. Autumn Scott. I don't have any questions. Just wanted to say thank you to your team. You know, I know that these last two years have been very challenging with the migrant crisis. And, you know, you've had to put up a strong line of defense. And so with that, thank you. It's not always an easy task, but you all have made the task. And so thank you, and thank you for your service. Thank you. Thank you, all the scotch. So left to the rookies, all right. All the men Gutierrez. Thank you, Chairman. Just wanted to congratulate you and your team again to join my colleagues. Recently, we had some cases of homeless living under bridges in some of our alleys here in the 14th Ward. And nothing but amazing response from your team. And just here to continue to support. And just thank you to all of you for the great work that you're doing for our city. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Thank you, Alderman Gutierrez. Alderman Fuentes. Thank you, Chairman. First, I want to say thank you. You're probably my favorite department. Just don't tell nobody else that, all right? No, seriously, I think that all of the work that you all have done around the migrant mission, around scaling up services for unhoused neighbors, supporting me specifically in the 26th Ward, I mean, you all, anytime I pick up the phone, you all answer and you go above and beyond. So if I haven't extended my gratitude and said thank you, thank you for all that you do and all the work that you're going to continue to do. But you're here this evening, so I'm going to make it worthwhile, and I got some questions. All right. So first, thank you for all of the work in entertaining the restructuring of some programs, One Summer Chicago, and really making Peacebook possible, expanding the pilot, making sure we're getting more peacekeepers into our neighborhoods. One of the things that we did struggle with in particular was documentation for young people, right? Some young people don't have birth certificates or don't have socials or don't have a photo ID. And it was extremely challenging in the process, right, to help young people sort of get all those documents in place so that we could get them employed through the summer. Is there an opportunity to sort of have an information sharing agreement with CPS? Because we know these young people go into school and they have to enroll with these documents. CPS has them. Is there an opportunity to do that so that there is a way to obtain these documents so young people can work? We should have a conversation with CPS. I can't say that, you know, data sharing is a thing. So, and sometimes I'll say that data sharing takes longer, but it never hurts to ask. All right. Perfect. I can help start that conversation. Perfect. In regards to the initiatives around homelessness, does the increase in funding make any provisions for extreme weather flexible shelter options? So let's talk about the work that we're doing with extreme weather. So there are a couple different things that we have. Sorry. first thing is around the fact that we have in our budget funding for extreme weather so when that happens we work with our shelter partners to extend their hours so we have two shelters that are 12 hours and we extend them during extreme weather to 24 hours the second thing that we're doing right now is asking our shelter partners who can expand beds for the winter. And so we usually get between one to 200 beds that are expanded. We have a RFP for gender-based violence that'll bring on about 40 hotel beds that closed, I believe, today. We also have an RFP that will bring on for our regular homeless system about 60 beds. So that will close shortly. In addition, like I talked about, the $30 million that we have with DOH. So La Casa, not La Casa Norte, but Northside Housing, they will open their doors. They actually have a ribbon cutting the December 6th. So that will bring on 70 beds for men. And then we're in the process with the other four of either La Casa Norte has closed on their shelter. And then others are in some form of their zoning has approved or they're looking for a site. So with all of those five shelters, we're going to see 300 new beds that will come online in the next year. We also have an RFP that will be, or an RFQ, or it was a RFQ that we're moving to phase two. Those 10 pre-qualified shelters will be able to receive funding to support their shelter infrastructure. So taking their congregate spaces to non-congregate spaces, that'll support an additional 1,000 beds that will be renovated and become more accessible, more private rooms, improved bathrooms, et cetera. So those are some of the things that we're doing. But I think it's also important to remember that we have 300 city sites across the city that serve as warming centers outside of DFSS. And so we leverage those. We also have our first deputy commissioner, Maura McCauley. She's been working very closely with OEMC mayor's office to make sure that we have really strong communication across all of our city departments that we are one band, one beat, one sound. And that's really helped so that we're all, you know, doing synchronized swimming. But the last part is under the leadership of Deputy Commissioner Andrea Chapman, we have our outreach team that will go out. And so they'll do extended hours. We also use that additional winter funding that we have to expand the winter hours for our five outreach agencies. And then we bring together their seven outreach agencies that are funded outside of DFSS through the Chicago Continuum of Care. We work with them to coordinate during extreme weather as well so that we are, you know, dividing and conquering and being more effective, not stepping on each other's toes. So it's multiple strategies that we leverage for extreme weather to make sure that we're able to, you know, effectively see and serve individuals who need our help. Thank you. And then the centers are both for extreme weather, for hot, cold. How about poor air quality? Well, we have actually had to use them for poor air quality, so yes. And so we will continue to do that? Yes. Thank you. So that usually, again, that's in partnership with Executive Director Toronto. That's with our Deputy Mayor. We usually coordinate to make sure that we're synchronized around that. Perfect. Appreciate it. So we know, and we've had this conversation, shelters are woefully underfunded and have been for many years, particularly the per bed per day rate at about $30, right? Where some folks have been wanting the actual cost to be at least 60 to 90 days per day per bed. What are some of your thoughts about how we can get there? What does the overall cost in the budget look like to make that shift? Obviously, we're facing a major deficit in this particular budget, but what sort of pathway do you see in the foreseeable future for us to be able to increase funding for shelter beds? So first, I want to thank this body for investing in our shelters. About seven years ago, our shelter bed rate, some shelters were receiving $6 per bed per day, which does not really cover the full cost of operations. And so today, on average, our shelters are about making about $26 per bed per day on average, a little bit higher for some of our non-congregate shelters. The cost to raise that, to bring everybody in line to $35 per bed per day, is about $9.9 million. and that would support about 42 shelter programs across 2,700 beds. Thank you. That's helpful. So moving to senior services, in this budget, do we see any cuts to senior services or senior centers? We did not make any cuts to senior services or senior centers. Thank you. and is there a way to work on promptly paying vendors who continue to deliver care? I know procurement is a thing. I know the reimbursement cycle is a thing. Have we looked at sort of like efficiency, structure changes? I see some nodding heads, so that makes me excited. Yes. So Raymond Barrett, Managing Deputy Commissioner of Administration, thank you for the question, Alder. So one thing that we do really streamline is since last summer, they may want to order to any time we have an accurate invoice from an agency. We do ensure payment within 30 days. And so that has been very consistent. The part, though, that is a little difficult to your process, mentioning the question that you were talking about, is that with our agencies, we're trying to continually provide technical support, especially when there's a lot of turnover or just lack of knowledge on the finance side. I used to be on the nonprofit side, had to do the operations of it, doing the HR. It's a lot of work. And so we see that with a lot of our agencies. So what our admin teams do is give that one-on-one customer service so they understand how to voucher any procurement. So they understand how we want to do documentation for reimbursements. That's where we see the greatest success is giving them that one-on-one support to ensure that they have those accurate invoices and they get paid within 30 days. Thank you. And then I have about 60 seconds left. So can you just tell me the number of year-round employment positions, the number of Chicago Youth Service Corps positions, and the number of summer Chicago positions in the 2025 budget? So for 2025, we will have 360 Chicago Youth Service Corps positions. We'll have 7,480 Chicagobility positions, 11,500 SIEP, so your traditional one summer. We'll have 225 MyShy, MyFuture safe spaces, so that's also year-round. We'll have 300 year-round employment slots, bringing the total for DFSS to 10,139 slots plus, oh I'm sorry, I got that wrong. That'll bring the total to 19,865 slots for DFSS and then 10,139 and add that to our, so that's our citywide partner. So that's CHA, CPS, parks, CTA, all of them. So they are 10,139. Our total is 19,865. And the total slots we had for 2024 for DFSS was 16,760. So total of 3,105 slots. That's additional slots we're adding next year. Awesome. Thank you. Thank you for all the work you all do. Thank you. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Autumn Cruz. Thank you, Chairman. I like this. There's not a lot of people we can, rookies can get go fairly quickly. So thank you, Commissioner. I also want to express my gratitude to you and your team for always be willing to work with my team and addressing some of the issues that we have in the ward. Barf have nothing but great things to say about your team. So I appreciate that. My questions go on, some of my questions go on for about carry-on funds. So whether it's grant money not spent within the year. So I'm going to focus from year 2024 proposed to year 2025. It seems that there is a 10.8 million from CCAP slash side administrate in and 116.3 million from PI slash PFA. And also there's another 52.6 million of Head Start funding. So when it comes to my questions, it's like, what's the reason identified by DFSS for the growing of unused funds? Thank you, Alder, for that question. Raymond Barrett, Managing Deputy Commissioner. there. So there's two pieces to this. One is that the appropriation ordinance is done by Office of Budget and Management. So the terminology of carryover funding and the determination of carryover funding for appropriation reasons is determined by them. But to your point, all those grants that you actually refer to, there is no carryover funding we spend within the allotment of that period. And that carryover funding that you're seeing in this budget book is purely for appropriation reasons. Those actual, those three grants that you mentioned are on a different calendar year than us. So the Child Care Services Grant is on July 1st. The PFAPI, which is part of the Early Childhood Black Grant grant, is also on July 1st to June 30th. And then the Head Start grants are December 1st to November 30th. So factoring in our calendar year and our appropriation authority, there is some calculation done by OBM. But to your point though, there isn't carryover funding we spend within the term of the grant. Okay, so there's no way there's a carryover. Again, everything has to spend within that year. Correct. Okay, perfect. That clarifies my second question. What are your plans for raising compensation for child care and early learning workers? Great question, Aldenwoman. So in the beginning of 2025, we'll be releasing our new Chicago Early Learning RFP. Right now, we are waiting to determine if CPS will give us a piece of their funding. So their new funding that's flowing down through the governor's office for Smart Start dollars. We're not sure how that funding allocation will flow down to us. But if it does, we'll leverage those funds to increase our preschool for all and preschool intervention funds for our state slots. If it doesn't, we'll have to look with OBM at other options to support raises to our slots for early learning. Have in previous year, have you received that money from CPS? This is an additional money. So we get our regular allocation. So we expect that, and that's what Raymond said runs July 1st to June 30th. This is an additional assessment on top of that regular allotment. Okay. Now my questions go regarding shelters. Okay. Do you have an average, like a ballpark figure, how much it costs yearly to operate? So let's say a shelter for 100 people with overnight emergency. like at a ballpark? So on average, what we understand is it's about $60 to $70 per bed per day. $60 to $70? Yes. Per day. Okay. Per bed per day. And I ask this because that, you know, when it comes to shelters, especially overnight shelters, you know, people don't have that opportunity to have overnight shelters. And even on the northwest side, something that, you know, we're working and I'm working closely with our state leaders is to have a shelter in the northwest side because the need is definitely there. So with the one system initiative that we have, are there any plans to create something in the northwest side for shelters, whether it's overnight, whether it's a regular system that we have, any plans? Right now we have not identified one. So the shelters that are coming are existing shelters that we have from the new arrival system. So it's the American Islamic College, the Young Women's Leadership Academy, and MWRD. Those are the three city shelters that will remain open. Right now, in terms of our shelter acquisition, we do have a shelter provider, Cornerstone, that is looking for a site. So we'd be more than happy to connect you with Cornerstone to see if there is a space that's viable in the ward and that they would be interested in. Okay. And on average, how long does it take for someone to get a shelter? So if they go to 311, they put in the request, what is the average time? I'm going to pass that one to Deputy Commissioner Andrea Chapman. Hi, Deputy Commissioner Andrea Chapman. On average, when there is a shelter bed available, we're able to move an individual or family into that bed within a matter of a day because of the capacity of our provider that does our senior well-beings, our crisis response, and our fire and relocation. But when there is no bed available, that average time to get someone into a bed is just a little bit over 19 days. and i asked that because we had a situation where it took about 12 days so we're trying to see if it's within the range um my final question is a bit from this book here um you know the the fss department of family services um the requests are there compared to last year it seems that the average age days are way higher than last year compared to this year. Is it because of the migraine situation? Is it because services have changed? Is this book right here? Yeah. Question? I'm sorry. I didn't understand your question. Can you repeat your question? So from last year, from 2024, for the average age and days for services, for example, like a shelter request, crisis referral, the timing for this year, the average, it has significantly has changed on how long it takes to address some of these issues. I'm just wondering what has changed and why the difference now? Thank you for your question, Alder. Again, Andrea Chapman, Deputy Commissioner for Homeless and Gender-Based Violence. A large part of the aging of those SRs that we're seeing in our Salesforce through 311 calls really did have a lot to do with a large number of old cases. in our system due to the new arrivals mission. And earlier part of this year, there was a large closeout to all of those old cases, which then we were able to really see the true aging and timing of how long it takes us to do those placements and support in some of these other service areas. But for some of the cases, capacity of our delegate really does play a large role, right? the high demand the supply and demand of our shelter system is an issue the high demand for shelters limited bed availability is always a factor and then staff capacity as we've heard today many of our delegate agencies are still struggling with staffing issues as they are trying to meet the high demand they're having a hard time hiring and retaining staff so those things always play into that but this also the same delegate that is doing all of the requests that you're seeing on the DFS side of this work those relocations the shelter crisis response senior well-being and fire assistance all being done by the same delegate agency and so it's the same team trying to really manage this large body of work and so you do see those things increase and we want to make sure that our delegates can efficiently and effectively meet the need. So sometimes you'll see that wait time, like for instance, with our senior well-beings, you're now seeing that those are, for us, what we're showing is from case, from the time the 3-1-1 call is placed in the case closure, it's about four and a half days. But that really is because they do multiple visits over the course of those days. Same thing with fire assistance. They don't close those cases out right away. Red Cross actually has to indicate that they no longer and need support from that agency before the case can be closed out. So if Red Cross has not stabilized that family, they won't have our delegate close out that case. Same thing with our crisis referrals. They go out, the team goes out on multiple occasions to try and support the individual or family before closing that out. So that's with some of those cases, when you see six days or five days, four days from the call to the case closure, a lot of that has to do with the repeated effort or other agencies that they're working with before the case is considered completed alderman and then maura has the actual number some numbers maura mccauley first deputy commissioner um as deputy commissioner chapman mentioned we did close out a number of the really um long um cases due to the new arrivals mission so i can just read our actual average days compared to the chart that you have in your book um so average days from so here's the average days from the three one call but the 311 call to case closure the relocation request is taking 52.14 days shelter request about 19 days um for when it closes out a crisis referral 6.7 days fire assistance 6.11 senior well-being check requests 4.53 um so it's it's it is lower than what is in your book and deputy commissioner chapman just provided yeah a lot of thank you for the context yeah because the numbers are are completely different so it makes more sense when it comes to like last year like you just mentioned senior well-being the correlation is different but yes now it makes sense thank you for the clarification and again thank you for all the work thank you Alderman Manohapamore. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Commissioner Kennazzi, and thank you to your entire team. It's been a very long day, and I appreciate that you're all here, because you should be here to listen to the flowers that people want to give you. you do the work that is really essential and I'm glad to see how much investment has been put into your programs for survivors for gender-based violence and in our ward in our police districts beyond you know calls for service that have to do with automobiles cars domestic violence and related incidents is um the reason for calls for service to 9-1-1 so i can thank you enough for that um and i also want to say that i i really do believe that we need to increase the home share tax back to four percent it wouldn't impact our budget um and it's something that's absolutely needed um because because i will say this um my ward has very it's very diverse across ethnicities and a lot of people that i asked on the street what their issue was many of the women that i spoke to said was domestic violence and they just need an alternative um versus calling 9-1-1 so um thank you for that i wanted to ask about i'm very concerned about the next four years especially our immigrant population and um central romero has been in the asian american museum of chicago they've been incredible partners in the 48th ward and they have helped reach 200 200, 2,697 people in the 48th ward to help pave the way for, you know, better life for them and their families, facilitating personal and community connections, and connecting them with vital resources through the community navigators programs. And I had a couple questions that I'm not sure if you can address now, but does the Legal Protection Fund help DACA recipients that are needing assistance with DACA renewals or inquiries? You know, in my own office, my director is a DACA recipient, and so this is very personal to me, and we have inquiries too. Is that something that you can comment on? So our current provider is NIJC, the National Immigrant Justice Center. I'm not sure. I'm going to ask, Mark, do you know if they do DACA legal assistance? Yes, they do anything related to immigrant legal services. They are capable of providing that support. They usually refer, deal with the more difficult cases that require extended time periods in court, but those are the types of cases that they are able to address. Mark Sanders II, Deputy Commissioner of Workforce Services. Thank you. Thank you. Can you speak on the level of investment that you have in the legal protection fund? So this year, our budget for legal protection fund is $3 million. On the corporate fund, it's $1.55 million. On ARPA funds, it's $1.45 million. that will sustain for 2025. And right now we have an RFP that closes today. Very good. We'd like to see that continue even without the ARPA funds. I had a question about we have very, we trend older adults in my ward, in the 48th ward. And I wanted to say thank you so much to Margaret and Andrea and the whole team for helping with so many issues that we have in the ward for being so responsive. Thank you very much for that. Did we ever have a Department on Aging? So prior to 2011, DFSS was five or six different departments. It was Mayor's Office of Workforce Development, Department on Aging, Department on Human Services, children and youth all of those different departments merged into one creating the department of family and support services so the department of aging merged into dfss and is now reborn as the senior services division i get it okay thank you thank you so much i know that we were part of that network at the broadway armory and we've been through a lot in the last year and half. So I appreciate that. I wanted to, we, of course, we want our seniors to stay. We want them to age in place. And there's a lot to coordinate there. So I just want to make sure that senior services are going to be continued to be funded at the current level. Senior services are continuously funded. Okay. Are there, is there any opportunity for rental assistance for low-income seniors? We have a rental assistance program through our six community service centers in And so it does have income requirements. And as well as individuals have one of the requirements of CSBG or the Community Services Block Grant is that individuals have to show that once their rent is paid, that they will be able to sustain their rent through income. And so individuals can apply. I would say that going into next year, the areas that we prioritize are fire, flood, and gender-based violence victims, but it's open to all individuals. Thank you for that. I wanted to shout out to Chandra, Selena, and Angelica for their assistance, and also the street operations team for helping so much. Debbie DeLopez? She's streets and sanitation. Oh, not here. Okay. There's so much coordination that needs to happen. And, you know, when we're talking about our houseless neighbors, and I appreciate the help. And, you know, we are speaking to our neighbors so much about what you do and the outreach teams. And it's a very important thing to highlight. I wish there was more out there because I think that it's all the workers that do outreach. It's a lot. so I just wanted to to say all that because we struggle you know even today you know out on Lakeshore, DeSauble Lakeshore Drive along the lakefront we're struggling and so thank you for your coordination with other agencies and I also want to pitch that we we're very grateful for the accelerated moving events that we had in the ward and, you know, through all of the Lakefront wards, we really appreciate it so much. We would love to see something actually on the calendar for the first quarter of next year or even sooner, thank you, because it works, you know. We want more than 60 people, more than 60 people that we have already helped through this program. And I really do believe it's something that we need to talk more about because people want to know what are we doing it's really hard to watch our neighbors struggle um but i know it works um somebody on on the sidewalk as i'm walking around in edgewater told me so you know he was there for five years um in the tents and changing yes it's life-changing and mccutcheon school which is on the border of 48 and 46 You know, they have 360 students there. Eighty-nine of them are housing insecure. Three of them are living in the tents. This is unacceptable for children to be living in the tents. If you know of children living in a tent, can you talk to us afterwards? It is illegal for children to be outside. And so if you come across that, you can give myself, Maura McCauley, Andrea Chapman, or even Selena a call, and we will work on that immediately. Thank you. I really appreciate that. I worry very much about them every day. Thank you for your comments about the early childhood program and all your work on My Chi, My Future. All of these programs are so important. I have so many questions for you. I want to continue to work with you, especially when it comes to violence interruption. And this is not just on the south and the southwest sides of Chicago. It's everywhere. In my ward, we're very transit-rich next to the red line. And we welcome everybody. And we all need to figure out what we're doing. Because a lot of instances of gun violence in my ward have involved youth and not necessarily residents of the 48th Ward. So it's a citywide, gun violence is a citywide epidemic. And so I would like that to be prioritized as well. Beyond that, I just want to say thank you again. And you made it. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. All right. Thank you, Alderman. I'll hop on work for Alderman Coleman. Thank you, Chairman, Commissioner Soros. Always a pleasure to you and the entire team. Senior Fest was such a hit. Thank you for coming. Yeah, that was so much fun. It was. Well, how much does that cost? I laugh. Do you know Raymond? Raymond Barrett, Managing Deputy Commissioner of Administration. So we actually have around $85,000 in our corporate budget that is set aside each year for Senior Fest. But I can say that Yolanda, who's in the box, does everything she can to get other in-kind matches. She's constantly working with other agencies and departments, et cetera, to chip in where they can. But in our budget, it's about $85,000. Does Millennium Park charge? Millennium Park does charge. have we ever considered going to a park district that won't charge i know there are some union fee i know they they're fee heavy over there shout out to millennium park but they worked with us okay charged but they did work with us i think the the hard part and i'll let yolanda speak to it is because we're bringing seniors from all across the city north siders don't want to go all the way south finding a location because we did smaller little neighborhood fest when during the pandemic but when you want to bring 5 000 seniors to one location grant park is the best venue to do that yolanda is there anything you want to add or union or union yolanda commissioner um i think when we talk about the total cost of senior fest it was a little over $200,000. But again, we leverage partnerships with other agencies. We actually have sponsorship opportunities from other corporate partners, as well as some contributions from other city departments to actually bring back Senior Fest. Okay. It was great. It was nice. But when I saw some of the, I know some of the fees at Millennium Park and even we as a Black Caucus, we've decided to activate our park districts in terms of the scholarship. So I just want to maybe make that investigated for 2025. Yeah, to maybe cut some costs that could go to other resources for that day. What's the cost per day per bed? For shelters? For shelters. Right now, on average our shelters receive about 26 per bed per day um for we have a few congregate shelters that receive a little bit more about 45 per bed per day and does that include meals they pay for the meals that's within the 26 right so in the homeless system we pay that average cost because we are typically not the only funder for shelters in our existing system so they may leverage other federal funding or their state funding they may also fundraise and so we are one funding stream of many that they may have um and so that we pay a portion but we've over the last five to six years we've worked to get all of our shelters up to that minimum 26 dollars i remember when i started some shelters were receiving about six dollars per bed per day wow so we've this body through council has really worked with us to bring those bed rates up. Who's doing the, I think you acknowledge who's in our box doing the outreach for the additional locations and then what does that look like? There's a new organization called Holistic Alliance in my ward that have transformed like 10 unit buildings and they're able to have 40 beds. with wraparound services, 24-hour surveillance. So I think that may be, what do you think, Maura? I would say that would probably be for one of our shelter RFPs. RFPs will go out next spring through the Community Development Block Grant that OBM releases. They'll release them in springtime, so like April, May. I would say that when that is released, it's not just DFSF funding, but it'll be any department that has delegate funding. So Department of Housing, CDPH, we'll all release our funding opportunities at that time. That will be one. I believe CDPH is already working with the provider on their stabilization housing. That would have been another opportunity. But in terms of renovations, we'll be doing that. And so our providers will be looking for general contractors. Okay. So they already have the, they have buildings, they have properties and they're looking. So I think that would be good for our rapid rehousing. Yeah. Right. Like that is what they're currently doing with the state. Gotcha. So that would say, go through our, um, the Chicago continuum of care, all Chicago and their Chicago rents program. They could be a landlord to us. Okay. But to know anyone in the box, I'll get some more information. Andrea. Okay. Wonderful. do you still have the re-entry in your house or is it now with Deputy Mayor of Gatewood? We still have it so we have the five re-entry centers and Mark can talk about the success of those but we also have Spring Forward so that selected pre-enrollment with intensive navigation going forward where we wrap individuals with job training so a traditional job as well as housing assistance. And so we've been able to support about 200 households that have a family member who was touched by the carceral system with, you know, some people have their loved ones, their children, 263 individuals have been housed and about 109 individuals have gone through the program and have full-time permanent jobs. And then Mark, do you want to talk about the re-entry centers? Well, I don't have time for Mark. Oh, okay. Yeah. But how, how is this re-entry and the Office of Reentry under Public Safety coordinating? Well, so Joseph Mapp and Mark are meeting on a regular basis. We're managing the services that we have at DFSS, but what the Office of Reentry and Joseph Mapp does is really look holistically across the city departments to make sure. So for example, Streets and Sand has reentry support as well as animal care and control. So it's making sure that we're seeing each other, that we're looking at the Department of human resources, their hiring practices. And so it's more coordination and being overarching of all of us so that each of us are playing our role. Okay. And the domestic violence programs? Domestic violence programs are going well. We have the... The two project managers. What specifically? I see. I'm sorry. I'm looking at the recommendation for two project managers for domestic violence program. Oh, on the program. I think Ream is going to take that question. Who and what do they do? We just had a hearing regarding violence against Black women and missing women and girls on last week. and had I known that this was under the umbrella DFSS, the two project managers would have been great to... I think Adriana was at the hearing. She was here in the box. Okay. Adriana, sorry, Andrea, do you want to talk about the work that the project managers in the gender-based violence section, the two that are corporate, not your ARPA PMs. Andrea Chapman, Deputy Commissioner for Homeless and Gender-Based Violence. Our project managers really work around providing training, education, prevention awareness, and working with our multidisciplinary teams to make sure that they are engaging in the community, They are supporting survivor services and advocating and connecting survivors with the services and resources that we have. They have done trainings throughout our GBV 101 training has been done throughout multiple city departments, our new arrival shelter. They will be in 2024 and 2025 training all of our shelter providers and doing a lot of public facing training as well. But those two project managers really do work to really make sure that we're coordinating, collaborating with multiple departments, multiple agencies around services and support for survivors of gender-based violence. Only two to cover the city of Chicago? Well, that's just on the corporate fund. That's just the corporate fund. We, oh, sorry. Go for it. uh rame and barrett uh so we actually have eight they have eight staff within the the gbv division i believe it's um majority of them are project managers and there is a supervisor of a family sport so it's mostly grant funded positions but there are two corporate positions okay are they um are they working with cpd in terms of their caps and the domestic violence because what we found, which is very disheartening, that there is not much partnership with CPD around domestic violence and providing those wraparound services for victims. So through our multidisciplinary team, the team supports that work with CPD. So they're working with them. They also work with our delegate agency. So we have Family Rescue is our DV provider that's through the state, and they're in our six community service centers. And so what the project managers do is they launch new initiatives, they manage the existing things, but also they're making sure they're doing the training. So that additional funding we have for expanded training, they're running that training right now until we get a delegate agency and helping to coordinate and attend at the Gender-Based Violence Task Force. and with the gender chairman may I have a couple of more questions I noticed the 500,000 the increase in that funding what will that be specifically for that's for the gender-based violence training that we're expanding to go to frontline staff at the city our shelter provider so that they can recognize the signs know how to identify gender-based violence and know where to refer people and then just in general when it comes up we just feel like it's important to have people to have that expanded training so the pms will be supporting the rollout of that program they'll do the rfp they'll help roll it out and then we have the youth services program where we're doing the youth training for young people as well in our schools so what is actually for victims in the portfolio we can go through it so in our funding allocation for 2025 we have the emergency cash assistance program so that's 3.95 million dollars and that's going to support 3 000 survivors with one-time payments we have our dv shelter hotel and housing so we released an rfp i believe that closed today that will bring on 40 hotel rooms for gender-based violence survivors. We have next year $1.7 million in counseling and case advocacy, $1.5 million in coordinated response in our multidisciplinary team, about $2.6 million in legal services, $1.8 million in prevention, $1.2 million in our Children's Survivor Services Fund, and then $1.5 million for youth who are impacted by gender-based violence. So the total is about $19.1 million. How much is that one-time payment? The one-time payment is $1,000. And is that case-by-case basis? Is it a certain time to apply? It's on a rolling basis per month. So the application opens every month, so a supplier can apply any time. they can go to the DV hotline, the domestic violence hotline. The network is the administrator for the program. So they can call 1-877-TOEND-DV. So 1-877-2END-DOMESTIK-VILENCE-DV. And you said the hotline, they do the intake of the information, and then who determines? They'll determine. They are the administrator for the program. The hotline? The hotline. The network. The network, is that in-house? No, the network is a nonprofit that we fund. Are they in Chicago? They are in Chicago. Where are they located? They have an office downtown. I believe it's on LaSalle. Do you know, Andrea? I don't have the exact address. They just moved into a new office. They were previously at the FSS central office and just recently in the last couple months moved into a new office downtown. Okay. Through the chair, could you give me the nationality, demographic, and age of the victims that were awarded last year? We'll see what we can provide you on that. But we can get you demographics, and we can also share how they use the funding. The majority, and I can tell you this, and we might actually have it in the book. Hold on. The majority of the funds, the survivors, were African American. Here we have it. In 2023, 79% of recipients resided on the south and west sides of Chicago, 63% identified as African American, 28% as Latinx, 86% of the recipients identified as female. The top 15 communities that received cash assistance from this program were Auburn-Gresham, South Shore, Chatham, Lawndale, South Chicago, Woodlawn, Roseland, West Garfield Park, Chicago Lawn, Humble Park, Englewood, Austin, Grand Boulevard, Near West Side, and West Englewood. Okay. So the network, they would have that breakdown, right? Can they break it down by Ward as well? We'll see what we can get you. Of the recipient? We'll see what we can get you. Okay. As always, thank you. Congratulations on just a job well done. I look forward to working with the department specifically on the domestic violence as we are now supporting black women who obviously 79% have used the hotline, but really hearing and supporting violence against black women. Thank you. We look forward to partnering with you. thank you uh on coleman uh on the fuentes thank you chair uh just a few more questions um for the rfp process for applications are we going to be providing technical assistance or have organizations help smaller organizations uh that may need support in that rfp i know we've done technical assistance before? Do we intend to do that, particularly for RFPs around one summer? So what we do for our RFPs, for all of them, regardless of what program division they're in, is we'll do a webinar that will go over how to apply. It'll answer any specific questions that potential respondents have, and it'll go over the application in terms of what the requirements are in the scope, what the outcome metrics that we'll be tracking, what the reporting requirements are. There's also an evaluation criteria section that we'll go over so people understand. And we tell them in the RFP, these are the sections, organizational capacity, community involvement, past experience. We look at their financials. It'll tell them the points per category. And then if they have any questions, we'll do a written addendum and answer it through that amendment process awesome thank you i'm glad we at least answer the questions um and then for the flexible housing pool will the funding remain at the 11.2 million level so our commitment for the flexible housing pool for the city is six million dollars on an annual basis since the start of the flexible housing pool one we're really excited to have it just because the the intention was that we wanted to support frequent users of the hospital system and that it would be not just the city investing into the flexible housing pool, but a number of non-profit government agencies as well as healthcare agencies. So City of Chicago, we have invested continuously on an annual basis since the start. Our investment to date is $31 million. Our annual commitment is $6 million. I would say to you that all of the investors need to invest on an annual basis. They need to make an annual commitment, and they need to invest because it can't just be on the city to make up the difference. And how do you believe that council members here can help advocate for that? I think just that, right? I think we have conversations. So here are the members that have put into the fund. So CHA, Aurora Advocate, Cook County Health, Meridian Health, MHN, and I wrote it down. I can't remember what it stands for, but I can get that to you. And the Chicago Community Trust. We need everyone and we need more hospitals, right? Because we know that when homeless individuals and unhoused individuals, it's cold outside, they need a place to go, they will go to the emergency room. That's hard for doctors. That's hard for ERs because that takes away from patients who are really sick. And so everyone needs to invest on an annual basis. And it's not just about clearing their particular hospital, right? This is a shared program. And when we do that, we get more people. And when we get more people inside, we see less people on the street. And it works out. It's a mutual benefit for everyone. That's right. Do you think that you could give us a list of, like, major players that we should be reaching out to to say, hey, we need you to make contributions to the flexible housing pool? Consistent. consistent annual contributions to the flexible housing pool. I could do that if you give me a list. Consistent, flexible, consistent contributions that are on an annual basis. It's not about I'm going to contribute one time, right? Because the cost of housing is going up. I think their cost is about $35,000 on an annual basis, right? And so it's not just keeping someone housed for years. These are people who have really chronic conditions. And so they may not like rapid rehousing, we're seeing 72% are able to self-resolve in 18 months and take on their own rent. These are individuals who have more complex needs, so it may take them longer than 24 months. And so we've got to be able to see people through the long haul. Got it. Thank you. Give me that list, I hope. Through the chair. All right. Thank you, Commissioner. Thank you, Chair. That's all for me. Thank you. Thank you, Alvin Fuentes. Just a couple items. Number one, I just want to thank you for your work in the homeless space and dealing with these encampments. I know that these are challenging throughout the city. I know your team spends an anointed amount of time working on those and working with individuals and going through everything that they need to do. And I know that many members have been asking about these accelerated moving events. What do we have in the budget for that for this year, how much is it greater than last year? And how much more will you be able to do, if any, in what has been your current level? And how much more you'll be able to do if that amount has been increased? Our current level of funding for 2024 is $28.8 million. And that's supporting with 300 households, 360 households being housed new, and then sustaining 1,000 existing households. So people who may have been housed a year ago who are still in it because the assistance is for 18 to 24 months, right? And so if people need longer, we want to keep them housed because the flip to that is if we don't, they will become unhoused. They will go back to living on the street and back to an encampment. In the budget, we have an investment of $7 million that will keep us level in 2025 with $28.8 million that will allow us to house 360 new households and keep 1,000 households housed. Our goal, right, is we're doing two AMEs a month. I am really excited because everybody knows what an AME is and everybody's asking for them. But we have to balance that with we still have an affordable housing shortage, So we need more landlords on. We have a good commitment, strong commitment on the south and west sides, but we need more landlords on the north and northwest side. So I think that's one thing where we could use more support. Now, you said seven million holds you level. Is that because of increased cost or why does why does that only hold you level? The other share is ARPA. So this is a corporate investment and the other remaining funds is ARPA. How much is ARPA versus corporate? It's 21. Raymond Barrett, Managing Deputy Commissioner. This year, our ARPA is $4.4 million for 2025. Previously, it was much higher. Okay, so the money that you're backing out from ARPA is being supplemented by the corporate fund. Correct. And theoretically in 2026, we would have to pick up another $4.5 million in corporate funding to maintain the same level of funding. Okay. And that's barring no cost increases. Correct. So right now the cost for a household is on average $30,000 to house one household. And what else comes with that other than just housing? So it's the housing, the case management, the utilities. They support with individuals with their furniture. They do the move in with it. And then, like I said, the case manager sticks with that household to make sure that anything that comes up, that they're able to help resolve that they're also an intermediary with the landlord. Okay. Of the funding and with ARPA, how much ARPA funding are you all theoretically utilizing in this 2025 upcoming year proposed? And how much have you used since its inception? You can do homeless and then overall. all? So for homeless services, we have our ARPA initiatives are. Okay. So our total score ARPA is $32.3 million. And to date, we have expended $25.2 million. dollars. And that's in total is that just homelessness? That's just homelessness. In total, we have $274 million that we have in total for our ARPA budget for all the programs. We've expended $164 million, which is about 60%. Okay. And what do you actually, as we all understand, ARPA funding will diminish or will actually go to zero at the end of next year. What is the game plan going forward for some of the programming that has been supported by ARPA? Some of it is right-sizing the programs. We knew we had to scale up quickly during the pandemic, and so some of that will be going back to our base need of where we were. We'll continue working with our own team within DFSS to make sure we're tracking outcomes and making sure that we understand which programs have been successful. There are some programs that will sunset just because they were not meant to extend past the timeline. These were just pilot programs. And then other programs were working with the Budget Office on sustainability. We also have a grants team that's helping us pick up additional outside grants to make sure we can supplant that funding. And so ultimately, of the programming, how much of the programming do you, how much of it is pilot versus things that you all believe should continue? I mean, it's a mixed bag, right? There are some things that it really depends. We've had success with, like I said, our rapid rehousing program. We've had success with some of our other youth programs. One program that in the youth space that is one time is micro grants. That was 600,000 meant to just be seed money to see how does the market respond for nonprofits when they receive grants up to, you know, five to $10,000. What are they able to do in community that was never meant to be long-term funding. Okay. And so ultimately, you all will have to either A, retool or find a new source of revenue or simply stop doing the programming that you have. What evaluative processes will you all undertake to see what we should continue doing, what we need to stop doing, how we will get through that and manage that? So we've been doing that since the start. So we have a director that really supports us with strategy, equity, and performance improvement. And so Sylvia and her team really work with us on a monthly basis, one, to make sure that we're tracking outcomes, that we see the data, and that we're meeting with our delegate agencies. So part of the work of the team in the box is they need to understand their data and they're working with it. We're having conversations with agencies. Some programs we thought would be wildly successful, they weren't. Some programs we're seeing that, you know, there is more capacity and we've been able to expand. When you look at programs like our mentoring program, where we've added additional support through our ARPA dollars, the funding in terms of the participation, because there's CPS has a mentoring program, we're realizing that we can bring that down and right-size it because scaling and expanding like we did really wasn't as necessary because there are other mentoring programs. And so we're evaluating and having conversations with our teams, our delegate agencies on how do we get to that really soft spot, that sweet spot to ensure that we have the right size for programming. If, and these are, I know we we've all been going through these budget exercises. is what, when the departmental cuts were proposed and made, what did you all cut to meet the 3% target that had been set forth by budget? So we have about $3.6 million in cuts. And so part of that is, like I said, in our workforce and our youth programs, we looked at agencies where we had awarded them a certain number of slots and we were seeing slots that were going unfilled where we had underspend. And so rather we did not cut programs where they were actually youth or participants in those programs. We actually just cut the unused slots. So we were able to do that. And then we also did $2 million in a grant that we gave to CPS for funding classrooms, teacher salaries in classrooms to bring them on par. That was something that was done years ago. Right now, CPS teachers actually make more than our early learning CBLs. So we use that $2 million as well. Okay. Now, if you have to go through further reductions, as I look at the numbers, and this is just some back of the napkin math, you all have a $165 million corporate funded appropriation, if we were to apply a overall $100 million, $200 million, $300 million cut would put you at approximately one and a half, three and a half, and five and a half percent, how would you all, what would you have to then do in order to meet your target? So let me just say that in this budget, we've already cut 12 positions on top of the three percent. If we were to make further cuts, that would impact individuals in programs, because we have cut and reduced the funding where we had programming that were unused slots. So you could see a reduction in youth enrichment programs that would impact our, because youth sits primarily on corporate, so that would be our enrichment, our prevention and intervention programs, our one summer Chicago programs. That would be some of our homeless programming. And so a lot of the work that we have in the department, senior services, is very little is funded on corporate. They are mostly grant funded through the state, through the Department of Aging. And so workforce is also on CDBG. So it would be a lot of youth and homeless that would be cut. so you so you're saying that the your senior services would remain intact and what else would remain intact for the most part seniors would remain intact early learning would remain intact it would primarily be on youth and homeless services youth and homeless services if you had to cut additionally from your budget and so i think that would be that would not only be direct services, right? So that would be your shelters, right? That would be the AMEs. That would be our outreach workers. The things that people call about for youth, that would be enrichment after school programming. It would be our scan program, service coordination and navigation for youth at the highest risk of violence. It would be the things that people are coming to us in crisis about that we are able to quickly respond to. Okay. Again, we're just, I'm just asking this question because we have a seemingly not an appetite on the revenue side, but we really haven't talked about the other side of that conversation is that what reductions would need to occur in order to make that budget balanced from a departmental perspective. So I know that this is difficult to do and to have these types of conversations. But again, we don't have the ability to print money as some of our other governmental partners do. I mean, we have to present something that's balanced and we're statutorily required to do that. And at the end of the conversation, the numbers must come together. And if we have to reach those points, I think it's imperative that we as a council and that our citizens understand what that looks like. And so, again, I don't want to potentially, you know, look into the future, but I think we have to be prepared for a future if we choose to make certain decisions. So any other questions? We're all good here? All right. The time is now 830 and committee will be at ease until 10 a.m. tomorrow. Thank you. I can't. Thank you.