Committee on Housing and Real Estate meeting, February 16, 2024
- When: Fri, Feb 16, 2024, 12:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Housing and Real Estate
- Video: https://vimeo.com/913032645
- Transcript: full text (19,708 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 11:02 Public comment
- 31:58 Appointment of Lissette Castaneda as Commissioner of the Department of Housing
- 39:41 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked the nominee why she wanted the position and said she looked forward to working…
- 41:40 Daniel La Spata: Praised the nominee's long record in community development and said her appointment made…
- 43:05 David H. Moore: Asked how the nominee's degree studies would help her as commissioner.
- 44:10 David H. Moore: Asked how her Logan Square experience applies to the South and West Sides.
- 45:36 David H. Moore: Pressed the nominee on how to get developers to build in areas like Englewood where sale…
- 50:24 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Raised concerns about gentrification and preserving affordable housing in Edgewater…
- 51:57 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked whether credit score requirements for housing eligibility would be addressed…
- 54:35 William Conway: Asked whether affordable housing should be built across the city and whether the nominee…
- 56:08 Walter R. Burnett: Commended the nominee and the mayor and discussed leveraging dollars to bring affordable…
- 58:36 Gregory I. Mitchell: Said South Side wards struggle with both new construction and rehab economics and asked…
- 1:00:49 Gregory I. Mitchell: Described condo buildings becoming rentals, hundreds of vacant homes, and homes lost to…
- 1:04:17 Gilbert Villegas: Asked the nominee about her strategy for using federal VASH vouchers to house veterans.
- 1:06:13 Marty Quinn: Asked the nominee's view on a state bill to end single-family zoning and said 13th Ward…
- 1:08:05 Jessica L. Fuentes: Described the city's housing challenges and expressed confidence in the nominee, noting…
- 1:09:59 Jessica L. Fuentes: Thanked the interim housing commissioner and urged colleagues to vote in favor.
- 1:12:21 Pat Dowell: Asked what changes or challenges the nominee sees in coordinating with the Chicago Housing…
- 1:14:45 Pat Dowell: Asked about ideas for the Chicago Low Income Housing Trust Fund.
- 1:16:09 Pat Dowell: Asked how the department will support affordable homeownership in a ward seeing high-priced…
- 1:20:38 Emma Mitts: Asked the nominee to work on housing recovery for West Side residents affected by flooding,…
- 1:23:35 Byron Sigcho-López: Described homelessness, displacement and vacant housing figures and called for a…
- 1:28:26 Acquisition of 8-acre property with industrial building at 4130 South Morgan Street for Streets and…
- 1:35:14 Maria E. Hadden: Said she supports the Morgan Street purchase and asked whether it meets all of Streets and…
- 1:36:23 Daniel La Spata: Supported the Morgan Street purchase and asked why the city sold 1717 West Pershing, which…
- 1:38:42 Walter R. Burnett: Asked whether moving Streets and Sanitation staff would change the city building on West…
- 1:40:29 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said she would support the purchase but urged the city to repurpose buildings it already…
- 1:41:27 Byron Sigcho-López: Said the property acquisition was part of a larger strategy and thanked departments for…
- 1:42:47 Lease of office space at 231 South LaSalle Street for the Office of Inspector General (34th Ward)
- 1:51:35 William Conway: Supported the Inspector General's new lease in the 34th Ward, citing the need for a…
- 1:53:16 Sale of city lots in East Garfield Park to Home and Housing LLC under City Lots for Working Families (24th…
- 1:57:47 Monique L. Scott: Asked who is building the modular homes for the East Garfield Park lots.
- 1:58:23 Restructuring of loan agreement with Erie Cooperative Limited Partnership for Harold Washington Apartments…
- 2:04:22 Walter R. Burnett: Supported the Harold Washington Apartments restructuring, describing Bickerdike as a…
- 2:05:53 First amendment to right of entry agreement for 1325 West 119th Street (21st Ward)
- 2:09:15 Sale of city-owned property at 6949 South Martin Luther King Drive under Adjacent Neighbors Land Acquisition…
- 2:10:51 Sale of city-owned property at 4259 West Monroe Street through ChiBlockBuilder (28th Ward)
- 2:13:56 Byron Sigcho-López: Agreed to standardize how land sale items are presented on future agendas.
- 2:14:29 Sales of city-owned lots through ChiBlockBuilder in the 24th, 17th and 37th Wards
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
At this February 16, 2024 meeting, the Committee on Housing and Real Estate recommended approval of the appointment of Lissette Castaneda as Commissioner of the Department of Housing. The vote followed ten public commenters who spoke in support and a round of questions from members on development economics on the South and West Sides, homeownership, CHA coordination, veterans' housing, and flood recovery. The committee also recommended a $20.8 million city purchase of a property at 4130 South Morgan Street for Streets and Sanitation and other departments, and a new downtown lease at 231 South LaSalle Street for the Office of Inspector General after roof damage at its current space. It further recommended a sale of city lots for modular homes in East Garfield Park, a $2.6 million loan restructuring for the Harold Washington Apartments in Humboldt Park, a right of entry extension in West Pullman, and several sales of city-owned lots. All items received do-pass recommendations by voice vote and were set for the February 21, 2024 City Council meeting.
Topics: Housing commissioner appointment, affordable housing, homeownership, city property acquisition, Inspector General office lease, city lots sales, loan restructuring, South and West Side development, veterans housing, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 11:02 Public comment: discussed
- 31:39 Rule 45 report from January 17, 2024: passed
- 31:58 Appointment of Lissette Castaneda as Commissioner of the Department of Housing: passed
- 1:28:26 Acquisition of 8-acre property with industrial building at 4130 South Morgan Street for Streets and Sanitation (11th Ward) (O2024-0007431): passed
- 1:42:47 Lease of office space at 231 South LaSalle Street for the Office of Inspector General (34th Ward): passed
- 1:53:16 Sale of city lots in East Garfield Park to Home and Housing LLC under City Lots for Working Families (24th Ward) (O2024-0007430): passed
- 1:58:23 Restructuring of loan agreement with Erie Cooperative Limited Partnership for Harold Washington Apartments (27th Ward): passed
- 2:05:53 First amendment to right of entry agreement for 1325 West 119th Street (21st Ward) (SO2024-0007432): passed
- 2:09:15 Sale of city-owned property at 6949 South Martin Luther King Drive under Adjacent Neighbors Land Acquisition Program (6th Ward): passed
- 2:10:51 Sale of city-owned property at 4259 West Monroe Street through ChiBlockBuilder (28th Ward): passed
- 2:14:29 Sales of city-owned lots through ChiBlockBuilder in the 24th, 17th and 37th Wards (O2024-0007433): passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Byron Sigcho-López (chair): Described homelessness, displacement and vacant housing figures and called for a collaborative approach with CHA, HUD and the state to address affordable housing and homeownership. (1:23:35); Said the property acquisition was part of a larger strategy and thanked departments for explaining given the importance of public dollars. (1:41:27); Agreed to standardize how land sale items are presented on future agendas. (2:13:56)
- Carlos Ramírez-Rosa (alderperson): Congratulated the nominee, praised her work at Lucha in Logan Square, and pledged the 35th Ward's full support. (38:06)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked the nominee why she wanted the position and said she looked forward to working with her. (39:41); Said she would support the purchase but urged the city to repurpose buildings it already owns, such as closed schools, to spur development. (1:40:29)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Praised the nominee's long record in community development and said her appointment made him more hopeful. (41:40); Supported the Morgan Street purchase and asked why the city sold 1717 West Pershing, which precipitated the need for the new site. (1:36:23)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked how the nominee's degree studies would help her as commissioner. (43:05); Asked how her Logan Square experience applies to the South and West Sides. (44:10); Pressed the nominee on how to get developers to build in areas like Englewood where sale prices do not cover construction costs. (45:36)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Raised concerns about gentrification and preserving affordable housing in Edgewater and discussed co-locating housing with transit and libraries. (50:24); Asked whether credit score requirements for housing eligibility would be addressed and how alderpersons can help the department. (51:57)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked whether affordable housing should be built across the city and whether the nominee supports the planned 600 affordable units on LaSalle Street, which she said she did. (54:35); Supported the Inspector General's new lease in the 34th Ward, citing the need for a separate, accessible office. (1:51:35)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Commended the nominee and the mayor and discussed leveraging dollars to bring affordable housing to underinvested communities. (56:08); Asked whether moving Streets and Sanitation staff would change the city building on West Washington in his ward or free up land. (1:38:42); Supported the Harold Washington Apartments restructuring, describing Bickerdike as a leading affordable housing organization. (2:04:22)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (alderperson): Said South Side wards struggle with both new construction and rehab economics and asked that homeownership be a department focus. (58:36); Described condo buildings becoming rentals, hundreds of vacant homes, and homes lost to tax delinquency in his ward. (1:00:49)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked the nominee about her strategy for using federal VASH vouchers to house veterans. (1:04:17)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked the nominee's view on a state bill to end single-family zoning and said 13th Ward residents would oppose it. (1:06:13)
- Jessica L. Fuentes (alderperson): Described the city's housing challenges and expressed confidence in the nominee, noting she would be the first Latina to lead the department. (1:08:05); Thanked the interim housing commissioner and urged colleagues to vote in favor. (1:09:59)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked what changes or challenges the nominee sees in coordinating with the Chicago Housing Authority and whether she would convene a quarterly coordination table. (1:12:21); Asked about ideas for the Chicago Low Income Housing Trust Fund. (1:14:45); Asked how the department will support affordable homeownership in a ward seeing high-priced construction. (1:16:09)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Asked the nominee to work on housing recovery for West Side residents affected by flooding, citing insurance costs and mold. (1:20:38)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Said she supports the Morgan Street purchase and asked whether it meets all of Streets and Sanitation's space needs. (1:35:14)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Asked who is building the modular homes for the East Garfield Park lots. (1:57:47)
Exchanges between members
- 51:17 Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked Moore for raising the need to address many housing issues at once.
- 54:16 Conway followed up playfully on Moore's question about the nominee's studies.
- 57:45 Burnett referenced Moore's point about underinvested communities where developers do not want to build.
- 58:51 Mitchell said he wanted to build on Moore's point about South Side development challenges.
- 1:12:21 Dowell followed up on the nominee's answer to Villegas about CHA vouchers.
- 1:24:12 Sigcho-López cited Quinn's point about small homeowners struggling with costs.
- 1:25:25 Sigcho-López cited Mitts's concerns about the federal response to West Side flooding.
- 1:26:25 Sigcho-López noted a commitment with Mitchell to discuss expanding homeownership.
- 1:40:36 Taylor continued along the line of La Spata's question about the property transaction.
- 1:52:31 Sigcho-López noted that Conway, as a non-member, could not make the motion.
- 2:13:56 Sigcho-López agreed with Dowell's request to standardize agenda information.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error