good morning buenos dias good morning um i want to uh welcome everyone uh to the meeting on the of the committee on housing and real estate of the chicago city council and the meeting is called to order today we have elated 11 items on the agenda we're going to start with a roll call uh we'll now have the roll call to establish quorum uh please have your your mics ready when your name is called um alderman vice chair mitchell mr mitchell present alderman lesbada alderman espada present uh alderman queen alderman queen present alderman moore not present alderman taylor i don't think she was here but so we have it as yet to be confirmed alters uh all the person fuentes all the person fuentes present alderman brunette all the member net present um alderman ramirez rosa alderman rosa present alderman villegas alderman villegas present alderman mitts the women it's not present all the women is present oh sorry remotely yeah my apologies i will go i'll get back to the uh to the remote attendance uh all the all the women claim all the women may not happen with present other women um all the women hadn't presence. So one, two, three, six, seven. Nice. So I think Alderwoman Taylor or Alderwoman Haddon. I'm not sure they're. Both of them are here. So we're meeting. They're coming back. So let's wait a second for them to come back to the chamber so that we can meet quorum. All right. So we have Alderman Manhattan, and we officially have quorum. Thank you again. Thank you, Alderman, and Alderman Manhattan. We're women, Janet Taylor as well. So I mark you both as present. And Alderman Moore. Thank you, Alderman Moore. So we have a total of 12 members. So we have quorum. We have a Rule 59 request for all the persons. That was Robinson, Harris, Tavares, Scott. we already counted all the person Mitz and all the person Rodriguez Sanchez. Can I get a motion to approve all five other persons for remote participation or six actually? So moved. All the person Jesse Fuentes moves. All those in favor say aye. All those oppose say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The other persons have been added to the quorum. We're going to now start with the public comment section. We have 10 speakers here today each speaker will have three minutes to speak all items on the agenda the first speaker is um juan calderon Thank you. immense pride and joy as we stand in support of a champion of our people. Lisette's unwavering commitment to fighting gentrification and displacement has been a beacon of hope for our community. Her dedication echoes the spirit of resilience and unity that defines our community. With Lisette at the helm of the Department of Housing, we are confident that the challenges that our community faces in Chicago will be addressed with compassion, wisdom, and innovative solutions that ensure no one is left behind. As we celebrate and we hope to celebrate this milestone, let us also reaffirm our commitment to support Lisette in her endeavors to create a more equitable and just housing landscape. Her success is our success, and together we will continue to fight for the rights and the dignity of every Chicagoan. Congratulations, Lisette. Your journey inspires us, your vision guides us, and your leadership gives us hope. Together we look forward to a future where every Puerto Rican, Latino, and Chicago has a place to call home. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Juan. Next speaker is Allison Clements. Good afternoon. My name is Allison Clements, and I serve as Executive Director of the Illinois Housing Council, a membership association that represents over 270 nonprofit organizations and private businesses active in the development and preservation of affordable housing throughout our state. Our organization's mission is to bring together industry leaders and policymakers to meet the fundamental need for affordable housing in Illinois, opening doors to greater opportunity for all residents. I'm here today to speak in full support of the appointment of Lisette Castaneda as Commissioner of the City of Chicago Department of Housing. Lisette served as a member of my organization's board of directors for three years, including as a member of our executive committee. During her service to IHC, Lisette played a leadership role in our organization's strategic planning process, helped to shape legislative policy to advance affordable housing development and preservation, and participated in our efforts to grow diversity and new talent in the industry. Lisette's background in non-profit organizational leadership, grassroots advocacy, and direct experience and affordable housing development position her to be a strong and effective leader at the Department of Housing. Lisette understands the challenges facing residents and communities in need of housing and investment, but she also understands the barriers that exist for developers that are working to bring desperately needed affordable housing to our city. Her unique expertise will be a huge asset in her service to Chicago, especially as the city seeks to streamline and add efficiency to the housing development process. Lisette is a well-respected leader in the field of affordable housing development, and I urge you to support her appointment as Commissioner of Housing. Thank you. Next speaker is Kate Gronstow. I also am honored to be here today on behalf of myself and Evergreen Real Estate Group to support the appointment of Lisette Castaneda to the Commissioner of Department of Housing. I've worked with Lisette for nearly the last five years on affordable housing development, but also a lot of community convening, bringing different groups of people together. And what I have learned about Lisette in that time is not just her commitment to the communities of Chicago, especially the areas that have had disinvestment or are experiencing gentrification, but also her ability to bring together diverse groups of people, different service providers, different entities, and try to work towards more equitable, but also more efficient ways of us utilizing the resources that we have available to us. So on behalf of myself and evergreen real estate group we support and hope you will approve the appointment of lisette castaneda thank you very much uh next is christian diaz good afternoon my name is christian diaz i'm director of equitable community development at palenque lsna formerly logan square neighborhood association i'm here to testify in full support of the confirmation of Lacer Castaneda to be Chicago's new Commissioner of Housing. Palenka LSNA is a coalition of 44 organizations, including churches, schools, park advisory councils, housing cooperatives, small businesses, and other nonprofits working to advance racial equity in Logan Square at Avondale, Hermosa. These are neighborhoods that are suffering through the cruelty of gentrification and mass displacement of people of color. We are thrilled to see our new Commissioner of Housing continue to be someone who respects and values community voice. Nisette Castaneda is absolutely the right person to lead Chicago's Department of Housing. Commissioner Castaneda represents a new way forward for Chicago. Chicago City Council must recognize that the people we need as a city, the workers, the nurses, the teachers, the firefighters, the baristas, the custodians, the people Chicago needs in order to thrive are finding it harder and harder to afford a decent and safe home to live in. And this should concern all of us. As a former executive director of Latin United Community Housing Association, Lisset Castañeda weeds strategy, equity, transparency, finance, and practicality seamlessly to create hundreds of affordable homes by the 606 Bloomingdale Trail and turning Humboldt Park United Methodist Church into affordable homes near the California Blue Line Station. As a former board president of the Logan Square Neighborhood Association, Lisset Castañeda organized tirelessly to preserve Lathrop Homes, one of the few public housing communities in the north side of Chicago. As co-chair of the Logan Square Blue Line Table with Elevated Chicago, Lisset Castañeda helped lead the charge for the Connected Communities Ordinance, which makes it easier to develop equitable communities in connection with public transit. In addition to all of this, Lissette helped establish the Here to Stay Community Land Trust, which was awarded $5 million to acquire and preserve affordable homes on the northwest side of Chicago. The Here to Stay Community Land Trust sold its first home to a family for $270,000 in a neighborhood where sales averaged $700,000. Chicago needs bold, innovative, and equitable solutions just like this. Now, Commissioner Castaneda is poised to walk through City Hall as a leader of the Department of Housing, knowing that she carries a torch for all our people with every step she takes, and we will stand with you every step of the way. We are thrilled to show our full support for the confirmation of Lisset Castaneda as Commissioner of Housing. This is a step in the right direction for our city. We have a lot of transformative work to do together. Thank you. Next, we have Efrain Elias. Good morning, good afternoon. I'm bringing a little bit of a different perspective from the labor side of things. On behalf of SEIU's 50,000 members, we want Lisette Castaneda and the alderman to know that SEIU Local 1 supports Lisette in this appointment, and we look forward to working together. We want to congratulate Lissette Castaneda on her DOH appointment. Lissette has the ability to be collaborative and rethink about how housing should be facilitated and developed in the city of Chicago and making sure that Chicago is a human right for everybody while simultaneously creating access to good union jobs. Lissette has focused her efforts on development in historically disinvested communities as well as communities that seen massive gentrification. I have the utmost confidence that Lissette is up to the job as an affordable housing champion and a natural born leader. SEIU Local One's 50,000 members wholeheartedly supports Lissette's appointment. And again, we hope that all the other persons do as well. Thank you guys. Thank you and good luck to you. Thank you. Thank you. Next we have Huacol de Reyes. With afternoon elders, my name is Huacol de Reyes and I'm here to provide a loud and unwavering commitment of support for my friend Liseska Tañeda appointment as commissioner of the Department of Housing. For those that don't know me, I am a Pilsen resident of over 25 years In that time, I have witnessed the cycle of disinvestment and turned into gentrification and displacement. I have built my career as a developer of affordable housing, mostly in and around the 25th Ward. As a community member, it remains discerning to me to witness the continued lack of public resources in Pilsen, even as private capital and new residents flow into our community and impact the cost of living. As a developer, with every passing year, building one unit of affordable housing has become harder and expensive. Lisette shares this dual resident developer perspective with me. She has lived community experience. She understands the impact of organizing, counseling, and building affordable housing. She knows that our communities need more resources beyond housing, too. We need investment in law and all hardworking communities, regardless of the racial makeup, to ensure a strong and resilient Chicago. Equally important, she has been a developer. She understands the never-ending administrative hurdles that delays units and at the end of the day makes each unit of housing more expensive. This means that our families wait longer for an affordable home if they are lucky enough to find one. As this administration takes on the challenge of improving the development process, her firsthand experience will be invaluable. Finally, on a personal note, I must acknowledge the importance of Lisette's personal background. She will be the first Latina commissioner of the Department of Housing, the first Latina commissioner in the city of Chicago's history. This despite Latinos being the largest minority group in the city, accounting for almost 29% of the population. Lisette's appointment is a crucial nod to this powerful tapestry of Chicagoans. It's also signaled to Latinas, like my two daughters, that serving their city as a commissioner is an attainable goal. Lisette is ready to meet this moment. She's a strong Latina woman, committed and passionate, and she understands the challenge in front of her. Her brain, her heart, and feet carry her history. Culture and commitment. Adelante, Lisette. Juntas en la lucha. Thank you. Next we have Natasha Brown. Good afternoon. I am Natasha Brown Castro, co-chair of the Puerto Rican Agenda of Chicago, and I am here to strongly support the appointment of Lestec Castaneda as the new commissioner for the Department of Housing for the City of Chicago. Chicago. For me, Ms. Castaneda, and for the Thai and Puerto Rican community, she is the first truly organic, informed commissioner in the history of the city of Chicago. She has not only been a trailblazer, a transformative leader, and the leader of one of the most important affordable housing development corporations in our community, Lucha, but she has demonstrated amazing leadership skills as the co-chair of the Puerto Rican Agenda Housing Committee. And in that capacity, she has helped other leaders of our community shepherd the most innovative policy addressing the issues of our marginalized communities in the urban setting, historical disinvestment, and displacement through gentrification. Illinois becomes the first in the country to create a designated cultural district. This designation means that five distinct communities in Illinois would become a designated cultural district promoting a historic and cultural community, preserving and developing historic and culturally significant structures, tradition, and languages, fostering local cultural development and education, providing a focal point for celebrating and strengthening the unique cultural identities of communities, and promoting growth and opportunity without generating displacement or expanding inequity thus this legislation encapsulate truly who and what lissette represents in this period in which we are facing a housing crisis in the city through homelessness and the migrant situation there is no one more qualified for this than lissette castaneda and more than anyone else she understands why we must adopt the bring chicago home referendum thank you thank you very much next we have sarah wick good afternoon mr chair and members of the committee i'm sarah wick senior vice president of affordable housing at related midwest as a passionate advocate of affordable housing i'm here today to speak proudly for the appointment of lizette casaneda to serve as the commissioner for Department of Housing. As you've heard, she has a stellar reputation, as you've heard from many of her peers, she has a stellar reputation in affordable housing industry as a capable and effective leader, and her accomplishments at Lucha and the Center for Changing Lives speak for themselves. Lisette isn't just an advocate for affordable housing, but she knows how to build it, and we really need that in this role. Equally important, she understands how to foster collaboration among the public-private and non-profit sectors to affect meaningful change. Her extensive experience as a developer, builder, and operator of affordable housing will undoubtedly serve her and the community well as she endeavors to streamline the affordable housing development process in alignment with the mayor's directive. Having an experienced practitioner like Lizette at the helm will greatly benefit Chicago, its neighborhoods, and its people. I applaud Mayor Johnson for appointing Lizette to this essential role, and I hope the committee will affirm this recommendation. We congratulate Lizette and wish her the very best. Thank you. Thank you. Next, we have Kevin Jackson. Good afternoon, Chairman and members of the committee and the public. On behalf of the Chicago Rehab Network and our mission of community empowerment and development without displacement, we welcome the appointment of Ms. Lisette Castaneda to Commissioner of Housing, a pivotal department for our neighborhoods, affordable housing, and the very fabric of our city overall. Ms. Castaneda is a seasoned leader, as others have attested, in community development and affordable housing. She knows the ins and outs of the business, and her organization, Lucha, has been a longstanding member of the Rehab Network, along with the other mission developers across the city. Lisette recently served on our board, and so did her predecessor, Juan Rivera, back in the early 90s. So the history is strong, the knowledge is important, the experience invaluable. She brings and possesses firsthand knowledge and experience of the endless variations of community voice, neighborhood hopes, and the fight for racial equity and inclusion. A promising road is ahead for the city of Chicago with her appointment and her future leadership for all of us. Housing is foundational to our lives and is a human right. We applaud the mayor for this appointment and we look forward to working with everyone to get this city right with housing and affordability. Thank you. Next is Giumera Rodriguez. Hi everyone. I come to speak more as a resident of Humble Park, a lifelong resident. I also work for the Puerto Rican Cultural Center and am a strong believer in affordable housing. I come from a Puerto Rican family that has resided in Humble Park for three generations. My grandmother lived in Humble Park when landlords were conducting arson for profit, while Puerto Rican families were still in their buildings. My mother lived in Humble Park when her friends from school would refuse to visit her house because of the reputation Humboldt Park had for gun violence and gang violence. I, as a lifelong resident of Humboldt Park, have watched almost every family I grew up with on my block get pushed out of our community because of gentrification and be replaced with short-term tenants who never say hi or care to know their neighbors. And while the familiar faces in Humboldt Park disappear, year after year I have watched the luxury condos rise out of thin air and set empty while more and more tents of houseless neighbors pop up in the park. Chicago is experiencing a real housing crisis and we need people like Lissette Castaneda who have years of experience, as everybody has attested to, advocating for and creating housing security in our most vulnerable neighborhoods. I wholeheartedly support her appointment, and I applaud Mayor Brandon Johnson for this, for Castaneda to serve as the Department of Housing Commissioner, and I'm excited to see the new Chicago we are co-creating. Thank you. Thank you so much. This concludes our public comment. We had also one written comment, a letter of support for the first item on the agenda. Oh, and we just received two more. So the three letters of support by Michael Burton and Joy Arugate. Those are two, as well as Minister Sylvia Jones. So we have at least 13 public records of support for the first item. Our first order of business is the Rule 45 report from january 17 2024 which was emailed and distributed to the committee members can i get a motion to recommend approval of this report so moved by other person jesse fuentes all those in favor say aye all those opposed a name and the painters of independent of the chair the ayes have it now we will move on on the items before the committee item number one is 820 24-0007307 the appointment of Lissette Castaneda as commissioner of the department of housing Lissette Castaneda from the department of housing is present and ready for any questions of committee members if you have any questions or comments please raise your hand to be recognized we will take in an order of raising your hand so we have alderman calo ramiro rosa alderman jenet taylor anyone else or should we start with Alderman oh after the after the comment commissioner thank you so much uh good afternoon chairman singa Lopez vice chairman Mitchell and all the members of the housing and real estate committee as has been stated my name is Lisa Castaneda I am here because my community has poured into me and I ask for your favorable consideration of my appointment as commissioner of the Department of Housing. I am a lifelong Chicagoan. The year that I was born, my hotel worker father and work-at-home mother were living in Lincoln Park. As their family grew, they wanted to buy a home. Unfortunately, they could no longer do so in the community. So they began the arduous process of finding a house that they loved and could afford, and finally found one in Logan Square. This was not today's Logan Square. When some family members were told where we were moving to, often much was made of how dangerous it was. What we found was a wonderful community, a yard and more space. Our family made a home there. My story cannot be recognized as one of gentrification and displacement, although it took place before I knew what those words meant. what I did come to understand quite vividly was that we were going to a different church and that I had to get up earlier to be bused back to my grammar school through my involvement in community organizations I learned what words to put to my experience and how to get involved in organizing for solutions particularly since my family's experience in gentrification and displacement would follow us to Logan Square this has led to more than 20 years of involvement in the vast world of housing I marched in the streets to demand the setting aside of a percentage of new housing as affordable I have worked with folks experiencing homelessness at risk of homelessness and living at very low AMIs I hope to run programs for home ownership and was part of establishing a community land trust to ensure affordable homeownership. I served on the boards of housing policy organizations. I am a housing practitioner. Most recently, I ran a community development corporation, the cornerstone of which was a development of affordable housing. During my time there, I led a phenomenal dedicated team, and the pipeline for development grew exponentially. It was through that work in policy, programs, and development that I got to collaborate with the Department of Housing more than ever before. Today, the Department of Housing oversees the affordable housing work that I advocated for, runs the programs for, and builds in my career. The set-asides are the Affordable Requirements Ordinance. DOH has funded projects that brought more affordability to Logan Square and Humboldt Park and beyond DOH has a down payment assistance program for affordable homeownership DOH has administered rental assistance programs for those at risk of homelessness DOH is also helping to fund non-congregate shelters for people experiencing homelessness and DOH uses policy to explore how to further the mission of expanding access and choice for residents and protect their rights to quality homes that are affordable, safe, and healthy. I made the choice to join the Department of Housing because of my experiences as a practitioner, because I know what it will mean to have a more streamlined process for development to those feeling housing vulnerability or instability, because I know what it will mean to have the Department of Housing be seen as a partner in the common goal of housing for all. I also know that the city needs a holistic view of housing while understanding that each ward and community is different. I know that we need to use all the resources, tools, partnerships, and collaborations available to us internally and externally and to find new ones. I am here because I want to lead with imagination, to start with the understanding that all things are and should be possible to ensure that every Chicagoan has a home. My mother still lives in that house in Logan Square. It is now a multi-generational home where my niece has on-demand access to Abuelita. I understand both from personal and professional experience what a difference it makes to have stable affordable housing and how hard it can be to maintain that stability and affordability. Everyone deserves a safe, decent, affordable home and should have the right to make their best housing choice for themselves and their families without being limited by a lack of opportunities or resources. I am here today because I want to be part of the work of making that a reality for all Chicagoans. I thank you for your favorable consideration of my appointment. Thank you, Commissioner. So we start with, yeah, we'll start with Alderman Ramirez Rosa. I had the first question, and then anybody else who wants to have any questions, please raise your hand. Oh, point information. Grandma. There you go. Alderman Ramirez Rosa. You know, I don't have any questions. I just want to say congratulations to our soon to be duly appointed and confirmed housing commissioner. We met in Logan Square. You have three older people here that represent portions of Logan Square, and I'm sure that all of them will speak very highly to the work that you have done in the housing advocacy space and the housing development space and the housing justice space for many decades. Lucha has always been such a wonderful organization and particularly when you took the helm you continued that legacy we could always count on referring families in our community to Lucha so that they can receive the help that they need so I know that the Department of Housing is in good hands and as we refer people to DOH for the various programs that DOH runs we have a person at the helm that knows exactly what service needs to look like to help our families. I love your lived experience and how that informs your work, because we are definitely going to continue to need the help of DOH in building affordable housing in communities with high displacement pressure like Logan Square, but also in preserving the naturally occurring affordable housing that is found in so many communities. So I'm proud that you're from Logan Square, but I know that now we're going to share you with the entire city. And I know that everything that you learned and everything that you accomplished in Logan Square will inform all of the work that you're going to bring to the entire city of Chicago. So congratulations, and you count with the 35th Ward's full support. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Other woman, Taylor? Commissioner, you was already going to go to heaven. According to all the testimony and the folks that are here, why this position? You could have did anything else. You could have been a developer. there are plenty you can fight against the city but this position tell me why you want it yeah I think for all of the reasons that were mentioned you know I I understand all of the perspectives and it was kind of like this was the thing that was left right this was the final frontier to come in to the inside and really work um on the inside to do the work that will be reflected back out into the communities. I got to DOH and I found a phenomenal team that is ready to do that work with me. So I'm very excited. It was a hard choice to leave the warm, warm, warm community that I come from. And I think that part of it is also that I want to make sure that I can work on a citywide level, that I can bring that experience and that knowledge, not just for the folks that I've been working with in Logan Square and in Humboldt Park and in the northwest side of the city, but also across the city because I want every person, every person to have a safe, decent, affordable roof over their head. I was just going to say now, don't say this to the end because we need somebody in hood and CAJ. Throwing that out there. I'm just throwing that out there. So this, I am excited that you are in this seat. The mayor definitely did his due diligence and making sure that he's made some good, some good appointments, I will say, and this one is definitely one. We know that affordable housing is an issue in certain parts of our city, and so I'm looking forward to working with you. My bark is worse than my bite, so, and I just, I know, I know that you would do well, and so I'm excited to see you in this position. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Alderman Taylor. Alderman Espada? Chair, kind of the same as Audman Ramirez Rosa. What's a question about housing I could possibly ask you that I haven't asked you in the past 18 years? you've always given such smart and empathetic and compassionate answers to and particularly the last few years getting to work with you in your capacity at Lucha and understanding that housing and a roof is just the beginning of stability in people's lives it's one of the beautiful things about Lucha that was really fostered under your predecessor that has continued to blossom in your leadership is thinking about all the needs and opportunities that one can express to people through community development. That community development is not just bricks and cement. It's the work that we do to change people's lives. But you know the bricks and cement really well as well. I will only close by saying you have always teased me for being very reflexively hopeful, and now you only have yourself to blame because you've made me so much more hopeful by placing yourself in this capacity for what we can do together for the city. So thank you for taking this on. Thank you. Alderman Moore. Thank you. First of all, thank you so much for reaching out and, you know, meeting with me and talking, discuss some of the things that we want to do that we want to do in my community. I see you're in a process of working on your bachelor's degree. Tell me how some ways you believe your bachelor's degree can help you as a better commissioner in housing. Yeah, so I started school, I don't know, like when I was a young warthog a long time ago. And I think that, you know, going through the process of finishing all of that out, I think it'll just give some credential back to the work that I've been doing. I think a lot of it and what I've done in my time and in my career has been to concentrate on doing the work. And that is really kind of where I've landed for the last several years, where I've just really concentrated on that. And I think at some point, whenever that does finish out, it'll sort of be the background to the work that I'm doing on the foreground already. Okay, and a lot of your work, understanding it was done in Logan Square, how do you look at the city from the whole, and specifically the south and west side of Chicago? Tell me some comparisons, I mean some commonalities between what you see in Logan Square, which that's more of your area that you dealt with, between the south and west side of Chicago, then, what are the differences, and then how can those differences that you see, how can we benefit on the south and west side of Chicago? Absolutely. Gentrification and displacement are just one side of the coin. The other side of the coin is disinvestment, which is a lot of what we have seen on the south and west side. Like I mentioned in my remarks, when we told my family or we told family members that we were moving to Logan Square, much was made of how dangerous it was going to be. And, you know, not to say that there weren't definitely some moments, because this was a very different community 30 years ago, that was desperate for also some investment. And unfortunately, that investment led to a lot of displacement. And so what I want to do is work in communities that have had that disinvestment for generations, for decades, and make sure that when we make investments in the communities, it does not lead to displacement, it simply leads to greater choice, greater access, and making sure that folks have everything that they need to not just survive, but to thrive. And given that, when we're talking with developers, and the cost, whether you build on the north side, and whether you build on the south side, a piece of wood costs what a piece of wood cost. But the ability to sail in those different areas of Northside or something versus Southwide or suburbs, wherever you want to take it, varies. And so developers tend not to want to build because of that cost description. How do we deal with that here at the city of Chicago? So yeah, I would love to build, David, but if it's going to cost me $300,000 to build a house that I only can get 150 or 250 for, I'm not doing it when I can build it for 300 and get 400 of it. So how do we deal with that? Housing is just one of the factors in a person's life. It is one of the social determinants of health. Part of what we want to do, part of what I want to see, is to make sure that when we build housing, it's not in an island, but that it is actually surrounded by transportation, by green space, by commercial development, by the grocery store that you need to go to and by a good school that you can send your kid to. And I think when we look at it holistically, it becomes something where we're not just looking at the sale price of this home on its own as an island, but are actually looking at what is happening that is transformational for the entire neighborhood and for the entire community. And I think that that is what is going to help drive development. That is part of how I want to work with Commissioner Boatwright at the Department of Planning and Development and with any of the commissioners that have a piece of how do we make sure that we're building more infrastructure and making more investments, not just in housing, in each community. Okay, so I'm going to come back on that one because I'm not hearing my answer to the question that I'm saying. If I'm a developer and I tell you that, that did not move me to come to build. And so I'm asking, I'm, again, the simple form, $300,000 is costing me on the North side and in Englewood. How do you get me to build in Englewood? And I heard everything you said, but it just, I don't see it. I'm not seeing it. So you have to, how do I get that developer to build in Englewood? Yeah. So I do think that the foundational thing is for it to be more holistic. I think very practically we can look at subsidies. We can look at making sure that, you know, we are putting out the rounds where we have our LIHTC tax credits and where we have whatever other options that we have for money to be able to look at the developers and say, we're going to help you make this change. We're going to help you do these things. That's what I need to hear. Those type of things. That's that you're putting some money in there. You're putting something in there and that and those things are very critical. Are you familiar with bridge bond deals? With bridge bond deals? With bond deals in general, sure. Yeah, like it's part of how we could do a lot of the work that we do. And that's how tax credits and all of that work. Okay. So when we talk about bridge bonds, I remember at CHA when I was a development manager, it was more or less using bonds to take up a short-term situation into a long-term financial situation was taken that you can, you know, in order for you to do a project. how can we use those different bond deals to do more affordable housing? Yeah, I think that there's lots of resources that are available to us. Bonds, low-income housing tax credits. In the case of commercial and market rate, we're also talking about new market tax credits and things like that. And I think all of those things are tools that we have to use and that we have to be creative about. And you mentioned CHA, and part of it is that I want to partner and collaborate so that we're not just leveraging what the Department of Housing has in its pot, but also leveraging what DPD has, what CHA has, and what all of the other sister agencies and other departments have access to. All right. Thank you so much. I appreciate you answering the questions. I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Yes, I also would like to recognize Alderman Conway as a non-member. thank you Alderman Clay also we have some people who are going to continue the meeting remotely Alderman Carlos Ramirez Rosa as well as Alderman Taylor but they'll remain in the meeting so thank you for making sure that we have it on the record Alderman Alderman Moore do you have any additional questions or no thank you Alderman Moore and now we have Alderman Manar Happenworth Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Commissioner. I'm very, I was very pleased to have a conversation with you about all the things that you're talking about today. Thank you for sharing your experience, your lived experience with us. I want to echo what others have been saying. I appreciate all the things that you're saying about giving people choice and access to whatever housing they they would like to pursue and you know in the edgewater area it is one of the more high opportunity areas so we're very concerned about gentrification and also preserving the affordable housing that that exists there. So I appreciate that you are committed to working with CHA. And I also thank Alter Moore for bringing up the fact that we have to address everything all at once is your challenge. So I appreciate what you're saying about holistic housing. We talked about the possibilities around transit in the 48th Ward. what we can do towards equity the possibility of co-locating public spaces like libraries so that we can possibly build affordable housing near it next to it on top of it and I just wanted to say thank you for for stepping up and also to you know ask you two things? Are we going to address the psycho score for eligibility for housing? And also, what is it that we can do as alders in our ward to help you be successful? Absolutely. The second question I'll address first. So I think with any of the things that we want to do, right, we always need aldermanic support, you know, in the wards, at the larger level with the budget, you know, when we want to have subsidies, we want to have all of these things, we have to have the resources behind it. And so that's the kind of support that I will always want. I always, with all of you, as well as with community, want to be a partner, want to be a collaborator, and want to be able to have conversations. And again, start from a place of imagination of the things that can happen, and then from there work into how do we make them happen. The question of the FICO score is one of those things that is not within my direct purview, but I am a practitioner. I come from a place where I understand what that means for community to be able to have access without barriers to housing. I understand that those are the sort of things that are not always reflective of how folks are able to maintain stability in their housing, and I want to fight for anything that increases stability for people. Thank you so much. Good luck. And we are here for you as well. Thank you. Alderman Taylor is not logged in yet, but can I have a motion to allow applicable to Rule 59, Alderman Carlos Romero-Grossa and Alderman Taylor to join remotely? So move about Alderman Clay. Everybody in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. The eyes of the chair have it. So Alderman Taylor will join us as soon as she can. I'm sure soon. Thank you. Now we continue with Alderman Burnett. Oh, you're, can't we? Alderman, call me, sorry. Yes, sir. Yeah, I thank you for the acknowledgement. I was merely coming over to say, I'm a non-member, so put me in where you can, which I appreciate that, which I think it's an opportune time, in fact. Yeah, you can take advantage. Well, I appreciate it. Yeah, and follow on a bit playfully from Alderman Moore's question is, while you're at DePaul, feel free to take Finance 310 with Professor Conway. I can promise you, you are overqualified to take the class. You're probably overqualified to teach the class, but you'd be certainly welcome in that classroom. um so in noting your your uh just a few questions um noting your extensive background i i assume that you um broadly agree that we need to be to increase affordable housing right across chicago right yeah i do yeah and when you think about affordable housing do you think about it sort of confining it to certain neighborhoods or do you think it's something it should really be you know all over the city yeah i think it should be all over the city i understand that it looks different in every ward um again i think part of the holistic approach is knowing that we have a plan and that we have a vision for the whole city and then in every community and in every ward we look at it slightly differently understanding that you know it's very different from one ward to one community and we want to acknowledge that um and and respect that i think i think that's great. And as you know, there's a plan to, you may know, there's a plan to build 600 affordable housing units on LaSalle Street with government incentive. Is that something that you're in favor of? I am in favor of anything that brings more affordability to any place in the city. If I could ask you to either say yes or no. I know maybe sometimes the mayor doesn't agree with that construct, but if you could say yes or no. I would absolutely be in favor of that. Yes. great thank you very much that's all i have thank you now we go back to all the member net thank you all the miccom thank you thank you very much uh congratulations commissioner it's a pleasure meeting with you um the other day thank you for meeting with me i mean i pretty much you know we pretty much talked about everything i wanted to talk about we really don't have to put it out in public i I just want to commend you and commend the mayor. This is another great appointment. Commend all of the people who came down rallying for you. It's like you gang banging and stuff. You bought your gang with you. This is our girl. You better not mess with her, right? The affordable housing people, right? But that's a testament and a credit to you, all of the great things that you've been able to do. You know, I feel very confident that you're going to do some great things for affordable housing. It's good that you're well-rounded. It's sort of reminding me of the planning commissioner. You know, you're so well-rounded in affordable housing, knowing both sides of it, the want and also the do, and you know how to do it. and you understand the perspective of being an affordable developer. So you know what they go through and how to help expedite those things. And maybe even coming up with some ideas of how to work with other people in the private industry to help make these things happen. You and I did have a conversation of trying to leverage dollars to make these things happen, not just on site, but also in those under-deserved communities like Reverend. like Alderman Moore was talking about where folks don't want to invest in because, you know, it's not profitable. So we talked about that and we know how that's important for these communities because once, you know, the good thing is once you start doing what I've always found, once you prime a community with some affordable housing, the market rate come right out, right? And so, you know, you and I are on the same page. So I look forward to working with you and happy to help you with whatever I can. And you got a, just so you know, you have a great staff working for you. You got some great people working for you. So congratulations to you. Congratulations to the mayor on this appointment. And we all are blessed in the city of Chicago to have you. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Vice Chair Mitchell. Well, congratulations. I appreciate the conversation you and I had. And I know we're going to have many, many more, but there's a couple of things I wanted to touch on. The first one I'll touch on, I actually do want to piggyback on what Alderman Moore said, because a lot of us, particularly on the South side, is having that development problem. But not just with the new builds, we're struggling with actually also the rehabs. So to his point, you know, we have a lot of people that are interested, a lot of guys done well for themselves, want to come back to the neighborhood, improve the neighborhood. but that spread just doesn't work for them. And when you talked about the holistic approach, I appreciate that. And I have a ward where it's on a transit line, where it has parks, where it has all those things that you, and we're still struggling. I know you're not going to have the answer right now. I know you have some tools in the toolbox, but I definitely want to make sure that's a focus in your department because you, like we talked, your experience with affordable housing is, don't even need to talk about it, it speaks for itself. But I'm concerned about the home ownership piece. And sometimes, well, since I've been an alderman, it's always talked about as a footnote. It's a little nugget that's talked about, which is a huge boulder in my ward. So I need that type of attention. You know, the resources, and I don't have a lot of tips on my ward. I don't have a lot of anything. And it makes the community is wondering, how did we even get here? So I want to make sure that that is not just a footnote or a nugget in your department with you going forward. I represent four areas. I represent South Shore, South Chicago, Calumet Heights, and South Derry. All of which, with the exception of South Shore in my northeast side, is historically home owned and owner occupied. I have large condo buildings that were once all occupied by homeowners. It's 60% rented now. I have my smaller condo buildings that aren't even condo buildings anymore. Someone came and bought them all out, now they're all rented. I have single family homes and I think in South Shore I have 367 vacant single family homes. In my south end I have over 1,000 households in the Jeffrey Manny area. I have 200, 300 former senior family homes that's being used as affordable housing. the dynamic of those communities have shifted and they have shifted and I think we touched on that and when we talk about displacement I don't know if these you guys regard these as factors of displacement but my homeowners have lost their houses to delinquent taxes to lack of estate planning they had no one to leave them with there's so many so many different issues and investors are scooping them up and to put a I've had situations where in my Calum Hattie Heights area A home that's worth $330,000 was scooped up for taxes. That totaled almost $2,000. Now you put a Section 8 tenant in it, it's fine. Rather do that than sell it, because it makes perfect business sense. These are the things I'm dealing with, and a couple other Alderman dealer when they wore, and those are the things we want to have front and center. We know, affordable housing, you're the guru. I'm very impressed. I want to turn you into a little home ownership commissioner. I can go on and on more and more, but I think you get the point. But I want to make sure we have that, the type of attention, experience, and the dedication that I know you're going to apply to this one side, I want to make sure you have that same energy in applying to this side. And I'm already willing to work with you on that. And actually it would be a pleasure. So with that said, commissioner, thank you. Yeah. I promise you don't have to turn me into someone who believes in homeownership. Like I'm with you. I understand the spectrum of housing. And I think that that's part of what I'm very excited to do, which is to go deeper on all the parts of housing in the Department of Housing. We're working at homelessness, we're working at rental, and we want to work in homeownership. We want to put more investment into helping people become homeowners if that is what they want to do. And I think that the thing that you and I agree on the most is making sure that people can stay in their homes. I understand how hard that is, both because I've done the work, I've worked in the programs, and from a personal standpoint, right? Again, my family owns in Logan Square. Like, that is a challenge when the property taxes go up and when you have all of these other maintenance things that you're trying to do. And so what I want to do is continue to expand and work on that because I want to make sure that if we're going to be not just a city but a country where homeownership is the best tool for wealth building, then that has to be accessible to everyone. And I want that to be accessible and maintained for everyone and make sure that you don't make an investment for 20, 30 years and you pay off your mortgage and you end up losing your house and not being able to pass that on. I understand how important that is and I want to work with you to continue to deepen that. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Alderman Villegas. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Commissioner, you know, when we talk about homelessness and need for housing, a lot of times a population that's always looked at is our veterans. And so given that the federal government is making a huge investment. And really, when you're talking about affordable housing and vouchers, you're looking at the vast vouchers that are being increased. So I wanted to hear from you as to what's going to be our strategy to make sure that we're taking advantage of those vouchers that the federal government is putting forward, especially for a population that's oftentimes overlooked. And so I wanted to hear what your strategy is going to be for veterans? Yeah, I think that so vast vouchers are a really important tool in the in the CHA toolbox that I want to make sure that we continue to work with CHA and anyone else who has vouchers, both for special populations like veterans and others. There is also a special initiatives for veterans in the CLIFT, Chicago Low Income Housing Trust Fund program, and I want to make sure that those are well-funded, well-run programs that have what they need in order to make sure that they can be the resources that veterans need. This is true for any number of special populations, but I think that those are two resources that we have to invest in and work harder on, and I want every one of our affordable housing developments to not just be something where it's just straight affordable housing, but that we've partnered with CHA, we've partnered with CLIF, we've partnered with whoever else we need to partner with to make sure that those that most needed are getting access to the resources. Cool. Well, I appreciate that communication and looking forward to working with you and your team on some initiatives that I have around making sure that our veterans that have served our country honorably have the dignity of having some housing. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Queen. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Congratulations, Commissioner. Last week in the state legislature, a state representative, Cam Buckner, filed a bill that would do away with the zoning of single-family criteria. Can you offer your opinion on that bill? Oh, I have not seen the bill. It's not something that I've necessarily been briefed on. Okay. So I'm happy to do some research and talk about that a little bit more. I think, you know, I would just have to have more information. Okay. I just wanted to, just for the record, that would be a bill that residents of the 13th Ward would be against to the point about building wealth. 13th Ward residents have worked for everything they have. In all respects, their home is the biggest investment they made in their entire life, and they would be fearful of losing that over some zoning bill in Springfield. So I just wanted to make sure that my resident's voice was articulated to you on the front end of this appointment. I appreciate that. And I think, as I've said before, I come in partnership and collaboration and wanting to hear any concerns always. Sure. And so I hope to be able to continue to talk to you. Yeah. Thank you so much. Congratulations. Thank you, Alderman Quinn. Other person, Fuentes? Thank you, Chair. Congratulations, Commissioner. Thank you. It's been a long road. For those who don't know, Lisette and I have been working together for a really long time. Prior to becoming an elected official, I co-chaired the Puerto Rican agenda of Chicago, a policy collective that sought to improve the conditions of Puerto Ricans in the diaspora and in Puerto Rico. And I had the privilege of having Lisette chair our housing committee. The reality of the city of Chicago is one that we all grapple with, whether you have tent encampments in your wards that are rapidly growing, whether you have families that are being displaced due to gentrification, whether you represent a ward that's historically disinvested that no one wants to build in because they're fearful of not being able to make a profit in their investment. Or you have family homeowners that can't keep up with what it means to have property tax increases, what it means to maintain a home. And we have families that are legacy families, three generations in a household and are extremely fearful that when the eldest is no longer with them, will they be able to keep up with the cost of owning without those sort of exemptions, right? Those are all of the realities that we face here in the city of Chicago. And I'm extremely confident in your ability to serve every need that the city has. There are positions that often require folks to have lived experience, educational experience, and to have the policy experience to be able to get the work done. And I think that you bring all of that. This is also probably, for at least the Latino caucus and the Latino community, one of the most historic appointments. You will be the first Latina to head the Department of Housing in the city of Chicago and its history in it. And I think that that is a huge win for our community. But I also trust your ability to be in solidarity with all communities across the city and to utilize your lived experience to be able to do good work, but to also be a learner and a listener. And that is the type of department leader that we need, not someone who's going to come in and roll out the agenda because they think that's what's best, but to listen to the elected representatives because folks elected us because we have a sense of what our community needs. I also want to take this moment to thank Jim, who's in the box, who did such great work in the interim of making sure that all of our housing portfolios and all of the projects that all of us wanted to see to the finish line would not only be ready, but he was such a thoughtful leader and collaborator. And it was always such a privilege, Jim, to be in conversation with you, to ask all the questions. And so thank you for leading the department the way you did and getting us to the point where we can have this set here. So I also want to acknowledge all of your work. I'm excited about this confirmation, both on a very personal level and the personal relationships that I've carried with you throughout the years and all of the work that you have done through Lucha on the Puerto Rican agenda in the 26th Ward, but also in a political way. we need to be able to rethink housing altogether. The city is demanding of us to be creative about how we address the needs of the city of Chicago. We have over 68,000 individuals that are experiencing homelessness in the third largest city in the country. We need to get to a better place. We don't have a lot of time. It's gonna be very difficult work and this work is gonna come with a lot of criticism. And so I am here to help flank you in that work as you choose to challenge systems and individuals and other agencies to get the work done. And I implore all of my colleagues to do the same, because every resident in the city of Chicago deserves the right to a safe roof over their head. And so I encourage all of my colleagues for a favorable vote in what is the proudest historic appointment I have seen as an elected, and that is to Commissioner Lissette Castaneda. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. I think we have one person on Zoom. other person, can you hear us? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Commissioner, thank you for taking the time this week to meet with me. I will say that I appreciated your passion for this job that you're about to take on. And so thank you for your time. I do have some questions. I wonder, you started talking when Alderman Villegas asked you about veterans, you talked a little bit about CHA and vouchers. And I wondered if you could be more specific about what kind of changes or challenges do you see in your new position in terms of having a closer relationship with the Chicago Housing Authority? Absolutely. So even just this morning, I met with CEO Tracy Scott and sort of reaffirmed that we want to work together in collaboration and in partnership to ensure that whatever resources they have can be combined with the resources that DOH has, that Ida has, that we all have, knowing that none of us has quite enough alone. and making sure that these things can all be layered. I know how important it is to have subsidy, even in an affordable unit, because sometimes even affordable is not affordable enough. And so making sure that we can continue to work with them and have access to the resources that they have access to to be part of the layering and the financing of any deal is going to be really important. In addition, even things like CHA's Choose to Own program, which encourages home ownership. I mean, that's available to CHA residents. Those are the things that I want to make sure that we can continue to work with them on and encourage residents and encourage anyone who has access to to take advantage of. Would you be willing to convene a table that includes the Chicago Housing Authority, IDAH, HUD, DOH, you know, even if it's members of this committee, our chairman or other vice chairman, to have a quarterly discussion so we can talk about coordination issues. Is that something you would be open to? I would be open to coordinating with the chair and the mayor's office on what that would look like. And I think generally, even informally, there will certainly be a lot of working together and coordination. I know that we're leading, the city is leading the streamlining process and the cut the tape initiative. And even working with them is all part of that. And I think I'd be open very much to something more formal as well. Okay. Can you talk about ideas you might have or changes you think you'd like to see made with the low income housing trust fund? the low income housing trust fund is a phenomenal program much like again the CHA which can provide subsidies it needs a lot it needs it needs money right I know that they were able to get the increase of the of the fees from the state level and we're still sort of waiting to see what those numbers will shake out to be and I think that the special initiatives that they are running are also really important for some of the most vulnerable Chicagoans. I want to see us make more investments into supporting that work of the special initiatives and making sure that those that are participating through that have the supportive services that they need. This has already been a huge concentration of the Department of Housing. I have staff that dedicate countless hours to working with the trust fund and making sure that it can continue to serve Chicagoans for a long time. Okay. I want to move on to specifics related to my ward. I represent a very diverse ward as well. However, I see a lot of high-priced housing being constructed, And I am looking for some affordable home ownership opportunities for people who are moderate in income, that can afford a home that's maybe $300,000 to $400,000 versus the $700,000, $800,000, $900,000 homes I see being built in some parts of my ward. How are you thinking about affordable housing for home ownership? Yeah, so I think a lot of it is going to be on our end on subsidies for homeowners, looking at down payment assistance and other ways in which we can help folks achieve home ownership when houses are being sold at the higher ends. Right now, we do have the BANA program, which helps with that. And I look forward to figuring out how do we continue to expand on that and grow the pot so that we can help more homeowners through into the housing that they're looking for through subsidies. Do you happen to know what your unit goal is for 2023? I mean, excuse me, 2024? for? The unit goal for? For home ownership opportunities. So right now through the BANA program, we have enough for about 25 subsidies. It'll depend on how much folks are able to qualify for. And I look forward to working in the coming months as we think about 2025 on expanding that so that we can achieve more homeownership through programs like that. Okay, Mr. Chairman, I just have two more short questions. One has to do with, you know, there's been some talk about changing the TIF program so that we can do more development in non-TIF areas. And one of the, I think, useful programs is the TIFF NIP program, the Neighborhood Improvement Program. How are you thinking about making sure we set aside money for those homeowners that just want to do some exterior and interior improvements? Yeah, I think TIFF NIP and other programs like the Home Repairs Program, which opens at the end of the month, I hope everybody got that notice, are tools that we want to continue to have no matter what in terms of like whether or not it's whatever way it's funded. We want to make sure that those programs are there and we know how important those things are as well again in maintaining home ownership. We know like I can't control things like property taxes but I can say here's a program which will allow you to do some of the maintenance on your house and that way you can you know save that money and offset it for whatever other needs there might be, again, in maintaining homeownership. So it's definitely not just on my radar, but a priority. Great. And then lastly, there's a campaign getting off the ground in my ward asking people to support rent control. Do you have a position on that at this time? I do not have a formal position on rent control. I think that the big thing is going to be the idea of making sure that there is affordability across the city. And like I've said, I want to achieve that in many different ways and in whatever resources we can find to be able to do that. Okay, well, I wish you the best. You know, Chicago is a diverse city and there's no one size fits all approach to housing development. And I hope that you, I've heard you use the word collaborative. And so I look forward to working with you on the issues that affect the city, but also affect my communities. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Alderman Dowell. Alderman Meats, can you hear us? Yes, I can. Thank you very much. Go ahead. Thank you, Commissioner. Well, soon to be Commissioner for reaching out to me. I do want to just see where your thoughts at in terms of housing here, on the west side, particularly for my ward and other ward surrounding who were affected by the flood. And I'm hoping that that's something that you will be able to work along with myself and the long-term recovery group that we have in place because it wasn't just a quick fix as the city may have thought it was for us. It is still a priority for us in saving our life and helping families to be able to stay in their home. And I want to make sure that we're using all the tools that we have in our toolbox to be able to help these families. One being your roof and porch program. But the problem that we ran into is insurance. And I just want to put that insurance companies who overpriced just to get insurance because we're in a flood zone area. And trying to be able to help these families is still mold and this is life and death situation. So I appreciate you reaching out to me, but hopefully as we move on, we can look to see how we can help families in addition to areas that have not been invested in, in terms of housing. Yes, Alderwoman, I look very much forward to working with you and learning more. I know we have a ward tour scheduled, which is a standing offer for any of the Alders. I'm happy to come out and meet. And I look forward to learning more from you. I know that on your recommendation, the team is already working with some of the folks who are working with the families, individuals that were affected after the flooding that perhaps still are in need of help, that there was not enough help provided by FEMA and others. And so I look forward to continuing to get insight from you on where we should be looking at and what are the things that we can do to help the ward. I greatly appreciate it and thank you so much. I'm looking forward to working along with you and see if we can make it better for my ward as well as the city of Chicago. Thank you. Thank you, all the person meets. And before we make the motion, as chair of the Housing Committee and Real Estate, I want to first thank the commission, the soon-to-be commissioner, for her answers today. I do think it's important that here, as committee members, we take the responsibility that has been given to us seriously in a precedent challenging time for the city of Chicago. We hear loud and clear the different challenges that we have. Small homeowners are struggling to pay the property taxes, potential bills, like Alderman Quinn mentioned, affecting small homeowners. Today in the city of Chicago, we have over 80,000 people that are housed that include 20,000 CPS children. We had also, just not too long ago, a lack of coordination and support and care that allowed that almost 300,000 black residents were displaced from the city of Chicago in the last two decades. We also have seen the displacement in neighborhoods like Humboldt Park and Pilsen, the Logan Square. They have seen almost 30,000 people that have been displaced just in those three communities. So today, the responsibility to make sure that we hold our agencies accountable, including our partners at the CHA, our partners at HUD, our partners at the state level, to make sure that we have now a collaborative approach to fix a broken system. That is the result of past decisions that have disinvested in our neighborhoods, that have allowed speculation to prey on the most vulnerable. So today, we talk about veterans, many of them homeless as well. So I think that the best way to honor, and that's what I think has been a challenge, and I think we also hear other person myths on the responsibility of the federal government. In the west side, this was declared a zone of disaster, yet the help never arrived. We also have insurance companies, and we'll definitely be talking more this year on subject matter hearings, of how these insurance companies are praying also and not really honoring their own contracts with our residents. And as a result, again, we have a system where we have right now 80,000 plus people unhoused, Well, we have almost an equivalent of vacant homes, 80,000 units that are vacant in the city of Chicago. So when we talk about supporting the small homeowner, when we talk about supporting the tenants, protecting tenants, when we talk about working for the city of Chicago, we must have that collaborative approach. I'm proud to see that in display today. I thank you all for the dialogue and conversation and commitment to work together. So I know that with Vice Chair Mitchell, now we have a commitment to work to discuss the expansion of homeownership and creation of generational wealth. Because those previous policies that passed, including redlining, continue to have happened today and is unacceptable. So today, our commitment to work collaboratively with the commissioner to make sure that we invest in our communities, that we bring all the weight of government to address one of the biggest challenges in the city of Chicago, which is creation of affordable public social housing and to do it creatively. So I love to continue working, not only under protection of tenants to address the issue of un-house, but also to support a small home ownership that we have heard. I think that we have many, many available tools, including the expansion of trust, housing co-ops, and many other ways that we can do to support that generational wealth that we hear our colleagues talking about today. So from this point on, we hope now we have a leader, and I am confident that we have a leader, proud to have a commissioner that cares, that wants to bring that spirit of collaboration. And more than anything else, I'm proud to have in front of us the first Latina Commissioner of Housing. So with that said, can I get a motion to recommend approval of this item? So move by Aldo President Jesse Fuentes. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. In the opinion of the chairs, the eyes have it, the do pass recommendation of this appointment will be reported out at the Wednesday, February 21st, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to congratulate Commissioner Castaneda. All right. Thank you again. Now we're going to move to the second item, and thank you for the patience on a Friday afternoon. Thank you very much. This is 02024-0007431, acquisition of 8-acre property with industrial building at 4130 South Morgan Street from TLP 4130 Morgan LLC. for operation of the Department of Fleet and Facility Management, Streets and Sanitation Facility in the 11th Ward. Michelle Woods from the Department of Fleet and Facility Management is present to testify on behalf of this ordinance. And Commissioner, I'm glad that we're also adding Commissioner Paul from the Commission of Streets and Sanitation to testify in front of the committee. Thank you again for being with us. Good afternoon, honorable chairman and members of the committee. uh for the record my name is michelle woods on behalf of the department of fleet and facility management the department has negotiated the acquisition of approximately one 168 350 square feet of office space and warehouse garage space comprised of approximately 146 687 square feet of warehouse and 22 000 square feet of office space the lot is approximately 8.06 acres the purchase price is 20 million point eight twenty point eight million and it's roughly 123 55 cents per square foot the property is located in the 11th ward and we've received alderley's support the property will be primarily used by the department of streets and sanitation but the chicago department of transportation the chicago fire department and the office of emergency management and communication will also occupy space on the property currently these departments are housed at 1717 west pershing which was marketed with the 1769 west pershing as part of a department of planning and development surplus property program dpd has both properties under contract for a possible future mixed-use development that will benefit the community because of the potential sale of 1717 west pershing 2fm began looking at alternate sites to house the operations streets and sanitation operational requirements were a central location on a truck route close to multiple expressways because they do serve all 50 wards a garage space for multiple vehicles like sweepers plows light duty vehicles and storage of essential equipment like barricades and traffic cones used in each ward for parades festivals and other community events 2fm has issued a task order for brokerage services and cbre was the selected low bidder for the project only four sites meeting the department's space requirements were identified of the four sites the site at 4343 west ohio was immediately eliminated because it did not meet the city's location requirements initially the remaining three property owners each wanted to lease their respective properties to the city but because of the importance of the operations and knowing that they will be continuing long after the lease expires we began negotiating to purchase the property that best met streets and sanitations requirements that property is the one located at 4130 south morgan there were several factors that justify the purchase price for the property one the current owner rented the property to the city as opposed to selling it the current owner most likely would be able to sell the property to another party at a significantly higher price due to the rent income from the city's lease the property taxes on the lease will increase over time and the owner would pass those on to those increases on to the city however if the city purchases the property the property would be exempt from real estate taxes purchasing the property outright will result in a significant cost savings long term because the property will most likely increase in value over time at the termination of a 10-year lease we would need to negotiate a new lease because the operations occurring there will continue into the future and the sum of the rents that the city would pay for the initial 10-year lease plus renewal would be significantly more expensive than the purchase price finding a lot to build a new building would cost double the purchase price of 4130 south morgan an example of this is the 3900 south normal property which was considered for um rent uh that was comparable in size but they also proposed a lease rate of 15 per square foot versus eight dollars per square foot it is recently built and the marketing stated that approximately 40 million was spent on the construction and improvements 41 30 south morgan will require improvements to build out the office space these improvements will be owned by the city as opposed to left for the owner at the end of the lease and then charged back as increases in property value at a higher rate for future leases and finally because of the unique nature of the work that's done by the departments fleet and facility management and cbre brokerage team had been unable to find any other available properties that met streets and sanitation's requirements the property features include a 21-foot vertical clearance to accommodate plows and larger trucks nine exterior dock doors two drive-up doors parking for 90 vehicles new led motion-censored lighting in the warehouse garage area it's located just south of 39th street in an industrial area and truck route the seller is tradeline properties whose economic disclosure statements were circulated last week and I respectfully request your favorable consideration of the acquisition on behalf of my colleagues at Streets and Sanitation. This concludes my presentation and I'm happy to answer any questions the committee may have. Streets and Sanitation Commissioner Stallard is joining me today along with representatives from DPD about their program and then we have representatives from CBRE, the real estate brokerage team as well. Thank you Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. Thank you. Commissioner, would you like to add anything or just wait for the questions? I'll wait for the questions. All right. Thank you. Any questions for Commissioner Alderman Burnett? And I may have missed this. Is the Alderman okay with it? Yes, Alderman Lee. Yeah, Alderman Lee has a senator with support. Any additional questions Alderman had? Thank you, guys, for the presentation, and thanks, Commissioner, for being here. while disappointed that the 49th Ward cannot provide the housing that you require. Parking spaces. That looks like it's the size of the 49th Ward, like right there. The entire property. I guess I'm wondering, so I'm planning to support this, happy to do so, and wondering of the needs that you have, does this meet them all? And or will there be kind of more sites that you guys are scouting out for some of your additional needs this is a perfect site for us for traffic services this is where we do over 1300 events with all other departments uh we will have all that housed there we're going to bring some people over from 2045 west washington over there too um to get them give them additional space over there that you know we got the department of buildings is over there i'll give some additional space there but this meet our needs okay fantastic thank you thank you any additional questions well alderman more no more questions all the money's better one more hey just one more question hey commissioner uh glad to support understand why we picked the space looks like it fits a lot of different needs that sounds great and i i'm gonna ask you a question about something that we can't change but just from my own information 1717 west pershing why did we sell it exactly because i i saw online we sold it for like six million we're putting 25 million dollars in tiff into the redevelopment it feels like it precipitated the need for this space can somebody talk to me about what that transaction noting clearly i support what we're talking about in part because we've been talking about for months in this committee the need and the desire to move more city operations and city staff out of the loop which this also solves i'm just curious if somebody can speak to that former site i think that's a dpd question how they elected and we have nolan here uh yeah thank you nolan's off with the department of planning and development i can try and answer your question um it's really part of a long-term strategy um for these buildings obviously these buildings have been on the city's inventory for decades, not generating taxes, generating a lot of money needed for improvements and maintenance of these properties. And so there was an opportunity to market one of the warehouse buildings. And along with that, we, you know, through conversations with Streets and Tenantation and 2FM, understanding that the 1717 site also needed a significant amount of investment to bring it back up to, you know, sort of safe operating conditions. And so there was just an opportunity there to market both of those properties. It generated a almost $200 million proposal for new development, including affordable housing, a new grocery store, office space, additional workspace for small businesses. It also aligns with a lot of what we've heard from the community, what they'd like to see there. They've been asking for years as well to see these properties redeveloped. And so it was just sort of a good opportunity for all of these things to come together. Hey, that's a really genuinely helpful answer. I really appreciate it. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Thank you. Alderman Burnett. Yeah. So just wanted to ask, you were saying that this may free up some folks from the building department over on Washington Street. Is that correct? No, Mike Lococo with traffic services, he has people over at 2045 West Washington Place that work for traffic services. We're putting it all under one house now. Okay, because I know the building department is in that building too, right? And we're in that building also, so it'll free up some space over there. So you all are going to come out and traffic service is going to come out, but the building department is going to stay in there? Yeah, no, no. I was strictly talking for the Department of Streets and Sanitation. No, I'm just concerned because that building is in my ward. No, no, no. Again, it was just... Is something different going to happen with the building? That's all I want to know. Anything different happening with that building, do you know? No, we're just moving our people under this one roof. That's what we're doing. We're getting everybody to work under one roof because we have the space now. Okay. And what I'm saying is in the Department of Buildings, they're in that building, that'll free up some space. There's going to be additional space now because Mike, I'll ask Mike McCoco, how many people would you say we have at 2045 West Washington? About 35. Yeah, so I know in my ward, you're all on Washington, but you park cars on Warren. There's a lot on Warren. You park cars on like three lots over there. Oh, that's OMC. We're in the basement. We're like the smallest one in the group. Okay, I'm just trying to think. Is other land going to become available because of you all moving? That's all. All right, if it's going to be a domino effect. That's fine. Thank you. All right, thanks. We have Alderman Taylor. Yes, thank you, Chair. I wanted to continue with the question and along what Alderman LaSpada talked about, why we'll vote to support this. I want us to be smart about where we spend our money at because these type of investments, we could repurpose the old school. We got a bunch of city buildings that we can actually go in. And I've said this before, but I really want us to, as DPD, look at the buildings and the things that we already own. If you all were to go in one of the communities, it could kickstart development. It could start economic development in certain parts of the wards. And so I want you all to think about it. I will be supporting this to vote, yes. But for future deals, we need to have a real conversation about how we're spending our money. Thanks, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Thank you all the person. And again, this was part of our commitment to continue this conversation being part of the larger strategy. This is a step, I think, in that direction. I know that there's a lot of work ahead of us, but I appreciate the departments being here explaining given the importance of public dollars. So we'll definitely continue committed on that line. So unless there's any other questions, can I get a motion to recommend approval of this item? So move Alderman Espada. Oh. Oh, yeah. And Alderman Bernettusek. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. In the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. The do pass recommendation of this ordinance will be reported out at the Wednesday, February 21st, 2024 City Council meeting. Thank you again, Commissioner. Thanks, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Michelle. all right so this is item number three is a direct introduction this is a lease agreement for the use of an office space to service the office of inspector general at 231 South La Salle Street in the 34th Ward we have both with us Michelle Woods from the Department of Fleet and Facility Management as well as our inspector general Deborah Buisburg so thank you both for being here with us and you know we start with the presentation and then we have the questions great again for the record my name is Michelle Woods on the behalf of the Department of Fleet and Facility Management I am aware that it is unusual for a direct introduction for real estate ordinance however extensive damage caused by a roof leak to the city facility housing the office of the Inspector General during the extreme cold weather we had last month warranted a more expeditious approval of a new location for their operations. 2FM has a plan to repair the roof as soon as the weather breaks. However, the current conditions require multiple air scrubbers operating because of the importance of the work that OIG does. An expeditious process to approve the lease is needed, this new lease. The department has negotiated a lease of approximately 48,549 square feet of office space at 23.50 per square foot the annual rent in 2021 will come to approximately 1 million dollars with a 2.5 percent annual increase this is 24 below the current market rate in addition we are able to get 16 months of no rent the property is located in the 34th ward at jackson and lasalle and we have received alder conway's support the office of budget and management approached ais at the time now 2fm in may of 2023 to discuss space needs for the office of the inspector general we gave the office of the inspector general our space programming questionnaire to complete and the form includes operational requirements for the space being requested a task order for brokerage services was approved and cbre was selected to assist in finding the location that met the oig requirements the main concerns and goals outlining outlined in the program questionnaire were to find a space that met several requirements sufficient square footage to accommodate staff and anticipated future hires including three future hires budgeted for 2024 improved security for the oig staff because of the sensitive nature of their work a location that is not in a city facility shared with other city departments to protect privacy of clients, and a location downtown close to multiple modes of public transportation as staff resides in multiple neighborhoods around the city. There were no city facilities that met the OIG requirements. Additionally, we requested information on vacant space from the county who did not have sufficient space for the entire OIG staff to stay together and for future growth. Our initial search in October of 2023 identified 16 properties that met the requirements. We searched, we went and looked at four properties and pared it down to a final two and requested the best and final offer from both properties. 231 South LaSalle provided the greatest value. 231 South LaSalle price is the most favorable deal we could get that meets the requirements it is 24 below the market rate market value in addition the improvement needs are minimal which will allow them to occupy sooner and this was a big factor for us improvements include construction of a secure vault for evidence 32 offices and a large meeting room improvements are expected to take five months to complete which is faster than the improvements that would be needed at other the other site considered and timing is a significant factor in the selection process here the lease has a 10-year term with an option to terminate in year seven a shorter term lease was requested but benign denied because of the amortization of improvement costs over the course of the lease we were successful in negotiating a termination and or contraction at year seven which would allow us to give up 50 of the space and get a reduced rent for the remaining term of the lease the landlord will abate gross rent for 16 months from the lease commencement and the landlord majority is owned by beacon capital and you have received the economic disclosure statements of parties with more than seven and a half percent interest the building meets the oig's operational requirements there is adequate square footage it is a secure building with a lobby presence and gated access to elevators it's separated from from other city facilities, and it's a location accessible to multiple modes of public transportation. Therefore, I ask your favorable consideration of this new lease. I am joined by the Inspector General, who can join me in answering any questions you may have. Thank you. We start with a round of questions. We have Alderman Moore first. Thank you. You touched on one of my, the questions that I was going to have. You said it's separated from other city facilities. I think that's critical. and if the IG wants to talk more about that, I know for a fact that I just walk in, I tell somebody I'm telling on them, so I don't mind. But other people I've seen, other people I know, if I've asked them, we'll go see this, but no, people are going to see me walk in there, stuff like that, I've heard that before. Can you talk more about that in terms of, have you heard people say that, experienced that, and how people may not even come before you for that situation? Absolutely. I appreciate the question. You're exactly right. The nature of our work requires in our physical facility that we meet and balance needs for security and confidentiality and independence and accessibility. And when we are in a city facility, we are faced with exactly the problem you described, which is that people do not want to come and talk to us where they reasonably are concerned that they might run into a colleague in the lobby or they might see somebody in the elevator. And so being in a non-city building will allow us to offer people a more comfortable environment to come and talk to us. We hear frequently from complainants or would-be complainants and from witnesses and from subjects of our investigations, for that matter, that they have privacy concerns. those are those are serious concerns which i take seriously we have profound obligations to protect people from retaliation from cooperating with our work and i believe that this is the best physical security physical space solution to to meet those needs all right thank you thank you champ thank you alderman any additional questions um alderman and then alderman uh thank you chair um thank you Thank you guys for this presentation. Inspector General, I know we've had some conversations about this. I'll say for the presentation, actually, I really appreciated the layout of kind of the process that you guys went through. So thank you again for that. And Chair, thanks for, I know, you know, we've talked about getting more info and details in these presentations. So this was really helpful to kind of have that full timeline, where you guys looked, why you got there. And then, of course, the natural, natural weather event, creating your situation. I remember, I think before starting my first term, actually visiting the office and then Inspector General Ferguson. And it was a cramped space then, like definitely cozy, cozy, maybe I'd say. And so I very, very supportive of this and, you know, echo Alderman Moore's statements and sentiments on, you know, why it's important to have this separate space. And obviously, security is of the utmost concern. And then, of course, most pressingly, we would like you to not be dealing with mold issues, water damage, and to have a functional space. So I think we should move on this as soon as possible. So thank you guys for bringing this to us and for AIS for moving so quickly on this. Thank you. We do have a repair for the roof plan, though. It is going to happen. We're not going to leave it like that. That is fantastic. Thank you. Thank you all the Yeah, it was, you know, as eloquently stated by my colleagues, I certainly voice my support for this. It is necessary that the inspector general have their own space that is separate yet accessible and a nice location. It's near here, but separate is perfect for that. obviously Inspector General Whitsburg has taken on a lot, which we appreciate in terms of really creating trust between the community and city officials. It's also a personal thrill for me, as some of you may know, I used to prosecute public corruption and financial crime cases hand-in-hand with the Inspector General's office back in time and oftentimes successfully. So it's a personal thrill for me to have this office moving into the 34th Ward. So I heartily express my support and move to pass mr chairman thank you so we have a motion by alderman conway all those oh oh you're not gonna be sorry it has to be a commitment great catch there has to be a committee member that's right so but we'll take it in spirit we'll take it as well to member net and now the person clay all those in favor god all those again say nay an opinion of the chair that i have it um they do pass recommendation for these owners will be reported out at the wednesday february 21st 24th city council meeting i appreciate both for working with us and otherwise a short time frame but i hope members see our commitment to improve the process so i appreciate both for working with us in a very short time frame and yeah look forward to working together thank you all very much thank you congratulations all right all right it's friday so i think that's good maybe that's what It does. So we move on to item number four. This is now on the Department of Housing. Item 02024-0007430, sale of city home lots at 3517-3431, 3433-3303 in West Flournoy Street at 3553 West Lexington Street to an execution of redevelopment agreement with Home and Housing LLC for East Garfield Park affordable housing homes under City Lots for Working Families Program in the 24th Ward. Brian O'Donnell from the Department of Housing is present to testify on behalf of this ordinance. Thank you, Brian. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good afternoon, committee members for the record. My name is Brian O'Donnell with the Homeownership Bureau in the Department of Housing. I am present this afternoon to provide testimony in support of ordinance to sell five lots to home and housing llc so that can build and sell single family homes in the home and square area of east scarf hill park i understand that alderwoman scott is joining us via zoom also present for the development team are stephanie neal and katan hartnett of iff right back there next no keep that up sorry the 24th ward lots will be sold for one dollar each under the city lots for working families program the proposed development is part of the larger reclaiming chicago effort led by united power for action and justice next the develop the developer home and housing llc is an entity created by illinois facilities fund for this proposed development the general contractor and architect are inherent homes designer and builder of modular homes the inherent factory is in the 24th ward on the 4600 block of west polk street the lot shown here outlet go back one yeah the lots down here outlined in red are the lots under consideration today the department typically requires eight lots minimum for a city lots for working families development however is the first city lots development to come through the chai block builder land sale website the department is seeking to waive the eight lot minimum and allow the five lot development to get underway. The department will work with the developer and 2FM to secure additional lots, hopefully in the not too distant future. Next. As you see, four of the five lots are on West Flournoy and the fifth on Lexington Street, and the land values are in the far right column. Next. The five lots can be found within the yellow parallelogram at the top of the of the image the original Sears Tower is located just south at Holman and Arlington next this slide shows the current maximum price allowed for a three-bedroom single-family home under the city lot for working families program about 392 thousand dollars this is substantially higher than the end of year average and median sales figures for East Garfield Park which came in at almost $251,000 and at $245,000 respectively. The department only sets a maximum price. The developer must meet or set a new construction market price. And though not part of the ordinance before you today, buyers of these zones will be eligible for Vanna Grants, up to $100,000 for current community residents and up to $90,000 for other buyers. Additionally, United Power has secured grant funding from the state for reclaiming Chicago homebuyers. Here are the proposed elevations for the five modular homes slated for the development. The floor plans show a three-bedroom, two-bathroom home. On the lower left, you can see there is a bedroom on the ground floor rear, which allows for a family room upstairs in addition to the living room on the main floor. this concludes my testimony do you have any questions thank you I know we have Alder person Scott also on the line but if you have any other questions Alder moment speech okay who's the who's doing the modular housing inherent thank you Alder person Scott any i'm not sure she can hear us but i know we do have a letter of support from alderman scott so unless unless anybody has any questions can we can we make a move to pass by alderman queen all those in favor say aye all those opposed nay independent of the chair the ayes have it they do pass recommendation of these ordinance will be reported out at the wednesday february 21st 24 meeting thank you again brian for for your testimony item number five is 02024-000730 37 restructuring of loan agreement with Erie Cooperative Limited Partnership for the Rehabilitation of Properties in the vicinity of West Huron Street and North Ketsey Avenue in the 27th Ward. Joseph Lewis from the Department of Housing is present to testify on behalf of these ordinance. Thank you for coming. Thank you Chairman Sigel Lopez and members of the committee. For the record my name is Joseph Lewis. I'm a financial planning analyst with the Department of housing the request before you is a proposed ordinance to authorize new financial assistance and the restructuring of an existing city loan in connection with the 87 unit affordable scattered site rental community known as the herald washington apartments the property that's the subject of this project is located in the 27th ward and alderman burnett has provided a letter of support for this proposal next slide please in particular the request includes approval of up to $2,600,000 in new financial assistance for the Harold Washington Apartments. The DOH also seeks authority to restructure the existing city agreements related to an existing home loan to allow when relevant units turn over to new tenants. For up to 29 of the units currently designated for occupancy by households earning no more than 50% of the area median income to instead be designated for occupancy by households earning no more than 60 percent of the area median income. Additionally, DOH seeks to extend affordability restrictions associated with the past home loan that are currently set to expire in 2027 to instead expire in 2042. These restructuring actions don't do not involve any other modification to the existing city loans principal balance, interest rate, repayment terms, or maturity. Next slide please. The subject properties are in the vicinity of west huron street and north kedsey avenue at 18 separate buildings all within the humble park community area and the 27th ward represented by alter alderman walter burnett jr next slide please through a holding company the properties were developed by not-for-profit organization bickerdike redevelopment corporation in the early 2000s and they are owned by bickerdike the 87 affordable rental units that make up the herald washington apartments are primarily larger units for families all but four units are at least two bedrooms in size and 54 units contain at least three bedrooms all 87 units are currently restricted to occupancy by households who earn no more than 50 percent of the area median income and to support construction and development of the subject properties approximately 20 years ago the city provided tax credits tax increment financing and home funds the affordability affordability period associated with the home funds is set to expire in 2027. next slide please shown here are representative photos of some of the properties under discussion for your information next slide please in the approximately 20 years since the properties were developed and placed in service as affordable housing the cost of operating these properties has risen materially and significant elements of the operating costs of these properties are beyond the developer's control. To reconfigure the property's financial structure, the proposed solution is a combination of approaches including a moderate increase to rent potential through conversion of approximately one-third of the units in this property in this project to 60% AMI rent restrictions, as well as reducing the property's hard debt obligations through payoffs and a reduction to the ongoing requirement to replenish a reserve for replacements and repairs. This combination of approaches requires approximately two million six hundred thousand dollars in financial assistance to implement and it was developed in consultation with hud to ensure that the property's financial model is viable for the next 15 years next slide please this slide identifies the sources and uses of funds for the proposal the new city financing is the only source of funds for the project as the proposal primarily concerns refinancing efforts the majority of the uses of funds are attributed to these restructuring activities rather than construction costs so a portion of the new city financing will be used to fund necessary repairs to building facades and sidings next slide please as previously mentioned the developer and owner is bickerdike redevelopment corporation which owns the property through a doing business as entity erie cooperative limited partnership established in 1967 bickerdike is a member-based not-for-profit Community Development Corporation based on the northwest side of Chicago, serving low and moderate income Chicagoans with a particular focus on the communities of Westtown, Humboldt Park, Logan Square, Avondale, and Hermosa. Vickerdike's mission is to provide high quality affordable housing, confront gentrification and displacement, promote economic development, and advocacy for equitable allocation of resources. Vickerdike Apartments, their property management affiliate, oversees a portfolio that includes approximately 1200 units and recent past projects completed by Bickerdike with city support include the Nelson Mandela apartments in 2018 and the Lucy Gonzalez Parsons apartments a deeply affordable transit oriented development at the Logan Square Blue Line station in 2022. Next slide please. I recap the requested actions in the slide for your consideration and I'm joined by Joy Arruguete and Michael Burton from Bickerdike's management team to answer any any questions that you may have. Thank you for your consideration of this matter. Thank you, Joseph. Any questions for the department or the Bob Eker Dyke team? Any questions? Otherwise, can I get a motion to approve? Oh, Albert and Burnett, go ahead. Yeah, so is this, is this... Yes, sir. Okay. I'm right on time. So, great organization, does a lot for affordable housing, probably one of the leaders in affordable housing in the city, to be quite honest about it, but also have the, they, they, so they need this money to sustain themselves, right? That's the only challenging part about affordable housing, that they have to come back, try to get money to keep their buildings up to par and all of those things. I support this 100%. You know, my story about this development when it was first built. The community was getting mad at me because they thought I was bringing some expensive condos to the neighborhood. But it was all affordable. So that's how beautiful that development is. And this would just help us to keep them up to par with all of the other nice houses that's being built in the area. So we appreciate everyone's support on this. Thank you. Thank you, Alderman Burnett. So can I get a motion to approve this item? the move by Alderman Clay all those in favor say aye all those opposed and nay in the eyes of the chair the eyes have it the do pass recommendation of these orders will be reported out at the Wednesday February 21st 24 City Council meeting and congratulations to the 27th award and and the applicant thank you thank you thank you everyone we we have a substitute of the ordinance for items item six this is a minor change that includes adding an additional city own lot to the right of the entry agreement. All committee members have also received a digital copy of the ordinance via email, so you can check. Here we have item number six for your referral is the SO20240007432, first amendment to right of entry agreement for time extension to inspect city property at 1325 West 119th Street and certain adjacent land by West Pullman Development Partners LLC and DEL3 Realty Advisors LLC in the 21st Ward. Can I get a motion first to accept and consider the substitute ordinance? The move by Vice Chair Mitchell. All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. In the eyes of the chair, the eyes have it. We have now Erica Silke from the Department of Planning and Development to present and testify to behalf of this ordinance. Thank you. Thank you. My name is Erica Selke, senior planner with the Department of Planning and Development. This is a request for an extension of an existing right of entry for property at 1325 West 119th Street. Can you go to the next slide, please? This is located in the West Pullman Community Area in the 21st Ward under Alderman Mosley. I have a letter of support from him dated January 24th. Next slide, please. So it's a bit of a complicated site, but everything you see there in purple is under the control of DL3 Realty Advisors. In red, you can see a city-owned parcel that is subject to this right of entry. And green is also a parcel. This is the parcel that was added in the substitute ordinance. that is also under the right of entry. The blue, there's some complicated pin splits here. So the blue shares some pins with the red parcel, but that would be subdivided out. Next slide, please. It's in the PMD 10 district. Next slide. So the DL3 is proposing to acquire all the parcels in the red dotted line the orange are the city parcels under the right of entry agreement next slide please they're proposing an industrial building again this is in the pmd 10 in the industrial corridor it would be a spec industrial warehouse type building next slide so extending this right of entry will directly facilitate efforts by DL3 realty advisors to redevelop this vacant property as a industrial use by allowing necessary access to complete environmental testing on the site. Thank you. Thank you, Erica. Any questions or comments? Otherwise, can I get a motion to move by the person Cuentes? All those in favor say aye. All those opposed say nay. In the eyes of the chair the eyes have it the do pass recommendation of these ordinance will be reported out at the next Wednesday February 21st 24 city council meeting thank you now we're moving to item number seven is ordinance 2024-0007-328 sale of city-owned property at 6949 South Martin Luther King Drive to Amanda Crew and their adjacent neighbors land acquisition program in the sixth ward James michaels from the department of planning and development is here present to testify on the car of this order thank you good afternoon chairman and members of the committee for the record by ms james michaels with the department of planning and development this item is an an lap sale for an unimproved city-owned parcel located at 69 49 north martin luther king to amanda curio the adjacent neighbor at 69 51 south martin luther king next slide the property is owned rs3 in the grand Crossing Community Area. Next slide. The parcel will be used as an extended yard. The appraised market value is $12,000, $12,500, and the sale price is $3,000. Next slide. The vacant lot dimensions are 25 by 123.9 by 3,900 square feet approximately. Next slide. In addition, the department has obtained AAS clearance on the parcel, and we have support from 6th Ward Alderman, William Hall. that concludes my presentation on this item thank you very much James I had any questions or comments otherwise can I get a motion to move some of all the person Jesse Fuentes all those in favor say aye all those opposed a name in the eyes of the chair guys have it the do pass recommendation of this ordinance will be reported out of the next Wednesday February 21st 24 City Council meeting item number eight is ordinance 20 to 4-0-0-0-7 362 the sale of vacant city-owned property at 4259 West Monroe Street to Larry Newman and Venetia Newman through the Chi Block Builder land sale platform in the 28th Ward. James Michaels, I'll also hear from the Department of Planning to present on behalf of this ordinance. For the record, my name is James Michaels from the Department of Planning and Development for the disposition of side yard properties received through the Chi Block platform located in the 28th, 24th, 17th, and 36th Ward. This will take care of the next few ordinances. Next slide. About 37th, sorry. 28th, 24th, 17th, and 37th awards. Next slide. Eligible buyers were required to show proof of owner accuracy and must own and reside in a home directly adjacent to the city lot. Next slide. The sale price for the qualified purchasers is 10% of the appraised market value. Next slide. Side yards deeds will require improvement within six months. After they improve, applicants can use property for any use permitted by zoning. Next slide. In addition, each qualified purchaser must hold the property for five years. Next slide. The Department recommends approval of the following properties within the 28th, 24th, 17th, and 37th wards with support from Alderman Jason Irving, Monique Scott, David Moore, and Emma Mitts. Included are the applicant's property locations, existing conditions, and zoning, and agreed purchase price, which represents 10% of the market value. Next slide. In summary, the Department of Planning and Development has reviewed the proposed sale of city parcels to qualified buyers in the 28th, 24th, 17th, and 37th wards and recommends approval of these parcels to pass city council. That's it. That concludes my presentation at this point. Thank you, James. Any questions or comments? Mr. Chairman. Oh, yep. Elder woman Dow. Yeah, no questions about what was presented, but just would ask for consistency in our agenda. So I'm looking at item 7, 8, which have purchase prices and addresses. addresses. Number nine does not have purchase prices for the individual lot. 10 doesn't have a list of lots or the purchase price. And 11 has the address and the purchase price. I'm just wondering if we could, as we have had in the past, just standardize this so we can just see it all at once on a glance. Yeah. Yeah, point. It's just a recommendation. Yep. Point noted, Alderwoman Dowell. Yeah, so we'll continue, you know, for the sake of consistency, make sure that, you know, we group them and make sure that every presentation is more standardized. So absolutely, point well taken. Any other comments? Move to pass by Alderman Quinn. all those in favor say aye all those opposing name in the opinion of the chair the eyes have it thank you james thank you yeah so and and precisely just for the sake of of consistency um we'll make sure that we we're gonna group items 9 10 and 11. so so i'm gonna read it into the record for, yeah, item number nine, there's ordinance 2024-0007369, the sale of city-owned vacant property at 1242 South Harding Avenue to Eileen Berg at 4047 West Fifth Avenue to Pamela Walker at 4157 West Fifth Avenue to Valerie Davis and at 1516 South Trip Avenue to Darno Tops Senior under the chai block builder land sale platform in the 24th ward um yeah we also have we're gonna group it just for just for the sake of time too item 10 is ordinance 2024-0007371 sale of city-owned properties in the 17th ward to select the buyers under the chai block build um builder land sale platform in the 17th ward and then we have item 11 ordinance 02024-0007433 sale of vacant city owned property at 531 north laramie street to roman uh castrejon and jasmine canter castrejon through the chai block builder land sale in a platform in the 37th ward as well and james michael from department of planning and development um also here was here to present so if we have a do a motion to approve all these three can I get a motion to approve? So move out the person Jesse Fuentes all those in favor say aye all those opposed say nay, in the eyes of the chair there I have it, the recommendation of these ordinance will be reported out at the Wednesday February 21st 24th city council meeting and I appreciate all your patience, there be no further business before the committee, can I get a motion just to adjourn? So move out all the woman Jesse Fuentes all those in favor say aye all those opposed say nay, in the opinion of the chairs i have it the meeting on the committee on housing and real estate is adjourned thank you all