Committee on Finance meeting, July 15, 2024
- When: Mon, Jul 15, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Finance
- Video: https://vimeo.com/983247379
- Transcript: full text (24,096 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 49:57 Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for up to $1.4 million in TIF funds for De Diego…
- 53:25 Daniel La Spata: Described the De Diego playground and pickleball court project as long in development and…
- 54:45 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked whether private dollars were raised for the De Diego playground and who would use…
- 55:28 Daniel La Spata: Responded to Alderperson Jeanette B. Taylor that the community has many young families and…
- 56:51 Chris Taliaferro: Said he supports the De Diego project and noted that George Rogers Clark school in his…
- 57:56 Pat Dowell: Told CPS staff she was still waiting for an answer on playground improvements at Mollison…
- 58:30 Amendment to Chapter 16-14 regarding the Neighborhood Opportunity Fund and DPD medium/large capital grant…
- 1:17:47 Daniel La Spata: Asked DPD to explain the local residency bonus and why it applies to the medium but not the…
- 1:19:21 William Conway: Asked whether the changes affect the 10 percent of NOF funds that stay with the ward or the…
- 1:20:04 David H. Moore: Thanked the chair for the briefing and said her housing background gave him confidence the…
- 1:21:40 David H. Moore: Asked whether the new pre-development funds could be applied retroactively to a past NOF…
- 1:22:53 David H. Moore: Said the new criteria could help community investors who put their own money into vacant…
- 1:24:42 Pat Dowell: Suggested that Alderperson David H. Moore bring developers with deficient applications to meet…
- 1:25:25 Gilbert Villegas: Asked whether labor protections or standards are used in scoring applications and who…
- 1:26:35 Scott Waguespack: Asked for the success rate of NOF projects since 2016, including how many were completed,…
- 1:27:58 Scott Waguespack: Asked whether funds for incomplete large projects are held in reserve or reallocated.
- 1:29:26 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Noted many vacant storefronts in her ward and asked whether churches and faith…
- 1:31:12 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked what options exist for applicants who lack seed capital to front costs under…
- 1:32:35 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Raised language access for small business owners applying for grants and said she…
- 1:35:11 Michael D. Rodriguez: Asked for a ward-by-ward breakdown of the increase in grant applications.
- 1:36:14 Pat Dowell: Said she appreciated DPD streamlining the programs and asked the department to develop general…
- 1:37:27 Resolution authorizing the Department of Housing to apply for the CDBG-CV Urban Shelter grant for 1622 N.…
- 1:48:18 Ordinances authorizing and denying payment of various small claims
- 1:48:57 Orders authorizing charitable solicitation (tag day) permits
- 1:49:58 Department of Law reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements for June 2024
- 1:50:32 Settlement: Melissa Najera, special representative for Alfonso Cazares, v. City of Chicago ($410,000)
- 1:55:43 Nicholas Sposato: Asked whether the Cazares case also alleged an illegal arrest.
- 1:56:25 Settlement: Mary Reading, special administrator of the estate of Dana Hubbert, v. City of Chicago ($2.5…
- 2:00:38 Nicholas Sposato: Asked to confirm the distance of the police pursuit in the Hubbert case and said he…
- 2:02:02 Settlement: Valles v. City of Chicago reversed conviction lawsuit ($7.6 million)
- 2:11:17 William Conway: Asked whether witnesses still stood by their identifications and whether a certificate of…
- 2:13:08 William Conway: Said that with no certificate of innocence, witnesses standing by their identifications, and…
- 2:13:41 Nicholas Sposato: Questioned witness credibility and officer discipline in the Valles case and said he would…
- 2:16:19 Scott Waguespack: Asked what claims were made against the county defendants in the Valles case, the role of…
- 2:20:40 Monique L. Scott: Asked to be recorded as a no on the Valles settlement.
- 2:24:01 Settlement: Livingston et al. v. City of Chicago and Griffin v. City of Chicago, Fire Department paramedic…
- 2:44:49 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether the physical tests were a graduation requirement in any other years and what…
- 2:46:59 Nicole T. Lee: Said the test appeared unnecessary and stated full support for the settlement to compensate…
- 2:48:14 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked how many men were not hired for failing the Fire Department physical tests.
- 2:48:30 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked for the racial makeup of the 11 plaintiffs.
- 2:48:57 Nicole T. Lee: Sought clarification that men who failed the test withdrew from the program voluntarily.
- 2:49:35 Derrick G. Curtis: Said the city should audit practices because candidates good enough for other agencies…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Finance, chaired by Alderperson Pat Dowell, heard public comment and then took up eight agenda items. The committee recommended passage of a TIF intergovernmental agreement of up to $1.4 million for playground and athletic court improvements at De Diego Elementary, an amendment to the Neighborhood Opportunity Fund rules consolidating Department of Planning and Development capital grants into medium and large programs with a new pre-development grant, and a resolution authorizing the Department of Housing to apply for state CDBG-CV urban shelter grants for two youth shelter sites. Small claims, tag day permits and Law Department reports were placed on the omnibus or filed. Of four proposed legal settlements, the $410,000 Cazares settlement, the $2.5 million Hubbert police pursuit settlement and the $11.25 million Livingston/Griffin Fire Department gender discrimination settlement were recommended for passage, while the $7.6 million Valles wrongful conviction settlement failed on a roll call announced as 9 yeas and 14 nays.
Topics: TIF funding for schools, Neighborhood Opportunity Fund, capital grant programs, non-congregate shelters, police misconduct settlements, wrongful conviction settlement, Fire Department discrimination settlement, public comment, language access, small claims and tag days
Agenda items discussed
- 49:26 Approval of the June 2024 monthly Rule 45 report: passed
- 49:57 Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for up to $1.4 million in TIF funds for De Diego Elementary Community Academy playground and athletic courts: passed
- 58:30 Amendment to Chapter 16-14 regarding the Neighborhood Opportunity Fund and DPD medium/large capital grant and pre-development grant programs: passed
- 1:37:27 Resolution authorizing the Department of Housing to apply for the CDBG-CV Urban Shelter grant for 1622 N. California and 8913 S. Ashland: passed
- 1:48:18 Ordinances authorizing and denying payment of various small claims: passed
- 1:48:57 Orders authorizing charitable solicitation (tag day) permits: passed
- 1:49:58 Department of Law reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements for June 2024
- 1:50:32 Settlement: Melissa Najera, special representative for Alfonso Cazares, v. City of Chicago ($410,000): passed
- 1:56:25 Settlement: Mary Reading, special administrator of the estate of Dana Hubbert, v. City of Chicago ($2.5 million): passed
- 2:02:02 Settlement: Valles v. City of Chicago reversed conviction lawsuit ($7.6 million): failed
- 2:24:01 Settlement: Livingston et al. v. City of Chicago and Griffin v. City of Chicago, Fire Department paramedic gender and disability discrimination ($11.25 million): passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Pat Dowell (chair): Told CPS staff she was still waiting for an answer on playground improvements at Mollison Elementary School. (57:56); Suggested that Alderperson David H. Moore bring developers with deficient applications to meet with Planning and Development staff to review the deficiencies. (1:24:42); Said she appreciated DPD streamlining the programs and asked the department to develop general parameters explaining underwriting decisions in the large program. (1:36:14)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Described the De Diego playground and pickleball court project as long in development and asked colleagues for favorable consideration. (53:25); Responded to Alderperson Jeanette B. Taylor that the community has many young families and daycares and the facilities would be used by residents of all ages. (55:28); Asked DPD to explain the local residency bonus and why it applies to the medium but not the large grant program. (1:17:47)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked whether private dollars were raised for the De Diego playground and who would use it, saying the cost seemed high for TIF dollars. (54:45); Asked how many men were not hired for failing the Fire Department physical tests. (2:48:14); Asked for the racial makeup of the 11 plaintiffs. (2:48:30)
- Chris Taliaferro (alderperson): Said he supports the De Diego project and noted that George Rogers Clark school in his ward is still waiting for safety improvements. (56:51)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked whether the changes affect the 10 percent of NOF funds that stay with the ward or the LaSalle Street projects, and was told they do not. (1:19:21); Asked whether witnesses still stood by their identifications and whether a certificate of innocence was sought in the Valles case. (2:11:17); Said that with no certificate of innocence, witnesses standing by their identifications, and a combined settlement above precedent, he asked to be recorded as a no. (2:13:08)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Thanked the chair for the briefing and said her housing background gave him confidence the proposal was vetted. (1:20:04); Asked whether the new pre-development funds could be applied retroactively to a past NOF grantee opening a flower shop in his ward. (1:21:40); Said the new criteria could help community investors who put their own money into vacant lots and urged colleagues to support the tool for redevelopment. (1:22:53)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked whether labor protections or standards are used in scoring applications and who monitors compliance. (1:25:25)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked for the success rate of NOF projects since 2016, including how many were completed, under construction, withdrawn or terminated. (1:26:35); Asked whether funds for incomplete large projects are held in reserve or reallocated. (1:27:58); Asked what claims were made against the county defendants in the Valles case, the role of the felony review attorney, and who the plaintiff's attorneys were. (2:16:19)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Noted many vacant storefronts in her ward and asked whether churches and faith organizations are eligible for the grants. (1:29:26); Asked what options exist for applicants who lack seed capital to front costs under the reimbursement-based pre-development grant. (1:31:12); Raised language access for small business owners applying for grants and said she wants to work with departments to improve it. (1:32:35)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson): Asked for a ward-by-ward breakdown of the increase in grant applications. (1:35:11)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Asked whether the Cazares case also alleged an illegal arrest. (1:55:43); Asked to confirm the distance of the police pursuit in the Hubbert case and said he supports the settlement. (2:00:38); Questioned witness credibility and officer discipline in the Valles case and said he would join his colleague in voting no. (2:13:41)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Asked to be recorded as a no on the Valles settlement. (2:20:40)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked whether the physical tests were a graduation requirement in any other years and what led to adopting and then dropping them. (2:44:49); Said the test appeared unnecessary and stated full support for the settlement to compensate the women. (2:46:59); Sought clarification that men who failed the test withdrew from the program voluntarily. (2:48:57)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Said the city should audit practices because candidates good enough for other agencies should be good enough for Chicago, and stated full support for the settlement. (2:49:35)
Exchanges between members
- 55:28 La Spata answered Taylor's question about who would use the De Diego playground.
- 1:20:04 Moore thanked the chair for the briefing on the capital grant changes.
- 1:24:42 The chair suggested Moore bring developers to meet with DPD staff about application deficiencies.
- 2:13:08 Conway asked the chair to record him as a no on the Valles settlement.
- 2:15:21 Sposato said he stood with his colleague in voting no on the Valles settlement.
- 2:38:07 Conway deferred his turn to Sposato as a former Fire Department member.
- 2:44:49 Lee followed up on the line of questioning Conway had just asked.
- 2:48:57 Lee sought to clarify the answer to Taylor's question about men who failed the test.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error