TIF redevelopment agreements in the Chicago City Council

Tax increment financing (TIF) districts set aside property tax growth for development. Redevelopment agreements give developers TIF assistance and need Council approval.

Results for TIF redevelopment agreements: 171 key roll calls, 24 more matching legislation, and 25 documents. Search again or refine, or ask a question about it on Research.

Roll calls

DateLegislationRecordVoteResult
Oct 14, 2026Redevelopment agreement with By the Hand Club For Kids NFP to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002874649–0Passed
Oct 14, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Hudson Michigan Avenue Owner LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002877249–0Passed
Oct 14, 2026Redevelopment agreement with North Lawndale Catalyst Initiative NFP to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002874849–0Passed
Oct 14, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002874549–0Passed
Oct 14, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002874349–0Passed
Sep 23, 2026Redevelopment agreement with 30 N LaSalle MF Redevelopment LLC and Leslie J. Raffel Foundation to provide…SO2026-002730350–0Passed
Sep 23, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Foundry Park Properties KP7 LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2026-002716649–1Passed
Sep 23, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Deeply Rooted Productions, Inc. to provide Housing and Economic Development…O2026-002723950–0Passed
Sep 23, 2026Redevelopment agreement with 111 Monroe Hotel Landlord LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2026-002714650–0Passed
Sep 23, 2026Second amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Public Building Commission regarding allocated tax…O2026-002713750–0Passed
Sep 23, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Housing Authority to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2026-002723550–0Passed
Jul 15, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Villa Guadalupe Senior Services Corp. to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002624849–0Passed
Jul 15, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Roosevelt/Clark Partners LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2026-002627544–5Passed
Jul 15, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Transit Authority to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002624649–0Passed
Jul 15, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Trudelta LLC to provide Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF) assistance for…O2026-002626049–0Passed
Jul 15, 2026Amendment of ordinance approving redevelopment plan for LaSalle Central Tax Increment Financing (TIF)…O2026-002625049–0Passed
Jul 15, 2026Amended and restated redevelopment agreement with Roosevelt/Clark Partners LLC to provide tax increment…SO2026-002626747–1Passed
Jun 17, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with the Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002539849–0Passed
Jun 17, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002539949–0Passed
Jun 17, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Axiom Flame LLC to provide Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF) assistance for…O2026-002547649–0Passed
Jun 17, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance…O2026-002543049–0Passed
Jun 17, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2026-002539749–0Passed
May 20, 2026Redevelopment agreement with South Side Community Art Center to provide Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF)…O2026-002492550–0Passed
May 20, 2026First amendment to redevelopment agreement with Westside Health Authority to provide tax increment financing…O2026-002487850–0Passed
May 20, 2026Redevelopment agreement with The Workshop Arts Collaborative LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002487050–0Passed
May 20, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002486950–0Passed
May 20, 2026First amendment of redevelopment agreement with Celadon Construction Corporation NFP, Celadon Partners LLC,…O2026-002487150–0Passed
Apr 15, 2026Amended redevelopment agreement with Institute of Cultural Affairs to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002406350–0Passed
Mar 18, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance…O2026-002332749–1Passed
Mar 18, 2026First amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing…O2026-002332549–1Passed
Mar 18, 2026Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2026-002332849–1Passed
Mar 18, 2026Third amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing…O2026-002332649–1Passed
Mar 18, 2026Redevelopment agreement with Food Love LLC to provide Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF) assistance for…O2026-002334050–0Passed
Feb 18, 2026Amended redevelopment agreement with BR Congress Owner LLC and Congress Theater NFP to provide tax increment…SO2026-002252449–0Passed
Jan 21, 2026Redevelopment agreement with 30 N LaSalle MF Redevelopment LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2025-002169150–0Passed
Jan 21, 2026First amendment to redevelopment agreement with Sinai Health System to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2025-002165650–0Passed
Dec 10, 2025Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2025-002098249–0Passed
Dec 10, 2025Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance…O2025-002099049–0Passed
Dec 10, 2025Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2025-002098149–0Passed
Dec 10, 2025Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance…O2025-002098749–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Renaissance Partners LP to extend tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for…O2025-002048244–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Ellis Park at 3520 S Cottage Grove…O2025-002048844–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Redevelopment agreement with 5050 Prairie LLC to provide Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF) assistance for…O2025-002048544–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Humboldt Park at 1440 N Humboldt BlvdO2025-002048944–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Chase Park at 4701 N Ashland AveO2025-002048744–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Pullman Hotel Group LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for…O2025-002048044–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Madison Community Plaza at 4008 W…O2025-002049144–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Amendment to Section V of tax increment financing (TIF) redevelopment agreement for Division/Homan TIF…O2025-002047944–0Passed
Nov 14, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Ogden Park at 6500 S Racine AveSO2025-002049244–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Homan Square Park at 3517 W…O2025-001992147–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance to National Railroad Passenger Corporation (Amtrak)…O2025-001992547–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of Ronan Park at 3000 W Argyle St and…O2025-001992347–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Redevelopment agreement with JRD LLC for City-owned lands at 4327 S Ellis Ave, 4320 S Greenwood Ave and 4347…O2025-001998347–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for improvement of River Park at 5100 N Francisco AveO2025-001992247–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Redevelopment agreement with JTA Development, Inc. to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance for…O2025-001991747–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Support of Class 7(d) tax incentive redevelopment agreement with Forty Acres Fresh Market LLC for property…O2025-001996647–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Hispanic Housing Development Corporation to provide tax increment financing…O2025-001991347–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Carole Robertson Center for Learning to provide Neighborhood Opportunity Fund…O2025-001999547–0Passed
Oct 16, 2025Support of Class 6(b) tax incentive redevelopment agreement with PICTOR 4435 S Western Boulevard LLC for…O2025-001996747–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Support of Class 6(b) tax incentive for property at 1400 W 46th St and redevelopment agreement with Bubbly…O2025-001879149–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Revised redevelopment agreement with Steep Theatre Corporation to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2025-001874849–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Redevelopment agreement for sale of properties to Citizens Building a Better Community LLC under City Lots…O2025-001822349–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Redevelopment agreement with After School Matters, Inc. to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance…O2025-001875849–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Field Building Revitalization Partners LLC and Downtown Chicago Neighborhood…SO2025-001876249–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Redevelopment agreement with R.A.G.E. Economic Uplifting Project LLC to provide Neighborhood Opportunity…O2025-001876749–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025Redevelopment agreement with 105 Adams Development LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF) assistance…SO2025-001875449–0Passed
Sep 25, 2025First amendment to redevelopment agreement with Center Court Development LLC for phased development of City…O2025-001885149–0Passed
Jul 16, 2025Redevelopment agreement with and sale of City-owned property at 2311, 2313, 2315 S State St (a.k.a. 3-5 E…SO2025-001818850–0Passed
Jul 16, 2025Redevelopment agreement with and provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance to Black Ensemble…O2025-001818050–0Passed
Jun 18, 2025Land sale and redevelopment agreement with Claretian Associates, Inc. for purchase of City lots at 8816,…O2025-001757450–0Passed
Jun 18, 2025Provision of tax increment financing (TIF) assistance to LeClaire Partners A-North JV L.P. for development…SO2025-001750649–0Passed
Jun 18, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Twisted Eggroll LLC for provision of neighborhood funds for renovation of…O2025-001748350–0Passed
Jun 18, 2025Support of Class 6(b) tax incentive and redevelopment agreement with 1300 NN Branch LLC for property at 1300…O2025-001749650–0Passed
Jun 18, 2025Support of Class 6(b) tax incentive for property generally at 4300 W Roosevelt Rd, and accompanying…O2025-001759150–0Passed
Jun 18, 2025Tax increment financing (TIF) redevelopment agreement and renewed lease agreement with Chicago Children's…SO2025-001672550–0Passed
May 21, 2025Neighborhood opportunity fund redevelopment agreement with MAAFA Redemption Project Inc. for conversion of…O2025-001599249–0Passed
Apr 16, 2025Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2025-001597850–0Passed
Apr 16, 2025Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2025-001598050–0Passed
Mar 12, 2025Sale of nine additional city lots to Heritage Pointe II Project amending redevelopment agreementO2025-001497450–0Passed
Mar 12, 2025Amended redevelopment agreement with Cup O' Joe Coffee LLC for provision of neighborhood opportunity funds…O2025-001556250–0Passed
Feb 19, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Oak-Larrabee LLC for construction of mixed-income housing project at 955 N…O2024-001099150–0Passed
Feb 19, 20256411 S. Central Ave sale of vacant firehouse for single-family residenceO2025-001496750–0Passed
Feb 19, 2025Amendment to original ordinance for sale of seven additional lots to Sunshine Gospel Ministries, NFPO2025-001497550–0Passed
Feb 19, 2025Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Franciscan Outreach for…O2025-001482850–0Passed
Jan 15, 2025Redevelopment agreement with Outwest Gallery and Cafe to provide neighborhood opportunity funds for property…O2024-001306050–0Passed
Dec 16, 2024Issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to LeClaire Courts North for residential housing development…O2024-001417450–0Passed
Dec 16, 2024Revised redevelopment agreement with Hudson Michigan Avenue Owner LLC to provide tax increment financing…O2024-001420549–1Passed
Dec 16, 2024Belmont/CentralO2024-001421450–0Passed
Dec 16, 2024Provision of TIF funds for redevelopment of Congress Theater by BR Congress Owner LLC, RevisedO2024-001421549–1Passed
Dec 16, 2024Amendment No. 1 to 63rd/Pulaski TIF Redevelopment and PlanO2024-001443250–0Passed
Dec 2, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of financial assistance to Thrive Exchange LLC for acquisition of…SO2024-001307248–0Passed
Oct 30, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Revolution Workshop for…O2024-001305847–0Passed
Oct 30, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2024-001305547–0Passed
Oct 30, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Heart of Uptown…O2024-001308047–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to German American National…O2024-001244448–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of financial assistance to The Ave SW LLC for acquisition,…SO2024-001244048–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Second amendment to redevelopment agreement and second amendment to authorizing ordinance with Our Revival…SO2024-001244648–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of financial assistance to SACRED Apartments Owner LLC for…SO2024-001243548–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Double Down Development…O2024-001244548–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to TimeLine Theatre Company…O2024-001244748–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2024-001243248–1Passed
Oct 9, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2024-001243148–1Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) grant to Brown Derby LLC for…SO2024-001243748–0Passed
Oct 9, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2024-001243048–1Passed
Oct 9, 2024Redevelopment agreement with BandWith Music Ltd. to provide neighborhood opportunity funds for capital…O2024-001244348–0Passed
Sep 18, 2024Redevelopment agreement with Plant Chicago, NFP to provide neighborhood opportunity funds for renovation of…O2024-001096648–0Passed
Sep 18, 2024Issuance of governmental note, construction loan, tax increment financing (TIF) grant and other financial…O2024-001097848–0Passed
Sep 18, 2024Issuance of affordable housing loan and other financial assistance to and execution of redevelopment…O2024-001098048–0Passed
Sep 18, 2024First amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing…O2024-001096548–0Passed
Jul 17, 2024Reconveyance of four city parcels from Bickerdike Redevelopment Corporation plus one releaseO2024-001011750–0Passed
Jul 17, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2024-001010050–0Passed
Jun 12, 2024Second amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment…O2024-000957947–0Passed
Jun 12, 2024Modification of City Lots for Working Families Program for fee reductions and waivers regarding…O2024-000963847–0Passed
Jun 12, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2024-000958347–0Passed
Jun 12, 2024Second amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment…O2024-000958047–0Passed
Jun 12, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2024-000958147–0Passed
Jun 12, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2024-000957847–0Passed
May 22, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to North Lawndale…O2024-000888648–0Passed
May 22, 2024First amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing…O2024-000834248–0Passed
May 22, 2024First amendment to redevelopment agreement with NP Avenue O LLC to provide tax increment financing (TIF)…O2024-000834047–1Passed
Apr 17, 2024Redevelopment agreement with and issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Ogden Washtenaw A2…SO2024-000837049–0Passed
Apr 17, 2024Acquisition of vacant city property and residential development of combined owner's propertyO2024-000841449–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024First amendment to redevelopment agreement with Portage Park Capital, LLC to provide tax increment financing…O2024-000787648–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024Negotiated sale of City-owned property at 4704-4738 West Fifth Ave to and execution of redevelopment…O2024-000791248–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2024-000787348–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024E.G. Woode LLC 1022 W 63rd StO2023-000440648–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024First amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing…O2024-000787548–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to provide tax increment financing (TIF) funds for…O2024-000787248–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024Revised Redevelopment Agreement adjusting payout terms of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Chicago…SO2024-000786448–0Passed
Mar 20, 2024Issuance of tax increment financing (TIF) grant, multi-family housing bonds and other financial assistance…SO2024-000732948–0Passed
Feb 21, 2024City financial assistance with Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds, multi-family housing loans and revenue…SO2024-000732650–0Passed
Feb 21, 2024Redevelopment Agreement with, sale of five city lots to Homan Housing LLC for East Garfield ParkO2024-000743050–0Passed
Feb 21, 2024Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…SO2024-000732350–0Passed
Feb 21, 2024Amendment of redevelopment agreement with Pioneros LLC for rehabilitation of former Pioneer Bank building at…O2024-000732550–0Passed
Jan 24, 2024Negotiated sale of 4727, 4735, 4739, 4743, 4755, 4757 and 4759 S Cottage Grove Ave to 4735 South Cottage…SO2023-000638950–0Passed
Dec 13, 2023Lincoln Ave 35-2015O2023-000600749–0Passed
Dec 13, 2023St. Laurence NOF RedevelopmentO2023-000570049–0Passed
Dec 13, 2023Second Amendment to Greater Southwest Industrial East TIF project and plan regarding repaymentO2023-000600549–0Passed
Dec 13, 2023Amendment to certain provisions of timing and substantive nature of TIF RDAO2023-000603349–0Passed
Nov 15, 2023First Amendment to Kenwood Academy IGAO2023-000570149–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Second amendment to Galewood/Armitage Industrial Redevelopment Project Area Tax Increment Finance…O2023-000509950–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Red Line land disposition with Chicago Transit AuthorityO2023-000510350–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2023-000506250–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Restructuring and redevelopment agreement with tax increment financing (TIF) assistance and additional City…O2023-000504750–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2023-000506650–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Black Fire BrigadeO2023-000510150–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Amended tax increment financing (TIF) redevelopment agreement with Celadon Construction Corporation NFP and…O2023-000494450–0Passed
Nov 1, 2023Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education for allocation of tax increment financing (TIF)…O2023-000505750–0Passed
Oct 16, 2023Sale 2358 S Whipple StO2023-000423449–0Passed
Oct 16, 2023Sale of seven parcels to Chicago Park District for expansion of Ronan ParkO2023-000445349–0Passed
Oct 4, 2023Amendment to Redevelopment Agreement for Englewood Connect LLC replacing with new Agreement & scopeO2023-000444449–0Passed
Oct 4, 2023IGA with CPS for improvements and repairs McCutcheon Elementary School with TIF fundsO2023-000444949–0Passed
Oct 4, 2023Imani Village Senior Resident Second Amendment to AgreementO2023-000445049–0Passed
Oct 4, 2023Amendment of Neighborhood Opportunity Fund Grant (NOF) with Ogden Washtenaw JV LLCO2023-000445449–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023TIF-funded improvements at Mark Skinner Elementary BranchO2023-000300648–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023Approval of Amendment No. 4 to Northwest Industrial Corridor Redevelopment TIF AreaO2023-000301748–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023TIF-improvements Roald Amundsen High SchoolO2023-000300348–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023Designation of Amendment No. 4 regarding Tax Increment Allocation Financing for Northwest IndustriaO2023-000302248–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023Intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Board of Education regarding tax increment financing (TIF) funds…O2023-000300548–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023TIF improvements at Uplift Community High School, 900 W Wilson AveO2023-000300448–0Passed
Sep 14, 2023Adoption of Amendment No. 4 to expanded Northwest Industrial Corridor Redevelopment Project AreaO2023-000302548–0Passed
Jul 19, 2023Amendment of ordinance appropriating tax increment financing (TIF) funds for infrastructure projects for…O2023-000136749–0Passed
Jul 19, 2023Substituted in CommitteeSO2023-000286749–0Passed
Jul 19, 2023TIF District Plan Amendment No. 3O2023-000136149–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023First amendment to intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Park District to increase provision of tax…O2023-000130950–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023Amendment of ordinance which authorized redevelopment agreement with Imani Senior Village Phase I LLC for…O2023-000129850–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023Amendment of redevelopment agreement with Little Village Business Incubator LLC for provision of…O2023-000194350–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023Redevelopment agreement with DL3 Thrive Exchange LIHTC South LLC to acquire property generally located at…O2023-000129650–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023Redevelopment agreement with and provision of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to Steep Theatre Company…O2023-000131450–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023Redevelopment agreement with and provision of tax increment financing (TIF) funds to 221 E. 49th Street LLC…O2023-000131850–0Passed
Jun 21, 2023Restructuring agreement with Renaissance Partners Limited Partnership, Renaissance Partners Corporation for…O2023-000129450–0Passed

Legislation

Documents

Passages from ordinances, agreements, agendas, transcripts and campaign money briefs that best match "tax increment financing TIF redevelopment agreement developer assistance", by meaning rather than exact words.

More example searches

Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error