On My Block · Chicago Politics

Some Chicago renters get gas and water bills split by formula from a third-party biller. Here's what the Council's two stalled renter ordinances would do about it

Neither would ban ratio utility billing. The Mayor's would bar markups, administrative charges and third-party vendor costs and require 90 days' notice of a switch; the FAIR ordinance would bar markups. Both have sat since Sept. 23.

Renters in buildings with one master gas or water meter are increasingly billed for utilities through a "ratio utility billing system," or RUBS, in which a third-party company divides the building's bill among units by a formula and adds a service fee, the Chicago Sun-Times reported Tuesday. Tenants it spoke with said bills that used to be a flat fee near $100 now swing month to month, from under $90 to more than $220.

Why it matters: the Sun-Times found no Chicago ordinance on RUBS, and no City department tracks how many buildings use it. The Illinois Commerce Commission told the paper it has no authority over ratio billing: "This would be a tenant-landlord matter." Chicago's Residential Landlord and Tenant Ordinance dates to 1986, and two competing rewrites are stuck on the Council floor (our story).

How it works now

  • State law lets landlords split master-metered utility costs by formula, but they must disclose the formula and let tenants see the master bill, the Sun-Times reported. No state law bans RUBS, and no agency regulates the billing companies.
  • Connecticut has banned the practice; Seattle and Los Angeles are considering bans, the paper reported. A National Consumer Law Center attorney told it, "The tenant's bill is not tied to actual tenant usage." The Illinois Apartment Association said RUBS gives usage-based estimates and encourages conservation.

What the two ordinances say

We searched the text of both for utility rules.

The Mayor's Protecting Renters Ordinance (SO2026-0026554, the version the Housing Committee passed 12 to 9 on Sept. 16):

  • A utility fee may not exceed the actual cost billed by the utility or, in a master-metered building, the tenant's share under a formula that follows the state's Tenant Utility Payment Disclosure Act.
  • The fee, or the total charged to all tenants for a billing period, "may not include any markup, administrative charge, or surcharge above the billed amount."
  • "A tenant may not be charged costs from third-party vendors, aggregators, or resellers under this provision."
  • During a lease, a landlord may not switch tenants from landlord-paid to tenant-paid utilities, or from fixed to variable charges, and must give 90 days' notice before the lease ends.
  • The landlord must give the formula in enough detail for a tenant to "reasonably calculate their share," provide the utility bill on request, and itemize any fee in writing with documentation before collecting it.

Ald. Gilbert Villegas's FAIR ordinance (SO2026-0027202, which the Zoning Committee passed 12 to 6 on Sept. 17):

  • A landlord may not "impose any markup above the amount actually billed by a utility provider" or convert an unpaid utility charge into rent.
  • Leases and listings must say whether utilities are included in rent, on the first page with other mandatory fees.

Neither ordinance prohibits ratio billing itself. How the Mayor's version would apply to a billing company's own service fee would depend on how the City enforces "markup" and "third-party vendors"; we're asking the Department of Housing.

What our records add

Both are stuck in the same place. On Sept. 23, each was "deferred and published" on the Council floor at the request of two members, Ervin (28th) and Sigcho-López (25th) for the Mayor's version and Villegas (36th) and Cardona (31st) for FAIR. The Clerk's record shows no action on either since. FAIR has 21 co-sponsors; the Mayor's version has none in the Clerk's record.

The rest of each. The Mayor's version would create a yearly rental registry and a Bureau of Rental Housing Services; FAIR would put an Office of Rental Housing in the Department of Buildings with registration every two years and higher fines for cutting off services.

What's next

Either can be called for a vote at any regular Council meeting; the next are Dec. 8 and 9, alongside the budget. Each needs 26 votes. The Sun-Times reported that few lawyers take RUBS cases and that some tenants have moved out over the bills.

Sources: Protecting Renters Ordinance (substitute text); FAIR ordinance (substitute text).

Support Chicago Politics

Keep Chicago Politics free for everyone

Chicago Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime