On My Block · Chicago Politics

Regulators give Peoples Gas $40 million of the $144 million it asked for. What the Council has asked for on gas bills

The Illinois Commerce Commission cut the request by more than $103 million and kept the 2035 deadline to retire old iron gas pipes. The Council has no vote on rates; its resolutions on rate hearings and shutoffs passed unanimously, and an ordinance on winter shutoff notices has sat in committee since 2023.

The Illinois Commerce Commission on Thursday approved a $40.3 million rate increase for Peoples Gas, less than a third of the $144 million the utility asked for, Capitol News Illinois reported in a story republished by Block Club Chicago. Peoples Gas serves nearly 900,000 customers in Chicago.

Why it matters: the full request would have added an average of $7 to $8 a month to household bills, Capitol News Illinois reported. Most of the dispute was over the cost of replacing Chicago's aging underground gas pipes, a program consumer groups wanted the state to end. The ICC kept it.

How the number came down

  • January 2026: Peoples Gas asked for $202 million, the Chicago Sun-Times reported.
  • Summer: it cut the request to $144 million, reflecting slower-than-expected progress retiring pipe.
  • October: the ICC's administrative law judges proposed $66.2 million.
  • Thursday: the commission approved $40.3 million, with a 9.48% return on equity. Peoples Gas had asked for 10.1%; its current rate is 9.38%.

The commission also cut North Shore Gas' $8.7 million request to about $1.9 million. In 2023, Peoples Gas won a record $306 million increase, the Sun-Times reported.

Reports differ on when the change reaches bills. Capitol News Illinois said new bills begin in December; the Sun-Times and the Chicago Tribune (as summarized by Capitol Fax) said January. Peoples Gas said it was still calculating the effect on bills.

The pipes

Most of the disputed spending is tied to the ICC's mandate that Peoples Gas retire more than 1,000 miles of aging iron gas pipe under Chicago streets by 2035. Advocates asked the commission to lift it, arguing the utility relies too much on replacement rather than repairing or relining pipe, or on home electrification. The ICC kept the deadline.

ICC Chair Doug Scott said Peoples Gas uses an "unnecessarily narrow" definition of pipeline replacement that makes the work more expensive, and that the commission would clarify it if the company asks. A Safety Monitor report on the program's progress is due in March 2027.

What people said

  • Scott called the order "a fair and reasonable determination reached over the course of an 11-month legal proceeding," the Sun-Times reported.
  • Peoples Gas called the decision "surprising and extremely disappointing" and said it cuts $25 million for "critical day-to-day safety work."
  • Sarah Moskowitz, executive director of the Citizens Utility Board, said the utility's "profit quest on the backs of struggling Chicagoans was especially brazen," noting record earnings in seven of the last nine years.
  • Abe Scarr of Illinois PIRG: "we're disappointed they did not end the failing Peoples Gas pipe replacement program."

What our records add

The City Council doesn't set gas rates; the ICC, a state agency, does. What the Council has done this term:

  • Rate hearings. In November 2023, as Peoples Gas sought its record increase, the Council voted 50 to 0 to call for hearings on the proposed hikes. The resolution was sponsored by Alds. William Conway (34th) and Maria Hadden (49th) with 21 co-sponsors (R2023-0004577).
  • Shutoffs. In February the Council voted 49 to 0 to call on Gov. JB Pritzker to direct the ICC to stop utility disconnections for nonpayment and adopt flexible collection procedures, a resolution from Ald. Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez (33rd) and Ald. Anthony Quezada (35th) (R2025-0021047).
  • Winter notices. Ald. Jason Ervin's (28th) ordinance requiring that people living in a building be notified before gas service is cut off from November to March has been in committee since June 2023 (O2023-0002229).
  • Electrification costs. A call for hearings on the cost of converting buildings from gas to electric heat and cooking, from Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36th) with 27 co-sponsors, has been in committee since January 2024 (R2024-0007274).

What's next

Peoples Gas said it is reviewing the final order before deciding its next steps. The March 2027 Safety Monitor report is the next public check on the pipe program. Customers struggling with bills can call the ICC's assistance line at 1-833-711-0374, the Sun-Times reported.

Support Chicago Politics

Keep Chicago Politics free for everyone

Chicago Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime