Judge rejects Justice Department bid to sidestep her in 'Broadview Six' inquiry; Chicago's U.S. attorney is due to testify Dec. 2
Judge April Perry will decide privilege claims herself before U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three prosecutors take the stand. The City Council called on Boutros to resign in July, 46 to 3. Who voted no, and what comes next.
U.S. District Judge April Perry on Friday denied a Justice Department request to hand privilege questions to a special master or another "disinterested judicial officer" before she hears testimony from U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros and three of his prosecutors on Dec. 2, the Chicago Tribune and Chicago Sun-Times reported.
Why it matters: Perry is examining whether federal prosecutors in Chicago misled her in the failed "Broadview Six" case, a conspiracy prosecution of six people who protested outside the Broadview immigration facility during Operation Midway Blitz in September 2025. The hearing has little precedent and could lead to sanctions or a criminal contempt finding, the Sun-Times reported. The City Council has already weighed in: in July it called on Boutros to resign.
Friday's ruling
As reported by the Tribune and Sun-Times:
- The request: Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the Justice Department's third-ranking official, argued in a Thursday filing that Perry had taken on the roles of investigator and prosecutor and so "cannot be the one to rule on the government's privilege assertions."
- The answer: about 14 hours later, Perry called the motion untimely, filed at 6:50 p.m. the night before potentially privileged material was due, and said it "reflects a basic misapprehension about what a special master does," since a special master is an arm of the court. Citing the Supreme Court's recognition of a judge's power to investigate frauds on the court, she wrote: "That is precisely what the Court intends to do here."
- Possible appeal: Woodward has floated asking the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for relief.
The case so far
- The charges: the six were charged with conspiring to impede a federal agent, accused of crowding around and pushing an agent's SUV, WBEZ reported. Most had ties to local politics, which raised questions about selective prosecution.
- The collapse: the case fell apart May 21 after Perry found alleged misconduct by the lead prosecutor in grand jury transcripts, and the charges were dropped.
- Boutros: he has said he learned of the misconduct in late April; he later acknowledged receiving a transcript documenting it by email on Oct. 14, 2025, and said he didn't remember reading it, the Sun-Times reported. Perry has called his denial "nearly unfathomable."
- Outside contacts: in March his office told Perry there were no communications about charging decisions with anyone outside the office, including the White House or Justice Department headquarters; it has since suggested some exist, the Sun-Times reported.
- The prosecutors: lawyers for Assistant U.S. Attorneys William Hogan, Matthew Skiba and Andres Almendarez said Nov. 16 their clients won't invoke the Fifth Amendment (Sun-Times). No private lawyer has signed on for Boutros, the Tribune reported.
What our records add
The Council's resignation call. On July 15 the Council adopted a resolution from Ald. Michael Rodriguez (22nd) calling on Boutros to resign and on the Justice Department to review matters connected to Operation Midway Blitz and the Broadview prosecutions (R2026-0026273). The vote was 46 to 3. Voting no: Alds. Nicholas Sposato (38th), Anthony Napolitano (41st) and James Gardiner (45th). Ald. Emma Mitts (37th) is recorded as not voting. A council resolution has no legal effect on a federal appointee.
Advertisement
How each ward voted
46 yea, 3 nay, 1 not voting · Jul 15, 2026 · Adopted
1Daniel La Spata: Yea
2Brian Hopkins: Yea
3Pat Dowell: Yea
4Lamont J. Robinson: Yea
5Desmon C. Yancy: Yea
6William E. Hall: Yea
7Gregory I. Mitchell: Yea
8Michelle A. Harris: Yea
9Anthony Beale: Yea
10Peter Chico: Yea
11Nicole T. Lee: Yea
12Julia M. Ramirez: Yea
13Marty Quinn: Yea
14Jeylú B. Gutiérrez: Yea
15Raymond A. Lopez: Yea
16Stephanie D. Coleman: Yea
17David H. Moore: Yea
18Derrick G. Curtis: Yea
19Matthew J. O'Shea: Yea
20Jeanette B. Taylor: Yea
21Ronnie L. Mosley: Yea
22Michael D. Rodriguez: Yea
23Silvana Tabares: Yea
24Monique L. Scott: Yea
25Byron Sigcho-López: Yea
26Jessica L. Fuentes: Yea
27Walter R. Burnett: Yea
28Jason C. Ervin: Yea
29Chris Taliaferro: Yea
30Ruth Cruz: Yea
31Felix Cardona Jr.: Yea
32Scott Waguespack: Yea
33Rossana Rodríguez Sánchez: Yea
34William Conway: Yea
35Anthony J. Quezada: Yea
36Gilbert Villegas: Yea
37Emma Mitts: Not voting
38Nicholas Sposato: Nay
39Samantha Nugent: Yea
40Andre Vasquez Jr.: Yea
41Anthony V. Napolitano: Nay
42Brendan Reilly: Yea
43Timothy R. Knudsen: Yea
44Bennett R. Lawson: Yea
45James M. Gardiner: Nay
46Angela Clay: Yea
47Matthew J. Martin: Yea
48Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Yea
49Maria E. Hadden: Yea
50Debra L. Silverstein: YeaR2026-0026273: the roll call, the timeline and the documents
Earlier votes. In October 2025 the Council condemned immigration agents' practices that endanger children, 47 to 0 (SR2025-0019952). In September 2026 it passed, 50 to 0, Ald. Daniel La Spata's (1st) ordinance requiring disclosure from City contractors that work with or profit from immigration enforcement (SO2025-0021035).
What's next
- Wed., Nov. 25: the government's deadline to explain why privilege should block parts of the testimony, the Tribune reported.
- Wed., Dec. 2: the evidentiary hearing, with testimony from Boutros and the three prosecutors.
We don't name the six former defendants here; the case against them was dismissed.