Committee on Finance meeting, September 14, 2026
- When: Mon, Sep 14, 2026, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Finance
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928482?video=1226632992
- Transcript: full text (24,828 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 11:06 Public comment period
- 25:46 Item 1: Order authorizing payment of various small claims
- 26:05 Item 2: Order denying payment of various small claims
- 26:25 Item 3: Charitable solicitation permits (Oxfam America, Plan International USA, Salvation Army)
- 27:16 Item 4: Law Department reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements for July and August 2026
- 28:00 Item 5A: Settlement, Lorenzo Williams v. City of Chicago, $225,000
- 32:24 Brendan Reilly: Asked whether the plaintiff would have been injured had he not resisted arrest while armed,…
- 34:35 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked whether the Williams plaintiff had drugs or alcohol in his system.
- 35:24 Jason C. Ervin: Asked how the $225,000 settlement compares to jury verdicts in similar use-of-force cases.
- 41:08 Item 5B: Settlement, Estate of Michael A. Jordan v. City of Chicago, $6 million
- 47:33 Brendan Reilly: Asked whether the plaintiff sought damages from the fleeing offender who caused the crash.
- 48:16 Scott Waguespack: Asked the city to explain how it determined the fleeing offender was judgment-proof.
- 50:15 Item 5C: Settlement, Gabriel Solache v. Reynaldo Guevara et al., $6 million
- 50:41 Item 5D: Settlement, Arturo DeLeon Reyes, $7.75 million
- 59:04 Samantha Nugent: Asked about the city's denied request for discovery into why the state's attorney stopped…
- 1:00:50 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked about an unreleased report on Guevara cases and how many more are pending, and…
- 1:03:08 Brian Hopkins: Asked what evidence of abuse during interrogation existed before the certificates of…
- 1:05:03 Emma Mitts: Asked about Guevara's current status and whether remaining cases could be resolved in a mass…
- 1:06:46 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked about his proposed ordinance to pause settlements based on certificates of innocence…
- 1:08:18 Raymond A. Lopez: Cited statements from the state's attorney's office doubting the plaintiffs' innocence and…
- 1:11:44 Pat Dowell: Said she did not believe the committee was rushing the Guevara settlements and noted Lopez's…
- 1:15:20 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether the Guevara case reports could be shared or briefed and which funds pay the…
- 1:17:09 Gilbert Villegas: Confirmed that the city's insurance applies at $20 million per claimant.
- 1:18:11 Scott Waguespack: Asked what happened to the Soto children and whether they received any justice.
- 1:19:22 Chris Taliaferro: Asked about a reported unreleased Guevara investigation report and argued the council, as…
- 1:23:12 Item 6: Appointment of Marshall Hatch Jr. to Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board
- 1:23:52 Item 8: Appointment of Janae DeFell to Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board
- 1:29:24 Item 7: Appointment of Ryan Gadia to Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board
- 1:37:31 Gregory I. Mitchell: Asked whether the advisory board seats are vacant and who is leaving.
- 1:38:33 Emma Mitts: Thanked the appointees for reaching out and praised Marshall Hatch Jr.'s work.
- 1:42:07 Pat Dowell: Called Lopez's concern about advisory board conflicts a fair point and asked DPD to respond.
- 1:45:30 Chris Taliaferro: Thanked the appointees and praised Marshall Hatch Jr.'s work with young men on the West…
- 1:46:42 Nicole T. Lee: Supported the appointments, welcomed an Asian American appointee, and asked the board to…
- 1:49:27 Derrick G. Curtis: Said city incentive programs often go to the same areas and asked that all parts of the…
- 1:51:02 William E. Hall: Asked whether advisory board members recuse themselves from conflicts and urged appointees…
- 1:52:11 Brendan Reilly: Asked appointee Ryan Gadia to confirm he does not live in Chicago.
- 1:53:12 William Conway: Raised a point of order on whether a Downers Grove resident is eligible for the advisory…
- 1:53:55 Michelle A. Harris: Questioned why qualified Chicago residents could not be found for the appointment.
- 1:54:15 Scott Waguespack: Asked where the rule allowing non-resident appointees is written and whether current board…
- 1:55:35 Matthew J. O'Shea: Requested a recess to get clarity on whether a non-resident can serve on the advisory…
- 1:58:17 Jason C. Ervin: Spoke in support of Marshall Hatch Jr.'s appointment, citing his work in West Garfield Park.
- 2:00:15 Item 9: Second amendment to master intergovernmental agreement with Public Building Commission for…
- 2:07:42 William Conway: Asked how Public Building Commission dollar amounts were set for the 78 development and the…
- 2:15:13 Pat Dowell: Agreed the city needs to do more to collect what is owed through administrative hearings.
- 2:15:40 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said prior administrations planned to sell the Central Hearing Facility and questioned…
- 2:18:36 Anthony Beale: Asked whether local alderpersons supported taking $10 million from the Lake Calumet TIF for a…
- 2:21:06 Ronnie L. Mosley: Thanked the acting fleet commissioner and asked the PBC for an update on its work related…
- 2:22:19 William Conway: Asked whether the PBC allocations come from TIF amounts the committee already approved.
- 2:24:54 Item 10: Ordinance adding Section 2-8-036 requiring three-fifths vote for bonds and indebtedness
- 2:29:29 Timothy R. Knudsen: Supported the ordinance, saying the prior $830 million bond's backloaded structure…
- 2:39:25 Felix Cardona Jr.: Supported the ordinance as good government, citing CFO turnover and a credit rating…
- 2:40:42 Jason C. Ervin: Opposed the three-fifths threshold, saying it would let a minority of members block…
- 2:44:50 Walter R. Burnett: Said a higher threshold requires members to be diligent and educated on debt, and warned…
- 2:46:52 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Supported the ordinance to require broader deliberation on borrowing, while voicing…
- 2:55:04 Marty Quinn: Closed on his ordinance requiring 30 votes for debt ordinances to strengthen council…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Finance, chaired by Alderman Pat Dowell, heard four public commenters, then approved its Rule 45 reports and routine small claims and charitable solicitation items. It recommended four lawsuit settlements: $225,000 to Lorenzo Williams over police use of force, which passed 18 to 13 on a roll call; $6 million to the estate of Michael A. Jordan, killed by a driver fleeing police; and $6 million and $7.75 million to Gabriel Solache and Arturo De Leon Reyes in wrongful conviction cases tied to former detective Reynaldo Guevara. The Guevara settlements drew questions about an unreleased city report, pending cases and certificates of innocence. On three Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board appointments, the committee approved Marshall Hatch Jr. and Janae DeFell but held the appointment of Ryan Gadia after members raised his residence outside Chicago. It also approved an amended intergovernmental agreement with the Public Building Commission after questions about spending on the Central Hearing Facility and a salt dome. Finally, by a 21 to 9 roll call, it approved Alderman Marty Quinn ordinance requiring a three-fifths council vote for bond and debt ordinances.
Topics: police misconduct settlements, Reynaldo Guevara cases, certificates of innocence, Chicago Development Fund appointments, board member residency, Public Building Commission, city debt and bonds, supermajority vote requirement
Agenda items discussed
- 11:06 Public comment: discussed
- 24:53 July and August 2026 Rule 45 reports: passed
- 25:46 Item 1: Order authorizing payment of various small claims: passed
- 26:05 Item 2: Order denying payment of various small claims: passed
- 26:25 Item 3: Charitable solicitation permits for Oxfam America, Plan International USA and the Salvation Army: passed
- 27:16 Item 4: Department of Law reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements for July and August 2026
- 28:00 Item 5A: Settlement in Lorenzo Williams v. City of Chicago ($225,000): passed
- 41:08 Item 5B: Settlement in Michael Jordan, administrator of the estate of Michael A. Jordan, v. City of Chicago ($6 million): passed
- 50:15 Item 5C: Settlement in Gabriel Solache v. Reynaldo Guevara et al. ($6 million): passed
- 50:41 Item 5D: Settlement with Arturo De Leon Reyes in Guevara-related wrongful conviction case ($7.75 million): passed
- 1:23:12 Item 6: Appointment of Marshall Hatch Jr. to the Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board: passed
- 1:29:14 Item 7: Appointment of Ryan Gadia to the Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board: held
- 1:23:52 Item 8: Appointment of Janae DeFell to the Chicago Development Fund Advisory Board: passed
- 2:00:15 Item 9: Second amendment to master intergovernmental agreement with the Public Building Commission for TIF-funded projects: passed
- 2:24:54 Item 10: Ordinance adding Section 2-8-036 requiring a three-fifths vote for bonds and other indebtedness: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Pat Dowell (chair): Said she did not believe the committee was rushing the Guevara settlements and noted Lopez's proposed ordinance was referred to the Rules Committee. (1:11:44); Called Lopez's concern about advisory board conflicts a fair point and asked DPD to respond. (1:42:07); Agreed the city needs to do more to collect what is owed through administrative hearings. (2:15:13)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked whether the plaintiff would have been injured had he not resisted arrest while armed, what message a settlement sends, and said he would vote no. (32:24); Asked whether the plaintiff sought damages from the fleeing offender who caused the crash. (47:33); Asked appointee Ryan Gadia to confirm he does not live in Chicago. (1:52:11)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Asked whether the Williams plaintiff had drugs or alcohol in his system. (34:35); Asked about his proposed ordinance to pause settlements based on certificates of innocence issued under the prior state's attorney. (1:06:46); Cited statements from the state's attorney's office doubting the plaintiffs' innocence and said he does not believe the account presented to justify the settlements. (1:08:18)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Asked how the $225,000 settlement compares to jury verdicts in similar use-of-force cases. (35:24); Spoke in support of Marshall Hatch Jr.'s appointment, citing his work in West Garfield Park. (1:58:17); Opposed the three-fifths threshold, saying it would let a minority of members block borrowing and would be unusual for a major city. (2:40:42)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked the city to explain how it determined the fleeing offender was judgment-proof. (48:16); Asked what happened to the Soto children and whether they received any justice. (1:18:11); Asked where the rule allowing non-resident appointees is written and whether current board members live outside Chicago. (1:54:15)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Asked about the city's denied request for discovery into why the state's attorney stopped opposing the certificates of innocence. (59:04)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Asked about an unreleased report on Guevara cases and how many more are pending, and called for public accounting of police misconduct costs. (1:00:50)
- Brian Hopkins (alderperson): Asked what evidence of abuse during interrogation existed before the certificates of innocence were issued. (1:03:08)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Asked about Guevara's current status and whether remaining cases could be resolved in a mass settlement to save money. (1:05:03); Thanked the appointees for reaching out and praised Marshall Hatch Jr.'s work. (1:38:33)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (alderperson): Asked whether the advisory board seats are vacant and who is leaving. (1:37:31)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked whether the Guevara case reports could be shared or briefed and which funds pay the settlements, including whether they are borrowed. (1:15:20); Supported the ordinance to require broader deliberation on borrowing, while voicing concern that borrowing votes get tied to the budget process. (2:46:52)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Confirmed that the city's insurance applies at $20 million per claimant. (1:17:09)
- Chris Taliaferro (alderperson): Asked about a reported unreleased Guevara investigation report and argued the council, as the client, should have access to it. (1:19:22); Thanked the appointees and praised Marshall Hatch Jr.'s work with young men on the West Side. (1:45:30)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Supported the appointments, welcomed an Asian American appointee, and asked the board to expand outreach on new markets tax credits. (1:46:42)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Said city incentive programs often go to the same areas and asked that all parts of the city share in investment. (1:49:27)
- William E. Hall (alderperson): Asked whether advisory board members recuse themselves from conflicts and urged appointees to do so when needed. (1:51:02)
- William Conway (alderperson): Raised a point of order on whether a Downers Grove resident is eligible for the advisory board. (1:53:12); Asked how Public Building Commission dollar amounts were set for the 78 development and the bus station. (2:07:42); Asked whether the PBC allocations come from TIF amounts the committee already approved. (2:22:19)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Questioned why qualified Chicago residents could not be found for the appointment. (1:53:55)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Requested a recess to get clarity on whether a non-resident can serve on the advisory board. (1:55:35); Said prior administrations planned to sell the Central Hearing Facility and questioned spending $11 million on it. (2:15:40)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked whether local alderpersons supported taking $10 million from the Lake Calumet TIF for a salt dome and who decided it. (2:18:36)
- Ronnie L. Mosley (alderperson): Thanked the acting fleet commissioner and asked the PBC for an update on its work related to WPAs, to be handled offline. (2:21:06)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Supported the ordinance, saying the prior $830 million bond's backloaded structure increased interest costs and a higher threshold would improve deal terms. (2:29:29)
- Felix Cardona Jr. (alderperson): Supported the ordinance as good government, citing CFO turnover and a credit rating downgrade. (2:39:25)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Said a higher threshold requires members to be diligent and educated on debt, and warned that smaller staff budgets make this harder. (2:44:50)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Closed on his ordinance requiring 30 votes for debt ordinances to strengthen council independence and fiscal oversight, and requested a roll call. (2:55:04)
Exchanges between members
- 1:11:44 Dowell said she did not believe the committee was rushing the settlements, responding to Lopez.
- 1:14:57 Vasquez thanked the chair for clarifying the status of Lopez's ordinance in the Rules Committee.
- 1:15:20 Vasquez followed up on the report his colleague Sigcho-López had mentioned.
- 1:39:54 Lopez joined his colleague from the West Side in thanking appointees for reaching out.
- 1:42:07 Dowell called Lopez's concern about conflicts a fair point of view.
- 1:47:43 Lee called Lopez's concern a fair point but said appointees' experience with the process is important.
- 1:49:21 Curtis said he wanted to build on a point Mitts had made.
- 1:53:12 Conway raised a point of order based on Reilly's question about Gadia's residence.
- 1:54:15 Waguespack followed up on Reilly's original question about residency.
- 1:55:51 Dowell asked O'Shea what clarity he was seeking with his recess request.
- 2:10:00 Reilly said he and O'Shea shared the same recollection about plans to sell the Central Hearing Facility.
- 2:15:13 Dowell agreed with Reilly that the city must do more to collect what is owed through administrative hearings.
- 2:15:40 O'Shea built on Reilly's concerns about the Central Hearing Facility.
- 2:22:19 Conway followed up on Beale's questions about TIF allocations.
- 2:26:39 Conway thanked Quinn for the ordinance and for his years of service.
- 2:31:25 Knudsen thanked Quinn for bringing the ordinance forward.
- 2:31:47 Lopez thanked Knudsen.
- 2:39:25 Cardona thanked Quinn for introducing the ordinance.
- 2:45:00 Burnett agreed with Lopez's point that debt terms and wording matter.
- 2:45:18 Burnett addressed part of Ervin's point about delay being used as a political tactic.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error