Committee on Workforce Development meeting, June 12, 2025
- When: Thu, Jun 12, 2025, 10:30 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Recessed
- Committee: Committee on Workforce Development
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928568/video/1092947412
- Transcript: full text (33,564 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 0:37 Michael D. Rodriguez: Said no vote would be taken on the rideshare ordinance and the committee would not…
- 30:15 Direct introduction: collective bargaining agreement between the City of Chicago and International…
- 36:57 Chicago Rideshare Living Wage and Safety Ordinance (subject matter hearing)
- 1:05:31 Chris Taliaferro: Asked for additional statistics on what happened in New York after its ordinance was…
- 1:11:11 Chris Taliaferro: Asked what profit Uber and Lyft make in the Chicago market.
- 1:12:24 Anthony J. Quezada: Asked the driver guild representative to respond to Uber's statements about insurance…
- 1:14:17 Anthony J. Quezada: Asked a driver how many hours he works weekly, what he earns per hour after expenses,…
- 1:17:03 Anthony J. Quezada: Cited the Uber CEO's compensation increase and said workers deserve a fair wage given…
- 1:20:18 Angela Clay: Asked how many drivers are on each platform and how long an average ride takes.
- 1:21:15 Angela Clay: Asked how the companies calculate the price of trips, citing a ride where the driver's pay was…
- 1:25:14 Angela Clay: Said the subject matter hearing deserves a public answer on how pay and dynamic pricing are…
- 1:33:10 Derrick G. Curtis: Asked Uber why it would need to cut drivers if paying minimum wage and why drivers work…
- 1:37:55 Derrick G. Curtis: Asked BACP whether rideshare drivers were exempt from the city minimum wage and about how…
- 1:40:47 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked for the racial and gender makeup of drivers on each platform.
- 1:41:48 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether either company had years of losses and requested ten years of financial…
- 1:42:52 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked how each company defines utilization compared with the ordinance, noting drivers…
- 1:56:15 Marty Quinn: Asked how much the city collects annually from the rideshare tax and whether any analysis of…
- 1:59:38 Marty Quinn: Suggested the city conduct its own analysis before budget season and before deciding on the…
- 2:00:16 William E. Hall: Said workers must be fairly compensated and asked whether a fair hourly wage figure has…
- 2:01:11 Michael D. Rodriguez: Said there have been ample negotiations but both sides have non-negotiables, centered…
- 2:06:03 William E. Hall: Pressed both sides for a concrete proposed hourly wage for drivers.
- 2:09:11 William E. Hall: Asked what an individual driver would make per hour under Lyft's proposal and confirmed the…
- 2:09:49 Michael D. Rodriguez: Summarized that the companies proposed pay as a percentage above minimum wage while…
- 2:10:49 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked what initial agreement drivers sign when joining Uber or Lyft and whether pay…
- 2:13:06 Stephanie D. Coleman: Read a 16th Ward driver's trip statement showing passenger payment, fees and driver…
- 2:14:46 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked what safety measures the companies have taken and whether costs like dash…
- 2:22:57 Byron Sigcho-López: Cited rising company profitability and asked how much it would cost the companies to pay…
- 2:27:48 Byron Sigcho-López: Said he finds it hard to believe a company with $9.8 billion in net income cannot pay…
- 2:55:58 Byron Sigcho-López: Said elected officials must decide whether they or corporations dictate laws and asked…
- 3:00:37 Nicole T. Lee: Said there appears to be agreement on deactivation transparency and asked both sides to…
- 3:11:29 Nicole T. Lee: Asked BACP what implementing and enforcing the ordinance would cost and require.
- 3:13:47 Nicole T. Lee: Raised concern that higher fares could reduce visits to Chinatown and tourism in her ward and…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Workforce Development heard ten public commenters, most of them rideshare drivers and faith leaders supporting the Chicago Rideshare Living Wage and Safety Ordinance, along with an operating engineers union representative who opposed it as written. The committee approved its May 2025 Rule 45 report and recommended a collective bargaining agreement with Teamsters Local 700 covering about 17 Department of Aviation employees. It then held a subject matter hearing on an updated draft of the rideshare ordinance, with the chair's policy director presenting its safety, deactivation, transparency and per-minute and per-mile pay provisions, followed by testimony and extended questioning of Uber, Lyft, driver advocates and the Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection. No vote was taken on the rideshare ordinance; the chair said he wants it passed, noted implementation would begin in March 2026, and recessed the meeting until Monday, June 16.
Topics: rideshare driver pay, utilization rate, driver deactivation, driver safety, fare prices, collective bargaining agreement, city tax revenue, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 29:53 Rule 45 report from May 2025: passed
- 30:15 Direct introduction: collective bargaining agreement between the City of Chicago and International Brotherhood of Teamsters Local 700: passed
- 36:57 Chicago Rideshare Living Wage and Safety Ordinance (subject matter hearing): discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Michael D. Rodriguez (chair): Said no vote would be taken on the rideshare ordinance and the committee would not accept a substitute because another one may be coming. (0:37); Said there have been ample negotiations but both sides have non-negotiables, centered on the pay model. (2:01:11); Summarized that the companies proposed pay as a percentage above minimum wage while advocates say expenses must be covered through a utilization rate, which is the essential disagreement. (2:09:49)
- Chris Taliaferro (alderperson): Asked for additional statistics on what happened in New York after its ordinance was implemented compared with Chicago. (1:05:31); Asked what profit Uber and Lyft make in the Chicago market. (1:11:11)
- Anthony J. Quezada (alderperson): Asked the driver guild representative to respond to Uber's statements about insurance costs. (1:12:24); Asked a driver how many hours he works weekly, what he earns per hour after expenses, and how his pay has changed. (1:14:17); Cited the Uber CEO's compensation increase and said workers deserve a fair wage given company profits. (1:17:03)
- Angela Clay (alderperson): Asked how many drivers are on each platform and how long an average ride takes. (1:20:18); Asked how the companies calculate the price of trips, citing a ride where the driver's pay was a small share of the fare. (1:21:15); Said the subject matter hearing deserves a public answer on how pay and dynamic pricing are calculated, as drivers report confusion. (1:25:14)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Asked Uber why it would need to cut drivers if paying minimum wage and why drivers work for both companies. (1:33:10); Asked BACP whether rideshare drivers were exempt from the city minimum wage and about how drivers pay taxes as independent contractors. (1:37:55)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked for the racial and gender makeup of drivers on each platform. (1:40:47); Asked whether either company had years of losses and requested ten years of financial results through the chair. (1:41:48); Asked how each company defines utilization compared with the ordinance, noting drivers want pay for waiting and pickup time. (1:42:52)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked how much the city collects annually from the rideshare tax and whether any analysis of the ordinance's financial impact on the city has been done. (1:56:15); Suggested the city conduct its own analysis before budget season and before deciding on the ordinance. (1:59:38)
- William E. Hall (alderperson): Said workers must be fairly compensated and asked whether a fair hourly wage figure has been discussed. (2:00:16); Pressed both sides for a concrete proposed hourly wage for drivers. (2:06:03); Asked what an individual driver would make per hour under Lyft's proposal and confirmed the answer of roughly $28 to $30 an hour. (2:09:11)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Asked what initial agreement drivers sign when joining Uber or Lyft and whether pay terms are transparent. (2:10:49); Read a 16th Ward driver's trip statement showing passenger payment, fees and driver earnings, and asked whether drivers understand this when signing up. (2:13:06); Asked what safety measures the companies have taken and whether costs like dash cameras fall on drivers. (2:14:46)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Cited rising company profitability and asked how much it would cost the companies to pay drivers a living wage. (2:22:57); Said he finds it hard to believe a company with $9.8 billion in net income cannot pay workers a living wage. (2:27:48); Said elected officials must decide whether they or corporations dictate laws and asked advocates how deactivation affects workers. (2:55:58)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said there appears to be agreement on deactivation transparency and asked both sides to explain the basis for the utilization rate. (3:00:37); Asked BACP what implementing and enforcing the ordinance would cost and require. (3:11:29); Raised concern that higher fares could reduce visits to Chinatown and tourism in her ward and asked for an analysis of the tax revenue impact. (3:13:47)
Exchanges between members
- 1:02:02 Alderperson Chris Taliaferro asked the chair whether a panelist could continue presenting statistics.
- 1:02:24 The chair told Alderperson Chris Taliaferro he was out of order but would be called first for questions.
- 1:05:20 The chair gave Alderperson Chris Taliaferro the floor for questions.
- 1:12:20 The chair recognized Alderperson Anthony J. Quezada.
- 1:20:11 The chair recognized Alderperson Angela Clay.
- 1:25:17 Alderperson Angela Clay told the chair that the pricing question deserved a public answer at the hearing.
- 1:33:08 The chair recognized Alderperson Derrick G. Curtis.
- 1:33:10 Alderperson Derrick G. Curtis thanked the chair.
- 1:40:37 The chair recognized Alderperson Andre Vasquez Jr. online.
- 1:55:58 The chair recognized Alderperson Nicole T. Lee for a point of clarification.
- 1:56:06 The chair recognized Alderperson Marty Quinn.
- 1:56:08 Alderperson Marty Quinn thanked the chair and said he was running the meeting well.
- 1:59:38 Alderperson Marty Quinn suggested to the chair that the city do its own fiscal analysis.
- 2:00:08 The chair recognized Alderperson William E. Hall.
- 2:01:11 The chair responded to Alderperson William E. Hall question that negotiations had reached non-negotiables on the pay model.
- 2:09:49 The chair summarized for Alderperson William E. Hall the core disagreement between the companies and advocates.
- 2:10:27 Alderperson William E. Hall thanked the chair and said they would work to get it done.
- 2:10:45 The chair recognized Alderperson Stephanie D. Coleman.
- 2:10:49 Alderperson Stephanie D. Coleman thanked the chair for holding the hearing.
- 2:22:53 The chair recognized Alderperson Byron Sigcho-López.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error