Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, November 15, 2024
- When: Fri, Nov 15, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576/video/1029804827
- Transcript: full text (63,859 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 5:53 Public comment
- 49:16 2025 budget hearing: Chicago Police Department
- 49:16 Jason C. Ervin: Opened the CPD hearing, offered condolences on the death of Officer Martinez, and noted the…
- 1:09:31 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked about the work of the Crime Gun Intelligence Center.
- 1:12:03 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked for an update on acquiring additional police helicopters.
- 1:16:07 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the consent decree includes officer mental wellness, expressed confidence it would…
- 1:26:19 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked the superintendent to highlight role models within the department for young people.
- 1:27:22 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked how budget cuts will affect the department.
- 1:31:02 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked what components the council should look for in gunshot detection technology under…
- 1:36:29 Pat Dowell: Asked for the status of the workforce allocation study she requested the previous year and about…
- 1:38:31 Pat Dowell: Said 910 officers on medical leave, overseen by one doctor, seemed high and asked how to get…
- 1:42:38 Pat Dowell: Asked about cuts to the Office of Community Policing and how the CAPS office will change.
- 1:51:35 Scott Waguespack: Asked about the importance of supporting officers' families, referencing past work on…
- 1:54:04 Scott Waguespack: Thanked staff for work on hate crimes and asked what further steps CPD is taking against…
- 1:59:23 Scott Waguespack: Asked about changes at the juvenile detention center and youth diversion efforts.
- 2:02:27 Emma Mitts: Asked how many officers retired and how many recruits were hired, with a demographic breakdown.
- 2:03:44 Emma Mitts: Asked how many resident calls about gunfire have come in since ShotSpotter was discontinued.
- 2:05:17 Emma Mitts: Asked about new CAPS strategies after ShotSpotter and how calls are prioritized.
- 2:13:46 Jason C. Ervin: Asked how officers can practice community policing when call prioritization leaves them no…
- 2:18:59 Chris Taliaferro: Credited district commanders and community organizations for a 57 percent drop in…
- 2:19:35 Chris Taliaferro: Raised concern about officer suicides and asked why nine mental health clinician vacancies…
- 2:24:37 Chris Taliaferro: Urged the department to fill the nine clinician vacancies in 2025.
- 2:31:38 Jason C. Ervin: Asked CPD to provide its event overtime data in a public form to understand external drivers…
- 2:34:27 Silvana Tabares: Asked CPD to respond to COPA's chief administrator's testimony that early statements on the…
- 2:40:20 Silvana Tabares: Asked whether the incident response team compiled witness accounts or video and who decided…
- 2:44:11 Silvana Tabares: Said early framing of the shooting omitted that an officer was shot and questioned whether…
- 2:47:23 Marty Quinn: Asked the superintendent to advocate for a new police district on the Southwest Side and to…
- 2:48:41 Marty Quinn: Said his district is the largest by population with the lowest officer-per-capita ratio and…
- 2:50:22 Marty Quinn: Asked whether detective promotions were drawing down patrol and how many sworn positions were…
- 3:57:26 Daniel La Spata: Raised concern about cutting performance analyst positions in the Office of Constitutional…
- 4:00:25 Daniel La Spata: Asked about the reduction of CAPS community organizers from 39 to 23 and why the positions…
- 4:02:24 Daniel La Spata: Asked what traffic stops are meant to accomplish, citing low gun recovery rates from stops.
- 4:10:04 Peter Chico: Asked how the department supports officers' mental health day to day, citing family members on…
- 4:12:45 Peter Chico: Asked about resources for the Victim Services Unit.
- 4:16:14 Michelle A. Harris: Called for legislation and resolutions to other levels of government to get high-powered…
- 4:16:49 Michelle A. Harris: Thanked the department for Area Two meetings with aldermen and her district commanders.
- 4:19:36 Raymond A. Lopez: Said CAPS meetings are not consistently held or published in all districts and asked how…
- 4:23:57 Raymond A. Lopez: Recommended centralized units for troubled buildings, business liaison officers and school…
- 4:26:05 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked whether CPD's special events unit can raise concerns on permits and requested…
- 4:30:41 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked whether officers could be required to see therapists or psychiatrists.
- 4:32:29 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked that business liaison officers return to meeting with business owners, citing…
- 4:33:40 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked about an increase in the livestock budget line.
- 4:45:49 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how adding more than 200 detectives has affected clearance rates.
- 4:51:12 Nicole T. Lee: Asked for better communication with crime victims about open cases.
- 4:53:01 Nicole T. Lee: Asked what factors determine whether CPD signs off on event permits and whether it can say no.
- 4:56:44 David H. Moore: Credited the superintendent with improving officer morale and thanked his district commanders.
- 4:59:13 David H. Moore: Asked whether police cars are still assigned to Chicago Park District parks.
- 5:01:20 David H. Moore: Asked whether reports that Officer Martinez's stop followed a shots-fired call were accurate.
- 5:08:09 Samantha Nugent: Asked how CPD worked with the budget office in deciding on staffing cuts.
- 5:10:42 Samantha Nugent: Asked whether UASI or other grant funds could support staffing in the Office of…
- 5:11:43 Samantha Nugent: Said the consent decree should be the city's guiding priority and expressed concern about…
- 5:13:28 Brendan Reilly: Asked CPD to send its response to his annual budget memo.
- 5:14:29 Brendan Reilly: Said colleagues are frustrated with vehicle pursuit policies amid burglary crews and asked…
- 5:17:32 Brendan Reilly: Said the city should fight rather than settle lawsuits and that the administration should…
- 5:25:45 Monique L. Scott: Described the impact of hearing the video of Officer Martinez's shooting and said officers…
- 5:27:43 Monique L. Scott: Said residents in her ward feel the effects of short staffing.
- 5:28:23 Monique L. Scott: Asked how the council can help the department do its job.
- 5:33:22 Bennett R. Lawson: Suggested a citywide effort to right-size large events, citing work on the Pride Parade.
- 5:37:38 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked how CPD is addressing a spike in commercial burglaries.
- 5:39:41 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked about cuts to the Bureau of Counterterrorism.
- 5:42:29 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked for CPD's fringe benefit cost because oversight agencies' budget floors are set as…
- 5:44:28 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Requested a list of CPD-related costs budgeted outside the department.
- 5:45:39 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked how CAPS meeting success is measured and how often district councilors meet with…
- 6:09:15 Matthew J. Martin: Said the proposed budget does not give CPD the tools to quickly comply with the consent…
- 6:11:35 Matthew J. Martin: Raised concern about proposed cuts to performance analyst and project positions given…
- 6:17:19 Matthew J. Martin: Asked how many of the 456 cut positions were tied to the consent decree and about…
- 6:21:45 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked what CPD is doing to recruit and retain officers.
- 6:26:43 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked about a reserve grant appropriation noted by the Better Government Association.
- 6:28:31 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked about the $82.5 million appropriation for legal judgments and settlements and…
- 6:34:03 Maria E. Hadden: Supported restoring officer mental wellness positions and asked how first responder mental…
- 6:36:10 Maria E. Hadden: Asked why most of a sexual assault kit grant is being carried over and whether there is a…
- 6:39:36 Maria E. Hadden: Asked what it would take to get more officers on foot patrol.
- 6:44:27 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked what consent decree items were cut from the consent decree budget line.
- 6:46:32 Byron Sigcho-López: Cited police misconduct settlement costs and Inspector General recommendations, and…
- 6:53:54 Byron Sigcho-López: Requested information on how CPD is addressing concerns about underreported traffic stops.
- 6:55:13 Ruth Cruz: Thanked district commanders for responding to shootings at a park in her ward.
- 6:56:36 Ruth Cruz: Asked how CAPS meetings can be reinvented to increase attendance, suggesting resident workshops…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations heard public comment and then held its 2025 budget hearing for the Chicago Police Department, with the superintendent and command staff answering questions after a COFA summary of the proposed $2.1 billion budget. Public commenters spoke for and against the proposed increase to CPD's budget, on youth peacekeeping and the Peace Book ordinance, pretextual traffic stops, police misconduct settlements, and other topics. Members questioned the department on consent decree staffing and position cuts, officer wellness clinicians, the workforce allocation study, medical leave, helicopters and vehicle pursuit policy, the loss of ShotSpotter, special event overtime and reimbursement, CAPS meetings, traffic stop data, victim services, detectives, sergeant staffing, language access, and off-duty officer employment. Several members and the superintendent stated that the nine officer wellness clinician vacancies proposed for cuts had been restored in talks with the mayor's office. No votes were taken; the chair excused the department subject to recall and recessed the committee until Tuesday.
Topics: CPD budget, consent decree, officer wellness, special event overtime, ShotSpotter, community policing, traffic stops, helicopters and pursuits, staffing and vacancies, victim services
Agenda items discussed
- 5:53 Public comment: discussed
- 49:16 2025 budget hearing: Chicago Police Department: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Opened the CPD hearing, offered condolences on the death of Officer Martinez, and noted the superintendent asked to appear that day rather than the following week. (49:16); Asked how officers can practice community policing when call prioritization leaves them no unobligated time, and whether police should stop answering some calls. (2:13:46); Asked CPD to provide its event overtime data in a public form to understand external drivers of overtime. (2:31:38)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Asked about the work of the Crime Gun Intelligence Center. (1:09:31); Asked for an update on acquiring additional police helicopters. (1:12:03); Said the consent decree includes officer mental wellness, expressed confidence it would be fully funded, and asked what is needed to stay in compliance. (1:16:07)
- Lamont J. Robinson (alderperson): Asked the superintendent to highlight role models within the department for young people. (1:26:19); Asked how budget cuts will affect the department. (1:27:22); Asked what components the council should look for in gunshot detection technology under the current RFI, and whether CPD sees technology as intervention or prevention. (1:31:02)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked for the status of the workforce allocation study she requested the previous year and about the vendor conducting it. (1:36:29); Said 910 officers on medical leave, overseen by one doctor, seemed high and asked how to get officers back to work. (1:38:31); Asked about cuts to the Office of Community Policing and how the CAPS office will change. (1:42:38)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked about the importance of supporting officers' families, referencing past work on death benefits for police and fire. (1:51:35); Thanked staff for work on hate crimes and asked what further steps CPD is taking against them. (1:54:04); Asked about changes at the juvenile detention center and youth diversion efforts. (1:59:23)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Asked how many officers retired and how many recruits were hired, with a demographic breakdown. (2:02:27); Asked how many resident calls about gunfire have come in since ShotSpotter was discontinued. (2:03:44); Asked about new CAPS strategies after ShotSpotter and how calls are prioritized. (2:05:17)
- Chris Taliaferro (alderperson): Credited district commanders and community organizations for a 57 percent drop in homicides in his area. (2:18:59); Raised concern about officer suicides and asked why nine mental health clinician vacancies were being cut. (2:19:35); Urged the department to fill the nine clinician vacancies in 2025. (2:24:37)
- Silvana Tabares (alderperson): Asked CPD to respond to COPA's chief administrator's testimony that early statements on the Dexter Reid shooting were based on information relayed by a deputy chief, which she described as routine. (2:34:27); Asked whether the incident response team compiled witness accounts or video and who decided on its release. (2:40:20); Said early framing of the shooting omitted that an officer was shot and questioned whether COPA's involvement in such incidents benefits public safety. (2:44:11)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked the superintendent to advocate for a new police district on the Southwest Side and to tour a facility on 63rd Street. (2:47:23); Said his district is the largest by population with the lowest officer-per-capita ratio and highest calls for service. (2:48:41); Asked whether detective promotions were drawing down patrol and how many sworn positions were cut. (2:50:22)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Raised concern about cutting performance analyst positions in the Office of Constitutional Policing from 18 to two. (3:57:26); Asked about the reduction of CAPS community organizers from 39 to 23 and why the positions were hard to fill. (4:00:25); Asked what traffic stops are meant to accomplish, citing low gun recovery rates from stops. (4:02:24)
- Peter Chico (alderperson): Asked how the department supports officers' mental health day to day, citing family members on the force. (4:10:04); Asked about resources for the Victim Services Unit. (4:12:45)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Called for legislation and resolutions to other levels of government to get high-powered guns off the streets. (4:16:14); Thanked the department for Area Two meetings with aldermen and her district commanders. (4:16:49)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Said CAPS meetings are not consistently held or published in all districts and asked how CPD will ensure they are. (4:19:36); Recommended centralized units for troubled buildings, business liaison officers and school liaisons rather than leaving them to districts. (4:23:57); Asked whether CPD's special events unit can raise concerns on permits and requested after-action reports for events. (4:26:05)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked whether officers could be required to see therapists or psychiatrists. (4:30:41); Asked that business liaison officers return to meeting with business owners, citing loitering and shootings near businesses. (4:32:29); Asked about an increase in the livestock budget line. (4:33:40)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked how adding more than 200 detectives has affected clearance rates. (4:45:49); Asked for better communication with crime victims about open cases. (4:51:12); Asked what factors determine whether CPD signs off on event permits and whether it can say no. (4:53:01)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Credited the superintendent with improving officer morale and thanked his district commanders. (4:56:44); Asked whether police cars are still assigned to Chicago Park District parks. (4:59:13); Asked whether reports that Officer Martinez's stop followed a shots-fired call were accurate. (5:01:20)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Asked how CPD worked with the budget office in deciding on staffing cuts. (5:08:09); Asked whether UASI or other grant funds could support staffing in the Office of Constitutional Policing. (5:10:42); Said the consent decree should be the city's guiding priority and expressed concern about resources for constitutional policing. (5:11:43)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked CPD to send its response to his annual budget memo. (5:13:28); Said colleagues are frustrated with vehicle pursuit policies amid burglary crews and asked if CPD is open to changing them. (5:14:29); Said the city should fight rather than settle lawsuits and that the administration should back up officers. (5:17:32)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Described the impact of hearing the video of Officer Martinez's shooting and said officers in her ward feel constrained by policies. (5:25:45); Said residents in her ward feel the effects of short staffing. (5:27:43); Asked how the council can help the department do its job. (5:28:23)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Suggested a citywide effort to right-size large events, citing work on the Pride Parade. (5:33:22); Asked how CPD is addressing a spike in commercial burglaries. (5:37:38); Asked about cuts to the Bureau of Counterterrorism. (5:39:41)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked for CPD's fringe benefit cost because oversight agencies' budget floors are set as a share of CPD's budget. (5:42:29); Requested a list of CPD-related costs budgeted outside the department. (5:44:28); Asked how CAPS meeting success is measured and how often district councilors meet with commanders. (5:45:39)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Said the proposed budget does not give CPD the tools to quickly comply with the consent decree, citing the monitor's findings on vacancies. (6:09:15); Raised concern about proposed cuts to performance analyst and project positions given data collection gaps noted by the monitor. (6:11:35); Asked how many of the 456 cut positions were tied to the consent decree and about proposed training academy cuts. (6:17:19)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked what CPD is doing to recruit and retain officers. (6:21:45); Asked about a reserve grant appropriation noted by the Better Government Association. (6:26:43); Asked about the $82.5 million appropriation for legal judgments and settlements and what is being done to reduce future settlements. (6:28:31)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Supported restoring officer mental wellness positions and asked how first responder mental health grant funds will be used. (6:34:03); Asked why most of a sexual assault kit grant is being carried over and whether there is a backlog. (6:36:10); Asked what it would take to get more officers on foot patrol. (6:39:36)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Asked what consent decree items were cut from the consent decree budget line. (6:44:27); Cited police misconduct settlement costs and Inspector General recommendations, and asked about risks from extremist group membership in the department. (6:46:32); Requested information on how CPD is addressing concerns about underreported traffic stops. (6:53:54)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Thanked district commanders for responding to shootings at a park in her ward. (6:55:13); Asked how CAPS meetings can be reinvented to increase attendance, suggesting resident workshops and more foot and bike patrols. (6:56:36)
Exchanges between members
- 2:25:12 Chairman Jason C. Ervin noted Alderman Chris Taliaferro had said he had one question and let him continue.
- 2:31:38 Chairman Jason C. Ervin built on Alderman Pat Dowell point by asking CPD for event data in a public format.
- 2:45:30 Chairman Jason C. Ervin told Alderman Silvana Tabares she raised a good point but cautioned against faulting the entire COPA agency.
- 4:32:29 Alderman Jeanette B. Taylor reiterated Alderman Raymond A. Lopez call to restore business liaison officers.
- 4:59:13 Alderman David H. Moore followed up on Alderman Jeanette B. Taylor point about Park District policing.
- 5:26:51 Alderman Monique L. Scott said she agreed with Alderman Brendan Reilly that the administration should allow officers to do their jobs.
- 5:44:13 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee asked Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. whether the fringe cost question had been asked of the budget director.
- 5:44:18 Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. replied that he believed it had been asked.
- 6:34:10 Alderman Maria E. Hadden echoed Alderman Matthew J. O'Shea concern about reductions in officer mental wellness positions.
- 6:39:17 Alderman Maria E. Hadden echoed Alderman Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth support for the 24th District commander.
- 6:43:11 Alderman Maria E. Hadden added her support to Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. request for special event cost lists.
- 6:57:13 Alderman Ruth Cruz echoed Alderman Maria E. Hadden call for more officers on foot patrol.
- 7:26:09 Chairman Jason C. Ervin clarified Alderman Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth question about functions other departments could perform, and she confirmed his summary.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error