Committee on Public Safety meeting, October 23, 2024
- When: Wed, Oct 23, 2024, 9:30 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Public Safety
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1022244346
- Transcript: full text (38,014 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 33:38 Public comment
- 33:41 Brian Hopkins: Reminded public speakers that the hearing concerns families who have lost loved ones and…
- 1:13:09 Subject matter hearing on violence against Black women and missing and murdered Black women and girls
- 1:13:28 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said that when Black women and girls go missing there is little urgency, and that the…
- 1:16:49 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said Superintendent Snelling has committed to working on the issue and that a state task…
- 1:18:22 Stephanie D. Coleman: Said Black women are 16 percent of Chicago's population but about a third of crime…
- 1:20:59 Stephanie D. Coleman: Said addressing the issue requires clergy, business, civic and education communities…
- 1:21:59 Brian Hopkins: Asked committee members to hold questions and listen to those sharing lived experiences.
- 3:17:52 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked CPD and the Invisible Institute how many missing persons cases remain unsolved,…
- 3:51:37 Maria E. Hadden: Said men are the perpetrators in almost all cases of violence against women and need to…
- 3:53:14 Maria E. Hadden: Asked why only CPD's Commander of Youth Investigations attended and not the superintendent…
- 3:54:01 Maria E. Hadden: Asked when automated missing persons reports began and suggested adding assigned detective…
- 3:57:39 Brian Hopkins: Said requests for information are being tracked and this is only the beginning of the…
- 4:04:32 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked which CPD representatives should attend the next hearing.
- 4:13:40 Desmon C. Yancy: Said Black men need to stand up and called it unacceptable that missing persons cases…
- 4:16:19 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Said domestic violence is a top concern in her 48th Ward and the leading 911 call…
- 4:19:44 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked the CPD commander whether police attitudes toward domestic violence calls have…
- 4:24:02 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Said most policy failure is in implementation and asked about the role of the CARES…
- 4:26:14 Nicole T. Lee: Said as chair of the Women's Caucus she looks forward to a joint hearing on enforcement of…
- 4:28:20 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how CPD and DCFS coordinate on cases and what training detectives receive for missing…
- 4:31:49 Resolution read as number 8960
- 4:32:41 Byron Sigcho-López: Raised concerns about bias and discrimination in how CPD takes cases and said more…
- 4:35:45 Byron Sigcho-López: Called on the council to take action and corrective measures so no victim's family is…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Public Safety held a subject matter hearing, convened with Alderpersons Taylor and Coleman, on violence against Black women and on missing and murdered Black women and girls. After 12 public commenters, the committee heard testimony from family members of missing and murdered women, community organizations, a CBS Chicago investigative reporter, Invisible Institute and City Bureau reporters who described prematurely closed missing persons cases and gaps in police data, mayor's office policy staff, and the CPD Commander of Youth Investigations, who described the automation of missing persons reports and planned data and training changes. Members questioned CPD on unsolved case counts, detective staffing, Amber Alert coordination and work with the state task force, criticized that only one CPD representative attended, and requested follow-up information through the chair. The committee approved its Rule 45 report and adopted a resolution read as number 8960; the chair said this was the start of the committee's work on the issue.
Topics: missing Black women and girls, violence against Black women, domestic violence, CPD missing persons investigations, police data practices, Amber Alerts, gender-based violence policy
Agenda items discussed
- 33:38 Public comment: discussed
- 1:12:55 Rule 45 report: passed
- 1:13:09 Subject matter hearing on violence against Black women and missing and murdered Black women and girls: discussed
- 4:31:49 Resolution read as number 8960: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Brian Hopkins (chair): Reminded public speakers that the hearing concerns families who have lost loved ones and asked them to observe appropriate decorum. (33:41); Asked committee members to hold questions and listen to those sharing lived experiences. (1:21:59); Said requests for information are being tracked and this is only the beginning of the committee's engagement on the issue. (3:57:39)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Said that when Black women and girls go missing there is little urgency, and that the goal is a plan with funding rather than another meeting. (1:13:28); Said Superintendent Snelling has committed to working on the issue and that a state task force alone is not enough without resources. (1:16:49); Asked CPD and the Invisible Institute how many missing persons cases remain unsolved, and expressed disappointment that CPD did not bring a number. (3:17:52)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Said Black women are 16 percent of Chicago's population but about a third of crime victims and that she partnered with Alderperson Jeanette B. Taylor to bring the issue forward. (1:18:22); Said addressing the issue requires clergy, business, civic and education communities as well as the police. (1:20:59); Asked which CPD representatives should attend the next hearing. (4:04:32)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Said men are the perpetrators in almost all cases of violence against women and need to take responsibility. (3:51:37); Asked why only CPD's Commander of Youth Investigations attended and not the superintendent or his office. (3:53:14); Asked when automated missing persons reports began and suggested adding assigned detective information to notices sent to alders. (3:54:01)
- Desmon C. Yancy (alderperson): Said Black men need to stand up and called it unacceptable that missing persons cases depend on being a political priority for police. (4:13:40)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Said domestic violence is a top concern in her 48th Ward and the leading 911 call type there according to a former commander. (4:16:19); Asked the CPD commander whether police attitudes toward domestic violence calls have changed. (4:19:44); Said most policy failure is in implementation and asked about the role of the CARES unit versus uniformed officers in crises. (4:24:02)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said as chair of the Women's Caucus she looks forward to a joint hearing on enforcement of orders of protection. (4:26:14); Asked how CPD and DCFS coordinate on cases and what training detectives receive for missing persons cases. (4:28:20)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Raised concerns about bias and discrimination in how CPD takes cases and said more police resources should not be requested when resources are poorly deployed. (4:32:41); Called on the council to take action and corrective measures so no victim's family is left without a callback. (4:35:45)
Exchanges between members
- 1:13:09 Hopkins turned the meeting over to co-conveners Taylor and Coleman for introductory remarks.
- 1:18:22 Coleman thanked Chair Brian Hopkins and the committee.
- 1:19:13 Coleman said she had a partner in Taylor in bringing the issue to the council.
- 3:17:31 Taylor said she would turn questioning over to Hopkins after her own questions.
- 3:50:43 Hadden thanked Coleman and Taylor for bringing the issue to the committee.
- 4:04:19 Hopkins recognized Coleman after her mother, former alderperson Shirley Coleman, spoke.
- 4:09:05 Coleman referenced Hadden in saying police districts have different resource needs.
- 4:12:59 Hopkins recognized Vice Chair Desmon C. Yancy.
- 4:13:08 Yancy thanked Taylor and Coleman for the hearing.
- 4:15:46 Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked Coleman and Taylor.
- 4:18:59 Manaa-Hoppenworth said she agreed with everything Hadden said.
- 4:25:47 Lee thanked the chair and Taylor and Coleman for bringing the issue forward.
- 4:31:36 Hopkins said he looks forward to the joint hearing Lee mentioned.
- 4:32:09 Sigcho-López thanked Taylor, Coleman and the panelists.
- 4:34:44 Sigcho-López thanked Taliaferro for taking the issue of police bias seriously.
- 4:36:46 Hopkins told Sigcho-López the matter he raised is also before the Police and Fire Committee.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error