Committee on Workforce Development meeting, May 13, 2025
- When: Tue, May 13, 2025, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Workforce Development
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928568/video/1082931074
- Transcript: full text (8,738 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 11:49 Public comment
- 59:55 Rule 59 remote attendance for Alderpersons Hall and Vasquez
- 1:00:45 Amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 2-152 by adding new Section 2-152-151 allowing relevant work experience…
- 1:01:07 Motion to accept the substitute ordinance
- 1:02:18 Gilbert Villegas: Said the city should value experience, training and certifications rather than only…
- 1:03:02 Gilbert Villegas: Said veterans make up a large share of those affected by degree requirements.
- 1:03:33 Gilbert Villegas: Thanked advocacy organizations, including Opportunity at Work, and said he would move for…
- 1:15:26 Michael D. Rodriguez: Congratulated Alderperson Gilbert Villegas, said degree requirements have created…
- 1:16:43 Nicholas Sposato: Said he supports the ordinance but asked HR and Law to address possible unintended…
- 1:17:33 Michael D. Rodriguez: Noted that similar language has passed the Illinois Senate and is going to the House.
- 1:19:15 Nicholas Sposato: Asked whether hiring outcomes skewed by race could lead to lawsuits, and said work ethic…
- 1:20:02 Michael D. Rodriguez: Noted that degree requirements also screen out almost 40% of white applicants.
- 1:20:18 Derrick G. Curtis: Said many people have lost opportunities despite being qualified without a degree, and…
- 1:21:08 Marty Quinn: Called the ordinance a good first step and asked whether institutional knowledge would be…
- 1:24:13 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said the issue is personal because he had to complete a degree online to avoid being…
- 1:24:50 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said the debt people take on for degrees often does not pay off and that experience…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Workforce Development heard ten public commenters. Several rideshare drivers urged passage of the Fair Share ordinance, and other speakers supported skills-based hiring. After a recess to reach quorum, the committee approved the April 2025 Rule 45 report and accepted a substitute ordinance from Alderperson Gilbert Villegas that would let relevant work experience count as equivalent to a college degree for city employment, unless the skills require an advanced degree. Representatives of Opportunity at Work and the Chicago Jobs Council testified in support. The Human Resources Commissioner said the ordinance codifies practices the department already uses, and the Department of Law said it had no legal concerns. Members asked about unintended consequences and promotions, and the committee passed the ordinance by voice vote. The chair said he would report it to the City Council meeting on May 21.
Topics: skills-based hiring, college degree requirements, city employment, rideshare driver pay, Fair Share ordinance, Rule 45 report
Agenda items discussed
- 11:49 Public comment: discussed
- 59:55 Rule 59 remote attendance for Alderpersons Hall and Vasquez: passed
- 1:00:27 Approval of the April 2025 Rule 45 report: passed
- 1:01:07 Motion to accept the substitute ordinance (SO2025-0016662): passed
- 1:00:45 Amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 2-152 by adding new Section 2-152-151 allowing relevant work experience equivalent to a college degree for eligibility for city employment: passed
- 1:26:33 Motion to adjourn: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Michael D. Rodriguez (chair): Congratulated Alderperson Gilbert Villegas, said degree requirements have created barriers to entry, and said union partners support the ordinance. (1:15:26); Noted that similar language has passed the Illinois Senate and is going to the House. (1:17:33); Noted that degree requirements also screen out almost 40% of white applicants. (1:20:02)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Said the city should value experience, training and certifications rather than only college degrees, noting 44% of Chicagoans lack a degree. (1:02:18); Said veterans make up a large share of those affected by degree requirements. (1:03:02); Thanked advocacy organizations, including Opportunity at Work, and said he would move for passage after questions. (1:03:33)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Said he supports the ordinance but asked HR and Law to address possible unintended consequences. (1:16:43); Asked whether hiring outcomes skewed by race could lead to lawsuits, and said work ethic and experience matter most to him. (1:19:15)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Said many people have lost opportunities despite being qualified without a degree, and moved to pass the ordinance. (1:20:18)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Called the ordinance a good first step and asked whether institutional knowledge would be considered for promotions. (1:21:08)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Said the issue is personal because he had to complete a degree online to avoid being blocked from promotion, and said he would fully support the ordinance. (1:24:13); Said the debt people take on for degrees often does not pay off and that experience should be recognized. (1:24:50)
Exchanges between members
- 1:15:26 The chair congratulated Alderperson Gilbert Villegas for bringing the ordinance forward.
- 1:20:02 The chair responded to Alderperson Nicholas Sposato concern by noting that many white applicants are also screened out.
- 1:20:19 Alderperson Derrick G. Curtis thanked Alderperson Gilbert Villegas for bringing the ordinance forward.
- 1:21:36 Alderperson Gilbert Villegas answered Alderperson Marty Quinn question about promotions.
- 1:24:09 Alderperson Andre Vasquez Jr. thanked Alderperson Gilbert Villegas for introducing the ordinance.
- 1:25:57 Alderperson Andre Vasquez Jr. thanked the chair for putting the item on the agenda.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error