Mic check, one, two, mic check, three, four, mic check. All right, we'll call the Committee on Workforce Development to come to order. We're going to go straight to public comment. I believe we have one online commenter, and that's Naomi Dodd. Naomi, are you there? Naomi Dodd, are you there? All right, we're going to move on. Let me know if they come back. You can press star six, is it? Hi, this is Naomi. Ah, very cool. You have three minutes. Go ahead. Okay, now? Now, yes. You want me? Oh, okay. I had something completely written up, but can I just get to what I had written? Well, okay, I'll just go. The reason why I believe that skills-based learning is very important is because the way I grew up, I've always learned things in a visual sort of way. And so me learning things in a visual sort of way, I did traditional learning that never worked for me. And so as part of me doing my skills-based training, I would do on-the-job training. So I would spend many times where in the beginning of my career, I worked as a customer service rep, and I learned databases. I learned SQL, I learned project management, I learned communication skills, and all of these things I learned that I would on the job. Even though I went to school for a degree in English, I found that those things helped me to communicate in order to learn different languages like Python, SQL, and so forth. And then I encountered with SARS, and SARS was a community that helped to enhance skills-based learning. And unfortunately, I've spent many times where I was the only woman and the only black at the table, and I wanted to make sure that that didn't happen in the next generation that came after me. And so I feel like my stumbling blocks were that the traditional education system did not work for me, and the traditional education system did not accommodate me. And so I'm really excited about something that accommodates someone who doesn't learn by opening up a book and just reading it and then learning concepts, and they learn the way that I do, which is hands-on, practical learning, and taking practical concepts and building a foundation around that. I think that different types of educational systems will take a leap into bigger opportunities to pursue your passions rather than looking at what pays you well, but you should do what you do well, so you should do your passion. And I think that skills-based learning makes you understand what your passion is. This is coming from someone who started off as a help desk, and now I work as a technical project manager for hospitals across the United States. And, you know, I started at $10 an hour, and now I'm well at over six figures. I work with people who have masks. Thank you so very much. Thank you. I'll remind the committee that we are limiting comments to three minutes and to ten speakers. The next public speaker will be Patricia Puente. I apologize. Can I speak after two more people? I apologize. Your time's now, ma'am. Go ahead. Okay. My thing of the work of, that's what you guys are talking right now, right? The workforce. I would appreciate if there was diversity, not only Hispanic people, because I was told that the people are telling, the Hispanic people are telling the rest of the Hispanic people, only speak Spanish, and like that, we could take all the jobs. Okay? I went to court, and the first thing that a man came to me and spoke Spanish. I'm like, wait, I'm in the United States of America. I'm not in South America or Mexico. I went to Daly Center. This man spoke French, and this man was Hispanic, and he started telling them, oh, we can't help you, because we don't have that language. Well, you know what? We need more interpreters. Diversity, please. Not only Hispanic people that speak Spanish, because they were told, do not speak English. And that's what I was told in my workforce when I was speaking English with the African Americans and the Caucasians. And the Hispanic man came to me and told me, you are not allowed to speak English in this company. I'm like, what the heck? I'm in the United States of America. And that's my concern. Please, make it diversity. Not only Hispanic, because they only want, and this is what they said, too. What? We're going to take over Illinois? Are you kidding me? Please, make it diversity. Get more speaking people of different languages. Next up is Lee Berry. Good morning, everybody. I may not be your typical rideshare driver, because I've been a media executive. I've actually been a consultant to the Department of Human Services here in Chicago. What I've recognized in the year and a half I've been doing some part-time rideshare driving is that we have a big problem, and that is that the rideshare issue, and I want to talk about the fair share ordinance, which is about fair wages, about due process for deactivations, and about safety for drivers. What we're dealing with, and this is a moral imperative, and I understand management. I understand that we have a moral imperative to make sure that the culture of Uber, Lyft, and the rideshare industry is worker-centered, because drivers are the ones doing the work. I do counseling when I'm in my car driving. I help people with their lives. I make people who are crying feel that there's a light at the end of the tunnel when I get done driving them. We're human beings, and the rideshare industry is about people. It's not just about algorithms and code. And we've come a long way now with the rideshare ordinance, with the people's lobby, in negotiating what we consider to be an equitable and fair law. And, you know, the gig economy is becoming a scourge in this country, across the board. There's a black hole in labor law, because independent contractors have no protections. Union members have protections. We don't. It's time that the city council take a look seriously at all the details of our rideshare ordinance, realize that we've come up with an equitable and fair solution that is a win-win for riders, passengers, drivers, and these companies that are making an absolute fortune writing code and developing algorithms, and that's all they do. At some point, these companies need to understand that they are a transportation company. They are not a code company. And the city of Chicago has an incredible history of working for labor, and the working person. The rideshare ordinance, what we call fair share, is ready to be voted on and ready to be passed. And we cannot continue to drive earning less than minimum wage when you take into account that we pay all of our car expenses. And we know there are stories of homeless drivers now, drivers living in their cars, drivers who have lost their homes because nobody's making the kind of money that was promised to them and actually they earned a number of years ago because it has been a slow bait-and-switch by Uber and Lyft. And there is so much anger and frustration. And I'm a person who's dealt with corporate culture most of my career in communication. Thank you, sir. Next up is Joseph Negrau. Forgive me if I say that incorrectly. Good morning. My name is Joseph Negrau, born and raised in Chicago. I live in the 41st Ward. I rose today to speak about the Fair Share Ordinance and Workforce Committee. I think it's important that this ordinance gets put forward and voted on as soon as possible. The companies have had more than two months now to negotiate and to try and come up to a solution. They have been stalling. They have used every trick in the book to push back a decision. And that means that every day drivers get shortchanged. Every day more passengers get overcharged. And this needs to stop. Making sure drivers get paid fairly. Making sure passengers aren't gouged. Making sure substantive safety improvements are made to the system. And most importantly, making sure that new avenues of transparency and accountability are implemented. We have been suffering from hidden pay structures and algorithmic manipulation, drivers being left behind, and this has to stop as soon as possible. You guys are passing increases for other workers in the city. They're getting raises in July. This keeps getting pushed back further and further, and drivers are falling behind. As far as safety is concerned, there's a big hole in the system. We just had recently a driver get assaulted severely. A couple months before that, another driver was assaulted. And there is no urgency on the part of the city or on the part of these companies to make things better for us. We have no idea who is actually sitting behind us when they get behind us in the car. And it's a sad thing to say that getting home safely, getting home alive, means that you're lucky because a lot of drivers are not. Thank you. Thank you. Next up is Ken Turner. Ken Turner? Hello. Are you ready? Yeah. Hi. Hello. Hello, everyone. My name is Ken. My last name is Turner. I'm fully deaf. And I live in Chicago, Illinois. I was born and I grew up in Chicago, Illinois. I've been working for Uber and for Lyft for now for six years. And I have had them have accused me incorrectly. There's a poster that says I'm deaf to let all the passengers know. So they know that I can't hear. So when they're sitting in the back, when they're sitting behind me, they know that I can't hear because of the poster that's in my car. And when they respond, you know, what's happened is I've let Uber know, I've let Lyft know because they've incorrectly accused me of being drunk when I was driving. And they were saying I had reckless driving. And other people that maybe have tapped me while I was driving, I've explained to them to look at the poster, I need to pay attention because I'm trying to follow the GPS, the navigation system. So what's happened is they've blamed me incorrectly. And it's been a misunderstanding because I have a drug test approved with alcohol, cocaine, all the drug tests. I went to a lab. I had a drug test that was done. It was a blood test. It came out completely clean. And it shows that I had nothing in my system. It showed that I have nothing in my system. So there's no reason for me to not be able to be driving. Right now, there's been a backlash in the system where they've had, there's been a bank statement that's shown that I have lost all of my money right now. I have no income that comes in right now. Totally broke. I've had a hard time being able to make money since I've lost this, since I've deactivated my account. I've had to be moving from house to house. And right now, it's been very tough for me. So I keep fighting. I keep fighting this because they deactivated my account. And I want to be able to work. Thank you. Next up is Richard Juarez. Rich Juarez. Hi. My name is Richard Juarez. I'm born and raised here in Chicago, 66 years. I am a veteran. I've given well over 47,000 rides. The thing that's really disturbing to me is this. Everyone wants to talk about corporate profits. And they look at us like we just drive from A to B. We do more than that. I've helped people with food allergies in my car. When you have an elderly person in the car, they're looking to me to help them. And I gladly help them. We're much more than drivers. And they think Uber and Lyft want to pay us what they believe is a fair hourly wage. And they just see us as transportation. But we are much more than that. I've had several people in my car that have opened up and I've done what I can to share a different perspective to help them move through our difficult times. Sometimes when they get out of my car, they have tears in their eyes because of what I shared with them. We're more than just drivers from A to B. We're more than just an assistant to someone that needs help, an elderly person or someone whose medical transportation didn't show up. We help people. We are more than that. And I challenge Uber and Lyft to consider this because they often talk about the number of cars out there. Consider this, and this is really important. When the platforms first started, your car could not be more than six years old. Then it went to 10. Then it went to 12. It is now at 15. Doesn't that tell you something? People that drive quality cars probably have a quality driver. The reason why they probably, my belief, they expanded the age requirement is because quality cars and quality drivers were falling off the platform. Why? Because we're not getting paid fairly. I believe drivers are more than just drivers. We help people. We help the community. We help safe lives. We reduce the rate of DUIs out there, and you hear it in court all the time. Pay a $50 Uber or $10,000 DUI. How many lives are impacted because of a DUI? We help people get, we help their businesses thrive because people don't have to worry about drinking and driving. They can go out and have a good time. They know they can get someone to get them home. We are more than just drivers. All we're asking for is to be paid a fair earning. Time and distance is the only way that's transparent because you know what you're getting paid per mile per minute. This cryptic algorithm, this gaslighting that they want to present to us and convince us of otherwise, that's ridiculous. Pay us. It's a proven model with taxis, time and distance. It's proven. Please help us support the Fair Share Ordinance and Workforce Committee. Thank you. Next up is George Blakemore. Fair Share. Something is inherently wrong here. Dealing with these jobs and the workforce development. While I'm talking, these two altruists are talking. They don't listen to us. They think that they are above us. Who does this or do this? One of these birds. Put a meeting there. I got to hurry up and run over to this other meeting that's going on. It's a sad fool down here. And they're all Democrats. It's something inherently wrong. And looking at the agenda, they should be talking. I'm glad that you don't have to stick to the topic on the agenda. On the agenda. Did you know you can be a Chicago policeman and not even a citizen of the United States of America? What is this diversity, equity, and inclusion to black people? A white woman can come in. A white man can come in. And I already have the majority of the contract. A white woman can come in. A Hispanic can come in. An Asian can come in. And what else, Mr. Blakemore, a disadvantaged white man? Who's a disadvantaged white man? I heard it's CTA Meek. A disadvantaged white man. There's something wrong here. I didn't want to go red. But blue was just so blue, just messed up all Democrats. And black people continued to vote for them. To vote for them. Sell out. House. House in, nigga. You use the word nigga. Yes. Woo-wee. What kind of man are you? I'm just like that ultimate. Forgive me if I use the term nigga. On the plantation, that's what the master made. Not a black man. He wasn't encouraged to teach you. To help you. To inform you. To engage you. And your workforce. Completely Hispanic. And more of them are coming. They are the new majority of the minority. And who doesn't affect more? The black men. What about the white men? They'll never take over from the white men. They'll never take over from the white men. They did not come across the Rio Grande to help you, to empower you, to engage you. They came across the Rio Grande to compete with you for these jobs, goods, contracts, and services. Mr. Bain will run to the next meeting now. Next up is Ann VanderWheel. Your time is up. Ma'am, please. Good morning. Chairman Rodriguez and committee members, thank you for this opportunity this morning. My name is Ann VanderWheel. I'm Director of Policy at New Moms. New Moms is a nonprofit organization located in the Austin neighborhood that partners with young moms as they pursue economic mobility, housing stability, and family well-being. New Moms endeavors to create pathways to opportunity for young moms up to age 24. We believe in their grit, potential, and tenacity to secure brighter futures for themselves and their children. The STARS initiative before you today is one such pathway. New Moms supports Alderman Villegas' ordinance allowing relevant work experience to be considered equivalent to a college degree to increase eligibility opportunities for city employment for workers skilled through alternative routes, who do not have bachelor's degrees unless the skills required can only be obtained through a degree. New Moms offers a comprehensive paid job training program through our successful candle company, Bright Endeavors, providing job skills and career readiness that help open doors to opportunity. New Moms engage in job training at Bright Endeavors. They're at the beginning of their journeys toward economic mobility. They're working towards entry-level positions that allow them to acquire the skills needed to pursue higher-wage work. The young moms in our job training program are among the nearly half of Chicagoans without a college degree. Removing degree requirements would greatly benefit them by increasing their access to high-wage jobs when they are prepared to take the next step in their career pathway. In fact, we work with them to be positioned as STARS with certifications, licenses, apprenticeships, and associate degrees that are part of the STARS program. We've also reshaped our internal job descriptions and hiring practices for skills-based hiring. This does not apply to all positions due to limitations imposed by funding partners such as Medicaid. However, wherever possible, both our internal practices and our external advocacy, we believe in skills-based hiring. We commend the committee for considering Alderman Villegas' proposal and encourage a yes vote in support of all those with bold dreams and the right skill set. Next up is Cheryl Holman. Good morning. Thank you for hearing us this morning. My name is Cheryl Holman. I'm the CEO of Community Assistance Programs. We run workforce development programs from age 18 to 65. It's important that we make sure that we count those that have aged. And if they have aged and retired, they should also be considered because they have a wealth of knowledge. We are not looking at the wealth of knowledge of the people that are in this city. If half of the city does not have a degree but they are qualified for jobs, then we are doing a systemic exclusion of a large population of people that we could use in our jobs. So we need to have a situation where the city believes that if you don't have a degree. And then looking at where we are now, we have so many clients who are not interested in going to college but are brilliant in working with all of the computer sciences and writing code and all of those things, and they are not considered if they don't have a degree. And a lot of degrees do not keep up with the population. So I'm here to support the amendment that would include the consideration of people that have experience and not degrees. Because right now, we have to change with the times. We are missing a whole population of youth that would get into different programs that want to do different jobs. But when you put up that sign that you must have a degree, then you're losing a lot. They don't even consider it. They move on. So we don't want to set up everyone for failure because they don't have a degree. Because you're also excluding the populations that don't have the funds to go to college. College has gotten so expensive. So there again, you are systemically excluding a population. So I really think that the city of Chicago has always been progressive when it comes to workforce development, and we appreciate it. But you have to move with the times to make sure that we are not exclusive but inclusive. Thank you. Thank you. Our last speaker is Jeanette Perez-Sanchez. Good morning, everyone. My name is Jeanette Perez-Sanchez. Since I was nine, I've been passionate about architecture, construction, and engineering. But even from a young age, I was told pursuing that dream, or any career for that matter, required one thing, a very expensive college degree. To start saving up, I joined the workforce in high school through a youth employment program in Little Village that taught me communication skills, teamwork building, problem solving. I also worked fast-paced jobs in customer service and warehouses, learning quickly and adapting under pressure. College was an option for me, and I was accepted for engineering. But when my family needed support, I chose them. Instead of going to college, I joined the Air Force and served as a public health technician, gaining leadership, adaptability, emotional intelligence, skills that stuck with me far beyond my military years. I've always learned best by doing, and after five years, I was ready to pursue my dream. But most job listings required a degree or field experience I didn't yet have. Still, I kept applying, hoping a recruiter would overlook my lack of a degree and see my willingness to learn instead. I found an apprenticeship where they didn't overlook the lack of a degree, but rather acknowledged the bigger value in passion, drive, and determination. I spent two years learning there on real-world projects, gaining both technical and professional skills. Later, when I pivoted into construction, I hit the same degree barrier, until another recruiter saw my potential. And even though they didn't hire me due to that requirement, they passed my resume to Revolution Workshop's Professional Pathways Program, a nonprofit that helped me deepen my knowledge of the field and sharpen my skills with any background or experience in construction. Today, I am a senior project engineer in construction, promoted in under a year with no bachelor's degree. What got me here is faith, dedication, persistence, adaptability, over 10 years of real-world experience, and people who recognize that intelligence, capability, and tenacity don't only come with a degree. People who are willing to see what I am truly capable of, not just what was on paper or lack thereof. I'm here to ask you to support this ordinance for a skill-based workforce because there are so many people out there with talent, experience, and grit who didn't take the traditional college route. They deserve a fair shot at city employment and beyond. Let's open doors, create more pathways, expand opportunities. Let's value different journeys, and make sure hard work... Thank you. skill, and potential count, whether someone has a degree or not. Thank you. All right. Thank you so much. Time has ended on public comment. Today we have two items on the agenda. First, the approval of the April Rule 45 report. Second, 02025-0016662, Amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 2-152, by adding Nuke Section 2-152-151, allowing relevant work experience equivalent to college degree for eligibility for hire to positions in city employment, unless skills required can only be attained through an advanced degree. We will wait on one more member for quorum, so I will call this meeting to recess until, let's go, 1050. Please, committee members, don't go anywhere. We want to get this done today. And I think we will. Alderman Curtis is on his way. He should be here momentarily. So we'll reconvene at 1050. Thank you. of Chicago City Council Rules of Conduct for Public Meetings, 2023 to 2027 pursuant to the Chicago City Council Rules of Order and Procedure, Rule 49, the sergeant at arm sets forth the following rules of conduct to be followed during the public comment period and the duration of all committee and city council meetings, profane, vulgar, threatening, abusive, or disruptive language is not permitted, demeaning, discriminatory, or harassing behavior and speech directed towards others is not permitted, disruptive behavior, including disruptive or disrespectful conduct during others' presentations, is not permitted, banners, flyers, or signage are not permitted, backpacks, large bags, and sharp objects are not permitted, clear bags, not tinted in color, that do not exceed 12 by 12 by 6 inches, will be permitted and are subject to search, health food and beverages, including in metal canisters, are not permitted, cell phones must be placed on silent prior to entering the meeting room, individuals must remain seated, public comment speakers are permitted to stand only when providing public comment, small handheld devices may be used only while seated, and the user must refrain from interfering with the view or hearing of other individuals, individuals or groups failing to adhere to these rules will be asked to cease such disruptive conduct and failure to comply will result in their being subject to removal from the meeting by the sergeant at arms. He's here. All right. We are going to do a quorum call. Alderman Talleyferro was here earlier. He's here. Alderman Yancey. Yancey present. Alderman Hall. Alderman Beale. Alderman Chico. Alderman Chico's present. Alderwoman Ramirez. Alderman Quinn. Alderman Quinn's present. Alderperson Gutierrez co-chair or vice chair. Vice chair Gutierrez is present. Alderman Coleman. Alderman Curtis. Present. Alderman Curtis is present. Chair Rodriguez is here. Alderman Quesada. Alderman Sposado. Alderman Sposado is here. Alderperson Vasquez. Alderwoman Clay. We have eight members present. We have quorum. By rule 59, Alders Hall. Are you there? Yes, I am. And Alderperson Vasquez. Present, chairman. Are also present. That will be reflected. By rule 59, Alders Hall and Vasquez have requested to attend the meeting by remote meeting. due to unrelated emergencies. All those in favor of permitting those two alders to attend remotely today, please respond by saying aye. Any opposed? Any opinion, Chair? The ayes have it. Thank you so much, Guy. You're welcome. Let's see. We have alders Cardona, Villegas, and Riley who were present that are non-members. That will be reflected on the minutes. At this time, oh, forgive me, we did public comments. Our first order of business is approval of the Rule 45 report from April 2025. Every member of the committee should have received a copy of your email. I'll take a motion from Alderman Chico, Alderman Yancey to approve the Rule 45. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Any opinion, Chair? The ayes have it. The second item before the committee today, 02025-0016662, Amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 2-152 by adding new Section 2-152-151, allowing relevant work experience equivalent to a college degree for eligibility for hire to position in city employment unless skills required can only be attained through advanced degree. We have a substitute ordinance on the matter circulating in advance of this meeting. That's SO 2025-0016662. I think Alderman Chico moves to accept the substitute. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed? Any opposed? In the opinion, Chair, the ayes have it. Today, we have several experts available to take questions about this resolution. One in the box, who is Annika Cole from Chicago Jobs Council, and we also have a remote panelist, Chalencia Wade from Opportunity at Work. In addition, we have Mike Howlett from the LRB who helped craft this ordinance, and we have Commissioner Blakemore from the Department of Human Resources, and Ray Phillips-Santos from the Department of Law, if we have any questions. Before we open up the Florida questions, I'd like to give a few minutes each to our expert panelists and our chief sponsor, Alderman Gil-Viegas, to speak on the resolution. Why don't we start with chief sponsor, Alderman Villegas? Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Vice Chairwoman for taking this ordinance up. Good morning, colleagues. As we work to build a more inclusive and effective city workforce, it is time that we recognize the value of experience, training, and college degrees. Strike that. It is time we recognize the value of experience, training, and certifications, not just college degrees when considering candidates for employment. For too long, we've used a college degree as the only measure of qualification, overlooking thousands and thousands of hardworking individuals whose real workforce knowledge, skills, and on-the-job training make them equally, if not more capable. Whether it's a veteran with leadership experience, a tradesperson with specialized certification, or someone who's completed job training programs in our communities, and I would add that veterans make up north of 55% of those that are impacted without college degrees. Their qualifications relative to what many college graduates gain in a classroom. They bring practical problem-solving, discipline, and lived experience exactly what our city needs in its workforce at this time. This ordinance opens the door for those 44% of Chicagoans that don't have college degrees and acknowledge the hard work and expertise they have built and honed throughout their various roles and jobs. I want to thank the tireless advocates who have pushed us to think differently and act more equitably. Specifically, the hard work of opportunity at work, who work to create a labor market where all workers skilled through alternative routes, also known as STARS, can work, learn, and earn to their full potential. Your work has been essential in driving forward policies that value diverse pathways to success and truly reflect the people of Chicago. Together, we're opening doors, broadening opportunity, and making sure that every resident, every resident, regardless of how they got there, has a fair shot at serving our great city. I'd like to also thank those other organizations that were not mentioned. Chicago Jobs Council, Manufacturing Renaissance, Hire 360, Employment and Employer Services, Center for Changing Lives, Her Skolas, Cannabis Equity Illinois Coalition, Community Youth Development Institute, Revolution Workshop, Rise Kit, Hire Heroes USA, Chicago Women in Trades, New Moms, Women Employed Community Assistance Program, and Skill Up Coalition. And at the time, when the time comes, Mr. Chairman, after questions, I would move for a due pass. I'll take that from a committee member. But online, we have an expert on the matter. Actually, their name is Blair Corcoran de Castillo. If you'd like to chime in now, you have a couple minutes. Go right ahead. Can you hear me? Very well. Go ahead. Great. Good morning, Chairman Rodriguez and members of the committee. It's an honor to be here to speak about the ordinance that Alderman Villegas has sponsored, one which seeks to unlock access to opportunity to good city jobs for individuals without a bachelor's degree. My name is Blair Corcoran de Castillo, and I lead the public sector and policy teams at the nonprofit Social Enterprise Opportunity at Work. And like Alderman Villegas said, our mission is to rewire the labor market so that all of the talent that exists across this country can work, learn, and earn to their full potential, especially a group of workers that we refer to as stars. These are workers that are skilled through alternative routes. Stars gain skills in a variety of different ways, through community college, military service, boot camps, and through the public workforce system. And they most commonly gain their skills to the job. They just don't have a bachelor's degree. And stars make up a significant portion of every region's workforce in this country, including in the city of Chicago. Almost half of all working adults, fully 2 million workers in the city are stars. In fact, our analysis suggests that there are 922,000 stars in the city of Chicago who have the skills for higher-wage jobs, if given the opportunity. And what many of us don't realize is that when a job requires a degree, we automatically screen out the majority of most demographic groups. In the city of Chicago, this translates to screening out of 61% of Black workers, 54% of Hispanic or Latino workers, 39% of white workers, 23% of Asian American Pacific Islander workers, and 54% of veteran workers. And over the past 30 years, stars have faced an uphill battle of systemic barriers in the labor market that has contributed to a decline in their economic mobility. And let's be honest, stars have always experienced the labor market differently, but there is really a market change for this generation of workers. Today, it takes more than 30 years for a star to earn the same wage that a bachelor's degree candidate earns on their first day after college. Another way to say that is that we are equating four years of university experience to 30 years of work experience. That is a seismic implication. And so, two years ago, we partnered with the council on Overby to kind of bust some of these myths about stars. And to show employers and stars alike, the skills and value that they bring to the labor market. And that campaign is called tear the paper ceiling. And it's led to a growing movement across the country related to skills-based talent practices. And the sector that has really been the biggest advocate by far has been the public sector. In fact, every level of government and both political parties have gotten behind it. At the federal level, we've seen both administrations, both of the past two administrations support it. At the state level, 26 states, red and blue alike, have torn the paper ceiling. And at the city level, Chicago could join some leading-edge cities like Philadelphia, Madison, Minneapolis, St. Paul, and New York City. And this makes sense because stars are a largely untapped talent source for the public sector, one which has critical hiring shortages and needs. And we know this because when we did research, we found that folks in the public sector hold degrees at a higher rate than their counterparts in the private sector. In fact, state and local government employees hold them at a higher rate than federal employees. And so, by adopting this ordinance, Chicago would be among a small set of leading cities to commit to building a skills-based economy. One that commits to giving anyone with the skills to do the job the opportunity to compete for it, regardless of where they built those skills. Stars are a critical part of the workforce, and it's time to activate them to meet the needs of this moment and the future of this city. Thank you for your time today. And I'm happy to answer any questions we have. Thank you so much. And in person, we have Annika Cole again from the Chicago Jobs Council, if you'd like to share some words. Yes, good morning. Thank you, Chairman Rodriguez, members of the committee. Thank you, Alderman Villegas, for sponsoring this important ordinance. My name is Annika Cole. I'm the policy advocacy manager at Chicago Jobs Council. CJC is a nearly 44-year-old member-based organization whose mission is reimagining our workforce so all people can thrive through employment. Our dozens of organizational members are primarily community-based workforce development service providers all across the state. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to the committee about the critical need to remove barriers for job seekers and tear the paper ceiling here in Chicago. We're in full support of implementing skills-based hiring practices in Chicago through this ordinance introduced by Alderman Villegas to amend Municipal Code Chapter 2-152 by adding new section 2-152-151. Chicago needs strategies to correct the workforce barriers that keep job seekers from getting into work onto career pathways. and contributing to their local communities. This ordinance would remove unnecessary degree requirements from city jobs where workers are well qualified through alternative routes other than a bachelor's degree. People skilled through alternative routes, also referred to as STARS, are adults aged 25 or older who are active in the labor force, hold a high school diploma or equivalent, and have built their skills through avenues like community colleges, apprenticeships, certifications, military service, and often on-the-job experience. These workers are prepared for higher wage work and are held back by outdated hiring practices. We're in full support of implementing the skills-based talent strategy here in Chicago. Workers skilled through alternative routes and the employers who need their abilities remain divided by the paper ceiling, an unseen barrier created by degree requirements. This paper ceiling has sharply reduced upward mobility for STARS, while companies face mounting talent shortages as they struggle to fill millions of positions across the country that are essential for our modern economy. Unfortunately, over the last few decades, STARS have experienced an increasing opportunity gap in our labor market. When a STARS enters the labor force today, it takes more than 30 years to earn the wages that a bachelor's degree worker earns in their first role after college on average. That stunning inequality is new to this generation of workers and has staggering implications on their access to family-sustaining wages and thriving careers, in part because they are STARS with the skills for higher wage work right now. In Chicago, there are nearly 944,000 STARS who could be making 50% more, according to Opportunity at Work. Thanks to the research at Opportunity at Work, we know that while Chicago is similar to other major cities in terms of racial diversity, white workers in Chicago are much more likely to hold a degree relative to other major metro areas, exacerbating the educational attainment gap across workers by race. When a job requires a degree in Chicago, employers automatically screen out 61% of black workers, 54% of Hispanic workers, 39% of white workers, and 23% of Asian American Pacific Islander workers. STARS make up a significant portion of the veteran workforce in the area. 68,000 veteran workers in Chicago metro are STARS, making up 54% of the veteran workforce as a whole. Despite making up more than half of the overall workforce in Chicago metro area, STARS are underrepresented in local government roles. STARS, of the estimated 348,000 local government workers in the region, 124,000 are STARS, just 36% of the public sector workforce. This highlights the significant gap in access to local government jobs for STARS compared to their representation in the broader labor force. Bachelor degree requirements remain a pervasive barrier for job seekers, not because the work necessitates formal education, but because of the outdated hiring practices. Employers and hiring managers often overestimate the percentage of the workforce holding degrees, contributing to misconceptions about the candidate pool. The reality is that STARS have skills needed for many roles, but traditional measures of hiring fail to account for their qualifications. We heard from Naomi, a star who had the skills for higher wage work and got support in job searching, testimonials from other STARS and mock interviews and advising, and now holds a job at Univision. Passing this ordinance would expand talent pools, enabling the city of Chicago to draw from a broader and more diverse group of qualified candidates to meet its workforce needs. Advance equity by providing access to city jobs for nearly half of Chicago's workforce, better reflecting the diversity of the community. And foster inclusion by breaking down systemic barriers and ensuring a fairer labor market. The best workforce development policies must not only consider how we impart workplace navigation and vocational skills, but also address systemic barriers faced by workers and job seekers. We believe that removing unnecessary degree requirements from city jobs is a much needed step in the right direction. We appreciate your consideration of the skills based hiring ordinance set by set worth by Alderman Viegas, Chicago Jobs Council, along with our partners Manufacturing Renaissance, Higher 360, Employment and Employer Services, Opportunity at Work, Center for Changing Lives, Priscolas, Cannabis Equity Illinois Coalition, Community Youth Development Institute, Revolution Workshop, Rise Kit, Higher Heroes USA, Chicago Women in Trades, New Moms, Women Employed, Community Assistance Programs, Skill Up Coalition, and the Chicago Cook Workforce Partnership. Urge all members of the Workforce Development Committee to support the amendment of Municipal Code Chapter 2-152. I urge an aye vote. I will do my best to answer any questions you may have. Thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to share this information with the committee. And thank you very much, Annika Cole and Blair Corcoran de Castillo for your testimony here. Before I go to committee members, I just wanted to say congratulations, Alder Person Viegas, for bringing this forward. This is an important matter. The fact is, is that our economy is changing. Expectations have changed over the past several decades. It seems as though there's been what's been called a race to the top, which really, as far as I'm concerned, is a race to the bottom. You know, essentially creating barriers to entry into fields versus opening opportunity. And I think that's what this is about. I've had conversation with a number of our union partners who are absolutely in support of this. This is a national movement to create more opportunity and breaking down barriers. And I got to say, this is a great effort, and I'm very proud that this is coming through the Workforce Committee. And I once again congratulate all of you for being here today, and to you, Chair Viegas, for bringing this forward to the committee. Thank you. Yeah, great. Exactly. More applause for me. Go right ahead. More applause for the effort, really. To my colleagues on the committee, any questions or comments on the matter? Alderman Sposado, go right ahead. Man, thank you. Yes, Alderman, you're correct. Just a question. Obviously, you all know bragging about my high school diploma all the time. So obviously, it's something I would support. Just a little worried about unintended consequences. So I'd like HR and law to weigh in on this. I'm just, you know, if she mentioned the one gal mentioned 60% black and brown people can't get jobs because of that. So even though we don't look at race anymore, I mean, is that is that something we have to worry about? That that would be my only concern. I believe that work ethic is the most important. I believe, I don't know many people that own businesses, but very rarely do people look at your where your degrees from anymore. They look at work experience and loyalty to the jobs you've had. So, but I'm just more concerned about just a slightly concerned about unintended consequences. So just wondering if law and HR could weigh in on that. One thing I'd add is we haven't mentioned this today, but the state of Illinois has passed a very, very similar language. So there is some precedent being established. It's passed the Senate going to the House and the language is very, very similar. But I'll allow Commissioner Blakemore to speak to the broader question. Good morning. I'm Sandra Blakemore, Commissioner for Department of Human Resources. We really see skill-based hiring and DHR has actually been doing this for several years now. So this ordinance codifies what we've been doing in DHR. And for DHR, when we're looking at applicants, our recruiters do not see any of their demographic information such as age, race, religion, gender. They're looking specifically to the minimum qualifications. And with skill-based hiring, it really diversifies and expands our labor pool. So we're excited about that because with our city employees, only a third of city employees have a college degree. So this not only helps prospective employees, but also helps our current city workforce. You want to hear from law. Ray, do you want to opine? Good morning, right? Ray Phillips-Santos on behalf of the City of Chicago's Department of Law. Alderman Sposato, the Department of Law does not have legal concerns on this ordinance. Very good. Do you have any specific questions beyond that? Well, I'm worried. The one Gail mentioned, 60%, you know, black and brown people can't get jobs. So my question would be, and my concern would be, if even though we don't look at that coming down the road, we see that 60% of the people are getting hired are white people, then could that create a lawsuit if a black or brown person was denied the job because they weren't experienced or educated enough? So as long as there's nothing to worry about, obviously, something I support, I think work ethic is a lost thing in this world nowadays. It's going down and down and down. You're just seeing this council loan about punctuality and everything with our colleagues and everything. So I'm just saying, you know, experience is huge to me and more so a work ethic. So, but if you think we're on salad. and I'm all for it, obviously. Thank you, Alderman. And I'd add, what I heard was also more than a third, almost 40% of white applicants are screened out because of lack of that. So I think it's important to include them as well. We have Alderman Curtis and then Alderman Quinn. No problem. Thank you. Thank you, Chairman. And I want to thank Alderman, Chairman Villegas for bringing this forward. Even though I will always support higher ed, but I believe that for so long, for so many years, there's been so many people that lost the great opportunity for not having that higher ed but have the qualifications. So I am definitely in support of this. I believe that everyone should have a right to the tree of life. So I definitely move to pass when that opportunity comes. Very good. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Quinn. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Question pertaining to within the city of Chicago about promotions. So I agree that this is a good first step. I also believe that institutional knowledge of our workforce is really critical, and I would hope that that would be taken into consideration for promotions and wanted to get some clarity on that. Go ahead, Alderman. Thank you for your question, Alderman Quinn. I, too, am concerned about that as well, and that's why we've been working closely with the organizations as well as HR to put forward a process that takes into consideration. My example is a foreman on a cement crew or a concrete crew, then a managing position opens up. Why aren't we looking at that person who's actually led actual workers, have made critical decisions on infrastructure improvements, but is excluded because of the degree? And so we want to make sure that that's in place. And so we've specifically spoken with HR about taking a look at that. And so HR, as they put these positions up, we're going to be working closely with the departments to see, really, is a degree required for this position in lieu of the experience? I think it's certainly worth a look. We wouldn't want to stunt our own talent's growth because of a lack of a certificate. And let's be honest, the cost of college tuition now is crazy. And we also have to take that into consideration. It's closing in on $100,000 per year in some institutions. So I think this is a good first step. I would support the idea of not stunting our own talent's growth by not having some sort of college. Thank you. So, Alderman Quinn, let me ask the commissioner to panel a bit more on that. Yes. Within the classification and compensation section at the Department of Human Resources, there are professionals who are expert in putting together the job specifications and the educational equivalencies. And as I recently said, we've been doing the equivalencies for several years, but the language was very general. So when I came on board, I said, we have to make it clear for everyone how these equivalencies work. For example, we recently updated the project manager job description. So now it says nine years of project management work experience or an associate degree in seven years or a bachelor's degree in five years. So that it's clear for anyone applying what the mix of work experience and or education you would need for the position. So we're doing that for all of our positions and we'll have that project completed by the end of this year. Thank you, Alderman. Alderman Vasquez online. Go ahead. Yeah. Thank you, Chairman. And thank you to Chairman Villegas for introducing this. This one's pretty personal to me. I'm somebody who I went to UIC, but didn't finish. And so working kind of retail, then management, then heading into the executive as far as a telecoms company where I worked at, I had to get a degree online just to make sure it wasn't keeping me from a promotion or another position. And so when I think about, one, the amount of people who are kept out and not considered for positions or hiring, independent of their actual skill sets or training or experience, we end up losing on amount of talent that is untapped. We know that in some regard, it can be viewed as classes, right? The amount of debt that people take on just to get a degree, to hopefully get a job that then barely pays for the loan that is taken out, isn't a winning, isn't a solution for people looking to get ahead and move up in life. And so I think making these changes and taking into account somebody's experience and skill set, independent of what a piece of paper might say, should be commended. And I think when we talk about how sometimes these jobs in government aren't necessarily as competitive as they can be in the private market, being able to have the opportunity for people who are just trying to start, grow their experience and continue in leadership is something that should be uplifted. And so I just wanted to thank you. I will be fully in support. It means a lot to me to be in a city council that can move this forward. It means a lot to me as a Chicagoan, trying to make sure we have opportunities for people. And as someone who had his own hurdles to try to get to where I am now, I think about younger folks trying to get their start and what this means. So thank you so much. And thank you so much for holding it on the agenda, Chairman. I'll be in support. Thank you, Alderperson Vasquez. Seeing no further hands, there was a motion by Alderman Curtis in favor of passing the item. All those in favor of passing this item, item two on the agenda, please respond by saying aye. Aye. And the opposed, in the opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. Congratulations. And thank you very much for your testimony. And thank you, Commissioner, for being here. I'll report this vote as a recommendation to pass at the next city council on Wednesday, May 21st. With there being no further business before the committee, may I have a motion to adjourn from Vice Chair Gutierrez. All those in favor, signify by saying aye. Any opposed, any opinion of the chairs, the ayes have it. The meeting on committee and workforce development is now adjourned. Good to see you.