Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards meeting, June 11, 2024
- When: Tue, Jun 11, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928576/video/956121241
- Transcript: full text (29,879 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 27:40 Map amendment for 3631-3657 N. Central and 5547-5557 W. Waveland
- 1:00:41 Re-referral of ordinance to the Committee on Housing and Real Estate under Rule 37
- 1:01:12 Ordinance on registration and regulation of vacant or abandoned commercial storefronts (substitute)
- 1:01:55 Anthony V. Napolitano: Presented the vacant storefront ordinance as eight months in the making, aimed at…
- 1:04:46 Brian Hopkins: Supported the vacant storefront ordinance, questioned the assumption that many landlords…
- 1:07:20 David H. Moore: Said in his ward some owners leave properties vacant for years without trying to lease and…
- 1:09:06 Anthony V. Napolitano: Said the registry would give police and the building department a contact for owners…
- 1:11:42 David H. Moore: Asked what tools exist to compel owners to lease vacant buildings and said he would work…
- 1:14:16 Byron Sigcho-López: Supported the vacant storefront registry, citing unknown LLC owners and rising property…
- 1:16:48 Daniel La Spata: Praised the vacant storefront ordinance as workable across very different commercial…
- 1:17:59 Ruth Cruz: Supported the vacant storefront ordinance, saying some owners tell prospective tenants they make…
- 1:19:26 Pat Dowell: Supported the storefront registry and sign removal requirement and asked how fees and exterior…
- 1:23:02 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether the storefront ordinance applies to storefronts not zoned for commercial use…
- 1:27:05 Bennett R. Lawson: Thanked the sponsor, the building department and business groups for their work on the…
- 1:27:36 Landmark fee waivers in the 4th and 35th Wards
- 1:28:11 Large signs over 100 square feet or 24 feet above grade
- 1:30:14 9th Ward map amendments in the Kensington/Roseland area (11 files)
- 1:38:35 Daniel La Spata: Asked why RT-4 zoning was proposed for 9th Ward lots and what housing type was planned.
- 1:40:36 11th Ward map amendment at W. 40th Place, W. 41st Street and S. Wallace Street
- 1:41:20 Nicole T. Lee: Explained her 11th Ward map amendment as creating zoning conformity in a mixed residential…
- 1:42:41 23rd Ward map amendment at 5353 S. Archer Avenue (B3-1 to RS-2)
- 1:43:08 Silvana Tabares: Said a civic association requested downzoning the former muffler shop site at 5353 S.…
- 1:43:44 Daniel La Spata: Asked whether the 5353 S. Archer downzoning would make the storefront nonconforming and was…
- 1:45:19 Silvana Tabares: Responded to the no vote by saying she was responding to a letter from the civic…
- 1:45:41 26th Ward map amendment at 2533-2537 W. Division for Puerto Rican arts and culture archives center
- 1:49:21 Jessica L. Fuentes: Supported rezoning for the Puerto Rican arts and culture archives center as preserving…
- 1:51:04 26th Ward map amendment at 2626 W. Division for community center
- 1:52:33 Jessica L. Fuentes: Supported the 2626 W. Division community center to replace a demolished Puerto Rican…
- 1:56:00 1st Ward map amendment at 2418-2426 N. Milwaukee Avenue (Hollander storage building redevelopment)
- 2:02:54 Pat Dowell: Asked what working toward a diverse group of residents meant beyond the 12 on-site affordable…
- 2:04:51 32nd Ward planned development amendment at 2746 N. Clybourn Avenue (Costco)
- 2:09:46 Subject matter hearing on citywide accessory dwelling unit ordinance
- 2:59:47 Pat Dowell: Questioned whether ADUs produce affordable housing based on the data presented and asked about…
- 3:09:30 Bennett R. Lawson: Said companion ordinances on incentives and affordability for ADUs are expected.
- 3:10:43 Walter R. Burnett: Asked how conversion units work in larger buildings and in business and commercial…
- 3:13:49 Walter R. Burnett: Asked whether coach houses could be built in townhouse developments and about fire safety…
- 3:17:54 Walter R. Burnett: Supported the ADU expansion, saying it would help affordability, and acknowledged…
- 3:23:44 Bennett R. Lawson: Said more work remains after the ADU ordinance passes.
- 3:23:54 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked what city programs could help small homeowners pay for basement and coach house…
- 3:27:15 Byron Sigcho-López: Repeated his call for a subject matter hearing with the assessor ahead of budget season.
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards heard public comment largely in support of expanding accessory dwelling units (ADUs) citywide, along with comments on the vacant storefront ordinance, a Puerto Rican archives center rezoning and 9th Ward rezonings. The committee passed as amended an ordinance creating registration and maintenance requirements for vacant ground-floor storefronts in occupied buildings, after members discussed bad actors, existing vacant building rules and zoning conflicts. It also passed landmark fee waivers, large sign permits, a set of 9th Ward rezonings near the planned Red Line extension, map amendments in the 11th, 23rd, 26th and 1st Wards, and a planned development amendment for the Costco site at 2746 N. Clybourn, with one item deferred and one ordinance re-referred to the Committee on Housing and Real Estate. The meeting closed with a subject-matter hearing, with no vote, on an ordinance to expand the ADU pilot citywide, where city staff reported pilot results and members asked about affordability, incentives for the South and West sides, and coach house rules.
Topics: accessory dwelling units, vacant storefronts, map amendments, Red Line extension area rezoning, Puerto Rican cultural facilities, Logan Square development, Costco planned development, large signs, landmark fee waivers, affordable housing
Agenda items discussed
- 27:40 Map amendment for 3631-3657 N. Central and 5547-5557 W. Waveland: deferred
- 1:00:41 Re-referral of ordinance to the Committee on Housing and Real Estate under Rule 37: passed
- 1:01:12 Ordinance on registration and regulation of vacant or abandoned commercial storefronts (substitute): passed
- 1:27:36 Landmark fee waivers in the 4th and 35th Wards: passed
- 1:28:11 Large signs over 100 square feet or 24 feet above grade: passed
- 1:30:14 9th Ward map amendments in the Kensington/Roseland area (11 files): passed
- 1:40:36 11th Ward map amendment at W. 40th Place, W. 41st Street and S. Wallace Street: passed
- 1:42:41 23rd Ward map amendment at 5353 S. Archer Avenue (B3-1 to RS-2): passed
- 1:45:41 26th Ward map amendment at 2533-2537 W. Division for Puerto Rican arts and culture archives center: passed
- 1:51:04 26th Ward map amendment at 2626 W. Division for community center: passed
- 1:56:00 1st Ward map amendment at 2418-2426 N. Milwaukee Avenue (Hollander storage building redevelopment): passed
- 2:04:51 32nd Ward planned development amendment at 2746 N. Clybourn Avenue (Costco): passed
- 2:09:46 Subject matter hearing on citywide accessory dwelling unit ordinance (SO2024-0008918): discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Bennett R. Lawson (chair): Thanked the sponsor, the building department and business groups for their work on the vacant storefront ordinance and said it may need tweaks. (1:27:05); Said companion ordinances on incentives and affordability for ADUs are expected. (3:09:30); Said more work remains after the ADU ordinance passes. (3:23:44)
- Anthony V. Napolitano (alderperson): Presented the vacant storefront ordinance as eight months in the making, aimed at owners who keep storefronts vacant on purpose, and said it was scaled back after stakeholder talks. (1:01:55); Said the registry would give police and the building department a contact for owners of dark storefronts used for unpermitted parties. (1:09:06)
- Brian Hopkins (alderperson): Supported the vacant storefront ordinance, questioned the assumption that many landlords prefer vacancy, and suggested allowing permitted advertising on vacant storefront windows. (1:04:46)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said in his ward some owners leave properties vacant for years without trying to lease and asked how the ordinance would help with an unopened new building. (1:07:20); Asked what tools exist to compel owners to lease vacant buildings and said he would work with the buildings commissioner on possible legislation, while supporting the ordinance. (1:11:42)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Supported the vacant storefront registry, citing unknown LLC owners and rising property taxes in Pilsen, and called for a subject matter hearing with the assessor. (1:14:16); Asked what city programs could help small homeowners pay for basement and coach house repairs needed to create ADUs. (3:23:54); Repeated his call for a subject matter hearing with the assessor ahead of budget season. (3:27:15)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Praised the vacant storefront ordinance as workable across very different commercial corridors. (1:16:48); Asked why RT-4 zoning was proposed for 9th Ward lots and what housing type was planned. (1:38:35); Asked whether the 5353 S. Archer downzoning would make the storefront nonconforming and was meant to compel the owner's cooperation, and asked to be recorded as a no vote. (1:43:44)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Supported the vacant storefront ordinance, saying some owners tell prospective tenants they make more money keeping storefronts empty. (1:17:59)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Supported the storefront registry and sign removal requirement and asked how fees and exterior maintenance rules compare to the vacant building ordinance. (1:19:26); Asked what working toward a diverse group of residents meant beyond the 12 on-site affordable units. (2:02:54); Questioned whether ADUs produce affordable housing based on the data presented and asked about subsidy use, affordability enforcement and incentives for the South and West sides. (2:59:47)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked whether the storefront ordinance applies to storefronts not zoned for commercial use and raised concern about penalizing owners who cannot lease due to downzoning. (1:23:02); Explained her 11th Ward map amendment as creating zoning conformity in a mixed residential and former manufacturing area. (1:41:20)
- Silvana Tabares (alderperson): Said a civic association requested downzoning the former muffler shop site at 5353 S. Archer to get community input on its future use. (1:43:08); Responded to the no vote by saying she was responding to a letter from the civic association and nearby residents. (1:45:19)
- Jessica L. Fuentes (alderperson): Supported rezoning for the Puerto Rican arts and culture archives center as preserving the community's historical memory and noted a land sale will go before the housing committee. (1:49:21); Supported the 2626 W. Division community center to replace a demolished Puerto Rican community center for seniors. (1:52:33)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Asked how conversion units work in larger buildings and in business and commercial districts, including ground-floor rear units and special use requirements. (3:10:43); Asked whether coach houses could be built in townhouse developments and about fire safety rules. (3:13:49); Supported the ADU expansion, saying it would help affordability, and acknowledged concerns about financial assistance for some communities. (3:17:54)
Exchanges between members
- 1:04:46 Hopkins commended the sponsor for bringing and improving the vacant storefront ordinance.
- 1:07:05 Moore thanked Napolitano and asked how the ordinance would help with a vacant new building in his ward.
- 1:07:24 Moore pushed back on Hopkins's view, saying some landlords in his ward do keep properties vacant on purpose.
- 1:09:06 Napolitano answered Moore that the registry would provide an owner contact.
- 1:09:22 Napolitano said he agreed with Hopkins that bad actors are a smaller portion of owners.
- 1:14:16 Sigcho-López thanked Napolitano for working with the administration on the ordinance.
- 1:15:15 Sigcho-López said he agreed with Hopkins that the ordinance does not apply to most owners.
- 1:16:48 La Spata praised Napolitano for the ordinance.
- 1:17:59 Cruz thanked Napolitano for the ordinance and his collaboration.
- 1:19:26 Dowell thanked Napolitano for the ordinance.
- 1:19:37 Dowell said she agreed with Moore about looking at properties whose owners are not seeking to rent.
- 1:23:10 Lee asked Napolitano questions about storefronts not zoned for commercial use.
- 1:27:05 Lawson thanked Napolitano for his work on the ordinance.
- 1:43:44 La Spata asked Tabares whether the downzoning would make the storefront nonconforming.
- 1:45:19 Tabares responded to La Spata's no vote by citing her community's request.
- 1:55:06 La Spata asked about the planned uses for the 2626 W. Division site, directed to Fuentes or her staff.
- 2:03:16 La Spata answered Dowell's question about affordability and family-sized units at the Milwaukee Avenue project.
- 3:09:30 Lawson told Dowell companion ordinances on incentives and affordability are coming.
- 3:18:07 Burnett said he understood Dowell's concern about financial assistance for building ADUs.
- 3:24:19 Sigcho-López echoed Dowell's call for incentives to help small homeowners.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error