City Council meeting, April 19, 2024
- When: Fri, Apr 19, 2024, 12:45 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Body: full City Council
- Video: https://vimeo.com/936019849
- Transcript: full text (31,341 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 22:07 Approval of remote participation by members under Rule 59
- 55:58 Gilbert Villegas: Presented the committee report recommending a Class L tax incentive.
- 56:10 Class L tax incentive for a property in the 11th Ward (Committee on Economic, Capital and Technology…
- 58:48 Substitute ordinance amending the 2024 annual appropriation ordinance within Fund 925 (grant-funded…
- 1:00:03 Anthony Beale: Asked that the chair clarify which item was being voted on, saying members were hearing only…
- 1:02:05 Jason C. Ervin: Explained that the Fund 925 amendment adds 2024 grant funding for several departments and…
- 1:05:36 Ordinance amending the 2024 appropriation ordinance to add $70 million for new arrivals
- 1:06:27 Anthony Beale: Said he opposed appropriating $70 million, recalling that he had said in November the budget…
- 1:08:47 Anthony Beale: Said he appreciated the governor and county board president but questioned why migrants were…
- 1:17:27 James M. Gardiner: Recalled the $150 million set aside for migrants in the 2024 budget at about $35 million…
- 1:18:13 James M. Gardiner: Said he expected further requests later in the year and questioned how much of the money…
- 1:19:11 James M. Gardiner: Predicted property tax increases in future years.
- 1:21:05 Byron Sigcho-López: Described opposition to the funding as bigotry and ignorance and contrasted it with a…
- 1:21:57 Byron Sigcho-López: Attributed the arrival of migrants to the Texas governor's busing rather than to the city.
- 1:22:29 Byron Sigcho-López: Said immigrants contribute and pay into the system.
- 1:26:26 David H. Moore: Said public commenters supporting the funding and opposing ShotSpotter did not represent the…
- 1:26:51 David H. Moore: Described residents who want to help migrants but tell him to vote no because they are not…
- 1:27:55 David H. Moore: Cited delays in a home repair program, a field house and an expired SSA as examples of unmet…
- 1:32:58 Nicole T. Lee: Described migrants gathering at her ward's police station and conditions at the Halsted…
- 1:33:23 Nicole T. Lee: Said the city needs to manage the money better and that shelter rates were too high for the…
- 1:34:19 Nicole T. Lee: Said the $70 million would help the city work with the county and state and called for…
- 1:37:18 Raymond A. Lopez: Recognized undocumented residents in his ward who he said never received city assistance.
- 1:38:35 Raymond A. Lopez: Said the federal government bears responsibility for the asylum process and that…
- 1:41:36 Raymond A. Lopez: Cited the death of a child in a city shelter and unsanitary conditions as failures of the…
- 1:50:14 Jessica L. Fuentes: Noted the council was voting on both the $70 million and the $1.25 billion bond for…
- 1:51:32 Jessica L. Fuentes: Cited 3,200 children in the shelter system and over 17,000 enrolled in CPS.
- 1:53:23 Jessica L. Fuentes: Disputed a colleague's statement about crime in Venezuela as not factual.
- 1:57:01 Michael D. Rodriguez: Thanked a public commenter for running a shelter in a former CVS in his ward.
- 1:58:32 Michael D. Rodriguez: Told the story of a migrant family he met at a park district shelter who later found…
- 2:00:53 Michael D. Rodriguez: Said the city would be joining the county and state in funding the migrant response…
- 2:02:43 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said concerns raised by colleagues about long-term residents not being served were not…
- 2:05:08 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said the busing was intended to divide the city ahead of the Democratic convention and…
- 2:06:54 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said he shared concerns about accountability and transparency in managing the response.
- 2:12:55 Scott Waguespack: Said a colleague's labeling of members as bigots was inappropriate and must stop.
- 2:14:20 Scott Waguespack: Said he got no response when he asked about electronic monitoring of men in a migrant…
- 2:15:40 Scott Waguespack: Said the 2024 budget was not done honestly and he had voted against it.
- 2:18:25 Desmon C. Yancy: Said Black Chicagoans were being put in a lose-lose position on the migrant funding.
- 2:19:05 Desmon C. Yancy: Said the South Shore ZIP code has more resettled migrants than any other and described…
- 2:20:24 Desmon C. Yancy: Said the $70 million unlocks state and county money and that voting no would not stop…
- 2:22:19 Emma Mitts: Said her concern was about disinvestment and racism affecting Black communities, not about…
- 2:24:05 Emma Mitts: Said she helped migrants early on but did not see similar help for Black residents in her ward.
- 2:25:19 Emma Mitts: Said she would vote no because no one had helped her community.
- 2:28:51 Jason C. Ervin: Said the city has an obligation to address the challenges and that $70 million is small…
- 2:30:30 Jason C. Ervin: Said division among members weakens the council and pledged to work with all caucuses on the…
- 2:37:11 Substitute ordinance authorizing $1.25 billion in general obligation and/or sales tax securitization bonds…
- 2:37:35 Pat Dowell: Called for a vote on the substitute ordinance authorizing $1.25 billion in bonds for housing and…
- 2:40:55 William Conway: Said he supports spurring housing development but had sought a smaller $350 million pilot in…
- 2:41:41 William Conway: Said the city is in perilous financial shape and proposed limiting the authorization to $750…
- 2:42:36 Alderperson William Conway motion to amend the bond authorization to $750 million (laid on the table)
- 2:49:29 Samantha Nugent: Said she supports using expired TIF revenue to back bonds without raising taxes.
- 2:49:50 Samantha Nugent: Said the $5 million threshold for council review is too high and asked how lost TIF…
- 2:50:58 Samantha Nugent: Said she would vote no because of insufficient oversight and transparency, adding that a…
- 2:51:29 Maria E. Hadden: Said she would support the bond ordinance and commended Housing and Planning staff.
- 2:51:59 Maria E. Hadden: Said wards without TIFs, like hers, face inequity and would benefit from the bond funds.
- 2:53:39 Maria E. Hadden: Said the $5 million threshold is appropriate given capital costs and that pilots and time…
- 2:57:32 Gilbert Villegas: Listed requests the administration did not commit to, including a lower threshold,…
- 3:00:13 Gilbert Villegas: Said his experience with the capital bill taught him projects must be line-itemed, and…
- 3:03:14 Brendan Reilly: Said he shared colleagues' concerns and that the $5 million cap for council approval is far…
- 3:04:27 Brendan Reilly: Said council review over $1 million would let the public see projects before approval and…
- 3:05:27 Alderperson Brendan Reilly motion to lower the council-approval threshold from $5 million to $1 million…
- 3:05:27 Brendan Reilly: Moved under Rule 29 to amend section 2.19 H to replace $5 million with $1 million.
- 3:09:53 Walter R. Burnett: Said he supports the bond and that many of the expiring TIFs backing it are in his ward.
- 3:12:17 Walter R. Burnett: Said expiring TIFs return money to other taxing bodies and that wards without TIFs have…
- 3:15:19 Walter R. Burnett: Said the expiring funds would return to the corporate fund anyway and compared the debate…
- 3:29:42 Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez motion to lower the council-approval threshold from $5 million to $2.5 million…
- 3:43:04 Daniel La Spata: Explained that he made the motions to table because he fully supports the bond ordinance,…
- 3:44:13 Pat Dowell: Said there are more projects than money and over 140 applications awaiting bond financing.
- 3:45:29 Pat Dowell: Described changes made, including quarterly reporting, a public data portal and council review…
- 3:53:08 Ordinance setting the next regular meeting for May 22, 2024
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The City Council took up three pieces of unfinished business that had been deferred and published on April 17, 2024, after a public comment period in which most speakers urged approval of funding for new arrivals and several also spoke about the ShotSpotter contract. A substitute ordinance amending Fund 925 of the 2024 appropriation passed 48 to 0. After extended debate, an ordinance amending the 2024 appropriation to add $70 million for the migrant response passed 30 to 18. The council then debated a substitute ordinance authorizing $1.25 billion in general obligation and/or securitization bonds for housing and economic development; motions by Alderpersons Conway, Reilly and Lopez to reduce the total authorization or the $5 million council-review threshold were each laid on the table, and the ordinance passed 32 to 17. A Class L tax incentive from the Committee on Economic, Capital and Technology Development also passed by voice vote, and the next meeting was set for May 22, 2024.
Topics: Migrant funding, 2024 budget amendment, Housing and economic development bonds, TIF, Council oversight threshold, Transparency, Public comment, ShotSpotter, Class L tax incentive
Agenda items discussed
- 22:07 Approval of remote participation by members under Rule 59: passed
- 56:10 Class L tax incentive for a property in the 11th Ward (Committee on Economic, Capital and Technology Development): passed
- 58:48 Substitute ordinance amending the 2024 annual appropriation ordinance within Fund 925 (grant-funded additions for Housing, Public Health, Disabilities, Family and Support Services, Police and Water): passed
- 1:05:36 Ordinance amending the 2024 appropriation ordinance to add $70 million for new arrivals: passed
- 2:37:11 Substitute ordinance authorizing $1.25 billion in general obligation and/or sales tax securitization bonds for housing and economic development: passed
- 2:42:36 Alderperson William Conway motion to amend the bond authorization to $750 million (laid on the table): failed
- 3:05:27 Alderperson Brendan Reilly motion to lower the council-approval threshold from $5 million to $1 million (laid on the table): failed
- 3:29:42 Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez motion to lower the council-approval threshold from $5 million to $2.5 million (laid on the table): failed
- 3:53:08 Ordinance setting the next regular meeting for May 22, 2024: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked that the chair clarify which item was being voted on, saying members were hearing only numbers without the language. (1:00:03); Said he opposed appropriating $70 million, recalling that he had said in November the budget was not balanced and money would run out by April. (1:06:27); Said he appreciated the governor and county board president but questioned why migrants were concentrated in Chicago rather than elsewhere in the county and state. (1:08:47)
- James M. Gardiner (alderperson): Recalled the $150 million set aside for migrants in the 2024 budget at about $35 million a month and said the new $70 million request was predictable. (1:17:27); Said he expected further requests later in the year and questioned how much of the money went to administrative costs and contractors. (1:18:13); Predicted property tax increases in future years. (1:19:11)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Described opposition to the funding as bigotry and ignorance and contrasted it with a 2019 vote for $2.3 billion for two developers. (1:21:05); Attributed the arrival of migrants to the Texas governor's busing rather than to the city. (1:21:57); Said immigrants contribute and pay into the system. (1:22:29)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said public commenters supporting the funding and opposing ShotSpotter did not represent the affected communities. (1:26:26); Described residents who want to help migrants but tell him to vote no because they are not seeing investment in their own community. (1:26:51); Cited delays in a home repair program, a field house and an expired SSA as examples of unmet ward needs. (1:27:55)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Described migrants gathering at her ward's police station and conditions at the Halsted shelter, including illness outbreaks and a child's death. (1:32:58); Said the city needs to manage the money better and that shelter rates were too high for the service provided. (1:33:23); Said the $70 million would help the city work with the county and state and called for transparency and a unified shelter system. (1:34:19)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Recognized undocumented residents in his ward who he said never received city assistance. (1:37:18); Said the federal government bears responsibility for the asylum process and that Democratic-led cities were also sending people to Chicago. (1:38:35); Cited the death of a child in a city shelter and unsanitary conditions as failures of the city. (1:41:36)
- Jessica L. Fuentes (alderperson): Noted the council was voting on both the $70 million and the $1.25 billion bond for housing and economic development. (1:50:14); Cited 3,200 children in the shelter system and over 17,000 enrolled in CPS. (1:51:32); Disputed a colleague's statement about crime in Venezuela as not factual. (1:53:23)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson): Thanked a public commenter for running a shelter in a former CVS in his ward. (1:57:01); Told the story of a migrant family he met at a park district shelter who later found work. (1:58:32); Said the city would be joining the county and state in funding the migrant response and urged colleagues to vote yes. (2:00:53)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Said concerns raised by colleagues about long-term residents not being served were not bigotry and colleagues' values should not be questioned. (2:02:43); Said the busing was intended to divide the city ahead of the Democratic convention and would not stop regardless of the vote. (2:05:08); Said he shared concerns about accountability and transparency in managing the response. (2:06:54)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Said a colleague's labeling of members as bigots was inappropriate and must stop. (2:12:55); Said he got no response when he asked about electronic monitoring of men in a migrant shelter in his ward. (2:14:20); Said the 2024 budget was not done honestly and he had voted against it. (2:15:40)
- Desmon C. Yancy (alderperson): Said Black Chicagoans were being put in a lose-lose position on the migrant funding. (2:18:25); Said the South Shore ZIP code has more resettled migrants than any other and described housing cost burdens there. (2:19:05); Said the $70 million unlocks state and county money and that voting no would not stop arrivals, so he would support it. (2:20:24)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Said her concern was about disinvestment and racism affecting Black communities, not about migrants. (2:22:19); Said she helped migrants early on but did not see similar help for Black residents in her ward. (2:24:05); Said she would vote no because no one had helped her community. (2:25:19)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Explained that the Fund 925 amendment adds 2024 grant funding for several departments and was not the $70 million appropriation. (1:02:05); Said the city has an obligation to address the challenges and that $70 million is small relative to a $16.5 billion budget. (2:28:51); Said division among members weakens the council and pledged to work with all caucuses on the challenges colleagues raised. (2:30:30)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Called for a vote on the substitute ordinance authorizing $1.25 billion in bonds for housing and economic development. (2:37:35); Said there are more projects than money and over 140 applications awaiting bond financing. (3:44:13); Described changes made, including quarterly reporting, a public data portal and council review above $5 million, and said a $1 million threshold would burden development. (3:45:29)
- William Conway (alderperson): Said he supports spurring housing development but had sought a smaller $350 million pilot in committee. (2:40:55); Said the city is in perilous financial shape and proposed limiting the authorization to $750 million covering the current term. (2:41:41)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Explained that he made the motions to table because he fully supports the bond ordinance, its staff and its transparency mechanisms. (3:43:04)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Said she supports using expired TIF revenue to back bonds without raising taxes. (2:49:29); Said the $5 million threshold for council review is too high and asked how lost TIF infrastructure funding would be replaced. (2:49:50); Said she would vote no because of insufficient oversight and transparency, adding that a website is not a substitute for council review. (2:50:58)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Said she would support the bond ordinance and commended Housing and Planning staff. (2:51:29); Said wards without TIFs, like hers, face inequity and would benefit from the bond funds. (2:51:59); Said the $5 million threshold is appropriate given capital costs and that pilots and time limits add bureaucracy. (2:53:39)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Presented the committee report recommending a Class L tax incentive. (55:58); Listed requests the administration did not commit to, including a lower threshold, apprenticeship requirements, corridor set-asides and an oversight advisory council. (2:57:32); Said his experience with the capital bill taught him projects must be line-itemed, and said he would vote no. (3:00:13)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said he shared colleagues' concerns and that the $5 million cap for council approval is far too high. (3:03:14); Said council review over $1 million would let the public see projects before approval and would not slow the program. (3:04:27); Moved under Rule 29 to amend section 2.19 H to replace $5 million with $1 million. (3:05:27)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Said he supports the bond and that many of the expiring TIFs backing it are in his ward. (3:09:53); Said expiring TIFs return money to other taxing bodies and that wards without TIFs have few development resources. (3:12:17); Said the expiring funds would return to the corporate fund anyway and compared the debate to council wars. (3:15:19)
- Carlos Ramírez-Rosa (alderperson): Said he supported the $1.25 billion bond, calling housing a human right and the bond a result of TIF reform advocacy. (3:39:03); Described the planned $625 million each for Housing and for Planning and Development programs. (3:39:30)
Exchanges between members
- 1:00:03 Beale asked through the chair which item Ervin's motion concerned.
- 1:02:05 Ervin explained that the item was the Fund 925 grant amendment, not the $70 million.
- 1:17:48 Gardiner cited Beale's point about the budget running out of money.
- 2:02:43 Vasquez said the concerns Beale raised about long-term residents were not bigotry.
- 2:02:43 Vasquez said the concerns Moore raised about long-term residents were not bigotry.
- 2:02:43 Vasquez said Gardiner's point about funds not reaching migrants or residents was not bigotry.
- 2:02:43 Vasquez said the concerns Lopez raised about long-term residents were not bigotry.
- 2:15:50 Waguespack referred to Beale's point in explaining his vote against the 2024 budget.
- 2:30:51 Ervin said the council must work together on the challenges Mitts described.
- 2:30:51 Ervin said the council must work together on the challenges Lopez described.
- 2:40:12 Beale asked Sigcho-López for a public apology for name calling.
- 3:03:14 Reilly said he shared Conway's concerns and interest in a smaller initial tranche.
- 3:03:14 Reilly said he shared Beale's concerns about the threshold.
- 3:03:14 Reilly said he shared Nugent's concerns about transparency.
- 3:03:14 Reilly said he shared Villegas's concerns about the bond ordinance.
- 3:13:16 Burnett called Moore's comments about areas without TIFs articulate.
- 3:22:43 Lopez said he agreed with much of Burnett's speech but took issue with the claim that the administration was willing to work with members.
- 3:25:02 Lopez thanked Dowell for removing language from the original bill that excluded the council.
Roll-call votes at this meeting
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error