Committee on Finance meeting, July 14, 2025
- When: Mon, Jul 14, 2025, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Finance
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1100395634
- Transcript: full text (61,807 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 37:27 Communication transmitting June 2025 reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements
- 38:04 Settlement: Felicia Nolls Bradley v. City of Chicago ($400,000, sidewalk trip and fall)
- 41:54 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked how many trip-hazard 311 requests are outstanding and what CDOT and the Law…
- 45:33 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked for data on how many sidewalk complaints become lawsuits and settlements and called…
- 49:36 Daniel La Spata: Said committee staff found roughly 29,000 outstanding sidewalk inspection complaints,…
- 50:49 Raymond A. Lopez: Pointed to the year-to-date settlement report showing repeated sidewalk payouts and said…
- 52:57 Gilbert Villegas: Said CDOT budgets about $5-6 million for sidewalks against an estimated $14 million need…
- 54:03 Nicholas Sposato: Said it may take money to save money and suggested investing to fix trip hazards to avoid…
- 54:52 Brendan Reilly: Requested total trip-and-fall settlement payouts for 2024 and 2025 year to date.
- 55:33 Settlement: Gilbert Mendes v. City of Chicago ($2.5 million, search warrant execution)
- 1:04:37 Nicholas Sposato: Asked how long guns were allegedly pointed in the Mendes case, saying he would support the…
- 1:06:03 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked why the Mendes settlement involving four people is smaller than an earlier $2.9…
- 1:07:03 Settlement: Marley Aguilar v. Eric Duron ($3 million, person struck by police vehicle)
- 1:11:03 William Conway: Asked whether police recovered contraband during the Aguilar chase.
- 1:12:54 Pat Dowell: Asked the age and prior criminal history of the plaintiff in the Aguilar case, and was told he…
- 1:16:04 Settlement: Jackie Wilson v. John Burge et al. ($12.7 million, wrongful conviction)
- 1:24:06 William Conway: Recused himself from the Wilson settlement under Rule 14, citing past work with the former…
- 1:24:51 Nicholas Sposato: Asked about the relationship between the Wilson brothers and whether Jackie Wilson knew…
- 1:26:24 Settlement: Roberto Almodovar v. former police detective ($17 million, wrongful conviction)
- 1:31:33 Brendan Reilly: Asked whether outside counsel handled the Almodovar case and the cost, and was given an…
- 1:32:03 Gilbert Villegas: Estimated pending reverse-conviction cases could cost half a billion dollars or more and…
- 1:33:36 Pat Dowell: Said how to pay for settlements, whether by bonds or other revenue, would have to be addressed…
- 1:35:27 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said accountability is needed to prevent future misconduct cases and asked how…
- 1:37:30 Daniel La Spata: Asked the chair to confirm that general obligation bond proceeds are not being moved to pay…
- 1:38:09 Pat Dowell: Clarified that bonding for settlements has been discussed among some members but has not happened.
- 1:39:04 Ordinance requiring a two-thirds Council vote for issuance of bonds and other indebtedness (Item 9)
- 1:39:45 Marty Quinn: Presented the ordinance to raise the vote needed for city borrowing from 26 to 34, citing a…
- 1:43:33 Anthony Beale: Supported the two-thirds ordinance, saying a 26-vote threshold enables trading of ward…
- 1:48:12 Matthew J. O'Shea: Supported the two-thirds ordinance, saying residents do not trust government and…
- 1:55:54 Scott Waguespack: Supported the two-thirds ordinance without a voter-approval step, saying Council should…
- 1:59:54 William Conway: Supported the two-thirds ordinance, describing the $830 million infrastructure bond's…
- 2:01:51 Monique L. Scott: Supported the two-thirds ordinance as promoting transparency, accountability and best…
- 2:03:06 Daniel La Spata: Opposed the two-thirds ordinance, noting large comparison cities use simple majorities and…
- 2:06:36 Marty Quinn: Submitted for the record information on Los Angeles and Texas laws on debt approval.
- 2:06:51 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked whether any briefings had been held on the two-thirds ordinance before documents…
- 2:08:27 Anthony Beale: Asked the Finance Department's debt manager where his information on other cities came from.
- 2:09:03 Jason C. Ervin: Opposed the two-thirds ordinance, saying most city debt stems from past pension decisions,…
- 2:12:43 Brian Hopkins: Supported the two-thirds ordinance on its merits, noting a 30% rise in per capita debt in the…
- 2:15:39 Gilbert Villegas: Supported the two-thirds ordinance as allowing more discussion and transparency on bonds…
- 2:18:33 Debra L. Silverstein: Said she is worried about city finances and will vote yes on the two-thirds ordinance.
- 2:19:21 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said he would not support the two-thirds ordinance at this time, arguing a higher vote…
- 2:23:19 Timothy R. Knudsen: Said months of negotiation with the CFO's office on an amendment limiting bond interest…
- 2:25:28 Byron Sigcho-López: Opposed voting on the two-thirds ordinance without subject matter hearings or discussion…
- 2:29:27 Brendan Reilly: Supported the two-thirds ordinance, noting the state requires a supermajority for debt and…
- 2:35:09 Nicole T. Lee: Said she voted against the $830 million bond but was conflicted on the two-thirds ordinance,…
- 2:36:12 Jason C. Ervin: Explained that bond repayment levies appear in the budget as expenses but bond issuances are…
- 2:39:58 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said she agreed more communication is needed but questioned supporters' past votes on…
- 2:42:51 Silvana Tabares: As a non-member, supported the two-thirds ordinance as good government that would require…
- 2:43:49 Anthony V. Napolitano: As a non-member, supported the two-thirds ordinance, saying a larger vote threshold…
- 2:51:12 Redevelopment agreement and TIF funds for Black Ensemble Theater, 4440-4450 N. Clark St., 47th Ward (Item 6)
- 3:00:03 Matthew J. Martin: Asked for support of the Black Ensemble Theater TIF agreement, describing the theater as…
- 3:04:15 Appointment of Michael Belsky as City Comptroller (Item 3)
- 3:16:30 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked the Comptroller nominee's top priority and urged filling 55 revenue-generating…
- 3:29:45 Jason C. Ervin: Supported the Comptroller appointment and stressed the need for timely, accurate accounting…
- 3:35:00 Derrick G. Curtis: Supported the Comptroller appointment and raised semi trucks parking on residential…
- 3:36:18 Scott Waguespack: Supported the Comptroller appointment and making financial practices understandable to the…
- 3:37:07 David H. Moore: Said he would support the Comptroller appointment but had heard concerns, and asked the…
- 3:43:24 Brian Hopkins: Supported the Comptroller appointment and commended the mayor for the nomination.
- 3:45:42 Byron Sigcho-López: Supported the Comptroller appointment and urged relief for seniors, low-income families…
- 3:54:33 Amendment to section 7-28 allowing seniors to keep the senior garbage discount when enrolled in Utility…
- 4:09:12 Substitute ordinance amending Chapter 2-44 regarding debt-lien and demolition-lien assignments (Item 5)
- 4:28:06 Anthony Beale: Asked how the lien ordinance prevents bad actors from transferring property to associates and…
- 4:45:39 David H. Moore: Asked how the lien ordinance relates to the existing housing court forfeiture process.
- 4:55:12 David H. Moore: Asked how the lien tools work when a tax buyer holds the property's taxes and whether they…
- 4:57:58 Bond inducement of up to $20 million for Homan Square Apartments Phase 4, 24th Ward (Item 7)
- 5:08:28 Monique L. Scott: Asked for support of the Homan Square rehabilitation, saying the phased approach will…
- 5:10:00 Substitute ordinance: TIF redevelopment agreement and city land sale for Southbridge Phase 1C, 2311-2315 S.…
- 5:24:30 Nicole T. Lee: Expressed support for Southbridge Phase 1C next to the 11th Ward.
- 5:25:06 Orders authorizing and denying payment of various small claims (Items 10-11)
- 5:25:39 Charitable solicitation permits for Knights of Columbus and ACLU (Item 12)
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Finance, chaired by Alderperson Pat Dowell, heard four public commenters and approved its Rule 45 reports. It recommended five legal settlements: $400,000 for a sidewalk trip-and-fall, $2.5 million in the Mendes wrongful search warrant case, $3 million in Aguilar v. Duron (passed on a roll call read as 18 yes and 11 no), $12.7 million to Jackie Wilson (with Alderpersons Lopez, Scott and Hopkins recorded as no), and $17 million to Roberto Almodovar; members raised concerns about sidewalk liability and the cost of settlements to the budget. Alderperson Marty Quinn ordinance to require a two-thirds Council vote for city bonds and other debt failed on a roll call announced as 16 yeas and 17 nays after a long debate. The committee also recommended the appointment of Michael Belsky as City Comptroller, a TIF agreement for Black Ensemble Theater, a cleanup ordinance letting seniors keep their garbage discount in the Utility Billing Relief program, a substitute ordinance creating debt-lien and demolition-lien assignment tools, a bond inducement for Homan Square Apartments Phase 4, and a TIF agreement and land sale for Southbridge Phase 1C.
Topics: legal settlements, sidewalk trip-and-fall liability, wrongful conviction settlements, two-thirds vote for city debt, City Comptroller appointment, TIF agreements, utility billing relief for seniors, lien assignment tools, affordable housing bonds, city budget
Agenda items discussed
- 36:24 Rule 45 reports for the Committee on Finance, joint committee and Subcommittee on Revenue: passed
- 37:27 Communication transmitting June 2025 reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements
- 38:04 Settlement: Felicia Nolls Bradley v. City of Chicago ($400,000, sidewalk trip and fall): passed
- 55:33 Settlement: Gilbert Mendes v. City of Chicago ($2.5 million, search warrant execution): passed
- 1:07:03 Settlement: Marley Aguilar v. Eric Duron ($3 million, person struck by police vehicle): passed
- 1:16:04 Settlement: Jackie Wilson v. John Burge et al. ($12.7 million, wrongful conviction): passed
- 1:26:24 Settlement: Roberto Almodovar v. former police detective ($17 million, wrongful conviction): passed
- 1:39:04 Ordinance requiring a two-thirds Council vote for issuance of bonds and other indebtedness (Item 9): failed
- 2:51:12 Redevelopment agreement and TIF funds for Black Ensemble Theater, 4440-4450 N. Clark St., 47th Ward (Item 6): passed
- 3:04:15 Appointment of Michael Belsky as City Comptroller (Item 3): passed
- 3:54:33 Amendment to section 7-28 allowing seniors to keep the senior garbage discount when enrolled in Utility Billing Relief (Item 4): passed
- 4:09:12 Substitute ordinance amending Chapter 2-44 regarding debt-lien and demolition-lien assignments (Item 5): passed
- 4:57:58 Bond inducement of up to $20 million for Homan Square Apartments Phase 4, 24th Ward (Item 7): passed
- 5:10:00 Substitute ordinance: TIF redevelopment agreement and city land sale for Southbridge Phase 1C, 2311-2315 S. State St., 3rd Ward (Item 8): passed
- 5:25:06 Orders authorizing and denying payment of various small claims (Items 10-11)
- 5:25:39 Charitable solicitation permits for Knights of Columbus and ACLU (Item 12): passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Pat Dowell (chair): Asked the age and prior criminal history of the plaintiff in the Aguilar case, and was told he was 20 with no criminal history. (1:12:54); Said how to pay for settlements, whether by bonds or other revenue, would have to be addressed during the budget process. (1:33:36); Clarified that bonding for settlements has been discussed among some members but has not happened. (1:38:09)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Asked how many trip-hazard 311 requests are outstanding and what CDOT and the Law Department are doing, saying sidewalk cases are becoming a settlement industry. (41:54); Pointed to the year-to-date settlement report showing repeated sidewalk payouts and said the issue needs to be taken more seriously. (50:49); Asked why the Mendes settlement involving four people is smaller than an earlier $2.9 million wrongful raid settlement for one person. (1:06:03)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked for data on how many sidewalk complaints become lawsuits and settlements and called for a settlement portal to understand spending. (45:33); Said accountability is needed to prevent future misconduct cases and asked how settlements are being paid now that the $82 million budgeted has been exceeded. (1:35:27); Said he would not support the two-thirds ordinance at this time, arguing a higher vote threshold without process changes would not add transparency and suggesting a year-long budget process or a three-fifths threshold. (2:19:21)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Said committee staff found roughly 29,000 outstanding sidewalk inspection complaints, representing a large liability, and invited members to a related hearing. (49:36); Asked the chair to confirm that general obligation bond proceeds are not being moved to pay settlements. (1:37:30); Opposed the two-thirds ordinance, noting large comparison cities use simple majorities and saying it would likely block infrastructure investment. (2:03:06)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Said CDOT budgets about $5-6 million for sidewalks against an estimated $14 million need and urged true repair costs in capital hearings. (52:57); Estimated pending reverse-conviction cases could cost half a billion dollars or more and asked how the city is paying for them. (1:32:03); Supported the two-thirds ordinance as allowing more discussion and transparency on bonds and urged support for a resolution seeking a city charter. (2:15:39)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Said it may take money to save money and suggested investing to fix trip hazards to avoid future settlements. (54:03); Asked how long guns were allegedly pointed in the Mendes case, saying he would support the settlement. (1:04:37); Asked about the relationship between the Wilson brothers and whether Jackie Wilson knew his brother would shoot. (1:24:51)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Requested total trip-and-fall settlement payouts for 2024 and 2025 year to date. (54:52); Asked whether outside counsel handled the Almodovar case and the cost, and was given an approximate figure for outside counsel costs to date. (1:31:33); Supported the two-thirds ordinance, noting the state requires a supermajority for debt and rating agencies have viewed recent borrowing unfavorably. (2:29:27)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Presented the ordinance to raise the vote needed for city borrowing from 26 to 34, citing a bond downgrade and the structure of the recent $830 million general obligation bond, and asked for a roll call. (1:39:45); Submitted for the record information on Los Angeles and Texas laws on debt approval. (2:06:36)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Supported the two-thirds ordinance, saying a 26-vote threshold enables trading of ward projects for votes and that the last two budgets were unbalanced. (1:43:33); Asked the Finance Department's debt manager where his information on other cities came from. (2:08:27); Asked how the lien ordinance prevents bad actors from transferring property to associates and said a three-year debarment is too short. (4:28:06)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Supported the two-thirds ordinance, saying residents do not trust government and describing being given conflicting information by the administration during budget meetings. (1:48:12); Asked the Comptroller nominee's top priority and urged filling 55 revenue-generating vacancies. (3:16:30)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Supported the two-thirds ordinance without a voter-approval step, saying Council should review bond proposals more closely given debt and pension obligations. (1:55:54); Supported the Comptroller appointment and making financial practices understandable to the public. (3:36:18)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked whether police recovered contraband during the Aguilar chase. (1:11:03); Recused himself from the Wilson settlement under Rule 14, citing past work with the former prosecutor involved. (1:24:06); Supported the two-thirds ordinance, describing the $830 million infrastructure bond's repayments of $137 million a year from 2049 to 2055. (1:59:54)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Supported the two-thirds ordinance as promoting transparency, accountability and best practices. (2:01:51); Asked for support of the Homan Square rehabilitation, saying the phased approach will benefit current residents. (5:08:28)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Opposed the two-thirds ordinance, saying most city debt stems from past pension decisions, changes belong in state law, and a supermajority would let a small group block action. (2:09:03); Explained that bond repayment levies appear in the budget as expenses but bond issuances are not tied to budget votes. (2:36:12); Supported the Comptroller appointment and stressed the need for timely, accurate accounting information. (3:29:45)
- Brian Hopkins (alderperson): Supported the two-thirds ordinance on its merits, noting a 30% rise in per capita debt in the decade before this administration and the structure of the recent infrastructure bond. (2:12:43); Supported the Comptroller appointment and commended the mayor for the nomination. (3:43:24)
- Debra L. Silverstein (alderperson): Said she is worried about city finances and will vote yes on the two-thirds ordinance. (2:18:33)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Said months of negotiation with the CFO's office on an amendment limiting bond interest did not produce agreement, so he would vote yes to gain negotiating leverage. (2:23:19)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Asked whether any briefings had been held on the two-thirds ordinance before documents were submitted. (2:06:51); Opposed voting on the two-thirds ordinance without subject matter hearings or discussion with the state and offered to work with Alderperson Timothy R. Knudsen on debt repayment approaches. (2:25:28); Supported the Comptroller appointment and urged relief for seniors, low-income families and small businesses. (3:45:42)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said she voted against the $830 million bond but was conflicted on the two-thirds ordinance, concerned it could stall infrastructure and payments, and wanted more time. (2:35:09); Expressed support for Southbridge Phase 1C next to the 11th Ward. (5:24:30)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Said she agreed more communication is needed but questioned supporters' past votes on parking meters and pension payments and said she had not heard of the ordinance before. (2:39:58)
- Silvana Tabares (alderperson): As a non-member, supported the two-thirds ordinance as good government that would require more conversations with more alderpersons on finances. (2:42:51)
- Anthony V. Napolitano (alderperson): As a non-member, supported the two-thirds ordinance, saying a larger vote threshold increases accountability and forces the administration to hear more members. (2:43:49)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Asked for support of the Black Ensemble Theater TIF agreement, describing the theater as an anchor for the Clark Street corridor. (3:00:03)
- Derrick G. Curtis (alderperson): Supported the Comptroller appointment and raised semi trucks parking on residential streets as an enforcement priority. (3:35:00)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said he would support the Comptroller appointment but had heard concerns, and asked the nominee to give a more direct answer on pension obligation bonds. (3:37:07); Asked how the lien ordinance relates to the existing housing court forfeiture process. (4:45:39); Asked how the lien tools work when a tax buyer holds the property's taxes and whether they apply only to affordable housing. (4:55:12)
Exchanges between members
- 50:49 Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez built on Alderperson Daniel La Spata figure of 29,000 outstanding sidewalk complaints to estimate potential liability.
- 52:57 Alderperson Gilbert Villegas offered a point of information to Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez on CDOT's sidewalk budget.
- 54:03 Alderperson Nicholas Sposato built on Alderperson Gilbert Villegas point about investing in sidewalk repairs.
- 54:33 The chair responded to Alderperson Nicholas Sposato that all members face sidewalk challenges and would support more CDOT funding.
- 1:33:36 The chair responded to Alderperson Gilbert Villegas question about paying for settlements, saying it would be addressed in the budget process.
- 1:38:09 The chair answered Alderperson Daniel La Spata that bonding for settlements has been discussed but has not happened.
- 1:43:33 Alderperson Anthony Beale commended Alderperson Marty Quinn for bringing the two-thirds ordinance.
- 1:48:12 Alderperson Matthew J. O'Shea repeated Alderperson Marty Quinn point about public trust in supporting the ordinance.
- 1:55:57 Alderperson Scott Waguespack commended Alderperson Marty Quinn for the ordinance and his research on other cities.
- 2:01:36 Alderperson William Conway thanked Alderperson Marty Quinn for putting the ordinance forward.
- 2:02:30 Alderperson Monique L. Scott said Alderperson Marty Quinn helped her understand the ordinance.
- 2:07:43 The chair asked Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez to clarify to whom his point of information about false statements was directed.
- 2:14:06 Alderperson Brian Hopkins cited Alderperson William Conway description of the $830 million infrastructure bond.
- 2:18:21 Alderperson Gilbert Villegas commended Alderperson Marty Quinn for putting the ordinance forward.
- 2:18:33 Alderperson Debra L. Silverstein commended Alderperson Marty Quinn for the measure.
- 2:19:21 Alderperson Andre Vasquez Jr. thanked Alderperson Marty Quinn for raising the issue while saying he would not support it.
- 2:23:30 Alderperson Timothy R. Knudsen said Alderperson Marty Quinn knew he had been undecided until recently.
- 2:26:00 Alderperson Byron Sigcho-López cited Alderperson Brian Hopkins point that the decision would outlast the current body.
- 2:26:30 Alderperson Byron Sigcho-López said he agreed with Alderperson Jason C. Ervin about how the city's debt arose.
- 2:28:09 Alderperson Byron Sigcho-López offered to work with Alderperson Timothy R. Knudsen on ways to address debt financing.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error