Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight meeting, September 9, 2024
- When: Mon, Sep 9, 2024, 1:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: Room 201A, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1007740113
- Transcript: full text (16,203 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 14:22 Rule 59 remote participation for Alderpersons Taylor and Hadden
- 14:40 Public comment
- 36:07 Subject matter hearing on the Inspector General's audit of the Department of Finance's workers' compensation…
- 57:56 Scott Waguespack: Credited the workers' compensation director and staff for professionalizing the program…
- 59:46 Scott Waguespack: Asked when the next annual Gallagher Bassett report would be released and how improvements…
- 1:02:52 Scott Waguespack: Said the problems uncovered appeared to be more mismanagement than fraud and that savings…
- 1:05:59 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked whether fraud in the workers' compensation program has decreased.
- 1:08:20 Bennett R. Lawson: Said about 1,735 open claims seems high relative to the workforce and asked how it…
- 1:11:35 Matthew J. Martin: Requested the anticipated scope and timeline of further third-party analysis of the…
- 1:12:09 Subject matter hearing on the Inspector General's quarterly report for the second quarter of 2024
- 1:19:40 Matthew J. Martin: Asked what debarment of a contractor would entail.
- 1:35:37 Matthew J. Martin: Asked why CPD declined to place a former official who did not cooperate with the…
- 1:38:09 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether investigations reported each quarter involve current or prior…
- 1:40:37 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said it is unacceptable for police officers to be part of extremist groups and asked…
- 1:42:18 Bennett R. Lawson: Said the city should be able to address extremism in policing and suggested the Council…
- 1:45:42 Chris Taliaferro: Asked whether policies on officers joining extremist organizations raise constitutional…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight, chaired by Alderperson Matthew J. Martin, approved remote participation for two members, heard six public commenters, and approved the July 2024 Rule 45 report. In a subject matter hearing on the Inspector General's audit of the Department of Finance's civilian workers' compensation program, the Inspector General reported that the department had substantially implemented Grant Thornton's recommended corrective actions since taking over the program from the Committee on Finance in 2019, with remaining improvements in peer-city analysis and annual reporting; Department of Finance officials cited 31.7 million dollars in savings since 2020 and declining open claims. In a second hearing on the Inspector General's second-quarter 2024 report, the Inspector General described intake and investigation statistics, sustained misconduct cases, COPA case closures under its timeliness initiative, and the Bureau of Internal Affairs' handling of allegations that officers belonged to the Oath Keepers, noting the mayor's office declined to convene a task force on extremism in law enforcement. Members asked about fraud trends, open claim levels, debarment, extremism policy and First Amendment issues; no legislative action was taken on either report.
Topics: workers' compensation program, Inspector General audits, Inspector General quarterly report, police extremism, COPA timeliness initiative, government transparency
Agenda items discussed
- 14:22 Rule 59 remote participation for Alderpersons Taylor and Hadden: passed
- 14:40 Public comment
- 35:50 Approval of the July 2024 Rule 45 report: passed
- 36:07 Subject matter hearing on the Inspector General's audit of the Department of Finance's workers' compensation program: discussed
- 1:12:09 Subject matter hearing on the Inspector General's quarterly report for the second quarter of 2024: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Matthew J. Martin (chair): Requested the anticipated scope and timeline of further third-party analysis of the workers' compensation program and credited Alderperson Scott Waguespack work on the issue. (1:11:35); Asked what debarment of a contractor would entail. (1:19:40); Asked why CPD declined to place a former official who did not cooperate with the Inspector General on the ineligible for rehire list. (1:35:37)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Credited the workers' compensation director and staff for professionalizing the program after it was moved from the Committee on Finance. (57:56); Asked when the next annual Gallagher Bassett report would be released and how improvements affect outside auditors' view of city finances. (59:46); Said the problems uncovered appeared to be more mismanagement than fraud and that savings should benefit taxpayers and the workforce. (1:02:52)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked whether fraud in the workers' compensation program has decreased. (1:05:59); Said about 1,735 open claims seems high relative to the workforce and asked how it compares with peer cities and how many new claims were filed in 2023. (1:08:20); Said the city should be able to address extremism in policing and suggested the Council could form its own task force. (1:42:18)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked whether investigations reported each quarter involve current or prior administrations. (1:38:09); Said it is unacceptable for police officers to be part of extremist groups and asked whether the published mayor's office response was its direct response. (1:40:37)
- Chris Taliaferro (alderperson): Asked whether policies on officers joining extremist organizations raise constitutional issues and whether recommendations were made to the CCPSA or CPD. (1:45:42)
Exchanges between members
- 1:11:54 The chair acknowledged Alderperson Scott Waguespack work shepherding the workers' compensation reforms.
- 1:40:37 Alderperson Andre Vasquez Jr. said Chairman Matthew J. Martin had asked many of the questions he had about the response on the Oath Keepers.
- 1:42:18 Alderperson Bennett R. Lawson echoed the concerns about extremism raised before him.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error