Joint Committee: Finance; Housing and Real Estate meeting, May 7, 2025
- When: Wed, May 7, 2025, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1081591549
- Transcript: full text (16,617 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 23:11 Rule 59 motion to allow remote participation
- 23:56 Byron Sigcho-López: Opened the public comment period, limited to 30 minutes with two minutes per speaker.
- 50:49 Byron Sigcho-López: Noted that numerous written comments in support were received and none against, and…
- 52:49 Motion to accept second substitute ordinance as amended establishing a nonprofit Residential Investment…
- 54:37 Pat Dowell: Asked the Commissioner of Housing to explain the changes in the new substitute.
- 1:01:54 Michael D. Rodriguez: Said the ordinance was worked on diligently, that the federal government is pulling…
- 1:03:26 Michael D. Rodriguez: Credited Manaa-Hoppenworth for resolving labor's concerns and said realtors, community…
- 1:04:38 Michael D. Rodriguez: Moved to pass the ordinance after colleagues' comments.
- 1:05:14 Walter R. Burnett: Commended the mayor, Inspector General, ethics staff and colleagues for their work on the…
- 1:05:54 Walter R. Burnett: Cited 1980s federal housing efforts, including Presidential Towers, as precedent for…
- 1:07:25 Walter R. Burnett: Said tools that help some parts of the city help the whole city, comparing it to the…
- 1:12:09 Pat Dowell: Asked Burnett whether he had a question on the ordinance.
- 1:12:56 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked the Inspector General and Board of Ethics director to report on changes since the…
- 1:15:42 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked whether the council would retain authority over the corporation after incorporation…
- 1:17:59 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Raised a point of information asking staff to clarify that Green Social Housing receives…
- 1:20:59 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked whether his earlier concerns about fees and cost caps had been addressed and was…
- 1:24:31 Nicole T. Lee: Said the administration heard concerns on ethics issues after she and others sought more time.
- 1:25:15 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether acquisitions would target large buildings or smaller properties that could…
- 1:26:25 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether Illinois Housing Development Authority financing is at risk from federal cuts.
- 1:30:12 Pat Dowell: Asked members to keep questions concise ahead of the noon City Council meeting.
- 1:30:35 David H. Moore: Said he valued the Inspector General's and ethics officer's input and would support the…
- 1:31:23 David H. Moore: Urged the administration to also focus on the Chicago Housing Authority's Plan for…
- 1:32:02 Jason C. Ervin: Said the enabling ordinance is one more tool, every deal returns to council, and wards that…
- 1:33:01 Jason C. Ervin: Said the program uses existing bond funds and does not require a tax increase.
- 1:33:57 Jason C. Ervin: Said a revolving fund could create affordability in perpetuity compared with a one-time…
- 1:35:33 Maria E. Hadden: Thanked the department, OIG and ethics staff and said the collaborative process should be a…
- 1:36:19 Maria E. Hadden: Said her mostly renter ward will benefit from more housing created citywide even if little…
- 1:39:16 Maria E. Hadden: Said the council will need to evaluate outcomes and refine the tool, especially given…
- 1:39:51 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said holding the matter for more questions and oversight reflected reduced confidence in…
- 1:41:21 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Urged expanding acquisition uses and support for converting basements into ADUs, and said…
- 1:42:26 Jessica L. Fuentes: Said the city needs more rental supply and that this is one of several approaches, and…
- 1:44:09 Jessica L. Fuentes: Renewed Rodriguez's motion to call the ordinance for a vote.
- 1:46:20 Anthony Beale: Asked whether the bond vote disclosed the Green Social Housing allocation and whether the…
- 1:47:14 Anthony Beale: Compared the proposal to Bring Chicago Home and said it creates another hurdle that may not…
- 1:48:17 Anthony Beale: Said the money should instead be invested in partnership with the Chicago Housing Authority,…
- 1:49:11 Brendan Reilly: Thanked the Inspector General and colleagues who held up the ordinance until ethics and…
- 1:50:59 Brendan Reilly: Said he still disagrees with the four-year board term and the creation of well-paid staff…
- 1:53:02 Brendan Reilly: Described cases where market-rate units subsidizing affordable units failed when market-rate…
- 1:59:07 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: As lead co-sponsor, thanked city staff, the Inspector General, Board of Ethics and…
- 2:00:42 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Cited a shortage of 120,000 affordable units and the risk to 2,500 pipeline units…
- 2:01:42 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Described the program as an efficient tool to recycle public funds into permanently…
- 2:03:46 Second substitute ordinance as amended establishing a nonprofit Residential Investment Corporation for Green…
- 2:03:46 Byron Sigcho-López: Announced the motion passed 25 to 13 and congratulated the sponsor and the Department of…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
A joint meeting of the Committee on Housing and Real Estate and the Committee on Finance, chaired by Alderpersons Sigcho-López and Dowell, considered a second substitute ordinance establishing a nonprofit Residential Investment Corporation to carry out the Green Social Housing program using a $135 million revolving loan fund from the housing bond. Most public commenters supported the ordinance, while several opposed it. Department of Housing and mayoral staff described amendments adding Inspector General and Board of Ethics oversight, gift, campaign finance and conflict-of-interest rules, a clarified income mix, and a cap on city operating support, and the Inspector General and Board of Ethics director said the ethics provisions were improved. Members debated council oversight after incorporation, long-term affordability, taxpayer cost, board terms and staff salaries, and federal housing cuts. The joint committee accepted the second substitute and recommended passage on a roll call announced as 25 yes and 13 no, to be reported at the May 7 City Council meeting.
Topics: Green Social Housing, Residential Investment Corporation, affordable housing, ethics and oversight, federal housing cuts, revolving loan fund, housing bond, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 23:11 Rule 59 motion to allow remote participation: passed
- 52:49 Motion to accept second substitute ordinance as amended establishing a nonprofit Residential Investment Corporation (Green Social Housing): passed
- 2:03:46 Second substitute ordinance as amended establishing a nonprofit Residential Investment Corporation for Green Social Housing: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Byron Sigcho-López (chair): Opened the public comment period, limited to 30 minutes with two minutes per speaker. (23:56); Noted that numerous written comments in support were received and none against, and listed the organizations that submitted letters. (50:49); Announced the motion passed 25 to 13 and congratulated the sponsor and the Department of Housing. (2:03:46)
- Pat Dowell (chair): Asked the Commissioner of Housing to explain the changes in the new substitute. (54:37); Asked Burnett whether he had a question on the ordinance. (1:12:09); Asked members to keep questions concise ahead of the noon City Council meeting. (1:30:12)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson): Said the ordinance was worked on diligently, that the federal government is pulling back housing support, and that creative efforts are needed. (1:01:54); Credited Manaa-Hoppenworth for resolving labor's concerns and said realtors, community groups and labor now support the ordinance. (1:03:26); Moved to pass the ordinance after colleagues' comments. (1:04:38)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Commended the mayor, Inspector General, ethics staff and colleagues for their work on the ordinance. (1:05:14); Cited 1980s federal housing efforts, including Presidential Towers, as precedent for public support of mixed-income development. (1:05:54); Said tools that help some parts of the city help the whole city, comparing it to the Neighborhood Opportunity Fund. (1:07:25)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Asked the Inspector General and Board of Ethics director to report on changes since the last hearing. (1:12:56); Asked whether the council would retain authority over the corporation after incorporation if the ordinance were later amended. (1:15:42); Asked whether his earlier concerns about fees and cost caps had been addressed and was told they had not. (1:20:59)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Raised a point of information asking staff to clarify that Green Social Housing receives $135 million, not $1.25 billion. (1:17:59); Said holding the matter for more questions and oversight reflected reduced confidence in some mayoral proposals, and that hearing from officials helped. (1:39:51); Urged expanding acquisition uses and support for converting basements into ADUs, and said he supports the ordinance. (1:41:21)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said the administration heard concerns on ethics issues after she and others sought more time. (1:24:31); Asked whether acquisitions would target large buildings or smaller properties that could house people faster. (1:25:15); Asked whether Illinois Housing Development Authority financing is at risk from federal cuts. (1:26:25)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said he valued the Inspector General's and ethics officer's input and would support the ordinance. (1:30:35); Urged the administration to also focus on the Chicago Housing Authority's Plan for Transformation. (1:31:23)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Said the enabling ordinance is one more tool, every deal returns to council, and wards that do not want it need not use it. (1:32:02); Said the program uses existing bond funds and does not require a tax increase. (1:33:01); Said a revolving fund could create affordability in perpetuity compared with a one-time spend and cited high rents driving young people out. (1:33:57)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Thanked the department, OIG and ethics staff and said the collaborative process should be a model for legislation. (1:35:33); Said her mostly renter ward will benefit from more housing created citywide even if little is built there. (1:36:19); Said the council will need to evaluate outcomes and refine the tool, especially given federal cuts. (1:39:16)
- Jessica L. Fuentes (alderperson): Said the city needs more rental supply and that this is one of several approaches, and that she was ready to support it weeks ago. (1:42:26); Renewed Rodriguez's motion to call the ordinance for a vote. (1:44:09)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked whether the bond vote disclosed the Green Social Housing allocation and whether the corporation's staff need council confirmation. (1:46:20); Compared the proposal to Bring Chicago Home and said it creates another hurdle that may not produce the intended results. (1:47:14); Said the money should instead be invested in partnership with the Chicago Housing Authority, which has vacant units. (1:48:17)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Thanked the Inspector General and colleagues who held up the ordinance until ethics and governance gaps were addressed. (1:49:11); Said he still disagrees with the four-year board term and the creation of well-paid staff positions not accountable to the council. (1:50:59); Described cases where market-rate units subsidizing affordable units failed when market-rate tenants could no longer afford rent. (1:53:02)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): As lead co-sponsor, thanked city staff, the Inspector General, Board of Ethics and colleagues for the revisions. (1:59:07); Cited a shortage of 120,000 affordable units and the risk to 2,500 pipeline units from proposed federal cuts. (2:00:42); Described the program as an efficient tool to recycle public funds into permanently affordable mixed-income housing. (2:01:42)
Exchanges between members
- 1:03:26 Rodriguez commended Manaa-Hoppenworth for her leadership on the ordinance.
- 1:11:57 Dowell asked Burnett whether he had a question on the ordinance.
- 1:17:59 Vasquez raised a point of information disputing Lopez's reference to $1.25 billion.
- 1:19:05 Lopez asked to finish speaking after the interruption.
- 1:30:12 Dowell thanked Lee after her remarks.
- 1:30:35 Moore said Lopez had already posed his question.
- 1:30:50 Moore commended Reilly for ensuring the Inspector General's and ethics officer's views were heard.
- 1:35:23 Hadden wished Ervin a happy birthday.
- 1:35:56 Hadden thanked Manaa-Hoppenworth for championing the ordinance.
- 1:40:12 Vasquez said Lopez's question helped frame the program as a smaller tool.
- 1:42:32 Fuentes acknowledged Manaa-Hoppenworth's work on the ordinance.
- 1:44:15 Fuentes renewed Rodriguez's motion to call the ordinance for a vote.
- 1:49:17 Reilly thanked Hadden for saying the process showed how legislative negotiation should work.
- 1:53:07 Reilly echoed Ervin's description of the issue as a math problem.
- 1:56:40 Reilly cited Beale's point about appointees being aligned with the administration.
- 1:58:52 Dowell asked Manaa-Hoppenworth to close on the ordinance.
- 1:59:07 Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked chairs Dowell and Sigcho-López.
- 1:59:38 Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked Reilly for his questions and concerns.
- 1:59:59 Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked Rodriguez for lifting the voices of labor partners.
- 2:02:22 Manaa-Hoppenworth echoed a point made by the vice mayor.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error