Committee on Economic, Capital and Technology Development meeting, July 9, 2024
- When: Tue, Jul 9, 2024, 9:30 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Economic, Capital and Technology Development
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928495/video/980806224
- Transcript: full text (22,104 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 44:16 June 2024 monthly report
- 44:35 Reappointments to Special Service Area No. 18 and No. 75 commissions
- 46:05 Substitute ordinance requiring city data to be processed and stored within the United States, with bid…
- 46:52 Gilbert Villegas: Said the data residency ordinance aims to attract data centers to grow the property tax…
- 49:21 Gilbert Villegas: Said modern data centers must meet city sustainability standards for new construction,…
- 51:48 Gilbert Villegas: Said the substitute reflects negotiations with the administration and committed to…
- 1:07:44 Daniel La Spata: Said public testimony gave him pause and asked whether property taxes would be the main…
- 1:10:07 Daniel La Spata: Asked the information security officer to explain his statement that the ordinance runs…
- 1:13:20 Daniel La Spata: Asked how data centers meet the sustainable development policy's indoor water use…
- 1:16:39 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked who is in the data center coalition and how large a data center footprint…
- 1:20:07 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked about concerns that data centers could lower nearby property values, using her…
- 1:22:16 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Said she had heard many concerns from environmental groups and moved to hold the…
- 1:26:14 Nicole T. Lee: Supported generating revenue but asked for a plain explanation of what the ordinance does and…
- 1:30:04 Nicole T. Lee: Asked where city data is housed today and about industry standards for redundancy.
- 1:42:19 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how compliance would be enforced and requested a schedule of affected contracts and…
- 1:48:25 Ruth Cruz: Asked which company would manage the data and what the witness's affiliation was.
- 1:51:08 Ruth Cruz: Said many questions remained unanswered and that voting that day would be a disservice.
- 1:53:05 Ruth Cruz: Said she did not need a reminder about her vote and pointed to the questions raised in the meeting.
- 1:59:56 Class 6B tax incentive for 5201 W. Grand Avenue (37th Ward)
- 2:04:34 Emma Mitts: Supported the incentive for 5201 W. Grand to bring a moving company into a vacant property.
- 2:06:12 Class 6B tax incentive renewal for 9165 S. Harbor Avenue (10th Ward)
- 2:11:29 Class 7a tax incentive for 5100 S. Damen (16th Ward)
- 2:17:11 Class 6B tax incentive for 2841 S. Ashland (12th Ward)
- 2:23:07 Class 6B tax incentive renewal for 1621-1625 W. Carroll (27th Ward)
- 2:28:33 Class 6B incentives for 4500 W. Chicago Avenue and 4545/4533 W. Augusta Boulevard (37th Ward)
- 2:37:41 Emma Mitts: Supported the Freedman Seating incentives, citing its 130-year history, job growth and community…
- 2:44:47 Class 6B tax incentive renewal for the Ford Supplier Park (10th Ward)
- 2:55:32 Substitute resolution calling for hearings on employee ownership transitions
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Economic, Capital and Technology Development approved its June 2024 report and three special service area commission reappointments, then took up a substitute data residency ordinance requiring city data to be stored in the United States and giving procurement bid incentives for storing it in Illinois or Chicago. Environmental groups and the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce urged the committee not to advance it, the chair described it as a way to grow the tax base through data center development, and the city's chief information security officer said it was counter to best practices in some respects and that implementation effects were not yet fully understood. After extended questions on revenue, data storage, sustainability and enforcement, members voted 8 to 5 to postpone consideration to the next meeting. The committee then recommended passage of property tax incentives for projects at 5201 W. Grand, 9165 S. Harbor, 5100 S. Damen, 2841 S. Ashland, 1621-1625 W. Carroll, the Freedman Seating campus on W. Chicago and W. Augusta, and the Ford Supplier Park, and approved a substitute resolution setting a September 4 hearing on employee ownership.
Topics: data residency ordinance, data centers, property tax incentives, Class 6B, environmental impact, city procurement, job retention, employee ownership, special service areas
Agenda items discussed
- 44:16 June 2024 monthly report: passed
- 44:35 Reappointments to Special Service Area No. 18 and No. 75 commissions: passed
- 46:05 Substitute ordinance requiring city data to be processed and stored within the United States, with bid incentives for Illinois and Chicago storage: held
- 1:59:56 Class 6B tax incentive for 5201 W. Grand Avenue (37th Ward): passed
- 2:06:12 Class 6B tax incentive renewal for 9165 S. Harbor Avenue (10th Ward): passed
- 2:11:29 Class 7a tax incentive for 5100 S. Damen (16th Ward): passed
- 2:17:11 Class 6B tax incentive for 2841 S. Ashland (12th Ward): passed
- 2:23:07 Class 6B tax incentive renewal for 1621-1625 W. Carroll (27th Ward): passed
- 2:28:33 Class 6B incentives for 4500 W. Chicago Avenue and 4545/4533 W. Augusta Boulevard (37th Ward): passed
- 2:44:47 Class 6B tax incentive renewal for the Ford Supplier Park (10th Ward): passed
- 2:55:32 Substitute resolution calling for hearings on employee ownership transitions: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Gilbert Villegas (chair): Said the data residency ordinance aims to attract data centers to grow the property tax base instead of raising property taxes, fines, fees or TIF sweeps. (46:52); Said modern data centers must meet city sustainability standards for new construction, including energy and water efficiency. (49:21); Said the substitute reflects negotiations with the administration and committed to codifying faster permitting for data centers with industry groups. (51:48)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Said public testimony gave him pause and asked whether property taxes would be the main revenue benefit of the data ordinance. (1:07:44); Asked the information security officer to explain his statement that the ordinance runs counter to best practices. (1:10:07); Asked how data centers meet the sustainable development policy's indoor water use requirement. (1:13:20)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked who is in the data center coalition and how large a data center footprint would be. (1:16:39); Asked about concerns that data centers could lower nearby property values, using her dense ward as an example. (1:20:07); Said she had heard many concerns from environmental groups and moved to hold the ordinance for talks with the environment commissioner. (1:22:16)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Supported generating revenue but asked for a plain explanation of what the ordinance does and how the 6 and 8 percent incentives work. (1:26:14); Asked where city data is housed today and about industry standards for redundancy. (1:30:04); Asked how compliance would be enforced and requested a schedule of affected contracts and their value. (1:42:19)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Asked which company would manage the data and what the witness's affiliation was. (1:48:25); Said many questions remained unanswered and that voting that day would be a disservice. (1:51:08); Said she did not need a reminder about her vote and pointed to the questions raised in the meeting. (1:53:05)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Supported the incentive for 5201 W. Grand to bring a moving company into a vacant property. (2:04:34); Supported the Freedman Seating incentives, citing its 130-year history, job growth and community hiring partnerships. (2:37:41)
Exchanges between members
- 1:08:45 La Spata asked Villegas to explain how the ordinance would generate revenue without a city income or services tax.
- 1:09:12 Villegas answered La Spata that revenue would come from property taxes on new data centers.
- 1:16:31 Manaa-Hoppenworth thanked Villegas for his work since the January hearing before asking questions.
- 1:23:03 Villegas argued that existing planning sustainability requirements address Manaa-Hoppenworth's concerns.
- 1:26:14 Lee asked Villegas to explain the ordinance at a high level.
- 1:48:42 Cruz asked Villegas which company would manage the city's data.
- 1:52:50 Villegas told Cruz voting no was her prerogative and that the ordinance could be amended later.
- 1:53:05 Cruz replied that she did not need a reminder about her vote and pointed to unanswered questions.
- 2:42:42 La Spata said he agreed with everything Mitts said about Freedman Seating.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error