Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, December 10, 2024
- When: Tue, Dec 10, 2024, 12:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1037983061
- Transcript: full text (11,758 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 41:48 Transfer of funds ordinances (items 10 through 25)
- 43:59 2025 Municipal Code Corrections ordinance
- 1:56:05 Jason C. Ervin: Explained that item one had no substitute and called for a re-vote on the Municipal Code…
- 1:57:23 Anthony Beale: Asked whether the code corrections ordinance contained the change to Law Department…
- 1:57:59 2025 Management Ordinance amending provisions on organization and functions of city government
- 1:58:53 Anthony Beale: Said the Inspector General had raised concerns that the Law Department would gain authority…
- 2:00:30 Jason C. Ervin: Said the Corporation Counsel has overall jurisdiction over departments but not to the extent…
- 2:00:41 Anthony Beale: Asked to hear from the Law Department rather than the chair on the question of Corporation…
- 2:01:49 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked that the Inspector General confirm for members that she is comfortable with the…
- 2:02:54 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked the Inspector General whether she was satisfied with the substitute language and…
- 2:04:31 Raymond A. Lopez: Read Article 6, Section 8 making the mid-year reporting provisions contingent on passing…
- 2:05:48 Jason C. Ervin: Told Lopez that the question of why Section 8 was included would need to be asked of the…
- 2:07:09 Raymond A. Lopez: Objected that the Law Department would not say who directed the language, stating it is…
- 2:08:03 Motion to strike Article 6, Section 8 of the Management Ordinance (motion to table failed; amendment adopted)
- 2:10:55 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said he was fine with amending the ordinance to strike Section 8.
- 2:11:05 Walter R. Burnett: Asked that the motion on Section 8 be fully explained again.
- 2:11:41 Pat Dowell: Asked the Law Department what effect striking Section 8 would have.
- 2:15:34 2025 annual appropriation ordinance with budget recommendations, text portion and amendments (items 2 and 3)
- 2:17:32 William Conway: Asked whether there were any changes in the amendment beyond removing added funding for two…
- 2:18:15 Brendan Reilly: Asked what a new assistant budget director for data analytics in the Office of Budget and…
- 2:19:29 Brendan Reilly: Asked when the city treasurer's security detail began being paid from the water enterprise…
- 2:21:04 Daniel La Spata: Asked about the reduction in the appropriation for payment of bonds from $156.7 million to…
- 2:22:01 Daniel La Spata: Asked about the change in Office of Public Safety Administration IT maintenance funding.
- 2:29:49 Gilbert Villegas: Asked what the city is doing to decouple from paying the CPS share of pension costs given…
- 2:31:41 Brendan Reilly: Said that as a former vice mayor he served with no staff budget and that $400,000 for the…
- 2:37:04 Expenditure of motor fuel tax funds allocated to the city for 2025
- 2:37:54 Intergovernmental agreement with the CTA and Cook County for allocation of motor fuel tax
- 2:38:15 Gilbert Villegas: Asked about the legal basis for the motor fuel tax allocation to the CTA, its required…
- 2:39:54 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Reminded members that the Transportation Committee holds quarterly hearings with the CTA…
- 2:40:36 Resolution amending classification plan and employee benefits regulations (salary resolution)
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations met to consider the 2025 budget package after hearing from nine public commenters. The committee recommended passage of transfer-of-funds ordinances, its October 2024 Rule 45 report, the 2025 Municipal Code Corrections ordinance, and the 2025 Management Ordinance, after members questioned the Law Department and the Inspector General about new Corporation Counsel language and voted to strike Article 6, Section 8, which would have tied mid-year reporting provisions to passage of the budget by December 13. Following a presentation by the Budget Director on closing a $346 million gap through about $256 million in new revenue and $90 million in cuts, members asked about amendments including data analytics staffing, a treasurer security detail paid from the water fund, the vice mayor's office budget, and CPS pension reimbursements, and the committee recommended the 2025 annual appropriation ordinance by roll call. The committee also recommended the motor fuel tax expenditure ordinance, an intergovernmental agreement with the CTA and Cook County on motor fuel tax, and the 2025 salary resolution.
Topics: 2025 budget, Annual appropriation ordinance, Management ordinance, Inspector General independence, Municipal Code corrections, Motor fuel tax, Vice mayor office budget, CPS pension reimbursement, Salary resolution, Public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 41:48 Transfer of funds ordinances (items 10 through 25): passed
- 43:33 Monthly Rule 45 report for October 2024: passed
- 43:59 2025 Municipal Code Corrections ordinance (O2024-0013675): passed
- 1:57:59 2025 Management Ordinance amending provisions on organization and functions of city government: passed
- 2:08:03 Motion to strike Article 6, Section 8 of the Management Ordinance (motion to table failed; amendment adopted): passed
- 2:15:34 2025 annual appropriation ordinance with budget recommendations, text portion and amendments (items 2 and 3): passed
- 2:37:04 Expenditure of motor fuel tax funds allocated to the city for 2025 (O2024-0013676): passed
- 2:37:54 Intergovernmental agreement with the CTA and Cook County for allocation of motor fuel tax (O2024-0013677): passed
- 2:40:36 Resolution amending classification plan and employee benefits regulations (salary resolution) (R2024-0013678): passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Explained that item one had no substitute and called for a re-vote on the Municipal Code Corrections ordinance as introduced. (1:56:05); Said the Corporation Counsel has overall jurisdiction over departments but not to the extent of directing investigations. (2:00:30); Told Lopez that the question of why Section 8 was included would need to be asked of the mayor. (2:05:48)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked whether the code corrections ordinance contained the change to Law Department authority, and was told it was in the management ordinance. (1:57:23); Said the Inspector General had raised concerns that the Law Department would gain authority to direct investigations and asked to confirm on the record that it has no jurisdiction over the Inspector General's office. (1:58:53); Asked to hear from the Law Department rather than the chair on the question of Corporation Counsel authority. (2:00:41)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked that the Inspector General confirm for members that she is comfortable with the substitute language. (2:01:49); Said he was fine with amending the ordinance to strike Section 8. (2:10:55); Reminded members that the Transportation Committee holds quarterly hearings with the CTA president where questions on fund use can be asked. (2:39:54)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Asked the Inspector General whether she was satisfied with the substitute language and whether the change would allow interference with her office. (2:02:54); Read Article 6, Section 8 making the mid-year reporting provisions contingent on passing the budget and revenue ordinances by December 13, and asked why it was included. (2:04:31); Objected that the Law Department would not say who directed the language, stating it is not privileged from council members. (2:07:09)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Asked that the motion on Section 8 be fully explained again. (2:11:05)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked the Law Department what effect striking Section 8 would have. (2:11:41)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked whether there were any changes in the amendment beyond removing added funding for two committees. (2:17:32)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked what a new assistant budget director for data analytics in the Office of Budget and Management would do. (2:18:15); Asked when the city treasurer's security detail began being paid from the water enterprise fund and about its increase in the amendment. (2:19:29); Said that as a former vice mayor he served with no staff budget and that $400,000 for the office is not justified while asking taxpayers for more revenue. (2:31:41)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked about the reduction in the appropriation for payment of bonds from $156.7 million to $143.5 million. (2:21:04); Asked about the change in Office of Public Safety Administration IT maintenance funding. (2:22:01)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked what the city is doing to decouple from paying the CPS share of pension costs given the new law taking effect in January. (2:29:49); Asked about the legal basis for the motor fuel tax allocation to the CTA, its required uses, and whether the CTA must report how it spends the money. (2:38:15)
Exchanges between members
- 1:57:17 Beale asked the chair whether the code corrections ordinance contained the Law Department authority change.
- 1:57:31 The chair told Beale the change was in the separate management ordinance.
- 2:00:41 Beale told the chair he wanted to hear from the Law Department rather than the chair's interpretation.
- 2:01:43 Beale thanked the chair after the Law Department's clarification.
- 2:02:02 The chair said hearing from the Inspector General was not necessary.
- 2:02:04 Vasquez replied that some members wanted to hear the Inspector General confirm the language.
- 2:05:48 The chair told Lopez his question about Section 8 would need to go to the mayor.
- 2:05:53 Lopez asked the chair who drafted the substitute.
- 2:07:41 Lopez told the chair the information on who directed the language was not privileged.
- 2:10:50 The chair turned to Vasquez, thinking he had his hand up.
- 2:11:05 Burnett asked the chair to explain the motion on Section 8.
- 2:12:36 Hadden said Section 8 was unnecessary and expressed appreciation for colleagues who moved the amendments.
- 2:17:32 Conway asked about other changes in the amendment.
- 2:21:03 La Spata thanked the chair before asking his questions.
- 2:29:38 Lopez thanked the chair after his questions.
- 2:32:57 Reilly said his remarks on the vice mayor's budget were not meant as disrespect to Burnett.
- 2:33:47 The chair thanked Reilly.
- 2:38:15 Villegas asked the chair whether the budget director would present on the motor fuel tax agreement.
- 2:39:57 Vasquez followed up on Villegas's question about CTA use of funds.
- 2:45:50 The chair thanked Dowell for reminding him to acknowledge additional staff.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error