Committee on License and Consumer Protection meeting, September 16, 2025
- When: Tue, Sep 16, 2025, 10:30 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: 201A, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on License and Consumer Protection
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928556?video=1118831200
- Transcript: full text (12,756 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 24:27 Public comment
- 38:36 Lifting the package goods license moratorium on a portion of Diversey Avenue
- 39:45 Lifting the package goods license moratorium on a portion of Howard Street
- 40:46 Ordinance adding Chapter 4-155 on licensing and regulation of video gaming terminals (substitute)
- 41:41 Anthony Beale: Explained the substitute directs 100 percent of video gaming revenue to the pension system.
- 42:37 Anthony Beale: Said the state is open to changing the revenue formula and that the city has not asked, and…
- 45:54 Brendan Reilly: Said it was instructive that Bally's did not appear and questioned whether the permanent…
- 49:33 Brendan Reilly: Said he historically opposed video gaming over addiction concerns but now has an open mind…
- 51:49 Brendan Reilly: Asked the sponsor whether the ordinance applies only to restaurants with incidental licenses.
- 53:19 David H. Moore: Asked about the difference between video gaming terminals and coupon machines.
- 54:34 Anthony Beale: Said many existing machines in the city are illegal and the ordinance would help bring them…
- 55:29 David H. Moore: Said he could not support the ordinance until concerns about African American participation…
- 56:58 Nicholas Sposato: Said border ward businesses lose customers to suburbs with video gaming and asked BACP…
- 1:03:08 Nicholas Sposato: Asked whether sweepstakes machines are illegal and noted they have operated unlicensed for…
- 1:04:36 Nicholas Sposato: Asked the sponsor to hold the ordinance for one month to gather more information.
- 1:07:52 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said he shares the sponsor's frustration and wants taverns in his border ward included.
- 1:09:44 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the city's revenue share is too small and asked what the administration's plan is…
- 1:10:30 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the item should be tabled until the administration presents a plan and more planning…
- 1:12:15 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked about separation requirements, the number of eligible locations and machines, and…
- 1:15:05 Anthony V. Napolitano: Agreed with the sponsor, saying the city has lost over $330 million by delaying video…
- 1:17:58 Anthony V. Napolitano: Suggested passing the ordinance with a delayed effective date to give BACP time to…
- 1:19:05 Matthew J. Martin: Requested BACP's full list of implementation needs, whether the mayor's office has…
- 1:21:16 William Conway: Asked about the state and city revenue split and the flaws in the city's impact study, and…
- 1:26:46 Debra L. Silverstein: Stated that the video gaming tax is 35 percent, with 30 percent to the state and 5…
- 1:29:57 Monique L. Scott: Said the ordinance would start bringing in revenue that exceeds what Bally's provides and…
- 1:33:25 Felix Cardona Jr.: Asked whether the ordinance could be amended to address PPA licenses.
- 1:34:15 Felix Cardona Jr.: Said the casino agreement requires good-faith renegotiation rather than constituting a…
- 1:37:51 Bennett R. Lawson: Moved to hold the ordinance to the October meeting, saying more work could produce…
- 1:38:18 Anthony V. Napolitano: Asked the sponsor whether video gaming has failed anywhere it has been implemented.
- 1:38:37 Debra L. Silverstein: Said the city has discussed video gaming for years and should have been ready, calling…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on License and Consumer Protection heard four public commenters, approved its July and August 2025 Rule 45 reports, and passed two ordinances lifting package goods license moratoriums on portions of Diversey Avenue and Howard Street. Most of the meeting addressed Alderperson Anthony Beale substitute ordinance to license and regulate video gaming terminals, amended so that all revenue would go to the pension system. Supporters cited lost revenue to bordering suburbs and the city's budget deficit, while the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce raised concerns about the city's agreement with Bally's, BACP asked for more time and resources to implement the program, and several members sought a one-month hold, inclusion of taverns, and a larger state revenue share. On a roll call requested by Alderperson Brendan Reilly, the substitute was recommended for passage by a vote of eight yeses to six nays, to be reported to the City Council on September 25, 2025.
Topics: video gaming terminals, pension revenue, Bally's casino agreement, bars and taverns, state revenue share, BACP implementation, package goods moratoriums, border wards, sweepstakes machines, Rule 45 reports
Agenda items discussed
- 24:27 Public comment
- 38:04 Approval of July and August 2025 Rule 45 reports: passed
- 38:36 Lifting the package goods license moratorium on a portion of Diversey Avenue: passed
- 39:45 Lifting the package goods license moratorium on a portion of Howard Street (O2025-0018759): passed
- 40:46 Ordinance adding Chapter 4-155 on licensing and regulation of video gaming terminals (substitute): passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Debra L. Silverstein (chair): Stated that the video gaming tax is 35 percent, with 30 percent to the state and 5 percent to the local government. (1:26:46); Said the city has discussed video gaming for years and should have been ready, calling it an opportunity to bring in revenue during the budget crisis. (1:38:37)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Explained the substitute directs 100 percent of video gaming revenue to the pension system. (41:41); Said the state is open to changing the revenue formula and that the city has not asked, and that video gaming could bring $60 million to $100 million a year. (42:37); Said many existing machines in the city are illegal and the ordinance would help bring them under regulation. (54:34)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said it was instructive that Bally's did not appear and questioned whether the permanent casino will open on time. (45:54); Said he historically opposed video gaming over addiction concerns but now has an open mind given business struggles and the budget deficit. (49:33); Asked the sponsor whether the ordinance applies only to restaurants with incidental licenses. (51:49)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked about the difference between video gaming terminals and coupon machines. (53:19); Said he could not support the ordinance until concerns about African American participation in the industry are answered. (55:29)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Said border ward businesses lose customers to suburbs with video gaming and asked BACP about implementation readiness and whether bars are covered. (56:58); Asked whether sweepstakes machines are illegal and noted they have operated unlicensed for years. (1:03:08); Asked the sponsor to hold the ordinance for one month to gather more information. (1:04:36)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Said he shares the sponsor's frustration and wants taverns in his border ward included. (1:07:52); Said the city's revenue share is too small and asked what the administration's plan is for Springfield. (1:09:44); Said the item should be tabled until the administration presents a plan and more planning and staffing are in place. (1:10:30)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked about separation requirements, the number of eligible locations and machines, and whether new staff could be revenue neutral. (1:12:15); Moved to hold the ordinance to the October meeting, saying more work could produce something all could support. (1:37:51)
- Anthony V. Napolitano (alderperson): Agreed with the sponsor, saying the city has lost over $330 million by delaying video gaming for ten years while border businesses lose customers. (1:15:05); Suggested passing the ordinance with a delayed effective date to give BACP time to implement it. (1:17:58); Asked the sponsor whether video gaming has failed anywhere it has been implemented. (1:38:18)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Requested BACP's full list of implementation needs, whether the mayor's office has formally sought a larger state revenue share, and the basis for the sponsor's revenue estimate. (1:19:05)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked about the state and city revenue split and the flaws in the city's impact study, and favored a one-month wait or later effective date. (1:21:16)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Said the ordinance would start bringing in revenue that exceeds what Bally's provides and could be adjusted later. (1:29:57)
- Felix Cardona Jr. (alderperson): Asked whether the ordinance could be amended to address PPA licenses. (1:33:25); Said the casino agreement requires good-faith renegotiation rather than constituting a breach, and confirmed revenue would go to police and fire pensions. (1:34:15)
Exchanges between members
- 50:29 Reilly cited Beale's point about the $1.2 billion budget deficit.
- 51:49 Reilly asked Beale whether the ordinance applies only to incidental license holders.
- 52:00 Beale answered that it covers incidental and PPA license holders and he is open to adding taverns.
- 54:34 Beale responded to Moore that most machines currently in the city are illegal.
- 55:05 Moore said the coupon machines are not illegal and raised participation concerns.
- 1:03:13 Sposato said he believed his colleague was wrong that sweepstakes machines are illegal.
- 1:04:48 Sposato asked Beale to consider holding the ordinance for one month.
- 1:07:56 O'Shea said he shares Beale's frustration over years of delay.
- 1:09:26 O'Shea echoed Reilly's view that the casino process was rushed.
- 1:15:05 Napolitano said he agreed with Beale on moving forward.
- 1:19:56 Martin asked Beale how the $60 million to $100 million estimate was reached.
- 1:20:26 Beale said the estimate was based on industry calculations.
- 1:22:38 Conway said he shared Beale's frustration but favored waiting a month.
- 1:26:13 Sposato echoed Napolitano's point that video gaming would encourage businesses to open in Chicago.
- 1:27:45 Reilly said he agreed with Beale that no revenue option should be left unturned.
- 1:28:12 Reilly said he would not oppose Sposato's idea of a four-week hold.
- 1:31:10 Scott asked Beale how much revenue the ordinance would bring in.
- 1:33:25 Cardona asked Beale whether the ordinance could be amended for PPA licenses.
- 1:33:35 Beale said he was open to amendments before the January 1 effective date.
- 1:37:55 Lawson said he agreed with nearly everything Reilly said but moved to hold the item to October.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error