Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, November 21, 2024
- When: Thu, Nov 21, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1031723947
- Transcript: full text (33,013 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 7:06 Public comment
- 11:53 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Technology and Innovation
- 23:35 Michael D. Rodriguez: Asked whether DTI has public-facing staff and raised language access capacity across…
- 26:13 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked what constituent relationship management tools will be available to ward offices so…
- 28:36 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked whether GIS mapping tools could be made available to ward offices to show residents…
- 31:25 Jason C. Ervin: Asked why DTI charges no personnel to enterprise funds such as water and aviation when it…
- 33:54 Jason C. Ervin: Asked where the ERP system replacement stands and what to expect over the next 6 to 18…
- 38:26 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked whether the CIO is comfortable with the city's cybersecurity and data protection.
- 40:24 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked DTI staff to visit his ward office to review its systems and improve services.
- 42:40 Timothy R. Knudsen: Described his office's internal tech portal and said there is a disconnect between 311…
- 43:37 Timothy R. Knudsen: Asked how DTI fits with OEMC as he drafts legislation to add CTA service requests to 311.
- 47:58 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked what is being done so council and COFA get departmental budget data in real time,…
- 51:36 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Requested a list of software used by the budget office and departments and how they…
- 52:31 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked why alderpersons can only see 311 data for their own wards and not citywide.
- 59:22 Emma Mitts: Requested a list of DTI's prime contractors and their subcontractors with participation…
- 1:02:19 Emma Mitts: Asked whether DTI will expand the Greater Grand Crossing tech apprenticeship program.
- 1:03:31 Emma Mitts: Asked how residents could access services without navigating between departments.
- 1:07:16 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked who manages the city website and said ward pages should be a first stop for…
- 1:11:27 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked DTI to work on website accessibility for older adults and people with vision…
- 1:12:52 William Conway: Commended the CIO for modernizing the department in a short time.
- 1:13:29 Jason C. Ervin: Asked DTI for a breakdown of contract spending by ethnic group and said 3% for African…
- 1:23:10 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Fleet and Facility Management
- 1:31:10 Samantha Nugent: Thanked 2FM for partnership on projects in her ward, including a fire station rehabilitation.
- 1:40:54 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked whether the snowplow and spreader fleet is ready and adequately staffed for repairs.
- 1:51:37 David H. Moore: Asked whether 2FM is on track to exceed last year's African American MBE spending.
- 1:55:07 David H. Moore: Asked whether the city saves more by leasing or owning facilities.
- 1:57:03 David H. Moore: Asked how many police vehicles are out of service and whether a reserve pool exists.
- 2:00:46 Marty Quinn: Asked how many mechanics 2FM is short.
- 2:02:12 Marty Quinn: Asked whether the hiring freeze affects hiring mechanics and suggested the council consider…
- 2:05:23 Marty Quinn: Said the council should be ready to help with pressure points before snow season and asked what…
- 2:11:29 Michael D. Rodriguez: Asked what share of the city fleet is now electric or hybrid.
- 2:16:39 Michael D. Rodriguez: Requested a list of electric vehicle manufacturers used by the city to review their…
- 2:25:10 Scott Waguespack: Asked whether new ambulances are advanced life support units.
- 2:25:34 Scott Waguespack: Asked about rental and leased vehicles with out-of-state plates and how many take-home…
- 2:27:48 Scott Waguespack: Asked for 2FM's oldest contracts not rebid in more than five years.
- 2:35:18 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked how 2FM prioritizes library maintenance, citing an aging Uptown library.
- 2:47:10 James M. Gardiner: Expressed gratitude to the commissioner and staff, including the graphics head, for…
- 2:48:38 William Conway: Confirmed that hybrid police vehicles recover their added cost through fuel savings in about…
- 2:49:34 William Conway: Asked where the renewable energy credits for the city's smaller buildings come from and…
- 3:00:08 Matthew J. Martin: Asked about 2FM's vacancies and whether any key impediments slow filling them.
- 3:04:08 Nicole T. Lee: Said recruitment is a widespread problem and building a mechanic pipeline will save money…
- 3:04:37 Nicole T. Lee: Asked where city charging stations are located and requested a map by ward, noting few…
- 3:06:30 Brendan Reilly: Said it was troubling that 2FM staff were not up to speed on energy procurement and urged…
- 3:07:31 Brendan Reilly: Said 2FM's 2025 initiatives were not bold given the department's growing corporate fund line…
- 3:09:14 Brendan Reilly: Asked how much 2FM spends on vacant lot remediation and its role in community gardens.
- 3:31:10 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked how nonprofits can obtain surplus city vehicles and what plans exist to make…
- 3:34:46 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked whether former ward yards are counted among vacant buildings and who maintains…
- 3:35:25 Stephanie D. Coleman: Flagged the former 16th Ward yard as a site of fly dumping and asked for better…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations continued its 2025 budget hearings with the Department of Technology and Innovation (DTI) in the morning and the Department of Fleet and Facility Management (2FM) in the afternoon, after one public commenter objected to proceeding with few members present. The Council Office of Financial Analysis reported a proposed DTI appropriation of $82.1 million, up 12%, and a 2FM appropriation of $558.3 million, down 5%. Members asked DTI about the ERP system replacement timeline, cybersecurity, constituent-service software for ward offices, real-time budget data, citywide 311 data access, and minority-owned business participation. 2FM questions covered mechanic shortages and the hiring freeze, fleet age and electrification, vacant city buildings, leasing versus owning, the Double Black Diamond solar agreement and electricity costs, environmental remediation of city lots, and MBE/WBE contract participation. The hearings were for review only; no votes were taken and both departments were excused subject to recall.
Topics: FY2025 budget, Department of Technology and Innovation, Fleet and Facility Management, ERP modernization, 311 data access, cybersecurity, fleet electrification, mechanic shortage, renewable energy, MBE/WBE participation
Agenda items discussed
- 7:06 Public comment: discussed
- 11:53 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Technology and Innovation: discussed
- 1:23:10 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Fleet and Facility Management: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Asked why DTI charges no personnel to enterprise funds such as water and aviation when it performs work for them, saying it would be fiscally appropriate to do so. (31:25); Asked where the ERP system replacement stands and what to expect over the next 6 to 18 months, saying it has taken too long. (33:54); Asked DTI for a breakdown of contract spending by ethnic group and said 3% for African American and Latino firms was too low and should reach double digits. (1:13:29)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson): Asked whether DTI has public-facing staff and raised language access capacity across departments. (23:35); Asked what share of the city fleet is now electric or hybrid. (2:11:29); Requested a list of electric vehicle manufacturers used by the city to review their labor practices and union status. (2:16:39)
- Ronnie L. Mosley (alderperson): Asked what constituent relationship management tools will be available to ward offices so systems can share information. (26:13); Asked whether GIS mapping tools could be made available to ward offices to show residents infrastructure work. (28:36); Asked how nonprofits can obtain surplus city vehicles and what plans exist to make environmentally contaminated land ready for development. (3:31:10)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Asked whether the CIO is comfortable with the city's cybersecurity and data protection. (38:26); Asked DTI staff to visit his ward office to review its systems and improve services. (40:24); Asked whether the snowplow and spreader fleet is ready and adequately staffed for repairs. (1:40:54)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Described his office's internal tech portal and said there is a disconnect between 311 and city software for ward offices. (42:40); Asked how DTI fits with OEMC as he drafts legislation to add CTA service requests to 311. (43:37)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked what is being done so council and COFA get departmental budget data in real time, saying the current timeline leaves too little time to assess the budget. (47:58); Requested a list of software used by the budget office and departments and how they connect. (51:36); Asked why alderpersons can only see 311 data for their own wards and not citywide. (52:31)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Requested a list of DTI's prime contractors and their subcontractors with participation percentages by ethnicity. (59:22); Asked whether DTI will expand the Greater Grand Crossing tech apprenticeship program. (1:02:19); Asked how residents could access services without navigating between departments. (1:03:31)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked who manages the city website and said ward pages should be a first stop for residents, calling uneven ward websites an equity issue. (1:07:16); Asked DTI to work on website accessibility for older adults and people with vision or hearing loss. (1:11:27); Asked how 2FM prioritizes library maintenance, citing an aging Uptown library. (2:35:18)
- William Conway (alderperson): Commended the CIO for modernizing the department in a short time. (1:12:52); Confirmed that hybrid police vehicles recover their added cost through fuel savings in about two years. (2:48:38); Asked where the renewable energy credits for the city's smaller buildings come from and whether the city is paid for credits from the solar farm. (2:49:34)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Thanked 2FM for partnership on projects in her ward, including a fire station rehabilitation. (1:31:10)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked whether 2FM is on track to exceed last year's African American MBE spending. (1:51:37); Asked whether the city saves more by leasing or owning facilities. (1:55:07); Asked how many police vehicles are out of service and whether a reserve pool exists. (1:57:03)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked how many mechanics 2FM is short. (2:00:46); Asked whether the hiring freeze affects hiring mechanics and suggested the council consider lifting it for mechanics. (2:02:12); Said the council should be ready to help with pressure points before snow season and asked what it could do. (2:05:23)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked whether new ambulances are advanced life support units. (2:25:10); Asked about rental and leased vehicles with out-of-state plates and how many take-home vehicles exist. (2:25:34); Asked for 2FM's oldest contracts not rebid in more than five years. (2:27:48)
- James M. Gardiner (alderperson): Expressed gratitude to the commissioner and staff, including the graphics head, for support of his ward. (2:47:10)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Asked about 2FM's vacancies and whether any key impediments slow filling them. (3:00:08)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said recruitment is a widespread problem and building a mechanic pipeline will save money long term. (3:04:08); Asked where city charging stations are located and requested a map by ward, noting few chargers in her ward. (3:04:37)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said it was troubling that 2FM staff were not up to speed on energy procurement and urged the city to leverage its purchasing power with state agencies. (3:06:30); Said 2FM's 2025 initiatives were not bold given the department's growing corporate fund line items. (3:07:31); Asked how much 2FM spends on vacant lot remediation and its role in community gardens. (3:09:14)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Asked whether former ward yards are counted among vacant buildings and who maintains them. (3:34:46); Flagged the former 16th Ward yard as a site of fly dumping and asked for better maintenance. (3:35:25)
Exchanges between members
- 42:40 Alderman Timothy R. Knudsen said his questions built on those of Alderman Ronnie L. Mosley about ward office technology.
- 1:06:42 Alderman Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth built on Alderman Emma Mitts question about helping residents access services.
- 1:40:10 The chair asked Alderman Emma Mitts whether a request was attached to her remarks, and she responded.
- 2:00:46 Alderman Marty Quinn picked up on Alderman Matthew J. O'Shea questions about mechanics.
- 2:18:54 The chair followed up on Alderman Michael D. Rodriguez questions about the hybrid sweeper.
- 2:47:55 The chair asked Alderman James M. Gardiner whether a request came with his praise.
- 3:04:17 Alderman Nicole T. Lee said she appreciated Alderman David H. Moore connecting 2FM with high school automotive programs.
- 3:06:37 Alderman Brendan Reilly agreed with the chair's earlier point about electricity aggregation and procurement.
- 3:28:24 The chair praised Alderman Emma Mitts development work near the Public Safety Training Center.
- 3:34:46 Alderman Stephanie D. Coleman followed up on Alderman Emma Mitts question about vacant city-owned properties.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error