# Johnson petition review runs a fifth day, and the challenge's own tally now has him about 900 signatures over the line

*By a consultant's running count, 73% of the challenged lines ruled on so far were struck. At that rate the Mayor finishes near 13,400 valid signatures, against 12,500 needed. The Board hasn't published a count; the hearing officer takes both cases Monday.*

By Chicago Politics · Updated Nov 22, 2026

The Chicago Board of Election Commissioners set a fifth day of its line-by-line records exam of Mayor Brandon Johnson's nominating petitions for 9 a.m. today, Sunday, and both objections to his papers go before Hearing Officer Linda R. Crane on Monday, [Chicago City Wire reported](https://chicagocitywire.com/chicago-board-sets-fifth-day-of-mayor-johnson-petition-review-as-consultant-puts-invalidation-rate-at-73-3). The newest figures from the challenge's side point to a narrow pass, not a removal, though they say it's too early to tell.

Why it matters: a candidate for mayor needs 12,500 valid signatures to make the Feb. 23 ballot. The Board hasn't published a tally, so every number here comes from one side and none is a finding. This follows [our Saturday story](/on-my-block/johnson-petition-review-day-four-25214-lines-challenged-hearings-monday).

## Saturday's count

From posts by political consultant Frank Calabrese, who has been tracking the exam for the challenge, as City Wire reported:

- **Lines ruled on:** 5,048 of 25,184 challenged lines, about 20%.
- **Result:** 3,702 objections sustained and 1,346 overruled, a 73.3% sustain rate overall and 73.1% on Saturday.
- **Saturday alone:** subtracting his Friday totals (2,964 sustained, 1,074 overruled), Saturday's rulings covered about 1,010 lines: 738 struck and 272 kept. That's our arithmetic.
- **His projection:** about 13,400 valid signatures, roughly 900 above the minimum. He wrote that it is "still too close" to say whether Johnson makes the ballot.

The base figures moved slightly. On Friday, City Wire reported 31,936 signatures filed and 25,214 challenged ([Friday's story](https://chicagocitywire.com/chicago-board-sets-fourth-day-of-review-of-mayor-brandon-johnson-s-petitions-as-consultant-puts-invalidation-rate-at-73-4)); Sunday's story uses 31,912 filed and 25,184 challenged, leaving 6,728 unchallenged. We use the newer numbers.

## The arithmetic

- If every unchallenged line stands, Johnson needs 5,772 of the 25,184 challenged lines, or 22.9%.
- So far 26.7% of ruled lines have been kept. Applied to all challenged lines, that gives about 13,440, which matches Calabrese's projection.
- About 20,100 challenged lines haven't been ruled on. Each percentage point in the keep rate on those lines is worth about 200 signatures.

That is not a forecast. Two things could move it a lot:

- **Whole-sheet objections.** The challenge also argues that some sheets were photocopied and some circulators were underage, City Wire reported. If sustained, those could strike entire sheets, including lines no one challenged one by one. They haven't been ruled on.
- **Appeals.** Disputed calls go to the hearing officer, who recommends a result to the Board, and either side can take the Board's decision to Cook County Circuit Court, [CBS Chicago reported](https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/mayor-brandon-johnson-ballot-challenge-board-of-elections-nominating-petitions/).

The campaign has its own figure: 32% of signatures examined on the first day were found valid, campaign sources told [ABC7 Chicago](https://abc7chicago.com/post/chicago-mayor-brandon-johnsons-campaign-says-petition-challenge-not-ballot-threat-signature-review-continues/20056365/) on Nov. 19, and it expected that rate to hold.

**Our count.** We counted 31,904 filled lines on the 3,301 sheets of Johnson's petition copy ([our mayor page](/elections/2027/mayor)). That's a count of lines, not valid signatures; it can't tell whether a signer is registered or signed twice, which is what the exam checks.

## Monday

- **9:30 a.m., 27-EB-MUN-013:** the case brought by three objectors including former state Sen. Rickey Hendon, who represents Willie Wilson's campaign in the challenge. This is the case under records exam.
- **10 a.m., 27-EB-MUN-006:** the second objection.

Both are before Crane in a 22nd-floor conference room, under a schedule the Board posted Saturday afternoon, City Wire reported. Neither is on the Board's agenda for Tuesday, Nov. 24. We don't name objectors who are private residents.

Twelve of the 16 mayoral candidates on the Board's list are marked as challenged; Wilson, Matt Brewer, Joe Holberg and George A. Cardenas are not, City Wire reported.

## What's next

- **Dec. 17:** last day for the Board to certify the ballot.
- **Feb. 23:** Election Day; **April 6:** a runoff if no one tops 50%.

Rulings will appear on our [objections page](/elections/2027/objections) when the Board posts them.


## Sources

1. chicagocitywire.com: [Chicago City Wire reported](https://chicagocitywire.com/chicago-board-sets-fifth-day-of-mayor-johnson-petition-review-as-consultant-puts-invalidation-rate-at-73-3)
2. chicagocitywire.com: [Friday's story](https://chicagocitywire.com/chicago-board-sets-fourth-day-of-review-of-mayor-brandon-johnson-s-petitions-as-consultant-puts-invalidation-rate-at-73-4)
3. CBS News: [CBS Chicago reported](https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/mayor-brandon-johnson-ballot-challenge-board-of-elections-nominating-petitions/)
4. ABC7: [ABC7 Chicago](https://abc7chicago.com/post/chicago-mayor-brandon-johnsons-campaign-says-petition-challenge-not-ballot-threat-signature-review-continues/20056365/)

---
Source: https://www.chicagopolitics.org/on-my-block/johnson-petition-review-day-five-challenge-tally-900-over-hearings-monday · Chicago Politics, an independent tracker of the Chicago City Council. Guide for agents: https://www.chicagopolitics.org/llms.txt
