# Line-by-line review of Mayor Johnson's petitions goes on with no ruling; 12 of 16 mayoral candidates face challenges

*Willie Wilson's campaign says it is winning the records exam; Johnson's campaign says it will beat the challenge. Our count of his petition copy: 31,904 filled lines, against a 12,500-signature minimum.*

By Chicago Politics · Updated Nov 19, 2026

Hearing officers at the Chicago Board of Election Commissioners are still checking Mayor Brandon Johnson's nominating petitions signature by signature against the voter rolls, and no ruling has been issued, [NBC Chicago reported](https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/painstaking-review-of-challenge-to-chicago-mayor-brandon-johnson-continues/4018628/) Wednesday evening. Twelve of the 16 people who filed for mayor face challenges to their papers, NBC reported. Rulings are expected "in coming days."

Why it matters: a sustained objection removes a candidate from the Feb. 23 ballot. NBC reported Johnson is the first sitting Chicago mayor to have his petitions challenged. The Board must certify the ballot by Dec. 17.

## How the review works

In a records exam, a representative of the objector and one of the candidate sit across a table from a Board hearing officer and go through each line, NBC reported. A signature counts only if it belongs to a registered voter, matches the signature on file, and the voter hasn't signed another mayoral candidate's petition this cycle.

## What each side says

- **The challenge.** Former state Sen. Rickey Hendon, who represents Willie Wilson's campaign, told NBC the main allegations so far concern voter registration and whether signatures are genuine: "We haven't even gotten to photocopies, duplicates, and we're beating him hands down on registration or signatures." Wilson is also a candidate for mayor.
- **NBC's own reporting** found some sheets that appeared to be photocopies, which it said election law prohibits, and some that had previously been submitted for City Treasurer Melissa Conyears-Ervin.
- **Johnson's campaign** has repeatedly said it is confident it will defeat the challenge, NBC reported. It has said it filed "more than enough" signatures.

These are claims made during a hearing, not findings. Only the hearing officer's recommendation and the Board's ruling decide the question.

## Who else is challenged

NBC listed Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias, Comptroller Susana Mendoza, Cook County Treasurer Maria Pappas, U.S. Rep. Mike Quigley, Danielle Carter-Williams, Lisa Nee, John Kelly, William Quinlan, John Kitover, Zoe Ma and Jesse Maronto, with hearings ongoing for several. Carter-Williams told NBC that if Johnson stays on, "everybody has to be on that ballot." Nee called the process "big money, cheap threats and same old bullying."

Separately, an objection argues that Giannoulias, Quigley and Pappas can't run while holding their current offices ([our story](/on-my-block/incompatible-offices-objection-giannoulias-quigley-pappas-electoral-board)).

## What our records add

**Our count of Johnson's copy.** We counted 31,904 filled-in signature lines on all 3,301 sheets of the petition copy the Board provided with his Oct. 23 filing ([our mayor page](/elections/2027/mayor)). That is a count of lines, not of valid signatures: it can't tell whether a signer is registered, signed twice, signed another mayoral petition or was photocopied, which is exactly what the records exam checks. It is about 2.6 times the 12,500 minimum.

**The others, for comparison.** On our counts of complete copies, Quigley filed 41,587 lines, Kelly 35,993 and Wilson 28,546. Our copies of Giannoulias' and Mendoza's petitions are missing sheets, so their counts are incomplete and we make no claim about them.

We found no public schedule for rulings. The Board's website, where it posts decisions, returned an access error to us from Nov. 2 through at least Nov. 15 ([our roundup](/on-my-block/2027-petition-objections-no-rulings-yet-ward-by-ward-where-they-stand)). Rulings will show on our [objections page](/elections/2027/objections) when we can reach the Board's list.

## What's next

- Hearing officers send recommendations to the Board, which rules. A losing candidate can appeal to Cook County Circuit Court.
- **Dec. 17:** last day to withdraw; the Board certifies the ballot.
- **Feb. 23:** Election Day; a runoff April 6 if no one tops 50%.


## Sources

1. NBC Chicago: [NBC Chicago reported](https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/painstaking-review-of-challenge-to-chicago-mayor-brandon-johnson-continues/4018628/)

---
Source: https://www.chicagopolitics.org/on-my-block/johnson-petition-challenge-line-by-line-review-12-of-16-mayor-candidates · Chicago Politics, an independent tracker of the Chicago City Council. Guide for agents: https://www.chicagopolitics.org/llms.txt
