Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, October 16, 2023
- When: Mon, Oct 16, 2023, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576
- Transcript: full text (20,379 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 35:30 Jason C. Ervin: Explained that written comment can go to the committee email and that public comment would…
- 36:03 Public comment procedure for budget hearings
- 37:13 Anthony Beale: Asked why public comment would be held at the end of each meeting rather than at the start.
- 37:24 Jason C. Ervin: Responded that public comment at the end of each day was at the discretion of the chair.
- 37:36 Anthony Beale: Said he disagreed and that the public should be heard first rather than waiting six or seven…
- 47:44 Public comment
- 47:44 Jason C. Ervin: Announced that after conferring with the Rules committee and the Sergeant at Arms, public…
- 57:05 Opening statements: Budget Director, Chief Financial Officer and Comptroller on the proposed 2024 budget
- 1:20:58 COFA overview of Finance General and Department of Finance budgets
- 1:31:22 David H. Moore: Asked whether members would receive the full COFA presentation deck.
- 1:31:53 Member questions on Finance General, Office of Budget and Management and Department of Finance budgets
- 1:32:02 Nicole T. Lee: Asked for details on what makes up the operational efficiencies used to close the budget gap.
- 1:34:20 Nicole T. Lee: Asked what made up the $41.5 million in personnel savings.
- 1:35:43 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether the healthcare savings would affect employee benefits.
- 1:44:57 Emma Mitts: Thanked the budget director for pre-budget outreach and asked about the status and expansion of…
- 1:48:00 Emma Mitts: Asked about plans to open more mental health clinics and who is on the working group choosing…
- 1:49:00 Emma Mitts: Asked where funding for new arrivals would come from and how much was currently available.
- 1:56:33 Brendan Reilly: Asked why the budget office does not use zero-based budgeting by department, which he said…
- 1:59:01 Brendan Reilly: Requested the total number of funded vacant positions carried into 2024, vacancies…
- 1:59:41 Brendan Reilly: Asked whether departments were directed to model 4 or 5 percent spending cuts.
- 2:10:35 Walter R. Burnett: Raised concern about the TIF surplus in his ward and wanted to ensure planned ward…
- 2:11:29 Walter R. Burnett: Said a prior policy for added affordable housing funding in a TIF district had not been…
- 2:12:12 Walter R. Burnett: Asked where neighborhood opportunity fund money owed back to his ward stands.
- 2:18:36 Pat Dowell: Asked the budget director for a single new arrivals budget showing programs, amounts, staffing…
- 2:20:08 Pat Dowell: Asked for a breakdown of the $100 million for anti-violence efforts, including gender-based…
- 2:22:09 Pat Dowell: Asked whether COFA's report that CDBG funding was zeroed out meant the program was ending.
- 2:31:50 Marty Quinn: Asked the total number of police on the job, how many could retire next year and how many could…
- 2:33:06 Marty Quinn: Asked whether the 400 civilianized police positions are union positions and what they are.
- 2:34:54 Marty Quinn: Asked whether retired officers could qualify for the civilian positions.
- 2:41:44 David H. Moore: Said the debt relief programs depended on property tax increases tied to CPI and stated that…
- 2:43:00 David H. Moore: Asked what one-time, non-recurring revenue sources are in the proposed budget and requested…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations opened its 2024 departmental budget hearings with the Budget Director, Chief Financial Officer and Comptroller, followed by a Council Office of Financial Analysis (COFA) overview of Finance General and the Department of Finance. After a disruption and recess, the chair allowed public comment before the presentations. Members asked about how the projected $538 million gap was closed, operational and healthcare savings, revenue reforecasts, TIF surplus, funding for the new arrivals mission, contractor payment delays, youth employment, mental health clinics, debt relief programs, police staffing and the costs of new departments. Many requests for further information were made through the chair, and the committee recessed for lunch; no votes were taken in this portion of the hearing.
Topics: 2024 budget, budget gap, new arrivals funding, TIF surplus, contractor payment delays, debt relief programs, youth employment, police staffing, ARPA spending, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 36:03 Public comment procedure for budget hearings: discussed
- 47:44 Public comment: discussed
- 57:05 Opening statements: Budget Director, Chief Financial Officer and Comptroller on the proposed 2024 budget: discussed
- 1:20:58 COFA overview of Finance General and Department of Finance budgets: discussed
- 1:31:53 Member questions on Finance General, Office of Budget and Management and Department of Finance budgets: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Explained that written comment can go to the committee email and that public comment would be taken at the end of each hearing day. (35:30); Responded that public comment at the end of each day was at the discretion of the chair. (37:24); Announced that after conferring with the Rules committee and the Sergeant at Arms, public comment would proceed at that time with three minutes per speaker. (47:44)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked for details on what makes up the operational efficiencies used to close the budget gap. (1:32:02); Asked what made up the $41.5 million in personnel savings. (1:34:20); Asked whether the healthcare savings would affect employee benefits. (1:35:43)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked why public comment would be held at the end of each meeting rather than at the start. (37:13); Said he disagreed and that the public should be heard first rather than waiting six or seven hours. (37:36)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked whether members would receive the full COFA presentation deck. (1:31:22); Said the debt relief programs depended on property tax increases tied to CPI and stated that keeping up with CPI is the only way to pay for these programs. (2:41:44); Asked what one-time, non-recurring revenue sources are in the proposed budget and requested a full list. (2:43:00)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Thanked the budget director for pre-budget outreach and asked about the status and expansion of youth employment programs and their agencies. (1:44:57); Asked about plans to open more mental health clinics and who is on the working group choosing locations. (1:48:00); Asked where funding for new arrivals would come from and how much was currently available. (1:49:00)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked why the budget office does not use zero-based budgeting by department, which he said he has advocated since 2007. (1:56:33); Requested the total number of funded vacant positions carried into 2024, vacancies eliminated, and a list of funded vacancies with salaries. (1:59:01); Asked whether departments were directed to model 4 or 5 percent spending cuts. (1:59:41)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Raised concern about the TIF surplus in his ward and wanted to ensure planned ward projects and possible convention needs are covered. (2:10:35); Said a prior policy for added affordable housing funding in a TIF district had not been met and that the money should go to affordable housing rather than surplus. (2:11:29); Asked where neighborhood opportunity fund money owed back to his ward stands. (2:12:12)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked the budget director for a single new arrivals budget showing programs, amounts, staffing and funding sources. (2:18:36); Asked for a breakdown of the $100 million for anti-violence efforts, including gender-based violence and the Community Safety Coordinating Center. (2:20:08); Asked whether COFA's report that CDBG funding was zeroed out meant the program was ending. (2:22:09)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked the total number of police on the job, how many could retire next year and how many could be hired. (2:31:50); Asked whether the 400 civilianized police positions are union positions and what they are. (2:33:06); Asked whether retired officers could qualify for the civilian positions. (2:34:54)
Exchanges between members
- 37:13 Beale asked the chair why public comment would be held at the end of each day.
- 37:24 The chair replied that the timing of public comment was at the chair's discretion.
- 37:36 Beale told the chair he disagreed with holding public comment at the end of the day.
- 1:31:31 The chair told Moore the full COFA deck would be sent electronically.
- 1:31:53 Moore thanked the chair.
- 1:44:42 The chair thanked Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee after her questions.
- 1:56:26 Mitts thanked the chair at the end of her questions.
- 1:56:29 The chair thanked Mitts.
- 2:10:26 The chair thanked Reilly and asked if he wanted to sign up for a second round.
- 2:17:56 In response to Burnett's point, the chair asked staff for figures on delegate agency funding and positions for returning residents.
- 2:19:49 The chair told Dowell that information requested through the chair would be shared with all members.
- 2:31:22 The chair thanked Dowell.
- 2:32:23 The chair interjected during Quinn's police staffing questions to say the numbers must be known that day.
- 2:32:51 Quinn thanked the chair.
- 2:33:29 Quinn thanked the chair for holding his time.
- 2:40:58 The chair thanked Quinn.
- 2:51:59 Moore asked the chair to be placed on the list for a second round.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error