Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, October 21, 2025
- When: Tue, Oct 21, 2025, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576?video=1129034950
- Transcript: full text (65,019 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 9:18 Public comment
- 21:02 Motion for Rule 59 participation by non-members
- 30:58 Opening statements by the Budget Director, CFO and Comptroller on the proposed 2026 budget
- 50:12 Round one of member questions to the Office of Budget and Management and Department of Finance
- 50:34 Anthony Beale: Asked the CFO why a property tax increase was no longer proposed and whether a smaller…
- 53:23 Anthony Beale: Asked how much of the TIF surplus goes to CPS and whether the budget depends on a CPS…
- 55:26 Anthony Beale: Asked whether the city is confident the social media tax would withstand a legal challenge.
- 1:03:08 Michelle A. Harris: Said the TIF sweep does not account for future projects and could end planned projects…
- 1:04:55 Michelle A. Harris: Said alderpersons should have been told their TIFs would be swept before the hearing.
- 1:09:03 Michelle A. Harris: Asked about funding for the Buildings Department demolition fund and said it is…
- 1:13:13 Jason C. Ervin: Said about 70% of the TIF surplus comes from disadvantaged areas and that the budget will…
- 1:15:25 Michael D. Rodriguez: Asked where the social media tax appears in the code and when collections would begin.
- 1:16:18 Michael D. Rodriguez: Said he could not support a budget balanced on the backs of the city workforce.
- 1:16:53 Michael D. Rodriguez: Asked how many lost positions are due to expiring federal relief funds versus federal…
- 1:25:30 Nicole T. Lee: Said the scale of the TIF surplus was a shock and that ward-level conversations had not…
- 1:26:12 Nicole T. Lee: Said the sweep would delay a Donovan Park field house and Pilsen Industrial TIF affordable…
- 1:29:05 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how the 2025 shortfall from the missed CPS pension payment will be covered.
- 1:36:14 Brendan Reilly: Asked how confident the city is in its legal standing for the social media tax and whether…
- 1:37:19 Brendan Reilly: Asked how relying on a roughly $1 billion TIF surplus squares with claims of stable revenue.
- 1:38:52 Brendan Reilly: Questioned the budget director's proposed 8.29% raise and asked for a list of non-union…
- 1:47:28 Debra L. Silverstein: Asked how much reducing the pension advance from $260 million to $120 million will…
- 1:48:06 Marty Quinn: Asked whether the budget includes a contribution to the rainy day fund.
- 1:49:13 Marty Quinn: Said raises above 5% and many employees earning over $200,000 erode taxpayer trust during a…
- 1:50:46 Marty Quinn: Said the 13th Ward should be included in flood relief.
- 1:54:49 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked whether discussions with Cook County on consolidating redundant functions had…
- 1:56:37 Jason C. Ervin: Said Cook County officials have shown no interest in taking on city functions without…
- 1:58:02 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked what the city has accomplished in Springfield and said the administration needs a…
- 1:59:23 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked what financial impact the delayed property tax bills will have on the budget.
- 2:03:25 Jason C. Ervin: Encouraged members to review their TIF reports, including a ten-year outlook, to understand…
- 2:04:27 Nicholas Sposato: Thanked the budget team and noted record attendance by members on the opening day of…
- 2:05:31 Pat Dowell: Said every alderperson should review TIF surplus reports with DPD and the budget office, citing…
- 2:06:02 Pat Dowell: Asked about the process and timing for distributing TIF surplus to special service areas.
- 2:08:17 Pat Dowell: Asked which community safety fund items are new initiatives, saying new spending should be…
- 2:15:43 Debra L. Silverstein: Said anything that could cause a credit downgrade is a major concern to her.
- 2:16:01 Debra L. Silverstein: Asked how many Chicago Public Library positions are being cut and whether Sunday hours…
- 2:18:54 Raymond A. Lopez: Said the TIF sweeps are a non-starter for him, citing $3.3 million from Back of the Yards…
- 2:19:52 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked how much budget revenue depends on taxes that do not yet exist.
- 2:23:24 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked whether the reduction in police and fire survivor payments was made to balance the…
- 2:31:20 David H. Moore: Asked whether reentry environment funds could support a Keep Chicago Clean campaign.
- 2:34:20 David H. Moore: Asked how to keep the head tax from hurting small franchise operators with 100 or more…
- 2:38:48 David H. Moore: Requested an analysis of the financial impact of the partial pension payment, especially if…
- 2:45:07 Gilbert Villegas: Asked why the city has not implemented an automated time and attendance system, citing…
- 2:46:51 Gilbert Villegas: Said the stalled ERP project lacks urgency despite more than $100 million in potential…
- 2:49:43 Gilbert Villegas: Asked how many lines of credit the city has, their balances and interest rates.
- 2:56:40 Felix Cardona Jr.: Said the TIF surplus sweep is detrimental to Northwest Side TIF districts with planned…
- 2:58:06 Felix Cardona Jr.: Asked how rising fines and fees revenue squares with the mayor's promise to reduce…
- 3:01:01 Felix Cardona Jr.: Said expanding the rideshare congestion zone burdens working-class commuters.
- 4:25:42 Samantha Nugent: Asked about the increase in Department of Environment positions and funding.
- 4:28:02 Samantha Nugent: Asked how the $2 per unit hemp tax was set and whether $10 million in six months is…
- 4:32:30 Samantha Nugent: Asked why the CARE program is budgeted in the corporate fund while reimbursed with federal…
- 4:36:55 Anthony J. Quezada: Praised the budget for avoiding property tax, grocery tax and garbage fee increases and…
- 4:38:02 Anthony J. Quezada: Said higher taxes on wealthy corporations are responsible policymaking given record…
- 4:39:33 Anthony J. Quezada: Asked why the head tax is needed despite corporate philanthropy for public safety.
- 4:46:54 Matthew J. Martin: Asked what share of the 2025 and 2026 gap closings are structural versus one-time.
- 4:47:40 Matthew J. Martin: Asked the CFO to confirm a downgrade could add about $410 to $415 million in borrowing…
- 4:48:46 Matthew J. Martin: Read rating agency statements and said the reduced pension advance, one-time fixes and…
- 4:59:11 Byron Sigcho-López: Said he supports commitments to fund CPS through the TIF surplus and asked about the CPS…
- 5:03:22 Byron Sigcho-López: Said the city has a revenue problem rather than a spending problem and asked about…
- 5:07:03 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked how an oversight body would address police overtime and chronic vacancies.
- 5:10:35 Monique L. Scott: Asked how much of the federal cut to community violence intervention funding affects…
- 5:11:13 Monique L. Scott: Asked whether OBM discussed with DPD how the TIF sweep would affect current and future…
- 5:13:13 Monique L. Scott: Read the governor's statement opposing a Chicago head tax and asked what the city would do…
- 5:24:51 William Conway: Noted the LaSalle Central TIF's projected revenue fell from $192 million to $125 million and…
- 5:26:41 William Conway: Asked why $163 million set aside for firefighter retro pay is not available and the city…
- 5:34:56 William Conway: Said the head tax math implies about 400,000 affected employees and asked for clarification.
- 5:58:11 Scott Waguespack: Requested the Department of Law analysis of the social media tax be shared through the…
- 5:58:31 Scott Waguespack: Said bonds deferring interest for 20 years contradict the tax-the-rich message and asked…
- 6:00:09 Scott Waguespack: Asked why consultant recommendations like special event cost recovery are not implemented…
- 6:09:38 Ruth Cruz: Expressed concern about one of her TIFs being surplused and asked how the remaining surplus is…
- 6:12:23 Ruth Cruz: Asked for a breakdown showing what was set aside and what is being borrowed for the fire contract.
- 6:14:06 Ruth Cruz: Said residents are concerned about the partial pension payment and asked what consultants have…
- 6:16:51 Daniel La Spata: Asked the odds that pension funds would need to sell assets in 2026 with a reduced advance…
- 6:19:16 Daniel La Spata: Asked when bond authorizations for settlements and the Local 2 retro pay will be voted on…
- 6:20:33 Daniel La Spata: Asked what can be learned from other cities with head taxes and why the tax applies to all…
- 6:28:05 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked how the late property tax bills affect the city's bottom line.
- 6:29:43 Lamont J. Robinson: Asked how the city can assist special service areas facing cash shortfalls.
- 6:32:01 Lamont J. Robinson: Raised concern about the TIF sweep's effect on 4th Ward projects.
- 6:39:32 Gregory I. Mitchell: Asked what instructions departments received on eliminating positions and how…
- 6:42:09 Gregory I. Mitchell: Requested a list of cut positions by department, classification and vacancy length.
- 6:43:03 Gregory I. Mitchell: Asked how much of the savings from cuts is offset by scheduled raises.
- 6:50:29 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked how eliminating five procurement field analyst union positions fits the claim of no…
- 6:52:35 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked whether corporations that raised $100 million for violence prevention will continue…
- 6:53:55 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked what alderpersons could do collectively to share in budget sacrifice.
- 7:01:04 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked about lower red light ticket volume and the Smart Streets expansion's revenue in…
- 7:03:29 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked what the congestion fee expansion will raise and suggested extending it to the…
- 7:03:59 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked about special event cost recovery and who pays CPD traffic management bills.
- 7:12:17 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked to confirm Chicago Legal Protection Fund funding will be maintained at last…
- 7:13:37 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked whether the body will be briefed on the legal analysis of the social media tax…
- 7:16:29 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked whether a percentage-based head tax was considered.
- 7:22:26 Jeylú B. Gutiérrez: Urged funding the legal protection fund at the $3 million level its providers requested.
- 7:23:01 Round two of member questions
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
This was the first day of Committee on Budget and Government Operations hearings on the Mayor's proposed 2026 budget, which presenters called the Protecting Chicago Budget. After three public commenters spoke, Budget Director Annette Guzman, the Chief Financial Officer and Comptroller Michael Belski described a $1.189 billion projected gap closed without a property tax increase. The plan uses new revenues such as a community safety surcharge (head tax), a social media amusement tax and online sports wagering, along with a roughly $1 billion TIF surplus, a hiring freeze and a reduced advance pension payment. Members questioned the size of the TIF surplus and its effect on ward projects, the head tax, the risk of a credit downgrade from the smaller pension advance, borrowing $166 million for firefighter retroactive pay, position cuts, and fines and fees revenue. The chair said the budget would not leave the committee without a signed intergovernmental agreement with Chicago Public Schools, and the committee recessed until the next morning without voting.
Topics: 2026 budget, TIF surplus, community safety surcharge (head tax), advance pension payment, credit rating, social media tax, firefighter retroactive pay borrowing, hiring freeze and position cuts, fines and fees, CPS intergovernmental agreement
Agenda items discussed
- 9:18 Public comment: discussed
- 21:02 Motion for Rule 59 participation by non-members: passed
- 30:58 Opening statements by the Budget Director, CFO and Comptroller on the proposed 2026 budget: discussed
- 50:12 Round one of member questions to the Office of Budget and Management and Department of Finance: discussed
- 7:23:01 Round two of member questions: discussed
- 8:40:10 Recess until Wednesday at 9:30 a.m.
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Said about 70% of the TIF surplus comes from disadvantaged areas and that the budget will not leave the committee without a signed CPS intergovernmental agreement on pension obligations. (1:13:13); Said Cook County officials have shown no interest in taking on city functions without revenue to support them. (1:56:37); Encouraged members to review their TIF reports, including a ten-year outlook, to understand the surplus impact on their wards. (2:03:25)
- Anthony Beale (alderperson): Asked the CFO why a property tax increase was no longer proposed and whether a smaller pension advance would lead to a downgrade. (50:34); Asked how much of the TIF surplus goes to CPS and whether the budget depends on a CPS reimbursement. (53:23); Asked whether the city is confident the social media tax would withstand a legal challenge. (55:26)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Said the TIF sweep does not account for future projects and could end planned projects in her ward and communities of color. (1:03:08); Said alderpersons should have been told their TIFs would be swept before the hearing. (1:04:55); Asked about funding for the Buildings Department demolition fund and said it is important to her ward. (1:09:03)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson): Asked where the social media tax appears in the code and when collections would begin. (1:15:25); Said he could not support a budget balanced on the backs of the city workforce. (1:16:18); Asked how many lost positions are due to expiring federal relief funds versus federal administration cuts. (1:16:53)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said the scale of the TIF surplus was a shock and that ward-level conversations had not occurred. (1:25:30); Said the sweep would delay a Donovan Park field house and Pilsen Industrial TIF affordable housing plans. (1:26:12); Asked how the 2025 shortfall from the missed CPS pension payment will be covered. (1:29:05)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked how confident the city is in its legal standing for the social media tax and whether outside counsel was consulted. (1:36:14); Asked how relying on a roughly $1 billion TIF surplus squares with claims of stable revenue. (1:37:19); Questioned the budget director's proposed 8.29% raise and asked for a list of non-union positions receiving raises. (1:38:52)
- Debra L. Silverstein (alderperson): Asked how much reducing the pension advance from $260 million to $120 million will cost the city in the future. (1:47:28); Said anything that could cause a credit downgrade is a major concern to her. (2:15:43); Asked how many Chicago Public Library positions are being cut and whether Sunday hours will be reduced. (2:16:01)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked whether the budget includes a contribution to the rainy day fund. (1:48:06); Said raises above 5% and many employees earning over $200,000 erode taxpayer trust during a deficit. (1:49:13); Said the 13th Ward should be included in flood relief. (1:50:46)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Asked whether discussions with Cook County on consolidating redundant functions had progressed, saying he was never invited. (1:54:49); Asked what the city has accomplished in Springfield and said the administration needs a concise state agenda. (1:58:02); Asked what financial impact the delayed property tax bills will have on the budget. (1:59:23)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Thanked the budget team and noted record attendance by members on the opening day of hearings. (2:04:27)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Said every alderperson should review TIF surplus reports with DPD and the budget office, citing two TIFs in her ward. (2:05:31); Asked about the process and timing for distributing TIF surplus to special service areas. (2:06:02); Asked which community safety fund items are new initiatives, saying new spending should be limited. (2:08:17)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Said the TIF sweeps are a non-starter for him, citing $3.3 million from Back of the Yards and Canaryville. (2:18:54); Asked how much budget revenue depends on taxes that do not yet exist. (2:19:52); Asked whether the reduction in police and fire survivor payments was made to balance the budget. (2:23:24)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked whether reentry environment funds could support a Keep Chicago Clean campaign. (2:31:20); Asked how to keep the head tax from hurting small franchise operators with 100 or more mostly part-time employees. (2:34:20); Requested an analysis of the financial impact of the partial pension payment, especially if a downgrade occurs. (2:38:48)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked why the city has not implemented an automated time and attendance system, citing potential savings. (2:45:07); Said the stalled ERP project lacks urgency despite more than $100 million in potential savings. (2:46:51); Asked how many lines of credit the city has, their balances and interest rates. (2:49:43)
- Felix Cardona Jr. (alderperson): Said the TIF surplus sweep is detrimental to Northwest Side TIF districts with planned projects. (2:56:40); Asked how rising fines and fees revenue squares with the mayor's promise to reduce regressive fines. (2:58:06); Said expanding the rideshare congestion zone burdens working-class commuters. (3:01:01)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Asked about the increase in Department of Environment positions and funding. (4:25:42); Asked how the $2 per unit hemp tax was set and whether $10 million in six months is realistic. (4:28:02); Asked why the CARE program is budgeted in the corporate fund while reimbursed with federal relief funds. (4:32:30)
- Anthony J. Quezada (alderperson): Praised the budget for avoiding property tax, grocery tax and garbage fee increases and layoffs. (4:36:55); Said higher taxes on wealthy corporations are responsible policymaking given record profits. (4:38:02); Asked why the head tax is needed despite corporate philanthropy for public safety. (4:39:33)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Asked what share of the 2025 and 2026 gap closings are structural versus one-time. (4:46:54); Asked the CFO to confirm a downgrade could add about $410 to $415 million in borrowing costs. (4:47:40); Read rating agency statements and said the reduced pension advance, one-time fixes and bonds for back pay invite a downgrade. (4:48:46)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Said he supports commitments to fund CPS through the TIF surplus and asked about the CPS agreement process. (4:59:11); Said the city has a revenue problem rather than a spending problem and asked about state-level revenue options. (5:03:22); Asked how an oversight body would address police overtime and chronic vacancies. (5:07:03)
- Monique L. Scott (alderperson): Asked how much of the federal cut to community violence intervention funding affects Chicago groups. (5:10:35); Asked whether OBM discussed with DPD how the TIF sweep would affect current and future projects. (5:11:13); Read the governor's statement opposing a Chicago head tax and asked what the city would do if the state acts. (5:13:13)
- William Conway (alderperson): Noted the LaSalle Central TIF's projected revenue fell from $192 million to $125 million and asked what is driving it. (5:24:51); Asked why $163 million set aside for firefighter retro pay is not available and the city must borrow. (5:26:41); Said the head tax math implies about 400,000 affected employees and asked for clarification. (5:34:56)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Requested the Department of Law analysis of the social media tax be shared through the chair. (5:58:11); Said bonds deferring interest for 20 years contradict the tax-the-rich message and asked for the long-term cost of the reduced pension advance. (5:58:31); Asked why consultant recommendations like special event cost recovery are not implemented immediately. (6:00:09)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Expressed concern about one of her TIFs being surplused and asked how the remaining surplus is distributed. (6:09:38); Asked for a breakdown showing what was set aside and what is being borrowed for the fire contract. (6:12:23); Said residents are concerned about the partial pension payment and asked what consultants have advised. (6:14:06)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked the odds that pension funds would need to sell assets in 2026 with a reduced advance payment. (6:16:51); Asked when bond authorizations for settlements and the Local 2 retro pay will be voted on and how they will be repaid. (6:19:16); Asked what can be learned from other cities with head taxes and why the tax applies to all employees once a firm passes 100. (6:20:33)
- Lamont J. Robinson (alderperson): Asked how the late property tax bills affect the city's bottom line. (6:28:05); Asked how the city can assist special service areas facing cash shortfalls. (6:29:43); Raised concern about the TIF sweep's effect on 4th Ward projects. (6:32:01)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (alderperson): Asked what instructions departments received on eliminating positions and how efficiency targets were evaluated. (6:39:32); Requested a list of cut positions by department, classification and vacancy length. (6:42:09); Asked how much of the savings from cuts is offset by scheduled raises. (6:43:03)
- Ronnie L. Mosley (alderperson): Asked how eliminating five procurement field analyst union positions fits the claim of no operational layoffs. (6:50:29); Asked whether corporations that raised $100 million for violence prevention will continue that participation. (6:52:35); Asked what alderpersons could do collectively to share in budget sacrifice. (6:53:55)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked about lower red light ticket volume and the Smart Streets expansion's revenue in his ward. (7:01:04); Asked what the congestion fee expansion will raise and suggested extending it to the lakefront. (7:03:29); Asked about special event cost recovery and who pays CPD traffic management bills. (7:03:59)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked to confirm Chicago Legal Protection Fund funding will be maintained at last year's level. (7:12:17); Asked whether the body will be briefed on the legal analysis of the social media tax and how social media is defined. (7:13:37); Asked whether a percentage-based head tax was considered. (7:16:29)
- Jeylú B. Gutiérrez (alderperson): Urged funding the legal protection fund at the $3 million level its providers requested. (7:22:26)
Exchanges between members
- 29:08 The chair explained the speaking order in response to Alderperson Anthony Beale question about who goes first.
- 1:13:20 The chair built on Chair Michelle A. Harris point about where TIF surplus dollars come from.
- 1:25:30 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee said she was picking up where Chair Michelle A. Harris left off on TIF concerns.
- 1:48:06 Alderperson Marty Quinn said he was picking up where Alderperson Brendan Reilly left off.
- 1:56:37 The chair added that Cook County officials have shown no interest in taking on city functions.
- 1:57:41 Alderperson Matthew J. O'Shea said the chair's comment reinforced his point about the lack of progress with the county.
- 2:05:31 Chair Pat Dowell said she was glad the chair raised the TIF surplus reports.
- 4:39:13 The chair asked Alderperson Anthony J. Quezada whether he had a question.
- 4:57:18 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee asked the chair to check that members received responses to mid-year through-the-chair requests.
- 4:57:35 The chair said mid-year responses were sent to requesting members and posted on the committee website.
- 5:03:10 Alderperson Byron Sigcho-López thanked the chair for attending the Board of Education meeting.
- 5:13:57 Alderperson Anthony Beale told the chair that the state could preempt the city's head tax authority.
- 5:14:05 The chair said preemption is a different matter from a veto of council action.
- 5:21:33 The chair followed up on Alderperson Monique L. Scott point about subcontractor payment delays.
- 5:39:41 Alderperson William Conway told the chair his questions on the retro pay were good ones.
- 5:39:46 The chair said the set-aside funds were absorbed by overexpenditures, mainly overtime.
- 6:34:28 Alderperson Lamont J. Robinson asked the chair whether he would bring CPS before the council.
- 6:35:41 Alderperson Lamont J. Robinson said he would support the chair's effort to bring CPS in.
- 7:22:26 Alderperson Jeylú B. Gutiérrez reiterated Alderperson Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth request on legal protection funding.
- 7:33:45 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee followed up on the layoff question Alderperson Ronnie L. Mosley raised.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error