Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards meeting, May 21, 2024
- When: Tue, May 21, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928576/video/948399335
- Transcript: full text (40,582 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 21:21 Deferral of listed items, including Napolitano text amendment on vacant buildings
- 24:18 Public comment
- 50:11 Appointment of Adrian Soto to the Zoning Board of Appeals
- 52:39 David H. Moore: Said he has worked with Adrian Soto for several years and supported his appointment to the…
- 53:32 Timothy R. Knudsen: Congratulated the ZBA appointee and asked how he would balance community opposition…
- 56:02 Appointment of Tanya Kadakia to the Chicago Plan Commission
- 56:17 Appointment of Kamina Brooks to the Chicago Plan Commission
- 1:01:18 Daniel La Spata: Welcomed the Plan Commission appointees and asked Kamina Brooks how her urban design degree…
- 1:04:32 Lamont J. Robinson: Commended Kamina Brooks, citing work with Community Builders in the 4th Ward.
- 1:05:38 Adopt-a-Landmark grant agreement with ECG Madison LLC for 801 W. Madison / 2 S. Halsted (34th Ward)
- 1:08:52 William Conway: Asked for support of the landmark grant, describing the long-vacant bank building as a…
- 1:09:55 Chicago Landmark designation of the John B. Murphy Memorial, 50 E. Erie (42nd Ward)
- 1:14:16 Amendment regarding occupancy thresholds for principal tenants using high-rise building signs (substitute)
- 1:17:41 Walter R. Burnett: Said the high-rise sign amendment reflects companies using less office space and helps…
- 1:18:53 Brendan Reilly: Said he would vote for the high-rise sign ordinance given market conditions, though he and…
- 1:20:22 Text amendment on permit specifications and location restrictions for cannabis business establishments…
- 1:20:46 William Conway: Said the cannabis text amendment gives flexibility downtown where schools are on upper…
- 1:23:48 Large signs over 100 square feet in multiple wards
- 1:25:39 Rezoning of 2901-2909 N. Milwaukee Avenue from B2/C1 to B3 (35th Ward)
- 1:27:08 Rezoning of 2240 N. Milwaukee Avenue from C1-5 to C1-1 (1st Ward)
- 1:27:31 Daniel La Spata: Explained the 2240 N. Milwaukee rezoning restores prior zoning after a lapsed Type 1 change…
- 1:28:42 Industrial planned development for 1614-1906 E. 95th Street, Isoflex Packaging expansion (8th Ward)
- 1:31:52 Residential-business planned development at 1116-1138 S. Paulina for City Church Fellowship auditorium (27th…
- 1:35:09 William Conway: Asked how much parking would serve the 1,500-seat church auditorium and which community…
- 1:38:37 Daniel La Spata: Said the City Church site has extensive transit access and that many older churches have no…
- 1:39:26 Walter R. Burnett: Said the community meeting on the City Church project mostly supported it and that…
- 1:41:36 Residential-business planned development at 370 N. Carpenter (27th Ward)
- 1:44:29 Planned development amendment for 400 N. Elizabeth Street residential towers (27th Ward)
- 1:46:57 Walter R. Burnett: Said 400 N. Elizabeth had about eight community meetings and involves minority…
- 1:50:02 Rezoning of 3601-3625 W. Chicago Avenue for affordable housing and Neighborhood Housing Services…
- 1:53:20 Rezoning of 225 W. Chicago Avenue planned development back to DX-5 (42nd Ward)
- 1:56:18 Brian Hopkins: Supported the cannabis ordinance, saying downtown siting decisions vary block by block and…
- 1:59:19 Timothy R. Knudsen: Agreed the 500-foot rule is arbitrary downtown but argued that removing the ZBA from…
- 2:01:42 Timothy R. Knudsen: Asked the sponsor why dispensaries could not remain ZBA special uses while allowing them…
- 2:05:49 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked whether the cannabis ordinance requires a mandatory public meeting and whether the…
- 2:07:03 Brendan Reilly: Said in his experience the ZBA has made cannabis decisions out of line with community…
- 2:10:49 Ruth Cruz: Asked the sponsor to explain the reasoning for moving from special use to Type 1 zoning for…
- 2:12:41 Reilly ordinance on minimum lot area reduction for existing buildings in -16 districts
- 2:15:41 Lamont J. Robinson: Presented his ordinance to allow greater minimum lot area reductions in -16 districts,…
- 2:18:22 Brendan Reilly: Argued his ordinance limiting MLA relief to existing buildings would help struggling…
- 2:35:47 Brian Hopkins: Asked the zoning administrator whether both MLA ordinances could be passed and reconciled.
- 2:52:29 William E. Hall: Asked how many units the LaSalle Street projects would create, the current downtown vacancy…
- 2:55:17 Bennett R. Lawson: Summarized for a colleague the argument that applying the bonus to both new and existing…
- 3:05:20 Lamont J. Robinson: Closed by thanking colleagues and asking for support to create quality affordable…
- 3:10:55 Robinson ordinance on minimum lot area reduction in -16 districts
- 3:19:57 Rezoning of 4023-27 S. Vincennes Avenue to RM-5 (4th Ward)
- 3:22:24 Rezoning of 4335 W. Fullerton Avenue to C1-1 (31st Ward)
- 3:24:00 Rezoning of 3200 S. Wallace Street to C1-1 to reopen a tavern (11th Ward)
- 3:24:58 Nicole T. Lee: Said the tavern owners held two community meetings and agreed to closing hours of 11 p.m.…
- 3:33:06 Bennett R. Lawson: Said he supported the 1055 W. Diversey project across the street from the 44th Ward.
- 3:41:52 Rezoning of 3787-89 S. Archer Avenue to C2-2 (12th Ward)
- 3:42:40 Julia M. Ramirez: Said she was supportive of the rezoning for the animal facility on Archer Avenue.
- 3:44:35 Rezoning of 6410 S. Honore Street for Metropolitan Family Services teen center (15th Ward)
- 3:46:53 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked whether the community center at 6410 S. Honore would still need a ZBA special use.
- 3:50:27 Rezoning of 7503-7525 S. Cicero Avenue for a car wash (18th Ward)
- 4:14:43 Institutional planned development amendment for hospital expansion at 5730-5736 W. Roosevelt Road (29th Ward)
- 4:29:16 Rezoning of 3731-3733 N. Sheffield Avenue to RM-6 (44th Ward)
- 4:33:25 Rezoning of 2035-2043 W. Irving Park Road for a 37-unit mixed-use building (47th Ward)
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Zoning, Landmarks and Building Standards deferred a list of items, heard nine public commenters, and recommended approval of three mayoral appointments: Adrian Soto to the Zoning Board of Appeals and Kamina Brooks and Tanya Kadakia to the Chicago Plan Commission. It approved an Adopt-a-Landmark grant for the former Mid-City Bank building, landmark designation of the John B. Murphy Memorial, a text amendment lowering occupancy thresholds for high-rise building signs, a batch of large signs, and dozens of map amendments and planned developments, including 400 N. Elizabeth, 370 N. Carpenter and a City Church Fellowship auditorium at Adams and Paulina. A text amendment moving downtown cannabis dispensary siting from Zoning Board of Appeals special use to the Type 1 or planned development process was debated, including objections from Ald. Timothy R. Knudsen about removing the ZBA, and was recommended for passage. Two competing minimum lot area (MLA) reduction ordinances for downtown -16 districts were debated at length: Ald. Brendan Reilly version limited to existing buildings failed on a roll call announced as 4 yeas to 13 nays, and Ald. Lamont J. Robinson broader version, which also covers new construction, passed on a roll call vote.
Topics: Minimum lot area reduction, Downtown residential conversion, Cannabis dispensary siting, Zoning Board of Appeals, Board appointments, Landmarks, High-rise signage, Planned developments, Map amendments, Parking
Agenda items discussed
- 21:21 Deferral of listed items, including Napolitano text amendment on vacant buildings: deferred
- 24:18 Public comment: discussed
- 50:11 Appointment of Adrian Soto to the Zoning Board of Appeals (A2024-0008929): passed
- 56:02 Appointment of Tanya Kadakia to the Chicago Plan Commission (A2024-0008927): passed
- 56:17 Appointment of Kamina Brooks to the Chicago Plan Commission (A2024-0008925): passed
- 1:05:38 Adopt-a-Landmark grant agreement with ECG Madison LLC for 801 W. Madison / 2 S. Halsted (34th Ward) (O2024-0008905): passed
- 1:09:55 Chicago Landmark designation of the John B. Murphy Memorial, 50 E. Erie (42nd Ward) (O2024-0008744): passed
- 1:14:16 Amendment regarding occupancy thresholds for principal tenants using high-rise building signs (substitute): passed
- 1:20:22 Text amendment on permit specifications and location restrictions for cannabis business establishments downtown (O2024-0008398): passed
- 1:23:48 Large signs over 100 square feet in multiple wards: passed
- 1:25:39 Rezoning of 2901-2909 N. Milwaukee Avenue from B2/C1 to B3 (35th Ward): passed
- 1:27:08 Rezoning of 2240 N. Milwaukee Avenue from C1-5 to C1-1 (1st Ward): passed
- 1:28:42 Industrial planned development for 1614-1906 E. 95th Street, Isoflex Packaging expansion (8th Ward): passed
- 1:31:52 Residential-business planned development at 1116-1138 S. Paulina for City Church Fellowship auditorium (27th Ward): passed
- 1:41:36 Residential-business planned development at 370 N. Carpenter (27th Ward): passed
- 1:44:29 Planned development amendment for 400 N. Elizabeth Street residential towers (27th Ward): passed
- 1:50:02 Rezoning of 3601-3625 W. Chicago Avenue for affordable housing and Neighborhood Housing Services headquarters (27th Ward): passed
- 1:53:20 Rezoning of 225 W. Chicago Avenue planned development back to DX-5 (42nd Ward): passed
- 2:12:41 Reilly ordinance on minimum lot area reduction for existing buildings in -16 districts (O2024-0008948): failed
- 3:10:55 Robinson ordinance on minimum lot area reduction in -16 districts (O2023-0006208): passed
- 3:19:57 Rezoning of 4023-27 S. Vincennes Avenue to RM-5 (4th Ward): passed
- 3:22:24 Rezoning of 4335 W. Fullerton Avenue to C1-1 (31st Ward): passed
- 3:24:00 Rezoning of 3200 S. Wallace Street to C1-1 to reopen a tavern (11th Ward): passed
- 3:41:52 Rezoning of 3787-89 S. Archer Avenue to C2-2 (12th Ward): passed
- 3:44:35 Rezoning of 6410 S. Honore Street for Metropolitan Family Services teen center (15th Ward): passed
- 3:50:27 Rezoning of 7503-7525 S. Cicero Avenue for a car wash (18th Ward): passed
- 4:14:43 Institutional planned development amendment for hospital expansion at 5730-5736 W. Roosevelt Road (29th Ward): passed
- 4:29:16 Rezoning of 3731-3733 N. Sheffield Avenue to RM-6 (44th Ward): passed
- 4:33:25 Rezoning of 2035-2043 W. Irving Park Road for a 37-unit mixed-use building (47th Ward): passed
- 4:40:57 Adjournment: passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Bennett R. Lawson (chair): Summarized for a colleague the argument that applying the bonus to both new and existing buildings could reduce interest in conversions of existing buildings. (2:55:17); Said he supported the 1055 W. Diversey project across the street from the 44th Ward. (3:33:06); Asked whether the community center at 6410 S. Honore would still need a ZBA special use. (3:46:53)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said he has worked with Adrian Soto for several years and supported his appointment to the ZBA, moving do pass. (52:39)
- Timothy R. Knudsen (alderperson): Congratulated the ZBA appointee and asked how he would balance community opposition against an aldermanic recommendation. (53:32); Agreed the 500-foot rule is arbitrary downtown but argued that removing the ZBA from dispensary siting leads toward aldermanic prerogative and weakens community engagement. (1:59:19); Asked the sponsor why dispensaries could not remain ZBA special uses while allowing them within 500 feet downtown. (2:01:42)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Welcomed the Plan Commission appointees and asked Kamina Brooks how her urban design degree and work in Charlotte inform her work. (1:01:18); Explained the 2240 N. Milwaukee rezoning restores prior zoning after a lapsed Type 1 change and had no negative community feedback. (1:27:31); Said the City Church site has extensive transit access and that many older churches have no parking lots. (1:38:37)
- Lamont J. Robinson (alderperson): Commended Kamina Brooks, citing work with Community Builders in the 4th Ward. (1:04:32); Presented his ordinance to allow greater minimum lot area reductions in -16 districts, saying it would enable more homes, affordable units and construction jobs downtown. (2:15:41); Closed by thanking colleagues and asking for support to create quality affordable housing downtown in existing or new buildings. (3:05:20)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked for support of the landmark grant, describing the long-vacant bank building as a future beacon for Greektown. (1:08:52); Said the cannabis text amendment gives flexibility downtown where schools are on upper floors and returns authority from the ZBA to the zoning committee. (1:20:46); Asked how much parking would serve the 1,500-seat church auditorium and which community groups were consulted. (1:35:09)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said he would vote for the high-rise sign ordinance given market conditions, though he and Conway were not consulted. (1:18:53); Said in his experience the ZBA has made cannabis decisions out of line with community sentiment and he would vote for the ordinance. (2:07:03); Argued his ordinance limiting MLA relief to existing buildings would help struggling downtown office buildings convert, and asked that Robinson's ordinance be held. (2:18:22)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Said the high-rise sign amendment reflects companies using less office space and helps landlords keep tenants. (1:17:41); Said the community meeting on the City Church project mostly supported it and that parking is available nearby. (1:39:26); Said 400 N. Elizabeth had about eight community meetings and involves minority contractors, and asked for support. (1:46:57)
- Carlos Ramírez-Rosa (alderperson): Asked support for rezoning a block of Milwaukee Avenue from B2 to B3 through the 35th Ward's community-driven process. (1:26:04); Said residents expect aldermen to have a say on cannabis dispensaries and thanked Conway for the text amendment. (2:09:26); Said new downtown units relieve displacement pressure elsewhere and asked to co-sponsor Robinson's ordinance. (2:39:02)
- Brian Hopkins (alderperson): Supported the cannabis ordinance, saying downtown siting decisions vary block by block and need aldermanic oversight with community review. (1:56:18); Asked the zoning administrator whether both MLA ordinances could be passed and reconciled. (2:35:47)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Asked whether the cannabis ordinance requires a mandatory public meeting and whether the affected ward alderpersons support it. (2:05:49)
- Ruth Cruz (alderperson): Asked the sponsor to explain the reasoning for moving from special use to Type 1 zoning for dispensaries. (2:10:49)
- William E. Hall (alderperson): Asked how many units the LaSalle Street projects would create, the current downtown vacancy rate, and what would change if the two ordinances were merged. (2:52:29)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Said the tavern owners held two community meetings and agreed to closing hours of 11 p.m. weekdays and midnight weekends, and she fully supports the rezoning. (3:24:58)
- Julia M. Ramirez (alderperson): Said she was supportive of the rezoning for the animal facility on Archer Avenue. (3:42:40)
Exchanges between members
- 1:35:09 Conway noted the City Church site is across from his ward and raised parking questions about the project in Burnett's ward.
- 1:56:21 Hopkins commended Conway for his leadership on the cannabis ordinance.
- 1:57:28 Burnett said he concurred and commended Conway for the cannabis ordinance.
- 1:58:37 Conway answered La Spata's question on whether dispensaries move from special use to Type 1 review.
- 2:01:42 Knudsen asked Conway why dispensaries could not remain ZBA special uses while relaxing the 500-foot rule downtown.
- 2:02:44 Knudsen said Conway's statement about knowing his ward better than the ZBA turns back the clock on aldermanic prerogative.
- 2:08:36 Reilly said he agreed with Knudsen that the ZBA has an important role, while supporting the ordinance.
- 2:10:26 Ramírez-Rosa thanked his seatmate Conway for bringing forward the text amendment.
- 2:11:21 Cruz asked Conway to explain the reasoning for moving from special use to Type 1 zoning.
- 2:26:36 Burnett asked whether Reilly's ordinance would automatically trigger 20% affordable housing for converted buildings.
- 2:33:19 La Spata asked whether Robinson's ordinance applies to both existing buildings and new construction.
- 2:40:10 Ramírez-Rosa commended Robinson's ordinance and asked to be added as a co-sponsor.
- 2:43:40 Ramírez-Rosa asked Reilly why he wanted to exclude new construction from the benefit.
- 2:44:08 Reilly answered that the choice is about prioritizing struggling existing buildings over new construction.
- 2:47:53 Ramírez-Rosa said he was sympathetic but that Reilly could achieve his goal through local review without passing his ordinance.
- 2:53:00 Conway answered Hall's question with unit counts for the LaSalle Street projects.
- 2:55:48 Reilly answered Hall that developers would tend to choose new construction over rehabilitation if the bonus applied to both.
- 2:59:26 Burnett said he understood Reilly's point but objected to limiting new projects to help existing ones.
- 3:05:56 Robinson, in closing, cited Ramírez-Rosa's comments about creating opportunities to live downtown.
- 3:05:51 Robinson, in closing, cited the vice mayor's comments about affordable housing downtown.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error