Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, December 2, 2024
- When: Mon, Dec 2, 2024, 12:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576/video/1024466718
- Transcript: full text (40,192 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 1:38:07 Public comment
- 2:05:49 FY2025 budget hearing: Chicago Department of Transportation
- 2:19:28 Gregory I. Mitchell: Asked about the policy for planting trees in the public way, citing sewer problems from…
- 2:20:23 Gregory I. Mitchell: Raised concerns that arterial resurfacing with only spot curb repairs could worsen…
- 2:21:41 Gregory I. Mitchell: Said newly resurfaced streets in his ward were dug up days later for lead line work and…
- 2:30:26 Daniel La Spata: Asked about CDOT's new planning and policy division.
- 2:33:23 Daniel La Spata: Asked how cutting sign management administrative positions affects the sign shop.
- 2:35:02 Daniel La Spata: Asked about a $500,000 reduction in the project coordination office and said underground…
- 2:42:08 Jason C. Ervin: Asked the estimated time to repair reported sidewalk trip hazards, citing the city's fiscal…
- 2:45:16 Jason C. Ervin: Said hazards above the de minimis threshold should be prioritized because unaddressed…
- 2:47:53 Emma Mitts: Asked what can be done at a West Side intersection where residents have sought a stop sign for…
- 2:49:57 Emma Mitts: Asked whether anyone monitors traffic diverted to side streets during Chicago Avenue construction.
- 2:51:11 Emma Mitts: Said smart streetlights in her ward seem too dim and asked for brighter lighting given safety…
- 2:59:39 Michelle A. Harris: Asked how CDOT reached its 3% corporate fund reduction and which vacancies were cut.
- 3:02:15 Michelle A. Harris: Thanked CDOT staff and asked for an offline conversation about next year's bond.
- 3:02:46 Pat Dowell: Asked about electric vehicle charging priorities for 2025 and which libraries will get chargers.
- 3:06:02 Pat Dowell: Asked how a roughly $700 million increase in grant funding will be used.
- 3:07:10 Pat Dowell: Said pothole damage claims rose from 344 to nearly 500 and asked what CDOT is doing to reduce…
- 3:15:58 Scott Waguespack: Asked whether CDOT has tracked injuries related to the scooter program.
- 3:18:21 Scott Waguespack: Raised complaints about large e-bikes speeding in bike lanes and asked whether policy…
- 3:20:59 Scott Waguespack: Suggested working with CPS on scooter safety and helmet education.
- 3:25:27 Brendan Reilly: Said departments were instructed to hold responses to his budget memos until their hearings…
- 3:26:14 Brendan Reilly: Said a data request sent on behalf of 15 alderpersons 13 days earlier remained unanswered by…
- 3:28:13 Nicole T. Lee: Asked IGA and the budget office for the status of all outstanding council requests before the…
- 3:29:16 Brendan Reilly: Said most CDOT managers supervise seven or fewer employees and urged increasing direct…
- 3:37:55 Marty Quinn: Asked what construction cost increases to expect in 2025.
- 3:39:23 Marty Quinn: Asked about electrician staffing and retirement eligibility.
- 3:41:36 Marty Quinn: Asked the total budget for trip-and-fall sidewalk repairs.
- 3:45:09 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked how many speed cameras the city has, how many more are allowed and what they…
- 3:47:10 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked whether more speed cameras are being discussed.
- 3:49:49 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the city should expand speed cameras where crash data supports it, saying they slow…
- 3:51:23 Nicholas Sposato: Asked what it would cost to replace 30 mph speed limit signs with 25 mph signs.
- 3:53:06 Nicholas Sposato: Said CDOT needs more money and staff for signs and electrical work.
- 3:54:15 Nicholas Sposato: Raised concerns about the cost and road rage of lowering the speed limit to 25 mph.
- 3:54:43 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how many signs CDOT replaces annually to gauge the effort of changing speed limit signs.
- 3:57:04 David H. Moore: Praised visible street work across the city and asked what funding sources are paying for it.
- 4:00:34 David H. Moore: Said 7.7% African American spend is not where it should be and asked what can be done.
- 4:03:24 David H. Moore: Asked the ethnicity of firms holding job order contracts.
- 4:05:10 Gilbert Villegas: Requested a list of grants by source and use.
- 4:05:33 Gilbert Villegas: Asked whether CDOT has a mentor-protégé program for construction.
- 4:09:36 Gilbert Villegas: Said the water department's 30-day emergency window reflects a failure to plan and asked…
- 4:16:53 Stephanie D. Coleman: Praised resurfacing on Ashland and stressed hiring workers from her neighborhood on…
- 4:18:25 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked how CDOT coordinates with forestry when trees block streetlights, citing safety.
- 4:19:55 Stephanie D. Coleman: Said ward work stopped during the DNC and asked whether CDOT has resources to catch up.
- 4:25:14 Nicole T. Lee: Requested the number of deferred menu projects by ward to manage resident expectations.
- 4:27:16 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked how CDOT will prioritize local needs such as lighting and vaulted sidewalks within…
- 4:31:04 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked whether overtime, which roughly doubled, will be kept within budget.
- 4:34:59 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked how CDOT will improve equity in contracting and what drives a large increase in…
- 4:43:05 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether CDOT vendors comply with environmental requirements in their contracts and…
- 4:46:15 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked how contractors are held accountable for repeated project delays.
- 4:50:35 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked to simplify landscape maintenance agreements for traffic circles.
- 5:03:20 William Conway: Asked how neighborhood opportunity funds from development interact with CDOT's work.
- 5:06:40 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked whether stop sign cameras exist to deter drivers cutting through side streets.
- 5:07:31 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked how many staff review permits and urged better coordination of special events.
- 5:09:17 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked who is responsible for Lake Shore Drive pedestrian underpasses.
- 5:15:25 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked whether bike lane plows could be used for sidewalks and called sidewalk snow…
- 5:16:34 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked how many accessible pedestrian signals the city has.
- 5:19:16 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked how CDOT measures the economic impact of pedestrianized streets.
- 5:32:16 Jason C. Ervin: Noted that state law bars speed cameras on Lake Shore Drive.
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations resumed its 2025 budget hearings with public comment from 13 speakers, several of whom urged funding for the Plow the Sidewalks pilot for disabled residents while others criticized property taxes, the mayor, council members and the city's sanctuary policy. The Council Office of Financial Analysis reported a proposed Chicago Department of Transportation budget of $2 billion, up 49% largely due to federal grants, with only 2.4% corporate funded, and Commissioner Tom Carney presented CDOT's 2024 work, including 188 miles of resurfacing and expanded lighting and alley reconstruction. Alderpersons asked about sidewalk trip hazards and their liability, utility and lead line coordination with street work, ADA ramps and accessible signals, speed cameras, e-bikes and scooters, contractor accountability, MBE/WBE participation, overtime, vacancies, menu program delays tied to the DNC, and funding for local infrastructure. Alderman Brendan Reilly also objected that departments had been told to hold budget memo responses and that a council data request to the budget office remained unanswered. The hearing was for review only; no vote was taken and the department was excused subject to recall.
Topics: FY2025 budget, Chicago Department of Transportation, Plow the Sidewalks pilot, sidewalk repairs, infrastructure coordination, speed cameras, bike lanes and e-bikes, MBE/WBE participation, menu program, budget data requests
Agenda items discussed
- 1:38:07 Public comment: discussed
- 2:05:49 FY2025 budget hearing: Chicago Department of Transportation: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Asked the estimated time to repair reported sidewalk trip hazards, citing the city's fiscal exposure. (2:42:08); Said hazards above the de minimis threshold should be prioritized because unaddressed reports create liability for the city. (2:45:16); Noted that state law bars speed cameras on Lake Shore Drive. (5:32:16)
- Nicole T. Lee (chair): Asked IGA and the budget office for the status of all outstanding council requests before the end of the day. (3:28:13); Asked how many signs CDOT replaces annually to gauge the effort of changing speed limit signs. (3:54:43); Requested the number of deferred menu projects by ward to manage resident expectations. (4:25:14)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (alderperson): Asked about the policy for planting trees in the public way, citing sewer problems from tree roots in his ward. (2:19:28); Raised concerns that arterial resurfacing with only spot curb repairs could worsen drainage problems. (2:20:23); Said newly resurfaced streets in his ward were dug up days later for lead line work and asked how coordination will improve. (2:21:41)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked about CDOT's new planning and policy division. (2:30:26); Asked how cutting sign management administrative positions affects the sign shop. (2:33:23); Asked about a $500,000 reduction in the project coordination office and said underground coordination improvements would have support. (2:35:02)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Asked what can be done at a West Side intersection where residents have sought a stop sign for years despite engineer advice. (2:47:53); Asked whether anyone monitors traffic diverted to side streets during Chicago Avenue construction. (2:49:57); Said smart streetlights in her ward seem too dim and asked for brighter lighting given safety concerns. (2:51:11)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Asked how CDOT reached its 3% corporate fund reduction and which vacancies were cut. (2:59:39); Thanked CDOT staff and asked for an offline conversation about next year's bond. (3:02:15)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked about electric vehicle charging priorities for 2025 and which libraries will get chargers. (3:02:46); Asked how a roughly $700 million increase in grant funding will be used. (3:06:02); Said pothole damage claims rose from 344 to nearly 500 and asked what CDOT is doing to reduce them. (3:07:10)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked whether CDOT has tracked injuries related to the scooter program. (3:15:58); Raised complaints about large e-bikes speeding in bike lanes and asked whether policy should be revisited. (3:18:21); Suggested working with CPS on scooter safety and helmet education. (3:20:59)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said departments were instructed to hold responses to his budget memos until their hearings and called this unacceptable. (3:25:27); Said a data request sent on behalf of 15 alderpersons 13 days earlier remained unanswered by the budget office. (3:26:14); Said most CDOT managers supervise seven or fewer employees and urged increasing direct reports. (3:29:16)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked what construction cost increases to expect in 2025. (3:37:55); Asked about electrician staffing and retirement eligibility. (3:39:23); Asked the total budget for trip-and-fall sidewalk repairs. (3:41:36)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Asked how many speed cameras the city has, how many more are allowed and what they generate in revenue. (3:45:09); Asked whether more speed cameras are being discussed. (3:47:10); Said the city should expand speed cameras where crash data supports it, saying they slow traffic. (3:49:49)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Asked what it would cost to replace 30 mph speed limit signs with 25 mph signs. (3:51:23); Said CDOT needs more money and staff for signs and electrical work. (3:53:06); Raised concerns about the cost and road rage of lowering the speed limit to 25 mph. (3:54:15)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Praised visible street work across the city and asked what funding sources are paying for it. (3:57:04); Said 7.7% African American spend is not where it should be and asked what can be done. (4:00:34); Asked the ethnicity of firms holding job order contracts. (4:03:24)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Requested a list of grants by source and use. (4:05:10); Asked whether CDOT has a mentor-protégé program for construction. (4:05:33); Said the water department's 30-day emergency window reflects a failure to plan and asked about shortening it. (4:09:36)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Praised resurfacing on Ashland and stressed hiring workers from her neighborhood on projects. (4:16:53); Asked how CDOT coordinates with forestry when trees block streetlights, citing safety. (4:18:25); Said ward work stopped during the DNC and asked whether CDOT has resources to catch up. (4:19:55)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Asked how CDOT will prioritize local needs such as lighting and vaulted sidewalks within its $2 billion budget. (4:27:16); Asked whether overtime, which roughly doubled, will be kept within budget. (4:31:04); Asked how CDOT will improve equity in contracting and what drives a large increase in contractual services. (4:34:59)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked whether CDOT vendors comply with environmental requirements in their contracts and what happens if not. (4:43:05); Asked how contractors are held accountable for repeated project delays. (4:46:15); Asked to simplify landscape maintenance agreements for traffic circles. (4:50:35)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked how neighborhood opportunity funds from development interact with CDOT's work. (5:03:20)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked whether stop sign cameras exist to deter drivers cutting through side streets. (5:06:40); Asked how many staff review permits and urged better coordination of special events. (5:07:31); Asked who is responsible for Lake Shore Drive pedestrian underpasses. (5:09:17)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked whether bike lane plows could be used for sidewalks and called sidewalk snow clearance an equity issue. (5:15:25); Asked how many accessible pedestrian signals the city has. (5:16:34); Asked how CDOT measures the economic impact of pedestrianized streets. (5:19:16)
Exchanges between members
- 2:42:26 The chair followed up on Alderman Daniel La Spata point about the fiscal impact of unrepaired sidewalk hazards.
- 2:45:18 The chair said Alderman Gregory I. Mitchell had raised the liability posed by unaddressed hazards.
- 3:28:13 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee responded to Alderman Brendan Reilly concerns by requesting the status of outstanding data requests.
- 3:28:33 Alderman Brendan Reilly thanked Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee for the request.
- 3:28:36 Alderman Brendan Reilly asked that Chairman Jason C. Ervin underscore his point about data requests.
- 3:37:13 Alderman Brendan Reilly noted the Lake Street bridge project would affect Alderman William Conway constituents as well as his own.
- 3:54:43 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee followed up on Alderman Nicholas Sposato question about speed limit signs.
- 4:00:38 Alderman David H. Moore returned to Alderman Emma Mitts question on African American contracting spend.
- 4:04:42 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee followed up on Alderman David H. Moore paving question with a request for miles by ward.
- 4:16:53 Alderman Stephanie D. Coleman echoed Alderman David H. Moore praise for street work.
- 4:24:09 Alderman Stephanie D. Coleman noted Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee agreed that wards should not wait until spring for delayed work.
- 4:25:14 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee followed up on Alderman Stephanie D. Coleman question with a request for deferred menu projects by ward.
- 4:35:02 Alderman Byron Sigcho-López echoed Alderman David H. Moore on reflecting diversity in contracting.
- 4:42:52 Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. added his support to Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee points on restoration.
- 4:55:18 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee agreed with Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. about problems with people feeding pigeons.
- 5:00:25 Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee referenced Alderman Matthew J. O'Shea comments on speed cameras.
- 5:10:04 Alderman Bennett R. Lawson referenced Alderman Stephanie D. Coleman question about signage.
- 5:10:48 Alderman Bennett R. Lawson followed up on Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee question about bike lanes and emergency vehicles.
- 5:15:25 Alderman Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth referenced Vice Chair Nicole T. Lee question about clearing bike lanes.
- 5:32:16 The chair responded to Alderman Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth that state law bars speed cameras on Lake Shore Drive.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error