Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, December 3, 2024
- When: Tue, Dec 3, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8925576/video/1035315717
- Transcript: full text (76,227 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 10:16 Public comment
- 33:48 FY2025 budget hearing: Chicago Board of Election Commissioners
- 44:51 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked whether the city has explored combining election operations with Cook County to…
- 46:15 Matthew J. O'Shea: Suggested city and county leadership meet with both election agencies to discuss cost…
- 48:11 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked about increasing CPS and private school student participation as election workers.
- 49:26 Marty Quinn: Asked the Board of Elections for the counterargument to merging with the county election…
- 50:01 Marty Quinn: Said the budget situation and redundancy in election authority make a merger worth exploring.
- 52:34 Marty Quinn: Asked about prospects for a second early voting location in each ward.
- 55:11 Pat Dowell: Asked how many voting machines the city has and said one electronic machine per precinct is not…
- 57:35 Pat Dowell: Requested early voting data by ward through the chair.
- 58:08 Pat Dowell: Asked for the criteria for adding a precinct, noting seniors who vote on Election Day may need…
- 1:00:10 Nicole T. Lee: Echoed calls for a second early voting location per ward and cited the Chinatown Library as a…
- 1:01:12 Scott Waguespack: Cited a 2011 city-county report and urged continued discussion of merging the two election…
- 1:03:30 Scott Waguespack: Said a decision made by voters decades ago should not prevent considering new approaches…
- 1:07:55 Walter R. Burnett: Asked how much more school board elections and expanded early voting cost the Board of…
- 1:09:02 Walter R. Burnett: Asked whether suburban election budgets are larger because of their many local races, in…
- 1:12:10 Raymond A. Lopez: Cited past changes to the council's structure to argue that the 1885 election arrangement…
- 1:14:24 Raymond A. Lopez: Requested data on unreturned permanent vote-by-mail ballots.
- 1:15:27 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked about voter roll maintenance, saying he believes the rolls contain many inactive…
- 1:18:08 Gilbert Villegas: Asked when electronic voting might become available in Illinois and the board's position…
- 1:19:59 Gilbert Villegas: Asked what cybersecurity safeguards protect touchscreen voting machines and election…
- 1:22:45 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked how many election judges serve, how they are paid and trained.
- 1:25:37 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said precinct consolidations without notice confused voters in her ward and requested…
- 1:26:52 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said poll workers lack a number to call for problems and that some polling places are…
- 1:28:38 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Supported conversations about consolidation with the county, noting the county already…
- 1:29:11 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked what the board does to promote vote by mail.
- 1:32:11 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether the board tracks which senior residences serve as polling places.
- 1:36:36 Maria E. Hadden: Asked what it would take for the board to evaluate a combined city-county system.
- 1:37:30 Maria E. Hadden: Said she was not convinced a merger would produce much savings and might create more…
- 1:43:24 Brendan Reilly: Said the Board of Elections had not responded to his annual budget memo sent two weeks…
- 1:44:03 Brendan Reilly: Asked about vacancies, salary increases, zero-based budgeting and IT contract spending at…
- 1:47:15 Brendan Reilly: Objected to the Maggie Daley Park early voting site as inconvenient for downtown voters and…
- 1:50:20 Anthony V. Napolitano: Asked whether elections could be consolidated onto fewer ballots to save money.
- 1:52:09 Anthony V. Napolitano: Suggested moving municipal elections from February to March to improve turnout.
- 1:53:51 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked for more coordination with ward offices on voter calls and for the county to…
- 1:56:36 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked about the increase in graphics spending, which the board said funds a planned…
- 2:18:31 Maria E. Hadden: Asked how polling places are compensated and requested a list of inaccessible locations.
- 3:09:56 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Human Resources
- 3:19:52 Jason C. Ervin: Asked the HR commissioner to explain how people are placed on and removed from the Do Not…
- 3:35:59 Jason C. Ervin: Asked where choke points occur in the city's lengthy hiring process.
- 3:36:48 Nicholas Sposato: Said hiring delays are often caused by outside employers slow to respond to background…
- 3:40:09 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether background-check vetting standards are consistent across DHR, police and the…
- 3:42:24 Nicole T. Lee: Asked whether DHR tracks how many hires are lost during the vetting process and whether…
- 3:46:08 Jason C. Ervin: Suggested legislation on consistent discipline be introduced in the Committee on Workforce…
- 3:54:48 Julia M. Ramirez: Asked about the hiring freeze and reports of hiring after it began.
- 3:55:40 Julia M. Ramirez: Asked how DHR communicates job openings to wards and community organizations.
- 3:58:01 Julia M. Ramirez: Requested data on city employees by ward to identify gaps in opportunity.
- 4:01:14 Michael D. Rodriguez: Asked what drove the drop in average time to hire from 155 to 103 days, saying it is…
- 4:02:58 Michael D. Rodriguez: Said working with labor partners such as AFSCME on title consolidation is important…
- 4:07:53 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Said ward offices lack employment manuals and called for shared standards to protect…
- 4:18:10 Samantha Nugent: Asked whether DHR had oversight of Do Not Hire recommendations before the policy rewrite…
- 4:20:24 Samantha Nugent: Said it would be important for the HR commissioner to have her own counsel.
- 4:22:44 Scott Waguespack: Said the Do Not Hire discussion raised possible liability issues and asked about the steps…
- 4:43:19 Nicholas Sposato: Said people can and do get removed from the Do Not Hire list through a petition to the…
- 4:45:25 William Conway: Asked the HR commissioner about a Civic Federation recommendation to cut or offset unfilled…
- 4:48:21 William Conway: Asked whether the council should consider a budget line to offset vacancies unlikely to be…
- 4:49:40 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked about the citywide employee performance review rollout and apprenticeship programs.
- 4:51:51 Byron Sigcho-López: Called for due process and a pro-worker approach in personnel matters and asked for…
- 4:55:06 Byron Sigcho-López: Expressed concern about comments mocking restorative justice processes.
- 5:20:05 Daniel La Spata: Asked how DHR will keep processing employees quickly despite cuts in its hiring and…
- 5:21:24 Daniel La Spata: Asked how claims in a department head's Do Not Hire memo are verified and called the…
- 5:22:57 Daniel La Spata: Described a restorative justice community court as an example of peace circles used for…
- 5:48:07 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Environment
- 6:44:38 William Conway: Asked what can be done to increase solar on public and private buildings.
- 7:07:48 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Administrative Hearings
- 7:29:45 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked why administrative hearing assessments and case filings have dropped since 2019 and…
- 7:32:33 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked whether remote hearings have produced cost savings.
- 7:50:54 FY2025 budget hearing: Chicago Animal Care and Control
- 8:17:40 Bennett R. Lawson: Said Animal Care and Control is doing more with less and suggested corporate sponsorships…
- 8:34:14 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked which department handles dead animals on the public way.
- 8:34:49 Ronnie L. Mosley: Asked about Animal Care and Control partnerships with senior buildings, libraries and park…
- 8:48:25 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked for guidance on residents keeping chickens and roosters, noting mixed neighbor…
- 8:56:36 FY2025 budget hearing: Office of the City Treasurer
- 9:26:07 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked the Treasurer to hold quarterly community financial events across the city.
- 9:28:09 Stephanie D. Coleman: Suggested the Black Caucus work with the Treasurer on a program for South and West…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations held a full day of FY2025 budget hearings, opening with public comment and then hearing from the Chicago Board of Election Commissioners, the Department of Human Resources, the Department of Environment, the Department of Administrative Hearings, Chicago Animal Care and Control, and the Office of the City Treasurer. Members questioned the Board of Elections about a possible merger with the county election authority, early voting capacity, precinct consolidation, polling place accessibility and voter roll maintenance. The Human Resources hearing focused on the Ineligible for Rehire (Do Not Hire) list, the EEO complaint process and the fact that department heads, not DHR, decide discipline, with several members calling for policy changes. Later hearings covered the Department of Environment's limited regulatory authority and federal funding, administrative hearing caseloads and fines, Animal Care and Control's reduced intake hours and overtime limits, and the Treasurer's investments, small-bank deposits, pensions and the Catalyst Fund. The hearings were informational; no votes were taken and many requests were made for information to be provided through the chair.
Topics: FY2025 budget, Board of Elections, early voting and polling places, city-county election merger, Do Not Hire list, workplace harassment and discipline, Department of Environment, administrative hearings, Animal Care and Control, City Treasurer investments
Agenda items discussed
- 10:16 Public comment: discussed
- 33:48 FY2025 budget hearing: Chicago Board of Election Commissioners: discussed
- 3:09:56 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Human Resources: discussed
- 5:48:07 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Environment: discussed
- 7:07:48 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Administrative Hearings: discussed
- 7:50:54 FY2025 budget hearing: Chicago Animal Care and Control: discussed
- 8:56:36 FY2025 budget hearing: Office of the City Treasurer: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Nicole T. Lee (chair): Echoed calls for a second early voting location per ward and cited the Chinatown Library as a possible shared site. (1:00:10); Asked whether background-check vetting standards are consistent across DHR, police and the mayor's office, including for Shakman-exempt hires. (3:40:09); Asked whether DHR tracks how many hires are lost during the vetting process and whether technology is being improved. (3:42:24)
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Asked the HR commissioner to explain how people are placed on and removed from the Do Not Hire list and how sexual harassment matters are handled. (3:19:52); Asked where choke points occur in the city's lengthy hiring process. (3:35:59); Suggested legislation on consistent discipline be introduced in the Committee on Workforce Development, citing employment, financial and reputational risk. (3:46:08)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Asked whether the city has explored combining election operations with Cook County to save money. (44:51); Suggested city and county leadership meet with both election agencies to discuss cost savings from combining operations. (46:15); Asked about increasing CPS and private school student participation as election workers. (48:11)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Asked the Board of Elections for the counterargument to merging with the county election authority. (49:26); Said the budget situation and redundancy in election authority make a merger worth exploring. (50:01); Asked about prospects for a second early voting location in each ward. (52:34)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked how many voting machines the city has and said one electronic machine per precinct is not enough. (55:11); Requested early voting data by ward through the chair. (57:35); Asked for the criteria for adding a precinct, noting seniors who vote on Election Day may need more polling places. (58:08)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Cited a 2011 city-county report and urged continued discussion of merging the two election agencies. (1:01:12); Said a decision made by voters decades ago should not prevent considering new approaches amid repeated budget shortfalls. (1:03:30); Said the Do Not Hire discussion raised possible liability issues and asked about the steps for placing someone on the list. (4:22:44)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Asked how much more school board elections and expanded early voting cost the Board of Elections. (1:07:55); Asked whether suburban election budgets are larger because of their many local races, in the context of a possible merger. (1:09:02)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Cited past changes to the council's structure to argue that the 1885 election arrangement can also change, and said 68% of voters support merging with the county. (1:12:10); Requested data on unreturned permanent vote-by-mail ballots. (1:14:24); Asked about voter roll maintenance, saying he believes the rolls contain many inactive registrations. (1:15:27)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked when electronic voting might become available in Illinois and the board's position on it. (1:18:08); Asked what cybersecurity safeguards protect touchscreen voting machines and election servers. (1:19:59)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Asked how many election judges serve, how they are paid and trained. (1:22:45); Said precinct consolidations without notice confused voters in her ward and requested the data behind those decisions. (1:25:37); Said poll workers lack a number to call for problems and that some polling places are not clean or accessible. (1:26:52)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Supported conversations about consolidation with the county, noting the county already covered election judge pay. (1:28:38); Asked what the board does to promote vote by mail. (1:29:11); Asked whether the board tracks which senior residences serve as polling places. (1:32:11)
- Maria E. Hadden (alderperson): Asked what it would take for the board to evaluate a combined city-county system. (1:36:36); Said she was not convinced a merger would produce much savings and might create more government. (1:37:30); Asked how polling places are compensated and requested a list of inaccessible locations. (2:18:31)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said the Board of Elections had not responded to his annual budget memo sent two weeks earlier. (1:43:24); Asked about vacancies, salary increases, zero-based budgeting and IT contract spending at the Board of Elections. (1:44:03); Objected to the Maggie Daley Park early voting site as inconvenient for downtown voters and asked the board to do better. (1:47:15)
- Anthony V. Napolitano (alderperson): Asked whether elections could be consolidated onto fewer ballots to save money. (1:50:20); Suggested moving municipal elections from February to March to improve turnout. (1:52:09)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked for more coordination with ward offices on voter calls and for the county to be involved in any merger hearing. (1:53:51); Asked about the increase in graphics spending, which the board said funds a planned mobile app. (1:56:36); Said ward offices lack employment manuals and called for shared standards to protect employees. (4:07:53)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Said hiring delays are often caused by outside employers slow to respond to background checks rather than by HR. (3:36:48); Said people can and do get removed from the Do Not Hire list through a petition to the commissioner, citing examples. (4:43:19)
- Michael D. Rodriguez (alderperson): Asked what drove the drop in average time to hire from 155 to 103 days, saying it is still too long. (4:01:14); Said working with labor partners such as AFSCME on title consolidation is important for efficiency. (4:02:58)
- Julia M. Ramirez (alderperson): Asked about the hiring freeze and reports of hiring after it began. (3:54:48); Asked how DHR communicates job openings to wards and community organizations. (3:55:40); Requested data on city employees by ward to identify gaps in opportunity. (3:58:01)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Asked whether DHR had oversight of Do Not Hire recommendations before the policy rewrite and who reports for the mayor's office. (4:18:10); Said it would be important for the HR commissioner to have her own counsel. (4:20:24)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked the HR commissioner about a Civic Federation recommendation to cut or offset unfilled vacancies. (4:45:25); Asked whether the council should consider a budget line to offset vacancies unlikely to be filled. (4:48:21); Asked what can be done to increase solar on public and private buildings. (6:44:38)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Asked about the citywide employee performance review rollout and apprenticeship programs. (4:49:40); Called for due process and a pro-worker approach in personnel matters and asked for recommendations on consistency. (4:51:51); Expressed concern about comments mocking restorative justice processes. (4:55:06)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked how DHR will keep processing employees quickly despite cuts in its hiring and compensation section. (5:20:05); Asked how claims in a department head's Do Not Hire memo are verified and called the reliance on trust disconcerting. (5:21:24); Described a restorative justice community court as an example of peace circles used for youth offenses. (5:22:57)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked why administrative hearing assessments and case filings have dropped since 2019 and said the council should examine who stopped writing tickets. (7:29:45); Asked whether remote hearings have produced cost savings. (7:32:33); Said Animal Care and Control is doing more with less and suggested corporate sponsorships for resources. (8:17:40)
- Ronnie L. Mosley (alderperson): Asked which department handles dead animals on the public way. (8:34:14); Asked about Animal Care and Control partnerships with senior buildings, libraries and park camps. (8:34:49)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Asked for guidance on residents keeping chickens and roosters, noting mixed neighbor reactions. (8:48:25); Asked the Treasurer to hold quarterly community financial events across the city. (9:26:07); Suggested the Black Caucus work with the Treasurer on a program for South and West Side hospitality businesses. (9:28:09)
Exchanges between members
- 49:26 Quinn picked up Alderman Matthew J. O'Shea question about merging the Board of Elections with the county.
- 1:01:12 Waguespack said he was building on Alderman Matthew J. O'Shea comments about a city-county election merger.
- 1:01:12 Waguespack said he was building on Alderman Marty Quinn comments about a city-county election merger.
- 1:14:24 Lopez added to the data request Chair Pat Dowell had made through the chair.
- 1:47:51 Reilly referenced Alderman Jeanette B. Taylor concerns in describing early voting site problems downtown.
- 1:56:31 Manaa-Hoppenworth referenced Chair Pat Dowell call for faster voting in each ward.
- 2:18:01 Quinn said he was building on Alderman Andre Vasquez Jr. request that the board share its Springfield positions.
- 2:19:43 Hadden said Alderman Raymond A. Lopez was right that many communities lack accessible polling locations.
- 3:25:21 O'Shea said he would follow the line of questions Chairman Jason C. Ervin started on DHR policies.
- 3:34:14 Ervin told Lopez the question on Do Not Hire placements had been asked and answered and asked him to move on.
- 3:35:59 Ervin followed up on Lopez's point about long hiring times.
- 3:37:30 Ervin asked Sposato to let the commissioner answer the hiring delay question.
- 3:52:36 Dowell asked Alderman Matthew J. O'Shea whether he remembered the company conducting the CPD staffing study.
- 3:55:50 Ramirez referenced Chairwoman Pat Dowell comments about the Taleo portal.
- 4:00:40 Rodriguez concurred with his colleague from the Third Ward in praising the HR commissioner.
- 4:15:01 Taylor endorsed Alderman Pat Dowell point that DHR should have a policy person or attorney.
- 4:20:24 Nugent agreed with Chairman Pat Dowell that the HR commissioner should have her own counsel.
- 4:35:10 Reilly returned to Alderman Marty Quinn question about peace circles.
- 4:37:52 Reilly pursued the same line of questioning as President Pro Tem Nugent on who reports for the mayor's office.
- 4:42:00 Ervin said Reilly's question about the Law Department was not fair to the witness and directed her not to answer.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error