Committee on Finance: Subcommittee on Revenue meeting, July 21, 2025
- When: Mon, Jul 21, 2025, 11:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Finance: Subcommittee on Revenue
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1102021273
- Transcript: full text (31,997 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 26:45 William E. Hall: Opened the subject matter hearing on the video gaming terminal tax and alderperson revenue…
- 28:47 Public comment
- 42:55 Consultant study on video gaming terminal revenue and impact on the Chicago casino
- 1:17:23 Daniel La Spata: Asked how much VGT growth reflects filling a gap, taking from slots, or a shift in gaming…
- 1:20:24 Daniel La Spata: Suggested comparing revenue per gaming position between VGTs and casino slots.
- 1:22:55 Daniel La Spata: Asked whether the data showed consistent declines in traditional casino slot revenue.
- 1:27:18 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked whether there was a comparison showing casino slot revenue where no VGTs exist.
- 1:28:58 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Argued that with growing VGT usage and steady casino attendance, it makes sense to expand…
- 1:30:22 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked about the city's strategy for seeking changes to the state tax split in Springfield.
- 1:31:55 Jason C. Ervin: Asked what a fully mature VGT market would generate within the state and municipal tax…
- 1:37:42 Pat Dowell: Asked whether the consultant interviewed casinos and why Rivers Casino, which has grown, was not…
- 1:41:26 Pat Dowell: Asked whether the city collects revenue from online gambling and whether that could help the…
- 1:43:07 Pat Dowell: Asked why gaming machines are seen in gas stations if VGTs are banned in the city.
- 1:44:35 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said she voted against the casino because of regional competition and asked whether…
- 1:49:35 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said sweepstakes-style machines operate in her ward untaxed and called for limits on…
- 1:53:09 Jeanette B. Taylor: Asked that Bally's be brought to the table before a VGT decision and that the city tax…
- 1:59:39 William E. Hall: Asked the consultant whether he had estimated revenue lost to sweepstakes machines…
- 2:01:22 Felix Cardona Jr.: Asked what distinguishes sweepstakes machines from VGTs.
- 2:03:07 Felix Cardona Jr.: Said the city is losing money to sweepstakes machines and the council should consider an…
- 2:03:24 Felix Cardona Jr.: Asked whether Rivers Casino revenue changed after VGTs arrived in Des Plaines.
- 2:05:23 William E. Hall: Said Rivers Casino revenue has gone up without the decline the study projects.
- 2:05:35 David H. Moore: Asked for data on the ownership and equity makeup of VGT and casino operators, including MBE…
- 2:08:09 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked for Rivers Casino data and described seeing heavy use of both VGTs and the…
- 2:09:29 Stephanie D. Coleman: Requested a list of on-site consumption licensees, citywide and in specific wards, as…
- 2:12:32 Stephanie D. Coleman: Said the city gets nothing from sweepstakes machines, which she linked to crime at…
- 2:17:05 Hospitality industry perspective on video gaming terminals
- 2:24:55 Jason C. Ervin: Asked how results would change if the city's VGT tax share matched the casino rate.
- 2:27:23 Jason C. Ervin: Expressed frustration that the analysis only covered the current tax structure, saying the…
- 2:45:04 Samantha Nugent: Asked whether the city would seek state legislation for a larger VGT share, suggesting city…
- 2:47:02 Michelle A. Harris: Asked how many jobs are generated by video gaming terminals.
- 2:49:40 Gaming industry perspective on video gaming terminals
- 2:59:03 Overview of alderperson-submitted revenue proposals analyzed by the Council Office of Financial Analysis
- 3:00:54 Centralized accident towing and storage proposal
- 3:03:49 Increased towing and storage fees proposal
- 3:18:39 Procurement of private vehicle auction services proposal
- 3:21:51 Streetlight advertisement proposal
- 3:24:19 Vacant property registration platform proposal
- 3:27:00 Workers' compensation light work and loss portfolio transfer proposals
- 3:38:59 Rideshare zone expansion (congestion surcharge)
- 3:44:02 Online sports wagering tax
- 3:45:45 Liquor tax restructuring to a percentage-based tax
- 3:49:52 Garbage fee options
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Finance Committee's Subcommittee on Revenue held this July 21, 2025 subject matter hearing on legalizing video gaming terminals (VGTs) in Chicago and on other revenue ideas, and no votes were taken. A city-hired consultant presented findings that VGT tax revenue would be largely offset by lost casino slot revenue, because the city's share of VGT tax is much smaller than its casino tax rate, along with an estimated loss of about 390 jobs at Bally's. Members questioned the analysis, including why Rivers Casino was excluded, how the job estimate was made, the role of unregulated sweepstakes machines, and whether the state tax split could be renegotiated. Representatives of the hospitality and gaming industries argued for VGTs. The Council Office of Financial Analysis then reviewed alderperson-submitted proposals, including towing and storage fee changes, streetlight advertising, vacant property registration and workers' compensation savings. City finance staff presented options for a rideshare zone surcharge expansion, an online sports wagering tax, a percentage-based liquor tax, and garbage fee increases.
Topics: video gaming terminals, Bally's casino, sweepstakes machines, state tax split, towing and storage fees, streetlight advertising, vacant property registration, workers' compensation, online sports wagering tax, garbage fee
Agenda items discussed
- 28:47 Public comment: discussed
- 42:55 Consultant study on video gaming terminal revenue and impact on the Chicago casino: discussed
- 2:17:05 Hospitality industry perspective on video gaming terminals: discussed
- 2:49:40 Gaming industry perspective on video gaming terminals: discussed
- 2:59:03 Overview of alderperson-submitted revenue proposals analyzed by the Council Office of Financial Analysis: discussed
- 3:00:54 Centralized accident towing and storage proposal: discussed
- 3:03:49 Increased towing and storage fees proposal: discussed
- 3:18:39 Procurement of private vehicle auction services proposal: discussed
- 3:21:51 Streetlight advertisement proposal: discussed
- 3:24:19 Vacant property registration platform proposal: discussed
- 3:27:00 Workers' compensation light work and loss portfolio transfer proposals: discussed
- 3:38:59 Rideshare zone expansion (congestion surcharge): discussed
- 3:44:02 Online sports wagering tax: discussed
- 3:45:45 Liquor tax restructuring to a percentage-based tax: discussed
- 3:49:52 Garbage fee options: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- William E. Hall (chair): Opened the subject matter hearing on the video gaming terminal tax and alderperson revenue ideas, noting no votes would be taken. (26:45); Asked the consultant whether he had estimated revenue lost to sweepstakes machines operating in gas stations. (1:59:39); Said Rivers Casino revenue has gone up without the decline the study projects. (2:05:23)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked how much VGT growth reflects filling a gap, taking from slots, or a shift in gaming preferences. (1:17:23); Suggested comparing revenue per gaming position between VGTs and casino slots. (1:20:24); Asked whether the data showed consistent declines in traditional casino slot revenue. (1:22:55)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Asked whether there was a comparison showing casino slot revenue where no VGTs exist. (1:27:18); Argued that with growing VGT usage and steady casino attendance, it makes sense to expand opportunities. (1:28:58); Asked about the city's strategy for seeking changes to the state tax split in Springfield. (1:30:22)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Asked what a fully mature VGT market would generate within the state and municipal tax portion. (1:31:55); Asked how results would change if the city's VGT tax share matched the casino rate. (2:24:55); Expressed frustration that the analysis only covered the current tax structure, saying the city needs scenarios to bring to Springfield. (2:27:23)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Asked whether the consultant interviewed casinos and why Rivers Casino, which has grown, was not in the analysis. (1:37:42); Asked whether the city collects revenue from online gambling and whether that could help the budget. (1:41:26); Asked why gaming machines are seen in gas stations if VGTs are banned in the city. (1:43:07)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Said she voted against the casino because of regional competition and asked whether Bally's is underperforming. (1:44:35); Said sweepstakes-style machines operate in her ward untaxed and called for limits on machines per store and required security. (1:49:35); Asked that Bally's be brought to the table before a VGT decision and that the city tax online gambling apps. (1:53:09)
- Felix Cardona Jr. (alderperson): Asked what distinguishes sweepstakes machines from VGTs. (2:01:22); Said the city is losing money to sweepstakes machines and the council should consider an ordinance on them. (2:03:07); Asked whether Rivers Casino revenue changed after VGTs arrived in Des Plaines. (2:03:24)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Asked for data on the ownership and equity makeup of VGT and casino operators, including MBE and WBE status. (2:05:35)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Asked for Rivers Casino data and described seeing heavy use of both VGTs and the casino near Wind Creek. (2:08:09); Requested a list of on-site consumption licensees, citywide and in specific wards, as likely VGT-eligible businesses. (2:09:29); Said the city gets nothing from sweepstakes machines, which she linked to crime at liquor stores, and asked whether VGT players are the same customers as Bally's. (2:12:32)
- Samantha Nugent (alderperson): Asked whether the city would seek state legislation for a larger VGT share, suggesting city or third-party ownership of terminals. (2:45:04)
- Michelle A. Harris (alderperson): Asked how many jobs are generated by video gaming terminals. (2:47:02)
Exchanges between members
- 1:33:23 Ervin apologized to Vasquez for interjecting during his questioning time.
- 1:53:22 Taylor echoed Dowell's point about collecting revenue from online gambling apps.
- 2:01:22 Cardona followed up on Taylor's concern about sweepstakes machines.
- 2:03:19 Cardona followed up on Dowell's question about Rivers Casino.
- 2:04:29 Cardona agreed with Taylor that the council needs to get a grasp of the issue.
- 2:05:23 Hall told Cardona that Rivers Casino revenue has gone up.
- 2:08:09 Coleman built on Taylor's questions about Rivers Casino.
- 2:08:09 Coleman built on Dowell's questions about Rivers Casino.
- 2:16:02 Hall cited Taylor's remarks that sweepstakes machines are a problem in wards.
- 2:55:45 Hall told Ervin he had made an error and corrected the state VGT revenue figures.
- 2:58:28 Hall thanked Ervin's office for its work on the revenue proposals.
- 2:58:28 Hall thanked Dowell for her work on the revenue proposals.
- 3:16:55 Coleman made a light remark to Ervin about the earlier tense exchange.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error