Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight meeting, June 6, 2024
- When: Thu, Jun 6, 2024, 2:00 PM (Chicago time)
- Where: Room 201A, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight
- Video: https://vimeo.com/showcase/8928512/video/954053897
- Transcript: full text (10,379 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 26:15 Public comment
- 44:21 Substitute ordinance prohibiting lobbyists from making contributions to the mayor or mayoral candidates…
- 44:54 Matthew J. Martin: Explained that the Board of Ethics recommended codifying a 2011 executive order barring…
- 52:52 Brendan Reilly: Asked who provided the legal opinion that the executive order was unenforceable and…
- 54:20 Brendan Reilly: Said the administration rejected offers to amend the ordinance, called that a missed…
- 55:13 Chris Taliaferro: Asked whether the Board had recommended extending the ban to other elected officials and…
- 56:20 Nicole T. Lee: Asked why language on registered lobbyists was struck and how the ban applies to entities a…
- 1:00:03 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Supported the ordinance as a measured step toward fairness and asked how candidates can…
- 1:03:32 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Asked the Board to share its database and guidance for campaign committees and fundraisers.
- 1:04:27 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked how long the doing-business database has existed, whether contractor contributions…
- 1:08:34 Scott Waguespack: Thanked the Board of Ethics director for helping aldermen with ethics issues and asked how…
- 1:16:37 Brendan Reilly: Said large contributions from organizations, rather than lobbyists, are the bigger problem…
- 1:18:43 Appointment of the Hon. Bernetta D. Bush to the Board of Ethics
- 1:23:15 Matthew J. O'Shea: Thanked both appointees for their willingness to serve.
- 1:25:59 Nicole T. Lee: Said the Board of Ethics is vital to restoring public trust and noted the value of diversity…
- 1:27:36 Chris Taliaferro: Thanked both Board of Ethics appointees and said they have his complete support.
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Ethics and Government Oversight heard five public commenters, including a Better Government Association representative who supported the lobbyist contribution ordinance and urged action on other Board of Ethics recommendations. The committee approved its March 2024 Rule 45 report and accepted an amended substitute ordinance codifying a 2011 mayoral executive order that bars lobbyists from contributing to the mayor, extending the ban to mayoral candidates and to entities a lobbyist owns at least 7.5% of and has lobbied for, with fines and possible 90-day registration suspensions. Board of Ethics Executive Director Steve Berlin explained that the board found five violations in the 2023 cycle but concluded it lacked authority to enforce the executive order. Members asked about the legal opinion, the scope of the ban, databases for checking restricted donors, and whether limits should extend to other officials and to large organizational contributors. The substitute was recommended for passage by voice vote, with the chair noting Ald. Chris Taliaferro as the exception, and the committee recommended approval of the Hon. Bernetta D. Bush and Sarah Gin to the Board of Ethics.
Topics: Lobbyist contributions, Campaign finance, Board of Ethics, Executive order codification, Board appointments, Public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 26:15 Public comment: discussed
- 44:02 Rule 45 report from March 2024: passed
- 44:21 Substitute ordinance prohibiting lobbyists from making contributions to the mayor or mayoral candidates (codifying Executive Order 2011-2): passed
- 1:18:43 Appointment of the Hon. Bernetta D. Bush to the Board of Ethics (A2024-0009552): passed
- 1:18:43 Appointment of Sarah Gin to the Board of Ethics (A2024-0009553): passed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Matthew J. Martin (chair): Explained that the Board of Ethics recommended codifying a 2011 executive order barring lobbyist contributions to the mayor after it considered allegations of contributions to Mayor Johnson's committee. (44:54)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked who provided the legal opinion that the executive order was unenforceable and confirmed the ordinance applies only to the mayor and mayoral candidates. (52:52); Said the administration rejected offers to amend the ordinance, called that a missed opportunity, and said he would support it. (54:20); Said large contributions from organizations, rather than lobbyists, are the bigger problem and asked for the Board's prior opinion on labor union contributions. (1:16:37)
- Chris Taliaferro (alderperson): Asked whether the Board had recommended extending the ban to other elected officials and whether anything prevents the council from doing so. (55:13); Thanked both Board of Ethics appointees and said they have his complete support. (1:27:36)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked why language on registered lobbyists was struck and how the ban applies to entities a lobbyist partly owns. (56:20); Said the Board of Ethics is vital to restoring public trust and noted the value of diversity on boards, supporting both appointees. (1:25:59)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Supported the ordinance as a measured step toward fairness and asked how candidates can screen out prohibited contributions. (1:00:03); Asked the Board to share its database and guidance for campaign committees and fundraisers. (1:03:32)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Asked how long the doing-business database has existed, whether contractor contributions or city employee contributions to the mayor should be codified, and how peer cities treat lobbying of executives. (1:04:27)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Thanked the Board of Ethics director for helping aldermen with ethics issues and asked how long it takes to process a violation case. (1:08:34)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Thanked both appointees for their willingness to serve. (1:23:15)
Exchanges between members
- 54:20 Reilly applauded the chair for his attempts to work with the administration on the ordinance.
- 1:00:03 Vasquez thanked and commended the chair for moving the ordinance forward.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error