Committee on License and Consumer Protection meeting, June 11, 2025
- When: Wed, Jun 11, 2025, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on License and Consumer Protection
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1091840764
- Transcript: full text (14,732 words, official captions)
Video chapters
- 20:34 Public comment
- 45:17 Substitute ordinance modifying procedures for designating restricted residential zones for short-term rentals
- 46:18 Anthony V. Napolitano: Said the 2016 short-term rental ordinance left the industry with no real-time…
- 49:50 Anthony V. Napolitano: Explained the amendment lets alderpersons close precincts to new short-term rentals…
- 51:23 Anthony V. Napolitano: Said existing registered short-term rentals are grandfathered and the ordinance is…
- 53:17 David H. Moore: Said he co-sponsored the short-term rental ordinance and asked whether homeowners renting…
- 56:31 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked for BACP to attend and raised concern about replacing short-term rental revenue…
- 58:30 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said Airbnb has addressed problems he raised quickly and suggested closer work with…
- 1:00:27 William Conway: Asked why restrictions apply at the precinct level when his dense precincts each have about…
- 1:02:14 William Conway: Raised concerns about infringing property rights without due process and asked to hear BACP…
- 1:03:36 Bennett R. Lawson: Noted about $9 million in shared housing funds goes to gender-based violence programs and…
- 1:04:09 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked about restricting only non-owner-occupied listings and whether business-zoned…
- 1:07:29 Silvana Tabares: Strongly supported the short-term rental ordinance, describing calls for service, a rental…
- 1:12:18 Brendan Reilly: Said nightly rentals in dense high-rises cause serious problems and called the ordinance a…
- 1:16:15 Marty Quinn: Described the burdensome 2016 opt-out petition process and supported the short-term rental…
- 1:18:59 Substitute ordinance regarding impoundment of pedicabs
- 1:19:37 Brendan Reilly: Said hundreds of unlicensed pedicabs undercut the 200 licensed operators, who are easier for…
- 1:27:17 Bennett R. Lawson: Asked whether the pedicab license cap might be raised, about ownership limits, and how…
- 1:31:03 William Conway: Said his ward shares the pedicab problems Alderperson Brendan Reilly described and urged a…
- 1:31:41 Substitute ordinance on public places of amusement and sidewalk cafes
- 1:32:13 Matthew J. Martin: Explained his ordinance would allow one- or two-year sidewalk cafe licenses and let…
- 1:33:57 Matthew J. O'Shea: Thanked Alderperson Matthew J. Martin, saying two-year cafe licenses would help…
- 1:35:38 David H. Moore: Supported two-year cafe licenses but opposed raising the number of gaming machines, saying…
- 1:38:25 Ordinance prohibiting peddling in portions of the 1st Ward
- 1:40:52 Ordinance disallowing additional liquor and package goods licenses in portions of the 13th Ward
- 1:41:19 Marty Quinn: Asked for approval of a liquor moratorium to make blocks consistent with the rest of the 13th…
- 1:41:50 Ordinance allowing additional package goods licenses on portions of 58th Street (20th Ward)
- 1:42:34 Ordinance allowing additional liquor and package goods licenses on a portion of Blue Island Avenue
- 1:43:37 Ordinance disallowing additional package goods licenses on a portion of Pulaski Road
- 1:44:38 Ordinance prohibiting sale of cannabinoid hemp products in the O'Hare residential area
- 1:45:38 Item 11 on the agenda
- 1:45:55 Subject matter hearing on congestion fee overcharging by rideshare companies
- 1:46:59 Debra L. Silverstein: Explained that Uber overcharged the congestion surcharge outside designated hours and…
- 1:54:13 Debra L. Silverstein: Asked Uber and city officials how much was overcharged, whether it was refunded, and…
- 1:55:52 Brendan Reilly: Said the downtown congestion surcharge falls on residents and hospitality workers and should…
- 1:58:57 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said residents within a half mile voted to support lifting the moratorium so a package…
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on License and Consumer Protection, chaired by Alderperson Debra L. Silverstein, heard 10 public commenters, including rideshare drivers criticizing Uber over fee errors, short-term rental hosts and Airbnb opposing changes to the shared housing ordinance, and licensed pedicab operators supporting impoundment of unlicensed pedicabs. The committee passed Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano substitute ordinance letting alderpersons restrict new short-term rentals by precinct through legislation, after debate over property rights and revenue for domestic violence programs, with Alderperson William Conway voting no. It also passed Alderperson Brendan Reilly ordinance allowing impoundment of pedicabs, Alderperson Matthew J. Martin ordinance allowing two-year sidewalk cafe licenses and raising public place of amusement thresholds (with Alderperson David H. Moore opposed), a peddling ban in part of the 1st Ward, several liquor and package goods moratorium changes, and a ban on hemp product sales in the O'Hare residential area, while one item was held. In a subject matter hearing, Uber, the Department of Finance and BACP discussed Uber's overcharging of about $1.78 million in congestion surcharges, which Uber said it had fully refunded while the city verifies the refunds before returning remitted funds.
Topics: short-term rentals, pedicab impoundment, sidewalk cafe licenses, public places of amusement, liquor moratoriums, congestion surcharge, rideshare drivers, hemp products, peddling, public comment
Agenda items discussed
- 20:34 Public comment: discussed
- 44:57 Approval of the May 2025 Rule 45 reports: passed
- 45:17 Substitute ordinance modifying procedures for designating restricted residential zones for short-term rentals: passed
- 1:18:59 Substitute ordinance regarding impoundment of pedicabs: passed
- 1:31:41 Substitute ordinance on public places of amusement and sidewalk cafes: passed
- 1:38:25 Ordinance prohibiting peddling in portions of the 1st Ward: passed
- 1:40:52 Ordinance disallowing additional liquor and package goods licenses in portions of the 13th Ward (O2025-0017186): passed
- 1:41:50 Ordinance allowing additional package goods licenses on portions of 58th Street (20th Ward): passed
- 1:42:34 Ordinance allowing additional liquor and package goods licenses on a portion of Blue Island Avenue: passed
- 1:43:37 Ordinance disallowing additional package goods licenses on a portion of Pulaski Road: passed
- 1:44:38 Ordinance prohibiting sale of cannabinoid hemp products in the O'Hare residential area: passed
- 1:45:38 Item 11 on the agenda: held
- 1:45:55 Subject matter hearing on congestion fee overcharging by rideshare companies: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Debra L. Silverstein (chair): Explained that Uber overcharged the congestion surcharge outside designated hours and convened the hearing to understand what happened and protect consumers. (1:46:59); Asked Uber and city officials how much was overcharged, whether it was refunded, and what happened to money remitted to the city. (1:54:13)
- Anthony V. Napolitano (alderperson): Said the 2016 short-term rental ordinance left the industry with no real-time solutions to parties and disruptions and places the burden on residents. (46:18); Explained the amendment lets alderpersons close precincts to new short-term rentals by ordinance, like liquor moratoriums, and lowers the industry's reopening petition threshold to 10 percent. (49:50); Said existing registered short-term rentals are grandfathered and the ordinance is not a blanket ban. (51:23)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Said he co-sponsored the short-term rental ordinance and asked whether homeowners renting rooms or basement units long term would be affected. (53:17); Supported two-year cafe licenses but opposed raising the number of gaming machines, saying it could disadvantage communities if gaming is legalized, and said he could not support the ordinance. (1:35:38)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Asked for BACP to attend and raised concern about replacing short-term rental revenue that funds domestic violence services. (56:31); Said Airbnb has addressed problems he raised quickly and suggested closer work with platforms instead of precinct-wide bans. (58:30); Thanked Alderperson Matthew J. Martin, saying two-year cafe licenses would help struggling small businesses. (1:33:57)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked why restrictions apply at the precinct level when his dense precincts each have about 2,750 residents, compared with block-level liquor moratoriums. (1:00:27); Raised concerns about infringing property rights without due process and asked to hear BACP on economic impact. (1:02:14); Said his ward shares the pedicab problems Alderperson Brendan Reilly described and urged a yes vote. (1:31:03)
- Bennett R. Lawson (alderperson): Noted about $9 million in shared housing funds goes to gender-based violence programs and clarified short-term rentals are stays of 30 days or less. (1:03:36); Asked about restricting only non-owner-occupied listings and whether business-zoned property is exempt, and said he wished the ordinance had more time. (1:04:09); Asked whether the pedicab license cap might be raised, about ownership limits, and how impoundment enforcement missions would work. (1:27:17)
- Silvana Tabares (alderperson): Strongly supported the short-term rental ordinance, describing calls for service, a rental used by car caravan participants, and investors targeting her ward near Midway. (1:07:29)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Said nightly rentals in dense high-rises cause serious problems and called the ordinance a responsible, optional tool he would vote for. (1:12:18); Said hundreds of unlicensed pedicabs undercut the 200 licensed operators, who are easier for inspectors to target, and that impoundment would deter them. (1:19:37); Said the downtown congestion surcharge falls on residents and hospitality workers and should be revisited. (1:55:52)
- Marty Quinn (alderperson): Described the burdensome 2016 opt-out petition process and supported the short-term rental ordinance as a tool for the Bungalow Belt. (1:16:15); Asked for approval of a liquor moratorium to make blocks consistent with the rest of the 13th Ward. (1:41:19)
- Matthew J. Martin (alderperson): Explained his ordinance would allow one- or two-year sidewalk cafe licenses and let businesses have four gaming machines and two pool tables before needing a PPA license. (1:32:13)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Said residents within a half mile voted to support lifting the moratorium so a package goods license could transfer to a new owner. (1:58:57)
Exchanges between members
- 45:58 The chair expressed condolences to Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano before he presented his ordinance.
- 53:23 Alderperson David H. Moore offered condolences to Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano and asked whether long-term room rentals would be affected.
- 54:27 Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano answered Alderperson David H. Moore that long-term rentals are not covered.
- 1:01:11 Alderperson William Conway asked the sponsor why restrictions apply by precinct.
- 1:02:19 Alderperson William Conway said he shared concerns raised by Alderperson Matthew J. O'Shea.
- 1:02:48 Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano responded to Alderperson William Conway property rights concern, saying the same precinct process has existed for nine years.
- 1:04:09 Alderperson Bennett R. Lawson asked the sponsor about owner-occupied restrictions in the ordinance.
- 1:07:23 Alderperson Silvana Tabares thanked Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano and strongly supported his ordinance.
- 1:11:36 Alderperson Brendan Reilly picked up on points made by Alderperson Silvana Tabares about short-term rentals.
- 1:14:20 Alderperson Brendan Reilly acknowledged Alderperson Matthew J. O'Shea point about revenue for important programs.
- 1:16:00 Alderperson Marty Quinn offered condolences to Alderperson Anthony V. Napolitano and thanked him for the ordinance.
- 1:17:43 Alderperson Marty Quinn said he shared the remarks of Alderpersons Napolitano, Tabares and Reilly.
- 1:27:17 Alderperson Bennett R. Lawson thanked Alderperson Brendan Reilly for the pedicab ordinance and asked about license caps.
- 1:27:49 Alderperson Brendan Reilly answered Alderperson Bennett R. Lawson about possibly adding licenses and enforcement missions.
- 1:31:16 Alderperson William Conway thanked Alderperson Brendan Reilly for his leadership on pedicabs.
- 1:33:57 Alderperson Matthew J. O'Shea thanked Alderperson Matthew J. Martin for the sidewalk cafe ordinance.
- 1:35:32 Alderperson William Conway thanked Alderperson Matthew J. Martin for the ordinance.
- 1:35:38 Alderperson David H. Moore thanked Alderperson Matthew J. Martin but said he could not support the gaming machine provision.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error