Committee on Budget and Government Operations meeting, December 4, 2024
- When: Wed, Dec 4, 2024, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Budget and Government Operations
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1035823755
- Transcript: full text (53,354 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 30:00 Public comment
- 1:13:11 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Procurement Services
- 1:26:18 Emma Mitts: Asked for the percentage breakdown of city contract payments to minority- and women-owned firms.
- 1:29:02 Emma Mitts: Said contract compliance data should be centralized in Procurement so the city can defend its…
- 1:31:18 Emma Mitts: Asked how outdated technology affects Procurement's work and timely payment of contractors.
- 1:35:46 Jason C. Ervin: Asked whether Procurement's staffing shortfall reflects its roughly 30% vacancy rate or a…
- 1:37:46 Jason C. Ervin: Suggested looking at reclassifying vacant positions to where resources are needed.
- 1:38:18 Pat Dowell: Complimented the Chief Procurement Officer's statement as a clear roadmap for the department.
- 1:42:03 Pat Dowell: Asked where delays in contract processing occur.
- 1:43:55 Pat Dowell: Asked what the city is doing to protect its minority contracting program from legal and federal…
- 1:49:27 Walter R. Burnett: Asked why Procurement does not track compliance on agreements such as the Bally's casino…
- 1:50:46 Walter R. Burnett: Suggested moving compliance monitoring for developments from the Department of Housing to…
- 1:52:41 Walter R. Burnett: Asked for the percentages of construction and non-construction payments going to African…
- 1:56:40 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said Procurement had failed in recent years and asked about the new outreach plans.
- 2:00:21 Matthew J. O'Shea: Asked whether unfilled vacancies are hurting the department's mission.
- 2:02:05 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the department must be staffed adequately and offered his support.
- 2:03:27 Raymond A. Lopez: Called for consolidating the city's fragmented procurement functions.
- 2:04:03 Raymond A. Lopez: Asked what positions make up Procurement's 41% vacancy rate.
- 2:06:16 Raymond A. Lopez: Said a technical issue led the city to accept a water contract bid roughly double a…
- 2:11:36 David H. Moore: Echoed praise for the CPO's clear roadmap and said understanding regulations is key to the…
- 2:14:01 David H. Moore: Asked for the top three areas the CPO found needing improvement.
- 2:18:50 David H. Moore: Asked how consistently procurements follow the published buying plan.
- 2:22:30 Gilbert Villegas: Asked about the veterans business program and offered to work on codifying it beyond the…
- 2:25:05 Gilbert Villegas: Asked what is being done to speed payment to small subcontractors.
- 2:26:28 Gilbert Villegas: Asked how the city is preparing its MWBE program for legal challenges as federal DBE…
- 2:32:55 Daniel La Spata: Asked how Procurement is operating with 11 vacant senior procurement specialist positions.
- 2:35:08 Daniel La Spata: Raised concern about vacant and eliminated positions in contract review and audit.
- 2:36:33 Daniel La Spata: Said leaving positions unfilled is not an efficiency and offered support for lifting the…
- 2:39:35 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how task orders work for vendors who win qualification-based contracts but receive…
- 2:44:16 Nicole T. Lee: Said slow payment to minority subcontractors discourages businesses and asked how to…
- 2:48:20 Nicole T. Lee: Requested data on prime contractors' spending with minority- and women-owned subcontractors.
- 2:49:47 Brendan Reilly: Questioned eliminating the only auditor positions in Procurement's Contract Review and Audit…
- 2:53:12 Brendan Reilly: Asked who performs Procurement's legal, assist agency and certification consulting contracts.
- 2:58:25 Brendan Reilly: Asked what Procurement pays to rent venues for outreach events.
- 3:02:36 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said contractors claiming MBE/WBE status often lack diverse workers on job sites and…
- 3:04:04 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said large developers inflate prices and then seek more TIF money.
- 3:06:46 Jeanette B. Taylor: Said many young people cannot pass trade apprenticeship drug tests.
- 3:13:14 Byron Sigcho-López: Commended the CPO and asked what challenges she inherited in reaching equity contracting…
- 3:16:54 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked how Procurement will meet the Cut the Tape goal of cutting RFP issuance time by…
- 3:19:50 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked for details on planned stakeholder focus groups.
- 3:23:27 Jason C. Ervin: Asked who is leading the ERP system effort and what phase it is in.
- 4:54:30 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Law
- 7:15:00 William Conway: Asked the Corporation Counsel to clarify a published quote that a council action violated…
- 7:20:13 William Conway: Said whether the Corporation Counsel regards council ordinances and represents the council…
- 7:20:36 William Conway: Asked how disputes between the executive and legislative branches are resolved.
- 7:23:04 Scott Waguespack: Asked whether the Law Department rewrote the Do Not Hire policy in 2024.
- 7:25:22 Scott Waguespack: Said council members should be involved in rewriting the Do Not Hire policy or it should…
- 7:26:24 Scott Waguespack: Called placing harassment victims in a peace circle with the accused absurd and said it…
- 7:30:34 Gregory I. Mitchell: Asked the Law Department to help update outdated ordinances, citing improvements made…
- 7:33:43 Gregory I. Mitchell: Said a resident's property is in his ward, he believes she has a strong case, and asked…
- 7:50:57 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Asked whether alderpersons have authority to place ward office employees on a Do Not…
- 7:54:45 Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth: Said the city should be an attractive employer, especially for women, women of color…
- 7:56:57 Stephanie D. Coleman: Said some council members want to help make two families with property disputes whole…
- 8:00:25 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked how the Law Department can help address violence against Black women with CPD…
- 8:02:39 Stephanie D. Coleman: Asked about the concentration of neglected vacant lots in her ward.
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Budget and Government Operations held its final day of FY2025 departmental budget hearings, beginning with public comment and then hearing from the Department of Procurement Services and the Department of Law. Members questioned the new Chief Procurement Officer about minority- and women-owned business participation, decentralized contract compliance, high vacancy rates during the hiring freeze, outdated technology, delays in paying subcontractors and the status of the citywide ERP system procurement. The Department of Law hearing covered recruitment, the new Special Collections Unit pursuing owners of large numbers of neglected vacant lots, affirmative litigation, settlements and judgments, reverse conviction cases, outside counsel spending, FOIA penalties, the Do Not Hire policy and the Corporation Counsel's role relative to the City Council. The hearings were informational; no votes were taken and the committee adjourned at the end of the day.
Topics: FY2025 budget, Department of Procurement Services, MBE/WBE contracting, contract compliance, ERP system, Department of Law, vacant lots enforcement, legal settlements, reverse conviction cases, Do Not Hire policy
Agenda items discussed
- 30:00 Public comment: discussed
- 1:13:11 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Procurement Services: discussed
- 4:54:30 FY2025 budget hearing: Department of Law: discussed
Alderpersons who spoke
- Jason C. Ervin (chair): Asked whether Procurement's staffing shortfall reflects its roughly 30% vacancy rate or a need for more positions. (1:35:46); Suggested looking at reclassifying vacant positions to where resources are needed. (1:37:46); Asked who is leading the ERP system effort and what phase it is in. (3:23:27)
- Emma Mitts (alderperson): Asked for the percentage breakdown of city contract payments to minority- and women-owned firms. (1:26:18); Said contract compliance data should be centralized in Procurement so the city can defend its programs if challenged. (1:29:02); Asked how outdated technology affects Procurement's work and timely payment of contractors. (1:31:18)
- Pat Dowell (alderperson): Complimented the Chief Procurement Officer's statement as a clear roadmap for the department. (1:38:18); Asked where delays in contract processing occur. (1:42:03); Asked what the city is doing to protect its minority contracting program from legal and federal challenges. (1:43:55)
- Walter R. Burnett (alderperson): Asked why Procurement does not track compliance on agreements such as the Bally's casino and private developments. (1:49:27); Suggested moving compliance monitoring for developments from the Department of Housing to Procurement. (1:50:46); Asked for the percentages of construction and non-construction payments going to African American firms. (1:52:41)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Said Procurement had failed in recent years and asked about the new outreach plans. (1:56:40); Asked whether unfilled vacancies are hurting the department's mission. (2:00:21); Said the department must be staffed adequately and offered his support. (2:02:05)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Called for consolidating the city's fragmented procurement functions. (2:03:27); Asked what positions make up Procurement's 41% vacancy rate. (2:04:03); Said a technical issue led the city to accept a water contract bid roughly double a competing bid, costing taxpayers over $20 million. (2:06:16)
- David H. Moore (alderperson): Echoed praise for the CPO's clear roadmap and said understanding regulations is key to the job. (2:11:36); Asked for the top three areas the CPO found needing improvement. (2:14:01); Asked how consistently procurements follow the published buying plan. (2:18:50)
- Gilbert Villegas (alderperson): Asked about the veterans business program and offered to work on codifying it beyond the pilot. (2:22:30); Asked what is being done to speed payment to small subcontractors. (2:25:05); Asked how the city is preparing its MWBE program for legal challenges as federal DBE programs are attacked. (2:26:28)
- Daniel La Spata (alderperson): Asked how Procurement is operating with 11 vacant senior procurement specialist positions. (2:32:55); Raised concern about vacant and eliminated positions in contract review and audit. (2:35:08); Said leaving positions unfilled is not an efficiency and offered support for lifting the freeze. (2:36:33)
- Nicole T. Lee (chair): Asked how task orders work for vendors who win qualification-based contracts but receive little work. (2:39:35); Said slow payment to minority subcontractors discourages businesses and asked how to centralize and speed the process. (2:44:16); Requested data on prime contractors' spending with minority- and women-owned subcontractors. (2:48:20)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Questioned eliminating the only auditor positions in Procurement's Contract Review and Audit division. (2:49:47); Asked who performs Procurement's legal, assist agency and certification consulting contracts. (2:53:12); Asked what Procurement pays to rent venues for outreach events. (2:58:25)
- Jeanette B. Taylor (alderperson): Said contractors claiming MBE/WBE status often lack diverse workers on job sites and called for growing new local developers. (3:02:36); Said large developers inflate prices and then seek more TIF money. (3:04:04); Said many young people cannot pass trade apprenticeship drug tests. (3:06:46)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Commended the CPO and asked what challenges she inherited in reaching equity contracting goals. (3:13:14); Asked how Procurement will meet the Cut the Tape goal of cutting RFP issuance time by about half. (3:16:54); Asked for details on planned stakeholder focus groups. (3:19:50)
- William Conway (alderperson): Asked the Corporation Counsel to clarify a published quote that a council action violated separation of powers. (7:15:00); Said whether the Corporation Counsel regards council ordinances and represents the council is relevant to the department's budget. (7:20:13); Asked how disputes between the executive and legislative branches are resolved. (7:20:36)
- Scott Waguespack (alderperson): Asked whether the Law Department rewrote the Do Not Hire policy in 2024. (7:23:04); Said council members should be involved in rewriting the Do Not Hire policy or it should be set by ordinance. (7:25:22); Called placing harassment victims in a peace circle with the accused absurd and said it should not happen again. (7:26:24)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (alderperson): Asked the Law Department to help update outdated ordinances, citing improvements made to a towing ordinance. (7:30:34); Said a resident's property is in his ward, he believes she has a strong case, and asked for assistance within ethical limits. (7:33:43)
- Leni Manaa-Hoppenworth (alderperson): Asked whether alderpersons have authority to place ward office employees on a Do Not Hire list. (7:50:57); Said the city should be an attractive employer, especially for women, women of color and people with disabilities. (7:54:45)
- Stephanie D. Coleman (alderperson): Said some council members want to help make two families with property disputes whole and asked how to prevent similar cases through legal aid partnerships. (7:56:57); Asked how the Law Department can help address violence against Black women with CPD and the State's Attorney. (8:00:25); Asked about the concentration of neglected vacant lots in her ward. (8:02:39)
Exchanges between members
- 1:40:29 Dowell said Chairman Emma Mitts had already asked her question about centralizing contract compliance.
- 1:40:50 Dowell thanked Chairman Jason C. Ervin for raising the reclassification of Procurement vacancies.
- 2:11:38 Moore echoed Chairman Pat Dowell praise for the CPO's clear roadmap.
- 3:02:28 Taylor said she liked Alderman Brendan Reilly point about the council helping Procurement reach its goals.
- 3:13:23 Sigcho-López referenced procurement issues Alderman Jeanette B. Taylor had described.
- 6:00:48 Lopez echoed Alderman Emma Mitts call to bring resolution for residents who testify each month.
- 6:16:55 Sigcho-López built on Chairwoman Pat Dowell concerns about police misconduct settlements.
- 6:28:34 Sigcho-López followed up on the FOIA issue Alderwoman Pat Dowell raised.
- 6:57:04 Reilly followed up on Alderman Gilbert Villegas question about peace circles.
- 7:23:31 Waguespack noted Alderman Brendan Reilly had started to touch on the peace circle issue and continued it.
- 7:33:43 Mitchell continued the discussion Alderman Brendan Reilly began about helping two residents with property disputes.
- 7:57:29 Coleman built on Alderwoman Jeanette B. Taylor question about families losing property in court.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error