Committee on Finance meeting, September 15, 2025
- When: Mon, Sep 15, 2025, 10:00 AM (Chicago time)
- Where: City Council Chamber, 2nd Floor, City Hall, 121 North LaSalle Street - Chicago, IL 60602
- Status: Scheduled & Published
- Committee: Committee on Finance
- Video: https://vimeo.com/1118205995
- Transcript: full text (20,929 words, automatic captions)
Video chapters
- 23:20 Public comment
- 36:02 Department of Law reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements for July and August 2025
- 36:42 Settlement: Danielle Young v. City of Chicago, $125,000
- 41:56 Settlement: Vincent Miller v. Danny May and City of Chicago, $350,000
- 45:31 Settlement: Jerome Tillis v. City of Chicago, $350,000
- 54:09 Nicholas Sposato: Asked whether the bystander in the Tillis case was asked to help or volunteered, and said…
- 57:19 William Conway: Said settling the Tillis case for $350,000 is a win for taxpayers given the medical costs…
- 57:54 Pat Dowell: Asked the Law Department to explain the Fire Department's policy on paramedics enlisting…
- 59:30 Raymond A. Lopez: Argued that settling the Tillis case fails to defend city paramedics and said the city…
- 1:02:18 Pat Dowell: Responded to Lopez that voting no does not make a lawsuit go away.
- 1:02:29 Raymond A. Lopez: Said the city sometimes needs to defend itself so plaintiffs do not expect the city to…
- 1:02:58 Nicholas Sposato: Said he objects to the settlement because the plaintiff was three times the legal limit.
- 1:03:28 Jason C. Ervin: Said repeated claim types raise risk management questions and urged helping departments…
- 1:07:54 Global settlement of lawsuits related to former Sergeant Ronald Watts, $90 million
- 1:12:10 Jason C. Ervin: Thanked the Law Department for the Watts global settlement and hoped the approach can be…
- 1:13:32 William Conway: Called the Watts settlement a very good outcome for taxpayers given near-certain liability…
- 1:14:42 Raymond A. Lopez: Praised the Law Department for the Watts settlement and asked for the payment schedule…
- 1:16:31 Nicholas Sposato: Praised the Law Department and said he fully supports the Watts settlement.
- 1:17:31 Brendan Reilly: Asked whether a judge encouraged bundling the Watts cases and whether the department is…
- 1:21:10 Matthew J. O'Shea: Said the Watts and Burge cases are a dark stain on CPD history and praised the…
- 1:23:03 Andre Vasquez Jr.: Said the lawsuits stem from officers victimizing people and hoped the city learns to…
- 1:25:32 Nicole T. Lee: Asked how much the city had already paid in Watts settlements and legal costs before the…
- 1:27:15 Pat Dowell: Thanked the Law Department for the Watts settlement, saying it helps the city move forward and…
- 1:28:38 TIF assistance for Field Building Revitalization Partners for adaptive reuse of 135 South LaSalle Street…
- 1:43:23 Jason C. Ervin: Questioned the joint venture percentages at 135 South LaSalle and asked which African…
- 1:46:15 William Conway: Asked whether TIF funds would be disbursed if contractors do not meet the 26 and 6 percent…
- 1:46:57 Gregory I. Mitchell: Asked when minority participation is reviewed relative to TIF disbursements and…
- 1:49:08 Brendan Reilly: Said the LaSalle Central TIF has been used sparingly and these projects pass a strict…
- 1:51:42 Byron Sigcho-López: Raised concerns about the lack of family-size units and asked for the affordability…
- 1:56:18 TIF redevelopment agreement with 105 Adams Development LLC for the Clark Adams Building, 105 West Adams…
- 2:14:42 Byron Sigcho-López: Asked about the general contractor and developer experience for 105 West Adams and…
- 2:18:58 TIF redevelopment agreement with After School Matters for the Orleans Teen Center, 1065 North Orleans Street
- 2:27:29 Amendment increasing TIF assistance to Steep Theater Company, 5300-5318 North Kenmore Avenue
- 2:34:54 Ordinances authorizing and denying payment of various small claims
- 2:35:33 Charitable solicitation permit for the Salvation Army
- 2:36:03 Senior Bill of Rights ordinance re-referred to joint Committee on Housing and Real Estate and Committee on…
- 2:37:18 Resolution calling for a subject matter hearing on Chicago's pension system
Meeting notes
AI-written from the transcript. Speakers are inferred from cues in the recording, so treat names as estimates and check the video at the linked time.
The Committee on Finance heard five public commenters, approved its Rule 45 reports, and recommended passage of four legal settlements, including a $90 million global settlement resolving 176 lawsuits arising from arrests by former Sergeant Ronald Watts and his tactical team. The $350,000 settlement involving paramedic care for Jerome Tillis drew debate, with Alderperson Raymond A. Lopez arguing the city should stop paying such settlements and others citing litigation risk; it was recommended for passage with several members recorded in opposition. The committee also recommended TIF redevelopment agreements for office-to-residential conversions at 135 South LaSalle ($98 million) and 105 West Adams ($67.5 million), $5 million for an After School Matters teen center, and an $880,000 increase for Steep Theater, after members raised questions about minority contractor participation, unit sizes, and affordability. Small claims items were placed on the omnibus, a Senior Bill of Rights ordinance was re-referred to a joint committee, and the chair held a resolution calling for a pension hearing.
Topics: legal settlements, Watts global settlement, risk management, TIF redevelopment agreements, LaSalle Street office conversions, affordable housing, minority contractor participation, After School Matters, Steep Theater, small claims
Agenda items discussed
- 23:20 Public comment
- 35:16 Approval of July and August 2025 Rule 45 reports: passed
- 36:02 Department of Law reports of verdicts, judgments and settlements for July and August 2025
- 36:42 Settlement: Danielle Young v. City of Chicago, $125,000: passed
- 41:56 Settlement: Vincent Miller v. Danny May and City of Chicago, $350,000: passed
- 45:31 Settlement: Jerome Tillis v. City of Chicago, $350,000: passed
- 1:07:54 Global settlement of lawsuits related to former Sergeant Ronald Watts, $90 million: passed
- 1:28:38 TIF assistance for Field Building Revitalization Partners for adaptive reuse of 135 South LaSalle Street (substitute): passed
- 1:56:18 TIF redevelopment agreement with 105 Adams Development LLC for the Clark Adams Building, 105 West Adams (substitute): passed
- 2:18:58 TIF redevelopment agreement with After School Matters for the Orleans Teen Center, 1065 North Orleans Street: passed
- 2:27:29 Amendment increasing TIF assistance to Steep Theater Company, 5300-5318 North Kenmore Avenue: passed
- 2:34:54 Ordinances authorizing and denying payment of various small claims: passed
- 2:35:33 Charitable solicitation permit for the Salvation Army: passed
- 2:36:03 Senior Bill of Rights ordinance re-referred to joint Committee on Housing and Real Estate and Committee on Budget and Government Operations: deferred
- 2:37:18 Resolution calling for a subject matter hearing on Chicago's pension system: held
Alderpersons who spoke
- Pat Dowell (chair): Asked the Law Department to explain the Fire Department's policy on paramedics enlisting bystander help. (57:54); Responded to Lopez that voting no does not make a lawsuit go away. (1:02:18); Thanked the Law Department for the Watts settlement, saying it helps the city move forward and reflects its risk management work. (1:27:15)
- Nicholas Sposato (alderperson): Asked whether the bystander in the Tillis case was asked to help or volunteered, and said the paramedics faced an intense situation. (54:09); Said he objects to the settlement because the plaintiff was three times the legal limit. (1:02:58); Praised the Law Department and said he fully supports the Watts settlement. (1:16:31)
- William Conway (alderperson): Said settling the Tillis case for $350,000 is a win for taxpayers given the medical costs and liability questions. (57:19); Called the Watts settlement a very good outcome for taxpayers given near-certain liability and litigation costs. (1:13:32); Asked whether TIF funds would be disbursed if contractors do not meet the 26 and 6 percent participation requirements. (1:46:15)
- Raymond A. Lopez (alderperson): Argued that settling the Tillis case fails to defend city paramedics and said the city must start saying no to such settlements. (59:30); Said the city sometimes needs to defend itself so plaintiffs do not expect the city to settle. (1:02:29); Praised the Law Department for the Watts settlement and asked for the payment schedule through the chair. (1:14:42)
- Jason C. Ervin (alderperson): Said repeated claim types raise risk management questions and urged helping departments adopt best practices; said he would support the Tillis settlement. (1:03:28); Thanked the Law Department for the Watts global settlement and hoped the approach can be used in other cases. (1:12:10); Questioned the joint venture percentages at 135 South LaSalle and asked which African American contractors are lined up. (1:43:23)
- Brendan Reilly (alderperson): Asked whether a judge encouraged bundling the Watts cases and whether the department is pursuing similar global resolutions. (1:17:31); Said the LaSalle Central TIF has been used sparingly and these projects pass a strict but-for test to deliver downtown affordable units. (1:49:08)
- Matthew J. O'Shea (alderperson): Said the Watts and Burge cases are a dark stain on CPD history and praised the Corporation Counsel and her team. (1:21:10)
- Andre Vasquez Jr. (alderperson): Said the lawsuits stem from officers victimizing people and hoped the city learns to identify misconduct; asked how the $90 million is divided among plaintiffs. (1:23:03)
- Nicole T. Lee (alderperson): Asked how much the city had already paid in Watts settlements and legal costs before the global settlement. (1:25:32)
- Gregory I. Mitchell (alderperson): Asked when minority participation is reviewed relative to TIF disbursements and requested a deep dive on how compliance is tracked. (1:46:57)
- Byron Sigcho-López (alderperson): Raised concerns about the lack of family-size units and asked for the affordability breakdown at 135 South LaSalle given the roughly 40 percent subsidy. (1:51:42); Asked about the general contractor and developer experience for 105 West Adams and supported an aggregate analysis of participation. (2:14:42)
Exchanges between members
- 1:02:18 Dowell told Lopez that voting no does not make a lawsuit go away.
- 1:02:29 Lopez replied that the city sometimes must defend itself to discourage further lawsuits.
- 1:05:23 Dowell thanked Ervin for his risk management remarks and asked the Law Department to respond.
- 1:13:32 Conway echoed Ervin's praise of the Watts settlement.
- 1:46:57 Mitchell asked for clarification building on Conway's question about disbursements and participation requirements.
- 1:50:47 Reilly credited Conway with negotiating the LaSalle projects.
- 1:52:42 Sigcho-López echoed Mitchell's question about local hiring.
- 1:55:32 Conway acknowledged Reilly's work on the LaSalle projects.
- 2:14:00 Dowell told Ervin that participation should also be viewed in the aggregate across TIF projects.
- 2:14:21 Ervin said he supports an aggregate review and respects the chair's position.
- 2:15:15 Sigcho-López agreed with the chair on looking at participation in the aggregate.
- 2:17:18 Dowell said she welcomed and supported Sigcho-López's inquiry.
- 2:17:51 Conway agreed to meet with Ervin and Sigcho-López about contractor participation.
Documents
Sources and methods: how we get and count this data · report an error